ML060860078

Attachment 3 Calculation PTN-BFJR-06-001 Phase 3 SDP for Turkey Point B AFW Pump Failure

ML060860078
Person / Time
Site:	Turkey Point
Issue date:	03/13/2006
From:	Florida Power & Light Co
To:	Document Control Desk, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
PTN-BFJR-06-001
Download: ML060860078 (31)

Text

L-2006-066 ATTACHMENT 3 CALCULATION PTN-BFJR-06-001 PHASE 3 SDP FOR TURKEY POINT "B" AFW PUMP FAILURE 5

Page 1 of 30 CALCULATION COVER SHEET Calculation No:

PTN-BFJR-06-001

Title:

PHASE 3 SDP FOR TURKEY POINT B AFW PUMP FAILURE A

0 INITIAL ISSUE

-ae 1 7,6WLg~

2#

N.

Descriptlon BY 7 Date _'dhk/Ver I fe atelDate REVISIONS PTN-BFJR-06--01 Rev 0 PTN AFWP B SDP Calc.doc

PTN-BFJR-06-001 Rev. 0 Page 2 of 30 LIST OF EFFECTIVE PAGES Calculation No:

PTN-BFJR-06-001 REV. 0

Title:

PHASE 3 SDP FOR TURKEY POINT B AFW PUMP FAILURE.

PAGE SECTION REV PAGE SECTION REV PAGE SECTION REV 1

COVER SHEET 0

2 LIST OF EF PG 0

3 TABLE OF CONTS 0

4 1.0 0

4 2.0 0

° 4

3.0 0

5 4.0 0

7 5.0 0

15 6.0 0

15 7.0 0

18 0

23 25 0

28 0

29 0

30 0

PTN-BFJR-06-031 Rev 0 PTN AFWP B SDP CalcFinal.doc

PTN-BFJR-06-001 Rev. 0 Page 3 of 30 TABLE OF CONTENTS Calculation No:

PTN-BFJR-06-001 REV. 0 ORMI mm 1.0 PURPOSE/SCOPE.....................

4

2.0 REFERENCES

4 3.0 METHODOLOGY.....................

4 4.0 ASSUMPTIONSIBASES.....................

5 5.0 CALCULATION.......................

7 6.0 CALCULATIONAL FILES....................

is 7.0 RESULTS 15 ATTACHMENT 1: SENSITIVITY CASE, USING MSPI DATA, WITH AFW B FAILURE TO RUN SET TO 1.0.....................

18 ATTACHME:NT 2, SENSITIVITY STUDY: BASE CASE, USING MSPI DATA, NOMINAL AFW B FAILURE TO RUN...........

23 ATTACHMENT 3: CLARIFICATION OF LOSS OF DC 3A OPERATOR RECOVERY ACTION............. 25 ATTACHMENT 4:

SUMMARY

OF TURKEY POINT PLANT RESPONSE TO LOSS OF AFW 1 HOUR AFTER A LOSS OF FEEDWATER..........................................................................

28 ATTACHMENT 5:

SUMMARY

OF NRC PHASE 3 SDP RESULTS....................................................... 29 ATTACHMENT 6: SPAR-H PERFORMANCE SHAPING FACTORS FOR EXECUTION....................... 30 LIST OF TABLES i

MMEMM Table (1): AFW Pump B Surveillance Data.

5 Table (2): Top 10 cutsets from SPAR Model for LODC3A.

9 Table (3): List of Key HEPs and Performance shaping Factors.

10 Table (4): Top 10 cutsets from SPAR Model for LOCHS.

11 Table (5): Top 10 cutsets from SPAR Model for LOMFW.

13 Table (6): Best Estimate Delta CDF.

16 Table (7): Summary of Delta CDF Sensitivity Study.

16 PTN-BFJR-06-001 Rev 0 PTN AFWP B SDP CaicFinal.doc

PTN-BFJR-6001 Rev. 0 Page 4 of 30 1.0 PURPOSEISCOPE This calculation documents the methodology and input used to support a response to the NRC phase 3 SDP (Ref. 1) associated with B AFW pump failure identified in a test run on November 7, 2005. During IST testing 11/7/05, the B AFW pump P28 exhibited high vibration and temperatures at the inboard journal bearing location inspection point (Reference 4). The reading was documented as 0.8 in/sec. On 11/8/05 the AFW pump was disassembled for inspection. The initial inspection included disassembling the coupling and pump inboard bearing. The results of this inspection found signs of uneven tooth wear on the pump coupling and evidence of grease caking.

Inspection of the inboard journal bearing found that the bearing was installed incorrectly. The bearing was installed 90 degrees from its correct orientation. This incorrect installation resulted in inadequate lubrication to the bearing and caused flaking of the sleeve bearing babbit.

2.0 REFERENCES

1. Turkey Point Nuclear Plant Integrated Inspection Report, 05000250/2005005 and 05000251/2005005 Preliminary White Finding, ; January 27, 2005.

2. NURG/CR-6883, The SPAR-H Human Reliability Analysis Method, 8/2005.

3. Emails from Glen Blinde 12/28/2005, Re: PTN AFW SDP issue success criteria need; 2/16/2006, Re: Questions on 858 & AFW MAAP runs.

4. CR 2005-30750 (High Vibrations on the P28 AFW Pump - Extent of Condition).

5. NEI-99-02 Appendix F, "Methodologies for Computing The Unavailability Index, The Unreliability Index and Component Performance Limits", Revision 4.

6. PTN Change Form PTN-C-06-001, February, 2006.

7. PTN-BFJR-00-001, "PTN PSA Model Update," FPL-RRAG, Revision 5, 6/24/04.

8. SPAR Model for Turkey Point Units 3 and 4, August 2005, version 9/30/2005.

3.0 METHODOLOGY Because the degradation of B AFW pump is time-dependent, its safety significance is assessed by including the following factors:

1. Based on the test data and operating experience of the B AFW pump,.the B AFW pump woL Id run at least one hour on or before October 30, 2005. Afterwards, the performance of B AFW pump is not determined, and is conservatively assumed to fail within the first hour.

2. If B AFW pump runs for an hour and then fails, the decay heat is significantly lower, allowing more time for operators to take actions stipulated in the EOP.

3. The lower decay heat after one hour from hypothetical accidents also allows a less stringent success criterion for feed and bleed.

4. Credit for operator actions (e.g., certain offsite power recovery actions) not included in the orig'nal baseline PSA model, which were not important due to lower probability of the sequences, should be included for consistency.

PTN-BFJR-06-CO1 Rev 0 PTN AFWP B SDP CalcFinal.doc

PTN-BFJR-M001 Rev. 0 Page 5 of 30

5. Usirg a mission time of 24 hours2.777778e-4 days <br />0.00667 hours <br />3.968254e-5 weeks <br />9.132e-6 months <br /> for 3 AFW pumps and 2 standby steam generator feed pumps overestimates the probability of selected sequences.

The approach used in the Phase 3 SDP is to review the SPAR model (Reference 8), the Turkey Point PSA model (Reference 7), MSPI data base and insights obtained from the sensitivity studies to develop a scoping estimate of the risk impact.

4.0 ASSUMPTIONS/BASES

1. SPAR-H for Human Error Probability estimates are used for revising the HEPs for cases in which B AFW pump fails after 1 hour1.157407e-5 days <br />2.777778e-4 hours <br />1.653439e-6 weeks <br />3.805e-7 months <br />.

2. Run times for B AFW pump collected from AFW system engineer indicate that the AFW pump was capable of running for more than one hour (see run time for 10/10/05). The pump capability (residual runtime) given a demand would be increasingly longer looking back in time due to the progressively less wear when pump experienced fewer run hours. This is indicated in the table below per email from Joe Laduca 12/31/2005.

Table (1): AFW Pump B Surveillance Data.

l Surveillance Runs plus Rx Reason (Procedure or Date Trips(hours)

Trip)

Residual runtime 1/3/2003 0.7 4-OSP-075.9 54.83 1/6/2003 1.3 4-OSP-075.2 54.13 C/6/2003 0.5 4-OSP-075.9 52.83 G/7/2003 1.75 4-OSP-075.2 52.33 1/8/2003 3.5 4-OSP-075.7 50.58 1/9/2003 1.5 3-OSP-075.2 47.08 9/10/2003 0.6 4-OSP-075.2 45.58 9/12/2003 0.5 4-OSP-075.9 44.98 10/13/2003 0.6 3-OSP-075.2 44.48 11/4/2003 0.5 4-OSP-075.7 43.88 11/10/2003 1.5 3-OSP-075.7 43.38 12/8/2003 0.6 3-OSP-075.2 41.88 12/9/2003 0.8 4-OSP-075.7 41.28 1/5/2004 0.9 3-OSP-075.2 40.48 1/5/2004 0.4 4-OSP-075.2 39.58 1/30/2004 1

3-OSP-075.7 39.18 2/2/2004 0.6 4-OSP-075.2 38.18 3/2/2004 0.5 3-OSP-075.2 37.58 3/4/2004 1.7 4-OSP-075.7 37.08 3/29/2004 1.1 4-OSP-075.2 35.38 3/29/2004 0.25 3-OSP-075.2 34.28 4/26/2004 1.1 3-OSP-075.7 34.03 5/14/2004 2.75 RxrTdpAFWAutoInitiation 32.93 PTN-BFJR-06-001 Rev 0 PTN AFWP B SDP CalcFinal.doc

PTN-BFJR-06-001 Rev. 0 Page 6 of 30 Table (1M: AFW Pumn B Surveillance Data.

Surveillance Runs plus Rx Reason (Procedure or Date Trips(hours)

Trip)

Residual runtime 5/24/2004 0.5 3-OSP-075.2 30.18 6/21/2004 0.5 3-OSP-075.2 29.68 6/21/2004 0.9 4-OSP-075.2 29.18 7/19/2004 1.7 3-OSP-075.7 28.28 7/20/2004 0.5 4-OSP-075.2 26.58 8/16/2004 0.4 3-OSP-075.2 26.08 9/13/2004 0.25 3-OSP-075.2 25.68 9/13/2004 0.5 4-OSP-075.2 25.43 10/11/2004 0.4 4-OSP-075.2 24.93

_11/8/2004 0.9 4-OSP-075.2 24.53 11/12/2004 1.4 4-OSP-075.7 23.63 1211/2004 1.2 3-OSP-75.7 22.23 1 26/2004 1

4-OSP-075.2 21.03 12/14/2004 1.8 Rxr Trip AFW Auto Initiation 20.03 12/25/2004 1.1 RxrTrip.AFW Auto Initiation 18.23 12/28/2004 0.9 RxrTripAFW Auto Initiation 17.13 1/10/2005 0.9 4-OSP-075.2 16.23 1/31/2005 1.33 4-OSP-075.7 15.33 2/24/2005 1.05 4-OSP-075.2 14.00 2/28/2005 0.43 4-OSP-075.2 12.95 2/28/2005 0.52 3-OSP-075.2.

12.52 2/28/2005 0.5 3-OSP-075.9 12.00 3/22/2005 0.5 3-OSP-075.2 11.50 3/22/2005 1.5 Rxr.Trp AFW Auto Initiation 11.00 4/.25/2005 0.4 3-OSP-075.2 9.50 5/6/2005 0.3 3-OSP-075.2 9.10 5/23/2005 0.5 3-OSP-075.2 8.80 5/27/2005 0.2

.3-OSP-075.2 8.30 6/25/2005 0.5 4-OSP-075.2 8.10 6/25/2005 0.6 3-OSP-075.7 7.60 6/27/2005 0.9 Rxr Trip AFW Auto Initiation 7.00 7/18/2005

. 1 4-OSP-075.7 6.1 7/20/2005 0.5 3-OSP-075.2 5.1 8/15/2005 0.5 4-OSP-075.2 4.6 9/12/2005 0.3 4-OSP-075.2 4.1 10/10/2005 0.4 3-OSP-075.2 3.8 10/10/2005 2.1 4-OSP-075.7 3.4 10/31/2005 0.6 Rxr Trip AFW Auto Initiation 1.3

_._November 7 ran 0.7 hours8.101852e-5 days <br />0.00194 hours <br />1.157407e-5 weeks <br />2.6635e-6 months <br />

3. As a sensitivity study, the MSPI industry. reliability data as a new generic prior and the SPAR model failure data were used for AFW pumps failure to start and run.

PTN-BFJR-06-031 Rev 0 PTN AFWP B SDP CalcFinal.doc

PTN-BFJR-06-001 Rev. O Page 7 of 30 5.0 CALCULATION Based on the test data and operating experience of the B AFW pump,.the B AFW pump would run at least one hour at normal failure rate (thus for the first hour given any hypothetical accidents, there is no Delta CDF increase) on or before October 31, 2005. Afterwards, the performance of B AFW pump is not determined, and is conservatively assumed to fail.

The risk impact of degraded B AFW pump is composed of two time windows, each with a different risk increase.

Time Window 1:

Before October 30, 2005, B AFW pump Is assumed to fall one hour or longer after automatic actuation

1. If B AFW pump runs for an hour and then fails, the decay heat is significantly lower, allowing more time for operators to take actions stipulated in the EOP.

A scoping MAAP run and an analysis based on decay heat equation indicated that at least an additional hour would be available for execution (Reference 7). The Human Error Probabilities, based on the SPAR-H, for the performance shaping factor "Available Time",

are adjusted from "just enough" to "nominal" due to much longer time and potentially less stress. Thus HEPs (see Attachment 6, which is excerpted from Reference 2) would be reduced by a factor of 10 or more.

2. The lower decay heat after one hour from hypothetical accidents also allows a less stringent success criterion for bleed and feed. Instead of 2 PORVs for bleed, either PORV opening is sufficient for the successful operation of bleed and feed. (see Attachment 4, which is excerpted from Reference 3, second and third cases)

This reduces the contribution of the dominant sequences LDC3A, by a factor of 10 or more.

The above factors are included in the Turkey Point SPAR model to estimate the delta CDF for the case where B AFW pump would fail after one hour of operation. Delta CDF is estimated to be approximately 3.2E-7 (a factor of 10 reduction from 3.2E-6NYr).

Time Window 2:

After October31, 2005, B AFW pump Is assumed to fall witin one hour of automatic actuation.

A review of the cutsets for loss of DC bus; indicates that if AFW fails within the first hour, those cutsets involving the stopping of the C pump are not valid, as the condition for it being failed due to deadheading is eliminated by B pump failing. The CDF is conservatively assumed to be 1.6 E-6/r (3.2E-6NYr, subtracted by 1.6E-6/Yr, a scoping elimination of the top cutest of loss of DC bus).

