ML20211D902

Staff Requirements Memo Re Phase II of Insp Rept of Seismic Reverification Program.Commission Agreed to Take No Action Re Eligibility of Rl Cloud Assoc,Inc to Be Independent Auditor for Reverification Program & to Release Phase II

ML20211D902
Person / Time
Site:	05000000, Diablo Canyon
Issue date:	02/17/1982
From:	Chilk S NRC OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY (SECY)
To:	Bickwit L, Dircks W, Kammerer C NRC OFFICE OF CONGRESSIONAL AFFAIRS (OCA), NRC OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR FOR OPERATIONS (EDO), NRC OFFICE OF THE GENERAL COUNSEL (OGC)
Shared Package
ML20209B094	List: CLI-81-30, Forwards Ltr to Util Re Approval of Teledyne Engineering Svcs 820402 Plan for Phase I of Independent Design Verification Program Per Commission Order CLI-81-30 & Request for Addl Info DD-82-10, Advises That Commission (W/O Commissioner Gilinsky) Has Agreed Not to Review DD-82-10 ML20209B088 ML20209B108 ML20209B121 ML20209B128 ML20209B163 ML20209B182 ML20209B189 ML20209B195 ML20209B200 ML20209B230 ML20209B236 ML20209B240 ML20209B252 ML20209B259 ML20209B324 ML20209B341 ML20209B345 ML20209B351 ML20209B360 ML20209B427 ML20209B433 ML20209B439 ML20209B498 ML20209B507 ML20209B533 ML20209B551 ML20209B566 ML20209B585 ML20209B591 ML20209B618 ML20209B630 ML20209B638 ML20209B642 ML20209B665 ML20209B669 ML20209B676 ML20209B690 ML20209B703 ML20209B780 ML20209B787 ML20209B794 ML20209B805 ML20209B818 ML20209B828 ML20209B832 ML20209B837 ML20209B841 ML20209B850 ... further results
References
REF-10CFR9.7 M820209, NUDOCS 8702240177
Download: ML20211D902 (2)

Text

..

,*' n, IN RESPONSE, PLEASE e

o UNITED STATES REFER TOs M820209 Ps NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMJSSION" n

{ g ju,E W ASHINGTON,0.C.205 Cys: Dircks 1

C, eh g

1 Februa 8

St lo p

OFFICE OF THE On SECRETARY LI!MIED DISTRIBUTION eYoung y

Cunningt Engelker MEMORANDUM FOR:

J.lliam J. Dircks, Executive Director for Operations

[

Leonard Bickwit, Jr., General Counsel Carlton Kammerer, Director, Congressional Affairs t

Joseph J. Fouchard, Dire r, Public Affair

-- j FROM Samuel J. Chilk, Secret

,M g

SUBJECT:

STAFF REQUIREMENTS - DISC /

ION OF PHASE II OFDIABLOCANYONREPORT,[INERS'0 P.M.,

TUESDAY, y FEBRUARY 9, 1982, COMMISS CONFERENCE ROOM, DC OFFICE (CLOSED TO PUBLIC ATTENDANCE)

I.

The Commission discussed Phase II of the Inspection Report of " Preliminary Report, Seismic Reverification Program" at Diablo Canyon Nuclear Power Plant, Units l_

and 2,.

The Commission agreed to take no action concerning the eligibility of R. L. Cloud Associates, Inc., to be independent auditor for the Reverification Program based on Phase II of the report.

The Commission unanimously agreed to release Phase II of the report.

(OPA)

The Commission noted that copies would be served on the parties in accordance with the December 23 Commission Order providing parties seven (7) days to comment on the report.

(OGC)

(Subsequently, the document was served on the parties.)

II.

The Commission discussed a February 8 letter from Congressman Udall.

The Commission requested OCA:

(1) to ascertain from Congressman Udall's staff whether the Congressman was aware of the Peer Group's role in the investigation (2) to determine if Congressman Udall had any particular concerns that prompted the letter; LIMITED DISTRIBUTION

p'

= -

-r.

.,p

.. a :. y e,-., -

A '

2

(

4-

/

.- ( 3 )

to notify the Committee on Interior and Insular Affairs that Phases I and II of the report had

- been released to.the public and that parties have

~

been provided time to comment thereon.

- (OCA)

(Subsequently,'on 2/9 OCA met with Congressman-Udall's staff.)

III. The Commission requested the Peer Panel to document their. findings regarding the report.

Qp (EDO)

(SECY Suspense:

2/24/82) brf+ W f w n-ir-rp.

cc:

Chairman Palladino Commissioner Gilinsky Commissioner Bradford Commissioner Ahearne l

Commissioner Roberts Commission Staff offices em m G

1 0

l 6

l e

e t

i e

e i

J

..m.

.~,..

..s.

-e.m..

.=

..=-=.=-_-===_,--,,-,-mwn,

,,,,,,-,m.,.

,,--* * " * = *. - *. *... -,.

m

• * ~ * =

=+*==eewup***

• d

- ~

a

-,.--rm.-.

w_%,

',,f.:

[

[

j*

g y

i

'~

Docket No: 50-275 FEB 191982 APPLICANT:

Pacific Gas & Electric Company FACILITY:

Diablo Canyon. Unit 1

SUBJECT:

SitGARY OF MEETING OM FEBRUARY 3.1982 WITH PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC CCMPANY TO DISCUSS THE SEISHIC NERIFICATION PROGRAM (PHASE 1) FOR DIABLO CANYON A meeting was held on February 3,1982 at the NRC officos in Cat"esda, Maryland.

This meeting had been previously scheduled for Jansury 19, 19R2. is a list of attendees and Enclousre 2 is the meeting agenda.

The NRC staff discussed with representatives of the Pacific Gas A Electric Comnany (PGaE)

R. L. Cloud Associatas. Inc. (RLCA), R. F. Ro<wfy, Inc.

(subcontractor o RLCA), and Teledyne issues regarding tha preposed PGaE plan for the seismic verification program-phase 1. is a list-ing of items that were discussed at the meetina (previously attached to the neeting notice dated January 8.19R2). is an NRC lettar dated January 28, 1982 to PGAE which centains five additional it::ms discussed at the meeting. A verbatim record of the r.aeting was kept and is attached as Enclosure 5.

This material is relevant to the Diablo Canyon Safety issue on seismic design adecuency which is currently tafore the Comission for consideration.

h &r Hans'E. Schier11ng Reverification Program l

Licensing Branch No. 3 Division of Licensino

Enclosures:

As stated cc w/ enclosures:

see next page

/

jyp,

}

See attached sheet for distribution o,.o p'.0L:LB=3 1

DL:

=2

..i>!H5chierh no: ph qlia 62030902B2 820219 PDH ADOCK 05000275 om > 2/ h,

/82 2/ /

/82 P

PDR

~

,,wc. c. o7. o e. w o. __-

_..........t...

.-...__.t 40 OFFICIAL RECORD COPY

a.;%F :.

,.w'. :;; -

^ *

• T.

-.'.. m..... '

.> w... n.-g.

. y;, -< 19._, ;" -. *,,_-,

~

y\\

s.

. f. ;. g. ".*...",?

• r *

.. _.., x..

g..,,.

l.

-}, r

.3 3 :.1;;'

,..,.s,

~

• . -},-. :.,,

r.,-

.4,

'* e',,"'

.n,-

~ ry

..,.7 s

DIABLO CANYON

~

g' Mr. Malcolm H. Furbush

..1: *

~

Vice President - General Counsel

~.d'~

Pacific Gas & Electric. Company.

