ML092440518: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(StriderTol Bot change)
(StriderTol Bot change)
 
Line 19: Line 19:


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:lim TENNESSEE VALLEY AUTHORITY BROWNS FERRY NUCLEAR PLANT UNIT 1 Steam Dryer Analysis August 7,2009
{{#Wiki_filter:lim TENNESSEE VALLEY AUTHORITY BROWNS FERRY NUCLEAR PLANT UNIT 1 Steam Dryer Analysis August 7,2009  


Steam Dryer Stress Analysis       [II]
[II]
Steam Dryer Stress Analysis
* Low Flow Noise Included
* Low Flow Noise Included
* Re-analyzing Steam Dryer Stress to Show SR > 2.0
* Re-analyzing Steam Dryer Stress to Show SR > 2.0  
  - As built steam dryer at 110 % OLTP
- As built steam dryer at 110% OLTP  
  - Modified steam dryer at 1200/0 OLTP 2
- Modified steam dryer at 1200/0 OLTP 2  


Steam Dryer Stress Analysis                     [II]
[II]
* 1100/0 OLTP Based on CDI 08-15P (March 2009) with:
Steam Dryer Stress Analysis
  - Low flow noise included
* 1100/0 OLTP Based on CDI 08-15P (March 2009) with:  
  - Adjusted bump-up for 1100/0 v 2 & 110 % resonance
- Low flow noise included  
  - Same steam dryer configuration
- Adjusted bump-up for 1100/0 v2 & 110% resonance  
  - Utilization of ASME Table NG 3352-1
- Same steam dryer configuration  
  - SR > 2.0 3
- Utilization of ASME Table NG 3352-1  
- SR > 2.0 3  


Steam Dryer Stress Analysis         iii]
iii]
* 120% OLTP Based on COl 08-15P (March 2009) with:
Steam Dryer Stress Analysis
  - Low flow noise included
* 120% OLTP Based on COl 08-15P (March 2009) with:  
  - Additional steam dryer modifications
- Low flow noise included  
  - Revision of two submodels o 1 SIA - 1 COl
- Additional steam dryer modifications  
  - Utilization of ASME Table NG 3352-1
- Revision of two submodels o 1 SIA - 1 COl  
  - SR > 2.0 4
- Utilization of ASME Table NG 3352-1  
- SR > 2.0 4  


Steam Dryer Stress Analysis             [II]
[II]
z x~ y         Outer Hood - Old Bar
Steam Dryer Stress Analysis z
                    & Lock Gussets Group I Drain Channels Group III index I Inner Hood Stiffeners Group II 5
x~
y index I Outer Hood - Old Bar  
& Lock Gussets Group I Drain Channels Group III Inner Hood Stiffeners Group II 5  


Steam Dryer Stress Analysis             mil Middle Hood/F&T Tie Bar Group IV Outer Hood Side Panel I Vane Bank End Wall Group V Outer Bank Discharge End panel I Middle Hood I Top Cover Group VI 6
Steam Dryer Stress Analysis mil Middle Hood/F&T Tie Bar Group IV Outer Hood Side Panel I Vane Bank End Wall Group V Outer Bank Discharge End panel I Middle Hood I Top Cover Group VI 6  