The core damage frequency increase due to the degraded B AFW pump over a year is estimated to be:

PTN-BFJR-0r6-O01 Rev 0 PTN AFWP B SDP CalcFinal.doc

PTN-BFJR-0OO1 Rev. 0 Page 8 of 30 1.6E-6/Yr

• 1/12 + 3.2E-7/Yr

• 11/12 = 4.3E-7/Yr, which is less than 1.OE-6/Yr. The Delta CDF increase is considered not risk significant.

There is still some margin in the estimated safety significance from the threshold of 1.OE-6/Yr, even if it is conservatively assumed that risk impact of the B AFW pump due to external events is as high as that due to internal events.

Other mitigating factors that may reduce the risk impact include:

1. Unit 3 and Unit 4 were shutdown to Mode 3 on October 24 because of grid instabilities due to Hurricane Wilma. Unit 3 was returned to full power operation on November 2. Unit 4 remained shutdown due to secondary chemistry problems. On October 31, the switchyard insulator salting caused loss of Unit 4 startup transformer and on November 1, the unit was placed in Mode 5. Following restoration of offsite power and resolution of chemistry problems, the unit was restarted on November 12 and returned to full power operation on November 14.

2. Using a mission time of 24 hours2.777778e-4 days <br />0.00667 hours <br />3.968254e-5 weeks <br />9.132e-6 months <br /> for 3 AFW pumps and 2 standby steam generator feed pumps overestimates the probability of selected sequences.

3. Manual actions stipulated in the plant procedures to recover failure of AFW pumps were not credited in the original baseline PSA model should be included to be consistent with NRC's SPAR model

4. The delta CDF for the time windows where B AFW pump was degraded, but could have run for longer than one hour, is lower than that for which B AFW pump was assumed to run for just one hour.

SAPHIRE,' and the latest Turkey Point model were used to understand the three dominant sequences contributing to the phase 3 SDP summarized in the NRC inspection report. The SPAR model was modified by incorporating the key modeling assumptions related to using SSGFW pump, with slightly higher delta CDF than that estimated in Reference 2 (see Attachment 5)

Mitigating factor 1: For the case of B AFW pump failing within the first hour, the operator action to stop the weaker pump is not applicable, as the B AFW pump would fail before the deadheading of the weaker [pump becomes an issue.

For the case when B AFW pump fails after running for one hour or more, the probability of dominant cutsets can be reduced by a factor of 10 or more, because:

1. The success criterion for feed and bleed is relaxed from two PORVs to one PORV.

2. Recovery action to locally use AFW train A given loss of DC bus A is proceduralized and credited in the Turkey Point PSA model, with failure probability of 0.11 including the hardWare failure.

PTN-BFJR-06-G)1 Rev 0 PTN AFWVP B SDP CalcFinal.doc

PTN-BFJR--001 Rev. 0 Page 9 of 30 Table (2): Top 10 cutsets from SPAR Model for LODC3A.

Cut

%Cut No.

% Total Set ProbJFrequency Basic Event Description Event Prob.

1 93.79 93.79 1.750E-006 IE-LODC3A LOSS OF DC BUS 3A 2.500E-003 AFW-TDPC-AFW TDP-C WEAKER OF 5.000E-001 WEAKER THE TWO TRAIN 2 PUMPS (PSA)

AFW-XHE-XM-OPERATOR FAILS TO TRIP 1.400E-003 TRIP1 AFW PUMP MFW-XHE-XL-OPERATOR FAILS TO 1.000E+000 TRIP RECOVER MFW 2

95.67 1.88 3.500E-008 IE-LODC3A LOSS OF DC BUS 3A 2.500E-003 AFW-TDP-FS-C AFW TDP C FAILS TO 7.OOOE-003 START MFW-XHE-XL-OPERATOR FAILS TO 2.000E-003 RESTORE RESTORE MFW (LODC3A-PSA) 3 97.01 1.34 2.500E-008 IE-LODC3A LOSS OF DC BUS 3A 2.500E-003 AFW-TDP-TM-C AFW TDP C UNAVAILABLE 5.000E-003 DUE TO TEST AND MAINTENANCE MFW-XHE-XL-OPERATOR FAILS TO 2.000E-003 RESTORE RESTORE MFW (LODC3A -

PSA) 4 98.25 1.24 2.305E-008 IE-LODC3A LOSS OF DC BUS 3A 2.500E-003 AFW-TDP-CF-COMMON CAUSE FAILURE 4.610E-003 FRBC OF TDP B & C TO RUN MFW-XHE-XL-OPERATOR FAILS TO 2.000E-003 RESTORE RESTORE MFW (LODC3A -

PSA) 5 98.97 0.72 1.348E-008 IE-LODC3A LOSS OF DC BUS 3A 2.500E-003 AFW-TDP-CF-COMMON CAUSE FAILURE 2.696E-003 FRALL OF TURBINE DRIVEN PUMPS TO RUN MFW-XHE-XL-OPERATOR FAILS TO 2.000E-003 RESTORE RESTORE MFW (LODC3A -

PSA) 6 99.13 0.16 2.951E-009 IE-LODC3A LOSS OF DC BUS 3A 2.500E-003 AFW-TDP-FR-C AFW TDP C FAILS TO RUN 5.366E-003 AFW-XHE-XL-OPERATOR FAILS TO 1.100E-001 TDPA MANUALLY ALIGN TDP-A GIVEN LOSS OF DC-3A (PSA)

MFW-XHE-XL-OPERATOR FAILS TO 2.000E-003 RESTORE RESTORE MFW (LODC3A -

PSA) 7 99.26 0.13 2.500E-009 IE-LODC3A LOSS OF DC BUS 3A 2.500E-003 AFW-CKV-CC-FAILURE OF FLOW TO SG-1.000E-004 3012 3B THROUGH CHECK VALVE 3-012 AFW-XHE-XM-OPERATOR FAILS TO 1.OOOE-002 FLOW2 INCREASE AFW TRAIN 2 FLOW GIVEN ONE DISCH PATH FAILED PTN-BFJR-06-CO1 Rev 0 PTN AFWP B SDP CalcFinal.doc

PTN-BFJR-06-001 Rev. 0 Page 10 of 30 Table (2): Top 10 cutsets from SPAR Model for LODC3A.

Cut

-%Cut No.

% Total Set ProbiFrequency Basic Event Description Event Prob.

MFW-XHE-XL-OPERATOR FAILS TO 1.000E+000 TRIP RECOVER MFW 8

99.39 0.13 2.500E-009 IE-LODC3A LOSS OF DC BUS 3A 2.500E-003 AFW-CKV-CC-FAILURE OF FLOW TO SG-1.000E-004 3010 3A THROUGH CHECK VALVE 3-010 AFW-XHE-XM-OPERATOR FAILS TO 1.OOOE-002 FLOW2 INCREASE AFW TRAIN 2 FLOW GIVEN ONE DISCH PATH FAILED MFW-XHE-XL-OPERATOR FAILS TO 1.000E+000 TRIP RECOVER MFW 9

99.52 0.13 2.500E-009 IE-LODC3A LOSS OF DC BUS 3A 2.500E-003 AFW-CKV-CC-FAILURE OF FLOW TO SG-1.OOOE-004 3014 3C THROUGH CHECK VALVE 3-014 AFW-XHE-XM-OPERATOR FAILS TO 1.OOOE-002 FLOW2 INCREASE AFW TRAIN 2 FLOW GIVEN ONE DISCH PATH FAILED MFW-XHE-XL-OPERATOR FAILS TO 1.OOOE+000 TRIP RECOVER MFW 10 99.63 0.11 2.134E-009 IE-LODC3A LOSS OF DC BUS 3A 2.500E-003 AFW-TDP-TM-AFW TRAIN 2 3.880E-003 TRAIN2 UNAVAILABLE DUE TO TEST AND MAINTENANCE (PSA)

AFW-XHE-XL-OPERATOR FAILS TO 1.100E-001 TDPA MANUALLY ALIGN TDP-A GIVEN LOSS OF DC-3A (PSA)

MFW-XHE-XL-OPERATOR FAILS TO 2.OOOE-003 RESTORE RESTORE MFW (LODC3A -

PSA)

For the case when B AFW pump fails after running for one hour or more, the HEPs are reduced by a factor of 10 because available time is nominal (See Attachment 6, the basis of SPAR-H for execution).

Table (3): Ust of Key HEPs and Performance shaping Factors.

HRA Basic Event Event Description/Shaping Distribution Probability/

InitialUMultiplier Name Factor

• Type/PSF Percentage AFW-XHE-XMI-THRTL OPERATOR FAILS TO Constrained 1.OE-3 THROTTLE SG FCVs Noninformative Action is modeled.

1.0E-3 Available Time Nominal time 100%

1.00 Stress/Stressors Nominal 100%

1.00 Complexity Nominal 100%

1.00 Experience/Training Nominal 100%

1.00 Procedures Nominal 100%

1.00 Egonomics/HMI Nominal 100%

1.00 PTN-BFJR-06-CO1 Rev 0 PTN AFWP B SDP CalcFinal.doc

PTN-BFJR-06-001 Rev. 0 Page 11 of 30 Table (3): Ust of Key HEPs and Performance shaping Factors.

HRA Basic Event Event Description/Shaping Distribution Probability/

Initial/Multiplier Name Factor TypeIPSF Percentage Fitness for Duty Nominal 100%

1.00 Work Processes Nominal 100%

1.00.

Dependency is not modeled.

SFP-XHE-XIM--SSGFP OPERATOR FAILS TO Constrained START AND ALIGN Noninformative STANDBY SG PUMP TRAINS Action is modeled.

1.OE-3 Available Time Nominal time 100%

1.00 Stress/Stressors Nominal 100%

1.00 Complexity Nominal 100%

1.00 Experience/Training Nominal 100%

1.00 Procedures Nominal 100%

1.00 Egonomics/HMI Nominal 100%

1.00 Fitness for Duty Nominal 100%

1.00 Work Processes Nominal 100%

1.00 Dependency is not modeled.

HPI-XHE-XM-FB OPERATOR FAILS TO Constrained 2.OE-3 INITIATE FEED AND Noninformative BLEED COOLING Action is modeled.

1.OE-3 Available Time Nominal time 100%

1.00 Stress/Stressors High 100%

2.00 Complexity Nominal 100%

1.00 Experience/Training Nominal 100%

1.00 Procedures Nominal 100%

1.00 Egonomics/HMI Nominal 100%

1.00 Fitness for Duty Nominal 100%

1.00 Work Processes Nominal 100%

1.00 Dependency is not modeled.

Table (4): Top 10 cutsets from SPAR Model for LOCHS.

Cut

% Cut ProbJ No.

Totsil Set Frequency Basic Event Description Event Prob.

1 70.82 70.82 2.888E-007 IE-LOCHS LOSS OF CONDENSER HEAT SINK 9.000E-002 AFW-TDP-CF-COMMON CAUSE FAILURE OF 2.696E-003 FRALL TURBINE DRIVEN PUMPS TO RUN HPI-XHE-XM-FB OPERATOR FAILS TO INITIATE 2.OOOE-002 FEED AND BLEED COOLING SFP-XHE-XM-OPERATOR FAILS TO START AND 5.950E-002 SSGFP1 ALIGN STANDBY SG PUMP TRAINS (DE 2

73.80 2.98 1.213E-008 IE-LOCHS LOSS OF CONDENSER HEAT SINK 9.000E-002 AFW-TDP-CF-COMMON CAUSE FAILURE OF 2.696E-003 FRALL TURBINE DRIVEN PUMPS TO RUN PPR-SRV-CC-PORV 1 (PCV-456) FAILS TO OPEN 5.OOOE-003 456 ON DEMAND PTN-BFJR-06-031 Rev 0 PTN AFWP B SDP CalcFinal.doc

PTN-BFJR-06001 Rev. 0 Page 12 of 30 Table (4): To 10 cutsets from SPAR Model for LOCHS.

Cut

% Cut ProbJ No.

Totail Set Frequency Basic Event Description Event Prob.

SFP-XHE-XM-OPERATOR FAILS TO START AND 1.000E-002 SSGFP ALIGN STANDBY SG PUMP TRAINS 3

76.78 2.98 1.213E-008 IE-LOCHS LOSS OF CONDENSER HEAT SINK 9.000E-002 AFW-TDP-CF-COMMON CAUSE FAILURE OF 2.696E-003 FRALL TURBINE DRIVEN PUMPS TO RUN PPR-SRV-CC-PORV 2 (PCV-455C) FAILS TO 5.000E-003 455C OPEN ON DEMAND SFP-XHE-XM-OPERATOR FAILS TO START AND 1.OOOE-002 SSGFP ALIGN STANDBY SG PUMP TRAINS 4

78.07 1.29 5.248E-009 IE-LOCHS LOSS OF CONDENSER HEAT SINK 9.000E-002 AFW-TDP-FS-A AFW TDP A FAILS TO START 7.000E-003 AFW-TDP-FS-C AFW TDP C FAILS TO START 7.000E-003 HPI-XHE-XM-FB OPERATOR FAILS TO INITIATE 2.OOOE-002 FEED AND BLEED COOLING SFP-XHE-XM-OPERATOR FAILS TO START AND 5.950E-002 SSGFP1 ALIGN STANDBY SG PUMP TRAINS (DE 5

79.26 1.19 4.853E-009 IE-LOCHS LOSS OF CONDENSER HEAT SINK 9.OOOE-002 AFW-TDP-CF-COMMON CAUSE FAILURE OF 2.696E-003 FRALL TURBINE DRIVEN PUMPS TO RUN HPI-XHE-XM-FB OPERATOR FAILS TO INITIATE 2.OOOE-002 FEED AND BLEED COOLING SFP-MOV-CC-FAILURE OF SSGFP DISCHARGE 1.000E-003 3012 PATH VALVE 3-012 6

80.25 0.99 4.023E-009 IE-LOCHS LOSS OF CONDENSER HEAT SINK 9.000E-002 AFW-TDP-FR-A AFW TDP A FAILS TO RUN 5.366E-003 AFW-TDP-FS-C AFW TDP C FAILS TO START 7.OOOE-003 HPI-XHE-XM-FB OPERATOR FAILS TO INITIATE 2.OOOE-002 FEED AND BLEED COOLING SFP-XHE-XM-OPERATOR FAILS TO START AND 5.950E-002 SSGFP1 ALIGN STANDBY SG PUMP TRAINS (DE 7

81.24 0.99 4.023E-009 IE-LOCHS LOSS OF CONDENSER HEAT SINK 9.000E-002 AFW-TDP-FR-C AFW TDP C FAILS TO RUN 5.366E-003 AFW-TDP-FS-A AFW TDP A FAILS TO START 7.000E-003 HPI-XHE-XM-FB OPERATOR FAILS TO INITIATE 2.0002-002 FEED AND BLEED COOLING SFP-XHE-XM-OPERATOR FAILS TO START AND 5.950E-002 SSGFP1 ALIGN STANDBY SG PUMP TRAINS (DE 8

82.16 0.92 3.749E-009 IE-LOCHS LOSS OF CONDENSER HEAT SINK 9.OOOE-002 AFW-TDP-FS-A AFW TDP A FAILS TO START 7.000E-003 AFW-TDP-TM-C AFW TDP C UNAVAILABLE DUE 5.000E-003 TO TEST AND MAINTENANCE HPI-XHE-XM-FB OPERATOR FAILS TO INITIATE 2.OOOE-002 FEED AND BLEED COOLING SFP-XHE-XM-OPERATOR FAILS TO START AND 5.950E-002 SSGFP1 ALIGN STANDBY SG PUMP TRAINS (DE 8308 0.92 3.749E-009 IE-LOCHS LOSS OF CONDENSER HEAT SINK 9.000E-002 PTN-BFJR-06-001 Rev 0 PTN AFWP B SDP CalcFinal.doc

PTN-BFJR406-D01 Rev. 0 Page 13 of 30 CTable (4): Top 10 cutsets from SPAR Model for LOCHS.

