ML20210U222: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(StriderTol Bot insert)
 
(StriderTol Bot change)
 
Line 17: Line 17:
=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:.
{{#Wiki_filter:.
                    .                                                                                                                                                                                                                          hO &. l
hO &.
                        +/st:weto                                                                                     UNITED STATES 8                                             o,h                                    NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
+/st:weto o,h UNITED STATES 8
                      ;                                                      j                                    WASHINGTON, D. C. 20555
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION j
                        %, *****ab thy 28,1986 Docket No.                                                     50-213/245/336 LICENSEE: Northeast Nuclear Energy Company (NNECO)
WASHINGTON, D. C. 20555
%, *****ab thy 28,1986 Docket No.
50-213/245/336 LICENSEE: Northeast Nuclear Energy Company (NNECO)
FACILITY: Haddam Neck Plant and Millstone Nuclear Power Station Units 1 and 2
FACILITY: Haddam Neck Plant and Millstone Nuclear Power Station Units 1 and 2


==SUBJECT:==
==SUBJECT:==
==SUMMARY==
==SUMMARY==
OF MAY 14, 1986 MEETING T0' DISCUSS THE STATUS OF OUTSTANDING FIRE PROTECTION REVIEW ISSUES On Wednesday, May 14, 1986 a meeting was held at the NRC offices in Bethesda between representatives of Northeast Utilities and the staff to discuss the status of the review of fire protection issues at Haddam Neck, Millstone I and Millstone 2. A list of the discussions concerning each plant is provided below. A list of attendees is attached.
OF MAY 14, 1986 MEETING T0' DISCUSS THE STATUS OF OUTSTANDING FIRE PROTECTION REVIEW ISSUES On Wednesday, May 14, 1986 a meeting was held at the NRC offices in Bethesda between representatives of Northeast Utilities and the staff to discuss the status of the review of fire protection issues at Haddam Neck, Millstone I and Millstone 2.
A list of the discussions concerning each plant is provided below. A list of attendees is attached.
Haddam Neck With regard to the licensee's September 16, 1985, request for technical exemptions, the staff indicated that its evaluation of these exemptions is being delayed pending receipt of NNEC0's formal response to the issues requiring clarification, which were transmitted to the licensee on March 25, 1986.
Haddam Neck With regard to the licensee's September 16, 1985, request for technical exemptions, the staff indicated that its evaluation of these exemptions is being delayed pending receipt of NNEC0's formal response to the issues requiring clarification, which were transmitted to the licensee on March 25, 1986.
A discussion of those issues followed resulting in the following understandings:
A discussion of those issues followed resulting in the following understandings:
: 1.       The licensee is preparing a document, which should be completed in early June, which updates and revises previously submitted information constituting NNEC0's approach to satisfying the requirements of Appendix R. This document reflects the recent Appendix R reassessment conducted by the licensee. It will contain, in the body of the report or by reference to past correspondence, all of the information requested in Generic Letter 81-12 or its clarification letter.
1.
: 2.     With the exception of an additional exemption for emergency lighting in outside areas, no other exemptions from the requirements of j                             Appendix R will be submitted.
The licensee is preparing a document, which should be completed in early June, which updates and revises previously submitted information constituting NNEC0's approach to satisfying the requirements of Appendix R.
: 3. With the exception of those conditions identified in the licensee's September 16, 1985 submittal, all penetrations of fire area boundaries are fire-rated and conform with the staff's fire protection guidelines.
This document reflects the recent Appendix R reassessment conducted by the licensee.
: 4. All cable re-routing will be done in con.formance with Section III.G.2 of Appendix R to 10 CFR 50.
It will contain, in the body of the report or by reference to past correspondence, all of the information requested in Generic Letter 81-12 or its clarification letter.
8606020251 860528 PDR       ADOCK 05000213 F                   PDR
2.
: 5. All fire barriers required to satisfy Appendix R to 10 CFR 50 and appendix A to BTP APCSB 9.5-1 are covered by the plant technical specifications.
With the exception of an additional exemption for emergency lighting in outside areas, no other exemptions from the requirements of j
: 6. Fire propagation through those HVAC ducts without fire dampers, identified in the September 16, 1985 submittal, will not prevent the plant from being safely shutdown.
Appendix R will be submitted.
: 7. The sprinkler system protecting structural steel is in accordance with the guidelines in NFPA Standard No 231 except for water density requirements.
3.
: 8. The fire barriers with unrated features identified in the September 16, 1986 submittal are not required to protect redundant shutdown divisions.
With the exception of those conditions identified in the licensee's September 16, 1985 submittal, all penetrations of fire area boundaries are fire-rated and conform with the staff's fire protection guidelines.
The staff suggested that .in anticipation of the upcoming Region I audit, and because of the licensee's Appendix R reassessment, the licensee should determine which of the previously approved exemptions in fire protection are still necessary.
4.
All cable re-routing will be done in con.formance with Section III.G.2 of Appendix R to 10 CFR 50.
8606020251 860528 PDR ADOCK 05000213 F
PDR
 
