ML17059B562
| ML17059B562 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Nine Mile Point  |
| Issue date: | 05/16/1997 |
| From: | Trench R MPR ASSOCIATES, INC. |
| To: | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML17059B563 | List: |
| References | |
| 085-295-02, 085-295-02-R01, 85-295-2, 85-295-2-R1, S14-33M009, S14-33M9, NUDOCS 9705280089 | |
| Download: ML17059B562 (28) | |
Text
CALC$Jg Pp~gO ILIMPR P.eu.o f<~c 4, oP lg MPR Associates, inc.320 King Street Alexandria, VA 22314 CALCULATION TITLE PAGE Client Project Title Niagara Mohawk Power Corporation NMP-1 RWCU Weld 33-FW-22 Overlay Design SSFLAW Overlay Size Page1of8+r4~u~avm Task No.085-9708-295-0 Calculation No.085-295-02 Preparer/Date Checker/Date Reviewer/Date Rev.No.s./hach p g~~r~~c~~~s (ra/pp 5//c/'5'P s/c/gg f~Quf~(r.(q7 QUALITY ASSURANCE DOCUMENT his document has been prepared, checked, and reviewed in accordance with the Quality Assurance requirements of 10CFR50 Appendix B, as specified in the MPR Quality Assurance Manual.9705280089 970519 PDR ADQCK 05000220 P PDR H'll c-A~gt4-EgH oo lilMPR MPR Associates, Inc.320 Nng Street Alexandria, VA 22314 of (+RECORD OF REVISIONS Calcuiation No.085-2952 Revision Prepared By c i~Description Checked By Page 2 Initial Issue Changed title of Attachment
- 1.
gV tiiMX u Calculation No.085-295-02 Prepared By p~~4 oP/g MPR Associates, Inc.320 King Street Alexandria, VA 22314 Page 3 CONTENTS Section 1.0 2.0 PURPOSE
SUMMARY
OF RESULTS.~Pa e 3.0 APPROACH 4.0 CALCULATION 5.0 OVERLAY LENGTH CALCULATION 6.0 ATI'ACHMENTS 1 SSFLAW Program Output 2 Examination Report for Weld 33-FW-22 dated 5/15/97 I
CAu 5'll-3HOoR km~O r~~MX R MPR Associates, Inc.320 King Street Alexandria, VA 22314>og lg Calculation No.085-295-02 Prepared By Page 4 1.0 PURPOSE The purpose of this calculation is to determine the thickness of an overlay to be installed at the location of Weld 33-FW-22 in the NMP-1 RWCU piping system.2.0
SUMMARY
The overlay size is: Thickness:
Length: 0.25-inch minimum 25-inch minimum, centered on the nozzle side edge of the weld crown 3.0 APPROACH In 1988 NMPC obtained computer program SSFLAW, which calculates overlay sizes using the method presented in Reference 1.Reference 2 describes the program, its development, and use, and provides a user manual for the program.The program performs the following operations:
SSFLAW assumes the crack extends 360 degrees around the pipe and penetrates fully through the original pipe walL The crack is assumed to stop at the overlay.
st~=A 4 1(
lXLMPR A.e MPR Associates, Inc.320 King Street Alexandria, VA 22314 Calculation No.085-295-02 Prepared By Checked By Page 5 SSFLAW then uses the stresses applied to the section to determine the overlay thickness needed to prevent plastic collapse of the section, including a factor of safety of 2.77 as required by NUREG-0313, Revision 2.4.0 CALCULATION 4.1 Pro m SSFLAWIn uts Appendix A to the SSFLAW user's manual (Reference 2)describes the inputs required to run the program.The required inputs for overlay sizing are listed below, along with the values to be used in the pI'ograIn.