Cut

°% Cut ProbJ No.

Totsil Set Frequency Basic Event Description Event Prob.

AFW-TDP-FS-C AFW TDP C FAILS TO START 7.000E-003 AFW-TDP-TM-A AFW TDP A UNAVAILABLE DUE 5.000E-003 TO TEST AND MAINTENANCE HPI-XHE-XM-FB OPERATOR FAILS TO INITIATE 2.000E-002 FEED AND BLEED COOLING SFP-XHE-XM-OPERATOR FAILS TO START AND 5.950E-002 SSGFP1 ALIGN STANDBY SG PUMP TRAINS (DE 10 83.93 0.85 3.456E-009 IE-LOCHS LOSS OF CONDENSER HEAT SINK 9.000E-002 AFW-TDP-CF-COMMON CAUSE FAILURE OF 4.610E-003 FRBC TDP B & C TO RUN AFW-TDP-FS-A AFW TDP A FAILS TO START 7.000E-003 HPI-XHE-XM-FB OPERATOR FAILS TO INITIATE 2.OOOE-002 FEED AND BLEED COOLING SFP-XHE-XM-OPERATOR FAILS TO START AND 5.950E-002 SSGFP1 ALIGN STANDBY SG PUMP TRAINS (DE For the case when B AFW pump fails after running for one hour or more, the HEPs are reduced by a factor Df 10 because available time is "nominal" instead of "just enough".

Table (5): Top 10 cutsets from SPAR Model for LOMFW.

Cut

% Cut ProbJ No.

Toti Set Frequency Basic Event Description Event Prob.

1 70.78 70.78 3.209E-007 IE-LOMFW LOSS OF MAIN FEEDWATER 1.000E-001 AFW-TDP-CF-COMMON CAUSE FAILURE OF 2.696E-003 FRALL TURBINE DRIVEN PUMPS TO RUN HPI-XHE-XM-FB OPERATOR FAILS TO INITIATE 2.OOOE-002 FEED AND BLEED COOLING MFW-XHE-XL-OPERATOR FAILS TO RECOVER 1.OOOE+000 MFWREC MFW SFP-XHE-XM-OPERATOR FAILS TO START AND 5.950E-002 SSGFPI ALIGN STANDBY SG PUMP TRAINS (DE 2

73.75 2.97 1.348E-008 IE-LOMFW LOSS OF MAIN FEEDWATER 1.OOOE-001 AFW-TDP-CF-COMMON CAUSE FAILURE OF 2.696E-003 FRALL TURBINE DRIVEN PUMPS TO RUN MFW-XHE-XL-OPERATOR FAILS TO RECOVER 1.000E+000 MFWREC MFW PPR-SRV-CC-PORV 1 (PCV-456) FAILS TO OPEN 5.000E-003 456 ON DEMAND SFP-XHE-XM-OPERATOR FAILS TO START AND 1.OOOE-002 SSGFP ALIGN STANDBY SG PUMP TRAINS 3

76.72 2.97 1.348E-008 IE-LOMFW LOSS OF MAIN FEEDWATER 1.OOOE-001 AFW-TDP-CF-COMMON CAUSE FAILURE OF 2.696E-003 FRALL TURBINE DRIVEN PUMPS TO RUN MFW-XHE-XL-OPERATOR FAILS TO RECOVER 1.000E+000 MFWREC MFW PPR-SRV-CC-PORV 2 (PCV-455C) FAILS TO 5.OOOE-003 455C OPEN ON DEMAND SFP-XHE-XM-OPERATOR FAILS TO START AND 1.OOOE-002 PTN-BFJR.06-CO1 Rev 0 PTN AFWP B SDP CalcFinal.doc

PTN-BFJR-6001 Rev.0 Page 14 of 30 Table (5): Top 10 cutsets from SPAR Model for LOMFW.

Cut

% Cut ProbJ No.

Totai Set Frequency Basic Event Description Event Prob.

SSGFP ALIGN STANDBY SG PUMP TRAINS 4

78.01 1.29 5.831E-009 IE-LOMFW LOSS OF MAIN FEEDWATER 1.000E-001

.AFW-TDP-FS-A AFW TDP A FAILS TO START 7.OOOE-003 AFW-TDP-FS-C AFW TDP C FAILS TO START 7.OOOE-003 HPI-XHE-XM-FB OPERATOR FAILS TO INITIATE 2.OOOE-002 FEED AND BLEED COOLING v

MFW-XHE-XL-OPERATOR FAILS TO RECOVER 1.OOOE+000 MFWREC MFW SFP-XHE-XM-OPERATOR FAILS TO START AND 5.950E-002 SSGFP1

. ALIGN STANDBY SG PUMP TRAINS (DE 5

79.20 1.19 5.392E-009 IE-LOMFW LOSS OF MAIN FEEDWATER 1.000E-001 AFW-TDP-CF-COMMON CAUSE FAILURE OF 2.696E-003 FRALL TURBINE DRIVEN PUMPS TO RUN HPI-XHE-XM-FB OPERATOR FAILS TO INITIATE 2.OOOE-002 FEED AND BLEED COOLING MFW-XHE-XL-OPERATOR FAILS TO RECOVER 1.OOOE+000 MFWREC MFW SFP-MOV-CC-FAILURE OF SSGFP DISCHARGE 1.000E-003 3012 PATH VALVE 3-012 6

80.19 0.99 4.470E-009 IE-LOMFW LOSS OF MAIN FEEDWATER 1.OOOE-001 AFW-TDP-FR-C AFW TDP C FAILS TO RUN 5.366E-003 AFW-TDP-FS-A AFW TDP A FAILS TO START 7.000E-003 HPI-XHE-XM-FB OPERATOR FAILS TO INITIATE 2.OOOE-002 FEED AND BLEED COOLING MFW-XHE-XL-OPERATOR FAILS TO RECOVER 1.OOOE+000 MFWREC MFW SFP-XHE-XM-OPERATOR FAILS TO START AND 5.950E-002 SSGFP1 ALIGN STANDBY SG PUMP TRAINS (DE 7

81.18 0.99 4.470E-009 IE-LOMFW LOSS OF MAIN FEEDWATER 1.000E-001 AFW-TDP-FR-A AFW TDP A FAILS TO RUN 5.366E-003 l AFW-TDP-FS-C AFW TDP C FAILS TO START 7.OOOE-003 HPI-XHE-XM-FB OPERATOR FAILS TO INITIATE 2.OOOE-002

.FEED AND BLEED COOLING MFW-XHE-XL-OPERATOR FAILS TO RECOVER 1.OOOE+000 MFWREC MFW SFP-XHE-XM-OPERATOR FAILS TO START AND 5.950E-002 SSGFP1 ALIGN STANDBY SG PUMP TRAINS (DE 8

82.1D.

0.92 4.165E-009 IE-LOMFW LOSS OF MAIN FEEDWATER 1.OOOE-001 AFW-TDP-FS-C AFW TDP C FAILS TO START 7.OOOE-003 AFW-TDP-TM-A AFW TDP A UNAVAILABLE DUE 5.000E-003 TO TEST AND MAINTENANCE HPI-XHE-XM-FB OPERATOR FAILS TO INITIATE 2.000E-002 FEED AND BLEED COOLING MFW-XHE-XL-OPERATOR FAILS TO RECOVER 1.OOOE+000 MFWREC MFW SFP-XHE-XM-OPERATOR FAILS TO START AND 5.950E-002 SSGFP1 ALIGN STANDBY SG PUMP TRAINS (DE PTN-BFJR-06-0)1 Rev 0 PTN AFWP B SDP CalcFinal.doc

PTN-BFJR-06-001 Rev. 0 Page 15 of 30 Table (5): Top 10 cutsets from SPAR Model for LOMFW.

Cut

% cut Probl No.

Total Set Frequency Basic Event Description Event Prob.

9 83.02 0.92 4.165E-009 IE-LOMFW LOSS OF MAIN FEEDWATER 1.000E-001 AFW-TDP-FS-A AFW TDP A FAILS TO START 7.000E-003 AFW-TDP-TM-C AFW TDP C UNAVAILABLE DUE 5.OOOE-003 TO TEST AND MAINTENANCE HPI-XHE-XM-FB OPERATOR FAILS TO INITIATE 2.OOOE-002 FEED AND BLEED COOLING MFW-XHE-XL-OPERATOR FAILS TO RECOVER 1.OOOE+000 MFWREC MFW SFP-XHE-XM-OPERATOR FAILS TO START AND 5.950E-002 SSGFP1 ALIGN STANDBY SG PUMP TRAINS (DE 10 83.87 0.85 3.840E-009 IE-LOMFW LOSS OF MAIN FEEDWATER 1.000E-001 AFW-TDP-CF-COMMON CAUSE FAILURE OF 4.610E-003 FRBC TDP B & C TO RUN AFW-TDP-FS-A AFW TDP A FAILS TO START 7.000E-003 HPI-XHE-XM-FB OPERATOR FAILS TO INITIATE 2.000E-002 FEED AND BLEED COOLING MFW-XHE-XL-OPERATOR FAILS TO RECOVER 1.000E+000 MFWREC MFW_

SFP-XHE-XM-OPERATOR FAILS TO START AND 5.950E-002 SSGFP1 ALIGN STANDBY SG PUMP TRAINS (DE Similarly, the probability of cutsets for other sequences are reduced by a factor of 10 due to the following mitigating factors:

1. Feed and bleed success criterion being relaxed to one of 2 PORVs,

2. Time to take actions is increased by at least an hour

3. Condensate system may be used for scenarios not involving power conversion systems 6.0 CALCULATIONAL FILES The key assumptions and data used in the calculation are documented in the calculation.

Additional files and information used for sensitivity studies are found in directory

\\\\Ws0847E4\\Max1 \\PTNAFW, 7.0 RESULTS The CDF increase is estimated by combining the different CDF for the two different time windows, one for B AFW pump failing before one hour and the other B AFW pump failing after one hour. F or the purpose of bounding evaluation, conservative values are used to simplify the calculation. A best-estimate based on the review of the NRC's phase 3 SDP and revised SPAR model yielcs the following:

PTN-BFJR-06-COI Rev 0 PTN AFWP B SDP CakFinal.doc

PTN-BFJR-0DO1 Rev. 0 Page 16 of 30 Table (6): Best Estimate Delta CDF.

Exposure Time 11 months I month Delta CDF AFW F ailure Time after 1 hour1.157407e-5 days <br />2.777778e-4 hours <br />1.653439e-6 weeks <br />3.805e-7 months <br /> in the first hour I weighted by exposure time delta CDF 3.20E-07 1.60E-06 4.27E-07 Additional sensitivity studies were performed by using the Turkey Point Rev 5B model with newer MS1I1 industry average failure data (Reference 6) for MOVs, Motor Driven Pumps, Turbine Driven Pumps, AOVs, EDGs, etc. Attachments 1 and 2 provide a list of dominant cutsets involving the B AFW pump, for failure probability of running set to 1.0 and 1.6E-2 respectively.

Comparable results are obtained using a similar approach but using Turkey Point PSA model with a scoping assumption based on insights of many exploratory runs considering the following factors:

1. Top cutsets involving A & C AFW failing to runs, can be reduced by a factor of 2 to 4, simply by applying convolution.

2. Top cutsets involving A& C AFW failing to start, can apply 0.5 or smaller for reasons similar to that of MSPI AFW FTS, PSL SPAR or even lower say a factor of 0.1 based on PSI. Unit 2 C AFW pump case

3. Selected cutsets involving LOG I.E. do not have offsite power recovery

4. For AkFW failing within the first hour, cutsets involving AHFAFWPTRP may be eliminated

5. Cutsets involving T3 and T1 may be mitigated by using condensate for secondary heat removal

6. Cutsets involving loss of 4 KV bus may be mitigated by condensate for secondary heat removal A scoping estimate is performed assuming a factor of 2 reduction (based on judgment and the fact that SPAR model results indicate a factor of 5 reduction as indicated in Table 6) for the delta CDF associated with B AFW pump failing after one hour from that when AFW fails within the first hour. The delta CDF in the first hour for the second case in Table 7, PTN Model with MSPI data is obtained by using the cutest files indicated in Attachments 1 and 2, by setting AHFPAFWPTRP to false, as this operator action is not required if AFW is assumed to fail in less than one hour. The delta CDF for the case in which AFW fails after one hour is obtained by reducing by a factor of 2 that for the case in which AFW is assumed to fail in less than one hour.

The results are summarized below.

Table (7): Summary of Delta CDF Sensitivity Study.

l Exposure Time I 11 months I 1 month I

Delta CDF PTN-BFJR406-C1 Rev 0 PTN AFWP B SDP CalcFinal.doc

PTN-BFJR-06-001 Rev.0 Page 17 of 30 AFW Failure in the first Time after 1 hour1.157407e-5 days <br />2.777778e-4 hours <br />1.653439e-6 weeks <br />3.805e-7 months <br /> hour weighted by exposure time SPAR Model delta CDF 3.20E-07 1.60E-06 4.27E-07 PTN Model with MSPI data delta CDF 2.79E-07 5.58E-07 3.02E-07 The increase in the CDF associated with the degraded B AFW pump is estimated to be lower than 4.3E-7/Yr.

