ML21096A077: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(StriderTol Bot change)
(StriderTol Bot change)
Line 15: Line 15:


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:}}
{{#Wiki_filter:Turkey Point Unit 3 and Unit 4 Reactor Protection System Engineered Safety Feature Actuation System Nuclear Instrumentation System Replacements Safety System Replacement Project LAR NRC 4th Presubmittal Meeting Telecon April 8, 2021 OPEN MEETING 1              Non-proprietary information suitable for public disclosure
 
Agenda - Open and Closed Sessions
* Open Session
    - Action Items From Feb 18th Presubmittal Meeting
    - Vendor Oversight Procedure Implementation
    - Next Pre-submittal Meeting Content and Schedule
* Closed Session
    - Architecture Overview
    - Human System Interface Overview
    - Human Factors Engineering Program Plan
    - Cybersecurity Overview
    - Technical Specification Surveillance Extension/Reduction
    - Lifecycle Schedule 2                  Non-proprietary information suitable for public disclosure
 
Introductions - Project Team
* FPL Nuclear Licensing
* Steve Catron - Licensing Fleet Manager
* Jarrett Mack - Fleet Licensing Lead
* David Stoia - Turkey Point Site Licensing Lead
* Bill Maher - Improved Technical Specification Project Director
* FPL Nuclear Engineering
* Brian Dunn - Fleet Design Director
* Phil Barnes - Design Engineering Manager
* Wes Frewin - Fleet Digital Design Supervisor
* Warren Busch - Project Engineer
* FPL Nuclear Oversight
* Rich Baird - Nuclear Oversight & Assessment Director
* FPL Information Technology
* Brian Derrico -Cybersecurity Manager
* Framatome
* Ron Legrand - Project Manager
* Brian Haynes - Licensing Lead
* Taha Abdelnaeem - Engineering Lead
* Ted Quinn - Licensing Engineer
* Jerry Mauck - Licensing Engineer
* Ron Jarrett - Licensing Engineer
* Rick Turk - Licensing Engineer (HFE)
* Bill Hannaman - Licensing Engineer (HFE)
* Sargent & Lundy -Third Party Review
* Pareez Golub 3                    Non-proprietary information suitable for public disclosure
 
Open Items from February 18th th Open Meeting
* Vendor oversight implementation procedure information
* Coordination with ITS submittal and approval process
* Lessons learned from NRC workshop Feb 10 th
    - Feedback on additional information from NRC on inspection procedures
* LAR Presentation (recommended for future meeting)
    - Method of PSAI info presentation
    - Tech Spec Extension/Reduction structure - compartmentalized
    - LAR commitments
* Establishment of e-reading room at the time of LAR submittal 4                      Non-proprietary information suitable for public disclosure
 
Vendor Oversight Plan - Implementing Procedures
* Follow-up from previous pre-submittal meetings to provide detail on oversight activity implementation
* Vendor Oversight Plan content
    - Describes the implementation of vendor oversight activities within the structure of FPL procedures
    - Lists procedure actions required that are oversight activities
    - Identifies programmatic plans and procedures, activities, and documents included in the scope of oversight activities
    - Identifies regulatory and industry guidance on acceptance criteria that flow down to document reviews
    - Includes references to documentation of oversight activity completion
* Procedures directly involved
    - Quality Assurance
    - Engineering
    - Project Management
    - Information Technology (Cyber Security) 5                      Non-proprietary information suitable for public disclosure
 
Vendor Oversight Plan - Implementing Procedures
* Quality Assurance
  - Scope of QA oversight activities consistent with applicable portions of NRC Inspection Manual, Inspection Procedure 35017, Quality Assurance Implementation Acceptance
  - Audit Topic Selection and Scheduling - Defines scope, activities, protocol
  - Performance of Nuclear Assurance Audits - audit preparation, execution and documentation of audit reports and finding resolution
* Engineering Procedures
  - Implementation and Design Output Criterion, ML19087A230
  - Control of Design Interfaces - control of receipt, distribution, review of vendor prepared documents, adequacy of deliverables
  - Hardware Supplier Oversight - tabulates programmatic elements, deliverables, and acceptance criteria for activities performed at vendor facilities. Includes software development
  - Engineering Risk Assessment and Mitigation - identify and address risk significant technical work, management oversight and 3rd party reviews
  - Cyber Security Controls for Systems Development Lifecycle - review approval of technical and management cyber security controls
  - Standard Design Process/Design Change Packages - Stakeholder reviews of evaluations and implementation documents 6                      Non-proprietary information suitable for public disclosure
 
Vendor Oversight Plan - Implementing Procedures
* Project and Risk Management Procedures
    - Nuclear Contract Management - requires document reviews by appropriate plant departments, challenge boards with senior management, field activity monitoring plan for installation phase
    - Project Management - assessment of project risk and mitigation, oversight quality plan including vendor oversight, stakeholder reviews of implementation documents, readiness challenge prior to installation
    - Nuclear Project Risk Management - evaluation of risks including vendor capability and performance, mitigation including vendor oversight and 3rd party reviews. Senior site management and vendor status meetings
* Information Technology
    - Cyber Security Process - review of vendor configuration management and secure environment, review of design and assessments
    - Information Security Requirements for the Procurement of Data and Services - trustworthiness of vendors, protection of supply chain from cyber threats End of VOP Procedure slides 7                        Non-proprietary information suitable for public disclosure
 