'~

P.O. Box 7441 U.li '^

i San Francisco, California 94120

... ~

l

~

cc:

• Philip' A. Crane, Jr., Esq.

c..,,i'$/'.

1, Pacific Gas & Electric Company, '.

1 '

- ",~ ' -

P.O. Box 7442 q.

~ :' '../.4 '. F :,.

~

~

San Francisco, California.'.94120 u :-.

m-

7. :

'Janice E. Kerr, Esq J-California Public Utilities'Comission _

~

350 McAllister Street San Francisco, California 94102,.

.~

+

.~

Mir. Frederick Eissler, President -

Scenic Shoreline Preservation Conference, Inc..

4623 More Mesa Drive 1

.~

Santa Barbara, California ? 93105 -

f-.'

Hs. Elizabeth Apfelberg.

14.15 Cozadero'

~

~

San Luis Obispo, California. 93401

~

...7

.. ;>:,7.:

3

' : r.

i.

' tr Gordon A. Silver l T,. O ".75

' '. & -1 *-, ii.'.'['. Q* ~ ".

'~

Ms. Sandra A. Silver.

1760 Alisal Street.

m e

San Luis Obispo California 93401,

}.,

tarry M. Wil M s.Esq.

.^ 7

~

Seymour & Willis

.~

601 California Street, Suite 2100

'~

San Francisco, California 94108 ;

~

?:

Hr. Richard Hubbard.

i.

!!HB Technical Associates.

Suite K 1723 Hamilton Avenue-

~

A' a -

San Jose, Cali forni.a 95125 i

c..

.Mr. John !!arrs,JManaging Editor San Luis Obispo County Telegram-Tribune

(

e 1321 Johnson Avenue

~

P. O. Box 112.

San Luis Obispo, California 93406

• Withcut Enclosure 3.

+. ~.

s

=. ~:

~..c,).f'gf. 'r d..}b y u.

~,.

+

a=

3

+

ocg

r..

.u

., a., -

).,, *,1, j... *

'n.

.~ b d'.(.p, y

-.y3

.. h '.].g,;-kl.['. ~].y. ;

y,.

.A

(*

p.

.{-

..;Q.y.42.

.:.Q: :...,.....

.;.n,.

.y..

gg.

. 4.,

..+

. n./..:

<t

. "...:. i.:r:

. R..:. :u.c c.

~y_.=-

..;.W:..;;:

' Mr. Malcols H. Furbus'h;

~ -m;y p;~~.o;:y" ; ;; y a.t

~ '

~

^

r.2 < '

3

^

2

.,.,. -n. u.-

:. -

.p w

....w.,_.,

e..

. e,

,3 ;.

~

cc: Resident Inspector /Diablo Canyon NPS

~

c/o U. S.' Nuclear R' gulatery. Comission

~

e P. O. Box 369 e,..ir? > n s N - N? " ~.,

Avila' Beach, California' 93424.,. -..,; p. 1 - 1,.

,u

". r....

. ~., -

~

• Ms. Raye ficming..vp#

.s.

3 ;. _

-.gy?;l.7 $

W...'. '. ; ? ' 3h,:.,..Y.j;%.y '-J L,:

1920 Nattie Road

. c'.

9344. 0-

.;,.?

'9

~

. Shell Beach, California

, ;,,,.,,.... ?

Joel Re'ynolds Esq.

f-John R..Phillips,'Esq.. ' '..

C.

Center for Law in the Public. Interest -

~

10951 West Pico Boulevard. '

'." ' E.-

Third Floor 7.

i Los Angeles, California -90064. -

,p,.

.g.'

+

-./.

1. aul C'. Valentine,. Esq

.~

~

321 Lytton Avenue ~ ~

Palo Alto, California ' 94302

. 7.

...,.- m :

,:...e. cg' -;.s, :

+..

7.

~.

Mr. Byron S. Georgiov -

..x... o s. '.

a O 'A A.. 1,...

Legal Affairs Secretary M

' NdW

. Governor's Office:

Y C

-State Capitol.

'. M.~c? 9.f"iff W [. '

c

.c

' Sacramento,. California. 95814- ' /.. :

.. : ;.....;i.

..a...

Herbert H. Brown, Esq. '.

Hill, Christopher & Phillips ' P.C. -

1900 M Street, N.W.. C

.: /

+.. F

. ;..c.

Washington, D.C.

20036:

n p&

~

~3.,

• Mr. Richard E. Blanke'nburg, Co. Publisher

\\

~

Mr.. Wayne A. Soroyan,. News Reporter s

s Louth County Publishing Cmpany.

.,,~

?

P. O. Box 460.

s '.

Arroyo Grande, Calf fornia "93420 9..xlp.,

Mr.. James 0.. Schuy'ler Vice President

. Nuclear Ge.biation Department.

Paci fic Gas & Electr.ic. C~mpany '

P.O. Box 7442 i

~ '

San Frar.cisco, California 94120 Bruce Norton, Esq.

~

Suite 202 3216 North 3rd Street.

Phoenix, Arizona 85312

'f

~-.

~

a.

• Without Enclosure 3.

...:.... +s:..

.g.,....

p,;.. y p ? y & y pi.*i., g g -'.s. {: g,..,,, '..

c...

g.y,j 7,,

~

S,, :W.....,.

- */2 z-n...

s..i.

..c.

.~

T,".,

....u...

.v...... '.-

... -..'.. -. g.... '..,.,...s

.s te t, u.1.,a,,

.,e y i.v.s..,.....v

' E.....=

.. T....V T J 3.

. '.... ' i. 9,h.

Mr. Malcolm H. Furbush '.

.w s,.x 3.:..

....... g.y-....

. <., *.. e....

.. s ; a..

.+. "...

c.. -

Mr. W. C.' Gangloff,..- ~..

.w' w.,.

.w.....

~~

y....

N i E.

i.

Westinghouse Electric Corporation 'Y. T ~

- - ~; -

v P. O. Box 355:

.. !-, a 4'.

n.:

~

- Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.15230L P

.i;..c:

m. ~.

.e..

, - a,,.. : 7... s.;....w

~

David F. Fleischaker; Esq. ' ~'/ W, h c. '.

s;f~....

V ' ' ' ' i /.. -

SN"..., : C. m f..

PJ 0. Box 1178 Oklahoma Cith.0klahoma.73101 l...

ww w.-

,.,..p....

Arthur C. Gehri Esq.,: ', ;;<.

e.',.i...n~,;u,. % ;,....f,

. r.l,. -

+....

• *O

{. D,..

.a -

.e.

t

.y.-s m;

.- U u ~'."

.h.,?. ' " '. W,

J Snell & Wiletr.

3100 Valley Center' V*

J.,/r,. m.

i Phoenix, Arizona 85073...-...

.N ?. : ~

7. s. i.

L

~.

.,.,....i.,...,,..

,~

, c s

.u.........%... m.,.. v..

x.+.,...

.w.

s...

..s..-

~.

.. s_ ;. _.

3...,.

..3...co.",,-..~.,,,......,..

e.

.+

r. #.

,..e s..i s

tw%.n

.g..

'n*.*,..'.6-....,.e.*

,..,.r S

., n-

- a.3.:

=....

M..

~

.h+*,,,,.'..*

5- {s.d,;

.'s J. ',/;. _;' *

~

,.,N S

.x,.

.c=. - er 3_.

~

.' i s.

t.

. r....e.3. -a.E NJT.:*

.... - e s:

.r*

q.-

-*.} :..

s*

• s' u...'.. t

• g.*

• a..,M.',. p s... ~..,i.** C,.',,,*,

' 1 -.,

. :.,s

r... j *

.,,g*

-t.J..p.~.,y.*..