In summary, a phase 3 safety significance determination has been performed, based in part, on the following key assumptions:

1. The degradation of the B AFW pump is time-dependent, as the pump continued to deliver adequate flow at least for one hour until 10/30/2005. Between 10/30/2005 and the date of condition discovery (11/07/05), the ability to deliver flow for longer than an hour is not determined.

2. Based on the test operating data, the B AFW pump would run at least one hour on or before October 30, 2005 (eight days prior to discovery). After October 30, 2005, the B AFW pump is conservatively assumed to fail in the first hour.

3. If the E AFW pump runs for one hour prior to failure, the decay heat is significantly lower, which allows more time for operators to take actions stipulated in the EOP.

4. Manual actions stipulated in the plant procedures (e.g. EOP, ONOP and OP) to provide secondary heat removal after the failure of AFW pumps by use of Standby Steam Generator Feedwater pumps and bleed and feed are included in the model (e.g. reduces the need for two pressurizer power operated relief valves to one).

The safety significance determination has concluded that the core damage probability increase over a year is less than 1.OE-6.

PTN-BFJR-06-D)1 Rev 0 PTN AFWP B SDP CalcFinal.doc

PTN-BFJR-06-001 Rev. 0 Page 18 of 30 : Sensitivity Case, Using MSPI data, with AFW B failure to run set to 1.0 Cutsets with Descriotions Reoort PTNR5C10 = 6.21E-08 C:\\2006MSPr\\CAFTA Files Rev C\\CutsVPTNRSC10AFWB.CUT Cutset Prob Event Prob C Rate U

1 7.95E-08 3.50E-03 9

1.OOE+00 0

1.60E-02 3

6.73E-04 H

1.OOE+00 1.00E+00 0

1.00E+00 0

6.40E.04 0

OF FEEDWATER (FHFPCD4-1VFHFPSSGFW) 5.OOE-01 7.10E02 0

2 7.63E.08 1.27E-01 9

1.OOE+00 0

1.60E-02 3

6.73E.04 H

1.60E.02 3

6.73E-04 H

1.00E+00 0

1.00E+00 0

1.OOE+00 0

7.50E-05 0

UNIT RWST (GHFPS2RCRC-GHFPOPPSI) 5.OOE-01 3

6.72E-08 1.OOE+00 9

1.00E+00 0

1.60E-02 3

6.73E.04 H

8.76E-04 3

1.00E-07 H

1.WOE+00 0

1.40E-03 0

5.00E-01 1.10E-01 0

4 4.84E-08 5.30E-02 9

1.00E+00 0

1.60E-02 3

6.73E-04 H

2.43E-02 3

1.03E-03 H

1.WOE+00 0

1.W0E+00 0

1.OOE+00 0

1.OOE+00 0

1.OOE+00 0

7.50E-05 0

UNIT RWST (GHFPS2RCRC-GHFPOPPSI) 5.OOE-01 1.W0E+00 5

3.97E-08 5.30E-02 9

1.OOE+00 0

1.60E-02 3

6.73E-04 H

1.WOE+00 0

2.OOE-02 1.WE+00 0

1.OOE+00 0

1.OOE+00 0

1.W0E+00 0

1.00E+00 0

7.50E-05 0

UNIT RWST (GHFPS2RCRC-GHFPOPPSI) 5.OOE-01 2115/2008 9:20 PM Exposure U 3.50E-03

.5 24 H

0.5

.5

.5 8.4E-4 0.5

.071 1.27E-01

.5 24 H

24 H

.5

.5

.5 7.5E405 0.5 1.0

.5 24 H

1 Y

.5 1.4E403 0.5 0.1097 5.30E-02

.5 24 H

24

.5

.5

.5

.5

.5 7.5E405 0.5 1.0 5.30E-02

.5 24 H

.5 1.999E-02

.5

.5

.5

.5

.5 7.5E405 0.5 Event Description

%ZZRU3C STEAM GENERATOR TUBE RUPTURE 3C GENERATOR AHFPAFWPTRP OPERATORS FAIL TO SHUT DOWN 1 OF THE TRAIN 2 PUMPS ATPFOAFWB AFW TURBINE-DRIVEN PUMP B FAILS TO RUN FHFPAFv'STM OPERATING CREW FAILS TO SWITCH STEAM SUPPLY TO AFW TRAIN 1 GIVEN SGTR IN SG 3C FHFPCD4-1 FAILURE TO RESET Si AND RESTART MFW FOLLOWING A REACTOR TRIP OR Si ACTUATION FHFPSSGFW FAILURE TO RECOVER SECON. HEAT SINK BY SSGFW ZHF-C2-004 FAILURE TO RESET Si AND RESTORE MFW AFTER LOSS OF AFW AND FAILURE TO USE SSGFW AS A BACKUP SOURCE ZZAFWPUMPC AFW PUMP C IS THE WEAKER OF THE 2 PUMPS ZZU400S UNIT 4 OUT OF SERVICE

%ZZT3CU3 LOSS OF MAIN FEEDWATER-NOT RECOVERABLE AHFPAFWPvTRP OPERATORS FAIL TO SHUT DOWN I OF THE TRAIN 2 PUMPS ATPFOAFWA AFW TURBINE-DRIVEN PUMP A FAILS TO RUN ATPFOAFWB AFW TURBINE-DRIVEN PUMP B FAILS TO RUN FHFPSSGFW FAILURE TO RECOVER SECON. HEAT SINK BY SSGFW GHFPOPPSI OPERATING CREW FAILS TO USE HHSI FROM OPPOSITE UNIT GHFPS2RCRC OPERATOR FAILS TO SWITCHOVER TO HIGH HEAD COLD LEG RECIRC (SMALL LOCA)

ZHF-C2-020 OPERATING CREW FAILS TO IMPLEMENT HHSR FOR A SMALL LOCA AND FAILS TO IMPLEMENT HHSI FROM OPPOSITE ZZAFWPUMPC AFW PUMP C IS THE WEAKER OF THE 2 PUMPS

%ZDC3A SPECIAL INITIATOR -LOSS OF 125VDC BUS 3A AHFPAFWPTRP OPERATORS FAIL TO SHUT DOWN I OF THE TRAIN 2 PUMPS ATPFOAFWB AFW TURBINE-DRIVEN PUMP B FAILS TO RUN EBDF33DO1I 125V DC BUS 3A FAILURE FHFPT4CD4-1 FAILURE TO RECOVER MFW OPERATING FWBFCVs LOCALLY ZHFPAFWPTRP FAILURE TO TRIP AFW PUMP B OR C WHEN BOTH ARE RUNNING ON TRAIN 2 ZZAFWPUMPC AFW PUMP C IS THE WEAKER OF THE 2 PUMPS ZHFPTRNAMAN OPERATORS FAIL TO MANUALLY ALIGN, START, AND RUN AFW TRAIN A GIVEN A LOSS OF DC BUS 3A

%ZZLOG LOSS OF GRID AHFPAFWPTRP OPERATORS FAIL TO SHUT DOWN I OF THE TRAIN 2 PUMPS ATPFOAFWB AFW TURBINE-DRIVEN PUMP B FAILS TO RUN EDGF44A DIESEL GENERATOR 4A FAILS TO RUN FHFPSSGFW FAILURE TO RECOVER SECON. HEAT SINK BY SSGFW GHFPOPPSI OPERATING CREW FAILS TO USE HHSI FROM OPPOSITE UNIT GHFPS2RCRC OPERATOR FAILS TO SWITCHOVER TO HIGH HEAD COLD LEG RECIRC (SMALL LOCA)

IHFPPORTFN OPERATOR FAILS TO UTILIZE PORTABLE FANS RHFPSRHVAC OPERATOR FAILURE TO START SR HVAC ZHF-C2-020 OPERATING CREW FAILS TO IMPLEMENT HHSR FOR A SMALL LOCA AND FAILS TO IMPLEMENT HHSI FROM OPPOSITE ZAFWPUMPC AFW PUMP C IS THE WEAKER OF THE 2 PUMPS ZZHVAC HVAC FLAG

%ZZLOG LOSS OF GRID AHFPAFWPvTRP OPERATORS FAIL TO SHUT DOWN I OF THE TRAIN 2 PUMPS ATPFOAFWB AFW TURBINE-DRIVEN PUMP B FAILS TO RUN EHFPCLR4KVS OPERATOR FAILS TO MANUALLY OPEN BREAKER TO ALLOW BUS TO LOAD - SOFT BREAKER FAIL EMM4ACLR 4160V BUS 4A BREAKERS FAIL TO OPEN -SOFT FAILURES FHFPSSGFW FAILURE TO RECOVER SECON. HEAT SINK BY SSGFW GHFPOPPSI OPERATING CREW FAILS TO USE HHSI FROM OPPOSITE UNIT GHFPS2RCRC OPERATOR FAILS TO SWITCHOVER TO HIGH HEAD COLD LEG RECIRC (SMALL LOCA)

IHFPPORTFN OPERATOR FAILS TO UTILIZE PORTABLE FANS RHFPSRHVAC OPERATOR FAILURE TO START SR HVAC ZHF-C2-020 OPERATING CREW FAILS TO IMPLEMENT HHSR FOR A SMALL LOCA AND FAILS TO IMPLEMENT HHSI FROM OPPOSITE ZZAFWPUMPC AFW PUMP C IS THE WEAKER OF THE 2 PUMPS PTN-BFJR-06-001 Rev 0 PTN AFWP B SDP CalcFinal.doc

PTN-BFJR-06-001 Rev. 0 Page 19 of 30 1.OOE+00 1.0 ZZHVAC HVAC FLAG 8

3.97E-08 1.27E-01 9

1.27E-01

%ZZT3CU3 LOSS OF MAIN FEEDWJATER-NOT RECOVERABLE 1.00E+00 0

.5 AHFPAFWPTRP OPERATORS FAIL TO SHUT DOWN 1 OF THE TRAIN 2 PUMPS 1.60E-02 3

6.73E-04 H

24 H

ATPFOAFWA AFW TURBINE-DRIVEN PUMP A FAILS TO RUN 1.60E-02 3

6.73E-04 H

24 H

ATPFOAFWB AFW TURBINE-DRIVEN PUMP B FAILS TO RUN 1.OOE+00 0

.5 FHFPSSGFW FAILURE TO RECOVER SECON. HEAT SINK BY SSGFW 1.OOE+00 0

.5 GHFPBLFEEDL OPERATING CREW FAILS TO IMPLEMENT BLEED-AND-FEED - LMFW W/LOW SG LEVEL 3.90E-05 0

4.OE-5 ZHF-C3-007 FAILURE TO TRIP ONE OF THE TWO TRAIN 2 AFW PUMPS, FAILURE TO RESTORE SECONDARY COOLING USING SSGFW AFTER LOSS OF AFW, AND FAILURETO RESETSI AND INITIATE BLEED-AND-FEED COOLING (AHFPAFWPTRP-FHFPSSGF 5.OOE-01 0.5 ZZAFWPUMPC AFW PUMP C IS THE WEAKER OF THE 2 PUMPS 7

3,31 E-08 5.30E-02 9

5.30E-02

%ZZLOG LOSS OF GRID 1.OOE+00 0

.5 AHFPAFWPTRP OPERATORS FAIL TO SHUT DOWN 1 OF THE TRAIN 2 PUMPS 1.60E-02 3

6.73E-04 H

24-H ATPFOAFWVB AFWTURBINE-DRIVENPUMPBFAILSTORUN 1.00E+00 0

.5 EHFPDOSTXT OPERATOR FAILS TO ATTEMPT DOSTXTIE 1.67E-02 3

210E-03 N

8 N

EMPA4P241A DIESEL OIL TRANSFER PUMP4P241A FAILS TO START 1.OOE+00 0

.5 FHFPSSGFW FAILURE TO RECOVER SECON. HEAT SINK BY SSGFW 1.OOE+00 0

.5 GHFPOPPSI OPERATING CREW FAILS TO USE HHSI FROM OPPOSITE UNIT

1.

1E+00 0

.5 GHFPS2RCRC OPERATOR FAILS TO SW[TCHOVER TO HIGH HEAD COLD LEG RECIRC (SMALL LOCA) 1.00E+00 0

.5 IHFPPORTFN OPERATOR FAILS TO UTILIZE PORTABLE FANS 1.OOE+00 0

.5 RHFPSRHVAC OPERATOR FAILURE TO START SR HVAC 7.50E-05 0

7.5E-05 ZHF-C2-020 OPERATING CREW FAILS TO IMPLEMENT HHSR FOR A SMALL LOCA AND FAILS TO IMPLEMENT HHSI FROM OPPOSITE UNIT RWST (GHFPS2RCRC-GHFPOPPSD 5.OOE-01 0.5 ZZAFWPUMPC AFN PUMP C IS THE WEAKER OF THE 2 PUMPS 1.WOE+00 1.0 ZZHVAC HVAC FLAG 8

3.25E-08 1.27E4-1 9

1.27E-01

%ZZT3CU3 LOSS OF MAIN FEEDWATER-NOT RECOVERABLE 1.OOE+00 0

.5 AHFPAFWPTRP OPERATORS FAIL TO SHUT DOWN I OF THE TRAIN 2 PUMPS 8.83E-03 0

6.825E-03 ATMOTRAIN1 AFW TRAIN 1 UNAVAILABLE DUE TO TEST OR MAINTENANCE 1.60E-02 3

6.73E-04 H

24 H

ATPFOAFWB AFW TURBINE-DRIVEN PUMP B FAILS TO RUN 1.OOE+00 0

.5 FHFPSSGFW FAILURE TO RECOVER SECON. HEAT SINK BY SSGFW 1.OOE+00 0

.5 GHFPOPPSI OPERATING CREW FAILS TO USE HHSI FROM OPPOSITE UNIT 1.OOE+00 0

.5 GHFPS2RCRC OPERATOR FAILS TO SWITCHOVER TO HIGH HEAD COLD LEG RECIRC (SMALL LOCA) 7.50E-05 0

7.5E-05 ZHF-C2-20 OPERATING CREW FAILS TO IMPLEMENT HHSR FOR A SMALL LOCA AND FAILS TO IMPLEMENT HHSI FROM OPPOSITE UNIT RWST (GHFPS2RCRC-GHFPOPPSI) 5.00E-1 0.5 ZZAFWPUMPC AFW PUMP C IS THE WEAKER OF THE 2 PUMPS 9