Future Pre-submittal Recommended Meeting Agenda Items
* Any open items from todays meeting, follow-up on existing open items
* License Amendment Request overview presentation
    - Method for addressing Plant Specific Action Items
    - Technical Specification extension/reduction structure/format
    - LAR commitments
* Diversity and Defense in Depth Evaluation Update
* Simulator and Training Plan and Schedule 8                  Non-proprietary information suitable for public disclosure
 
Thank you!
Questions/Comments?
9      Non-proprietary information suitable for public disclosure
 
Acronym List Actuation Logic Test                                                        ALT Anticipated Operational Occurrence                                          AOO Channel Calibration Test                                                    CCT Channel Check                                                                CC Channel Operational Test                                                    COT Digital Input/Digital Output                                                DI/DO Engineered Safety Features Actuation System                                  ESFAS Factory Acceptance Test                                                      FAT Florida Power and Light                                                      FPL Functional Requirements Analysis                                            FRA Framatome USA                                                                Framatome Human Factors Engineering                                                    HFE Human System Interface                                                      HSI Implementation Plan                                                          IP Independent Verification and Validation                                      IV&V Institute of Electrical and Electronic Engineers                            IEEE Improved Standard Technical Specifications                                  ITS Interim Staff G7uidance                                                      ISG 10                          Non-proprietary information suitable for public disclosure
 
Acronym List License Amendment Request                                                LAR Limiting Condition for Operation                                        LCO Nuclear Instrumentation System                                          NIS Operating Experience                                                    OE Reactor Protection System                                                RPS Safe Development and Operational Environment                            SDOE Specified Acceptable Fuel Design Limits                                  SAFDL Safety Evaluation Report                                                SER Surveillance Frequency Control Program                                  SFCP Safety Video Display Unit                                                SVDU Technical Specification                                                  Tech Spec (TS)
Tricon Communication Module                                              TCM Tricon PLC                                                              Tricon Triple Modular Redundant                                                TMR Turkey Point Nuclear Plant Units 3 & 4                                  T.P. 3&4 United States Nuclear Regulator Commission                              NRC Updated Final Safety Analysis Report                                    UFSAR Vendor Oversight Plan                                                    VOP 11                        Non-proprietary information suitable for public disclosure}}

Revision as of 12:29, 9 September 2021

FPL Slides for Meeting with FPL-Turkey Point Units 3 and 4 Concerning Digital Instrumentation and Control Modification
ML21096A077
Person / Time
Site: Turkey Point  NextEra Energy icon.png
Issue date: 04/08/2021
From:
Florida Power & Light Co
To: Adrienne Brown
NRC/NRR/DORL/LPL2-2
Brown E
References
Download: ML21096A077 (11)


Text

Turkey Point Unit 3 and Unit 4 Reactor Protection System Engineered Safety Feature Actuation System Nuclear Instrumentation System Replacements Safety System Replacement Project LAR NRC 4th Presubmittal Meeting Telecon April 8, 2021 OPEN MEETING 1 Non-proprietary information suitable for public disclosure

Agenda - Open and Closed Sessions

  • Open Session

- Action Items From Feb 18th Presubmittal Meeting

- Vendor Oversight Procedure Implementation

- Next Pre-submittal Meeting Content and Schedule

  • Closed Session

- Architecture Overview

- Human System Interface Overview

- Human Factors Engineering Program Plan

- Cybersecurity Overview

- Technical Specification Surveillance Extension/Reduction

- Lifecycle Schedule 2 Non-proprietary information suitable for public disclosure

Introductions - Project Team

  • FPL Nuclear Licensing
  • Steve Catron - Licensing Fleet Manager
  • Jarrett Mack - Fleet Licensing Lead
  • David Stoia - Turkey Point Site Licensing Lead
  • Bill Maher - Improved Technical Specification Project Director
  • FPL Nuclear Engineering
  • Brian Dunn - Fleet Design Director
  • Phil Barnes - Design Engineering Manager
  • Wes Frewin - Fleet Digital Design Supervisor
  • Warren Busch - Project Engineer
  • FPL Nuclear Oversight
  • Rich Baird - Nuclear Oversight & Assessment Director
  • FPL Information Technology
  • Brian Derrico -Cybersecurity Manager
  • Ron Legrand - Project Manager
  • Brian Haynes - Licensing Lead
  • Taha Abdelnaeem - Engineering Lead
  • Ted Quinn - Licensing Engineer
  • Jerry Mauck - Licensing Engineer
  • Ron Jarrett - Licensing Engineer
  • Rick Turk - Licensing Engineer (HFE)
  • Bill Hannaman - Licensing Engineer (HFE)
  • Sargent & Lundy -Third Party Review
  • Pareez Golub 3 Non-proprietary information suitable for public disclosure