. gf. *t F*

f 9*

'o

.g w'.

t

.*4

. *. '., '

• 3 I * )=, f J.,e

~

. 6.,,.,/a..( e,..at.',,,,i..6,'

4.,..

,'s.

s,

.i m,

3e e

• g

s.,

}, - 1

• q f e' ^.

t., F.

, s...;' A %..a l%, 'l s^

.l,jp

, i. C.4 f

..3*,.*-Ai*g.

.i.,%,--*',.'*

4.

.'.,#*t. *, '

.t* c -

,4h "i

9 i.

,...e 9; ::

.%.~..

. = m.....y: a ;y..d.=. c * -

,,- n3 w 7..g.%z.,.....9, y,........e.

,,,.;; m"*

~v.

t. : e a c, % y..s......

c n.,.

- 1 3..n.f; a,;~

y.

.,. =.

+

-e y;..,

. s ;.

sw g

,.s...,-.....r...

y.

.".,m.,s,..

..,,... n..,. a. d.

.~

-.v..

w s

.A

..s...

.s

.n.

s c..

,3., 7 ^a.,p.. ;M.. T, -d...-l.*

....&e..,.

..,,.. ? *.', i.

. ~..n.

...J*

.,~.u,.'.,1..a'

,-...v. b,_s.,. 6.

=

g.

.,.--ii...,.~....+y,-*

r.

..)

..~.*

.1......,.,;.

..s;:,..

so

,, [ g.,

a.,..-. z~.,,.,

P.,.]

e.. JM :. ; J *,'s- ;. s ~ C,y*'

....s,

.,J w.

.2 e..

s

... s s.

.Y*

, O ' ~ 'f[.e /,.,,* 3 ',. j'g[ ;J.]Ig,.~.

e

,,,.,,..,4...*

,, =. c 7. x '.

,,,e

.,%,-..*y....

t.s

....,., j r..

m s.

c..

.. ;.-=. a 4

• c,. g..,

3--

,.,. - 3..-

.,J

.4..

2

. s

..,.,..-?,g -

.,.. v...'

• . r :.

.w

.e_.

S

.

• p,

• Q

.v,.

. J+, ". S. E } r j *;* ** " '

• e e.

g <..T h e-e

.e

,6..,s 4,..a

.. r.s t

. ; t.,

• q e,'... t. ;.

~'

.Q.

g-

.o-a -

.. e.u.._. s...

.. ~..

.~.

7 m

ecy

• c,., r; m, f,......,..r...

.,... i

.t gg..

...s-

-,e

.,,, r' <

a - q.

=

e

, A.;

3

.y, 3

.e

, ?

a.

o

• si..t.

s.

t

,e

.,*.~'.,1J.o.

. g,

.*2

• . e g a.., e. i'

,5 v

A 9

4 # c, (,.

,g,.

4.j

• .y

s.. *

-,m p..

. 0.,.w.

.4 r

.m'.

w-s,

..... w,:

. *.. s.s n.

., ~

e.

.n...

-. g 2

....e.,........ c..

v

• Without' Enclosure 3.

~

~

-my--,-..

.,.--yyy,,y.yvy-

,,.,.wy

._--.y

.w,w--,..

mw-

o. 89

. ; ;.c..

y jy.

p' t p.g g gg ',;;. cc c;q.w.:.2.w.5]$w w sd g g y,;.gz y.,. q _

g g..: _., y -

c.

... ~

• c,,,

gg.r;tpyeprg

~

s...

n:

.c

. 2.y s.:v&. '1: n :. w:C..

. ?...,.' :.l..,??.

,'.l.' - Q ; * ; y -O..

ENCLDSURE.1

~-

y a.

.~ ::

y.~. ;

/ ::Q::' * * ::( 1_,.y. ;" i.

Q.

V-t

v. Diablo Canyon Feb. 3,1982 Meeting

~

...'2 Attendance List-

_. p ",x

,.,5

-y.

f s*'

.y..,:.e. j.+ s,. x., s.n.

...... ~ =".-,u.: ::: :

.7

+.,.,..

u. s.

.r,

r '..w e

Name

< u.* e i b.;,n.:.y,.'fAffiliation

. m. u.o.:..; y.n.. w Hans Schierling.n::

.u:

1

.. V 'r,. s

. '. n >C.; ' NRR-.

- Q.:

4

..,.:.. :t

c.,

...f.

'. w e _. f.y.

Diek Vollmer' t.

~

^'

. NRR

..~

Dick DeYoung. - :'

W W :~ '..

I&E.

~

g *. g r..

'.2.: w v. ? *'. '.NRR -

Harold Denton

.~. W D. Eisenhut.

,... c,.. J NRR

• v B. Jones

.J-2 JJ-:

. ; ELD -

F. Miraglia' l e ';.V5 * -NRR Jesse L. Crews

. s

.:fr ~.<.. :...

' Region Y:

Philip J. Morrill' f......

Region V Bob Bosnak

' ' ',C i. [.':.P.f- $.'.' 9 I HRR/DE/MES rm...a - mu.

.,,.:! %. 'G;V NRR/DE/SEB Frant Schauer

.N

.~

/

n.

. w.

n Goutam Bagchi

'~ T E: C.-e:r d. +. w..... ;v-J..w"J' NRR/DE/EQB '

j

..;u

.s.

'$.,Q::'hd :.',.. i... NRR/DL I Ken Herring Q.

.D:... r,. ". s

. :,=...x :..

NRR/DE/SEB P. T. Kuo. '.

42 J.~ P. Knight.

~#

.RR/DE N

.)

J. H. Sniezek.

T.,,..

.J l&E

... '?.".'..

A. Giambusso

.. D... '.

Stone & Webster -

e R. L. Tedesco '..'

~ NRR^

~

..dy>

y

.-NRR/DE/ET Stephen S. Skjet l1"

~

A. W. Dromerick.

-_,..J:

!&E/Eng. E/ Tech. Supp.

..o 3. e.,

F. C. Cherny

.s.,, '... NRR/DE/MEB

,L Walter P. Haass. ~

.. i.."e,; ;.. NRR/QAB.

.T

~

'?.

IE:HQ -

J.

R'. Fair

.y _..,.

E. J. Sullivan

' NRR/DE D. Fleischaker Joint Intervenors

~

H. Brown State of California

~

P. Hubbard MHS/ State of California m.

Bob Senseney NRC/ International Programs

/

' ~ '

B. D. Liaw NRC/0CM l.

i

.g,

, ;Y ' ',9'

~.

~. 3.',

• h'j.:?..'f.? ?

• f.*.5

% J'+.,6 b k*.' Ta' e'

?x' o'

5..

1;9

,.... t** A

~ " '

4 s

+

r

^

~

~

~-

,)* [.,., #

b*b '

.,.,.',,e.-,.,.~*'*

,g.

..,g'-

...a s..-:

".?.

e 4

.f,

,,, ~

l.*. - ~.. ;.. ^. ef,. ;.w.- t e

.' ~~

r

.... _. r s. j: %

..,..,c-

... V. ;::,f,.

. A:

".5 ;...

~

2.,..a.

n, I.

.'

• s..'.. I'. ; q. '... Q.,

.. '., ~ *hy,

n.*-

~

'.. -. +

• . v. j g,. _'

s.

..s..

Name

. c - 4 p. s y,". '; ^.

Affiliation

.. m.-, : :.. :-

c.v:... n.c.. :..

.,. r..a

~

t-

~~.n-

.. ~n.n,: ::.w..

.t.