3.24E-08 5.30E-02 9

5.30E-02

%ZZLOG LOSS OF GRID 1.OOE+00 0

.5 AHFPAFWPTRP OPERATORS FAIL TO SHUT DOWN I OF THE TRAIN 2 PUMPS 1.60E-02 3

6.73E-04 H

24 H

ATPFOAFWB AFWTURBINE-DRIVEN PUMP B FAILS TO RUN 1.63E-02 0

1.630E-02 ETM4AEDG EDG 4A IN TEST OR MAINTENANCE 1.OOE+00 0

.5 FHFPSSGFW FAILURE TO RECOVER SECON. HEAT SINK BY SSGFW 1.CoE+00 0

.5 GHFPOPPSI OPERATING CREW FAILS TO USE HHSI FROM OPPOSITE UNIT 1.OOE+00 0

.5 GHFPS2RCRC OPERATOR FAILS TO SWITCHOVER TO HIGH HEAD COLD LEG RECIRC (SMALL LOCA) 1.OOE+00 0

.5 IHFPPORTFN OPERATOR FAILS TO UTILIZE PORTABLE FANS 1.W1E+00 0

.5 RHFPSRHVAC OPERATOR FAILURE TO START SR HVAC 7.50E-05 0

7.5E-05 ZHF-C2-020 OPERATING CREW FAILS TO IMPLEMENT HHSR FOR A SMALL LOCA AND FAILS TO IMPLEMENT HHSI FROM OPPOSITE UNIT RWST (GHFPS2RCRC-GHFPOPPS) 5.00E-1 0.5 ZZAPWPUMPC AFW PUMP C IS THE WEAKER OF THE 2 PUMPS 1.00E+00 1.0 ZZHVAC HVAC FLAG 10 3.19E-08 5.30E-02 9

5.30E-02

%ZZLOG LOSSOFGRID 1.OOE+00 0

.5 AHFPAFWPTRP OPERATORS FAIL TO SHUT DOWN 1 OF THE TRAIN 2 PUMPS 1.60E-02 3

6.73E-04 H

24 H

ATPFOAFWA AFWTURBINE-DRIVENPUMPAFAILSTORUN 1.60E-02 3

8.73E-04 H

24 H

ATPFOAFWB AFWTURBINE-DRIVENPUMPBFAILSTORUN 1.00E+00 0

.5 FHFPSSGFW FAILURE TO RECOVER SECON. HEAT SINK BY SSGFW 1.NE+00 0

.5 GHFPOPPSI OPERATING CREW FAILS TO USE HHSI FROM OPPOSITE UNIT 1.OOE+Q0 0

.5 GHFPS2RCRC OPERATOR FAILS TO SWITCHOVER TO HIGH HEAD COLD LEG RECIRC (SMALL LOCA) 7.50E-05' 0

7.5E-45 ZHF-C2-20 OPERATING CREW FAILS TO IMPLEMENT HHSR FOR A SMALL LOCA AND FAILS TO IMPLEMENT HHSI FROM OPPOSITE UNIT RWST (GHFPS2RCRC-GHFPOPPSD 5.OOE-01 0.5 ZZAFWPUMPC AFW PUMP C IS THE WEAKER OF THE 2 PUMPS 11 3.17E-08 1.10E-1 9

1,10E-1

%ZZT3AU3 LOSS OF MAIN FEEDWATER - RECOVERABLE 1.OOE+00 0

.5 AHFPAFWPTRP OPERATORS FAIL TO SHUT DOWN 1 OF THE TRAIN 2 PUMPS 1.60E-02 3

6.73E-04 H

24 H

ATPFOAFWA AFW TURBINE-DRIVEN PUMP A FAILS TO RUN 1.60E-02 3

6.73E-04 H

24 H

ATPFOAFWB AFW TURBINE-DRIVEN PUMP B FAILS TO RUN 1.OOE0+0 0

.5 FHFPCD4-1 FAILURE TO RESET SI AND RESTART MFW FOLLOWING A REACTOR TRIP OR SI ACTUATION PTN-BFJR-0&001 Rev 0 PTN AFWP B SDP CalcFinal.doc

PTN-BFJR-06-001 Rev. 0 Page 20 of 30 1.OOE+00 0

.5 FHFPSSGFW FAILURE TO RECOVER SECON. HEAT SINK BY SSGFW 1.OOE+00 0

.5 GHFPBLFEEDL OPERATING CREW FAILS TO IMPLEMENT BLEED-AND-FEED - LMFW WILOW SG LEVEL 3.60E-05 0

3.6E-05 ZHF-C3-006 FAILURE TO TRIP ONE OF THE TWO TRAIN 2 AFW PUMPS, FAILURE TO RESTORE MFW AFTER LOSS OF AFW. AND FAILUKE IO RESET SI ANU INITIATE BLEED-AND-FEED COOLING (AHFPAFWTRP-FHFPCD4.1-GHFPBLFEEDL) 5.OOE-01 0.5 ZZAFWPUMPC AFW PUMP C IS THE WEAKER OF THE 2 PUMPS 12 3.1 5E-08 5.30E-02 9

5.30E-02

%ZZLOG LOSSOFGRID 1.OOE+00 0

5 AHFPAFWNPTRP OPERATORS FAIL TO SHUT DOWN 1 OF THE TRAIN 2 PUMPS 1.60E-02 3

e.73E-04 H

24 H

ATPFOAFWB AFWTURBINE-DRIVENPUMPBFAILSTORUN 1.59E-02 3

2.O0E-03 N

8 N

ESVN43434A SOLENOID VALVE SV-4-3434A FAILS TO OPEN 1.OOE+00 0

.5 FHFPSSGFW FAILURE TO RECOVER SECON. HEAT SINK BY SSGFW 1.OOE+00 0

.5 GHFPOPPSI OPERATING CREW FAILS TO USE HHSI FROM OPPOSITE UNIT 1.OOE+00 0

.5 GHFPS2RCRC OPERATOR FAILS TO SWITCHOVER TO HIGH HEAD COLD LEG RECIRC (SMALL LOCA) 1.00E+00 0

.5 IHFPPORTFN*

OPERATOR FAILS TO UTILIZE PORTABLE FANS 1.00E+00 0

.5 RHFPSRHVAC OPERATOR FAILURE TO START SR HVAC 7.50E-05 0

7.5E-05 ZHF-C2-020 OPERATING CREW FAILS TO IMPLEMENT HHSR FOR A SMALL LOCA AND FAILS TO IMPLEMENT HHSI FROM OPPOSITE UNIT RWST (GHFPS2RCRC-GHFPOPPSI 5.00E-01 0.5 ZZAFWPUMPC AFW PUMP C IS THE WEAKER OF THE 2 PUMPS 1.OOE+00 1.0 ZZHVAC HVAC FLAG 13 3.02E-08 1.OOE+00 9

1.00

%ZZIAU3 UNIT3LOSSOF IA 1.OOE+00 0

.5 AHFPAFWPTRP OPERATORS FAIL TO SHUT DOWN I OF THE TRAIN 2 PUMPS 1.60E-02 3

6.73E-04 H

24 H

ATPFOAFWA AFW TURBINE-DRIVEN PUMP A FAILS TO RUN 1.60E-02 3

0.73E-04 H

24 H

ATPFOAFWB AFWTURBINE-DRIVEN PUMPBFAILSTORUN 1.001E+00 0

.5 FHFPT4CD4-1 FAILURE TO RECOVER MFW OPERATING FWBFCVs LOCALLY 1.OOE+00 0

.5 GHFPOPPSI OPERATING CREW FAILS TO USE HHSI FROM OPPOSITE UNIT 1.00E+00 0

.5 GHFPS2RCRC OPERATOR FAILS TO SWITCHOVER TO HIGH HEAD COLD LEG RECIRC (SMALL LOCA) 5.02E-02 3

5.88E-06 H

1 Y

HADF33T9I AIR DRYER 3T9 FAILS TO DELIVER FLOW (1 YR EXPOSURE) 7.50E-05 0

7.5E-05 ZHF-C2-020 OPERATING CREW FAILS TO IMPLEMENT HHSR FOR A SMALL LOCA AND FAILS TO IMPLEMENT HHSI FROM OPPOSITE UNIT RWST (GHFPS2RCRC-GHFPOPPSD 5.OOE-01 0.5 ZZAFWPUMPC AFW PUMP C IS THE WEAKER OF THE 2 PUMPS 14 298E-08 3.50E-03 9

3.50E-03

%ZZRU3A STEAM GENERATOR TUBE RUPTURE 3A GENERATOR 1.OOE+00 0

.5 AHFPAFWFLO OPERATOR FAILS TO THROTTLE UP AFW FLOW 1.OOE+00 0

.5 AHFPAFWPTRP OPERATORS FAIL TO SHUT DOWN I OF THE TRAIN 2 PUMPS 1.60E-02 3

6.73E-04 H

24 H

ATPFOAFWB AFW TURBINE-DRIVEN PUMP B FAILS TO RUN 1.OOE+00 0

.5 FHFPCD4-1 FAILURE TO RESET SI AND RESTART MFW FOLLOWING A REACTOR TRIP OR Si ACTUATION 1.OOE+00 0

.5 FHFPSSGFW FAILURE TO RECOVER SECON. HEAT SINK BY SSGFW 1.70E-45 0

1.7E-5 ZHF-C2-426 FAILURE TO THROTTLE UP AFW FLOW AND FAILURE TO USE SSGFW AS A BACKUP SOURCE OF FEEDWATER (AHFPAFWFLO

• FHFPSSGFW) 5.OOE-01 0.5 ZZAFWPUMPC AFW PUMP C IS THE WEAKER OF THE 2 PUMPS 15 2.98E-08 3.50E-03 9

3.50E-03

%ZZRU3B STEAM GENERATOR TUBE RUPTURE 3B GENERATOR 1.OOE+00 0

.5 AHFPAFWFLO OPERATOR FAILS TO THROTTLE UP AFW FLOW 1.OOE+00 0

.5 AHFPAFWPTRP OPERATORS FAIL TO SHUT DOWN 1 OF THE TRAIN 2 PUMPS 1.60E-02 3

8.73E-04 H

24 H

ATPFOAFWB AFWTURBINE-DRIVENPUMPBFAILSTORUN 1.OOE+00 0

.5 FHFPCD4-I FAILURE TO RESET SI AND RESTART MFW FOLLOWING A REACTOR TRIP OR SI ACTUATION 1.OOE+00 0

.5 FHFPSSGFW FAILURE TO RECOVER SECON. HEAT SINK BY SSGFW 1.70E-05 0

1.7E-5 ZHF-C2-028 FAILURE TO THROTTLE UP AFW FLOW AND FAILURE TO USE SSGFW AS A BACKUP SOURCE OF FEEDWATER (AHFPAFWFLO

• FHFPSSGFW) 5.O0E-1 0.5 ZZAFWPUMPC AFW PUMP C IS THE WEAKER OF THE 2 PUMPS 16 2.98E-08 3.50E-03 9

3.50E-03

%ZZRU3C STEAM GENERATOR TUBE RUPTURE 3C GENERATOR 1.OOE+00 0

.5 AHFPAFWFLO OPERATOR FAILS TO THROTTLE UP AFW FLOW 1.OOE+00 0

.5 AHFPAFWPTRP OPERATORS FAIL TO SHUT DOWN 1 OF THE TRAIN 2 PUMPS 1.60E-02 3

6.73E-04 H

24 H

ATPFOAFWB AFWTURBINE-DRIVENPUMPBFAILSTORUN 1.OOE+00 0

.5 FHFPCD4-1 FAILURE TO RESET Si AND RESTART MFW FOLLOWING A REACTOR TRIP OR SI ACTUATION 1.OOE+00 0

.5 FHFPSSGFW FAILURE TO RECOVER SECON. HEAT SINK BY SSGFW 1.70E-45 0

1.7E-5 ZHF-C2-026 FAILURE TO THROTTLE UP AFW FLOW AND FAILURE TO USE SSGFW AS A BACKUP SOURCE OF FEEDWATER (AHFPAFWFLO - FHFPSSGFW) 5.00E-1 0.5 ZZAFWPUMPC AFW PUMP C IS THE WEAKER OF THE 2 PUMPS 17 2.58E408 8.94E-01 9

8.94E-01

%ZZT1U3 REACTORTRIP 1.60E-02 3

e.73E-04 H

24 H

ATPFOAFWA AFWTURBINE-DRIVENPUMPAFAILSTORUN 1.60E-02 3

6.73E-04 H

24 H

ATPFOAFWB AFW TURBINE-DRIVEN PUMP B FAILS TO RUN 1.80E-0 0

1.80E-46 NRDFPHYSICAL FAILURE OF CONTROL RODS TO INSERT WITH POWER REMOVED 1.OOE+00 1.0 ZZATWS ATWS FLAG 18 2.58E-08 8.94E-01 9

8.94E-01

%ZZTIU3 REACTORTRIP PTN-BFJR-06-001 Rev 0 PTN AFWP B SDP CalcFinal.doc

1.604-02 3

1.60E-02 3

1.80E-06 0

1.00E+00 19 244E-08 1.27E-41 9

1.00E+00 0

5,13E-03 3

1.60E-02 3

1.00E+00 0

1.00E+00 0

1.OOE+00 0

7.50E-05 0

UNIT RWST (GHFPS2RCRC GHFPOPPSQ 5.00E-01 20 2.23E-08 5.30E-02 9

1.OOE+00 0

1.60E-02 3

1.12E-02 3

1.OOE+00 0

1.00E+00 0

1.00E+00 0

1.00E+00 0

1.OOE+00 0

7.50E-05 0

UNIT RWST (GHFPS2RCRC-GHFPOPPSD 5.00E-01 1.OOE+00 21 2.19E-08 1.27E-01 9

1.57E-04 1.60E-02 3

1.00E+00 0

1.00E+00 0

1.10E-03 0

(FHPSSGFW-GHFPBLFEEDL) 22 2.15E-08 1.OOE+00 9

1.00E+00 0

1.60E-02 3

1.OOE+00 0

1.00E+00 0

1.00E+00 0

3.72E-01 3.09E-03 1.OOE+00 0

7.50E-05 0

UNIT RWST (GHFPS2RCRC-GHFPOPPSI 5.00E-01 5.OOE-01 0

23 2.15E-08 1.00E+00 9

1.00E+00 0

1.60E-02 3

1.00E+00 0

1.00E+00 0

1.OOE+00 0

3.72E-01 3.09E-03 1.OOE+00 0

7.50E-05 0

UNIT RWST (GHFPS2RCRC-GHFPOPPSI 5.00E-01 5.00E-01 0

24 2.15E-08 5.30E-02 9

1.00E+00 0

PTN-BFJR-06-001 Rev.0.