Steam Dryer Stress Analysis                                                                                 III]
III]
Noise Retained Modifications Reinforcing Bar ole Old Tie Bar/Lock Gusset Replace with TVA Gusset Group I                                                                             lli; i
Steam Dryer Stress Analysis Noise Retained Modifications Old Tie Bar/Lock Gusset Reinforcing Bar ole Replace with TVA Gusset Group I lli; i  
                                                                                                    't:! *        ; ll~
't:!  
                                                                                                                      -.L 3tL Drill Yo" DIA Re' ThtuP lie
; ll~
                                                  ~ Two (2) lJUssets are "'ll\lired per               C-vssel Pad s:eam dam. four (-4) iotal per unit.
-.L 3tL Drill Yo" DIA Re' ThtuP lie  
n
~ Two (2) lJUssets are "'ll\\lired per C-vssel Pad s:eam dam. four (-4) iotal per unit.  
                                                                                  ~Oam(1
~Oam(1 n
                                                                                                                        ~   ~
~
~
Existing Configuration at 4 Locations, Where Old TB Remnant and Lock Gusset Were Retained.
L/
L/
Existing Configuration at 4 Locations, Where Old TB Remnant and Lock Gusset Were Retained.
Stress Intensities Seen in Base Plate, TB 1
Stress Intensities Seen in Base Plate, TB Connection & Lock Gusset Connections.                                                                                     1 Mod Removes this Configuration and Replaces with Revised Gusset as Found in all other Locations, Stiffens the top of Steam Dam with a ~
Connection & Lock Gusset Connections.
Pipe Section, & Reinforces the %" Thick Outer STEAM DAM GUSSET ASSEMBLY Hood Cover.                                                                                 PATCH PLATE LOCATIONS DETAILS - BFN U1 7
Mod Removes this Configuration and Replaces with Revised Gusset as Found in all other Locations, Stiffens the top of Steam Dam with a ~
Pipe Section, & Reinforces the %" Thick Outer STEAM DAM GUSSET ASSEMBLY Hood Cover.
PATCH PLATE LOCATIONS DETAILS - BFN U1 7  


Steam Dryer Stress Analysis                                             1m Noise Retained Modifications Inner Hood Stiffeners - Group II 3.f1E Limiting stress location is at bottom corner of                 3,1 Hood Stiffener 2 sided fillet weld. Addition of stress relief semi-circular hole reduces stress acting on weld and adds flexibility to corner.                                                             HOOD SlIPPORT Modifications provide a resultant SRF = .53
Steam Dryer Stress Analysis 1m Noise Retained Modifications Inner Hood Stiffeners - Group II Limiting stress location is at bottom corner of Hood Stiffener 2 sided fillet weld. Addition of stress relief semi-circular hole reduces stress acting on weld and adds flexibility to corner.
                                                                          .2:5
Modifications provide a resultant SRF =.53 Previous Solid Sub Model Revised to Evaluate Stress Relief and Resultant SRF HOOD SlIPPORT
                                                                    -----~1.75 I
.2:5  
                                                                                    ~. !
-----~1.75  
Previous Solid Sub Model Revised to Evaluate Stress Relief                        000-TO-HOOD SUPPORT RELIEF HO ASEUNE DIMENSIONS and Resultant SRF 8
~.
I 3.f1E 3,1 000-TO-HOOD SUPPORT RELIEF HO ASEUNE DIMENSIONS 8  


Steam Dryer Stress Analysis                                                                       [iI]
[iI]
Noise Retained Modifications                                                                   1Ia" Drain el(ref}j J'ttt Drain Channels - Group III R 3.50 (lefl - \
Steam Dryer Stress Analysis Noise Retained Modifications Drain Channels - Group III DC Follow the Dryer Skirt Modal Response. Limiting Stress Location is at Bottom of Drain Channel Weld, that has been Already Reinforced and Wrapped Underneath the DC. Addition of Stress Relief Semi-circular Hole Reduces Stress Acting on Weld and Adds Flexibility to Corner.
DC Follow the Dryer Skirt Modal Response. Limiting Stress Location is at                             ~A Bottom of Drain Channel Weld, that has been Already Reinforced and Wrapped Underneath the DC. Addition of Stress Relief Semi-circular Hole Reduces Stress Acting on Weld and Adds Flexibility to                               ----114" Dryer Skirt (reI) _ _
Modifications Provide SRF =.43 Previous Solid Sub Model Revised to Evaluate Stress Relief and Resultant SRF 1Ia" Drain el(ref}j J'ttt R 3.50 (lefl-\\
Corner.
~
Modifications Provide SRF = .43            18" [)fain Ch01f1nel (reI) -_~/         _
A
Previous Solid Sub                                    Semi-circu Re~H Model Revised to                  'Nolie: These dimensi:>ns are g;ven as arc I~
----114" Dryer Skirt (reI)__
Evaluate Stress Relief                along .!he O'..I"V3".ure of drain Ch01f1 Section A-A and Resultant SRF                                      DRAIN CHANNEL END RELIEF HOLE CONCEPT 9
18" [)fain Ch01f1nel (reI) -_~/
Semi-circu Re~H  
'Nolie: These dimensi:>ns are g;ven as arc I~
along.!he O'..I"V3".ure of Section A-A drain Ch01f1 DRAIN CHANNEL END RELIEF HOLE CONCEPT 9  


Steam Dryer Stress Analysis                                                                                                                                 [iJJ Noise Retained Modifications 6     This n:et::h is appbcable only co lie bars spanning the ou~r ci;scharge duc.-:s. 4 reauired.
[iJJ Steam Dryer Stress Analysis Noise Retained Modifications 6 This n:et::h is appbcable only co lie bars spanning the ou~r ci;scharge duc.-:s. 4 reauired.
                                                                        .... - -- -                              See FW'e Middle Hood/F&T Tie Bar - Group IV One location, between outer and middle banks, has a high stress located under the tie                                                                     See OU.:er Tie Bar-to-Hood bar in the weld to the hood section. Additional     "
Middle Hood/F&T Tie Bar - Group IV One location, between outer and middle banks, has a high stress located under the tie bar in the weld to the hood section. Additional reinforcement using a reinforcing plate and additional welds is to be added.
Reinroreement DetI:iI Shee, reinforcement using a reinforcing plate and additional welds is to be added.
Vane Rank A total of four (4) symmetrical locations will be Cover (rei) modified.
Vane Rank A total of four (4) symmetrical locations will be             Cover (rei)                       8,80t:om comers ma~ be rounded to 0.25" maximum rallYs
l~
                                                                                                      'thin % 1 inc:ll 01 flare break line to {aciSta:e welding.
~, [7/0-Max
modified.
,__.. __.--.-~
l~ ~                            1**1   l'
See FW'e
                                                                                                                                                          'j  ,I.      6"    *1
'j,I.
                                                      ~, [7/0-Max (ref)                  C ,__ .. __.-- .-~
6"
Surfac.e may be m.a.chined a requ'red ior lihlp if vane bank                                             FLARED & TAPERED TIE BAR to hood offsl!l is Iessthill 114'_
*1 (ref)
OUTER VANE BANK DISCHARGES 10
C FLARED &TAPERED TIE BAR OUTER VANE BANK DISCHARGES See OU.:er Tie Bar-to-Hood Reinroreement DetI:iI Shee, 8,80t:om comers ma~ be rounded to 0.25" maximum rallYs  
'thin % 1 inc:ll 01 flare break line to {aciSta:e welding.  
~
1**1 l'
Surfac.e may be m.a.chined a requ'red ior lihlp if vane bank to hood offsl!l is Iessthill 114'_
10  


Steam Dryer Stress Analysis                                                                                                 mil 318" x 2" Reinfordng Bar Noise Retained Modifications                                                                                  "7 3/8" Vane Bank 3/8" Outer Hood ~.                                               L-- End Plate (ref)
Steam Dryer Stress Analysis mil Noise Retained Modifications Outer Hood Side Panel
/ Vane Bank End Wall Group V Limiting Component is the 3/8" thick Vane Bank End Closure Plate.
Structural Thickness Changes Of Drain Trough, behind Plate, Contribute to Stress Intensity. Mod Provides Reinforcement to Distribute Stress 318" x 2" Reinfordng Bar "7
3/8" Vane Bank 3/8" Outer Hood ~.
L-- End Plate (ref)
Closure Plate (ref)
Closure Plate (ref)
Outer Hood Side Panel                                                              Bf
Bf 1/4" Vane Bank Outlet Skle Trough Plate (ref) 1/2" x 6-1/2' Trough Upper Ring (ref) C ReinforCing Plate, Both SiOes (re.f) 1/2" Vane Bank Bottom Plate (ref)
/ Vane Bank End Wall                                                                                                  1/4" Vane Bank Outlet Group V                                  Upper Ring (ref)  C                                                        Skle Trough Plate (ref) 1/2" x 6-1/2' Trough ReinforCing Plate, Both SiOes (re.f) 1/2" Vane Bank Bottom Plate (ref)
End View - Outer Hood Closure-to-Vane 1/2" x6-1/2' Trough Reinforcing Plate (ref)  
Limiting Component is the 3/8" thick                            End View - Outer Hood Closure-to-Vane Vane Bank End Closure Plate.
~ 318" Vane Bank End Plate (ref) -
1/2" x 6-1/2' Structural Thickness Changes Of        Trough Reinforcing Plate (ref)   ~       318" Vane Bank End Plate (ref) -
316  
Drain Trough, behind Plate, Contribute to Stress Intensity. Mod Provides 316 Reinforcement to Distribute Stress
~~..,
                                                                                                                        ~~ ,
2' x 318" thk x 24" Ig Reinfordng Bar 318" Hood Closure Plate (ref) --'..., I lY Section A-A (Cut Thru Trough)
2' x 318" thk x 24" Ig Reinfordng Bar 318" Hood Closure Plate (ref) - - ' ..., I lY Section A-A (Cut Thru Trough)                   Section B-B (Cut Thru Perforated Plate) 11
Section B-B (Cut Thru Perforated Plate) 11  


Steam Dryer Stress Analysis                                                                 [II]
[II]
                                                                                                        'A~
Steam Dryer Stress Analysis R 0.25 (TVP)
R 0.25 (TVP)
Noise Retained Modifications  
Noise Retained Modifications                                             +
+  
Outer Bank Discharge End panel
'A~
/Middle Hood/ Top Cover 114 Group VI Limiting stress is in the 1f4" thick hood cover plate and 1f4" attachment fillet weld. Mod provides additional reinforcement, additional                                                             3.00 weldment, and stiffening.
Outer Bank Discharge End panel  
oJ!
/Middle Hood/ Top Cover Group VI 114 Limiting stress is in the 1f4" thick hood cover plate and 1f4" attachment fillet weld. Mod provides additional reinforcement, additional 3.00 weldment, and stiffening.
                                                    -L- ~        ,_,~-
B oJ! ~
                                                                    "_      ..LJ B
..LJ
                                                                                                                ~
-L-
MIDDLE HOOD/COVER PLATE/END CLOSURE REINFORCING GUSSET 0.25                           0.75 SECTION B-B 12
~-
~
MIDDLE HOOD/COVER PLATE/END CLOSURE REINFORCING GUSSET 0.25 0.75 SECTION B-B 12  


Steam Dryer Stress Analysis                             [II]
[II]
- Interim Operation at Limited Power o Based on stress analysis at 11 Oo~ OLTP with currently modified steam dryer o Low flow noise included o SR > 2.0 o Implement mid-cycle
Steam Dryer Stress Analysis  
- Operation at 120% OLTP after Additional Steam Dryer Modifications o Based on stress analysis at 1200~ OLTP with additional modifications to steam dryer o Low flow noise included o SR > 2.0 o Implement modifications Fall 2010 13
- Interim Operation at Limited Power o Based on stress analysis at 11 Oo~ OLTP with currently modified steam dryer o Low flow noise included o SR > 2.0 o Implement mid-cycle  
- Operation at 120% OLTP after Additional Steam Dryer Modifications o Based on stress analysis at 1200~ OLTP with additional modifications to steam dryer o Low flow noise included o SR > 2.0 o Implement modifications Fall 2010 13  


Steam Dryer Stress Analysis [II]
[II]
Planned Submittals
Steam Dryer Stress Analysis Planned Submittals  
  - 110 % OLTP o Load report o Stress report o Limit curves
- 110 % OLTP o Load report o Stress report o Limit curves  
  - 120% OLTP o Load report o Stress report o Limit curves o Submodels
- 120% OLTP o Load report o Stress report o Limit curves o Submodels  
  - Submittal by August 28 14}}
- Submittal by August 28 14}}

Latest revision as of 09:32, 14 January 2025

TVA Conference Call Presentation Slides on Browns Ferry Nuclear Plant, Unit 1 Steam Dryer Analysis
ML092440518
Person / Time
Site: Browns Ferry Tennessee Valley Authority icon.png
Issue date: 08/07/2009
From:
Tennessee Valley Authority
To:
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
Brown E, NRR/DORL, 415-2315
Shared Package
ML092440524 List:
References
TAC MD5262
Download: ML092440518 (14)


Text

lim TENNESSEE VALLEY AUTHORITY BROWNS FERRY NUCLEAR PLANT UNIT 1 Steam Dryer Analysis August 7,2009

[II]

Steam Dryer Stress Analysis

  • Low Flow Noise Included
  • Re-analyzing Steam Dryer Stress to Show SR > 2.0

- As built steam dryer at 110% OLTP

- Modified steam dryer at 1200/0 OLTP 2

[II]

Steam Dryer Stress Analysis

  • 1100/0 OLTP Based on CDI 08-15P (March 2009) with:

- Low flow noise included

- Adjusted bump-up for 1100/0 v2 & 110% resonance

- Same steam dryer configuration

- Utilization of ASME Table NG 3352-1

- SR > 2.0 3

iii]

Steam Dryer Stress Analysis

  • 120% OLTP Based on COl 08-15P (March 2009) with:

- Low flow noise included

- Additional steam dryer modifications

- Revision of two submodels o 1 SIA - 1 COl

- Utilization of ASME Table NG 3352-1

- SR > 2.0 4

[II]

Steam Dryer Stress Analysis z

x~

y index I Outer Hood - Old Bar

& Lock Gussets Group I Drain Channels Group III Inner Hood Stiffeners Group II 5

Steam Dryer Stress Analysis mil Middle Hood/F&T Tie Bar Group IV Outer Hood Side Panel I Vane Bank End Wall Group V Outer Bank Discharge End panel I Middle Hood I Top Cover Group VI 6

III]

Steam Dryer Stress Analysis Noise Retained Modifications Old Tie Bar/Lock Gusset Reinforcing Bar ole Replace with TVA Gusset Group I lli; i

't:!

ll~

-.L 3tL Drill Yo" DIA Re' ThtuP lie

~ Two (2) lJUssets are "'ll\\lired per C-vssel Pad s:eam dam. four (-4) iotal per unit.

~Oam(1 n

~

~

Existing Configuration at 4 Locations, Where Old TB Remnant and Lock Gusset Were Retained.

L/

Stress Intensities Seen in Base Plate, TB 1

Connection & Lock Gusset Connections.

Mod Removes this Configuration and Replaces with Revised Gusset as Found in all other Locations, Stiffens the top of Steam Dam with a ~

Pipe Section, & Reinforces the %" Thick Outer STEAM DAM GUSSET ASSEMBLY Hood Cover.

PATCH PLATE LOCATIONS DETAILS - BFN U1 7

Steam Dryer Stress Analysis 1m Noise Retained Modifications Inner Hood Stiffeners - Group II Limiting stress location is at bottom corner of Hood Stiffener 2 sided fillet weld. Addition of stress relief semi-circular hole reduces stress acting on weld and adds flexibility to corner.

Modifications provide a resultant SRF =.53 Previous Solid Sub Model Revised to Evaluate Stress Relief and Resultant SRF HOOD SlIPPORT

.2:5


~1.75

~.

I 3.f1E 3,1 000-TO-HOOD SUPPORT RELIEF HO ASEUNE DIMENSIONS 8

[iI]

Steam Dryer Stress Analysis Noise Retained Modifications Drain Channels - Group III DC Follow the Dryer Skirt Modal Response. Limiting Stress Location is at Bottom of Drain Channel Weld, that has been Already Reinforced and Wrapped Underneath the DC. Addition of Stress Relief Semi-circular Hole Reduces Stress Acting on Weld and Adds Flexibility to Corner.

Modifications Provide SRF =.43 Previous Solid Sub Model Revised to Evaluate Stress Relief and Resultant SRF 1Ia" Drain el(ref}j J'ttt R 3.50 (lefl-\\

~

A


114" Dryer Skirt (reI)__

18" [)fain Ch01f1nel (reI) -_~/

Semi-circu Re~H

'Nolie: These dimensi:>ns are g;ven as arc I~

along.!he O'..I"V3".ure of Section A-A drain Ch01f1 DRAIN CHANNEL END RELIEF HOLE CONCEPT 9

[iJJ Steam Dryer Stress Analysis Noise Retained Modifications 6 This n:et::h is appbcable only co lie bars spanning the ou~r ci;scharge duc.-:s. 4 reauired.

Middle Hood/F&T Tie Bar - Group IV One location, between outer and middle banks, has a high stress located under the tie bar in the weld to the hood section. Additional reinforcement using a reinforcing plate and additional welds is to be added.

Vane Rank A total of four (4) symmetrical locations will be Cover (rei) modified.

l~

~, [7/0-Max

,__.. __.--.-~

See FW'e

'j,I.

6"

  • 1 (ref)

C FLARED &TAPERED TIE BAR OUTER VANE BANK DISCHARGES See OU.:er Tie Bar-to-Hood Reinroreement DetI:iI Shee, 8,80t:om comers ma~ be rounded to 0.25" maximum rallYs

'thin % 1 inc:ll 01 flare break line to {aciSta:e welding.

~

1**1 l'

Surfac.e may be m.a.chined a requ'red ior lihlp if vane bank to hood offsl!l is Iessthill 114'_

10

Steam Dryer Stress Analysis mil Noise Retained Modifications Outer Hood Side Panel

/ Vane Bank End Wall Group V Limiting Component is the 3/8" thick Vane Bank End Closure Plate.

Structural Thickness Changes Of Drain Trough, behind Plate, Contribute to Stress Intensity. Mod Provides Reinforcement to Distribute Stress 318" x 2" Reinfordng Bar "7

3/8" Vane Bank 3/8" Outer Hood ~.

L-- End Plate (ref)

Closure Plate (ref)

Bf 1/4" Vane Bank Outlet Skle Trough Plate (ref) 1/2" x 6-1/2' Trough Upper Ring (ref) C ReinforCing Plate, Both SiOes (re.f) 1/2" Vane Bank Bottom Plate (ref)

End View - Outer Hood Closure-to-Vane 1/2" x6-1/2' Trough Reinforcing Plate (ref)

~ 318" Vane Bank End Plate (ref) -

316

~~..,

2' x 318" thk x 24" Ig Reinfordng Bar 318" Hood Closure Plate (ref) --'..., I lY Section A-A (Cut Thru Trough)

Section B-B (Cut Thru Perforated Plate) 11

[II]

Steam Dryer Stress Analysis R 0.25 (TVP)

Noise Retained Modifications

+

'A~

Outer Bank Discharge End panel

/Middle Hood/ Top Cover Group VI 114 Limiting stress is in the 1f4" thick hood cover plate and 1f4" attachment fillet weld. Mod provides additional reinforcement, additional 3.00 weldment, and stiffening.

B oJ! ~

..LJ

-L-

~-

~

MIDDLE HOOD/COVER PLATE/END CLOSURE REINFORCING GUSSET 0.25 0.75 SECTION B-B 12

[II]

Steam Dryer Stress Analysis

- Interim Operation at Limited Power o Based on stress analysis at 11 Oo~ OLTP with currently modified steam dryer o Low flow noise included o SR > 2.0 o Implement mid-cycle

- Operation at 120% OLTP after Additional Steam Dryer Modifications o Based on stress analysis at 1200~ OLTP with additional modifications to steam dryer o Low flow noise included o SR > 2.0 o Implement modifications Fall 2010 13

[II]

Steam Dryer Stress Analysis Planned Submittals

- 110 % OLTP o Load report o Stress report o Limit curves

- 120% OLTP o Load report o Stress report o Limit curves o Submodels

- Submittal by August 28 14