S Y ? f.J ; " Westinghouse.:.

W. C. Gangloff..

' E c

e yl. M.: :rw,%;.

a..

..A:. fiAITECH'.."~ '

..,s M. N.; Tramp.

{',w.

R.".

.v 1. #! /s.r..

John 1. Riesland

~

=

.3

. a.t - NNC' E ~- :..

~

Jane-H. Bergler

.i..

,pi.l.'

< ~ ~ PG&E J

~

~.

~

...... '., c William A. Bourassa~

m.,r. -

'SN.UPPS/Rockville. Md.

1

..e.

.~ b ; o William G.,Wendiand.

.. ).

R. SanaCort.

M. J. Holley..'Jr.. ' ' ',,j :,' ~.> ;.Q-j,i } $~ Hansen. Holley &

,'., <. > tc '.s - -

<y

.g-

. Inc.

Dick Da' vin.

• e,.,,".c/. "s.l P E E'

..~-

.s."

Frank Sestak. Jr.,..

f. R.y.' '..': '.' Stone & Webster Carlo Richardson, Jr.. ' _ ] j.3. M. j.' Stone & Webster

~

s Craig Grochmal....... [.,.'.:.;..fr4 M..V.... Stone & Webst. er

.p m~

Edward Denison '.i..:.,il

..,..d... N~ n ~G, Robert!L. Cloud. ' Associates-i 7.-

J RobertC1hud.

g=. 3:.jC.R. (.... (, Robert'L'. Cloud. Associates v

. c. -

i Roger F. Reedy

,l;7.:

r.'[.R.F. Reedy.Inc.

?

William E. Cooper:.

.j'f.,9 f,.-'.....

Teledyne Engineering Services f

?...i +

. James Rocca.

.. - > ;3;;.... ". PG&E -

John 8. Hoch(

y.

.. -S.,i.

-PG1E -

~~

Bruce Norton

., e. '9 f ',..,;, d.W. '

Norton Burke. Berry & French P.C.

D. A. Brand

' PG&E. ~

6....- ',PG&E Jim McCracken

~

~i' Roy R. Fray

'l, :l. M '. -.

. PG&E:

m

. 7 Y.,...- ". r.... PG&E'.

Gary H. Moore y

e.

>). S t.

Barclay S. Lew-

. <.,J:. '

~'...PG&E. I Richard F. Locke.

' ', /. :. '

. PG&E Warren A. Raymond PG&E Willi.am J. Olmstead NRC/0 ELD v

A a.

l

---

,.N.n.-

- - -, -, - - - - ~ - -. - - ~ - -

. -,, ~, +,,...,. -. -

,,m-.

.,--n..~

f J

$,c(

~ '. _ _ '

x. 6 4.

a

.

• i.i-

.<'.,.s...

. 'q.,4', *

;

:. ~.. j' :,'. Q T: '.. '.. : i:" ~ '.,w. l

'f, '.; e

l. - *

'"e..

.. i.

,'..r

~

a

....l] _ ~.i ;..

. &. %.T ',,. ]z '..

e'..

.C..

. -. ?... ' f ' c, /

.=

=..

...m

. - y.t +

i..L.c,. ::::.

-.gyctgSwtg g.

. - ~,

-)

,V,

.,(...

- y

-TAgenda

. f.'

.c L'

~V J -

. Meeting with PG&E.

.,. /..; -

February 3.-1982

('

-' Seismic Reverification Program.

m

... x: :.,..

u.

_.;.i. ~. -

Opening Commen, >:

aw.-

...e.~.~

0900 - 0910 ts and Introductio/P *HRC

~

..

• L s..,..'

.w.;

r.

A' 0915 - 0930 -"..

.' Opening Comments and Introduction - PG&E.

. r:..

v.

~.

q..

0930 - 1045 r w..

I.

. Scope and Technical Aspects.of Plan

s. -

" ~

J:.",i... Items l', 2. 3 & 5 of Jan. 28 ltr.

D.- G.. Eisenhut to H. Furbush p'. _. : :

r

.W.

..-c Items I.1'-18 appended to Mtg. Notice Agenda.

y, n

r....

.' Break

~

1045 - 1100

.e

~

, i.

v:..e.II'.': Sample Criteria 1100 - 1230

_ p. 2

p...

,..c. J.

'.*f. J.Ites 4 of' Jan.- 28 ltr. D. 'G. Eisenhut 3

. W.;'%,...:;;. to. H, Furbush'

~

,.Q

,2 l.~ h l..; $.:.y.~{b y.-:':v,p.* O P " ^

.. q.>... :.,.:.7,;... Items II.1-6 appended to Mtg. Notice

... c a..,....<

.u..... Agenda.

~

..y.

..::n.

. : y.

a s.

t..

. Lunch.'.,., u ir ?, s.

1230 - 1:30'

-. '.... 3 u:.

.g..,w.

4 1.30 - 2:151 ~

,, S.III.f Benchmarking of Results '

c...

. g. j '.: ' Item 'III.T' appended to Mtg. Notice Agenda 2.

2:15

.3:15_

' IV. 0A Au'dit Methods.

^

-. ;I'temslIV.~1-4 appended to Mtg. Notice Agenda

.~.

t..

l... n.,

e Break. : '

3:15 - 3:30.

.v.s:.,f...

u.

. y ~...

.u.

~e 3:30 - 4:30 V.: Size and Technical Qualifications of Review Team Items V.1-4 appended to Mtg. Notice Agenda 4:30 - 5:30 VI.. Contractual and Financial Qualifications

. of Review Team a

Itcins. VI.1-5 appended to Mtg. Notice Agenda

~

v t

e

.-e..

1 b

I 2

.t a. #c..

n, -n,..e.e,u,.:n ;.

a u,.a....

m

.~...w.

. t :.

u.

%._ a g _~,.... A. u.,.. :....,..

,~.~.~.s.m..,

.m.

. u..

_3. u. -.,.

m._

.-m r

c...

~.

-~.

Ao.m

.,_ m o EHCl.05URE 3 w.

~1.'..

e=

e a

e,

..i P.'

j i

\\.

~

Attachment.

, " * ?.

r

.. s ;

,e

'.r.. Agenda ltems

~'

.. ;.- -,,- Heeting with PG&E.

t

" January. 19, 1982

. Seismic ~ Reverif.ication Program

.. 2

~.

u.

I.. Scope and Technical Aspects of 'P1'an t.

II.. Sample-Criteria J..'-

.c

-.. - ~

~

g.

1.-..

r

. ~.M.~.'"

~'.f d.

III.. Benchmarking of Results

^r. a. n. i......z.

.r.

IV.

QA Audit Methods V.

Size ar.' Technical Qualifications of Review Team

~

VI.

Contractual and Financial Qualifications of Review Team E

3 t,

O g-

e. k*

.e

.^#

-k y.

s

• /

m

' +,

d g

g*

s 1

e b-

+

8

1. e I

l 1

f g

e y

s M MLGedAtW $ sb~:.ed $ dE85&$5 $m.,,.&45~ulv:mdswlun: audh.4ddl;&:gh

- T. -

y c ~

n

e

:.;--;::.h,.

. c-

. a.

.y..._

7

. u w. -

.y...~.

~.. ~,,

a:..

u..

y.,.,

g

~

. 3..,..

~-

^

^

. _ 2

~ '.-

a-n

15. Seismic service contract activities within

~

.:c.

c; program scope

~-

76

.,:.. ;.,3

16. Details for analysis' of' PGSL" internal ' interfaces

~'

17.

Definitions for (a)!. ' c:significant deficiency.or.

N ! ?..w :..

. e-error ano (b) insignificant deficiency or. error 18.- Guidelines for determining appropriateness of design methods considering change in " state of the art" technology..

II.

Sample Criteria

~.

1.

Criteria for selection-of semple calculation and for expansion of sample, size if needed 2.

Statistical basis for sample-size and procecure in case of failure

- e-

. e,.

.;l

_ :7...

3.

Eqaipment sample from safe shutdowrt 3

.m i... 4 :

N. _.)

and cooldown systems 7 '.' '1 6,Y : ? " ~,

.u 4L Adequacy of design process anc quality assurance; reporting on basis of sample. cases a

5.

Criteria for sampTe checks 'ano independent calculations f,...

6.

Application of current evaluation'tecnniques to independent sample calculations. in' analysis of structures and components.'.

111.

benchmarking of Results '

t 4-1.

Benchmarking to NRC probleins, of. computer code for piping analysis t.

g

~

IV.

0A Audit Methods 1.

Reporting procedure for R. F Reedy to R.

L.. Cloud and PGhE

~

2.

Scope of QA review (procuremer$t documentation control; instructions, procedures and drawings; document control; auditing) 3.

Review of operational QA prograb (post 1978) with respect to implementation of corrective actions

w..h

,.. a:l s.,n l%m-%m=.md:.xs:.Niy.:,w..,,:+m.u.,.m..ww.,

i

.a, ann -

e

.<.w y..

~.

__n

~ < -

~

,. r;

~c-n :.

-.~

4

.. ~,,

.n.

3.

e

(

. u.

.? '-

p rJ;

.g ;;..:

' Y.

Size and Technical Qualifications of Review Team 1.

Identification and qualifications.of individuals

~

performing QA review

4, :..

v 2.

Expertise of incividuals in. civil'-structural '

design and analysis

. 37 -' '

..-w

.;.,~,-

.a 3.

Expertise in seismic analysis of structures

~

t 4.

' Assignment of individuals with appropriate expertise to. specific tasks' c

5 VI.

Contractual ~ and Financial Qualifications of Review Team 1.

Previous involvement of co' cpanies. and individuals in Diablo Canyon activities. now under their independent review scope.

...n -

. "y ;,; :.,..

a 2.

Previous involvement of companies or, inoiviouals in Diablo Canyon Seismic design work. '.

..-~.; -' ".:;

~

-c-(

j. 2,... d:s w :;p.W y?

Q 3... Previous employment by PG8E.of individuals now participating in independent review-.

c.:..i.

.. ; J N,

n 4.

Ownership or control of PGLE stock by incividuals.

participating in independent review- ~

. u : - ?... 3;; p: -

-y'.

~

r ployr.ent by PG8E of relatives or members of present 5.

m cusehold of individuals partic'ipating in review,

.and position if appropriate..

..m

. w......_;

.. ;. ;. a..a. v, ~ +....

m;3.,

.t.n g.u. ;.,..;.,

~

w

.~:..

.c

_. u.. c;

., z,....,...,...., ; i.

-y.

o.: e v.c

3 r.

+

r.

. <. ?. :. g t.

e,

. c..-n :'.

.....w

. ~.

r

.. n +,; q >:.7;.. :.,,

L, _:/ ~. ',

. %w l

f.,

• "ye' i

4

,.,,.,m

?

~ -

s.

5 t

,8 s

a l

s.

6 l

t

• ~

).

I k

/

PRELIMINARY NOTIFICATION OF EVENT OR UNUSUAL OCCURRENCE--PNO-V-82-09 DATE: 2/ 4/8 / 14 This preliminary notification constitutes EARLY notice.of events of POSSIBLE safety or publich interest significance.: The information:is as initially received without verification or.

1 evaluation, and is be.sically all that is known by IE staff on this date.

J-Facility: Pacific Gas & Electric Co. (PG&E)

Diablo Canyon thit No.1

. Licensee Emergency Classification:

. Docket No. 50-275

. Notification of Unusual Event Alert San Lui.s ObLspo Cotnty, Califomia Site Area Emergency-

Subject:

SEISliIC QUALIFICATION OF.

ot pl ab PRESSURIZER RELIEF,'PORV AND PORV BLOCKING VALVES The licensee notified NRC Region V (San Francisco) of plans to make written notification to the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board (ASLB) in the Diablo.

Canyon proceeding regarding the apparent lack of proper: seismic qualification.

of the pressurizer relief,.PORV and.PORV Blocking. valves as well as associated piping.

According to PC&E, the subject valves and associated piping were seismicallye qualified using seismic design spectra of. the containment; building operating:

floor. (elevation 140 feet), whereas.the: valves :are located at the top of the pressurizer vessel between elevations 170 feet and 180 feet.

Specific analyses to determine the significance of this finding is currently; in progress by PG&E.

The ASLB notification is being made in this instance because these valves:

and their qualification were the subj ect: of specific -issue 7.in the recently completed ASLB public hearing.

Media intorest is expected.

NRC Region V (San Francisco) received 1

notification of this occurrence. from an NRC Region V iinspector at PG&E's offices in San Francisco at-2:50 p.m. PST on February.24,.1982.

Thisi information is current as of that time.

CONTACT:

P. J. Morrill, 463-3740 or.

J. L. Crews, 463-3735 DISTRIBUTION:

H. St.

MNBB Phillips E/W Willste Landow Chairman Palladino EDO NRR IE NMSS OIA,

Comm. Gilinsky AEOD RES Can. Bradford PA Air Rights Com. Ahearne MPA SP INPO MAIL:

Ccem. Roberts ELD NSAC ACRS ADM: oc.Mgt.Br.

SECY Regional Offices

/

CA 4

400 05'7a g

_g

• '[

'. ;partiuq)

• A l.

,i NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION UNITED STATES 4

Q

, s WASHINGTCN, D.C. 20555

%,4..w,/

February 26, 1982 gy

. OFFICE OF THE

.d g,,.

s.

SECRETARY

~

.f,,,, f$323

, !Ja

[d CQ.J, K, ' /*; w

./

I '5 * 1 Or / / Q i,)

MEMORANDUM FOR:

Persons on Service List for CLI-82-1 (Dockets 50-275 0.L. and 5,6-323 0.L.)

FROM:

Scott W. S tucky,,. h keting and Service Branc ( '[1'

SUBJECT:

ADDITIONAL VIEWS OF COMMISSIONER GILINSKF REGARDING PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC'S MATERIAL FALSE STATEMENT On February 26, 1982, Commissioner Victor Gilinsky released his additional views relating to the Commission's order CLI-82-1 of February 10, 1982, in the Diablo Canyon matter.

A copy of Mr. Gilinsky's statement is attached, and should be appended to your copy of CLI-82-1.

Attachment:

As Stated

(

k 4>0)

.n n d C

~

u

I 8203020000 920226

~

PDR ADOCK 05000275 9

PDR

. y.,~.

. =

.u.

c:ta, -- -

g.

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION

'82 FE 26 P2 :30 COMMISSIONERS:

~

=Nunzio J. Palladino, Chairman 6.

Victor Gilinsky

' ' " ~

4 Peter A. Bradford John F.'Ahearne Thomas M. Roberts q-l,*C E b S3't081

)

In the Matter of;

}

)

PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC CO. )

Docket No. 50-275 0.L.

)

50-323 0.L.

(Diablo Canyon Nuclear Power )

Plant, Units 1 & 2)

)

)

' ADDITIONAL VIEWS OF COMMISSIONER GILINSKY REGARDING-PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC'S MATERIAL FALSE STATEMENT t

e On February'10, 1982, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission

~

charged Pacific Gas and Electric with making a ma'terial f

false statement in discuss. ions of the Diablo Canyon seismic design with the NRC.