. 5.
All fire barriers required to satisfy Appendix R to 10 CFR 50 and appendix A to BTP APCSB 9.5-1 are covered by the plant technical specifications.
6.
Fire propagation through those HVAC ducts without fire dampers, identified in the September 16, 1985 submittal, will not prevent the plant from being safely shutdown.
7.
The sprinkler system protecting structural steel is in accordance with the guidelines in NFPA Standard No 231 except for water density requirements.
8.
The fire barriers with unrated features identified in the September 16, 1986 submittal are not required to protect redundant shutdown divisions.
The staff suggested that.in anticipation of the upcoming Region I audit, and because of the licensee's Appendix R reassessment, the licensee should determine which of the previously approved exemptions in fire protection are still necessary.
Millstone 1 The licensee provided clarification on several questions arising from the staff's review of NNEC0's request for technical exemptions from the requirements of Appendix R, dated November 21, 1985. The licensee will be submitting a formal response to these questions in the near term. NNEC0 will be submitting an additional exemption request for emergency lighting in outside areas. Also, at the staff's suggestion, the licensee will be providing comments to correct any technical errors on previous staff safety evaluations concerning fire protection.
Millstone 1 The licensee provided clarification on several questions arising from the staff's review of NNEC0's request for technical exemptions from the requirements of Appendix R, dated November 21, 1985. The licensee will be submitting a formal response to these questions in the near term. NNEC0 will be submitting an additional exemption request for emergency lighting in outside areas. Also, at the staff's suggestion, the licensee will be providing comments to correct any technical errors on previous staff safety evaluations concerning fire protection.
As with Haddam Neck, the licensee will be preparing a document which updates and revises previously submitted information constituting NNEC0's approach to satisfying the requirements of Appendix R. This document will reflect the recent Appendix R reassessment conducted by the licensee. It will contain, in the body of the report or by reference, all of the information requested in Generic Letter 82-12 or its clarification letter.
As with Haddam Neck, the licensee will be preparing a document which updates and revises previously submitted information constituting NNEC0's approach to satisfying the requirements of Appendix R.
This document will reflect the recent Appendix R reassessment conducted by the licensee.
It will contain, in the body of the report or by reference, all of the information requested in Generic Letter 82-12 or its clarification letter.
The staff informed the licensee that evaluation of the requested technical exemptions will be delayed pending receipt of the above-referenced information.
The staff informed the licensee that evaluation of the requested technical exemptions will be delayed pending receipt of the above-referenced information.
The staff emphasized that it was important for NNECO to complete this effort well before the anticipated Region I audit, tentatively scheduled for late October 1986.
The staff emphasized that it was important for NNECO to complete this effort well before the anticipated Region I audit, tentatively scheduled for late October 1986.
Millstone 2 The licensee informed the staff that additional technical exemption requests will be submitted. This will be done in conjunction with the preparation of a revised Appendix R compliance report, similar to what is being done for Haddam Neck and Millstone 1.                                            .
Millstone 2 The licensee informed the staff that additional technical exemption requests will be submitted. This will be done in conjunction with the preparation of a revised Appendix R compliance report, similar to what is being done for Haddam Neck and Millstone 1.