Page 21 of 30 6.73E-04 H

24 H

ATPF0AANB AFWTURBINE-DRIVENPUMPBFAILSTORUN 6.73E-04 H

24 H

ATPFOAFWC AFW TURBINE-DRIVEN PUMP C FAILS TO RUN 1.80E-06 NRDFPHYSICAL FAILURE OF CONTROL RODS TO INSERTWITH POWER REMOVED 1.0 ZZATWS ATWS FLAG 1.27E-01

%ZZT3CU3 LOSS OF MAIN FEEDWATER-NOT RECOVERABLE

.5 AHFPAFWPTRP OPERATORS FAIL TO SHUT DOWN I OF THE TRAIN 2 PUMPS 5.14E-03 N

I N

ATPAOAFWA AFWTURBINE-DRIVENPUMPAFAILSTOSTART 6.73E-04 H

24 H

ATPFOAFWB AFWTURBINE-DRIVENPUMPBFAILSTORUN

.5 FHFPSSGFW FAILURE TO RECOVER SECON. HEAT SINK BY SSGFW

.5 GHFPOPPSI OPERATING CREW FAILS TO USE HHSI FROM OPPOSITE UNIT

.5 GHFPS2RCRC OPERATOR FAILS TO SWITCHOVER TO HIGH HEAD COLD LEG RECIRC (SMALL LOCA) 7.5E-05 ZHF-C2-020 OPERATING CREW FAILS TO IMPLEMENT HHSR FOR A SMALL LOCA AND FAILS TO IMPLEMENT HHSI FROM OPPOSITE 0.5 ZZAFWPUMPC AFW PUMP C IS THE WEAKER OF THE 2 PUMPS 5.30E-02

%ZZLOG LOSS OF GRID

.5 AHFPAFWPTRP OPERATORS FAIL TO SHUT DOWN 1 OF THE TRAIN 2 PUMPS Q.73E-04 H

24 H

ATPFOAFWB AFW TURBINE-DRIVEN PUMP B FAILS TO RUN 1.13E-02 N

1 N

EDGA44A DIESEL GENERATOR 4A FAILS TO START

.S FHFPSSGFW FAILURE TO RECOVER SECON. HEAT SINK BY SSGFW

.5 GHFPOPPSI OPERATING CREW FAILS TO USE HHSI FROM OPPOSITE UNIT

.5 GHFPS2RCRC OPERATOR FAILS TO SWITCHOVER TO HIGH HEAD COLD LEG RECIRC (SMALL LOCA)

.5 IHFPPORTFN OPERATOR FAILS TO UTILIZE PORTABLE FANS

.5 RHFPSRHVAC OPERATOR FAILURE TO START SR HVAC 7.5E-05 ZHF-C2-020 OPERATING CREW FAILS TO IMPLEMENT HHSR FOR A SMALL LOCA AND FAILS TO IMPLEMENT HHSI FROM OPPOSITE 0.5 ZZAFWPUMPC AFW PUMP C IS THE WEAKER OF THE 2 PUMPS 1.0 ZZHVAC HVAC FLAG 1.27E-01

%ZZT3CU3 LOSS OF MAIN FEEDWATER-NOT RECOVERABLE 1.569E-04 AMMOCCTPAAC CCF (2t3) OF TURBINE-DRIVEN PUMP A,C TO START 6.73E-04 H

24 H

ATPFOAFWB AFW TURBINE-DRIVEN PUMP B FAILS TO RUN

.5 FHFPSSGFW FAILURE TO RECOVER SECON. HEAT SINK BY SSGFW

.5 GHFPBLFEEDL OPERATING CREW FAILS TO IMPLEMENT BLEED-AND-FEED -LMFW WILOW SG LEVEL 1.1E-3 ZHF-C2-028 OPERATORS FAIL TO RECOVER SEC COOLING USING SSGFW AND FAIL TO IMPLEMENT BLEED-AND-FEED COOLING 1.00

%ZZIA34 DUAL UNIT LOSS OF IA

.5 AHFPAFWPTRP OPERATORS FAIL TO SHUT DOWN 1 OF THE TRAIN 2 PUMPS 0.73E-04 H

24 H

ATPFOAFWB AFWTURBINE-DRIVENPUMPBFAILSTORUN

.5 FHFPT4CD4-1 FAILURE TO RECOVER MFW OPERATING FWBFCVs LOCALLY

.5 GHFPOPPSI OPERATING CREW FAILS TO USE HHSI FROM OPPOSITE UNIT

.5 GHFPS2RCRC OPERATOR FAILS TO SWITCHOVER TO HIGH HEAD COLD LEG RECIRC (SMALL LOCA) 3.717E-01 HMM3M3321 LOCAL FAULTS IN HEADER M 332 (1 YR EXPOSURE) 3.086E-03 HMMCCFALLR CCF TO RUN-4/4 U3 & U4 IA COMPRESSORS (2 DAY EXPOSURE)

.5 XHFPRCPTRP OPERATING CREW FAILS TO TRIP RCPs GIVEN DUAL-UNIT TRIP 7.5E-05 ZHF-C2-020 OPERATING CREW FAILS TO IMPLEMENT HHSR FOR A SMALL LOCA AND FAILS TO IMPLEMENT HHSI FROM OPPOSITE 0.5 ZZAFWPUMPC AFW PUMP C IS THE WEAKER OF THE 2 PUMPS 0.5 ZZIAU3 FLAG - 3CM RUNNING, 4CM IN STANDBY 1.00

%ZZIA34 DUAL UNIT LOSS OF IA

.5 AHFPAFWPTRP OPERATORS FAIL TO SHUT DOWN 1 OF THE TRAIN 2 PUMPS 6.73E-04 H

24 H

ATPFOAFWB AFWTURBINE-DRIVENPUMPBFAILSTORUN

.5 FHFPT4CD4-1 FAILURE TO RECOVER MFW OPERATING FWBFCVs LOCALLY

.5 GHFPOPPSI OPERATING CREW FAILS TO USE HHSI FROM OPPOSITE UNIT

.5 GHFPS2RCRC OPERATOR FAILS TO SWITCHOVER TO HIGH HEAD COLD LEG RECIRC (SMALL LOCA) 3.717E-01 HMM4M4321 LOCAL FAULTS IN HEADER M 432 (1 YR EXPOSURE) 3.086E-03 HMMCCFALLR CCF TO RUN-4/4 U3 & U4 IA COMPRESSORS (2 DAY EXPOSURE)

.5 XHFPRCPTRP OPERATING CREW FAILS TO TRIP RCPs GIVEN DUAL-UNIT TRIP 7.5E-05 ZHF-C2-020 OPERATING CREW FAILS TO IMPLEMENT HHSR FOR A SMALL LOCA AND FAILS TO IMPLEMENT HHSI FROM OPPOSITE 0.5 ZZAFWPUMPC AFW PUMP C IS THE WEAKER OF THE 2 PUMPS 05 ZZIAU4 FLAG - 4CM RUNNING, 3CM IN STANDBY 5.302-02

%ZZLOG LOSS OF GRID

.5 AHFPAFWPTRP OPERATORS FAIL TO SHUT DOWN I OF THE TRAIN 2 PUMPS PTN-BFJR-06-001 Rev 0 PTN AFWP B SDP CalcFinal.doc

1.60E-02 3

1.08E-02 2

1.00E+00 0 1.00E+00 0 1.OOE+00 0

1.00E+00 0

1.OOE+.0 0

1.OOE+00 0

7.50E-05 0

UNIT RWST (GHFPS2RCRC-GHFPOPPSI) 5.00E-01 1.00E+00 25 1.80E-08 3.50E-03 9

1.00E+00 0 1.60E-02 3

1.60E-02 3

1.00E+00 0

1.00E+00 0

6.40E-04 0

OF FEEDWATER (FHFPCD4-1-FHFPSSGFW) 5.0E2-01 6.73E-04 H

3.00E-05 H

24 1

.5

.5

.5

.5

.5

.5 7.5E405 PTN-BFJR-06-001 Rev. 0 Page 22 of 30 H

ATPFOAFWB AFW TURBINE-DRIVEN PUMP B FAILS TO RUN M

EBSP46332A BASKET STRAINER BS4-6332A PLUGS EHFPDOSTXT OPERATOR FAILS TO ATTEMPT DOST XTIE FHFPSSGFW FAILURE TO RECOVER SECON. HEAT SINK BY SSGFW GHFPOPPSI OPERATING CREW FAILS TO USE HHSI FROM OPPOSITE UNIT GHFPS2RCRC OPERATOR FAILS TO SWITCHOVER TO HIGH HEAD COLD LEG RECIRC (SMALL LOCA)

IHFPPORTFN OPERATOR FAILS TO UTILIZE PORTABLE FANS RHFPSRHVAC OPERATOR FAILURE TO START SR HVAC ZHF-C2-020 OPERATING CREW FAILS TO IMPLEMENT HHSR FOR A SMALL LOCA AND FAILS TO IMPLEMENT HHSI FROM OPPOSITE ZZAFWPUMPC AFW PUMP C IS THE WEAKER OF THE 2 PUMPS ZZHVAC HVAC FLAG

%ZZRU3A STEAM GENERATOR TUBE RUPTURE 3A GENERATOR AHFPAFWNPTRP OPERATORS FAIL TO SHUT DOWN I OF THE TRAIN 2 PUMPS H

ATPFOAFWA AFW TURBINE-DRIVEN PUMP A FAILS TO RUN H

ATPFOAFWB AFW TURBINE-DRIVEN PUMP B FAILS TO RUN FHFPCD4-1 FAILURE TO RESET Si AND RESTART MFW FOLLOWING A REACTOR TRIP OR Si ACTUATION FHFPSSGFW FAILURE TO RECOVER SECON. HEAT SINK BY SSGFW ZHF-C2-004 FAILURE TO RESET Si AND RESTORE MFW AFTER LOSS OF AFW AND FAILURE TO USE SSGFW AS A BACKUP SOURCE ZZAFWPUMPC AFW PUMP C IS THE WEAKER OF THE 2 PUMPS 0.5 1.0 3.50E-03

.5 6.73E-04 H

24 6.73E-04 H

24

.5

.5 6.4E-4 0.5 Report Summary:

Filename: C:A2006MSPIACAFTA Files Rev C\\CutslPTNR5C10AFWB.CUT Print date: 2/1 52006 9:20 PM Not sorted Printed the first 25 PTN-BFJR-06-001 Rev 0 PTN AFWP B SDP CalcFinal.doc

PTN-BFJR-06-001

. Rev.0 Page 23 of 30, Sensitivity Study: Base Case, Using MSPI data, Nominal AFW B failure to run Cutsets with DescrIptions Report PTNR5CI0 - 3.87E-06 C:\\2OO6MSPI\\CAFTAFiles RevC\\Cuts\\TNRSCI0.CUT 2V112006 9:30 PM N

Cutset Prob Event Prob C Rate U

Exposure U

Event Desciption I

I.27E-09 3.50E-03 9

3.50E-03

%ZZRU3C STEAM GENERATOR TUBE RUPTURE 3C GENERATOR I.00E+00 0

.5 AHFPAFWPTRP OPERATORS FAIL TO SHUT DOWN I OF THE TRAIN 2 PUMPS 1.60E-02 3

6.73E-04 H

24 H

ATPFOAFWB AFWTURBINE-DRIVEN PUMP B FAILS TO RUN 1.00E+00 0.5 FHFPAFWSTM OPERATING CREW FAILS TO SWITCH STEAM SUPPLY TO AFW I.OOE+00 0

.5 FHFPCD4-1 FAILURE TO RESET Si AND RESTART MFW FOLLOWING A REACTOR TRIP I 1.00E+00 0

.5 FHFPSSGFW FAILURE TO RECOVER SECON. HEAT SINK BY SSGFW 6.40E-04 0

6.4E-4 ZHF-C2-004 FAILURE TO RESET SI AND RESTORE MFW AFTER LOSS OF AFW AND FAI (FHFPCD4-lIFHFPSSGFW) 5.OOE-01 0.5 ZZAFWPUMPC AFW PUMP C IS THE WEAKER OF THE 2 PUMPS 7.1OE-02 0

.071 ZZU400S UNIT40UTOFSERVICE 2

1.22E-09 1.27E-01 9

1.27E-01

%ZZT3CU3 LOSS OF MAIN FEEDWATER-NOTRECOVERABLE I.00E+00 0

.5 AHFPAFWPTRP OPERATORS FAIL TO SHUT DOWN I OF THE TRAIN 2 PUMPS 1.60E-02 3

6.73E-04 H

24 H

ATPFOAFWA AFWTURBINE-DRIVEN PUMPAFAILSTO RUN 1.60E-02 3

6.73E-04 H

24 H

ATPFOAFWB AFWTURBINE-DRIVEN PUMP B FAILS TO RUN I.00E+00 0

.5 FHFPSSGFW FAILURE TO RECOVER SECON. HEAT SINK BY SSGFW 1.00E+00 0

.5 GHFPOPPSI OPERATING CREW FAILS TO USE HHSI FROM OPPOSITE UNIT 1.00E+00 0

.5 GHFPS2RCRC OPERATOR FAILS TO SWITCHOVER TO HIGH HEAD COLD LEG 7.50E-05 0

7.5E-05 ZHF-C2-020 OPERATING CREW FAILS TO IMPLEMENT HHSR FOR A SMALL LOCA A (GHFPS2RCRC GHFPOPPSI) 5.00E-0I 0.5 ZZAFWPUMPC AFW PUMP C IS THE WEAKER OF THE 2 PUMPS 3

1.08EE09 1.00E+00 9

1.0

%ZZDC3A SPECIALINnITATOR-LOSSOF 125VDCBUS3A 1.OOE+00 0

.5 AHFPAFWPTRP OPERATORS FAILTO SHUT DOWN I OFTHE TRAIN 2 PUMPS 1.60E-02 3

6.73E-04 H

24 H

ATPFOAFWB AFWTURBINE-DRIVEN PUMP B FAILS TO RUN 8.76E-04 3

1.00E-07 H

I Y

EBDF33DOW1 125V DC BUS 3A FAILURE 1.00E+00 0,

.5 FHFPT4CD4-1 FAILURE TO RECOVER MFW OPERATING FWBFCVs LOCALLY 1.40E-03 0

I.AE-03 ZHFPAFWPTRP FAILURE TO TRIP AFW PUMP B OR C WHEN BOTH ARE RUNNn 5.00E-01 0.5 ZZAFWPUMPC AFW PUMP C IS THE WEAKER OF THE 2 PUMPS 1.IOE-01 0

0.1097 ZHFPTRNAMAN OPERATORS FAILTO MANUALLY ALIGN, START, AND RUNAl 4

7.76E-10 5.30E-02 9

5.30E-02

• /.ZZLOG LOSSOFGRID I.OOE+00 0

.5 AHFPAFvVPTRP OPERATORS FAILTOSHUr DOWN I OFTHETRANN2PUMPS 1.60E-02 3

6.73E-04 H

24 H

ATPF0AFWB AFWVTURBINE-DRIVENPUMPBFAILSTORUN 2.43E-02 3

1.03E-03 H

24 EDWF44A DIESEL GENERATOR 4A FAILS TO RUN I.00E+00 0

.5 FHFPSSGFW FAILURE TO RECOVER SECON. HEAT SINK BY SSGFW I.OOE+00 0

.5 GHFPOPPSI OPERATING CREW FAILS TO USE HHSI FROM OPPOSITE UNIT 1.00E+00 0

.5 GHFPS2RCRC OPERATOR FAILS TO SWITCHOVER TO HIGH HEAD COLD LEG 1.00E+00 0

.5 IHFPPORTFN OPERATOR FAILS TO UTILIZE PORTABLE FANS 1.00E+00 0

.5 RHFPSRHVAC OPERATOR FAILURE TO START SR HVAC 7.50E-05 0

7.5E-05 ZHF-C2-020 OPERATING CREW FAILS TO IMPLEMENT HHSR FOR A SMALL LOCA A (GHFPS2RCRC GHFPOPPSI) 5.00E-01 0.5 ZZAFWPUMPC AFW PUMP C IS THE WEAKER OF THE 2 PUMPS 1.00E+00 1.0 ZZHVAC HVAC FLAG 5

6.37E.10 5.30E-02 9

5.30E-02

%ZZLOG LOSS OF GRID 1.00E+00 0

.5 AHFPAFWPTRP OPERATORS FAIL TO SHUT DOWN I OF THE TRAIN 2 PUMPS 1.60E-02 3

6.73E-04 Hi 24 H

ATPFOAFWB AFWTURBINE-DRIVEN PUMP B FAILS TO RUN 1.00E+00 0

.5 EHFPCLR4KVS OPERATOR FAILS TO MANUALLY OPEN BREAKER TO ALLOW 2.00E-02 L.999E-02 EMM4ACLR 4160V BUS 4A BREAKERS FAIL TO OPEN - SOFT FAILURES 1.00E+00 0

.5 FHFPSSGFW FAILURE TO RECOVER SECON. HEAT SINK BY SSGFW 1.00E+00 0

.5 GHFPOPPSI OPERATING CREW FAILS TO USE HIISI FROM OPPOSITE UNIT I.00E+00 0

• 5 GHFPS2RCRC OPERATOR FAILS TO SWITCHOVER TO HIGH HEAD COLD LEC 1.00E+00 0

.5 IHFPPORTFN OPERATOR FAILS TO UTILIZE PORTABLE FANS I. ODE+00 0

.5 RHFPSRHVAC OPERATOR FAILURE TO START SR HVAC 7.50E-05 0

7.5E-05 ZHF-C2-020 OPERATING CREW FAILS TO IMPLEMENT HHSR FOR A SMALL LOCA A (GHFPS2RCRC-GHFPOPPSI) 5.00E-01 0,5 ZZAFWPUMPC AFW PUMP C IS THE WEAKER OF THE 2 PUMPS

'TRAIN I GIVEN SGTR IN SG 3C OR SI ACTUATION ULURE TO USE SSGFW AS A BACKUP SOURCE OF FEEDWATER RECIRC (SMALL LOCA)

ND FAILS TO IMPLEMENT HHSI FROM OPPOSITE UNIT RWST NG ON TRAIN 2 FIV TRAIN A GIVEN A LOSS OF DC BUS 3A

RECIRC (SMALL LOCA)

ND FAILS TO IMPLEMENT HHSI FROM OPPOSITE UNIT RWST

'BUS TO LOAD - SOFT BREAKER FAIL I RECIRC (SMALL LOCA)

ND FAILS TO IMPLEMENT HHSI FROM OPPOSITE UNIT RWST PTN-BFJR-0-01 Rev 0 PTN AFWp B SDP CalcFinal.doc

PTN-BFJR-06-001 Rev. 0 Page 24 of 30 1.00E+00 1.0 ZZHVAC HVAC FLAG 6

6.36E-10 1.27E-01 9

I.27E-01

/ZZT3CU3 LOSSOFMAINFEEDWATER-NOTRECOVERABLE 1.00E+00 0

.5 AHFPAFWPTRP OPERATORS FAIL TO SHUT DOWN I OF THE TRAIN 2 PUMPS 1.60E-02 3

6.73E-04 H

24 H

ATPFOAFWA AFWTURBINE-DRIVENPUMPAFAILSTORUN 1.60E-02 3

6.73E-04 H

24 H

ATPFOAFWB AFWTURBINE-DRIVENPUMPBFAILSTO RUN I.OOE+00 0

.5 FHFPSSGFW FAILURE TO RECOVER SECON. HEAT SINK BY SSGFW 1.00E+00 0

.5 GHFPBLFEEDL OPERATING CREW FAILS TO IMPLEMENT BLEED-AND-FEED -LMFW W/LOW SG LEVEL 3.90E-05 0

4.0E-5 ZHF-C3-007 FAILURE TO TRIP ONE OF THE IWO TRAIN 2 AFW PUMPS, FAILURE TO RESTORE SECONDARY COOLING USING SSGFW AFTER LOSS OF AFW, AND FAILURE TO RESET SI AND INMATE BLEED-AND-FEED COOLING (AHFPAFM'P7W-FHFPSSGF 5.00E-01 0.5 ZZAFWPUMPC AFW PUMP C IS THE WEAKER OF THE 2 PUMPS 7

5.31E-10 5.30E-02 9

5.30E.02 NZZLOG LOSS OF GRID I.OOE+00 0

.5 AHFPAFWPTRP OPERATORS FAIL TO SHUT DOWN I OF THE TRAIN 2 PUMPS 1.60E-02 3

6.73E-04 H

24 H

ATPFOAFWB AFWTURBINE-DRIVEN PUMP B FAILS TO RUN I.OOE+00 0

.5 EHFPDOSTXT OPERATOR FAILS TO ATTEMPT DOST XllE 1.67E 02 3

2.10E-03 N

S N

EMPA4P241A DIESELOILTRANSFER PUMP 4P241A FAILS TO START 1.00E+00 0

.5 FHFPSSGFW FAILURE TO RECOVER SECON. HEAT SINK BY SSGFW 1.00E+00 0

.5 GHFPOPPSI OPERATING CREW FAILS TO USE HHSI FROM OPPOSITE UNIT I.OOE+00 0

.5 GHFPS2RCRC OPERATOR FAILS TO SWITCHOVER TO HIGH HEAD COLD LEG RECIRC (SMALL LOCA) 1.00E+00 0

.5 IHFPPORTFN OPERATOR FAILS TO UTILIZE PORTABLE FANS I.OOE+00 0

.5 RHFPSRHVAC OPERATOR FAILURE TO START SR HVAC 7.50E-05 0

7.5E-05 ZHF-C2-020 OPERATING CREW FAILS TO IMPLEMENT HHSR FOR A SMALL LOCA AND FAILS TO IMPLEMENT HHSI FROM OPPOSITE UNIT RWST (GHFPS2RCRC-GHFPOPPSI) 5.00E-01 0.5 ZZAFWPUMPC AFW PUMP C IS THE WEAKER OF THE 2 PUMPS 1.00E+00 1.0 ZZHVAC HVAC FLAG 8

5.21E-10 1.27E-01 9

1.27E-01

%ZZT3CU3 LOSSOFMAINFEEDWATER-NOTRECOVERABLE I.OOE+00 0

.5 AHFPAFWPTRP OPERATORS FAILTO SHUT DOWN I OFTHE TRAIN 2 PUMPS 6.83E-03 0

6.825E-03 ATMOTRAINI AFIWTRAIN I UNAVAILABLE DUETO TEST OR MAINTENANCE 1.60E-02 3

6.73E-04 H

24 H

ATPFOAFWB AFWTURBINE-DRIVEN PUMP B FAILS TO RUN I.OOE+00 0

.5 FHFPSSGFW FAILURE TO RECOVER SECON. HEAT SINK BY SSGFW 1.00E+00 0

.5 GHFPOPPSI OPERATING CREW FAILS TO USE HHSI FROM OPPOSITE UNIT I.OOE+00 0

.5 GHFPS2RCRC OPERATOR FAILS TO SWITCHOVER TO HIGH HEAD COLD LEG RECIRC (SMALL LOCA) 7.50E-05 0

7.5E-05 ZHF-C2.020 OPERATING CREW FAILS TO IMPLEMENT HHSR FOR A SMALL LOCA AND FAILS TO IMPLEMENT HHSI FROM OPPOSITE UNIT RWST (GHFPS2RCRC-GHFPOPPSI) 5.00E-01 0.5 ZZAFWPUMPC AFW PUMP C IS THE WEAKER OF THE 2 PUMPS 9

5.19E-10 5.30E-02 9

5.30E-02 "ZZLOG LOSS OF GRID I.OOE+00 0

.5 AHFPAFWPTRP OPERATORS FAIL TO SHUT DOWN I OF THE TRAIN 2 PUMPS 1.60E-02 3

6.73E-04 H

24 H

ATPFOAFWB AFW TURBINE-DRIVEN PUMP B FAILS TO RUN I.63E-02 0

1.630E-02 ET`M4AED EDG 4A IN TEST OR MAINTENANCE 1.00E+00 0

.5 FHFPSSGFWV FAILURE TO RECOVER SECON. HEAT SINK BY SSGFW I.OOE+00 0

.5 GHFPOPPSI OPERATING CREW FAILS TO USE HHSI FROM OPPOSITE UNIT I.OOE+00 0

.5 GHFPS2RCRC OPERATOR FAILS TO SWITCHOVER TO HIGH HEAD COLD LEG RECIRC (SMALL LOCA)

I.OOE+00 0

.5 IHFPPORTFN OPERATOR FAILS TO UTILIZE PORTABLE FANS I.OOE+00 0

.5 RHFPSRHVAC OPERATOR FAILURE TO START SR HVAC 7.50E-05 0

7.5E-05 ZHF-C2.020 OPERATING CREW FAILS TO IMPLEMENT HHSR FOR A SMALL LOCA AND FAILS TO IMPLEMENT HHSI FROM OPPOSITE UNIT RWST (GHFPS2RCRC-GHFPOPPSI) 5.00E-01 0.5 ZZAFWPUMPC AFW PUMP C IS THE WEAKER OF THE 2 PUMPS 1.00E+00 1.0 ZZHVAC HVAC FLAG 10 5.11E510 5.30E-02 9

5.30E-02

%ZZLOG LOSS OF GRID 1.00E+00 0

.5 AHFPAFWPTRP OPERATORS FAIL TO SHUT DOWN I OF THE TRAIN 2 PUMPS 1.60E-02 3

6.73E.04 H

24 H

ATPFOAFWA AFWTURBINE-DRIVENPUMPAFAILSTORUN 1.60E-02 3

6.73E.04 H

24 H

ATPFOAFWB AFWTURBINE-DRIVEN PUMP B FAILS TO RUN 1.00E+00 0

.5 FHFPSSGFV FAILURE TO RECOVER SECON. HEAT SINK BY SSGFW I.OOE+00 0

.5 GHFPOPPSI OPERATING CREW FAILS TO USE HHSI FROM OPPOSITE UNIT I.OOE+00 0

.5 GHFPS2RCRC OPERATOR FAILS TO SWITCHOVER TO HIGH HEAD COLD LEG RECIRC (SMALL LOCA) 7.50E-05 0

7.5E-05 ZHF-C2-020 OPERATING CREW FAILS TO IMPLEMENT HHSR FOR A SMALL LOCA AND FAILS TO IMPLEMENT HHSI FROM OPPOSITE UNIT RWST (GHFPS2RCRC-GHFPOPPSI) 5.00E-01 0.5 ZZAFWPUMPC AFW PUMP C IS THE WEAKER OF THE 2 PUMPS Report Sanmary:

Filename: C:A2006MSPI"CAFTA Files Rev C\\Cuts\\PTNR.5CIO.CUT Print date: 2/15/2006 9:30 PM Not sorted, Printed the first 10 PTN-BFJR-06-001 Rev 0 PTN AFWP B SDP CalcFinal.doc

PTN-BFJR-06-001 Rev.0 Page 25 of 30 : Clarification of Loss of DC 3A Operator Recovery Action FcM.aakded by Ching Averet unt-.Nuclc^-I pl uc on 1 I 0

M~ark Avereft 02/17/2006 07:44 AM To:

ching guey@fpl.com cc:Brien VincentIJuno/Nuclear/FplNuc@FplNuc, Glen Blinde/Ptn/Nuclear/FplNuc@FplNuc, Mahmoud Heiba/Juno/Nuclear/FplNuc@FplNuc

Subject:

Re: AHFPTRNAMAN See response in blue.

Mark Ching Guey 02/17/2006 07:31 AM To:

Mark Averett/Juno/Nuclear/FplNuc@FplNuc cc:Brien VincentIJuno/Nuclear/FplNuc@FplNuc, Mahmoud Heiba/Juno/Nuclear/FplNuc, Glen Blinde/Ptn/Nuclear/FplNuc@FplNuc

Subject:

Re: AHFPTRNAMAN Does this imply that the Bimbaum importance of the hardware (A AFW pump, and train 1 steam admission valve, mainly) involved may need to be added (or allocated based on its contribution to 0.1083, which may be reduced if the MSPI data is used, I presume that FTR of 0.096 for Train A AFW pump may dominate)? Yes, it does. Replacing ZHFPTRNAMAN with ATPFOAFWA in the cutsets would approximate the increase in Bimbaum due to the hardware portion of the AHFPTRNAMAN recovery.

This may not be an important issue, until DC bus 3A becomes dominant sequence of concem.

Also, Glen's email earlier may change the HEP somewhat? No. Glen's email simply confirms that the AHFPTRNAMAN recovery is possible.

Ching PTN-BFJR.06-001 Rev 0 PTN AFWP B SDP CalcFinal.doc

PTN-BFJR-06-001 Rev. 0 Page 26 of 30 Mark Avereft 02/17/2006 07:10 AM To: ching gueyafpl.com cc: Brien VincentlJunolNuclear/FplNuc@FplNuc, Mahmoud HeibalJunolNuclearlFplNuc@FplNuc, glen blindeefpl.com

Subject:

AHFPTRNAMAN

Ching, I found the reference for the 0.11 probability for the recovery event AHFPTRNAMAN in the Rev. 4 update calculation.

PTN-03-068 Recovery for %ZZDC3A/B Sequences Descripio Actual Change During the cutset review with the Licensed Operator Instructors, it was pointed out that it did not appear that the dependency of SSGFW on the feedwater bypass valves (FCV-3-479, 489, and 499) was adequately modeled. This was discovered by noting that the loss of DC Bus 3A (power for these valves) was not resulting in a failure of SSGFW. This was corrected via change PTN-03-066. This change brought a lot of loss of DC Bus 3A cutsets to the top. The Licensed Operator Instructors also pointed out that Train 1 of AFW which is lost due to the loss of DC Bus 3A due to steam admission valve not opening and the FCVs not opening could be recovered by manually opening these valves and manually controlling the FCVs using local Indication.

• RECOVERY**

ZHFPTRNAMAN 0.1 097

%ZZDC3A ATPFOAFWB ATPFOAFWC This recovery action was modeled In the HRA Toolbox as event AHFPTRNAMAN. The hardware portion of this recovery was determined by quantifying the gate A0003, giving a failure probability of 0.1083, dwarfing the the human error part of the recovery of 1.4E-3.

This recovery cannot easily be placed into the fault tree itself as it is very cutset-specific. Therefore, the recovery was applied using the recovery rule file to apply it to the individual cutsets.

The probability of the recovery was set to the sum of the hardware and human error probabilities, or 0.1097.

The addition to the recovery rule file is shown below:

"CLEAR RECOVERY FLAGS**

PTN-BFJR-06-001 Rev 0 PTN AFWP B SDP CalcFinal.doc

PTN-BFJR-06-001 Rev. 0 Page 27 of 30

,6ZZDC3A ATPAOAFWB ATPFOAFWC

.77rflDe3A ATDn, F'."B ATPA^AA eF'

%ZZDC3A ATMOTRAIN2

%ZZDC3A AHFAOPUMPB ATPFOAFWC

%ZZDC3A AHFAOPUMPC ATPFOAFWB

%ZZDC3A AHFAOPUMPB ATPAOAFWC

%ZZDC3A AHFAOPUMPC ATPAOAFWB

%ZZDC3A AHFPAFWPTRP ATPFOAFWB ZZAFWPUMPC

%ZZDC3A AHFPAFWPTRP ATPFOAFWC ZZAFWPUMPB

%ZZDC3A AHFPAFWPTRP ATPAOAFWB ZZAFWPUMPC

%ZZDC3A AHFPAFWPTRP ATPAOAFWC ZZAFWPUMPB

%ZZDC3A AROPO-3418 ATPFOAFWC

%ZZDC3A ATPFOAFWB AROPO-3419

%ZZDC3A AROPO-3418 ATPAOAFWC

%ZZDC3A ATPAOAFWB AROPO-3419

%ZZDC3A AMMOCCFAVBD

%ZZDC3A AMMOCCFAVBF

%ZZDC3A AMMOCCFAVDF

%ZZDC3A AMM3SSHV2 ZZU400S

%ZZDC3A ACVNOPD243 ATPFOAFWC

%ZZDC3A ACVNOPD243 ATPFOAFWC

%ZZDC3A ACVNOS003B ATPFOAFWC

%ZZDC3A ACVNOS003C ATPFOAFWB

%ZZDC3A ACVNOPD243 ATPAOAFWC

%ZZDC3A ACVNOPD243 ATPAOAFWC

%ZZDC3A ACVNOS003B ATPAOAFWC

%ZZDC3A ACVNOS003C ATPAOAFWB Added ZHFPTRNAMAN to gate ZREC6 for placeholding.

Mark PTN-BFJR-06-001 Rev 0 PTN AFWP B SDP CalcFinal.doc

PTN-BFJR-0MO1 Rev.0 Page 28 of 30 Plant Response to Loss of AFW 1 : Summary of Turkey Point Hour after a Loss of Feedwater MAAP File Name Event Description Results PTN_,AFWlHRLSGWR_2HHSI_2PORVSGL60 86400 sec run PTN_LOHSlHRlHHSIlPORV_SGL6CHRA 43200 sec run PTNLOHSlHR_2HHSIlPORV_SGL6CHRA 43200 sec run PTN_LOHS1HR_2HHSI_2PORV_SGL6CHRA 43200 sec run PTNLOHSIHR_2HHSI_2PORV_SGL6CNOCD 36000 sec run PTN_LOHS1HR_NOF&B_NOCHG 36000 sec run PTNLOHSlHRNOF&BNOCHGAFWRESTHRA 43200 sec run PTN_LOOP_LOHS1HR_NOF&B_NOCHG 30000 sec PTN_2IN_S1LOCA_LOHS1HR_NOCHG 86400 sec PTN_LOOP_AFW1HRLSGWR_2HHSI_2PORVSGL60 86400 sec run Loss of feedwater Loss of AFW@ lhr SSGFW available Loss of feedwater Loss of AFW/SSGFW @ lhr Bleed & feed initiated (1 HHSIP - 1 PORV) to avoid core uncovery Loss of feedwater Loss of AFW/SSGFW @ lhr Bleed & feed initiated (2 HHSIP - 1 PORV) to avoid core uncovery Loss of feedwater Loss of AFW/SSGFW @ lhr Bleed & feed initiated (2 HHSIP - 2 PORV) to avoid core uncovery Loss of feedwater Loss of AFW/SSGFW @ lhr Bleed & feed initiated (2 HHSIP - 2 PORV) to avoid core damage Loss of feedwater Loss of AFW/SSGFW @ lhr No bleed & feed initiated No charging Loss of feedwater Loss of AFW/SSGFW @ lhr No bleed & feed initiated No charging AFW restored to avoid core damage LOOP/Loss of feedwater Loss of AFW/SSGFW @ lhr No bleed & feed initiated No charging 2" SlLOCA Loss of AFW/SSGFW @ lhr Minimum SI @ 77 sec No charging Loss of feedwater Loss of AFW@ lhr SSGFW available S/G dryout - none Core uncovery - none Fuel damage - none Bleed & feed - none CL recirc - none S/G dryout - none Core uncovery - none Fuel damage - none Bleed & feed - 22596 sec CL recirc - > 43200 sec S/G dryout - none Core uncovery - none Fuel damage - none Bleed & feed - 23166 sec CL recirc - > 43200 sec S/G dryout - none Core uncovery - none Fuel damage - none Bleed & feed - 23746 sec CL recirc - 33132 sec S/G dryout - 26834 sec Core uncovery - 28406 sec Fuel damage - none Bleed & feed - 27646 sec CL recirc - 35861 sec S/G dryout - 25787 sec Core uncovery - 28221 sec Fuel damage - 30657 sec Bleed & feed - n/a CL recirc - n/a S/G dryout - 25787 sec Core uncovery - 28221 sec Fuel damage - none Bleed & feed - n/a CL recirc - n/a AFW restored - 28746 sec S/G dryout - 23810 sec Core uncovery - 26186 sec Fuel damage - 28580 sec Bleed & feed - n/a CL recirc - n/a S/G dryout - none Core uncovery - none Fuel damage - none Bleed & feed - none CL recirc - 78507 sec S/G dryout - none Core uncovery - none Fuel damage - none Bleed & feed - none CL recirc - none PTN-BFJR46-001 Rev 0 PTN AFWP B SDP CalcFinal.doc

PTN-BFJR-06-001 Rev. 0 Page 29 of 30 : Summary of NRC Phase 3 SDP Results sequotice Best Vs. Curfert Roport by DM i 4n cut (b-c)

Project TKPTL3 Analysis: RANDOM Units: Per Year Event Sequence Curr Freq Base fteq Per Dillerence Ratio Curr 1329a Differ*

End it Ie prYear year Cnt Cnt nce State LOQHS 02-07-07 0.000E+00 0.0O0E+00 0.000NE00 O)U00Q&00 O

O O

LOCCW 18 0.000E+00 0.000E+00 0.000E+00 0.000E+o0 0

0 0

GE)

LOCCW 17 3.738E-1 2 3.73SE-12 noooLNoo 1.OWEt00 3

3 0

CD LOCCW 15 0.000E+00 0.0002E00 0.oooE+Do 0.000E400 0

I

.1 CO LOCCW 13 0.000Eo00 0.000E+00 0.00000 O.OOO00Etoo 0 1

.1 CO OCCW 6-06 O.000.E+00 0.000E+00 0.000E+00 O.o0 E+000 O o

0 CD LOCHS 02-02 45 t.4622E-11

.00WE+00 1S002E00 6

O 0

CD LOCCW 26-10 3.331 E-11 3.331 E-11 0000E*00 t

is S

o C

LOCCW aes9 0.000E400 0.000E+00 0.000oE00 0.0002E00 0 OQ 0

CD LOCHS 02-06-15 O.oooE400 0.000E+00 a OOCE.0 0.000E+00 0-0 0

CD LOC 1HS 02-00-17 0.o00E+00 0

0.0002E00 o.oOOE-0 0 0

0 CD LOCcW 26-12 2.331E-11

.832E-11 0.000E200 1.000E400 8 S

0 C6 LOCHS 02-06-18 0.000o+c0 0.000E+00 oooCE+00 0.000E*00 0

0 0

co LOCCW 26-08 0.000E+00 0.000E+00 0.000E+00 0.0o0E+O40 o 0

co LOCHS 02-07403 0.0 0E+oo o0 oE000+0o

.00CE400 0.000E+00 0 o

0 CD LOCHS 02o07-0 O.O000E+00 0.0000E+0 O000E400 0.000E400 0

o 0

0 CO LOCHS 02-04-13

-. OOOE+00 0.000E+00 0.00oE+0O 0 00BE*00 0 0

0 CO LOOP 18-43-3 1.t7E2-11 iAW 11 5.310E-12 1.467Et00 3 5

2 1CD LDC3A 15-11 7.286E-12 2.21lE-13 7.055E-12 a

.153E01 o 14

-11 Co C6HW 13 1.0D6E-11 0.00oE+00 1.096E-1 1 0.000E400 3

0 3 S LOMFW 1a 1217E-11 0.000E+o0 1t217E It 0.000E+00 O

3 CD LOOP

, te i,403E-t1 0.000E 00 1.403E-1l 0.000C.00 e

0 CO MLOCA 12 2.0311-11 238-E.11

.9482-11 3.91-8900 23 9

14 co LOCCW 25-11 9.s12E-11 2.313E-11 68s-9E-1I 4.026E+00 30 12 te CD LOICW 26-11 9.312E-11 Z313E-11 6.99sE-11 4.02SEo00 30 12 18 CD SLOCA 19-11 9.312E-1 1 2.313E1 6.999E-11 4.02E*

30 12 18 CD LOOP 16-45 3.152E.10 2.0o5E21 1.0s7F-10 1.534E400 17 38

-21 CD LOOP 14 1.0282-1o 3.3062-1Z 1.092E-10 o

.823E.01 28 2

26 CD LAC3A 4

4494E-10 5.OS21-12 4.444E-10 8.896E0 44 0

O CD LtIAs 19-11 1.392E-9 4.757E-10 1463E-09 4.076E400 48 T7 91 SLOCAK 18 T.6R52-09 3.B922-11 1.64-06Eg 429E1+oi 33 T13 20 LOOP 19-11 2.470E9 64252.10 1.s2sE40 s.844E400 15 30

-1S CD TP.A4S 14 2.07E-09 1.7642--10 2.A312-09 1.4782.01 109 179

.70 CD LAOB.

-14 3.0022-09 8.1 202-11 I

.0111-09 3.8082.01 27 109

-82 CD LAC3B 15-11 4.873E4-9 1227E-09 3.8646E09 3.0722.00 63 60 13 CD LAC3A

.15-11 4.873E-09 1227E-09 3.S46E-09 32.72E.00 63 SO so 13 sOIR 30 5.5BOE-09 1261E-10 5,4s2E49 4.356E+0-255.

49 206 CD S~iR 32-11 932F.9

.3-060-to

• 80.6092-0 3.004E401 s0 32 CD LOC-S 15.11 2.195e-0a 5.710E-09 1.624E2-8

.3.844E400 72 104

-32 CD LOMFW 15-11 2.439E-08 6.344Es09 1.805E-08 3.845E+00 73 104

-31 CD 1.I 18 4.268E24) 1.32DEi 9 4.1 36E-3214E+01 173 88 87 CD TR1ANS 15-11 1.708E-07 4.449E-08 1263E-07.

3.839E400 95 135

-40 CD G1T R

8 1 1.59aE-07

_6.30E-09 1.544E-07 2.943E401 434 163 271 CD LOOP 17 1.968E407 1.693E2-0 1.7sE4-07 1.162E601 471 299 172 Co LOCHS 14 3.870E-07 1.1 0C-08 3.760E-07 3.518E+01 3.41 214 127 CD LOMFW 14 4.300E-07 1225E-08 4.1704-07 3.6102.01 353 293 60 CD DC3A 14 1.867E-06 2.123E-08 1.8462-00 8 7942.Q 59 212

.153 Co TOTALS 5.6i56E-0 2.473E-06 2287E400 5390 5010 380 200&'12121 Page 22 Modd Rev. 3.31 200511OM28 13:55:45 PTN-BFJR-06-001 Rev 0 PTN AFWP B SDP Calcdoc

PTN-BFJR-06-001 Rev. 0 Page 30 of 30 : SPAR-H Performance Shaping Factors for Execution Pi ant:

Initatitng Event:

Basic Event:

Event Coder:

Baic Event Contexct.

twliG Event DescripUon:__

lArt IL EVALUATE EACH PSF FOR ACTION A. Evaluate PM~ for thicAction Portion of (be TsikJf Any.

ire PSF Level:

Mutlfpler for Please note specIfic reasons few Action PSF level selection In this colum n.

TWiiK:I

'Imd..ue avA*Hirq

__It r(I vqe~.On Time avaiWbe Iis I(b SNe time required 0.0!

SWti MInxim I

LV.I I

0 MoI..

11ga'm.1k InI FitessOX 4 0

Tlul~intlirl~tO crew 0.5 Imsuflkeit ~ Info g.rom

.ny I

[END]

PTN-BFJRI-06-001 RevO0 PTN AFWP B SDP CalcFlnal.doc