The Commission's Order was brief to the, point of being telegraphic, and,I sense that the public was left wondering about the Commission's finding as well as its significance in view of the Commission's failure to impose a civil penalty.

What follows is my own view'of the matter:

~. '

Last September, PG&E informed the NRC that errors had.been i

i discovered in the seismic design of.thei Diablo Canyon nuclear power plant, which had just received NRC permission for test and low. power' operation.

The NRC suspended the low J

" *i *,.---. : ^." ~ T r. _ ~ _-_.., *= * '":T;;_, J!C?r*i*, ;n.1 _ L.; 7 7._r:n.1 -..- a r :. u -._ :.

-,_,m-_

' p.

_2-power license and required a reverification of the plant's seismic design.

On November 3, the NRC met with PG&E officials, led by the Company President, Barton W.

Shackelford, and with PG&E's consultant, Robert L. Cloud, to a discuss the seismic reverification program being conducted by Dr. Cloud's firm.

As a result of questions raised by other parties to the case and in Congress, NRC was becoming increasi,ngly interested in the extent to which Dr. Cloud's review would be conducted independently of PG&E.

The. Company naturally had a strong interest in emphasizing Dr. Cloud's independence since NRC's early acceptance of him as an independent reviewer might have speeded up the reverification program which stood in the way of the power plant's startup.

At the meeting, Harold Denton, NRC's Director of Nuclear Reactor Regulation, asked whether NRC would receive the same reports which Dr. Cloud gave to PG&E.

George Maneatis, a PG&E Senior Vice President, responded "You.just got it.

And I have to say, Mr. Denton, that some of these things have just been disclosed to'me, so you got it almost the same time I did."

Bruce Norton, PG&E's attorney in the Diablo Canyon case, stated "I might add we do not have it (Cloud's report].

It's not a question of us reviewing it.

We don't have it 4

8 e

-+

og.ew-m.we as se

-eow

either.

It just hasn't been done yet...."

He then added, with considerable force, "I frankly resent the impiication that Dr. Cloud is not an independent reviewer because he *

+1s...The report itself hasn't been prepared.

If you want a copy of it before we get it,' fine, or sbnultaneously.

It is

~

an independent consultant, and you know, I don't know how we can show you that more than to give you the reports when they are prepared."

In fact, s NRC pieced together later, at the time these statuments were made PG&E had already reviewed and commente~d

{

on two separate dr'fts of Dr. Cloud's report and, a

unbeknownst to NRC, was about to receive the third' draft.

The NRC's subsequent in~vestigation revealed that six of the PG&E officials at the November 3 meeting, including Donald' A. Brand, the Vice President of Engineering, who was responsible ~for handling the Cloud contract, knew of PG&E's review of the cloud reports.

The company's officials failed s

to' correct the false statements made in the mseting.

Perhaps more importantly, neither the Company nor Dr. Cloud corrected these statements after the meeting although they had ample opportunity to do so.-

4 1er. Norton, who had insisted at the November 3 meeting that PG&E had no access,to Cloud's reports, told NRC investigators that he did not learn about drafts of the Cloud report submitted to PG&E until December 14.

He had e

b

... : ~n

- L __

• L

^ asked'PG&E'before the November.3 meeting about the status of Cloud's report 7nd'was apparently misinformed by his clients.

He told the NRC investigators that, "If I had known the report of October 21st had been received by PG&E, I-would not hav'e said what'I said because when I'used the term report, I[wasencompassinganyreportwhetheritbe prelimidary, interim, final, whatever..."

7 Mr. Maneatis told the NRC investigators that,.at the meeting, he was referring to Dr. Cloud's oral report of November 3 to the NRC.

Mr. Maneatis explained that he did not know that PG&E had received written drafts of the Cloud

• {

report until he was told of such reports by the NRC on December 10.

The other PG&E exployees and Dr. Cloud have said that they assumed that the questions raised related to the final report, not to the draft reports.

This last artificial distinction won't wash.

Even PG&E's General

• Counsel, Malcolm Ft5rbush, agreed that the Company's statements " appear to be incorrect" and said that, "Had I l

l known about those reports, I would have said something at the meeting.",In fact", in this context the draft reports

-are inherently'more significant; it is the drafting which determines what will be emphasized and what will not."

Where does this leave us?

It is troubling that a company which seeks permission to operate nuclear power plants L

e.

-e+..

- * = -

• e,wm

_m,g g,4,

'~..

should be'so insensitive to-its obligation to inform federal regulators and the public...The issue is not the circulation

~

of the reports but'the false portrayal of PG&E's relationship with Dr. Cloud's firm.- When we grant a utility a

the authority to operate a nuclear power plant we must be confident that its' officials will,be forthright with,us.'

That is why the Commission's finding that PG&E had made a material false statement is so important.

11 I-would have gone beyond the terms of the Commission's order and imposed a civil penalty to underline the seriousness

• with which the Commission views PG&E's actions.

l; Nevertheless, the Commission did require the top management l'

,of PG&E to meet with NRC officials to discuss. ways of I

ensuring that this. problem will not recur.

A meeting l

between the Chairman of the Board of PG&E and the NRC

^

Director-o'f Inspection and Enforcement and the NRC Regional L

1 Administrator is scheduled to take place in the near future.

f PG&E should lose no time in acting to restore co'nfidence in l

its integrity.

(

As for Dr. Cloud, we cannot, in my view, simply ignore the l~

fact that he also had an obligation to inform the NRC that

.his draft reports were being reviewed by PG&E.

Again, it is

.not the circulation of the report which is of concern, but the failure to disclose the interact' ions between Dr. Cloud's firm and PG&E when the question was raised by NRC.

The only r

l l

.-,, _ =.,

= -.

~

reasonable course, at this point, is to regard his report as, in effect, a PG&E report and to look to someone else to perform the ' independent audit of the reverification program.

9 9

e l -.

4 b

t e

e l

9 4

a 9

9 I

e 9

+

S y

e 3

4 I

b i

4 4

M4 e

m aw,

m.

O o*.

6

REGULATORY-INFORMATION DISTRIBUTION SYSTEM (RIOS)

• ACCESSION N8R 820302008d 00C.0 ATE: 82/02/26 NOTARIZED:.NO 00CKET

• FACIL:50-275 Ojablo Canyon Nuclear Power Plant, Unit 1, Pac [ific Ga 05000275 50-323 Diaolo Canyon Nuclear Power Plant, Unit 2, Pacific Ga 05000323

'AUTM.NAME AUTHuR AFFILIATION STUCKY,3.A.

Occketing & Services Branch RECIP.NAME RECIPIENT AFFILIATION Office of the Executive Legal Direct'or

SUBJECT:

Forkards V Gilinsky addl views ce CLI-82-1 COPIES RECEIVED LTR d ENCL bSIZE *.,

DISTRIbuTIUN CODE OSoas TITLE: Non - Antitrust Issuances NOTESri cy*J Hanchett (Regian V).LPORt2cys 05000275 1 cysJ Hanchett: '(Region V).LPOR:2cys.

05000323 RECIPIENT COPIES RECIPIENT COPIES in f"^f LTTR ENCL 10 CODE /NAME LTTR ENCL ACTION:t % m s.'**WFi GED 1

1 LIC BR #3 LA 1

1 I

I 1

INTERNAL: ASLAP 5

'5 ASLB 01 1

1 ELD /PSS 1

1 GC 1

1 IE 1

2 PA i

1 EXTERNAL: LPOR

1. 1 - -t NRC"POR 1

1 NTIS 1

1 9

6 6

\\\\~

... \\\\\\

li 19

\\

. TOTAL' NUMBER OF COPIES ttEGUIRED: LTTR W ENCL W

w.

..-~.-s+~

~.. _, -

_,n-v -..

~

y u-

~

j

X A.

y

"+

-NRR DAILY HIGHLIGHT

' March 18, '1982 DIABLO CANYON Two long ~ days of discussions were held on Wednesday-and Thursday.of last

. week among lawyers and technical persons representing PG&E, Governor Brown, Joint Intervenors and NRC Staff concerning a possible settlement among all parties on the scope'of Diablo Canyon Seismic Design Reverification program and the independent company or companies to carry out such a program. As a result-of the apparent progress' achieved by these discussions, all parties agreed to extend the deadline for agreement until the following Tuesday.

The representatives then consulted with each of'their respective parties over the next several days.

On Tuesday of this week the parties reported to the NRC Staff the results of these consultations.

Based on these reports, the Staff concluded and all parties agreed that further discussions'were n6t likely to be fruitful in reaching a settlement that all parties would accept.

NRC Staff, in accordance with the Commission decision of March 4, is now considering PG&E's proposal that Teledyne Engineering Services be approved.

as the independent company to carry out the Seismic Design Reverification program required by the Commission's Order of November 19.-1981.

~

-9 O

G 6

• GG y

G D

O e

9

+

o l

c l

h l

l

})\\

c t

I

+

".~

meog#

's 0,,

UNITED STATES 3

NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION o

s j

WASWNGTON. D. C. 20555

%'..M.o#

March 22, 1982 Docket No. 50-275 MEMORANDUM FOR:

F. J. Miraglia, Chief Licensing Branch No. 3, DL FROM:

H. E. Schierling, Project Manager, Licensing Branch No. 3, DL.

SUBJECT:

NOTICE OF MEETING WITH PACIFIC GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY AND CONTRACTORS - DIABLO CANYON, UNIT 1, DESIGN VERIFICATION PROGRAM Date & Time:

Thursday & Friday March 25 & 26, 1982 9:00 AM - 4:00 PM Location:

Room P-118 Phillips Building 7920 Norfolk Avenue

+

Bethesda, MD

Purpose:

March 25 - To discuss the organizational structures for the Design Verification Program. Phases I and II and to discuss issues pertaining to revisions of the Phase I program (preliminary agenda items attached).

March 26 - To discuss staff questions pertaining to the QA audit reviews performed by R. F. Reedy, Inc.

(preliminary agenda items attached).

Participants:

NRC

.PG&E D. Eisenhut J. Hoch, et al R. Vollmer R. Tedesco J. Knight F. Miraglia PG&E contractors for W. Haass Phase I and proposed H. Schierling contractors for Phase B. Buckley II as appropriate.

J. Crews T. Bishop P. Morrill M. Messier CM Hans E. Schierling, P oject Manager Design Verification Program o

c ns rig k

See next page [

cc:

,r eig*

AGENDA ITEMS (PRELIMINARY)

I.

March 25, 1982 Meeting 1.

Teledyne qualifications in civil-structural aspects of nuclear-power plant design.

2.

Teldyne procedures and criteria for evaluation of ' current con-tractor performance to date and in future Phase I activities.

3.

Consolidation into single Phase I program plan of earlier Phase I submittals and inclusion of required NRC revisions and of potential additional revisions by Teledyne.

4.

Proposed organizational structure and contractors for Phase I of design verification program.

5.

Information on independence (financial and technical) and qualifi~

cations of proposed Phase II contractors.

t e

m

e. a.,w. 4 4

• • • • m

--T

y..g-0 4

AGENDA ITEMS (PRELIMINARY)

II. March 26, 1982 1.

Criteria for e0aluation of QA programs; applicability'of selected parts of ANSI N45.2.11 considered for guidance in evaluating PG&E QAP..

2.

Implementation of the QA program by PG&E relative to its.

---

assigned " audit role."

3.

Applicability of QA manual to Unit 1.

4.

Impact of organization change in 1972 relative to effective-ness of implementation of QA program.

5.

Verification of design work accomplished by service related contractors prior to requirement for contractor to apply QA in 1977-1979 time frame, t-6.

Current assessment of overall QA. program effectiveness based' on review and evaluation performed to date.

-ww e

-e--m-me.e. ee-.

& amme, m p, 4. m,

..4

c.

Mr. Malcola H. Furbush Vice President - General. Counsel Pacific Gas & Electric Company P.O. Box 7442 San Francisco, California 94120 s.

cc: Philip A. Crane, Jr., Esq.

Pacific Gas A Electric Company P.O. Box 7442 San Francisco, California 94120 Janice E. Kerr, Esq.

California Public Utilities Commission 350 M: Allister Street San Francisco, California 94102

.Mr. Frederick Eissler, President Scenic Shoreline Preservation Conference, Inc.

4623 More Mesa Drive Santa Barbara, California 93105 Ms. Elizabeth Apfelberg 1415 Cozadero San Luis 031spo, California 93401 1

Mr. Gordon A. Silver Ms. Sandra A. Silver 1760 Alisal Street San Luis Obispo, California 93401 Harry M. Willis, Esq.

Seymour & Willis-l 601 California Street, Saite 2100 San Fran:isco, California 94108 Mr. Richard Habbard MH3 Technical Associates Suite K 1723 hamil ton

• venue San Jose, Cali fornia 95125 Mr. John "arrs, Managinc Editor San Luis Obispo County Telegram-Tribune 1321 Jchnson Avenue P. O. Box 112 San Luis Obispo, California 93406 I

m.,,.

~e,

,, +, - - -. _,,

._y.y--,--

____ -,~., _ -- _ _,

-,,.w

--e-

-e------

+y-wy r-=--Tw

---

4' ---

re---

-es wm w

rmw-.

p--

n st-Mr. Palcolm H. Furbush

- 2'-

Resident Inspector /Biablo Canyon NPS cc:

.~

c/o U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Cornmission P. O. Box 369 q _ ~-

Avila Beach, California 93424 Ms. Raye Fleming 1920 P.attie Road Shell beach, California 93440 Joel F.eynolds, Esq.

John R. Phillips, Esq.

Center for Law in the Public Interest 10951 Vest Pico Boulevard Thiro Floor

~

1.os Angeles, California 900b4 Paul C. Valentine, Esq.

321 L,stten Avenue-Palo Alto, California 94302 P.r. tyron 5. Georgiov Legal Af f airs Secretary Governor's Of fice State Capitol Satramento, (.ali fornia 95814 Herbert H. Brown, Esq.

Hill, Christopher 6 Phillips, P.C.

1903 !. Street, ii.W.

• lashira; ton, D.C.

20036 itr. Dick Blankenburg, Editor & Co-Publisher South County Puolishing Corapany P. O. box 460 Arroyo Grance, Cali fornia 93420 nr. Jnes 0. Schuyler Vice Frestoent - Nuclear Generation Departirent Pacific bas & Electric Company P.O. box 7442 San Francisco, Cali fornia 94120 bruce '.orton, E sq.

Suite 20t 3216 teortt. 3rd Street Phoenix, Arizona 85012 o w a ++ n -

• • • • • • ~***~#

r unii i

i uq

5 s.

.t;.c s

Mr.-Malcolm H.'Furbush :

Mr. W. C. Gangloff Westinghouse Electric Corporation P. O. Box 355 Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 15230 David F. Fleischaker, Esq.

P. O. Box 1178 Oklahoma City, Oklahoma 73101 Arthur C. Gehr, Esq.

Snell & Wilmer 3100 Valley Center Phoenix, Arizona 85073 t

Mr. Owen H. Davis, Director Federal Agency Relations Pacific Gas and Electric Company 105017th Street, N.W.

Suite 1180 Washington, D.c.

20036 A

e M

e

MEETING NOTICE DISTRIBUTION Docket File 50- 275 I&E Region I NRC PDR

, I&E Region II Local PDR I&E Region III NSIC I&E Region'IV TERA I&E Region V l

LB#3 Files NRC Participants nhut D. Eisenhut

'R. Purple R. Vollmer R. Tedesco R. Tedesco B. J. Youngblood J. Knight A. Schwencer F. Miraglia F. Miragita W.,Haass E. Adensam H. Schierling J. Miller B. Buckley G. Lainas R. Hattson T. Ippolito T.'Speis B. Russell.

M. Srinivasan D. Crutchfield O. Parr T. Novak F. Rosa S. Varga B. Sheron, Acting D. Vassallo L. G. Hulman R. Clark R. Houston J. Stolz W. Gammill R. Vollmer F. Congel J. Knight L. Rubenstein R. Bosnak

. W. Butler F. Schauer C. Berlinger R. Jackson G. Lear F. Schroeder K. Kniel Attorney, OELD D. Skovholt OIE (3)

G. Knighton ACRS(16)

M. Ernst OSD(7)

A. Thadani J. LeDoux. I&E W. Minners E. Grimes, I&E S. Hanauer M. Williams, DL H. Thomoson W. Johnston JZwolinski S. Pawlicki P. Collins V. Benaroya,

D. Ziemann Z. Ros2 toc y V. Moore W. Haass Regional Administrator R. Engelken D. Muller bec: Applicant Service i.i n R. Ballard W. Regan Branch LB83 A. Toalston Project Manager fl2T4enun95 B. Buckley Licensing Assistant J. Lee O

1 4

~

i

~ <. -

-G~~

~

naren i/. i '-:u

^' l

.3.

C.

5.

FORT OFFIC1-: OF INvFCTinN AND ENFORCEMENT

(

6 I

7.

R.

9 FACTI.ITY NOTIFICATION ITEM OR FVENT REGIONAL ACTION-10 13.

Riverbend Telephone call tie =rade of Potential Construction Deficiency:. Gulf Follow up in 17.

Linit 1 from GSU States Utilities (GStJ) natified RIV on 3/16/82 that accardance with 13.

DN "~.O-4*.R Licensine the deficiency invn1ving the utilization of a sinwie

'MC 2597 14

~

En=ineer en current transformer'in recirculation puse circuits l

15.

3/16/82 was bein= up,raded to a si=nificant construction I

1A.

deficiency (See DR 2/17/82).

The 1.tcensee plans to 17.

redesien the circuit to. Provide redundancy.

The 18.

Licensee plans to submit a 30-day report in

,j i

19 accordance with 50.55te).

70 1.

7.

FORT OFFICF. OF INSPECTION AND FNFORCEMENT DAILY REPORT - REGION V 7

DATE: 3/17/82 4.

Notification Item or Event Retm i ona l Action g ility ific Gas T*1echone ca11 At ItS9 a.m. on 3/14/82, a seismic event was observed by control Information Oniv

. Electric from Resident room operators.

Ground acceleration was measured at 0.0008 s for 9

Diablo Canyon Inspector on a 20 second duration by the Teratech seismic monitors.. The in.

lini t 1 3/15/82.

earthaquake was centered'about eleven miles soitth-east of the site St.

DN 50-775 Na dama=e to the facilitv was observed.

-12.

13.

Sacramento Licensee Today the Ifeensee is conductins an Emersency Plan exercise over Information Only 14.

Municipal confirmed on a Period of about 8.5 hours5.787037e-5 days <br />0.00139 hours <br />8.267196e-6 weeks <br />1.9025e-6 months <br />.

The exercise is directed primartiv 15, ittility 3/8/82.

-.taward onsite responses however, the EOF will be activiated and

~and offsite surveys wi!! be performed. Local movernment 14 District

~

earticiention will be minimal.

17.

Rancho Seco 19.

DN 50-312 19 20.

Veterans Administration An enforcement conference has been scheduled for 3/23/82.

Information Only' 21.

Medical Center between the mana=ement of the V.A. Medical Center and the 27.

Fresno, CA mana=ement of the Region V office.

The NRC will be represented 23.

License No. 04-0197t5-03 by the Chief. Radioin=ical Safety Branch and the Chief. Materials 74.

Radiation Protection Section.

The NRC will discuss the T5 t

enfarcement cettans available to the NRC as a result of findings 26.

-from a recent inspection.

77.

78.

General Mea. R. D. Thoaas. Chief. Materials Radiation Protection Section, will Participate Information Only 79 In a -seminae an 3/19/82, for the medical staff at the Letterman Army Medic.1-30.

Canter. Presidio, San Francisco, CA.

Mr. Thomas will discuss licensine, re=ulations

't.

and the inspection and enforcement Pro = ram associated with the use of radio-

...e<,i.

+,.

..m a r % t e s,,..

J

.m m

~,

-s, a:c

• _w

,r g, i jg,,

p t

,%?

-~ ~ % e.

k

• • - j

{

,r

~

Y

.' ~,.

',M:

?

o m.

u_x a

o

~. -

': ' h *?%

...s...

e..

-a w a t s r.s e.

en. xo ns

z. < vossent e =re e s v~ s A 3 en s n = * 'r e 30 San Dieao, o

31.

California af iodine-131 for enen t > <. **~ *s u e en e n ~ **v e,

320 License No.

dose of 29.9 mci. thyroid carcinoma instead of the prescribed The misadministration was attributed A report will be filo 33 04-01369-02 technician error.

to The calibration date of 2/26/82, was not TI 1106/1.

in accarefance with 34.

noted bY the technicians Prior to institeited encrectiveisotOPe administration.

35.

licensee has Ihe 36 mistake in the festsere.

This item is submitted for information Procedures to prevent the same 77 on1Y and is closed far rePortin9 39 (cant.)

Purposes.

39, IsAllY RFPORT - RFGION V 40 g r.

41.

f4 te Seeaker 42.

Subiect p3, COO--

Thomas W.

Pishne Oreanizatinn 30.

Section Chief, Nuclear Power Plant Construction 1

Reartar Construction.

Napa Rotary Club, Napa, CA

.7 b@

Proiects Branch h8 Pacific Telephone call LO.

Gas 2,

% __ ~

from licensee O.

Flectric F6- _

yn of the Pressurireb Relief.

on 2/24/67.

__y t The licensee 1.

Diablo Canyon to mak* written notification to the Atomic SafetYnotified NRC Region V of Plans A PN was issued on 2/24/82.

2.

lin i t I Board (ASLB) in the Diablo and 1.icensinq Canyon proCeedin#s re9ardin9 1

DN 50-775 apparent lack PORV and PORV Blockins valves.of Proper seismic qualification af the pressurize the 4

relief, 5

associated riefne were seismica11Y qualified usina seismic des 19n The subiert valves and 4

seertra af the containment building operatins floor (elevation 7

140 feet), whereas the valves are located at the top of the 1

pressurizer vessel between elevations 170 3

The AM B notification is beins made in this instance because these feet and 180 feet.

5 valves and their qualification were the subiert of specific issue in the receni1Y completed ASLB eubliC hearine.

9

~m w

-- ~

~wm

-m--

,,-e e

p