9 General The staff advised the licensee regarding certain fire protection concerns that often arise during fire protection audits. The licensee was advised to be prepared to discuss such issues during the planned regional fire protection compliance inspections. These concerns included:
9
: 1. Closure of fire dampers under high air flow.
. General The staff advised the licensee regarding certain fire protection concerns that often arise during fire protection audits. The licensee was advised to be prepared to discuss such issues during the planned regional fire protection compliance inspections. These concerns included:
: 2. Security-related fire door modifications
1.
: 3. Sprinkler system obstructions
Closure of fire dampers under high air flow.
: 4. Smoke stratification and fire detector operation.
2.
                )           .
Security-related fire door modifications 3.
                                              %W           . YP Dennis Ku icki, Mechanical Fire             es J. Shea, Project Manager Protection Engineer                   Integrated Safety Assessment Plant, Electrical, Instrumentation         Project Directorate and Control System Branch             Division of PWR Licensing-- B Division of PWR Licensing - B cc: See Next Page l
Sprinkler system obstructions 4.
Smoke stratification and fire detector operation.
YP
)
% W Dennis Ku icki, Mechanical Fire es J. Shea, Project Manager Protection Engineer Integrated Safety Assessment Plant, Electrical, Instrumentation Project Directorate and Control System Branch Division of PWR Licensing-- B Division of PWR Licensing - B cc: See Next Page


            .                    (                                 <
(
Mr. John F. Opeka                       Haddam Neck Plant &
Mr. John F. Opeka Haddam Neck Plant &
Connecticut Yankee Atomic Power Company Millstone Nuclear Power Station, Northeast Nuclear Energy Company           Unit No. I cc:
Connecticut Yankee Atomic Power Company Millstone Nuclear Power Station, Northeast Nuclear Energy Company Unit No. I cc:
Gerald Garfield, Esquire                 Kevin McCarthy, Director Day, Berry & Howard                       Radiation Control Unit Counselors at Law                         Department of Environmental City Place                               Protection Hartford, Connecticut 06103-3499         State Office Building Hartford, Connecticut 06106 Edward J. Mroczka Vice President, Nuclear Operations       Board of Selectmen Northeast Utilities Service Company       Town Hall Post Office Box 270                       Haddam, Connecticut 06103 Hartford, Connecticut 06141-0270 Superintendent State of Connecticut                       Haddam Neck Plant Office of Policy and Management           RFD #1 ATTN: Under Secretary Energy               Post Office Box 127E Division                       East Hampton, Connecticut 06424 80 Washington Street Hartford, Connecticut 06106               Resident Inspector Haddam Neck Plant Richard M. Kacich, Supervisor             c/o U.S. NRC Operating Nuclear Plant Licensing           East Haddam Post Office Northeast Utilities Service Company         East Haddam, Connecticut 06423 Post Office Box 270 Hartford, Connecticut 06141-0270 Regional Administrator, Region I U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Consnission 631 Park Avenue King of Prussia, Pennsylvania 19406 Northeast Nuclear Energy Company ATTN: Superintendent Millstone Nuclear Power Station P. O. Box 128 Waterford, Connecticut 06385 Resident Inspector                                                                                       i l
Gerald Garfield, Esquire Kevin McCarthy, Director Day, Berry & Howard Radiation Control Unit Counselors at Law Department of Environmental City Place Protection Hartford, Connecticut 06103-3499 State Office Building Hartford, Connecticut 06106 Edward J. Mroczka Vice President, Nuclear Operations Board of Selectmen Northeast Utilities Service Company Town Hall Post Office Box 270 Haddam, Connecticut 06103 Hartford, Connecticut 06141-0270 Superintendent State of Connecticut Haddam Neck Plant Office of Policy and Management RFD #1 ATTN: Under Secretary Energy Post Office Box 127E Division East Hampton, Connecticut 06424 80 Washington Street Hartford, Connecticut 06106 Resident Inspector Haddam Neck Plant Richard M. Kacich, Supervisor c/o U.S. NRC Operating Nuclear Plant Licensing East Haddam Post Office Northeast Utilities Service Company East Haddam, Connecticut 06423 Post Office Box 270 Hartford, Connecticut 06141-0270 Regional Administrator, Region I U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Consnission 631 Park Avenue King of Prussia, Pennsylvania 19406 Northeast Nuclear Energy Company ATTN: Superintendent Millstone Nuclear Power Station P. O. Box 128 Waterford, Connecticut 06385 Resident Inspector c/o U.S. NRC Millstone Nuclear Power Station P. O. Box 811 Niantic, Connecticut 06357 First Selectman of the Town of Waterford Hall of Records 200 Boston Post Road Waterford, Connecticut 06385 9
c/o U.S. NRC                                                                                             '
Millstone Nuclear Power Station P. O. Box 811 Niantic, Connecticut 06357 First Selectman of the Town of Waterford Hall of Records 200 Boston Post Road                                                 -
Waterford, Connecticut 06385 9
L
L


APPENDIX R EXEMPTIONS MEETING MAY 14, 1986 ATTENDEE                   AFFILIATION James J. Shea                         NRC Gerand van Noordennen                 Northeast Utilities - Licensing Dennis Kubicki                       NRC/NRR/PEICSB James W. Naylor                       Northeast Utilities -
APPENDIX R EXEMPTIONS MEETING MAY 14, 1986 ATTENDEE AFFILIATION James J. Shea NRC Gerand van Noordennen Northeast Utilities - Licensing Dennis Kubicki NRC/NRR/PEICSB James W. Naylor Northeast Utilities -
Fire Protection William J. Lepper Northeast Utilities - Electrical Bohdan M. Pokora Northeast Utilities - Reactor Plant Systems                       .
Fire Protection William J. Lepper Northeast Utilities - Electrical Bohdan M. Pokora Northeast Utilities - Reactor Plant Systems Anthony N. Patrizz Northeast Utilities -
Anthony N. Patrizz Northeast Utilities -
Fire Protection l
Fire Protection 1
l M
l l
M


              .                                fiay 28,1986 General The staff advised the licensee regarding certain fire protection concerns that often arise during fire protection audits. The licensee was advised to be prepared to discuss such issues during the planned regional fire protection compliance inspections. These concerns included:
fiay 28,1986
: 1. Closure of fire dampers under high air flow.                             ;
. General The staff advised the licensee regarding certain fire protection concerns that often arise during fire protection audits.
: 2. Security-related fire door modifications
The licensee was advised to be prepared to discuss such issues during the planned regional fire protection compliance inspections. These concerns included:
: 3. Sprinkler system obstructions                                           ;
1.
: 4. Smoke stratification and fire detector operation.
Closure of fire dampers under high air flow.
1 Original signed by: D. Kubicki                 Original signed by: J. Shea Dennis Kubicki, Mechanical Fire             James J. Shea, Project Manager Protection Engineer                     Integrated Safety Assessment Plant, Electrical, Instrumentation           Project Directorate and Control System Branch               Division of PWR Licensing - B Division of PWR Licensing - B cc: See Next Page DISTRIBUTION Docket File 7,
2.
      *'ISAPD Reading' JShea CGrimes PAnderson D0sborne FAkstulewicz Y                             l
Security-related fire door modifications 3.
                                                                                    .h SAP:DPL-B       ISAP:DPL-B     ISAP:DPL-       PU#hDP         ISAP:DPL-B(F I JShea:lt         PAndprson     CGrimes         00sborne       FAkstulewicz 05/31/86         05/88/86       05/t%/86         05g/86         05/d86 i}}
Sprinkler system obstructions 4.
Smoke stratification and fire detector operation.
1 Original signed by: D. Kubicki Original signed by: J. Shea Dennis Kubicki, Mechanical Fire James J. Shea, Project Manager Protection Engineer Integrated Safety Assessment Plant, Electrical, Instrumentation Project Directorate and Control System Branch Division of PWR Licensing - B Division of PWR Licensing - B cc: See Next Page DISTRIBUTION Docket File 7,
*'ISAPD Reading' JShea CGrimes PAnderson D0sborne FAkstulewicz Y
l
.h SAP:DPL-B ISAP:DPL-B ISAP:DPL-PU#hDP ISAP:DPL-B(F I JShea:lt PAndprson CGrimes 00sborne FAkstulewicz 05/31/86 05/88/86 05/t%/86 05g/86 05/d86}}

Latest revision as of 00:58, 6 December 2024

Summary of 860514 Meeting W/Util in Bethesda,Md Re Status of Outstanding Fire Protection Review Issues,Including Util Rept Addressing Generic Ltr 81-12.List of Attendees Encl
ML20210U222
Person / Time
Site: Millstone, Haddam Neck, 05000000
Issue date: 05/28/1986
From: Kubici D, Kubicki D, James Shea
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
To:
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
GL-81-12, NUDOCS 8606020251
Download: ML20210U222 (6)
v • d • e


Text

.

hO &.

+/st:weto o,h UNITED STATES 8

NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION j

WASHINGTON, D. C. 20555

%, *****ab thy 28,1986 Docket No.

50-213/245/336 LICENSEE: Northeast Nuclear Energy Company (NNECO)

FACILITY: Haddam Neck Plant and Millstone Nuclear Power Station Units 1 and 2

SUBJECT:

SUMMARY

OF MAY 14, 1986 MEETING T0' DISCUSS THE STATUS OF OUTSTANDING FIRE PROTECTION REVIEW ISSUES On Wednesday, May 14, 1986 a meeting was held at the NRC offices in Bethesda between representatives of Northeast Utilities and the staff to discuss the status of the review of fire protection issues at Haddam Neck, Millstone I and Millstone 2.

A list of the discussions concerning each plant is provided below. A list of attendees is attached.

Haddam Neck With regard to the licensee's September 16, 1985, request for technical exemptions, the staff indicated that its evaluation of these exemptions is being delayed pending receipt of NNEC0's formal response to the issues requiring clarification, which were transmitted to the licensee on March 25, 1986.

A discussion of those issues followed resulting in the following understandings:

1.

The licensee is preparing a document, which should be completed in early June, which updates and revises previously submitted information constituting NNEC0's approach to satisfying the requirements of Appendix R.

This document reflects the recent Appendix R reassessment conducted by the licensee.

It will contain, in the body of the report or by reference to past correspondence, all of the information requested in Generic Letter 81-12 or its clarification letter.

2.

With the exception of an additional exemption for emergency lighting in outside areas, no other exemptions from the requirements of j

Appendix R will be submitted.

3.

With the exception of those conditions identified in the licensee's September 16, 1985 submittal, all penetrations of fire area boundaries are fire-rated and conform with the staff's fire protection guidelines.

4.

All cable re-routing will be done in con.formance with Section III.G.2 of Appendix R to 10 CFR 50.

8606020251 860528 PDR ADOCK 05000213 F

PDR

. 5.

All fire barriers required to satisfy Appendix R to 10 CFR 50 and appendix A to BTP APCSB 9.5-1 are covered by the plant technical specifications.

6.

Fire propagation through those HVAC ducts without fire dampers, identified in the September 16, 1985 submittal, will not prevent the plant from being safely shutdown.

7.

The sprinkler system protecting structural steel is in accordance with the guidelines in NFPA Standard No 231 except for water density requirements.

8.

The fire barriers with unrated features identified in the September 16, 1986 submittal are not required to protect redundant shutdown divisions.

The staff suggested that.in anticipation of the upcoming Region I audit, and because of the licensee's Appendix R reassessment, the licensee should determine which of the previously approved exemptions in fire protection are still necessary.

Millstone 1 The licensee provided clarification on several questions arising from the staff's review of NNEC0's request for technical exemptions from the requirements of Appendix R, dated November 21, 1985. The licensee will be submitting a formal response to these questions in the near term. NNEC0 will be submitting an additional exemption request for emergency lighting in outside areas. Also, at the staff's suggestion, the licensee will be providing comments to correct any technical errors on previous staff safety evaluations concerning fire protection.

As with Haddam Neck, the licensee will be preparing a document which updates and revises previously submitted information constituting NNEC0's approach to satisfying the requirements of Appendix R.

This document will reflect the recent Appendix R reassessment conducted by the licensee.

It will contain, in the body of the report or by reference, all of the information requested in Generic Letter 82-12 or its clarification letter.

The staff informed the licensee that evaluation of the requested technical exemptions will be delayed pending receipt of the above-referenced information.

The staff emphasized that it was important for NNECO to complete this effort well before the anticipated Region I audit, tentatively scheduled for late October 1986.

Millstone 2 The licensee informed the staff that additional technical exemption requests will be submitted. This will be done in conjunction with the preparation of a revised Appendix R compliance report, similar to what is being done for Haddam Neck and Millstone 1.

9

. General The staff advised the licensee regarding certain fire protection concerns that often arise during fire protection audits. The licensee was advised to be prepared to discuss such issues during the planned regional fire protection compliance inspections. These concerns included:

1.

Closure of fire dampers under high air flow.

2.

Security-related fire door modifications 3.

Sprinkler system obstructions 4.

Smoke stratification and fire detector operation.

YP

)

% W Dennis Ku icki, Mechanical Fire es J. Shea, Project Manager Protection Engineer Integrated Safety Assessment Plant, Electrical, Instrumentation Project Directorate and Control System Branch Division of PWR Licensing-- B Division of PWR Licensing - B cc: See Next Page

(

Mr. John F. Opeka Haddam Neck Plant &

Connecticut Yankee Atomic Power Company Millstone Nuclear Power Station, Northeast Nuclear Energy Company Unit No. I cc:

Gerald Garfield, Esquire Kevin McCarthy, Director Day, Berry & Howard Radiation Control Unit Counselors at Law Department of Environmental City Place Protection Hartford, Connecticut 06103-3499 State Office Building Hartford, Connecticut 06106 Edward J. Mroczka Vice President, Nuclear Operations Board of Selectmen Northeast Utilities Service Company Town Hall Post Office Box 270 Haddam, Connecticut 06103 Hartford, Connecticut 06141-0270 Superintendent State of Connecticut Haddam Neck Plant Office of Policy and Management RFD #1 ATTN: Under Secretary Energy Post Office Box 127E Division East Hampton, Connecticut 06424 80 Washington Street Hartford, Connecticut 06106 Resident Inspector Haddam Neck Plant Richard M. Kacich, Supervisor c/o U.S. NRC Operating Nuclear Plant Licensing East Haddam Post Office Northeast Utilities Service Company East Haddam, Connecticut 06423 Post Office Box 270 Hartford, Connecticut 06141-0270 Regional Administrator, Region I U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Consnission 631 Park Avenue King of Prussia, Pennsylvania 19406 Northeast Nuclear Energy Company ATTN: Superintendent Millstone Nuclear Power Station P. O. Box 128 Waterford, Connecticut 06385 Resident Inspector c/o U.S. NRC Millstone Nuclear Power Station P. O. Box 811 Niantic, Connecticut 06357 First Selectman of the Town of Waterford Hall of Records 200 Boston Post Road Waterford, Connecticut 06385 9

L

APPENDIX R EXEMPTIONS MEETING MAY 14, 1986 ATTENDEE AFFILIATION James J. Shea NRC Gerand van Noordennen Northeast Utilities - Licensing Dennis Kubicki NRC/NRR/PEICSB James W. Naylor Northeast Utilities -

Fire Protection William J. Lepper Northeast Utilities - Electrical Bohdan M. Pokora Northeast Utilities - Reactor Plant Systems Anthony N. Patrizz Northeast Utilities -

Fire Protection l

l M

fiay 28,1986

. General The staff advised the licensee regarding certain fire protection concerns that often arise during fire protection audits.

The licensee was advised to be prepared to discuss such issues during the planned regional fire protection compliance inspections. These concerns included:

1.

Closure of fire dampers under high air flow.

2.

Security-related fire door modifications 3.

Sprinkler system obstructions 4.

Smoke stratification and fire detector operation.

1 Original signed by: D. Kubicki Original signed by: J. Shea Dennis Kubicki, Mechanical Fire James J. Shea, Project Manager Protection Engineer Integrated Safety Assessment Plant, Electrical, Instrumentation Project Directorate and Control System Branch Division of PWR Licensing - B Division of PWR Licensing - B cc: See Next Page DISTRIBUTION Docket File 7,

  • 'ISAPD Reading' JShea CGrimes PAnderson D0sborne FAkstulewicz Y

l

.h SAP:DPL-B ISAP:DPL-B ISAP:DPL-PU#hDP ISAP:DPL-B(F I JShea:lt PAndprson CGrimes 00sborne FAkstulewicz 05/31/86 05/88/86 05/t%/86 05g/86 05/d86

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20210U222&oldid=4014586"