Open Items from February 18th th Open Meeting

  • Vendor oversight implementation procedure information
  • Coordination with ITS submittal and approval process
  • Lessons learned from NRC workshop Feb 10 th

- Feedback on additional information from NRC on inspection procedures

  • LAR Presentation (recommended for future meeting)

- Method of PSAI info presentation

- Tech Spec Extension/Reduction structure - compartmentalized

- LAR commitments

  • Establishment of e-reading room at the time of LAR submittal 4 Non-proprietary information suitable for public disclosure

Vendor Oversight Plan - Implementing Procedures

  • Follow-up from previous pre-submittal meetings to provide detail on oversight activity implementation
  • Vendor Oversight Plan content

- Describes the implementation of vendor oversight activities within the structure of FPL procedures

- Lists procedure actions required that are oversight activities

- Identifies programmatic plans and procedures, activities, and documents included in the scope of oversight activities

- Identifies regulatory and industry guidance on acceptance criteria that flow down to document reviews

- Includes references to documentation of oversight activity completion

  • Procedures directly involved

- Quality Assurance

- Engineering

- Project Management

- Information Technology (Cyber Security) 5 Non-proprietary information suitable for public disclosure

Vendor Oversight Plan - Implementing Procedures

  • Quality Assurance

- Scope of QA oversight activities consistent with applicable portions of NRC Inspection Manual, Inspection Procedure 35017, Quality Assurance Implementation Acceptance

- Audit Topic Selection and Scheduling - Defines scope, activities, protocol

- Performance of Nuclear Assurance Audits - audit preparation, execution and documentation of audit reports and finding resolution

  • Engineering Procedures

- Implementation and Design Output Criterion, ML19087A230

- Control of Design Interfaces - control of receipt, distribution, review of vendor prepared documents, adequacy of deliverables

- Hardware Supplier Oversight - tabulates programmatic elements, deliverables, and acceptance criteria for activities performed at vendor facilities. Includes software development

- Engineering Risk Assessment and Mitigation - identify and address risk significant technical work, management oversight and 3rd party reviews

- Cyber Security Controls for Systems Development Lifecycle - review approval of technical and management cyber security controls

- Standard Design Process/Design Change Packages - Stakeholder reviews of evaluations and implementation documents 6 Non-proprietary information suitable for public disclosure

Vendor Oversight Plan - Implementing Procedures

  • Project and Risk Management Procedures

- Nuclear Contract Management - requires document reviews by appropriate plant departments, challenge boards with senior management, field activity monitoring plan for installation phase

- Project Management - assessment of project risk and mitigation, oversight quality plan including vendor oversight, stakeholder reviews of implementation documents, readiness challenge prior to installation

- Nuclear Project Risk Management - evaluation of risks including vendor capability and performance, mitigation including vendor oversight and 3rd party reviews. Senior site management and vendor status meetings

  • Information Technology

- Cyber Security Process - review of vendor configuration management and secure environment, review of design and assessments

- Information Security Requirements for the Procurement of Data and Services - trustworthiness of vendors, protection of supply chain from cyber threats End of VOP Procedure slides 7 Non-proprietary information suitable for public disclosure

Future Pre-submittal Recommended Meeting Agenda Items

  • Any open items from todays meeting, follow-up on existing open items
  • License Amendment Request overview presentation

- Method for addressing Plant Specific Action Items

- Technical Specification extension/reduction structure/format

- LAR commitments

  • Diversity and Defense in Depth Evaluation Update
  • Simulator and Training Plan and Schedule 8 Non-proprietary information suitable for public disclosure

Thank you!

Questions/Comments?

9 Non-proprietary information suitable for public disclosure

Acronym List Actuation Logic Test ALT Anticipated Operational Occurrence AOO Channel Calibration Test CCT Channel Check CC Channel Operational Test COT Digital Input/Digital Output DI/DO Engineered Safety Features Actuation System ESFAS Factory Acceptance Test FAT Florida Power and Light FPL Functional Requirements Analysis FRA Framatome USA Framatome Human Factors Engineering HFE Human System Interface HSI Implementation Plan IP Independent Verification and Validation IV&V Institute of Electrical and Electronic Engineers IEEE Improved Standard Technical Specifications ITS Interim Staff G7uidance ISG 10 Non-proprietary information suitable for public disclosure

Acronym List License Amendment Request LAR Limiting Condition for Operation LCO Nuclear Instrumentation System NIS Operating Experience OE Reactor Protection System RPS Safe Development and Operational Environment SDOE Specified Acceptable Fuel Design Limits SAFDL Safety Evaluation Report SER Surveillance Frequency Control Program SFCP Safety Video Display Unit SVDU Technical Specification Tech Spec (TS)

Tricon Communication Module TCM Tricon PLC Tricon Triple Modular Redundant TMR Turkey Point Nuclear Plant Units 3 & 4 T.P. 3&4 United States Nuclear Regulator Commission NRC Updated Final Safety Analysis Report UFSAR Vendor Oversight Plan VOP 11 Non-proprietary information suitable for public disclosure