, e'e i t Int n i n d n h.SSFLAWdefaultvalues for these parameters are used.The program calculates these parameters for Type 304 material at the input temperature of the system (discussed below).0 eratin Tem erature.Per Reference 3, the design nozzle temperature is 575'F.Pressure.Per Reference 3, the design pressure of the nozzle is 1300 psig.Pi e Outside Diameter and Wall Thickness.
Per Reference 3, the weld is in nominal 6-inch piping (6.625-inch actual OD)with 0.38-inch minimum wall thickness.
~+~<I4-9Hoa~/LIMPR MPR Associates, Inc.320 King Street Alexandria, VA 22314 Calculation No.085-295-02 Prepared By Page 6 A lied Stresses.Stresses are calculated in Reference 4 as follows: Applied Tensile Stress;Applied Bending Stress: 0.4 ksi 12.0 ksi Note that the above stresses include secondary stresses due to thermal expansion.
Treating thermal stresses as primary stresses is required by NUREG-0313, Revision 2 for overlays fabricated from SMAW weld metal.Per the SSFLAW user manual, pressure stress is calculated separately by the program and so is not to be included in the input stresses.Note that the following parameters are speciQed for input into Program SSFLAW but are not needed for the overlay sizing calculation method: 'eld Type Residual Stress State Haw Orientation, Length and Depth Service Interval Reference Source for Allowable Haw Size Therefore, for Program SSFLAW runs made in this calculation, the input values for these parameters are selected as default values.Pro m SSFLAW Results Attachment 1 presents the printout from Program SSFLAW run for the above inputs.The results show that an overlay thickness of 0.25-inch minimum is acceptable for the applied stresses.Program SSFLAW was developed and used in accordance with the MPR Associates Quality Assurance Program.
e.~~s'i<seed~iiiMPu d'+lc MPH Associates, Inc.320 King Street Alexandria, VA 22314 Calculation No.085-29542 Prepared By Checked By Page 7 5.0 OVERLAY LENGTH CALCULATION Code Case N-504 (Reference 5)provides the foHowing instruction for determining the length of the overlay required beyond each edge of the observed flaws: Length=0.75 (R)(t)where R=outer radius and t=nominal wall thickness of pipe.Accordingly, the required overlay length beyond each end of the observed flaws for this 6-inch OD, schedule 80 pipe is: Length=0.75 (6.625"/2)(0.432")=0.9" Per Reference 6 (Attachment 2), the observed length of the indication is 0531-inch (equal to 7/16-inch plus 3/32-inch).
The required length is then: 0.531"+2 (0.9")=2.33" Use 2.5-inch minimum length centered on the nozzle side edge of the weld crown.
r l P 5A s i<-%Mow tsiMPR MPR Associates, Inc.320 King Street Alexandria, VA 22314 g gp/+Calculation No.085-295-02 Prepared By 6-Checked By Page 8
5.0 REFERENCES
"Evaluation of Flaws in Austenitic Steel Piping,"Section XI Task Group for Piping Flaw Evaluation (ASME Code), Journal Of Pressure Vessel Technology, Volume 108, No.3, August 1986.2.MPR Report MPR-1037, Revision 1,"SSFLAW-A Computer Program to Evaluate Cracks in Stainless Steel Piping (Version 1.1)," April 1988.3.Southwestern Engineering Company Drawing 77528, Rev.17,"Regenerative Clean-up Heat 4 Exchanger" (for RWCU HX ND-03).4.MPR Calculation 085-295-01,"NMP-1 RWCU Weld 33-FW-22 Overlay Design, Stresses for Input to Program SSFLAW," Revision 0.5.ASME Boiler And Pressure Vessel Code Case N-504, dated April 30, 1992.6.NMPC Radiographic Examination Report for Weld 33-FW-22 dated 5/15/97.Pncluded as I Attachment 2.]
