ML020850432: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(StriderTol Bot insert)
 
(StriderTol Bot change)
 
Line 23: Line 23:
Nuclear Management Company, LLC
Nuclear Management Company, LLC
6610 Nuclear Road
6610 Nuclear Road
Two Rivers, WI 54241
Two Rivers, WI 54241
SUBJECT:         POINT BEACH NUCLEAR PLANT
SUBJECT:
                NRC INSPECTION REPORT 50-266/02-03(DRP); 50-301/02-03(DRP)
POINT BEACH NUCLEAR PLANT
NRC INSPECTION REPORT 50-266/02-03(DRP); 50-301/02-03(DRP)
Dear Mr. Warner:
Dear Mr. Warner:
On February 25, 2002, the NRC completed a team inspection at the Point Beach Nuclear Plant.
On February 25, 2002, the NRC completed a team inspection at the Point Beach Nuclear Plant.  
The enclosed report documents the inspection findings which were discussed on February 25
The enclosed report documents the inspection findings which were discussed on February 25
with you and members of your staff.
with you and members of your staff.
This inspection was an examination of activities conducted under your license as they relate to
This inspection was an examination of activities conducted under your license as they relate to
the identification and resolution of problems, and compliance with the Commissions rules and
the identification and resolution of problems, and compliance with the Commissions rules and
regulations and with the conditions of your operating license. Within these areas, the
regulations and with the conditions of your operating license. Within these areas, the
inspection involved selected examination of procedures and representative records,
inspection involved selected examination of procedures and representative records,
observations of activities, and interviews with personnel.
observations of activities, and interviews with personnel.
On the basis of the samples selected for review, the team concluded that, overall, problems
On the basis of the samples selected for review, the team concluded that, overall, problems
were properly identified, evaluated, and resolved within the problem identification and resolution
were properly identified, evaluated, and resolved within the problem identification and resolution
program. However, the inspectors identified one finding for which the safety significance was
program. However, the inspectors identified one finding for which the safety significance was
still to be determined. This issue pertained to the failure of the 2P-15B safety injection pump on
still to be determined. This issue pertained to the failure of the 2P-15B safety injection pump on
February 20, 2002, because of nitrogen gas binding. The conditions that resulted in the
February 20, 2002, because of nitrogen gas binding. The conditions that resulted in the
accumulation of nitrogen in the pump were still being evaluated by both your staff and the NRC
accumulation of nitrogen in the pump were still being evaluated by both your staff and the NRC
at the end of this inspection. This issue will be considered an Unresolved Item pending
at the end of this inspection. This issue will be considered an Unresolved Item pending
completion of those reviews. A preliminary NRC review of the risk significance of the finding
completion of those reviews. A preliminary NRC review of the risk significance of the finding
determined that it was at least of very low safety significance (Green).
determined that it was at least of very low safety significance (Green).  


M. Warner                                         -2-
M. Warner
-2-
In accordance with 10 CFR 2.790 of the NRCs Rules of Practice, a copy of this letter
In accordance with 10 CFR 2.790 of the NRCs Rules of Practice, a copy of this letter
and its enclosure will be available electronically for public inspection in the NRC Public
and its enclosure will be available electronically for public inspection in the NRC Public
Document Room or from the Publicly Available Records System (PARS) component of
Document Room or from the Publicly Available Records System (PARS) component of
NRCs document system (ADAMS). ADAMS is accessible from the NRC Web site at
NRCs document system (ADAMS). ADAMS is accessible from the NRC Web site at  
http://www.nrc.gov/NRC/ADAMS/index.html (the Public Electronic Reading Room).
http://www.nrc.gov/NRC/ADAMS/index.html (the Public Electronic Reading Room).
                                              Sincerely,
Sincerely,
                                              /RA/
/RA/
                                              Roger Lanksbury, Chief
Roger Lanksbury, Chief
                                              Branch 5
Branch 5
                                              Division of Reactor Projects
Division of Reactor Projects
Docket Nos. 50-266; 50-301
Docket Nos. 50-266; 50-301
License Nos. DPR-24; DPR-27
License Nos. DPR-24; DPR-27
Enclosure:     Inspection Report 50-266/02-03(DRP);
Enclosure:
                50-301/02-03(DRP)
Inspection Report 50-266/02-03(DRP);  
cc w/encl:     R. Grigg, President and Chief
  50-301/02-03(DRP)
                Operating Officer, WEPCo
cc w/encl:
              R. Anderson, Executive Vice President
R. Grigg, President and Chief
                and Chief Nuclear Officer
  Operating Officer, WEPCo
              T. Webb, Licensing Manager
R. Anderson, Executive Vice President
              D. Weaver, Nuclear Asset Manager
  and Chief Nuclear Officer
              T. Taylor, Plant Manager
T. Webb, Licensing Manager
              A. Cayia, Site Director
D. Weaver, Nuclear Asset Manager
              J. ONeill, Jr., Shaw, Pittman,
T. Taylor, Plant Manager
                Potts & Trowbridge
A. Cayia, Site Director
              K. Duveneck, Town Chairman
J. ONeill, Jr., Shaw, Pittman,  
                Town of Two Creeks
  Potts & Trowbridge
              D. Graham, Director
K. Duveneck, Town Chairman
                Bureau of Field Operations
  Town of Two Creeks
              A. Bie, Chairperson, Wisconsin
D. Graham, Director
                Public Service Commission
  Bureau of Field Operations
              S. Jenkins, Electric Division
A. Bie, Chairperson, Wisconsin
                Wisconsin Public Service Commission
  Public Service Commission
              State Liaison Officer
S. Jenkins, Electric Division
  Wisconsin Public Service Commission
State Liaison Officer


DOCUMENT NAME: G:\poin\poi2002003 drp.wpd
DOCUMENT NAME: G:\\poin\\poi2002003 drp.wpd
To receive a copy of this document, indicate in the box: "C" = Copy without attachment/enclosure "E" = Copy with attachment/enclosure "N" = No copy
To receive a copy of this document, indicate in the box: "C" = Copy without attachment/enclosure   "E" = Copy with attachment/enclosure   "N" = No copy
OFFICE             RIII                             C RIII                         N
OFFICE
NAME               MKunowski/trn                         RLanksbury
RIII
DATE               03/25/02                             03/25/02
C RIII
                                                          OFFICIAL RECORD COPY
N
NAME
MKunowski/trn
RLanksbury
DATE
03/25/02
03/25/02
OFFICIAL RECORD COPY


M. Warner             -3-
M. Warner
-3-
ADAMS Distribution:
ADAMS Distribution:
WDR
WDR  
DFT
DFT  
BAW
BAW
RidsNrrDipmIipb
RidsNrrDipmIipb
Line 102: Line 114:
JRK1
JRK1


          U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
                          REGION III
REGION III
Docket Nos:         50-266; 50-301
Docket Nos:
License Nos:       DPR-24; DPR-27
50-266; 50-301
Report No:         50-266/02-03(DRP); 50-301/02-03(DRP)
License Nos:
Licensee:           Nuclear Management Company, LLC
DPR-24; DPR-27
Facility:           Point Beach Nuclear Plant, Units 1 & 2
Report No:
Location:           6610 Nuclear Road
50-266/02-03(DRP); 50-301/02-03(DRP)
                    Two Rivers, WI 54241
Licensee:
Dates:             January 22 through February 25, 2002
Nuclear Management Company, LLC
Inspectors:         M. Kunowski, Project Engineer (Lead Inspector)
Facility:
                    P. Krohn, Senior Resident Inspector
Point Beach Nuclear Plant, Units 1 & 2
                    R. Langstaff, Senior Reactor Engineer
Location:
Approved by:       Roger Lanksbury, Chief
6610 Nuclear Road
                    Branch 5
Two Rivers, WI 54241
                    Division of Reactor Projects
Dates:
January 22 through February 25, 2002
Inspectors:
M. Kunowski, Project Engineer (Lead Inspector)
P. Krohn, Senior Resident Inspector
R. Langstaff, Senior Reactor Engineer
Approved by:
Roger Lanksbury, Chief
Branch 5
Division of Reactor Projects


                                    SUMMARY OF FINDINGS
2
IR 05000266-02-03; 05000301-02-03, on 1/22-2/25/2002. Nuclear Management Company,
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS
IR 05000266-02-03; 05000301-02-03, on 1/22-2/25/2002. Nuclear Management Company,
LLC, Point Beach Nuclear Plant, baseline inspection of the identification and resolution of
LLC, Point Beach Nuclear Plant, baseline inspection of the identification and resolution of
problems.
problems.
The inspection was conducted by two regional inspectors and a resident inspector. No findings
The inspection was conducted by two regional inspectors and a resident inspector. No findings  
were identified during this inspection. The significance of most findings is indicated by their
were identified during this inspection. The significance of most findings is indicated by their
color (Green, White, Yellow, Red) using Inspection Manual Chapter 0609, Significance
color (Green, White, Yellow, Red) using Inspection Manual Chapter 0609, Significance
Determination Process (SDP). Findings for which the SDP does not apply are indicated by
Determination Process (SDP). Findings for which the SDP does not apply are indicated by
No Color or by the severity level of the applicable violation. The NRCs program for
No Color or by the severity level of the applicable violation. The NRCs program for
overseeing the safe operation of commercial nuclear power reactors is described at its Reactor
overseeing the safe operation of commercial nuclear power reactors is described at its Reactor
Oversight Process website at http://www.nrc.gov/NRR/OVERSIGHT/index.html.
Oversight Process website at http://www.nrc.gov/NRR/OVERSIGHT/index.html.
Identification and Resolution of Problems
Identification and Resolution of Problems
The team concluded that the licensee was generally effective at identifying problems and
The team concluded that the licensee was generally effective at identifying problems and
putting them into the corrective action program. There was strong management emphasis on
putting them into the corrective action program. There was strong management emphasis on
plant staff to identify problems and, overall, a very responsive plant staff. Since 1997, there
plant staff to identify problems and, overall, a very responsive plant staff. Since 1997, there
had been an average of 4120 condition reports written each year. A recent change from a
had been an average of 4120 condition reports written each year. A recent change from a
mainframe-based, dated, and user-unfriendly corrective action database to a Web-based
mainframe-based, dated, and user-unfriendly corrective action database to a Web-based
system was expected by the licensee to improve plant staff involvement with the corrective
system was expected by the licensee to improve plant staff involvement with the corrective
action program and to increase program management capability. Corrective action program
action program and to increase program management capability. Corrective action program
timeliness was still an area of weakness and one where the licensee was expending additional
timeliness was still an area of weakness and one where the licensee was expending additional
efforts. Included in this effort was an emphasis on making improvements for overdue or less
efforts. Included in this effort was an emphasis on making improvements for overdue or less
than prompt assessments of problems and implementation of corrective actions and for an
than prompt assessments of problems and implementation of corrective actions and for an
excessive number of due date extensions. Although there had been some dissatisfaction
excessive number of due date extensions. Although there had been some dissatisfaction
expressed with some aspects of the corrective action program, the inspectors identified no
expressed with some aspects of the corrective action program, the inspectors identified no
impediments to a safety conscious work environment. One finding was identified that was at
impediments to a safety conscious work environment. One finding was identified that was at
least of very low safety significance (Green). This finding pertained to the failure of the 2P-15B
least of very low safety significance (Green). This finding pertained to the failure of the 2P-15B
safety injection pump on February 20, 2002, because of nitrogen gas binding. The conditions
safety injection pump on February 20, 2002, because of nitrogen gas binding. The conditions
that resulted in the accumulation of nitrogen in the pump were still being evaluated by both the
that resulted in the accumulation of nitrogen in the pump were still being evaluated by both the
licensees staff and the NRC at the end of this inspection. This issue will be considered an
licensees staff and the NRC at the end of this inspection. This issue will be considered an
Unresolved Item pending completion of those reviews.
Unresolved Item pending completion of those reviews.
                                                  2


                                          Report Details
3
4.     OTHER ACTIVITIES (OA)
Report Details
4.
OTHER ACTIVITIES (OA)
4OA2 Identification and Resolution of Problems
4OA2 Identification and Resolution of Problems
    a. Effectiveness of Problem Identification
      a. Effectiveness of Problem Identification
  (1) Inspection Scope
      (1) Inspection Scope
      The inspectors conducted plant tours; observed surveillance tests in progress;
The inspectors conducted plant tours; observed surveillance tests in progress;
      interviewed plant personnel; and reviewed inspection reports issued over the last year;
interviewed plant personnel; and reviewed inspection reports issued over the last year;
      corrective action program documents (condition reports (CRs) - as of
corrective action program documents (condition reports (CRs) - as of
      December 21, 2001, CRs were replaced by documents called CAPs (Corrective Action
December 21, 2001, CRs were replaced by documents called CAPs (Corrective Action
      Program documents)), and selected maintenance work orders (WOs) for several high
Program documents)), and selected maintenance work orders (WOs) for several high
      risk systems to determine if problems were being properly identified, characterized, and
risk systems to determine if problems were being properly identified, characterized, and
      entered into the corrective action program for evaluation and resolution. These systems
entered into the corrective action program for evaluation and resolution. These systems
      were Service Water (SW), 4160-volt, emergency diesel generators (EDGs), safety
were Service Water (SW), 4160-volt, emergency diesel generators (EDGs), safety
      injection (SI), and instrument air. The inspectors also reviewed several recent licensee
injection (SI), and instrument air. The inspectors also reviewed several recent licensee
      audits and self-assessments. The effectiveness of the audits and assessments was
audits and self-assessments. The effectiveness of the audits and assessments was
      evaluated by comparing the audit and assessment results against self-revealing and
evaluated by comparing the audit and assessment results against self-revealing and
      NRC-identified issues. A listing of the documents requested by the inspectors prior to
NRC-identified issues. A listing of the documents requested by the inspectors prior to
      the inspection and those documents reviewed during the inspection is included at the
the inspection and those documents reviewed during the inspection is included at the
      end of this report.
end of this report.
  (2) Findings
      (2) Findings
      In general, problems were properly identified, characterized, and entered into the
In general, problems were properly identified, characterized, and entered into the
      corrective action program for evaluation and resolution. There was strong management
corrective action program for evaluation and resolution. There was strong management
      emphasis on plant staff to document problems in the corrective action program and a
emphasis on plant staff to document problems in the corrective action program and a
      plant staff that, overall, was very responsive. Since 1997, there had been an average of
plant staff that, overall, was very responsive. Since 1997, there had been an average of
      4120 CRs written per year. In 2001, there were 3819 CRs/CAPs generated. On
4120 CRs written per year. In 2001, there were 3819 CRs/CAPs generated. On
      December 21, 2001, the licensee switched its corrective action program database
December 21, 2001, the licensee switched its corrective action program database
      system from a mainframe-based, dated, and relatively user-unfriendly system (called
system from a mainframe-based, dated, and relatively user-unfriendly system (called
      NUTRK) to a Web-based, user-friendly system (called t-Track).
NUTRK) to a Web-based, user-friendly system (called t-Track).
      Several process improvements had helped to encourage the writing of CRs\CAPs: the
Several process improvements had helped to encourage the writing of CRs\\CAPs: the
      CR\AR hotline; department corrective action program liaisons; the new web-based
CR\\AR hotline; department corrective action program liaisons; the new web-based
      system; and the Good Catch initiative for examples of notably good problem
system; and the Good Catch initiative for examples of notably good problem
      identification. Through routine trending of corrective action program data, the licensee
identification. Through routine trending of corrective action program data, the licensee
      had identified instances where CR/CAP generation rates by various work groups had
had identified instances where CR/CAP generation rates by various work groups had
      not met station management expectations. For instance, in one plant group, the
not met station management expectations. For instance, in one plant group, the
      expected number of CRs/CAPs were being generated but more than 85% of them were
expected number of CRs/CAPs were being generated but more than 85% of them were
      written by 2 of the 23 persons in the work group. For another group, the percentage of
written by 2 of the 23 persons in the work group. For another group, the percentage of
      self-identified CAPs fell below an expected value. In both examples, the licensee took
self-identified CAPs fell below an expected value. In both examples, the licensee took
      corrective actions.
corrective actions.
                                                3


      Regarding audits and self-assessment findings, there were no major discrepancies with
4
      the observations of the inspectors. Appropriate corrective actions were taken by the
Regarding audits and self-assessment findings, there were no major discrepancies with
      licensee for problems identified during the audits and self-assessments.
the observations of the inspectors. Appropriate corrective actions were taken by the
b.   Prioritization and Evaluation of Issues
licensee for problems identified during the audits and self-assessments.
  (1) Inspection Scope
    b.
      The inspectors reviewed a sample of CRs/CAPs to verify the appropriateness of the
Prioritization and Evaluation of Issues
      category assigned, operability and reportability determinations, extent of condition
      (1) Inspection Scope
      evaluations, root and apparent cause evaluations, and the assigned corrective actions.
The inspectors reviewed a sample of CRs/CAPs to verify the appropriateness of the
      As part of this assessment, the inspectors attended the stations daily management
category assigned, operability and reportability determinations, extent of condition
      meeting where newly generated CRs/CAPs were reviewed and the subsequent daily
evaluations, root and apparent cause evaluations, and the assigned corrective actions.  
      meeting of department corrective action program liaisons. The inspectors also attended
As part of this assessment, the inspectors attended the stations daily management
      a meeting of the Corrective Action Review Board (CARB). In addition, the inspectors
meeting where newly generated CRs/CAPs were reviewed and the subsequent daily
      reviewed licensee actions on several problems identified by the inspectors during the
meeting of department corrective action program liaisons. The inspectors also attended
      previous problem identification and resolution inspection (PI&R) in March 2001 (NRC
a meeting of the Corrective Action Review Board (CARB). In addition, the inspectors
      Inspection Report 50-266/01-06; 50-301/01-06). The documents listed at the end of the
reviewed licensee actions on several problems identified by the inspectors during the
      report were used by the inspectors during the assessment of this area.
previous problem identification and resolution inspection (PI&R) in March 2001 (NRC
  (2) Findings
Inspection Report 50-266/01-06; 50-301/01-06). The documents listed at the end of the
      In general, issues were appropriately categorized, prioritized, and evaluated. In
report were used by the inspectors during the assessment of this area.
      addition, licensee actions to address a concern identified during the previous PI&R with
      (2) Findings
      the appropriateness of the initial screening of CRs were generally effective. During the
In general, issues were appropriately categorized, prioritized, and evaluated. In
      review of CRs/CAPs, the inspectors identified one example (CR 01-0203, 4KV System
addition, licensee actions to address a concern identified during the previous PI&R with
      Grounds) where not all of the pertinent evaluations conducted by the licensee for a
the appropriateness of the initial screening of CRs were generally effective. During the
      problem had been documented in the closed-out CR. This example and other examples
review of CRs/CAPs, the inspectors identified one example (CR 01-0203, 4KV System
      identified by the licensee highlight the need for continued emphasis by the licensee on
Grounds) where not all of the pertinent evaluations conducted by the licensee for a
      thorough documentation of evaluations and corrective actions.
problem had been documented in the closed-out CR. This example and other examples
c.   Effectiveness of Corrective Actions
identified by the licensee highlight the need for continued emphasis by the licensee on
  (1) Inspection Scope
thorough documentation of evaluations and corrective actions.
      The inspectors reviewed CRs/CAPs to verify that corrective actions commensurate with
    c.   Effectiveness of Corrective Actions
      the issues were identified and implemented in a timely manner, including corrective
      (1) Inspection Scope
      actions to address common cause or generic concerns. During the previous PI&R, the
The inspectors reviewed CRs/CAPs to verify that corrective actions commensurate with
      inspectors identified concerns with daisy-chaining---the closing of CRs to other CRs
the issues were identified and implemented in a timely manner, including corrective
      which could be closed to yet other CRs-and the possibility that not all of the corrective
actions to address common cause or generic concerns. During the previous PI&R, the
      actions for the various CRs would be taken because of the difficulty in tracking all of the
inspectors identified concerns with daisy-chaining---the closing of CRs to other CRs
      problems that may be closed to any one CR. In addition, the inspectors in the previous
which could be closed to yet other CRs-and the possibility that not all of the corrective
      PI&R identified a concern with corrective action program timeliness, in that several CRs
actions for the various CRs would be taken because of the difficulty in tracking all of the
      had more than a few due date extensions and several CR evaluations and corrective
problems that may be closed to any one CR. In addition, the inspectors in the previous
      actions were overdue or had exceptionally extended due dates. The documents listed
PI&R identified a concern with corrective action program timeliness, in that several CRs
      at the end of the report were used during the review.
had more than a few due date extensions and several CR evaluations and corrective
                                                4
actions were overdue or had exceptionally extended due dates. The documents listed
at the end of the report were used during the review.


(2) Findings
5
    Generally, effective corrective actions commensurate with the issues were identified by
      (2) Findings
    the licensee and implemented in a timely manner. However, problems with overdue
Generally, effective corrective actions commensurate with the issues were identified by
    problem assessments and implementation of corrective actions, and with excessive
the licensee and implemented in a timely manner. However, problems with overdue
    number of due date extensions were identified by the licensee and the inspectors.
problem assessments and implementation of corrective actions, and with excessive
    Licensee corrective actions for these problems were ongoing as of the end of the
number of due date extensions were identified by the licensee and the inspectors.  
    inspection. Specific observations in this area are discussed below.
Licensee corrective actions for these problems were ongoing as of the end of the
    *       The inspectors reviewed the licensees actions on CR 93-137, which was written
inspection. Specific observations in this area are discussed below.
            in 1993 and was still open at the time of the inspection. This CR was written to
*
            document a potential problem with fault currents exceeding the breaker rating for
The inspectors reviewed the licensees actions on CR 93-137, which was written
            certain short circuits (bolted faults) in the 480-volt, 4160-volt, and 13.8-kilovolt
in 1993 and was still open at the time of the inspection. This CR was written to
            systems. This issue had previously been reviewed in late 1996 by the NRC and
document a potential problem with fault currents exceeding the breaker rating for
            a violation was identified for untimely corrective actions (Inspection Report
certain short circuits (bolted faults) in the 480-volt, 4160-volt, and 13.8-kilovolt
            No. 50-266/96018; 50-301/96018). During the present inspection, the inspectors
systems. This issue had previously been reviewed in late 1996 by the NRC and
            concluded that continuing actions by the licensee had been timely. Through
a violation was identified for untimely corrective actions (Inspection Report
            procedure changes and extensive engineering analyses employing a reduction
No. 50-266/96018; 50-301/96018). During the present inspection, the inspectors
            of over-conservatisms, the licensee had been able to narrow down the problem
concluded that continuing actions by the licensee had been timely. Through
            and had developed and approved a plan to upgrade certain 480-volt breakers
procedure changes and extensive engineering analyses employing a reduction
            and bus-work over the next several years that should allow closure of
of over-conservatisms, the licensee had been able to narrow down the problem
            CR 93-137.
and had developed and approved a plan to upgrade certain 480-volt breakers
    *       Regarding daisy-chaining, the inspectors reviewed an instance where at least
and bus-work over the next several years that should allow closure of
            11 CRs pertaining to various problems with the commercial grade dedication and
CR 93-137.
            procurement programs were ultimately closed, either directly or through other
*
            CRs that were closed directly, to one corrective action (Action Number 23) of the
Regarding daisy-chaining, the inspectors reviewed an instance where at least
            CR written to address a problem with the Alert and Notification System. The
11 CRs pertaining to various problems with the commercial grade dedication and
            inspectors identified that the two recommended corrective actions for
procurement programs were ultimately closed, either directly or through other
            CR 00-2933, relating to the procedure for the conditional release of QA items
CRs that were closed directly, to one corrective action (Action Number 23) of the
            from receiving, had not been implemented. CR 00-2933 had been closed to
CR written to address a problem with the Alert and Notification System. The
            CR 00-2312, which had been closed to Action Number 23. Action Number 23
inspectors identified that the two recommended corrective actions for
            was closed on November 16, 2001. In this instance, the items not corrected
CR 00-2933, relating to the procedure for the conditional release of QA items
            were minor.
from receiving, had not been implemented. CR 00-2933 had been closed to
    *       Regarding the issue with excessive due date extensions, during the previous
CR 00-2312, which had been closed to Action Number 23. Action Number 23
            PI&R, the inspectors noted that a CR written in 1997 (CR 97-0249) for the need
was closed on November 16, 2001. In this instance, the items not corrected
            to revise the administrative procedure controlling the use of equivalent spare
were minor.
            parts in safety-related systems had the due date extended 13 times. And while
*
            the procedure was revised early last year in response to the procurement of a
Regarding the issue with excessive due date extensions, during the previous
            replacement service water pump motor with inadequate wire insulation, the CR
PI&R, the inspectors noted that a CR written in 1997 (CR 97-0249) for the need
            remained open pending incorporation of other planned changes to the
to revise the administrative procedure controlling the use of equivalent spare
            procedure. During this PI&R, the inspectors noted that the CRs due date had
parts in safety-related systems had the due date extended 13 times. And while
            now been extended 18 times; however, near the end of the inspection, the
the procedure was revised early last year in response to the procurement of a
            procedure revision to address the remaining changes was approved.
replacement service water pump motor with inadequate wire insulation, the CR
    *       In an issue related to timeliness of corrective actions, the inspectors noted that
remained open pending incorporation of other planned changes to the
            CR 01-0368 dealt with an unexpected apparent rise in Unit 2 power during a
procedure. During this PI&R, the inspectors noted that the CRs due date had
            dilution on Unit 1 on Feb 2, 2001. For this CR there were two corrective actions,
now been extended 18 times; however, near the end of the inspection, the
                                                5
procedure revision to address the remaining changes was approved.
*
In an issue related to timeliness of corrective actions, the inspectors noted that
CR 01-0368 dealt with an unexpected apparent rise in Unit 2 power during a
dilution on Unit 1 on Feb 2, 2001. For this CR there were two corrective actions,


            one to do an apparent cause evaluation (ACE) and the other to make an
6
            Operations Notebook entry to notify all crews. The due date for this last item
one to do an apparent cause evaluation (ACE) and the other to make an
            was initially April 26, 2001, but was changed five times before the action was
Operations Notebook entry to notify all crews. The due date for this last item
            closed without being taken because so much time had elapsed since the event
was initially April 26, 2001, but was changed five times before the action was
            and the operating crews were already aware of the event.
closed without being taken because so much time had elapsed since the event
    *       Another timeliness issue was associated with the failure on February 20, 2002,
and the operating crews were already aware of the event.
            of the Unit 2 B SI pump. The pump seized and failed during a monthly
*
            preventative-maintenance lubrication activity. The licensees initial determination
Another timeliness issue was associated with the failure on February 20, 2002,
            was that the pump seized due to nitrogen gas binding caused by leakage of
of the Unit 2 B SI pump. The pump seized and failed during a monthly
            nitrogen-saturated water from the 2A SI accumulator back through two or more
preventative-maintenance lubrication activity. The licensees initial determination
            check valves. The licensee also established that corrective actions proposed
was that the pump seized due to nitrogen gas binding caused by leakage of
            after an August 1999 review of NRC Information Notice (IN) 88-23,
nitrogen-saturated water from the 2A SI accumulator back through two or more
            Supplement 5, Potential for Gas Binding of High Pressure Safety Injection
check valves. The licensee also established that corrective actions proposed
            Pumps During a Loss-of-Coolant Accident, pertaining to the potential for gas
after an August 1999 review of NRC Information Notice (IN) 88-23,
            binding of high head safety injection pumps, were not timely. Timely completion
Supplement 5, Potential for Gas Binding of High Pressure Safety Injection
            of these actions may have prevented the failure of the pump. In addition, the
Pumps During a Loss-of-Coolant Accident, pertaining to the potential for gas
            inspectors noted that the possibility of plant conditions conducive of gas binding
binding of high head safety injection pumps, were not timely. Timely completion
            was identified in February 2001 when CR 01-0454 was written because of
of these actions may have prevented the failure of the pump.   In addition, the
            decreasing level in the Unit 2A SI accumulator. Since much of this information
inspectors noted that the possibility of plant conditions conducive of gas binding
            came to light at the end of the inspection, the inspectors were not able to
was identified in February 2001 when CR 01-0454 was written because of
            complete an evaluation of these issues and had not come to any enforcement
decreasing level in the Unit 2A SI accumulator. Since much of this information
            conclusion on this particular matter.
came to light at the end of the inspection, the inspectors were not able to
            Using the Significance Determination Process (SDP) Phase 1 Screening
complete an evaluation of these issues and had not come to any enforcement
            Worksheet and the Phase 2 Worksheets for the Mitigating Systems
conclusion on this particular matter.
            Cornerstone, the inspectors concluded that enough nitrogen gas may have been
Using the Significance Determination Process (SDP) Phase 1 Screening
            present to cause failure of the 2P-15B pump at anytime during the 30-day period
Worksheet and the Phase 2 Worksheets for the Mitigating Systems
            prior to the pumps failure. The pumps failure rendered one train of SI incapable
Cornerstone, the inspectors concluded that enough nitrogen gas may have been
            of performing its safety function. Based on this information, this finding was
present to cause failure of the 2P-15B pump at anytime during the 30-day period
            considered to be at least of very low safety significance (Green). Pending
prior to the pumps failure. The pumps failure rendered one train of SI incapable
            completion of a Phase 3 SDP analysis, the safety significance of the finding is
of performing its safety function. Based on this information, this finding was
            To Be Determined (TBD) and this issue is considered an Unresolved Item
considered to be at least of very low safety significance (Green). Pending
            (URI 50-301/02-03-01).
completion of a Phase 3 SDP analysis, the safety significance of the finding is
d.   Assessment of Safety Conscious Work Environment
To Be Determined (TBD) and this issue is considered an Unresolved Item
(1) Inspection Scope
(URI 50-301/02-03-01).
    The inspectors interviewed plant staff and CRs/CAPs to assess whether there were
    d.   Assessment of Safety Conscious Work Environment
    impediments to the establishment of a safety conscious work environment.
      (1) Inspection Scope
(2) Findings
The inspectors interviewed plant staff and CRs/CAPs to assess whether there were
    From the interviews and record reviews, the inspectors identified no impediments to a
impediments to the establishment of a safety conscious work environment.  
    safety conscious work environment. Some individuals expressed dissatisfaction with
      (2) Findings
    some aspects of the corrective action process, such as the user-unfriendly NUTRK
From the interviews and record reviews, the inspectors identified no impediments to a
    database system (which had since been replaced by a user-friendly Web-based system)
safety conscious work environment. Some individuals expressed dissatisfaction with
    and workers being assigned to assess and correct problems that were identified by the
some aspects of the corrective action process, such as the user-unfriendly NUTRK
                                                6
database system (which had since been replaced by a user-friendly Web-based system)
and workers being assigned to assess and correct problems that were identified by the


    same workers but would be more efficiently assessed and corrected by someone else.
7
    But the inspectors noted a strong emphasis by management on establishing an
same workers but would be more efficiently assessed and corrected by someone else.
    atmosphere conducive to employees readily documenting and resolving problems and
But the inspectors noted a strong emphasis by management on establishing an
    an overall strong sentiment by interviewed plant staff to document problems.
atmosphere conducive to employees readily documenting and resolving problems and
an overall strong sentiment by interviewed plant staff to document problems.  
4OA6 Meeting(s)
4OA6 Meeting(s)
.1   Exit Meeting
.1
    The inspectors presented the inspection results to Mr. M. Warner and other members of
Exit Meeting
    licensee management in an exit meeting on February 25, 2002. Licensee management
The inspectors presented the inspection results to Mr. M. Warner and other members of
    acknowledged the findings presented and indicated that no proprietary information was
licensee management in an exit meeting on February 25, 2002. Licensee management
    provided to the inspectors.
acknowledged the findings presented and indicated that no proprietary information was
                                            7
provided to the inspectors.


                              KEY POINTS OF CONTACT
8
KEY POINTS OF CONTACT
Nuclear Management Company, LLC (NMC)
Nuclear Management Company, LLC (NMC)
J. R. Anderson     Point Beach Nuclear Plant (PBNP) Production Planning Manager
J. R. Anderson
L. Armstrong       Design Engineering Manager
Point Beach Nuclear Plant (PBNP) Production Planning Manager
D. Black           Nuclear Safety Analysis Senior Engineer
L. Armstrong
A. J. Cayia       Kewaunee-Point Beach (KPB) Site Director
Design Engineering Manager
F. Flentje         NRC Coordinator
D. Black
D. Hettick         Performance Assessment Manager
Nuclear Safety Analysis Senior Engineer
R. Hopkins         Nuclear Oversight Supervisor
A. J. Cayia
T. C. Kendall     Design Engineering Supervisor
Kewaunee-Point Beach (KPB) Site Director
P. Kleinschmidt   Bolted Fault Project Manager
F. Flentje
C. W. Krause       Senior Regulatory Compliance Engineer
NRC Coordinator
R. G. Mende       KPB Engineering Director
D. Hettick
K. Peveler         KPB Nuclear Oversight Manager
Performance Assessment Manager
S. A. Pfaff       Corrective Action Supervisor
R. Hopkins
R. Pulec           KPB Performance Assessment Manager
Nuclear Oversight Supervisor
R. Repshas         KPB Support Services Manager
T. C. Kendall
G. D. Strharsky   PBNP Assistant Operations Manager
Design Engineering Supervisor
T. H. Taylor       PBNP Plant Manager
P. Kleinschmidt
M. Warner         Site Vice-President
Bolted Fault Project Manager
T. J. Webb         KPB Regulatory Affairs Manager
C. W. Krause
J. Walsh           KPB Procedures Program Manager
Senior Regulatory Compliance Engineer
W. Yarosz         KPB Emergency Planning Supervisor
R. G. Mende
                    ITEMS OPENED, CLOSED, AND DISCUSSED
KPB Engineering Director
Opened
K. Peveler
50-301/02-03-01         URI     2P-15B Safety Injection Pump Failure During Monthly
KPB Nuclear Oversight Manager
                                  Preventative Maintenance Lubrication Activity
S. A. Pfaff
Closed
Corrective Action Supervisor
None
R. Pulec
Discussed
KPB Performance Assessment Manager
None
R. Repshas
                                            8
KPB Support Services Manager
G. D. Strharsky
PBNP Assistant Operations Manager
T. H. Taylor
PBNP Plant Manager
M. Warner
Site Vice-President
T. J. Webb
KPB Regulatory Affairs Manager
J. Walsh
KPB Procedures Program Manager
W. Yarosz
KPB Emergency Planning Supervisor
ITEMS OPENED, CLOSED, AND DISCUSSED
Opened
50-301/02-03-01
URI
2P-15B Safety Injection Pump Failure During Monthly
Preventative Maintenance Lubrication Activity
Closed
None
Discussed
None


                        LIST OF ACRONYMS USED
9
ACE Apparent Cause Evaluation
LIST OF ACRONYMS USED
AR   Action Request
ACE
ASME American Society of Mechanical Engineers
Apparent Cause Evaluation
CA   Corrective Action
AR
CAP Corrective Action Program
Action Request
CARB Corrective Action Review Board
ASME
CR   Condition Report
American Society of Mechanical Engineers
DC   Direct Current
CA
EDG Emergency Diesel Generator
Corrective Action
EOP Emergency Operating Procedure
CAP
EWR Engineering Work Request
Corrective Action Program
FSAR Final Safety Analysis Report
CARB
INPO Institute of Nuclear Power Operations
Corrective Action Review Board
KPB Kewaunee-Point Beach
CR
KV   Kilovolt
Condition Report
LCO Limiting Condition for Operation
DC
LER Licensee Event Report
Direct Current
LTA Less Than Adequate
EDG
MOV Motor-Operated Valve
Emergency Diesel Generator
NCV Non-Cited Violation
EOP
NMC Nuclear Management Company, LLC
Emergency Operating Procedure
NP   Nuclear Power Business Unit Procedure
EWR
OA   Organizational Assessment
Engineering Work Request  
OE   Operating Experience
FSAR
OI   Operating Instruction
Final Safety Analysis Report
OOS Out-Of-Service
INPO
PBNP Point Beach Nuclear Plant
Institute of Nuclear Power Operations
PMT Post-Maintenance Testing
KPB
psi Pounds Per Square Inch
Kewaunee-Point Beach
QA   Quality Assurance
KV
QCR Quality Condition Report
Kilovolt
RCE Root Cause Evaluation
LCO
RCP Reactor Coolant Pump
Limiting Condition for Operation
SDP Significance Determination Process
LER
SRO Senior Reactor Operator
Licensee Event Report
SW   Service Water
LTA
TS   Technical Specification
Less Than Adequate
V   Volt
MOV
WO   Work Order
Motor-Operated Valve
                                      9
NCV
Non-Cited Violation
NMC
Nuclear Management Company, LLC
NP
Nuclear Power Business Unit Procedure
OA
Organizational Assessment
OE
Operating Experience
OI
Operating Instruction
OOS
Out-Of-Service
PBNP
Point Beach Nuclear Plant
PMT
Post-Maintenance Testing
psi
Pounds Per Square Inch
QA
Quality Assurance
QCR
Quality Condition Report
RCE
Root Cause Evaluation
RCP
Reactor Coolant Pump
SDP
Significance Determination Process
SRO
Senior Reactor Operator
SW
Service Water
TS
Technical Specification
V
Volt
WO
Work Order


                                  LIST OF DOCUMENTS REVIEWED
10
The following is a list of licensee documents reviewed during the inspection. Inclusion of a
LIST OF DOCUMENTS REVIEWED
The following is a list of licensee documents reviewed during the inspection. Inclusion of a
document on this list does not imply that NRC inspectors reviewed the entire document, but,
document on this list does not imply that NRC inspectors reviewed the entire document, but,
rather that selected sections or portions of the document were evaluated as part of the overall
rather that selected sections or portions of the document were evaluated as part of the overall
inspection effort. In addition, inclusion of a document on this list does not imply NRC
inspection effort. In addition, inclusion of a document on this list does not imply NRC
acceptance of the document, unless specifically stated in the body of the inspection report.
acceptance of the document, unless specifically stated in the body of the inspection report.
Condition Report
Condition Report
  93-137                     Plant Electrical Equipment May Be Used in     March 30, 1993
93-137
                              Applications Beyond Fault Current Ratings
Plant Electrical Equipment May Be Used in
  97-0249 (Quality           Process Improvements SPEED NP 9.3.3           October 30, 1997
Applications Beyond Fault Current Ratings
  Condition Report
March 30, 1993
  (QCR))
97-0249 (Quality
  98-1004                     SI Accumulator Level Decrease                 March 11, 1998
Condition Report
  99-2346                     Seismic Qualification of Service Water         October 6, 1999
(QCR))
                              Pump Column Bolting Questioned
Process Improvements SPEED NP 9.3.3
  00-0094                     Plant Electrical Equipment May Be Placed       January 7, 2000
October 30, 1997
                              Into Alignments Beyond Equipment Fault
98-1004
                              Current Ratings
SI Accumulator Level Decrease
  00-0128                     P-32F-M Thermocouple Installation Not         January 11, 2000
March 11, 1998
                              Properly Documented
99-2346
  00-0213                     Low Forebay Level, Lowest -9.6', Trip         January 20, 2000
Seismic Qualification of Service Water
  00-0494                     CR History of CIM Concerns                     February 10, 2000
Pump Column Bolting Questioned
  00-0514                     QA Classification of Packing Kit for 850       February 9, 2000
October 6, 1999
                              Hydraulic Cylinder Questioned
00-0094
  00-0834                     Corrosion Inhibitor Used in G-01 Without       March 9, 2000
Plant Electrical Equipment May Be Placed
                              the Required Evaluation
Into Alignments Beyond Equipment Fault
  00-2077                     Procurement Evaluation Deficiencies           June 16, 2000
Current Ratings
  00-2312                     Commercial Grade Dedication Program           August 1, 2000
January 7, 2000
  00-2335                     Abnormal Sound From P-32A Service             August 3, 2000
00-0128
                              Water Pump
P-32F-M Thermocouple Installation Not
  00-2423                     Dedication Criteria Changed During Receipt     August 10, 2000
Properly Documented
                              Inspection
January 11, 2000
  00-2426                     Lack of As Found Data During Receipt           August 10, 2000
00-0213
                              Inspection
Low Forebay Level, Lowest -9.6', Trip
                                                  10
January 20, 2000
00-0494
CR History of CIM Concerns
February 10, 2000
00-0514
QA Classification of Packing Kit for 850
Hydraulic Cylinder Questioned
February 9, 2000
00-0834
Corrosion Inhibitor Used in G-01 Without
the Required Evaluation
March 9, 2000
00-2077
Procurement Evaluation Deficiencies
June 16, 2000
00-2312
Commercial Grade Dedication Program
August 1, 2000
00-2335
Abnormal Sound From P-32A Service
Water Pump
August 3, 2000
00-2423
Dedication Criteria Changed During Receipt
Inspection
August 10, 2000
00-2426
Lack of As Found Data During Receipt
Inspection
August 10, 2000


00-2427 Documenting Discrepancies During Receipt   August 10, 2000
11
        Inspection
00-2427
00-2428 Technical Evaluations Dont Address         August 10, 2000
Documenting Discrepancies During Receipt
        Equipment Qualification
Inspection
00-2792 Less Than Adequate Wire Storage, QA         September 20, 2000
August 10, 2000
        Versus Non-QA
00-2428
00-2812 Alert and Notification System (ANS) Siren   September 22, 2000
Technical Evaluations Dont Address
        Failure Response Weak
Equipment Qualification
00-2933 Form for QA Conditional Release Form       September 29, 2000
August 10, 2000
        Doesnt Match Procedure
00-2792
00-2948 Crib Freeze Event CAs Concerns             October 2, 2002
Less Than Adequate Wire Storage, QA
00-3079 Condenser Steam Dump Malfunction           October 13, 2000
Versus Non-QA
00-3299 Damaged Breaker Auxiliary Switches         October 23, 2000
September 20, 2000
00-4014 Leak On Unit 2 Conoseals                   December 30, 2000
00-2812
00-4150 Electrical Perturbation On Unit 2 Generator December 17, 2000
Alert and Notification System (ANS) Siren
01-0001 Unexpected Alarm During Service Water       January 1, 2001
Failure Response Weak
        Pump Start
September 22, 2000
01-0003 TS-33 Problems Due To Failing Pressure     January 2, 2001
00-2933
        Indicator
Form for QA Conditional Release Form
01-0022 Less Than Adequate Work Plan To Thaw       December 29, 2000
Doesnt Match Procedure
        Frozen Pipe
September 29, 2000
01-0030 Service Water Pump Expansion Joints         January 3, 2001
00-2948
01-0039 Service Water Pump Expansion Joints         January 3, 2001
Crib Freeze Event CAs Concerns
01-0048 P-32C Work Packages Not Ready               January 5, 2001
October 2, 2002
01-0102 Less Than Adequate Evaluation of Part 21   January 10, 2001
00-3079
        NUTRK Item - AGASTAT
Condenser Steam Dump Malfunction  
01-0109 Rope And Wood On Service Water Piping       January 12, 2001
October 13, 2000
01-0111 Untimely CR Initiation by OA Personnel     January 11, 2001
00-3299
01-0112 Replacement Service Water Pump Motors       January 12, 2001
Damaged Breaker Auxiliary Switches
01-0122 Apparent Cause Evaluation Action Not       January 12, 2001
October 23, 2000
        Created
00-4014
01-0148 Wrong Thermocouple Extension Cable         January 16, 2001
Leak On Unit 2 Conoseals
        Installed
December 30, 2000
                              11
00-4150
Electrical Perturbation On Unit 2 Generator
December 17, 2000
01-0001
Unexpected Alarm During Service Water
Pump Start
January 1, 2001
01-0003
TS-33 Problems Due To Failing Pressure
Indicator
January 2, 2001
01-0022
Less Than Adequate Work Plan To Thaw
Frozen Pipe
December 29, 2000
01-0030
Service Water Pump Expansion Joints
January 3, 2001
01-0039
Service Water Pump Expansion Joints
January 3, 2001
01-0048
P-32C Work Packages Not Ready
January 5, 2001
01-0102
Less Than Adequate Evaluation of Part 21
NUTRK Item - AGASTAT
January 10, 2001
01-0109
Rope And Wood On Service Water Piping
January 12, 2001
01-0111
Untimely CR Initiation by OA Personnel
January 11, 2001
01-0112
Replacement Service Water Pump Motors
January 12, 2001
01-0122
Apparent Cause Evaluation Action Not
Created
January 12, 2001
01-0148
Wrong Thermocouple Extension Cable
Installed
January 16, 2001


01-0203 4 KV System Grounds                       January 19, 2001
12
01-0216 New Thermocouple Found Faulty             January 19, 2001
01-0203
01-0220 Incomplete IWP                             January 21, 2001
4 KV System Grounds
01-0241 CRs Not Written as Result of               January 23, 2001
January 19, 2001
        Self-Assessment
01-0216
01-0259 West Service Water Supply Isolation Valve January 24, 2001
New Thermocouple Found Faulty
        Installation
January 19, 2001
01-0289 Service Water Safety Monitor Assumptions   January 27, 2001
01-0220
01-0301 CR Trend Review Problems                   January 29, 2001
Incomplete IWP
01-0307 Service Water Pressure Indicator           January 30, 2001
January 21, 2001
01-0310 SW-2930A Valve Body Pitted                 January 30, 2001
01-0241
01-0318 No VT-2 Qualified Individual On Shift When January 30, 2001
CRs Not Written as Result of
        Required
Self-Assessment
01-0319 Less Than Adequate Work Plan SFP HX       January 30, 2001
January 23, 2001
        [Spent Fuel Pool Heat Exchanger] Inlet
01-0259
        Valve
West Service Water Supply Isolation Valve
01-0323 Temp Change To AOP 9A Concern             January 30, 2001
Installation
01-0330 Declining Vendor Performance - IPSCO       February 1, 2001
January 24, 2001
01-0335 Increased Magnitude Of Change In SW       February 1, 2001
01-0289
        [Service Water] Pump Vibration Readings
Service Water Safety Monitor Assumptions
01-0338 CAP Procedure Violations                   February 1, 2001
January 27, 2001
01-0341 SW Line Stop Less Than Affective           February 1, 2001
01-0301
01-0344 Service Water Expansion Joint - Spare     February 2, 2001
CR Trend Review Problems
        Parts Wrong Size
January 29, 2001
01-0365 Valve Accessibility Questioned             February 3, 2001
01-0307
01-0368 Unit 2 Rise in Power - Dilution for Unit 1 February 2, 2001
Service Water Pressure Indicator
01-0369 Energy Had Been Verified Released For     February 2, 2001
January 30, 2001
        Tag Series O SW SW-2927A OP REV 2-1
01-0310
        By The Work Group, But No One From The
SW-2930A Valve Body Pitted
        Work Group Signed On
January 30, 2001
01-0377 CR Routing and Closing                     February 6, 2001
01-0318
01-0380 Line Stop Machines Installation Delays     February 5, 2001
No VT-2 Qualified Individual On Shift When
                            12
Required
January 30, 2001
01-0319
Less Than Adequate Work Plan SFP HX
[Spent Fuel Pool Heat Exchanger] Inlet
Valve
January 30, 2001
01-0323
Temp Change To AOP 9A Concern
January 30, 2001
01-0330
Declining Vendor Performance - IPSCO
February 1, 2001
01-0335
Increased Magnitude Of Change In SW
[Service Water] Pump Vibration Readings
February 1, 2001
01-0338
CAP Procedure Violations
February 1, 2001
01-0341
SW Line Stop Less Than Affective
February 1, 2001
01-0344
Service Water Expansion Joint - Spare
Parts Wrong Size
February 2, 2001
01-0365
Valve Accessibility Questioned
February 3, 2001
01-0368
Unit 2 Rise in Power - Dilution for Unit 1
February 2, 2001
01-0369
Energy Had Been Verified Released For
Tag Series O SW SW-2927A OP REV 2-1
By The Work Group, But No One From The
Work Group Signed On
February 2, 2001
01-0377
CR Routing and Closing
February 6, 2001
01-0380
Line Stop Machines Installation Delays
February 5, 2001


01-0387 SW-2974B Work Schedule Of 2/5/01 Parts       February 5, 2001
13
        Issue
01-0387
01-0395 Untimely Corrective Action                   February 6, 2001
SW-2974B Work Schedule Of 2/5/01 Parts
01-0403 Inadequate Safety Screening                 February 8, 2001
Issue
01-0407 Line Stop Seal Failure                       February 7, 2001
February 5, 2001
01-0418 Procedure Sign Off Sequence Not Used         February 8, 2001
01-0395
01-0421 Service Water Piping Degradation             February 8, 2001
Untimely Corrective Action
01-0423 4160 VAC Breaker Damage                     February 8, 2001
February 6, 2001
01-0425 Package Release Without Tag Series           February 8, 2001
01-0403
        Accepted
Inadequate Safety Screening
01-0429 Classification of CR 01-0368                 February 9, 2001
February 8, 2001
01-0438 Ineffective Followup on RCE 00-007 Actions   January 10, 2001
01-0407
01-0444 Service Water System Piping Contaminated     February 9, 2001
Line Stop Seal Failure
01-0448 Containment Fan Cooler SW Flow Out Of       February 13, 2001
February 7, 2001
        Spec
01-0418
01-0449 NUTRK Not User-Friendly                     February 13, 2001
Procedure Sign Off Sequence Not Used
01-0452 Micrologger Routes Erased                   February 12, 2001
February 8, 2001
01-0454 U2 'A' Safety Injection SI Accumulator Level February 12, 2001
01-0421
01-0457 Service Water Gauge Out Of Tolerance         February 12, 2001
Service Water Piping Degradation
01-0471 Accumulator Level Indicator Failing         February 14, 2001
February 8, 2001
01-0481 Storage Of Spare SW Pump Motors             February 14, 2001
01-0423
01-0529 Corrective Action Not Incorporated           February 20, 2001
4160 VAC Breaker Damage
01-0552 New Piping Insulation Damaged               February 22, 2001
February 8, 2001  
01-0572 SI Accumulator Level Spikes                 February 22, 2001
01-0425
01-0587 Documentation Of Service Water System       February 26, 2001
Package Release Without Tag Series
        Test
Accepted
01-0596 Welder Bypassed Hold Point                   February 26, 2001
February 8, 2001  
01-0605 QCR Closed Prior to Actions Being           February 26, 2001
01-0429
        Completed
Classification of CR 01-0368
01-0612 Less Than Adequate Indication On 'F'         February 27, 2001
February 9, 2001
        Service Water Pump Ammeter
01-0438
                              13
Ineffective Followup on RCE 00-007 Actions
January 10, 2001
01-0444
Service Water System Piping Contaminated
February 9, 2001
01-0448
Containment Fan Cooler SW Flow Out Of
Spec
February 13, 2001
01-0449
NUTRK Not User-Friendly
February 13, 2001
01-0452
Micrologger Routes Erased
February 12, 2001
01-0454
U2 'A' Safety Injection SI Accumulator Level
February 12, 2001
01-0457
Service Water Gauge Out Of Tolerance
February 12, 2001
01-0471
Accumulator Level Indicator Failing
February 14, 2001
01-0481
Storage Of Spare SW Pump Motors
February 14, 2001
01-0529
Corrective Action Not Incorporated
February 20, 2001
01-0552
New Piping Insulation Damaged
February 22, 2001
01-0572
SI Accumulator Level Spikes
February 22, 2001
01-0587
Documentation Of Service Water System
Test
February 26, 2001
01-0596
Welder Bypassed Hold Point
February 26, 2001
01-0605
QCR Closed Prior to Actions Being
Completed
February 26, 2001
01-0612
Less Than Adequate Indication On 'F'
Service Water Pump Ammeter
February 27, 2001


01-0618 Corrective Action Program CAP Self-     February 28, 2001
14
        Assessment Issues
01-0618
01-0634 RCE 00-067 Corrective Actions           July 1, 2001
Corrective Action Program CAP Self-
01-0635 Priorities Not Assigned in NUTRK       March 1, 2001
Assessment Issues
01-0638 SW Mod Work Caused Vacuum Loss         March 1, 2001
February 28, 2001
01-0639 SW Mod Work Caused Air In-leakage       March 1, 2001
01-0634
01-0651 Less Than Adequate Closure of Condition March 5, 2001
RCE 00-067 Corrective Actions
        Reports
July 1, 2001
01-0662 Overdue Corrective Action               March 5, 2001
01-0635
01-0693 CIM Not Updated To Reflect New Type     March 7, 2001
Priorities Not Assigned in NUTRK  
        After Coolers
March 1, 2001
01-0697 Condition Report Actions Not Adequately March 6, 2001
01-0638
        Dispositioned - CR 98-1161
SW Mod Work Caused Vacuum Loss
01-0705 Exact Time 'C' CCW [Component Cooling   March 9, 2001
March 1, 2001
        Water] Returned To Service Unknown
01-0639
01-0706 New SW Valves Not Shown On Any         March 9, 2001
SW Mod Work Caused Air In-leakage
        Controlling Diagrams
March 1, 2001
01-0731 Inappropriate Closure of Action         March 12, 2001
01-0651
01-0733 OA Witness Of Shipment                 March 10, 2001
Less Than Adequate Closure of Condition
01-0734 Service Water Motor Shipped             March 9, 2001
Reports
        Inappropriately
March 5, 2001
01-0738 Abnormal Noise From P-32A               March 11, 2001
01-0662
01-0761 CFC [Containment Fan Cooler] Flow       March 13, 2001
Overdue Corrective Action
        Outside Of Band
March 5, 2001
01-0768 NUTRK Anonymous Notification           March 12, 2001
01-0693
01-0782 SW Pump Motor Replacement Problems     Initiated 3/14/01
CIM Not Updated To Reflect New Type
01-0794 Service Water Motor SPEED Insufficient March 13, 2001
After Coolers
01-0817 SI Accumulator Fill Concerns           March 15, 2001
March 7, 2001
01-0818 Incomplete Weld Exam On Containment     March 15, 2001
01-0697
        Fan Cooler
Condition Report Actions Not Adequately
01-0821 P32C-M Locked Rotor Test Results       March 15, 2001
Dispositioned - CR 98-1161
01-0852 Drawings Reflect Wrong Valve Positions March 16, 2001
March 6, 2001
01-0870 Weld Data Sheets Not Complete           March 21, 2001
01-0705
                            14
Exact Time 'C' CCW [Component Cooling
Water] Returned To Service Unknown
March 9, 2001
01-0706
New SW Valves Not Shown On Any
Controlling Diagrams
March 9, 2001
01-0731
Inappropriate Closure of Action
March 12, 2001
01-0733
OA Witness Of Shipment
March 10, 2001
01-0734
Service Water Motor Shipped
Inappropriately
March 9, 2001
01-0738
Abnormal Noise From P-32A
March 11, 2001
01-0761
CFC [Containment Fan Cooler] Flow
Outside Of Band
March 13, 2001
01-0768
NUTRK Anonymous Notification
March 12, 2001
01-0782
SW Pump Motor Replacement Problems
Initiated 3/14/01
01-0794
Service Water Motor SPEED Insufficient
March 13, 2001
01-0817
SI Accumulator Fill Concerns
March 15, 2001
01-0818
Incomplete Weld Exam On Containment
Fan Cooler
March 15, 2001
01-0821
P32C-M Locked Rotor Test Results
March 15, 2001
01-0852
Drawings Reflect Wrong Valve Positions
March 16, 2001
01-0870
Weld Data Sheets Not Complete
March 21, 2001


01-0903 Procedure Misaligned Valves               March 22, 2001
15
01-0911 Additional Information Provided By       March 20, 2001
01-0903
        Engineering - Operability Of P-32C Drawn
Procedure Misaligned Valves
        Into Question
March 22, 2001
01-0919 Wrong Component Danger Tagged             March 22, 2001
01-0911
01-0952 Incorrect Valve Labels                   March 26, 2001
Additional Information Provided By
01-0958 Potential Valve Failure - Valve Stem     March 26, 2001
Engineering - Operability Of P-32C Drawn
        Separation
Into Question
01-0983 Containment Fan Cooling Flexible Piping   March 28, 2001
March 20, 2001
        Concern
01-0919
01-1001 Less Than Adequate Formal Documentation   March 30, 2001
Wrong Component Danger Tagged
        and Tracking of Effectiveness Review
March 22, 2001
        Actions
01-0952
01-1027 Overdue Condition Reports                 April 3, 2001
Incorrect Valve Labels
01-1032 RWST Level Transmitter Found Out of       April 2, 2001
March 26, 2001
        Calibration
01-0958
01-1046 Evaluation Actions Not Documented in     April 4, 2001
Potential Valve Failure - Valve Stem
        NUTRK
Separation
01-1047 NRC/PI&R Inspection Concern of CR Cross   April 3, 2001
March 26, 2001
        Referencing
01-0983
01-1048 NRC/PI&R Inspection Concerns Less Than   April 3, 2001
Containment Fan Cooling Flexible Piping
        Adequate SRO Screenings
Concern
01-1059 Found Local Control Switch               April 3, 2001
March 28, 2001
        For 1A52-84, 1A06 Feed to 1X14
01-1001
        Transformer, In The Pullout Position. Per
Less Than Adequate Formal Documentation
        PC 43 Part 2
and Tracking of Effectiveness Review
01-1073 Lost/Misplaced Condition Report           April 4, 2001
Actions
01-1105 MOV Failed to Shut Remotely               April 5, 2001
March 30, 2001
01-1131 Condition Report Closure Inappropriate   April 6, 2001
01-1027
01-1137 Breaker Charging Spring Failed To         April 7, 2001
Overdue Condition Reports
        Discharge
April 3, 2001
01-1146 Hoses Not Used For Draining Systems       April 9, 2001
01-1032
01-1150 Breaker Inseat Not Updated In Champs     April 9, 2001
RWST Level Transmitter Found Out of
01-1178 Heat Exchangers Opened Prior To           April 17, 2001
Calibration
        Scheduled
April 2, 2001
                            15
01-1046
Evaluation Actions Not Documented in
NUTRK
April 4, 2001
01-1047
NRC/PI&R Inspection Concern of CR Cross
Referencing
April 3, 2001
01-1048
NRC/PI&R Inspection Concerns Less Than
Adequate SRO Screenings
April 3, 2001
01-1059
Found Local Control Switch  
For 1A52-84, 1A06 Feed to 1X14
Transformer, In The Pullout Position. Per
PC 43 Part 2
April 3, 2001
01-1073
Lost/Misplaced Condition Report
April 4, 2001
01-1105
MOV Failed to Shut Remotely
April 5, 2001
01-1131
Condition Report Closure Inappropriate
April 6, 2001
01-1137
Breaker Charging Spring Failed To
Discharge
April 7, 2001
01-1146
Hoses Not Used For Draining Systems
April 9, 2001
01-1150
Breaker Inseat Not Updated In Champs
April 9, 2001
01-1178
Heat Exchangers Opened Prior To
Scheduled
April 17, 2001


01-1210 Service Water Valve Has Significant Leak   April 11, 2001
16
01-1244 U2 Service Water Leak On A Containment   April 11, 2001
01-1210
        Fan Cooler
Service Water Valve Has Significant Leak
01-1270 High Heat Exchanger Flow Rate               April 13, 2001
April 11, 2001
01-1279 Less Than Adequate Specified               April 14, 2001
01-1244
        Post-Maintenance Testing
U2 Service Water Leak On A Containment
01-1297 Coordination Of Work Activities             April 14, 2001
Fan Cooler
        MR 98-024*J
April 11, 2001
01-1319 Containment Fan Cooler Outlet Throttle     April 17, 2001
01-1270
        Valve Potential Part 21
High Heat Exchanger Flow Rate
01-1334 SW-2880 Signature Indicates Valve Stem     April 18, 2001
April 13, 2001
        Bent
01-1279
01-1339 Closed Work Order - ASME Discrepancies     April 18, 2001
Less Than Adequate Specified
01-1363 Valves Pre-fabricated Backwards             April 19, 2001
Post-Maintenance Testing
01-1394 Pressure Test Data                         April 21, 2001
April 14, 2001
01-1402 ANII Hold Points Bypassed                   April 20, 2001
01-1297
01-1453 No Oil in 1P-15A Sightglass                 April 24, 2001
Coordination Of Work Activities
01-1470 Operations Adverse Trend                   April 24, 2001
MR 98-024*J
01-1471 Potentially Decreased Performance           April 24, 2001
April 14, 2001
01-1482 Bus And Breaker Short Circuit Rating       April 25, 2001
01-1319
        Discrepancies
Containment Fan Cooler Outlet Throttle
01-1492 LTA communication on RP Close Out of a     April 26, 2001
Valve Potential Part 21
        CR
April 17, 2001
01-1551 Lack of Timely CR Initiation               April 30, 2001
01-1334
01-1556 Condition Report Priority LTA               May 1, 2001
SW-2880 Signature Indicates Valve Stem
01-1568 Questioning Proper Installation Of CFC Ball May 1, 2001
Bent
        Valves
April 18, 2001
01-1577 Work Order LCO Tracking                     May 1, 2001
01-1339
01-1599 Trend Report Finding                       May 4, 2001
Closed Work Order - ASME Discrepancies
01-1600 Potential Adverse Trend in NDE             May 4, 2001
April 18, 2001
        [Non-Destructive Evaluation]
01-1363
01-1601 Adverse Trend in Warehouse Fire             May 4, 2001
Valves Pre-fabricated Backwards
        Protection
April 19, 2001
                            16
01-1394
Pressure Test Data
April 21, 2001
01-1402
ANII Hold Points Bypassed
April 20, 2001
01-1453
No Oil in 1P-15A Sightglass
April 24, 2001
01-1470
Operations Adverse Trend
April 24, 2001
01-1471
Potentially Decreased Performance
April 24, 2001
01-1482
Bus And Breaker Short Circuit Rating
Discrepancies
April 25, 2001
01-1492
LTA communication on RP Close Out of a
CR
April 26, 2001
01-1551
Lack of Timely CR Initiation
April 30, 2001
01-1556
Condition Report Priority LTA
May 1, 2001
01-1568
Questioning Proper Installation Of CFC Ball
Valves
May 1, 2001
01-1577
Work Order LCO Tracking
May 1, 2001
01-1599
Trend Report Finding
May 4, 2001
01-1600
Potential Adverse Trend in NDE
[Non-Destructive Evaluation]
May 4, 2001
01-1601
Adverse Trend in Warehouse Fire
Protection
May 4, 2001


01-1602 Error Mode Classifications                 May 4, 2001
17
01-1615 Service Water Flow Instrument Misaligned   May 2, 2001
01-1602
01-1631 Effectiveness Review of RCE               May 4, 2001
Error Mode Classifications
01-1650 Ops Increase Error Rate - Skill Based     May 5, 2001
May 4, 2001
        Errors
01-1615
01-1677 Coating On Containment Fan Coolers         May 7, 2001
Service Water Flow Instrument Misaligned
        Questioned
May 2, 2001
01-1678 Support In Containment Has Unqualified     May 1, 2001
01-1631
        Coating
Effectiveness Review of RCE
01-1688 TS-76 Concerns                             May 9, 2001
May 4, 2001
01-1698 Overdue Corrective Actions                 May 9, 2001
01-1650
01-1718 Valve Repair Work Inadequacies             May 10, 2001
Ops Increase Error Rate - Skill Based
01-1723 Work Order Documentation Inadequate       May 10, 2001
Errors
01-1834 Maintenance Corrective Action Item Due     May 21, 2001
May 5, 2001
        Date Extensions Not Documented
01-1677
01-1851 Missing RRM Documentation For             May 23, 2001
Coating On Containment Fan Coolers
        Completed Work
Questioned
01-1856 G01 HX Corrosion                           May 23, 2001
May 7, 2001
01-1902 Corrective Actions For CR 00-1812 Do Not   May 24, 2001
01-1678
        Address Concern
Support In Containment Has Unqualified
01-1962 Condition Report (CR) Without Priorities   June 4, 2001
Coating
01-1963 Piping Class Incorrectly Shown On P&ID     June 5, 2001
May 1, 2001
01-1966 QA/SR RWST Level Transmitter Out of       June 4, 2001
01-1688
        Calibration
TS-76 Concerns
01-1994 OD Part II for CR 01-1559 Not Completed in June 6, 2001
May 9, 2001
        30 Days as Required
01-1698
01-2035 Lesson Plan Not Revised Per Condition     June 12, 2001
Overdue Corrective Actions
        Report
May 9, 2001
01-2160 Corrective Action Program Weakness         June 26, 2001
01-1718
01-2085 Safety Injection Pump Motor Bearing Had   June 17, 2001
Valve Repair Work Inadequacies
        No Oil Visible in Fill Connection
May 10, 2001
01-2104 Insufficient Copper Tubing In Reserve For June 18, 2001
01-1723
        Work Order
Work Order Documentation Inadequate
                              17
May 10, 2001
01-1834
Maintenance Corrective Action Item Due
Date Extensions Not Documented  
May 21, 2001
01-1851
Missing RRM Documentation For
Completed Work
May 23, 2001
01-1856
G01 HX Corrosion
May 23, 2001
01-1902
Corrective Actions For CR 00-1812 Do Not
Address Concern
May 24, 2001
01-1962
Condition Report (CR) Without Priorities
June 4, 2001
01-1963
Piping Class Incorrectly Shown On P&ID
June 5, 2001
01-1966
QA/SR RWST Level Transmitter Out of
Calibration
June 4, 2001
01-1994
OD Part II for CR 01-1559 Not Completed in
30 Days as Required
June 6, 2001
01-2035
Lesson Plan Not Revised Per Condition
Report
June 12, 2001
01-2160
Corrective Action Program Weakness
June 26, 2001
01-2085
Safety Injection Pump Motor Bearing Had
No Oil Visible in Fill Connection
June 17, 2001
01-2104
Insufficient Copper Tubing In Reserve For
Work Order
June 18, 2001


01-2142 U1 Safety Injection Accumulator Level Out   June 24, 2001
18
        of Calibration
01-2142
01-2166 Service Water Isolation Valve Leaks         June 27, 2001
U1 Safety Injection Accumulator Level Out
        Through
of Calibration
01-2168 Service Water Zurn Strainer Inoperable     June 26, 2001
June 24, 2001
01-2170 Potential Conflict With Service Water LCOs June 26, 2001
01-2166
01-2178 Large Fish Kill Results In Unit 2 Trip     June 28, 2001
Service Water Isolation Valve Leaks
01-2181 Emergent Temp Change To AOP                 June 27, 2001
Through
01-2191 Two Tag Series In Effect For Same Job       June 27, 2001
June 27, 2001
01-2237 CR 00-3888 Corrective Action Not           July 2, 2001
01-2168
        Completed
Service Water Zurn Strainer Inoperable
01-2243 Revision of Operability Determination       July 3, 2001
June 26, 2001
        Contains Deficiencies
01-2170
01-2264 Corrective Actions Without Assigned         July 3, 2001
Potential Conflict With Service Water LCOs
        Priorities
June 26, 2001
01-2267 Scheduled Conflict Would Have Caused       July 5, 2001
01-2178
        LCO Entry
Large Fish Kill Results In Unit 2 Trip
01-2283 Corrective Action Items Overdue             July 9, 2001
June 28, 2001
01-2337 Rework Of Circ Water Seal Supply Strainer   July 13, 2001
01-2181
01-2384 Less Than Adequate Closeout of Condition   July 19, 2001
Emergent Temp Change To AOP
        Report Dealing With Alarm Response Book
June 27, 2001
        Adequacy
01-2191
01-2386 Unknown White Residue On Refueling         July 19, 2001
Two Tag Series In Effect For Same Job
        Water Storage Tank
June 27, 2001
01-2406 Blockage Of Emergency Diesel Generator     July 23, 2001
01-2237
        Cooler Tubes
CR 00-3888 Corrective Action Not
01-2426 Hole In U1 [Unit 1] Refueling Water Storage July 25, 2001
Completed
        Tank
July 2, 2001
01-2487 Priorities Not Assigned As Required to     August 3, 2001
01-2243
        Condition Reports
Revision of Operability Determination
01-2526 Ineffective Corrective Action - Failure To August 8, 2001
Contains Deficiencies
        Test Redundant Emergency Diesel
July 3, 2001
        Generator
01-2264
01-2598 AM 3-4 Obsolete Revision of 10 CFR 50.65   August 16, 2001
Corrective Actions Without Assigned
                            18
Priorities
July 3, 2001
01-2267
Scheduled Conflict Would Have Caused
LCO Entry
July 5, 2001
01-2283
Corrective Action Items Overdue
July 9, 2001
01-2337
Rework Of Circ Water Seal Supply Strainer
July 13, 2001
01-2384
Less Than Adequate Closeout of Condition
Report Dealing With Alarm Response Book
Adequacy
July 19, 2001
01-2386
Unknown White Residue On Refueling
Water Storage Tank
July 19, 2001
01-2406
Blockage Of Emergency Diesel Generator
Cooler Tubes
July 23, 2001
01-2426
Hole In U1 [Unit 1] Refueling Water Storage
Tank
July 25, 2001
01-2487
Priorities Not Assigned As Required to
Condition Reports
August 3, 2001
01-2526
Ineffective Corrective Action - Failure To
Test Redundant Emergency Diesel
Generator
August 8, 2001
01-2598
AM 3-4 Obsolete Revision of 10 CFR 50.65
August 16, 2001


01-2705 Nuclear Safety Analysis NSA Adverse CR     August 29, 2001
19
        Trend
01-2705
01-2707 Condition Report Closed With Uncompleted   August 29, 2001
Nuclear Safety Analysis NSA Adverse CR
        Corrective Actions
Trend
01-2721 Condition Reports Did Not Determine if     August 29, 2001
August 29, 2001
        Functional Failures Were Maintenance
01-2707
        Preventable
Condition Report Closed With Uncompleted
01-2771 NUTRK Items Without Priority Assigned       September 7, 2001
Corrective Actions
01-2781 Damaged Auxiliary Switch On 4 KV Breaker   September 8, 2001
August 29, 2001
        A52-DHVR-1200-31
01-2721
01-2799 Errors In Drawing For G-02 Metering, DCNs   September 9, 2001
Condition Reports Did Not Determine if
        Not Done
Functional Failures Were Maintenance
01-2810 Potential Adverse Trend in Q List Program   September 11, 2001
Preventable
01-2918 Evaluation Due Dates                       September 24, 2001
August 29, 2001
01-2927 Schedule Plant to Revise Refueling         September 25, 2001
01-2771
        Procedures to Include Improved Technical
NUTRK Items Without Priority Assigned
        Specifications (ITS)
September 7, 2001
01-2929 Condition Report Closed Without             September 28, 2001
01-2781
        Consideration of Apparent Cause
Damaged Auxiliary Switch On 4 KV Breaker
        Evaluation Recommendations
A52-DHVR-1200-31
01-2969 Potential Current Transformer Issue In     September 26, 2001
September 8, 2001
        1A52-59 Cubicle
01-2799
01-2994 Less Than Adequate Support For MCE         October 2, 2001
Errors In Drawing For G-02 Metering, DCNs
        Testing Of Unit 2 SI Pump Motor
Not Done
01-3039 Operability Determinations Not Reviewed     October 5, 2001
September 9, 2001
        For ITS Implications
01-2810
01-3058 Condition Reports With No Assigned Priority October 9, 2001
Potential Adverse Trend in Q List Program
01-3107 Less Than Adequate Apparent Cause           October 10, 2001
September 11, 2001
        Evaluation and Follow-up Actions
01-2918
01-3148 Diesel Testing Not Identified In           October 16, 2001
Evaluation Due Dates
        Schedule/Test Plan
September 24, 2001
01-3166 Inadequate Closure of Condition Report CR   October 16, 2001
01-2927
        01-1329 - FPEE On Modified Fire Damper
Schedule Plant to Revise Refueling
01-3174 Grounding Card Latch Mechanism Difficult   January 18, 2001
Procedures to Include Improved Technical
        To Verify Engaged
Specifications (ITS)
01-3199 SRO Screening Issues With CR 01-3139       October 19, 2001
September 25, 2001
                            19
01-2929
Condition Report Closed Without
Consideration of Apparent Cause
Evaluation Recommendations
September 28, 2001
01-2969
Potential Current Transformer Issue In  
1A52-59 Cubicle
September 26, 2001
01-2994
Less Than Adequate Support For MCE
Testing Of Unit 2 SI Pump Motor
October 2, 2001
01-3039
Operability Determinations Not Reviewed
For ITS Implications
October 5, 2001
01-3058
Condition Reports With No Assigned Priority
October 9, 2001
01-3107
Less Than Adequate Apparent Cause
Evaluation and Follow-up Actions
October 10, 2001
01-3148
Diesel Testing Not Identified In
Schedule/Test Plan
October 16, 2001
01-3166
Inadequate Closure of Condition Report CR
01-1329 - FPEE On Modified Fire Damper  
October 16, 2001
01-3174
Grounding Card Latch Mechanism Difficult
To Verify Engaged
January 18, 2001
01-3199
SRO Screening Issues With CR 01-3139
October 19, 2001


01-3258                 Safety-Related Bus Voltages High - 7 day   November 21, 2001
20
                          LCO Entered
01-3258
01-3284                 Condition Reports Threshold for EP Issues October 26, 2001
Safety-Related Bus Voltages High - 7 day
01-3357                 NUTRK Actions Not Prioritized             November 5, 2001
LCO Entered
01-3414                 7% Condition Report Items Overdue         November 9, 2001
November 21, 2001
01-3492                 Problems With CR 00-1039 Resolution       November 15, 2001
01-3284
01-3545                 Procedures Indicate LCO Is Required May   November 26, 2001
Condition Reports Threshold for EP Issues
                          Be Incorrect
October 26, 2001
01-3606                 CR Verification Not Completed in Timely   November 30, 2001
01-3357
                          Manner
NUTRK Actions Not Prioritized
01-3626                 Less Than Adequate Documentation To       December 3, 2001
November 5, 2001
                          Support Operability Determination
01-3414
01-3678                 Condition Reports Priority -100           December 7, 2001
7% Condition Report Items Overdue
November 9, 2001
01-3492
Problems With CR 00-1039 Resolution
November 15, 2001
01-3545
Procedures Indicate LCO Is Required May
Be Incorrect
November 26, 2001
01-3606
CR Verification Not Completed in Timely
Manner
November 30, 2001
01-3626
Less Than Adequate Documentation To
Support Operability Determination
December 3, 2001
01-3678
Condition Reports Priority -100
December 7, 2001
Operability Determination (OD)
Operability Determination (OD)
OD for CR 93-0137       Plant Electrical Equipment May Be Used in Revision 8
OD for CR 93-0137
                          Applications Beyond Fault Current Ratings August 6, 2001
Plant Electrical Equipment May Be Used in
OD for CR 00-3299       Chipped Auxiliary Switch On Breaker       October, 2000
Applications Beyond Fault Current Ratings
                          A52-DHVR-1200-15
Revision 8
OD for CR 99-2346       SW Pump Discharge Column Connections       March 6, 2001
August 6, 2001
OD for CR 01-1105       MOV Failed to Shut Remotely               April 6, 2001
OD for CR 00-3299
Chipped Auxiliary Switch On Breaker  
A52-DHVR-1200-15
October, 2000
OD for CR 99-2346
SW Pump Discharge Column Connections
March 6, 2001
OD for CR 01-1105
MOV Failed to Shut Remotely
April 6, 2001
Drawing Number
Drawing Number
PB 31 E APS 240 052     Schematic Diagram                         Revision D
PB 31 E APS 240 052
09                      4160V SWGR Bus 1-A06 (2-A06)
09
                          Feeder Breaker 1A52-84 (2A52-89 to STA
Schematic Diagram
                          Service XFMR IX-14 (2X-14)
4160V SWGR Bus 1-A06 (2-A06)
PB 02 E SIS 000 002     Elementary Wiring Diagram                 Revision D
Feeder Breaker 1A52-84 (2A52-89 to STA
06                      4160V SWGR.2A05 Cubicle-74 Safety
Service XFMR IX-14 (2X-14)
                          Injection Pump 2P-015A
Revision D
                          PBNP Unit 2
PB 02 E SIS 000 002
PB 01 E APS 256 004     Elementary Wiring Diagram                 Revision E
06
01                      4160 Switchgear Cubicle-58 Station Service
Elementary Wiring Diagram
                          Transformer Breaker 1A-52-58
4160V SWGR.2A05 Cubicle-74 Safety
                          PBNP Unit 1
Injection Pump 2P-015A
                                              20
PBNP Unit 2
Revision D
PB 01 E APS 256 004
01
Elementary Wiring Diagram
4160 Switchgear Cubicle-58 Station Service
Transformer Breaker 1A-52-58
PBNP Unit 1
Revision E


PB 01 E APW 240     Connection Diagram                       Revision E
21
034 03              4160V Switchgear 1A05-Cubicle 58
PB 01 E APW 240
                    Station Service Transformer 1X-13
034 03
PB 01 E APS 03015   Elementary Wiring Diagram               Revision E
Connection Diagram
07                  4160 SWGR 1A05-Cubicle 57
4160V Switchgear 1A05-Cubicle 58
                    Bus Tie Breaker 1A52-57
Station Service Transformer 1X-13
PB 01 E APS 031 001 Elementary Wiring Diagram               Revision E
Revision E
11                  4160 Switchgear Cubicle 60
PB 01 E APS 03015
                    Emergency Generator Breaker 1A52-60
07
                    PBNP Unit 1
Elementary Wiring Diagram
PB 01 E APS 031 002 Elementary Wiring Diagram               Revision E
4160 SWGR 1A05-Cubicle 57
05                  Alternative Power to 1A-05 from G02 EDG
Bus Tie Breaker 1A52-57
                    Breaker 1A52-66
Revision E
                    PBNP Unit 1
PB 01 E APS 031 001
PB 01 E RPS 141     Schematic Diagram                       Revision E
11
078 18              SI Logic Engineered Safety Features
Elementary Wiring Diagram
                    (ESF) Systems Train A
4160 Switchgear Cubicle 60
                    Reactor Safeguards Systems
Emergency Generator Breaker 1A52-60
                    PBNP Unit 1
PBNP Unit 1
SK-M-21-2           Refueling Water Storage Tank - 1-T13,   Revision 0
Revision E
                    2-T13
PB 01 E APS 031 002
PB 01 MSIG 246 001 1-T13 RWST Assembly And Details         Revision E
05
05
Elementary Wiring Diagram
Alternative Power to 1A-05 from G02 EDG
Breaker 1A52-66
PBNP Unit 1
Revision E
PB 01 E RPS 141
078 18
Schematic Diagram
SI Logic Engineered Safety Features
(ESF) Systems Train A  
Reactor Safeguards Systems
PBNP Unit 1
Revision E
SK-M-21-2
Refueling Water Storage Tank - 1-T13,  
2-T13
Revision 0
PB 01 MSIG 246 001
05
1-T13 RWST Assembly And Details
Revision E
Action Request (AR)
Action Request (AR)
AR ACE000251       Tag Series Changes And Loss Of           October 22, 2001
AR ACE000251
                    Awareness Of Clearance Status
Tag Series Changes And Loss Of
AR ACE000260       G-04 Low Oil Level                       October 30, 2001
Awareness Of Clearance Status
AR ACE000294       Resistance Readings May Be Affected By   November 14, 2001
October 22, 2001
                    Nomex Wear
AR ACE000260
AR ACE000299       IP-29 Turbine-Driven Auxiliary Feedwater November 20, 2001
G-04 Low Oil Level
                    Pump Spurious Overspeed Trips
October 30, 2001
AR ACE000321       Wrong Oil Used In Auxiliary Feedwater   December 11, 2001
AR ACE000294
                    Turbine Bearings
Resistance Readings May Be Affected By
AR ACE000325       Unanticipated Outward Rod Motion         December 13, 2001
Nomex Wear
AR ACE000327       Component Cooling Water Pump Oil         December 17, 2001
November 14, 2001
                    Sample Results
AR ACE000299
                                          21
IP-29 Turbine-Driven Auxiliary Feedwater
Pump Spurious Overspeed Trips
November 20, 2001
AR ACE000321
Wrong Oil Used In Auxiliary Feedwater
Turbine Bearings
December 11, 2001
AR ACE000325
Unanticipated Outward Rod Motion
December 13, 2001
AR ACE000327
Component Cooling Water Pump Oil
Sample Results
December 17, 2001


AR ACE000496 Plant Electrical Equipment May Be Used in   April 1, 1993
22
            Applications Beyond Fault Ratings
AR ACE000496
AR ACE000497 4160V and 480V System Operating             December 3, 1997
Plant Electrical Equipment May Be Used in
            Voltages Are Significantly Higher Than the
Applications Beyond Fault Ratings
            Nominal System Voltages
April 1, 1993
AR ACE000498 Operating the 480V System at Voltage       December 3, 1997
AR ACE000497
            Magnitudes Higher Than 500V Causes
4160V and 480V System Operating
            Equipment to be Derated From Ratings at
Voltages Are Significantly Higher Than the
            480V to Ratings at 600V for Fault Current
Nominal System Voltages
AR ACE000499 System Model Should be Revised With         December 3, 1997
December 3, 1997
            Plant Operations to Determine More
AR ACE000498
            Realistic Equipment Alignments
Operating the 480V System at Voltage
AR ACE000500 Additional Scenarios Should be Analyzed     December 3, 1997
Magnitudes Higher Than 500V Causes
            and Existing Scenarios Should be Revised
Equipment to be Derated From Ratings at
            to More Accurately Reflect How PBNP is
480V to Ratings at 600V for Fault Current
            Operated
December 3, 1997
AR ACE000526 Missed Surveillance For PAM Core Exit       December 14, 2001
AR ACE000499
            T/Cs
System Model Should be Revised With
AR CA001184 Extent of Condition Review of Other         March 15, 2001
Plant Operations to Determine More
            SPEEDs
Realistic Equipment Alignments
AR CA001193 Reinforce Managements Expectations That   July 3, 2001
December 3, 1997
            Requirements of Administrative Procedures
AR ACE000500
            Are to be Complied With
Additional Scenarios Should be Analyzed
AR CA001461 Bus And Breaker Short Circuit Rating       April 30, 2001
and Existing Scenarios Should be Revised
            Discrepancies
to More Accurately Reflect How PBNP is
AR CA001634 Dilution of Accountability for Programs for June 5, 2001
Operated
            Vendor Technical Information Program and
December 3, 1997
            Component Instruction Manual
AR ACE000526
AR CA003148 Revise NP 9.3.3                             November 25, 1997
Missed Surveillance For PAM Core Exit
AR CA003235 Review the Calculations for Each Breaker or March 16, 1994
T/Cs
            Other Piece of Switchgear That is
December 14, 2001
            Calculated to be Overloaded
AR CA001184
AR CA003236 Write and Submit an LER for Condition of   July 10, 1997
Extent of Condition Review of Other
            Plant Electrical Equipment May Be Used in
SPEEDs
            Applications Beyond Fault Ratings
March 15, 2001
                                  22
AR CA001193
Reinforce Managements Expectations That
Requirements of Administrative Procedures
Are to be Complied With
July 3, 2001
AR CA001461
Bus And Breaker Short Circuit Rating
Discrepancies
April 30, 2001
AR CA001634
Dilution of Accountability for Programs for
Vendor Technical Information Program and
Component Instruction Manual
June 5, 2001
AR CA003148
Revise NP 9.3.3
November 25, 1997
AR CA003235
Review the Calculations for Each Breaker or
Other Piece of Switchgear That is
Calculated to be Overloaded
March 16, 1994
AR CA003236
Write and Submit an LER for Condition of
Plant Electrical Equipment May Be Used in
Applications Beyond Fault Ratings
July 10, 1997


AR CA003237 Complete a Revision to the Operability     December 3, 1997
23
            Determination to Address: Equipment
AR CA003237
            Removed From the List, Equipment Which
Complete a Revision to the Operability
            May Experience Fault Currents of Higher
Determination to Address: Equipment
            Magnitude, and Equipment Added to the
Removed From the List, Equipment Which
            List Attached to the New Fault Duty
May Experience Fault Currents of Higher
            Calculation
Magnitude, and Equipment Added to the
AR CA003238 The SSC in the Operability Determination   March 26, 1998
List Attached to the New Fault Duty
            for This CR [93-137] Have Been Determined
Calculation
            to be Operable, But Degraded
December 3, 1997
AR CA003239 Document That the Operability             September 11, 2000
AR CA003238
            Determination to Supported Bolted Shorts
The SSC in the Operability Determination
            as Described in CR 93-137 Reflects Most
for This CR [93-137] Have Been Determined
            Recent Review
to be Operable, But Degraded
AR CA003240 Finalize and Issue the New Preliminary     September 11, 2000
March 26, 1998
            Short Circuit Calculations Based on
AR CA003239
            Procedure Changes to be Completed Per
Document That the Operability
            CR 00-0094
Determination to Supported Bolted Shorts
AR CA003242 Request a Schedule and Justification be   August 14, 2001
as Described in CR 93-137 Reflects Most
            Provided for Which One of the Four Options
Recent Review  
            That Are Being Considered as Possible
September 11, 2000
            Solutions to the Bolted Fault Issue
AR CA003240
AR CA003518 NRC 50.59 Inspection Requested A           January 16, 2002
Finalize and Issue the New Preliminary
            Procedural Tie Be Created In IT-21 And
Short Circuit Calculations Based on
            IT-22, Back To TRM Section 3.5.1
Procedure Changes to be Completed Per
AR CA002130 Potential Adverse Trend in Q List Program September 13, 2001
CR 00-0094
AR CAP000126 Short Circuit Fault Current Calculations   January 7, 2000
September 11, 2000
AR CAP000726 Corrective Actions For CR 00-1812 Do Not   May 24, 2001
AR CA003242
            Address Concern
Request a Schedule and Justification be
AR CAP001532 Plant Electrical Equipment May Be Used in March 30, 1993
Provided for Which One of the Four Options
            Applications Beyond Fault Rating
That Are Being Considered as Possible
AR CAP001877 FSAR Discrepancy On Definition Of Reg     January 16, 2002
Solutions to the Bolted Fault Issue
            Guide Category 2
August 14, 2001
AR CAP001886 Incomplete 50.59 Screening Answer For     January 16, 2002
AR CA003518
            Changes To Relief Valve CC-736A/B
NRC 50.59 Inspection Requested A
AR CAP001897 Letdown Isolation Valve Appendix R         January 17, 2002
Procedural Tie Be Created In IT-21 And  
            Operation During Degraded Voltage
IT-22, Back To TRM Section 3.5.1  
            Conditions
January 16, 2002
AR CAP001900 Incomplete Corrective Actions Regarding   January 17, 2002
AR CA002130
            Classification Of RC-427
Potential Adverse Trend in Q List Program
                                  23
September 13, 2001
AR CAP000126
Short Circuit Fault Current Calculations
January 7, 2000
AR CAP000726
Corrective Actions For CR 00-1812 Do Not
Address Concern
May 24, 2001
AR CAP001532
Plant Electrical Equipment May Be Used in
Applications Beyond Fault Rating
March 30, 1993
AR CAP001877
FSAR Discrepancy On Definition Of Reg
Guide Category 2
January 16, 2002
AR CAP001886
Incomplete 50.59 Screening Answer For
Changes To Relief Valve CC-736A/B
January 16, 2002
AR CAP001897
Letdown Isolation Valve Appendix R
Operation During Degraded Voltage
Conditions
January 17, 2002
AR CAP001900
Incomplete Corrective Actions Regarding
Classification Of RC-427
January 17, 2002


AR CAP001901 FSAR Chapter 9 Changes For CFC Service     January 17, 2002
24
            Water Pressure Not Also Made In Chapter 6
AR CAP001901
AR CAP001910 Safety Evaluation 2000-0014 Incomplete     January 17, 2002
FSAR Chapter 9 Changes For CFC Service
AR CAP001915 Questioning Corrective Action For           January 18, 2002
Water Pressure Not Also Made In Chapter 6
            CR 00-2859 On Screening Procedure Temp
January 17, 2002
            Change
AR CAP001910
AR CAP001916 Incorrect Answer To Tech Spec Change       January 18, 2002
Safety Evaluation 2000-0014 Incomplete
            Question In 50.59 Evaluation
January 17, 2002  
AR CAP001957 Individual Requested To Do Work Not         January 24, 2002
AR CAP001915
            Qualified Or Trained To Do
Questioning Corrective Action For  
AR CAP001962 WO For SR Equipment Bypassed QC             January 24, 2002
CR 00-2859 On Screening Procedure Temp
            Review
Change
AR CAP001965 SW Pumps Discharge Expansion Joints         January 25, 2002
January 18, 2002
            Have Surface Cracks
AR CAP001916
AR CAP001966 Outdated Procedures For New PPCS, With     January 25, 2002
Incorrect Answer To Tech Spec Change
            No New Procedures In Place
Question In 50.59 Evaluation
AR CAP001970 Poor Loading Of E-12 (SO4B2) Work Week     January 25, 2002
January 18, 2002
AR CAP001979 Minor Deficiencies In The Corrective Action January 25, 2002
AR CAP001957
            Program
Individual Requested To Do Work Not
AR CAP001984 Negative Trend Of Security Self Reporting   January 25, 2002
Qualified Or Trained To Do  
            Issues In Corrective Action System
January 24, 2002
AR CAP001985 NRC Commitment To Inspection Unit 2         January 25, 2002
AR CAP001962
            Internals Lift Rig Not Met
WO For SR Equipment Bypassed QC
AR CAP001992 NUTRK Database Is Inaccurate               January 28, 2002
Review
            And Cluttered With Outdated Action
January 24, 2002
            Requests
AR CAP001965
AR CAP001996 Lack Of Documentation Of Adverse Issues     January 28, 2002
SW Pumps Discharge Expansion Joints
AR CAP002031 NP5.3.1 Does Not Allow Closure Of ARs To   January 30, 2002
Have Surface Cracks
            Other Formal Tracking Mechanisms
January 25, 2002
AR CAP002038 Questionable Acceptable Voltage Ranges     January 31, 2002
AR CAP001966
            For Instrument Buses
Outdated Procedures For New PPCS, With
AR CAP002039 Vibration Indications On G-01               January 31, 2002
No New Procedures In Place
AR CAP002065 CAP Closed Without All Corrective Actions   February 4, 2002
January 25, 2002
            Completed
AR CAP001970
AR CAP002083 P-032D Service Water Pump Vibration And     February 5, 2002
Poor Loading Of E-12 (SO4B2) Work Week
            Shaft Wear Resolution
January 25, 2002
                                  24
AR CAP001979
Minor Deficiencies In The Corrective Action
Program
January 25, 2002
AR CAP001984
Negative Trend Of Security Self Reporting
Issues In Corrective Action System
January 25, 2002
AR CAP001985
NRC Commitment To Inspection Unit 2
Internals Lift Rig Not Met
January 25, 2002
AR CAP001992
NUTRK Database Is Inaccurate  
And Cluttered With Outdated Action
Requests
January 28, 2002
AR CAP001996
Lack Of Documentation Of Adverse Issues
January 28, 2002
AR CAP002031
NP5.3.1 Does Not Allow Closure Of ARs To
Other Formal Tracking Mechanisms
January 30, 2002
AR CAP002038
Questionable Acceptable Voltage Ranges
For Instrument Buses
January 31, 2002
AR CAP002039
Vibration Indications On G-01
January 31, 2002
AR CAP002065
CAP Closed Without All Corrective Actions
Completed
February 4, 2002
AR CAP002083
P-032D Service Water Pump Vibration And
Shaft Wear Resolution
February 5, 2002


AR CAP002264           Untimely Implementation of                 February 21, 2002
25
                        Recommendations From IN 88-023-05
AR CAP002264
Untimely Implementation of
Recommendations From IN 88-023-05
February 21, 2002
Lists
Lists
                        List of Apparent Cause Evaluations - 2001 2001
List of Apparent Cause Evaluations - 2001
                        List of Completed Root Cause Evaluations - 2001
2001
                        2001
List of Completed Root Cause Evaluations -
                        List of Temporary Modifications - 2001     January 3, 2002
2001
2001
List of Temporary Modifications - 2001
January 3, 2002
Root Cause Evaluations (RCEs)
Root Cause Evaluations (RCEs)
98-190                 Inappropriate Design Pressure For The AFW Revision 1
98-190  
                        [Auxiliary Feedwater] Discharge Valve
Inappropriate Design Pressure For The AFW
                        Modification
[Auxiliary Feedwater] Discharge Valve
98-214                 Disabled Service Water Pump Auto Start     November 30, 2001
Modification
                        Feature On EDG [Emergency Diesel
Revision 1
                        Generator] Breaker Closure Results in
98-214
                        Missed LCO
Disabled Service Water Pump Auto Start
00-104                 Common Cause Assessment for Procedure     March 2, 2001
Feature On EDG [Emergency Diesel
                        Quality Issues
Generator] Breaker Closure Results in
01-013                 Speed For P-32C Service Water Pump
Missed LCO
                        Motor
November 30, 2001
01-013                 Replacement Service Water Pump Motor       June 8, 2001
00-104
                        Does Not Meet Design Requirements
Common Cause Assessment for Procedure
01-033                 Maintenance Rule Component Common         May 8, 2001
Quality Issues
                        Cause
March 2, 2001
01-046                 Unit 1 Loss Of Inverter                   July 18, 2001
01-013
01-047                 Unit 1 Main Feed Pump Inboard Bearing     July 19, 2001
Speed For P-32C Service Water Pump
                        Failure
Motor
01-0151               G04 Generator Failure Equipment Rood       August 5, 2001
01-013
                        Cause
Replacement Service Water Pump Motor
01-052                 Failure To Perform TS Required EDG         August 9, 2001
Does Not Meet Design Requirements
                        Testing
June 8, 2001
01-055                 Reactor Coolant Pump Seal Malfunction     September 6, 2001
01-033
                        Caused Unit Shutdown
Maintenance Rule Component Common
                                            25
Cause
May 8, 2001
01-046
Unit 1 Loss Of Inverter
July 18, 2001
01-047
Unit 1 Main Feed Pump Inboard Bearing
Failure
July 19, 2001
01-0151
G04 Generator Failure Equipment Rood
Cause
August 5, 2001
01-052
Failure To Perform TS Required EDG
Testing
August 9, 2001
01-055
Reactor Coolant Pump Seal Malfunction
Caused Unit Shutdown
September 6, 2001


26
Nuclear Plant Memorandum (NPM)
Nuclear Plant Memorandum (NPM)
2002-0006             Minutes From The December 19, 2001         January 4, 2002
2002-0006
                      CARB Meeting
Minutes From The December 19, 2001
2002-0052             Third Quarter 2001 Corrective Action       January 28, 2002
CARB Meeting
                      Program Trends
January 4, 2002
2002-0056             CARB Agenda For The February 5, 2002       February 1, 2002
2002-0052
                      Meeting
Third Quarter 2001 Corrective Action
Program Trends
January 28, 2002
2002-0056
CARB Agenda For The February 5, 2002
Meeting
February 1, 2002
Work Orders
Work Orders
9924742               Temporary Relocate 1LT-972/1LI-921 to       April 14, 2001
9924742
                        Allow for Installation of Welds and
Temporary Relocate 1LT-972/1LI-921 to
                        Anchorage on RWST, Then Return to
Allow for Installation of Welds and
                        Original Locations
Anchorage on RWST, Then Return to
9937026               Transmitter Enclosure is Damaged,           April 2, 2001
Original Locations
                        Condition Report Submitted
April 14, 2001
9945054                IT-013 Repair Weld                         July 24, 2001
9937026
9945202               IT-13 Clean Residue/Insp 2 Day Later       July 19, 2001
Transmitter Enclosure is Damaged,
Condition Report Submitted
April 2, 2001
9945054
IT-013 Repair Weld
July 24, 2001
9945202
IT-13 Clean Residue/Insp 2 Day Later
July 19, 2001
Plant Modifications
Plant Modifications
MR-99-040             Unit 1 RWST Seismic Upgrade                 July 12, 2000
MR-99-040
Unit 1 RWST Seismic Upgrade
July 12, 2000
Engineering Work Request (EWR)
Engineering Work Request (EWR)
02-019                 Protective Enclosure for Sightglass/Oiler   January 25, 2002
02-019
                        Assemblies
Protective Enclosure for Sightglass/Oiler
Assemblies
January 25, 2002
Nuclear Power Business Unit Procedures (NPs)
Nuclear Power Business Unit Procedures (NPs)
5.3.1                 Action Request Process                     Revision 19
5.3.1
5.3.7                 Operability Determinations                 Revision 8
Action Request Process
5.4.1                 Open Item Tracking System (NUTRK)           Revision 11
Revision 19
9.3.3                 Spare Parts Equivalency Evaluation [SPEED] Revisions 2 and 3
5.3.7
9.8.1                 Specification Preparation, review, and     Revision 0
Operability Determinations
                        Approval Process
Revision 8
                                              26
5.4.1
Open Item Tracking System (NUTRK)
Revision 11
9.3.3
Spare Parts Equivalency Evaluation [SPEED]
Revisions 2 and 3
9.8.1
Specification Preparation, review, and
Approval Process
Revision 0


9.8.2                 Technical Review and Approval of           Revisions 0 and 1
27
                      Requisitions
9.8.2
9.8.4                 Safety Classification of Sub-Components     Revision 0
Technical Review and Approval of
                      and Materials
Requisitions
9.8.5                 Dedication of Commercial Grade Items       Revisions 0 and 1
Revisions 0 and 1
9.8.6                 Conditional Release of QA-related Items and Revision 0
9.8.4
                      Services
Safety Classification of Sub-Components
9.8.9                 Product Technical Information               Revision 0
and Materials
9.9.2                 Quality Receipt                             Revision 0
Revision 0
9.9.3                 Spare Parts Equivalency Evaluation [SPEED] Revisions 2 and 3
9.8.5
9.10.1               Warehouse Material Issue                   Revision 0
Dedication of Commercial Grade Items
10.2.4               Work Order Processing                       Revision 7
Revisions 0 and 1
9.8.6
Conditional Release of QA-related Items and
Services
Revision 0
9.8.9
Product Technical Information  
Revision 0
9.9.2
Quality Receipt
Revision 0
9.9.3
Spare Parts Equivalency Evaluation [SPEED]
Revisions 2 and 3
9.10.1
Warehouse Material Issue
Revision 0
10.2.4
Work Order Processing
Revision 7
Other Procedures and Documents
Other Procedures and Documents
AM (Administrative   Implementation of the Maintenance Rule at   Revision 4
AM (Administrative
Manual) 3-4          PBNP
Manual) 3-4
A-P-01-17             Improved Technical Specifications Audit     October 5, 2001
Implementation of the Maintenance Rule at
A-P-01-018           Maintenance Rule Audit                     August 28, 2001
PBNP
FP-NO-SQ-01           Performance of Supplier Audits/Surveys     Revision 1
Revision 4
FP-SC-GEN-01         Procurement - General                       Revision 1
A-P-01-17
FP-SC-RSI-01         Receiving                                   Revision 0
Improved Technical Specifications Audit
FP-SC-RSI-02         Quality Receipt                             Revision 0
October 5, 2001
FP-SC-RSI-03         Procurement Deficiency Reports             Revision 0
A-P-01-018
Licensee Event       Inadequately Rated Electrical Buses Could   July 30, 1997
Maintenance Rule Audit
Report 97-032        Disable Switchgear and Cause Secondary
August 28, 2001
                      Fires That Prevent Safe Shutdown Per
FP-NO-SQ-01
                      Appendix R
Performance of Supplier Audits/Surveys
OEG (OE Group         Root Cause Evaluation                       Revision 6
Revision 1
Guide) 001
FP-SC-GEN-01
OEG 003               Corrective Action Program Guidance         Revision 2
Procurement - General
PBF (Point Beach     Procedure Preparer/Technical Reviewer       Revision 4
Revision 1
Form)-0026q          Checklist
FP-SC-RSI-01
PBF-0026r             Procedure Validation                       Revision 1
Receiving
                                            27
Revision 0
FP-SC-RSI-02
Quality Receipt  
Revision 0
FP-SC-RSI-03
Procurement Deficiency Reports
Revision 0
Licensee Event
Report 97-032
Inadequately Rated Electrical Buses Could
Disable Switchgear and Cause Secondary
Fires That Prevent Safe Shutdown Per
Appendix R
July 30, 1997
OEG (OE Group
Guide) 001
Root Cause Evaluation
Revision 6
OEG 003
Corrective Action Program Guidance
Revision 2
PBF (Point Beach
Form)-0026q
Procedure Preparer/Technical Reviewer
Checklist
Revision 4
PBF-0026r
Procedure Validation  
Revision 1


PBF-1531           Conditional Release Request                 Revision 2
28
PBF-1583           Design Verification Notice                   Revision 1
PBF-1531
PBF-1586b           CI Manual Distribution
Conditional Release Request  
S-A-CA-01-01       Assessment of Point Beach Corrective         February 2001
Revision 2
                    Action Program
PBF-1583
Spare Parts         Replace Obsolete Westinghouse Motor With    February 8, 2002
Design Verification Notice
Equivalency         Equivalent Marathon Electric Motor
Revision 1
PBF-1586b
CI Manual Distribution
S-A-CA-01-01
Assessment of Point Beach Corrective
Action Program
February 2001
Spare Parts
Equivalency
Evaluation Document
Evaluation Document
2002-006
2002-006
                    Nuclear Oversight Quarterly Reports         1st, 2nd, and 3rd
Replace Obsolete Westinghouse Motor With
                                                                Quarters, 2001
Equivalent Marathon Electric Motor
                    Corrective Action Program Performance       October, November,
February 8, 2002
                    Indicators                                  December 2001;
Nuclear Oversight Quarterly Reports  
                                                                January 2002
1st, 2nd, and 3rd
                    Bolted Fault Meeting Minutes                 January 21, 2002
Quarters, 2001
                    Project Work Plan: Bolted AC Fault Issue     Revision 3
Corrective Action Program Performance
                                                                August 28, 2000
Indicators
                    AC Bolted Fault Project History and Timeline 2001
October, November,
                    Electrical Fault Overduty Resolution Plan   May and November
December 2001;
                    Updates                                      2001; February
January 2002
                                                                2002
Bolted Fault Meeting Minutes
                    SI Pump Gas Binding Event Operating         February 23, 2002
January 21, 2002
                    Experience Review
Project Work Plan: Bolted AC Fault Issue
                    Corrective Action Trend Reports             1st, 2nd, and 3rd
Revision 3  
                                                                Quarters, 2001
August 28, 2000
                    Corrective Action Review Board Member
AC Bolted Fault Project History and Timeline
                    Attendance Records
2001
Chemistry Logs     Unit 1 RWST Chemical Analyses               February 5, 2002
Electrical Fault Overduty Resolution Plan
NUTRK Operating     NRC Information Notice 88-023, Potential   May 12, 1988
Updates
Experience Review  for Gas Binding of High Pressure Safety     January 5, 1989
May and November
                    Injection Pumps During a Loss-of-Coolant     January 30, 1990
2001; February
                    Accident, Original Notice and 5             December 10, 1990
2002
                    Supplements                                  December 18, 1992
SI Pump Gas Binding Event Operating
                                                                September 1, 1999
Experience Review
NUTRK Operating     NRC Information Notice 97-040, Potential   June 26, 1997
February 23, 2002
Experience Review  Nitrogen Accumulation Resulting From
Corrective Action Trend Reports
                    Backleakage From Safety Injection Tanks
1st, 2nd, and 3rd
                                        28
Quarters, 2001
Corrective Action Review Board Member
Attendance Records
Chemistry Logs
Unit 1 RWST Chemical Analyses  
February 5, 2002
NUTRK Operating
Experience Review
NRC Information Notice 88-023, Potential
for Gas Binding of High Pressure Safety
Injection Pumps During a Loss-of-Coolant
Accident, Original Notice and 5
Supplements
May 12, 1988
January 5, 1989
January 30, 1990
December 10, 1990
December 18, 1992
September 1, 1999
NUTRK Operating
Experience Review
NRC Information Notice 97-040, Potential
Nitrogen Accumulation Resulting From
Backleakage From Safety Injection Tanks
June 26, 1997


NUTRK Operating       SOER 97-01, Potential Loss of High         December 6, 1997
29
Experience Review    Pressure Injection and Charging Capability
NUTRK Operating
                      From Gas Intrusion
Experience Review
NUTRK Operating       SEN 179, Long-Standing Design             January 29, 1998
SOER 97-01, Potential Loss of High
Experience Review    Weaknesses and Ineffective Corrective
Pressure Injection and Charging Capability
                      Actions Cause Gas Binding Failures of High
From Gas Intrusion
                      Head Safety Injection Pumps
December 6, 1997
NUTRK Operating       OE 8830, Potential Nitrogen Voiding and   March 26, 1998
NUTRK Operating
Experience Review    Water Hammer in the Low Pressure Safety
Experience Review
                      Injection System
SEN 179, Long-Standing Design
NUTRK Operating       OE 9876, 4B HHSI Pump Gas Binding        May 4, 1999
Weaknesses and Ineffective Corrective
Actions Cause Gas Binding Failures of High
Head Safety Injection Pumps
January 29, 1998
NUTRK Operating
Experience Review
OE 8830, Potential Nitrogen Voiding and
Water Hammer in the Low Pressure Safety
Injection System
March 26, 1998
NUTRK Operating
Experience Review
Experience Review
Plant Internal Letter NRC Information Notice No. 88-23: Potential June 7, 1988
OE 9876, 4B HHSI Pump Gas Binding
NEPB-88-252          For Gas Binding of High-Pressure Safety
May 4, 1999
                      Injection Pumps During A Loss-of-Coolant
Plant Internal Letter
                      Accident
NEPB-88-252
Plant Internal Letter NRC Information Notice No. 88-23,           March 6, 1989
NRC Information Notice No. 88-23: Potential
NEM-89-143            Supplement 1: Potential For Gas Binding of
For Gas Binding of High-Pressure Safety
                      High-Pressure Safety Injection Pumps
Injection Pumps During A Loss-of-Coolant
                      During Loss-of-Coolant Accident
Accident
Plant Internal Letter NRC Information Notice No. 88-23           April 23, 1990
June 7, 1988
NEM-90-368            Supplement 2: Potential For Gas Binding of
Plant Internal Letter
                      High-Pressure Safety Injection Pumps
NEM-89-143
                      During A Loss-of-Coolant Accident
NRC Information Notice No. 88-23,
Plant Internal Letter NRC Information Notice No. 88-23,           June 18, 1991
Supplement 1: Potential For Gas Binding of
NPM 91-0400          Supplement 3: Potential For Gas Binding of
High-Pressure Safety Injection Pumps
                      High-Pressure Injection Pumps During A
During Loss-of-Coolant Accident
                      Loss-of-Coolant Accident
March 6, 1989
Plant Internal Letter NRC Information Notice No. 88-23,           February 5, 1993
Plant Internal Letter
NPM 93-0092          Supplement 4: Potential For Gas Binding of
NEM-90-368
                      High-Pressure Safety Injection Pumps
NRC Information Notice No. 88-23
                      During A Design Basis Accident
Supplement 2: Potential For Gas Binding of
                                          29
High-Pressure Safety Injection Pumps
During A Loss-of-Coolant Accident
April 23, 1990
Plant Internal Letter
NPM 91-0400
NRC Information Notice No. 88-23,
Supplement 3: Potential For Gas Binding of
High-Pressure Injection Pumps During A
Loss-of-Coolant Accident
June 18, 1991
Plant Internal Letter
NPM 93-0092
NRC Information Notice No. 88-23,
Supplement 4: Potential For Gas Binding of
High-Pressure Safety Injection Pumps
During A Design Basis Accident
February 5, 1993


  DOCUMENTS REQUESTED FROM THE LICENSEE PRIOR TO ONSITE INSPECTION
30
DOCUMENTS REQUESTED FROM THE LICENSEE PRIOR TO ONSITE INSPECTION
Two copies of administrative procedures related to:
Two copies of administrative procedures related to:
      corrective action program
corrective action program
      work orders
work orders
      operability determinations
operability determinations
      temporary modifications
temporary modifications
      root cause analysis
root cause analysis
      procedure change, use, and adherence
procedure change, use, and adherence
One copy of audits and self-assessments conducted since January 1, 2001, in the following
One copy of audits and self-assessments conducted since January 1, 2001, in the following
areas:
areas:
              corrective action process
corrective action process
              maintenance/work control
maintenance/work control
              operations
operations
              engineering
engineering
One copy of minutes for onsite and offsite committee meetings, including the Corrective Actions
One copy of minutes for onsite and offsite committee meetings, including the Corrective Actions
Review Board, conducted since January 1, 2001
Review Board, conducted since January 1, 2001
Two copies of a listing of:
Two copies of a listing of:
              root cause evaluations completed since January 1, 2001
root cause evaluations completed since January 1, 2001
              CRs generated since January 1, 2001, related to corrective actions
CRs generated since January 1, 2001, related to corrective actions
              work orders and CRs generated since January 1, 2001, related to the service
              water, safety injection, and the 4160-volt systems
work orders and CRs generated since January 1, 2001, related to the service
              temporary modifications
water, safety injection, and the 4160-volt systems  
              operability determinations
temporary modifications
                                                30
operability determinations
}}
}}

Latest revision as of 19:25, 16 January 2025

IR 05000266/2002-003; 05000301/2002-003, on 1/22-2/25/2002. Nuclear Management Company, LLC, Point Beach Nuclear Plant, Baseline Inspection of the Identification and Resolution of Problems. No Violations Noted
ML020850432
Person / Time
Site: Point Beach  NextEra Energy icon.png
Issue date: 03/25/2002
From: Lanksbury R
NRC/RGN-III/DRP/RPB5
To: Warner M
Nuclear Management Co
References
IR-02-003
Download: ML020850432 (28)


See also: IR 05000266/2002003

Text

March 25, 2002

Mr. M. Warner

Site Vice President

Kewaunee and Point Beach Nuclear Plants

Nuclear Management Company, LLC

6610 Nuclear Road

Two Rivers, WI 54241

SUBJECT:

POINT BEACH NUCLEAR PLANT

NRC INSPECTION REPORT 50-266/02-03(DRP); 50-301/02-03(DRP)

Dear Mr. Warner:

On February 25, 2002, the NRC completed a team inspection at the Point Beach Nuclear Plant.

The enclosed report documents the inspection findings which were discussed on February 25

with you and members of your staff.

This inspection was an examination of activities conducted under your license as they relate to

the identification and resolution of problems, and compliance with the Commissions rules and

regulations and with the conditions of your operating license. Within these areas, the

inspection involved selected examination of procedures and representative records,

observations of activities, and interviews with personnel.

On the basis of the samples selected for review, the team concluded that, overall, problems

were properly identified, evaluated, and resolved within the problem identification and resolution

program. However, the inspectors identified one finding for which the safety significance was

still to be determined. This issue pertained to the failure of the 2P-15B safety injection pump on

February 20, 2002, because of nitrogen gas binding. The conditions that resulted in the

accumulation of nitrogen in the pump were still being evaluated by both your staff and the NRC

at the end of this inspection. This issue will be considered an Unresolved Item pending

completion of those reviews. A preliminary NRC review of the risk significance of the finding

determined that it was at least of very low safety significance (Green).

M. Warner

-2-

In accordance with 10 CFR 2.790 of the NRCs Rules of Practice, a copy of this letter

and its enclosure will be available electronically for public inspection in the NRC Public

Document Room or from the Publicly Available Records System (PARS) component of

NRCs document system (ADAMS). ADAMS is accessible from the NRC Web site at

http://www.nrc.gov/NRC/ADAMS/index.html (the Public Electronic Reading Room).

Sincerely,

/RA/

Roger Lanksbury, Chief

Branch 5

Division of Reactor Projects

Docket Nos. 50-266; 50-301

License Nos. DPR-24; DPR-27

Enclosure:

Inspection Report 50-266/02-03(DRP);

50-301/02-03(DRP)

cc w/encl:

R. Grigg, President and Chief

Operating Officer, WEPCo

R. Anderson, Executive Vice President

and Chief Nuclear Officer

T. Webb, Licensing Manager

D. Weaver, Nuclear Asset Manager

T. Taylor, Plant Manager

A. Cayia, Site Director

J. ONeill, Jr., Shaw, Pittman,

Potts & Trowbridge

K. Duveneck, Town Chairman

Town of Two Creeks

D. Graham, Director

Bureau of Field Operations

A. Bie, Chairperson, Wisconsin

Public Service Commission

S. Jenkins, Electric Division

Wisconsin Public Service Commission

State Liaison Officer

DOCUMENT NAME: G:\\poin\\poi2002003 drp.wpd

To receive a copy of this document, indicate in the box: "C" = Copy without attachment/enclosure "E" = Copy with attachment/enclosure "N" = No copy

OFFICE

RIII

C RIII

N

NAME

MKunowski/trn

RLanksbury

DATE

03/25/02

03/25/02

OFFICIAL RECORD COPY

M. Warner

-3-

ADAMS Distribution:

WDR

DFT

BAW

RidsNrrDipmIipb

GEG

HBC

PGK1

C. Ariano (hard copy)

DRPIII

DRSIII

PLB1

JRK1

U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION

REGION III

Docket Nos:

50-266; 50-301

License Nos:

DPR-24; DPR-27

Report No:

50-266/02-03(DRP); 50-301/02-03(DRP)

Licensee:

Nuclear Management Company, LLC

Facility:

Point Beach Nuclear Plant, Units 1 & 2

Location:

6610 Nuclear Road

Two Rivers, WI 54241

Dates:

January 22 through February 25, 2002

Inspectors:

M. Kunowski, Project Engineer (Lead Inspector)

P. Krohn, Senior Resident Inspector

R. Langstaff, Senior Reactor Engineer

Approved by:

Roger Lanksbury, Chief

Branch 5

Division of Reactor Projects

2

SUMMARY OF FINDINGS

IR 05000266-02-03; 05000301-02-03, on 1/22-2/25/2002. Nuclear Management Company,

LLC, Point Beach Nuclear Plant, baseline inspection of the identification and resolution of

problems.

The inspection was conducted by two regional inspectors and a resident inspector. No findings

were identified during this inspection. The significance of most findings is indicated by their

color (Green, White, Yellow, Red) using Inspection Manual Chapter 0609, Significance

Determination Process (SDP). Findings for which the SDP does not apply are indicated by

No Color or by the severity level of the applicable violation. The NRCs program for

overseeing the safe operation of commercial nuclear power reactors is described at its Reactor

Oversight Process website at http://www.nrc.gov/NRR/OVERSIGHT/index.html.

Identification and Resolution of Problems

The team concluded that the licensee was generally effective at identifying problems and

putting them into the corrective action program. There was strong management emphasis on

plant staff to identify problems and, overall, a very responsive plant staff. Since 1997, there

had been an average of 4120 condition reports written each year. A recent change from a

mainframe-based, dated, and user-unfriendly corrective action database to a Web-based

system was expected by the licensee to improve plant staff involvement with the corrective

action program and to increase program management capability. Corrective action program

timeliness was still an area of weakness and one where the licensee was expending additional

efforts. Included in this effort was an emphasis on making improvements for overdue or less

than prompt assessments of problems and implementation of corrective actions and for an

excessive number of due date extensions. Although there had been some dissatisfaction

expressed with some aspects of the corrective action program, the inspectors identified no

impediments to a safety conscious work environment. One finding was identified that was at

least of very low safety significance (Green). This finding pertained to the failure of the 2P-15B

safety injection pump on February 20, 2002, because of nitrogen gas binding. The conditions

that resulted in the accumulation of nitrogen in the pump were still being evaluated by both the

licensees staff and the NRC at the end of this inspection. This issue will be considered an

Unresolved Item pending completion of those reviews.

3

Report Details

4.

OTHER ACTIVITIES (OA)

4OA2 Identification and Resolution of Problems

a. Effectiveness of Problem Identification

(1) Inspection Scope

The inspectors conducted plant tours; observed surveillance tests in progress;

interviewed plant personnel; and reviewed inspection reports issued over the last year;

corrective action program documents (condition reports (CRs) - as of

December 21, 2001, CRs were replaced by documents called CAPs (Corrective Action

Program documents)), and selected maintenance work orders (WOs) for several high

risk systems to determine if problems were being properly identified, characterized, and

entered into the corrective action program for evaluation and resolution. These systems

were Service Water (SW), 4160-volt, emergency diesel generators (EDGs), safety

injection (SI), and instrument air. The inspectors also reviewed several recent licensee

audits and self-assessments. The effectiveness of the audits and assessments was

evaluated by comparing the audit and assessment results against self-revealing and

NRC-identified issues. A listing of the documents requested by the inspectors prior to

the inspection and those documents reviewed during the inspection is included at the

end of this report.

(2) Findings

In general, problems were properly identified, characterized, and entered into the

corrective action program for evaluation and resolution. There was strong management

emphasis on plant staff to document problems in the corrective action program and a

plant staff that, overall, was very responsive. Since 1997, there had been an average of

4120 CRs written per year. In 2001, there were 3819 CRs/CAPs generated. On

December 21, 2001, the licensee switched its corrective action program database

system from a mainframe-based, dated, and relatively user-unfriendly system (called

NUTRK) to a Web-based, user-friendly system (called t-Track).

Several process improvements had helped to encourage the writing of CRs\\CAPs: the

CR\\AR hotline; department corrective action program liaisons; the new web-based

system; and the Good Catch initiative for examples of notably good problem

identification. Through routine trending of corrective action program data, the licensee

had identified instances where CR/CAP generation rates by various work groups had

not met station management expectations. For instance, in one plant group, the

expected number of CRs/CAPs were being generated but more than 85% of them were

written by 2 of the 23 persons in the work group. For another group, the percentage of

self-identified CAPs fell below an expected value. In both examples, the licensee took

corrective actions.

4

Regarding audits and self-assessment findings, there were no major discrepancies with

the observations of the inspectors. Appropriate corrective actions were taken by the

licensee for problems identified during the audits and self-assessments.

b.

Prioritization and Evaluation of Issues

(1) Inspection Scope

The inspectors reviewed a sample of CRs/CAPs to verify the appropriateness of the

category assigned, operability and reportability determinations, extent of condition

evaluations, root and apparent cause evaluations, and the assigned corrective actions.

As part of this assessment, the inspectors attended the stations daily management

meeting where newly generated CRs/CAPs were reviewed and the subsequent daily

meeting of department corrective action program liaisons. The inspectors also attended

a meeting of the Corrective Action Review Board (CARB). In addition, the inspectors

reviewed licensee actions on several problems identified by the inspectors during the

previous problem identification and resolution inspection (PI&R) in March 2001 (NRC

Inspection Report 50-266/01-06; 50-301/01-06). The documents listed at the end of the

report were used by the inspectors during the assessment of this area.

(2) Findings

In general, issues were appropriately categorized, prioritized, and evaluated. In

addition, licensee actions to address a concern identified during the previous PI&R with

the appropriateness of the initial screening of CRs were generally effective. During the

review of CRs/CAPs, the inspectors identified one example (CR 01-0203, 4KV System

Grounds) where not all of the pertinent evaluations conducted by the licensee for a

problem had been documented in the closed-out CR. This example and other examples

identified by the licensee highlight the need for continued emphasis by the licensee on

thorough documentation of evaluations and corrective actions.

c. Effectiveness of Corrective Actions

(1) Inspection Scope

The inspectors reviewed CRs/CAPs to verify that corrective actions commensurate with

the issues were identified and implemented in a timely manner, including corrective

actions to address common cause or generic concerns. During the previous PI&R, the

inspectors identified concerns with daisy-chaining---the closing of CRs to other CRs

which could be closed to yet other CRs-and the possibility that not all of the corrective

actions for the various CRs would be taken because of the difficulty in tracking all of the

problems that may be closed to any one CR. In addition, the inspectors in the previous

PI&R identified a concern with corrective action program timeliness, in that several CRs

had more than a few due date extensions and several CR evaluations and corrective

actions were overdue or had exceptionally extended due dates. The documents listed

at the end of the report were used during the review.

5

(2) Findings

Generally, effective corrective actions commensurate with the issues were identified by

the licensee and implemented in a timely manner. However, problems with overdue

problem assessments and implementation of corrective actions, and with excessive

number of due date extensions were identified by the licensee and the inspectors.

Licensee corrective actions for these problems were ongoing as of the end of the

inspection. Specific observations in this area are discussed below.

The inspectors reviewed the licensees actions on CR 93-137, which was written

in 1993 and was still open at the time of the inspection. This CR was written to

document a potential problem with fault currents exceeding the breaker rating for

certain short circuits (bolted faults) in the 480-volt, 4160-volt, and 13.8-kilovolt

systems. This issue had previously been reviewed in late 1996 by the NRC and

a violation was identified for untimely corrective actions (Inspection Report

No. 50-266/96018; 50-301/96018). During the present inspection, the inspectors

concluded that continuing actions by the licensee had been timely. Through

procedure changes and extensive engineering analyses employing a reduction

of over-conservatisms, the licensee had been able to narrow down the problem

and had developed and approved a plan to upgrade certain 480-volt breakers

and bus-work over the next several years that should allow closure of

CR 93-137.

Regarding daisy-chaining, the inspectors reviewed an instance where at least

11 CRs pertaining to various problems with the commercial grade dedication and

procurement programs were ultimately closed, either directly or through other

CRs that were closed directly, to one corrective action (Action Number 23) of the

CR written to address a problem with the Alert and Notification System. The

inspectors identified that the two recommended corrective actions for

CR 00-2933, relating to the procedure for the conditional release of QA items

from receiving, had not been implemented. CR 00-2933 had been closed to

CR 00-2312, which had been closed to Action Number 23. Action Number 23

was closed on November 16, 2001. In this instance, the items not corrected

were minor.

Regarding the issue with excessive due date extensions, during the previous

PI&R, the inspectors noted that a CR written in 1997 (CR 97-0249) for the need

to revise the administrative procedure controlling the use of equivalent spare

parts in safety-related systems had the due date extended 13 times. And while

the procedure was revised early last year in response to the procurement of a

replacement service water pump motor with inadequate wire insulation, the CR

remained open pending incorporation of other planned changes to the

procedure. During this PI&R, the inspectors noted that the CRs due date had

now been extended 18 times; however, near the end of the inspection, the

procedure revision to address the remaining changes was approved.

In an issue related to timeliness of corrective actions, the inspectors noted that

CR 01-0368 dealt with an unexpected apparent rise in Unit 2 power during a

dilution on Unit 1 on Feb 2, 2001. For this CR there were two corrective actions,

6

one to do an apparent cause evaluation (ACE) and the other to make an

Operations Notebook entry to notify all crews. The due date for this last item

was initially April 26, 2001, but was changed five times before the action was

closed without being taken because so much time had elapsed since the event

and the operating crews were already aware of the event.

Another timeliness issue was associated with the failure on February 20, 2002,

of the Unit 2 B SI pump. The pump seized and failed during a monthly

preventative-maintenance lubrication activity. The licensees initial determination

was that the pump seized due to nitrogen gas binding caused by leakage of

nitrogen-saturated water from the 2A SI accumulator back through two or more

check valves. The licensee also established that corrective actions proposed

after an August 1999 review of NRC Information Notice (IN) 88-23,

Supplement 5, Potential for Gas Binding of High Pressure Safety Injection

Pumps During a Loss-of-Coolant Accident, pertaining to the potential for gas

binding of high head safety injection pumps, were not timely. Timely completion

of these actions may have prevented the failure of the pump. In addition, the

inspectors noted that the possibility of plant conditions conducive of gas binding

was identified in February 2001 when CR 01-0454 was written because of

decreasing level in the Unit 2A SI accumulator. Since much of this information

came to light at the end of the inspection, the inspectors were not able to

complete an evaluation of these issues and had not come to any enforcement

conclusion on this particular matter.

Using the Significance Determination Process (SDP) Phase 1 Screening

Worksheet and the Phase 2 Worksheets for the Mitigating Systems

Cornerstone, the inspectors concluded that enough nitrogen gas may have been

present to cause failure of the 2P-15B pump at anytime during the 30-day period

prior to the pumps failure. The pumps failure rendered one train of SI incapable

of performing its safety function. Based on this information, this finding was

considered to be at least of very low safety significance (Green). Pending

completion of a Phase 3 SDP analysis, the safety significance of the finding is

To Be Determined (TBD) and this issue is considered an Unresolved Item

(URI 50-301/02-03-01).

d. Assessment of Safety Conscious Work Environment

(1) Inspection Scope

The inspectors interviewed plant staff and CRs/CAPs to assess whether there were

impediments to the establishment of a safety conscious work environment.

(2) Findings

From the interviews and record reviews, the inspectors identified no impediments to a

safety conscious work environment. Some individuals expressed dissatisfaction with

some aspects of the corrective action process, such as the user-unfriendly NUTRK

database system (which had since been replaced by a user-friendly Web-based system)

and workers being assigned to assess and correct problems that were identified by the

7

same workers but would be more efficiently assessed and corrected by someone else.

But the inspectors noted a strong emphasis by management on establishing an

atmosphere conducive to employees readily documenting and resolving problems and

an overall strong sentiment by interviewed plant staff to document problems.

4OA6 Meeting(s)

.1

Exit Meeting

The inspectors presented the inspection results to Mr. M. Warner and other members of

licensee management in an exit meeting on February 25, 2002. Licensee management

acknowledged the findings presented and indicated that no proprietary information was

provided to the inspectors.

8

KEY POINTS OF CONTACT

Nuclear Management Company, LLC (NMC)

J. R. Anderson

Point Beach Nuclear Plant (PBNP) Production Planning Manager

L. Armstrong

Design Engineering Manager

D. Black

Nuclear Safety Analysis Senior Engineer

A. J. Cayia

Kewaunee-Point Beach (KPB) Site Director

F. Flentje

NRC Coordinator

D. Hettick

Performance Assessment Manager

R. Hopkins

Nuclear Oversight Supervisor

T. C. Kendall

Design Engineering Supervisor

P. Kleinschmidt

Bolted Fault Project Manager

C. W. Krause

Senior Regulatory Compliance Engineer

R. G. Mende

KPB Engineering Director

K. Peveler

KPB Nuclear Oversight Manager

S. A. Pfaff

Corrective Action Supervisor

R. Pulec

KPB Performance Assessment Manager

R. Repshas

KPB Support Services Manager

G. D. Strharsky

PBNP Assistant Operations Manager

T. H. Taylor

PBNP Plant Manager

M. Warner

Site Vice-President

T. J. Webb

KPB Regulatory Affairs Manager

J. Walsh

KPB Procedures Program Manager

W. Yarosz

KPB Emergency Planning Supervisor

ITEMS OPENED, CLOSED, AND DISCUSSED

Opened

50-301/02-03-01

URI

2P-15B Safety Injection Pump Failure During Monthly

Preventative Maintenance Lubrication Activity

Closed

None

Discussed

None

9

LIST OF ACRONYMS USED

ACE

Apparent Cause Evaluation

AR

Action Request

ASME

American Society of Mechanical Engineers

CA

Corrective Action

CAP

Corrective Action Program

CARB

Corrective Action Review Board

CR

Condition Report

DC

Direct Current

EDG

Emergency Diesel Generator

EOP

Emergency Operating Procedure

EWR

Engineering Work Request

FSAR

Final Safety Analysis Report

INPO

Institute of Nuclear Power Operations

KPB

Kewaunee-Point Beach

KV

Kilovolt

LCO

Limiting Condition for Operation

LER

Licensee Event Report

LTA

Less Than Adequate

MOV

Motor-Operated Valve

NCV

Non-Cited Violation

NMC

Nuclear Management Company, LLC

NP

Nuclear Power Business Unit Procedure

OA

Organizational Assessment

OE

Operating Experience

OI

Operating Instruction

OOS

Out-Of-Service

PBNP

Point Beach Nuclear Plant

PMT

Post-Maintenance Testing

psi

Pounds Per Square Inch

QA

Quality Assurance

QCR

Quality Condition Report

RCE

Root Cause Evaluation

RCP

Reactor Coolant Pump

SDP

Significance Determination Process

SRO

Senior Reactor Operator

SW

Service Water

TS

Technical Specification

V

Volt

WO

Work Order 10

LIST OF DOCUMENTS REVIEWED

The following is a list of licensee documents reviewed during the inspection. Inclusion of a

document on this list does not imply that NRC inspectors reviewed the entire document, but,

rather that selected sections or portions of the document were evaluated as part of the overall

inspection effort. In addition, inclusion of a document on this list does not imply NRC

acceptance of the document, unless specifically stated in the body of the inspection report.

Condition Report

93-137

Plant Electrical Equipment May Be Used in

Applications Beyond Fault Current Ratings

March 30, 1993

97-0249 (Quality

Condition Report

(QCR))

Process Improvements SPEED NP 9.3.3

October 30, 1997

98-1004

SI Accumulator Level Decrease

March 11, 1998

99-2346

Seismic Qualification of Service Water

Pump Column Bolting Questioned

October 6, 1999

00-0094

Plant Electrical Equipment May Be Placed

Into Alignments Beyond Equipment Fault

Current Ratings

January 7, 2000

00-0128

P-32F-M Thermocouple Installation Not

Properly Documented

January 11, 2000

00-0213

Low Forebay Level, Lowest -9.6', Trip

January 20, 2000

00-0494

CR History of CIM Concerns

February 10, 2000

00-0514

QA Classification of Packing Kit for 850

Hydraulic Cylinder Questioned

February 9, 2000

00-0834

Corrosion Inhibitor Used in G-01 Without

the Required Evaluation

March 9, 2000

00-2077

Procurement Evaluation Deficiencies

June 16, 2000

00-2312

Commercial Grade Dedication Program

August 1, 2000

00-2335

Abnormal Sound From P-32A Service

Water Pump

August 3, 2000

00-2423

Dedication Criteria Changed During Receipt

Inspection

August 10, 2000

00-2426

Lack of As Found Data During Receipt

Inspection

August 10, 2000

11

00-2427

Documenting Discrepancies During Receipt

Inspection

August 10, 2000

00-2428

Technical Evaluations Dont Address

Equipment Qualification

August 10, 2000

00-2792

Less Than Adequate Wire Storage, QA

Versus Non-QA

September 20, 2000

00-2812

Alert and Notification System (ANS) Siren

Failure Response Weak

September 22, 2000

00-2933

Form for QA Conditional Release Form

Doesnt Match Procedure

September 29, 2000

00-2948

Crib Freeze Event CAs Concerns

October 2, 2002

00-3079

Condenser Steam Dump Malfunction

October 13, 2000

00-3299

Damaged Breaker Auxiliary Switches

October 23, 2000

00-4014

Leak On Unit 2 Conoseals

December 30, 2000

00-4150

Electrical Perturbation On Unit 2 Generator

December 17, 2000

01-0001

Unexpected Alarm During Service Water

Pump Start

January 1, 2001

01-0003

TS-33 Problems Due To Failing Pressure

Indicator

January 2, 2001

01-0022

Less Than Adequate Work Plan To Thaw

Frozen Pipe

December 29, 2000

01-0030

Service Water Pump Expansion Joints

January 3, 2001

01-0039

Service Water Pump Expansion Joints

January 3, 2001

01-0048

P-32C Work Packages Not Ready

January 5, 2001

01-0102

Less Than Adequate Evaluation of Part 21

NUTRK Item - AGASTAT

January 10, 2001

01-0109

Rope And Wood On Service Water Piping

January 12, 2001

01-0111

Untimely CR Initiation by OA Personnel

January 11, 2001

01-0112

Replacement Service Water Pump Motors

January 12, 2001

01-0122

Apparent Cause Evaluation Action Not

Created

January 12, 2001

01-0148

Wrong Thermocouple Extension Cable

Installed

January 16, 2001

12

01-0203

4 KV System Grounds

January 19, 2001

01-0216

New Thermocouple Found Faulty

January 19, 2001

01-0220

Incomplete IWP

January 21, 2001

01-0241

CRs Not Written as Result of

Self-Assessment

January 23, 2001

01-0259

West Service Water Supply Isolation Valve

Installation

January 24, 2001

01-0289

Service Water Safety Monitor Assumptions

January 27, 2001

01-0301

CR Trend Review Problems

January 29, 2001

01-0307

Service Water Pressure Indicator

January 30, 2001

01-0310

SW-2930A Valve Body Pitted

January 30, 2001

01-0318

No VT-2 Qualified Individual On Shift When

Required

January 30, 2001

01-0319

Less Than Adequate Work Plan SFP HX

[Spent Fuel Pool Heat Exchanger] Inlet

Valve

January 30, 2001

01-0323

Temp Change To AOP 9A Concern

January 30, 2001

01-0330

Declining Vendor Performance - IPSCO

February 1, 2001

01-0335

Increased Magnitude Of Change In SW

[Service Water] Pump Vibration Readings

February 1, 2001

01-0338

CAP Procedure Violations

February 1, 2001

01-0341

SW Line Stop Less Than Affective

February 1, 2001

01-0344

Service Water Expansion Joint - Spare

Parts Wrong Size

February 2, 2001

01-0365

Valve Accessibility Questioned

February 3, 2001

01-0368

Unit 2 Rise in Power - Dilution for Unit 1

February 2, 2001

01-0369

Energy Had Been Verified Released For

Tag Series O SW SW-2927A OP REV 2-1

By The Work Group, But No One From The

Work Group Signed On

February 2, 2001

01-0377

CR Routing and Closing

February 6, 2001

01-0380

Line Stop Machines Installation Delays

February 5, 2001

13

01-0387

SW-2974B Work Schedule Of 2/5/01 Parts

Issue

February 5, 2001

01-0395

Untimely Corrective Action

February 6, 2001

01-0403

Inadequate Safety Screening

February 8, 2001

01-0407

Line Stop Seal Failure

February 7, 2001

01-0418

Procedure Sign Off Sequence Not Used

February 8, 2001

01-0421

Service Water Piping Degradation

February 8, 2001

01-0423

4160 VAC Breaker Damage

February 8, 2001

01-0425

Package Release Without Tag Series

Accepted

February 8, 2001

01-0429

Classification of CR 01-0368

February 9, 2001

01-0438

Ineffective Followup on RCE 00-007 Actions

January 10, 2001

01-0444

Service Water System Piping Contaminated

February 9, 2001

01-0448

Containment Fan Cooler SW Flow Out Of

Spec

February 13, 2001

01-0449

NUTRK Not User-Friendly

February 13, 2001

01-0452

Micrologger Routes Erased

February 12, 2001

01-0454

U2 'A' Safety Injection SI Accumulator Level

February 12, 2001

01-0457

Service Water Gauge Out Of Tolerance

February 12, 2001

01-0471

Accumulator Level Indicator Failing

February 14, 2001

01-0481

Storage Of Spare SW Pump Motors

February 14, 2001

01-0529

Corrective Action Not Incorporated

February 20, 2001

01-0552

New Piping Insulation Damaged

February 22, 2001

01-0572

SI Accumulator Level Spikes

February 22, 2001

01-0587

Documentation Of Service Water System

Test

February 26, 2001

01-0596

Welder Bypassed Hold Point

February 26, 2001

01-0605

QCR Closed Prior to Actions Being

Completed

February 26, 2001

01-0612

Less Than Adequate Indication On 'F'

Service Water Pump Ammeter

February 27, 2001

14

01-0618

Corrective Action Program CAP Self-

Assessment Issues

February 28, 2001

01-0634

RCE 00-067 Corrective Actions

July 1, 2001

01-0635

Priorities Not Assigned in NUTRK

March 1, 2001

01-0638

SW Mod Work Caused Vacuum Loss

March 1, 2001

01-0639

SW Mod Work Caused Air In-leakage

March 1, 2001

01-0651

Less Than Adequate Closure of Condition

Reports

March 5, 2001

01-0662

Overdue Corrective Action

March 5, 2001

01-0693

CIM Not Updated To Reflect New Type

After Coolers

March 7, 2001

01-0697

Condition Report Actions Not Adequately

Dispositioned - CR 98-1161

March 6, 2001

01-0705

Exact Time 'C' CCW [Component Cooling

Water] Returned To Service Unknown

March 9, 2001

01-0706

New SW Valves Not Shown On Any

Controlling Diagrams

March 9, 2001

01-0731

Inappropriate Closure of Action

March 12, 2001

01-0733

OA Witness Of Shipment

March 10, 2001

01-0734

Service Water Motor Shipped

Inappropriately

March 9, 2001

01-0738

Abnormal Noise From P-32A

March 11, 2001

01-0761

CFC [Containment Fan Cooler] Flow

Outside Of Band

March 13, 2001

01-0768

NUTRK Anonymous Notification

March 12, 2001

01-0782

SW Pump Motor Replacement Problems

Initiated 3/14/01

01-0794

Service Water Motor SPEED Insufficient

March 13, 2001

01-0817

SI Accumulator Fill Concerns

March 15, 2001

01-0818

Incomplete Weld Exam On Containment

Fan Cooler

March 15, 2001

01-0821

P32C-M Locked Rotor Test Results

March 15, 2001

01-0852

Drawings Reflect Wrong Valve Positions

March 16, 2001

01-0870

Weld Data Sheets Not Complete

March 21, 2001

15

01-0903

Procedure Misaligned Valves

March 22, 2001

01-0911

Additional Information Provided By

Engineering - Operability Of P-32C Drawn

Into Question

March 20, 2001

01-0919

Wrong Component Danger Tagged

March 22, 2001

01-0952

Incorrect Valve Labels

March 26, 2001

01-0958

Potential Valve Failure - Valve Stem

Separation

March 26, 2001

01-0983

Containment Fan Cooling Flexible Piping

Concern

March 28, 2001

01-1001

Less Than Adequate Formal Documentation

and Tracking of Effectiveness Review

Actions

March 30, 2001

01-1027

Overdue Condition Reports

April 3, 2001

01-1032

RWST Level Transmitter Found Out of

Calibration

April 2, 2001

01-1046

Evaluation Actions Not Documented in

NUTRK

April 4, 2001

01-1047

NRC/PI&R Inspection Concern of CR Cross

Referencing

April 3, 2001

01-1048

NRC/PI&R Inspection Concerns Less Than

Adequate SRO Screenings

April 3, 2001

01-1059

Found Local Control Switch

For 1A52-84, 1A06 Feed to 1X14

Transformer, In The Pullout Position. Per

PC 43 Part 2

April 3, 2001

01-1073

Lost/Misplaced Condition Report

April 4, 2001

01-1105

MOV Failed to Shut Remotely

April 5, 2001

01-1131

Condition Report Closure Inappropriate

April 6, 2001

01-1137

Breaker Charging Spring Failed To

Discharge

April 7, 2001

01-1146

Hoses Not Used For Draining Systems

April 9, 2001

01-1150

Breaker Inseat Not Updated In Champs

April 9, 2001

01-1178

Heat Exchangers Opened Prior To

Scheduled

April 17, 2001

16

01-1210

Service Water Valve Has Significant Leak

April 11, 2001

01-1244

U2 Service Water Leak On A Containment

Fan Cooler

April 11, 2001

01-1270

High Heat Exchanger Flow Rate

April 13, 2001

01-1279

Less Than Adequate Specified

Post-Maintenance Testing

April 14, 2001

01-1297

Coordination Of Work Activities

MR 98-024*J

April 14, 2001

01-1319

Containment Fan Cooler Outlet Throttle

Valve Potential Part 21

April 17, 2001

01-1334

SW-2880 Signature Indicates Valve Stem

Bent

April 18, 2001

01-1339

Closed Work Order - ASME Discrepancies

April 18, 2001

01-1363

Valves Pre-fabricated Backwards

April 19, 2001

01-1394

Pressure Test Data

April 21, 2001

01-1402

ANII Hold Points Bypassed

April 20, 2001

01-1453

No Oil in 1P-15A Sightglass

April 24, 2001

01-1470

Operations Adverse Trend

April 24, 2001

01-1471

Potentially Decreased Performance

April 24, 2001

01-1482

Bus And Breaker Short Circuit Rating

Discrepancies

April 25, 2001

01-1492

LTA communication on RP Close Out of a

CR

April 26, 2001

01-1551

Lack of Timely CR Initiation

April 30, 2001

01-1556

Condition Report Priority LTA

May 1, 2001

01-1568

Questioning Proper Installation Of CFC Ball

Valves

May 1, 2001

01-1577

Work Order LCO Tracking

May 1, 2001

01-1599

Trend Report Finding

May 4, 2001

01-1600

Potential Adverse Trend in NDE

[Non-Destructive Evaluation]

May 4, 2001

01-1601

Adverse Trend in Warehouse Fire

Protection

May 4, 2001

17

01-1602

Error Mode Classifications

May 4, 2001

01-1615

Service Water Flow Instrument Misaligned

May 2, 2001

01-1631

Effectiveness Review of RCE

May 4, 2001

01-1650

Ops Increase Error Rate - Skill Based

Errors

May 5, 2001

01-1677

Coating On Containment Fan Coolers

Questioned

May 7, 2001

01-1678

Support In Containment Has Unqualified

Coating

May 1, 2001

01-1688

TS-76 Concerns

May 9, 2001

01-1698

Overdue Corrective Actions

May 9, 2001

01-1718

Valve Repair Work Inadequacies

May 10, 2001

01-1723

Work Order Documentation Inadequate

May 10, 2001

01-1834

Maintenance Corrective Action Item Due

Date Extensions Not Documented

May 21, 2001

01-1851

Missing RRM Documentation For

Completed Work

May 23, 2001

01-1856

G01 HX Corrosion

May 23, 2001

01-1902

Corrective Actions For CR 00-1812 Do Not

Address Concern

May 24, 2001

01-1962

Condition Report (CR) Without Priorities

June 4, 2001

01-1963

Piping Class Incorrectly Shown On P&ID

June 5, 2001

01-1966

QA/SR RWST Level Transmitter Out of

Calibration

June 4, 2001

01-1994

OD Part II for CR 01-1559 Not Completed in

30 Days as Required

June 6, 2001

01-2035

Lesson Plan Not Revised Per Condition

Report

June 12, 2001

01-2160

Corrective Action Program Weakness

June 26, 2001

01-2085

Safety Injection Pump Motor Bearing Had

No Oil Visible in Fill Connection

June 17, 2001

01-2104

Insufficient Copper Tubing In Reserve For

Work Order

June 18, 2001

18

01-2142

U1 Safety Injection Accumulator Level Out

of Calibration

June 24, 2001

01-2166

Service Water Isolation Valve Leaks

Through

June 27, 2001

01-2168

Service Water Zurn Strainer Inoperable

June 26, 2001

01-2170

Potential Conflict With Service Water LCOs

June 26, 2001

01-2178

Large Fish Kill Results In Unit 2 Trip

June 28, 2001

01-2181

Emergent Temp Change To AOP

June 27, 2001

01-2191

Two Tag Series In Effect For Same Job

June 27, 2001

01-2237

CR 00-3888 Corrective Action Not

Completed

July 2, 2001

01-2243

Revision of Operability Determination

Contains Deficiencies

July 3, 2001

01-2264

Corrective Actions Without Assigned

Priorities

July 3, 2001

01-2267

Scheduled Conflict Would Have Caused

LCO Entry

July 5, 2001

01-2283

Corrective Action Items Overdue

July 9, 2001

01-2337

Rework Of Circ Water Seal Supply Strainer

July 13, 2001

01-2384

Less Than Adequate Closeout of Condition

Report Dealing With Alarm Response Book

Adequacy

July 19, 2001

01-2386

Unknown White Residue On Refueling

Water Storage Tank

July 19, 2001

01-2406

Blockage Of Emergency Diesel Generator

Cooler Tubes

July 23, 2001

01-2426

Hole In U1 [Unit 1] Refueling Water Storage

Tank

July 25, 2001

01-2487

Priorities Not Assigned As Required to

Condition Reports

August 3, 2001

01-2526

Ineffective Corrective Action - Failure To

Test Redundant Emergency Diesel

Generator

August 8, 2001

01-2598

AM 3-4 Obsolete Revision of 10 CFR 50.65

August 16, 2001

19

01-2705

Nuclear Safety Analysis NSA Adverse CR

Trend

August 29, 2001

01-2707

Condition Report Closed With Uncompleted

Corrective Actions

August 29, 2001

01-2721

Condition Reports Did Not Determine if

Functional Failures Were Maintenance

Preventable

August 29, 2001

01-2771

NUTRK Items Without Priority Assigned

September 7, 2001

01-2781

Damaged Auxiliary Switch On 4 KV Breaker

A52-DHVR-1200-31

September 8, 2001

01-2799

Errors In Drawing For G-02 Metering, DCNs

Not Done

September 9, 2001

01-2810

Potential Adverse Trend in Q List Program

September 11, 2001

01-2918

Evaluation Due Dates

September 24, 2001

01-2927

Schedule Plant to Revise Refueling

Procedures to Include Improved Technical

Specifications (ITS)

September 25, 2001

01-2929

Condition Report Closed Without

Consideration of Apparent Cause

Evaluation Recommendations

September 28, 2001

01-2969

Potential Current Transformer Issue In

1A52-59 Cubicle

September 26, 2001

01-2994

Less Than Adequate Support For MCE

Testing Of Unit 2 SI Pump Motor

October 2, 2001

01-3039

Operability Determinations Not Reviewed

For ITS Implications

October 5, 2001

01-3058

Condition Reports With No Assigned Priority

October 9, 2001

01-3107

Less Than Adequate Apparent Cause

Evaluation and Follow-up Actions

October 10, 2001

01-3148

Diesel Testing Not Identified In

Schedule/Test Plan

October 16, 2001

01-3166

Inadequate Closure of Condition Report CR

01-1329 - FPEE On Modified Fire Damper

October 16, 2001

01-3174

Grounding Card Latch Mechanism Difficult

To Verify Engaged

January 18, 2001

01-3199

SRO Screening Issues With CR 01-3139

October 19, 2001

20

01-3258

Safety-Related Bus Voltages High - 7 day

LCO Entered

November 21, 2001

01-3284

Condition Reports Threshold for EP Issues

October 26, 2001

01-3357

NUTRK Actions Not Prioritized

November 5, 2001

01-3414

7% Condition Report Items Overdue

November 9, 2001

01-3492

Problems With CR 00-1039 Resolution

November 15, 2001

01-3545

Procedures Indicate LCO Is Required May

Be Incorrect

November 26, 2001

01-3606

CR Verification Not Completed in Timely

Manner

November 30, 2001

01-3626

Less Than Adequate Documentation To

Support Operability Determination

December 3, 2001

01-3678

Condition Reports Priority -100

December 7, 2001

Operability Determination (OD)

OD for CR 93-0137

Plant Electrical Equipment May Be Used in

Applications Beyond Fault Current Ratings

Revision 8

August 6, 2001

OD for CR 00-3299

Chipped Auxiliary Switch On Breaker

A52-DHVR-1200-15

October, 2000

OD for CR 99-2346

SW Pump Discharge Column Connections

March 6, 2001

OD for CR 01-1105

MOV Failed to Shut Remotely

April 6, 2001

Drawing Number

PB 31 E APS 240 052

09

Schematic Diagram

4160V SWGR Bus 1-A06 (2-A06)

Feeder Breaker 1A52-84 (2A52-89 to STA

Service XFMR IX-14 (2X-14)

Revision D

PB 02 E SIS 000 002

06

Elementary Wiring Diagram

4160V SWGR.2A05 Cubicle-74 Safety

Injection Pump 2P-015A

PBNP Unit 2

Revision D

PB 01 E APS 256 004

01

Elementary Wiring Diagram

4160 Switchgear Cubicle-58 Station Service

Transformer Breaker 1A-52-58

PBNP Unit 1

Revision E

21

PB 01 E APW 240

034 03

Connection Diagram

4160V Switchgear 1A05-Cubicle 58

Station Service Transformer 1X-13

Revision E

PB 01 E APS 03015

07

Elementary Wiring Diagram

4160 SWGR 1A05-Cubicle 57

Bus Tie Breaker 1A52-57

Revision E

PB 01 E APS 031 001

11

Elementary Wiring Diagram

4160 Switchgear Cubicle 60

Emergency Generator Breaker 1A52-60

PBNP Unit 1

Revision E

PB 01 E APS 031 002

05

Elementary Wiring Diagram

Alternative Power to 1A-05 from G02 EDG

Breaker 1A52-66

PBNP Unit 1

Revision E

PB 01 E RPS 141

078 18

Schematic Diagram

SI Logic Engineered Safety Features

(ESF) Systems Train A

Reactor Safeguards Systems

PBNP Unit 1

Revision E

SK-M-21-2

Refueling Water Storage Tank - 1-T13,

2-T13

Revision 0

PB 01 MSIG 246 001

05

1-T13 RWST Assembly And Details

Revision E

Action Request (AR)

AR ACE000251

Tag Series Changes And Loss Of

Awareness Of Clearance Status

October 22, 2001

AR ACE000260

G-04 Low Oil Level

October 30, 2001

AR ACE000294

Resistance Readings May Be Affected By

Nomex Wear

November 14, 2001

AR ACE000299

IP-29 Turbine-Driven Auxiliary Feedwater

Pump Spurious Overspeed Trips

November 20, 2001

AR ACE000321

Wrong Oil Used In Auxiliary Feedwater

Turbine Bearings

December 11, 2001

AR ACE000325

Unanticipated Outward Rod Motion

December 13, 2001

AR ACE000327

Component Cooling Water Pump Oil

Sample Results

December 17, 2001

22

AR ACE000496

Plant Electrical Equipment May Be Used in

Applications Beyond Fault Ratings

April 1, 1993

AR ACE000497

4160V and 480V System Operating

Voltages Are Significantly Higher Than the

Nominal System Voltages

December 3, 1997

AR ACE000498

Operating the 480V System at Voltage

Magnitudes Higher Than 500V Causes

Equipment to be Derated From Ratings at

480V to Ratings at 600V for Fault Current

December 3, 1997

AR ACE000499

System Model Should be Revised With

Plant Operations to Determine More

Realistic Equipment Alignments

December 3, 1997

AR ACE000500

Additional Scenarios Should be Analyzed

and Existing Scenarios Should be Revised

to More Accurately Reflect How PBNP is

Operated

December 3, 1997

AR ACE000526

Missed Surveillance For PAM Core Exit

T/Cs

December 14, 2001

AR CA001184

Extent of Condition Review of Other

SPEEDs

March 15, 2001

AR CA001193

Reinforce Managements Expectations That

Requirements of Administrative Procedures

Are to be Complied With

July 3, 2001

AR CA001461

Bus And Breaker Short Circuit Rating

Discrepancies

April 30, 2001

AR CA001634

Dilution of Accountability for Programs for

Vendor Technical Information Program and

Component Instruction Manual

June 5, 2001

AR CA003148

Revise NP 9.3.3

November 25, 1997

AR CA003235

Review the Calculations for Each Breaker or

Other Piece of Switchgear That is

Calculated to be Overloaded

March 16, 1994

AR CA003236

Write and Submit an LER for Condition of

Plant Electrical Equipment May Be Used in

Applications Beyond Fault Ratings

July 10, 1997

23

AR CA003237

Complete a Revision to the Operability

Determination to Address: Equipment

Removed From the List, Equipment Which

May Experience Fault Currents of Higher

Magnitude, and Equipment Added to the

List Attached to the New Fault Duty

Calculation

December 3, 1997

AR CA003238

The SSC in the Operability Determination

for This CR [93-137] Have Been Determined

to be Operable, But Degraded

March 26, 1998

AR CA003239

Document That the Operability

Determination to Supported Bolted Shorts

as Described in CR 93-137 Reflects Most

Recent Review

September 11, 2000

AR CA003240

Finalize and Issue the New Preliminary

Short Circuit Calculations Based on

Procedure Changes to be Completed Per

CR 00-0094

September 11, 2000

AR CA003242

Request a Schedule and Justification be

Provided for Which One of the Four Options

That Are Being Considered as Possible

Solutions to the Bolted Fault Issue

August 14, 2001

AR CA003518

NRC 50.59 Inspection Requested A

Procedural Tie Be Created In IT-21 And

IT-22, Back To TRM Section 3.5.1

January 16, 2002

AR CA002130

Potential Adverse Trend in Q List Program

September 13, 2001

AR CAP000126

Short Circuit Fault Current Calculations

January 7, 2000

AR CAP000726

Corrective Actions For CR 00-1812 Do Not

Address Concern

May 24, 2001

AR CAP001532

Plant Electrical Equipment May Be Used in

Applications Beyond Fault Rating

March 30, 1993

AR CAP001877

FSAR Discrepancy On Definition Of Reg

Guide Category 2

January 16, 2002

AR CAP001886

Incomplete 50.59 Screening Answer For

Changes To Relief Valve CC-736A/B

January 16, 2002

AR CAP001897

Letdown Isolation Valve Appendix R

Operation During Degraded Voltage

Conditions

January 17, 2002

AR CAP001900

Incomplete Corrective Actions Regarding

Classification Of RC-427

January 17, 2002

24

AR CAP001901

FSAR Chapter 9 Changes For CFC Service

Water Pressure Not Also Made In Chapter 6

January 17, 2002

AR CAP001910

Safety Evaluation 2000-0014 Incomplete

January 17, 2002

AR CAP001915

Questioning Corrective Action For

CR 00-2859 On Screening Procedure Temp

Change

January 18, 2002

AR CAP001916

Incorrect Answer To Tech Spec Change

Question In 50.59 Evaluation

January 18, 2002

AR CAP001957

Individual Requested To Do Work Not

Qualified Or Trained To Do

January 24, 2002

AR CAP001962

WO For SR Equipment Bypassed QC

Review

January 24, 2002

AR CAP001965

SW Pumps Discharge Expansion Joints

Have Surface Cracks

January 25, 2002

AR CAP001966

Outdated Procedures For New PPCS, With

No New Procedures In Place

January 25, 2002

AR CAP001970

Poor Loading Of E-12 (SO4B2) Work Week

January 25, 2002

AR CAP001979

Minor Deficiencies In The Corrective Action

Program

January 25, 2002

AR CAP001984

Negative Trend Of Security Self Reporting

Issues In Corrective Action System

January 25, 2002

AR CAP001985

NRC Commitment To Inspection Unit 2

Internals Lift Rig Not Met

January 25, 2002

AR CAP001992

NUTRK Database Is Inaccurate

And Cluttered With Outdated Action

Requests

January 28, 2002

AR CAP001996

Lack Of Documentation Of Adverse Issues

January 28, 2002

AR CAP002031

NP5.3.1 Does Not Allow Closure Of ARs To

Other Formal Tracking Mechanisms

January 30, 2002

AR CAP002038

Questionable Acceptable Voltage Ranges

For Instrument Buses

January 31, 2002

AR CAP002039

Vibration Indications On G-01

January 31, 2002

AR CAP002065

CAP Closed Without All Corrective Actions

Completed

February 4, 2002

AR CAP002083

P-032D Service Water Pump Vibration And

Shaft Wear Resolution

February 5, 2002

25

AR CAP002264

Untimely Implementation of

Recommendations From IN 88-023-05

February 21, 2002

Lists

List of Apparent Cause Evaluations - 2001

2001

List of Completed Root Cause Evaluations -

2001

2001

List of Temporary Modifications - 2001

January 3, 2002

Root Cause Evaluations (RCEs)98-190

Inappropriate Design Pressure For The AFW

[Auxiliary Feedwater] Discharge Valve

Modification

Revision 1

98-214

Disabled Service Water Pump Auto Start

Feature On EDG [Emergency Diesel

Generator] Breaker Closure Results in

Missed LCO

November 30, 2001

00-104

Common Cause Assessment for Procedure

Quality Issues

March 2, 2001

01-013

Speed For P-32C Service Water Pump

Motor

01-013

Replacement Service Water Pump Motor

Does Not Meet Design Requirements

June 8, 2001

01-033

Maintenance Rule Component Common

Cause

May 8, 2001

01-046

Unit 1 Loss Of Inverter

July 18, 2001

01-047

Unit 1 Main Feed Pump Inboard Bearing

Failure

July 19, 2001

01-0151

G04 Generator Failure Equipment Rood

Cause

August 5, 2001

01-052

Failure To Perform TS Required EDG

Testing

August 9, 2001

01-055

Reactor Coolant Pump Seal Malfunction

Caused Unit Shutdown

September 6, 2001

26

Nuclear Plant Memorandum (NPM)

2002-0006

Minutes From The December 19, 2001

CARB Meeting

January 4, 2002

2002-0052

Third Quarter 2001 Corrective Action

Program Trends

January 28, 2002

2002-0056

CARB Agenda For The February 5, 2002

Meeting

February 1, 2002

Work Orders

9924742

Temporary Relocate 1LT-972/1LI-921 to

Allow for Installation of Welds and

Anchorage on RWST, Then Return to

Original Locations

April 14, 2001

9937026

Transmitter Enclosure is Damaged,

Condition Report Submitted

April 2, 2001

9945054

IT-013 Repair Weld

July 24, 2001

9945202

IT-13 Clean Residue/Insp 2 Day Later

July 19, 2001

Plant Modifications

MR-99-040

Unit 1 RWST Seismic Upgrade

July 12, 2000

Engineering Work Request (EWR)02-019

Protective Enclosure for Sightglass/Oiler

Assemblies

January 25, 2002

Nuclear Power Business Unit Procedures (NPs)

5.3.1

Action Request Process

Revision 19

5.3.7

Operability Determinations

Revision 8

5.4.1

Open Item Tracking System (NUTRK)

Revision 11

9.3.3

Spare Parts Equivalency Evaluation [SPEED]

Revisions 2 and 3

9.8.1

Specification Preparation, review, and

Approval Process

Revision 0

27

9.8.2

Technical Review and Approval of

Requisitions

Revisions 0 and 1

9.8.4

Safety Classification of Sub-Components

and Materials

Revision 0

9.8.5

Dedication of Commercial Grade Items

Revisions 0 and 1

9.8.6

Conditional Release of QA-related Items and

Services

Revision 0

9.8.9

Product Technical Information

Revision 0

9.9.2

Quality Receipt

Revision 0

9.9.3

Spare Parts Equivalency Evaluation [SPEED]

Revisions 2 and 3

9.10.1

Warehouse Material Issue

Revision 0

10.2.4

Work Order Processing

Revision 7

Other Procedures and Documents

AM (Administrative

Manual) 3-4

Implementation of the Maintenance Rule at

PBNP

Revision 4

A-P-01-17

Improved Technical Specifications Audit

October 5, 2001

A-P-01-018

Maintenance Rule Audit

August 28, 2001

FP-NO-SQ-01

Performance of Supplier Audits/Surveys

Revision 1

FP-SC-GEN-01

Procurement - General

Revision 1

FP-SC-RSI-01

Receiving

Revision 0

FP-SC-RSI-02

Quality Receipt

Revision 0

FP-SC-RSI-03

Procurement Deficiency Reports

Revision 0

Licensee Event

Report 97-032

Inadequately Rated Electrical Buses Could

Disable Switchgear and Cause Secondary

Fires That Prevent Safe Shutdown Per

Appendix R

July 30, 1997

OEG (OE Group

Guide) 001

Root Cause Evaluation

Revision 6

OEG 003

Corrective Action Program Guidance

Revision 2

PBF (Point Beach

Form)-0026q

Procedure Preparer/Technical Reviewer

Checklist

Revision 4

PBF-0026r

Procedure Validation

Revision 1

28

PBF-1531

Conditional Release Request

Revision 2

PBF-1583

Design Verification Notice

Revision 1

PBF-1586b

CI Manual Distribution

S-A-CA-01-01

Assessment of Point Beach Corrective

Action Program

February 2001

Spare Parts

Equivalency

Evaluation Document

2002-006

Replace Obsolete Westinghouse Motor With

Equivalent Marathon Electric Motor

February 8, 2002

Nuclear Oversight Quarterly Reports

1st, 2nd, and 3rd

Quarters, 2001

Corrective Action Program Performance

Indicators

October, November,

December 2001;

January 2002

Bolted Fault Meeting Minutes

January 21, 2002

Project Work Plan: Bolted AC Fault Issue

Revision 3

August 28, 2000

AC Bolted Fault Project History and Timeline

2001

Electrical Fault Overduty Resolution Plan

Updates

May and November

2001; February

2002

SI Pump Gas Binding Event Operating

Experience Review

February 23, 2002

Corrective Action Trend Reports

1st, 2nd, and 3rd

Quarters, 2001

Corrective Action Review Board Member

Attendance Records

Chemistry Logs

Unit 1 RWST Chemical Analyses

February 5, 2002

NUTRK Operating

Experience Review

NRC Information Notice 88-023, Potential

for Gas Binding of High Pressure Safety

Injection Pumps During a Loss-of-Coolant

Accident, Original Notice and 5

Supplements

May 12, 1988

January 5, 1989

January 30, 1990

December 10, 1990

December 18, 1992

September 1, 1999

NUTRK Operating

Experience Review

NRC Information Notice 97-040, Potential

Nitrogen Accumulation Resulting From

Backleakage From Safety Injection Tanks

June 26, 1997

29

NUTRK Operating

Experience Review

SOER 97-01, Potential Loss of High

Pressure Injection and Charging Capability

From Gas Intrusion

December 6, 1997

NUTRK Operating

Experience Review

SEN 179, Long-Standing Design

Weaknesses and Ineffective Corrective

Actions Cause Gas Binding Failures of High

Head Safety Injection Pumps

January 29, 1998

NUTRK Operating

Experience Review

OE 8830, Potential Nitrogen Voiding and

Water Hammer in the Low Pressure Safety

Injection System

March 26, 1998

NUTRK Operating

Experience Review

OE 9876, 4B HHSI Pump Gas Binding

May 4, 1999

Plant Internal Letter

NEPB-88-252

NRC Information Notice No. 88-23: Potential

For Gas Binding of High-Pressure Safety

Injection Pumps During A Loss-of-Coolant

Accident

June 7, 1988

Plant Internal Letter

NEM-89-143

NRC Information Notice No. 88-23,

Supplement 1: Potential For Gas Binding of

High-Pressure Safety Injection Pumps

During Loss-of-Coolant Accident

March 6, 1989

Plant Internal Letter

NEM-90-368

NRC Information Notice No. 88-23

Supplement 2: Potential For Gas Binding of

High-Pressure Safety Injection Pumps

During A Loss-of-Coolant Accident

April 23, 1990

Plant Internal Letter

NPM 91-0400

NRC Information Notice No. 88-23,

Supplement 3: Potential For Gas Binding of

High-Pressure Injection Pumps During A

Loss-of-Coolant Accident

June 18, 1991

Plant Internal Letter

NPM 93-0092

NRC Information Notice No. 88-23,

Supplement 4: Potential For Gas Binding of

High-Pressure Safety Injection Pumps

During A Design Basis Accident

February 5, 1993

30

DOCUMENTS REQUESTED FROM THE LICENSEE PRIOR TO ONSITE INSPECTION

Two copies of administrative procedures related to:

corrective action program

work orders

operability determinations

temporary modifications

root cause analysis

procedure change, use, and adherence

One copy of audits and self-assessments conducted since January 1, 2001, in the following

areas:

corrective action process

maintenance/work control

operations

engineering

One copy of minutes for onsite and offsite committee meetings, including the Corrective Actions

Review Board, conducted since January 1, 2001

Two copies of a listing of:

root cause evaluations completed since January 1, 2001

CRs generated since January 1, 2001, related to corrective actions

work orders and CRs generated since January 1, 2001, related to the service

water, safety injection, and the 4160-volt systems

temporary modifications

operability determinations