C.4m 5 J4-gg Ho ra1MPR MPR Associates, Inc.320 King Street Alexandria, VA 22314/D OP/$Calculation No.085-295-02 Prepared By M cs~Checked By Page 1 ATTACHMENT 1 SSFLAW Program Output I
ÃQeu 0 DOC NO O$S'.Z tS'-o z Of t$SSFLAW Version 1.1 (April 5, 1988)ATI'ACHMENT OF Overlay Sizing Calculation Results 33-FW-22 Weld Overlay Sizing Date: 5/16/97 Pipe Material: Type 304 Stainless Steel Sm=16.67 ksi Sy=18.50 ksi Pipe Geometry: Outside Diameter=Wall Thickness=
6.625 in 0.380 in System Operating Conditions:
Pressure=1300.0 psig Temperature=
575.0 F Tensile Stress (ksi)Bending Stress (ksi)Pressure Stress (ksi)Normal Conditions 0.40 12.00 5.02 Faulted Conditions 0.40 12.00 5.02 Required Weld Overlay Dimensions:
Overla Thickness=
0.233 in verlay Length=1.
WMPR 5'I4-39<o/2 MPR Associates, Inc.320 King Street Alexandria, VA 22314 Calculation No.085-295-02 Prepared By Checked By Page 1 ATTACHMENT 2 Radiographic Examination Report for Weld 33-FiV-22 dated 5/15/97
n I..y,l r~~~t 4L.C S(4-33HLIQ ada!r't3 O p l4 RADIOQRAPEIC EXAMINATION REPORT OOC.NO AWACHMen Z SHEET~OFT NIAGARA IC MOII*IIIK RT ExAMINATloN REPoltT Kine Mlle Point Unit lSO/b wg.: Syatem:+i~~P NDS Re port: Page 1 ot J Work Document: Exam Item: Procedure:
/01'tC.Radiation Source and SIN:~c4 llstsrl~I Typo: C./+5+No.ol Curios: tI~KY: Mn: Baae Metal Thlckneae!-
ObJect to Film Dlatance:-5'4 Weld Thickneee!
Film Load: Ellldl~Douhle~Other Pips Qlamelar or.Prooeaslnp:
lisnusl~Auto Weld Leepth: 'yensttometsr Numhe Wellflilp Presses(sei liood: penetrsmelsr Mstarlal nd No.: rtdt~~>>s Location: Film Side!""-ri Shim Material and Thlckneaa Sack: Technique Qeed r o/2 Geometric Vnaharpnoee (VG)0-S.Z./04>>/()ee ()MI io 0 0 IA C H'0 C H AC'h I Q C O H Io~t~t 0 Q C C 0 do C If 0~r 0 C JC Co o le I C~e C O H C c V H C 4, I 0 0~d Wu Q C l H C Eu L 0~r 6 Ee C 0 r ot H C O H Ie Es C Mm 0~C Et ar Ei C V 0 Cy cx EllmJahmchrr f<<dh 1$C)Ctsv~vrtr~4 W~00 11ndt W<HCvrdp g J Eet, Q 5 (1 CiN)Q h ct.uT 5"'t~c.'I Q rmsr)4.~I$Jhde ufo(, Otal, 0 M~lM c S Th OV'ttlAcceotaytce Criteria!Examiner 1: '~4'xaminer Reviewer: ANtt~Exam Item table?Yea No t.evet~bate!
t.evel~Date!~'~Prevloue WctsgF Level: halo: Pals Rsvleusdy Yee thn No D~te: mavin>>sr
/
.-.-~L4 NQHQlSK PlantlUnjt:
ljlne t5jje pojnt Unjt.!$0/Dao.: System'.srarcv stjixv gDE Report-+orL Document: Palate ot Exam Item.ProcedvreIRN4:
5'(4-S3Ho~1~e~>($o+/4 r6 (54+we+roe~DOC.NO ATTACHMENT SHEET>QF-+=g~(Tn SCALE-&<~CA v S~~~)c78IC Exainjner 1;Examjnor 2-Aevle~1: Lev,L CaaPsny: nslc-<~r:-~I"W: b'av>: Coaes~r: