ML20148C172
| ML20148C172 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | South Texas, Comanche Peak  |
| Issue date: | 01/18/1980 |
| From: | Cyphert S JUSTICE, DEPT. OF |
| To: | Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8001280470 | |
| Download: ML20148C172 (9) | |
Text
--
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
~
Before'the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board In the Matter of
)
i HOUSTON LIGHTING & POWER
)
COMPANY, et al. (South
)
Docket Nos. 50-498A Texas Project, Units 1
)
50-499A and 2)
)
)
TEXAS UTILITIES GENERATING
)
COMPANY,. et al. (Comanche
)
Docket Nos. 50-445A Peak Steam Electric
)
50-446A Station, Units 1 and 2)
)
APPLICATION FOR ISSUANCE OF SUBPOENAS The Department of Justice
(" Department"), pursuant to
~
'10 C.F.R.
S2.720, hereby makes an application for the issuance of a subpoena to produce documents identified hereinafter and attached to this application.
On November 29, 1979, the Department issued the " Motion i
of the Department of Justice for Modification of the July 24, 1979 Order of the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board and Application for Issuance of Subpoenas"
(" Motion") requesting that the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board ("Doard") issue the j
subpoenas for which the Department applied in the Motion.
The 4
l
' Board subsequently issued said subpoenas and, in the " Order 1
Modifying Hearing Schedule" of December 14, 1979, denied "TUGCO's Opposition to the Motion of the Department of' Justice for Modification of Discovery and Hearing Schedule; Motion to i
80012804-70 l-
om m
ct D
D oo o
. 1 f\\. f i
a
') -_
Oucch fiuhpnenan; and fot O! het Relivi" of i ocen i et 10, 1970.
j i
'The nobpocoa Ect docu!c.entn attachod he r ein is to coincide with the C ah;'o c a a n to tontify tlhich the Capettrent tcauected in it s l
Iotion vnd t h e l' o a r ci c u b c ec'u e n tl y i n n u c c'.
l i
'i-h i n cubpoena dece:. tecur callr for the production or doeur ento chich ar e r elevent to the isnuo c" cc petition in the electtic atility in'uctiy in the state o' Te e
and out r ounding ntat<7, the nttuctutt ei the electr ic ut ility i ndurt r y in end tcanor. bly.vijacent t o t he u t n t. c o f ?,:a c, accecn to n u c.i e a t pouet p]ents, other cou r cen of (;ener a t ion and tiancaiccion cod the in t t::t et e ve t ne : intt an tale opo t c.ti on of u t il it ion in and atound the S t at c: of Texan.
_S u. b. t.ra c n > f_ o r D o c u r.e _n._t c_
Diano!d Shantock Cotpotation, Cleveland, Ohio Respect f ully suhiri tted,
)
0 n
,o s
bt 0
h?5!
N $~*'
I?Y
.,>_l,.. - ~.,
8' t
e bucun B1caen Cyphett b a s h i nci t o n,
D.C.
Attotney Janucty 18, 1980 Anti tt uct Division (f. S. Depal twent of Justice
( 2 0 2-7 2 6-6 M 7 )
+
c c.,:
- n..
i o s pi t r
i r<
.s s.
n..
,,)
s 3
,,., r
, i..
v
.s 1
I
!!VCL';/," 1:i;G UI. A'; N :V (W 'l l : N.
'~
D 64 D
- DWf
/1 H r.. i.,m r..r-iau a
U 'g"
- l!4idMM 1,'l Gl'i' l iK; A'.:1) l'U/li:f:
( :t f.'. ',i ; Y, al a1.
( D0'.11 h %':itu p r. > j. :c :
t h t :i I.h 3 and.')
A g,. g. pg I. i
.s...
?
M - /, 9 ;.h W:, m Un t, l 'fl F.G CIMi;i!/.TI NG (:U W-( ('s., i r. c' l'(f ah D 1 cir;;i M) oc i r.i C r,g..f,f;ig p e. i ' i <.
Uit i l.s I i:.tl '> )
.r 0 - ~,, 4 t i.%
3 t<<
Keeper of Records i
Dinnond Shnmrock Corocration Diamorid Shamrock Buildin(o 1]00 Superior Avenue.
Cleveland, 0110 44114 i
a i
'O ;
zi'. ', '. lilJ,1!il.) W D. " ' '. Ni;l(t ) hi ap;4-:
e 1:. r i.9 95...C.e.l.ehr.eem..Ec.de.r.a1.Bui.1. ding.
.O.. f..f..i..c..e....o..f....t..h.. e../. m....t.i..t..r..u..s..t....D.. ;i.v...i..c..i..o.n.....G.. r. q. a.t... L..ak..e.. s..F...i. e..l.d a,. t 4...h.l. ev. e l a. n.d,eb......h..i..o....
s C
O l
..,c..,..
,.9..3Q.....
.. I 9. 8......
t
'ls ruary 0
.., c h i,.. A. s.:,
v.
.n.
- i., ; %
A
}
in n
,d. cce ri.ti.:..I action mui 1.. ny: crith.w. ib. dne e. 3 a m ohj.. tN
<!c. u i'..d b the nu e! -!...che,h:le.
4 5
i ny oi:n:a: or um Nn. :n. in:n "
i.ri;..;:Nu wwn L
i I4,..
-~ ~.-..
i Susan B.
Cyph e.r tu
._.~
u,,
,.- a., r f..
. p,~
c
- o. v....
...; s,
t., o
. n....
,s.,
n >.., !.. (2.02 ).7.24.666.7..
..,... ~. ~ -. -.
~- * " ' -
i
]O(*..?.ll
- '.'. '. $) f O P'
,, o - !.. ; : e v' s, ; n ! *.< se s c ' es.'f
'~"
' ' ' ' ' ' ' H e.
6
^t I
g.
.!, s lI.
's p, !
u
' i c It 's **
. ):. s o,'s
- r. r: 0 -
- 1. >!
'I-
t f,,
e. - g.0, s.,. (,
- t..
' ' I c l'=
- !..e (; s l %
e'. ? : N * '.
a.c:
_r,.
s
1
/[
SCHODULE j
i I.
l DEF1MITIOMS J.
" Document" meana, without limiting the generality of itc meaning, all original (or copies where originals are unavellable) and non-identical copies (whether dilferent from originals by reanon of notation made on such copics or otherwise) of all uritten, recorded or graphic matter, however produced or reproduced, whether or not now in existence, of correspondence, telegrann, notcs or cound recc>r6ings of any type of conversation, rac o t ing or con-ference, minuten of directors' or co.aci L tee meetings,
no;aa r c ad a, inter-of fice commun irationc, studies, analyses, notes, books, records, reports, cuumarien and resul ts of invectigationc and tests, revieus, contracts, agreements, pauphlets, diariac, calendar or diary entrien, mapa, graphs, charts, s ta ti stical recorda, computer data or papers similar to any of the foregoing, however denoni nated, including preliminary versiona, draf tc or revisions of any of the foregeing nna any supporting, underlying or: preparatory Matollat.
)
i 2.
" Diam.ond" ucans the Diamond Shamrock Corporation.
3.
"TU" neans Te::as Utilities Co. and its subsidiariec Texac Pn.et & Light, Texan Electric Service Company, and Dallas Power and Light.
4.
"Whooling" means the transportation of electricity by a utility over its lines for another utility, including the receipt from and delivery to anothe: nysten of 1!ke amounts of energy, but not necessarily the same energy.
5.
"H LL P" means the Houston Lighting and Power Company.
II.
CL A I M O F PRI V _I_L_.U.G_ E If any dc;cument in withheld under claim of privilege, furnish a 3ist which identifica cach docunent for which prjvilege in claimed and which includes the following information for each such document: date, cubject mot' r,
sender, recipient, persons to whom copies were furniched together with their job titles, the basis on which privilege in clained, and the perngraph of thin cubpoena to which such documento recponds.
O D W] f III.
S; d T
_3 I
N e/.
INST 8UCTIOMS lt in requested that the documents submittcd be grouped according to the individual paragraph of the subpoena acetion to which they are responsivo and, within ca.ch such group, the documents should be arranged, as much au poncible, in chronological order.
In order to facilitate the handling of the documents which will be received it wou] d be appreciated if each of the documento would be nurabered consecutively.
It in suggented that in numbering the documents each page be numSered, except in thoce inctancen where the documents are bound together, when numbering only the first page in appropriate.
This procedure, if followed, will preserve the identity of all the documento coming from the con.pany, and alno in: ore the accurate and expeditious return ot thece docunents to t h e corc.p a ny.
In lieu of producing these documento at a depocition, the
,D e pa r t rae n t of Juntice in willing to discuna other arrangements f or production which raay be agreeable to counsel for Diamond and tl.e Depar t;nent attorneys.
Tne t irae period covered by thic cubpoena in 1976 to the present.
This nubpoena specifically requents that the Keeper of Recordc.',carch the files of George Knowlea, !!a r t: n.lil be r g and Uilliam Bricker for documento recponnive to t h i t, request.
Should any questions arise concerning this subpoone, please contact Susan B.
Cyphert (202-724-6472 or 724-6361) at the following address:
Department of Justice P.O.
Box 14141 4
Washington, D.C.
20044 IV.
DOCUllCMT3 TO DC PRODUCFD 1.
All doeuraents which relate or refer in any manner to communications between Diamond and TV concerning:
a).
Purchauing p m. e r f l o ra YU.
U O
b).
The cost of purchan.ing power froa TU.
JL v
c).
Lignite ir.ine cite power generation.
d).
The transnjssion or wheeling of poucr ovar TU's
- 1inon, e).
Co-generation.
f).
Joint generation, including generation using nuclear fuel.
2.
All doenments which relate or r e f e :..in any manner to commun ications between Diamond and DL6P concerning:
a).
The amount of power Diamond has purchaced or anticipateu purchaning from HLFP.
b).
The cost of power Diamond has purchased or anticipates purchaning from HELP.
c).
Lignite mine cito power generation.
d).
The transni;aion or wheeling of power f rom ou tnide of HL&P's cervice terrjtory to Diaraond.
e).
Co-generation.
f).
Joint generation, including generation using nuclear fuel.
3.
All other doenments not provided under Items 1 or 2 which show Diaa nd'n st.udy or inouiry into alternative nothods, ways, or cources of obtaining e)ectric power for its f aci] itiec in Texns (including any studien regarding the conta of cons tructing or adding to existing tranuminsion lineG), othcr than nurchacing from HL&P.
4.
All documents which contairi a comparison of electric power cocts (e.J., rate studica) in any area of: the United Statca.
5.
All documents filed before Texas Public Utilitico Commission relating to HLEP or TU's electric power ratec.
6.
All docuraento ubich relate or refer, in any way, to an annuanraent (engineering, economic, or otherwise) of the intrastate operations of any electric utility company in Texac.
I 1
UNITl;0 ST/3LD Or AMERI M NUCLl;AD Re;GULhTOuY C O M i1 H S T O.-
Defore the Atoaic.Jafetr_and Licearing Board 31: the iintter of
)
HOUSTON LIGil'TII G Ai 0 P0;' C R )
Docket Hon. 50-498A CO.,
et al.(South Tey.as
)
50-499A Project, Units 1 and 2)
)
)
TEXA3 UTILITILS Gidi: RATING
)
Docket Noc. 50-415A COR % Y (Coaanche Pech
)
50-446A Stea:t Llectric Station,
)
Unito 1.and 2)
)
}oc g
D '3 } f o
c 5.b.
Y oo.
Cl,H..J. C P I C A.T. _L_O. P. S L.RV..I. C C.
I narnoy certiiy that servicc of the foregoing Applicaeion I'o r Icot_nce of Suh?oena hca been rende on the following pa cica linted hereto this 10cn day of January.1980, by deponiting copier thereof in tne United Statec mail, first clans, po s t ag e prepaic.
j Marshal 1 C. 1;i 11 e r, Lsquire Alan S.
Rosenthal, Usquire Chairenn Chairman A tor,t i c S a f e t y & Licenning Board flichael C.
L'a r r a r, Enquire Panel Thoman S.
i;oor e, Ucquire j
U.S.
i;uc l ea r kogulatory Atomic Safety and Licensita Cora:ai n c i on Apper) Lourd Panel Washington, D.
C.
20555 U.S.
Nuclear Reynl atory Coumicsion liichael L.
- G1acer,
- l. quire Washington, D.
C.
20555 1150 17tn Street, U...
i.'a c h i n g t o n,
D.
C.
2003G Jerome D.
S h a r f ra a n, Usquire U.S.
Nuclear Regulatory Sheldon J.
holfe, Ucquiro Comrai t n i on Atoraic Saf ety & Licensing Doard Washington, D.
C.
20555 Piln O i U.S.
Nuclear Degulatory Chane H.
Stephens, Secretary Conmiasion Docketing and Service Dranch Wannington, D.
C.
20555 U.S.
duelear Regulatory Commiscion Samuel J.
Chilh, Secretary Uns h i ng t.a n,
D.
C.
20555 Office of the Secretary of the Coumincion Jerome Saltzman U.S.
Nuclear Regulatory Chief, Antitrust and Com.a i n c i.o n Indemnity Group Washington, D.
C.
20555 U.S.
Nuclear Regulatory Cou ni cc i on Washington, D.
C.
20555 l
t I
i
i.i r..;i t 1 i.
C.
Pric-noy P.
tm my, ' a ;ui re l
C o r.t r e l Ihew r a f.igh t Co.
liichaal !! ! c
.2, i;m;uire P.
O.
Do< 212i U.S.
Nuc1 car Reg t.1 a Lc r y l
Corpun Christi, Ten n 78403 Comaincion n'an h i ng ton,
D.
C.
20355 G.
I'. upruco, General l:c nag e r l
City Pui.,lic Servi'ec Loard Jerry L.
ila r r i n, r,g nire P.O.
Ci>x 1771 City Attorney, San,ntonjo, Te:a, 73203 Richard C.
Belough, Esquire s
As s i s t an t C i t.y /> t t or ney j
Perry C.
3 r i t. t a i h City of Atnitin Pr n". i dc n '
P.O.
D <,:. 100B T 2x s U.i1i tits Generating Auctin, h u, 78767 Oc: c.ny 2001 uryan Tow :r Robert C.
hcoiarmid, Lugiire De1 i t n,
" o. as 75201 lhnert A J :;!,1 o n, i quire Spiegel ar,J M c D i :; r t i d 4
a.L.
..ancock, Director 2000 Virginia Avenue, 4.w.
Ci b o.
i:artin h)actric h aa !ii ng to n, D C.
20030 Utility DeparLcent P.
O.
!;o :. 1000 Dan H.
iMvidson Auc.jn, Texan 73707 City hanager City of Austin G.
U.
Oprea, Jr.
P.
O.
Dca 1000 1,x ecu t i>/c Vi ce Pr es ident Auctin, Tc;:a s 78767 lloucton Lighting & l'av :. r 3
C o..ip a ny Don R.
autler, t;squ i r c j
P.
O.
Pnx 1700' 1225 Southuect'iower j
H o u a t :. n, 'rox a n 77001 Auntin, Texas 78701 j
Jon C... cod, Ucquire Joseph Ir ion Hornhan, 1:sc;n i r n U.
Regar Uils,on, U.tquire flerlyn D.
S r.ap e l n, Ucquire hattnev3, haulin, Unctarlano Spencer C.
Gelyca, fsguire i
L aarrett a:orsha:a, Porsythe & Sa'ipeln 3500 Alaro National Building 2001 Dryan Touer, Suite 2500 San I,ntonio, Texan 73205 Dallac, To::as 75201 Dav i:1 fi. S t.a h l, Unguiro Joseph I'not to, Ccquire I nh w.,
- f. i ncol n & Benle Nicholas S.
Reynolds, Esquire Suite 701 Dobevoice
(, Liberman 1050 17tn Strnot, U.n.
1200 17th Street, N.W.
j Washington, D.
C.
2003G Mach i ng t:on, D.
C.
20036
- ,
- i c' 3 e l 1.
- li 1 ler, Esquire Douglos P.
Jonn, Ucquir.e l
Jam s A.
Carney, Lwuire Akin, G u m,,, Hauer & Peld Saren D.
belling, nnquire 1333 Meu !!ampshi re Avenue, N.W.
I n h n::,, Lineoln & Beal:
Suito 400 4200 Onc f'i r s t :<a t io na l l'1ana Machington, D.
C.
20036 Chicago, Illinoic
.50G0J l
1 1
l
b u:,
lorg an ilun ter, naquire 1:obert Lowenctein, r, squire itcG i n n i n, Lochridge & 1; i l 'J o r e J.
A.
Bouknight, t,3 quire 5th Pleor, Tenac' State tank Gilliam J.
Franal i n, Ucquire Dullding Lovenntoin, 130 V m a n, lic i o,
900 Cong r em.. Avenne Axelrad & Toll Auc t i n, To:.a a 78101 102S Cc>nnecticut Avenue, !!. u.
Washington, D.
C.
20036 Jay N. Galt, Ouguiro Looney, i; i chol 3, Johnson C.
L.
Barnett, Unquiro
& licyeL Cnarlec G.
- Thrcsh, Jr.,
Enguire 219 Couch Drive J.
Gregory Copeland, Ucquire O k i n h 'n u City, Oklahoma 73]O1 Theodore P.
- Ucisc, Jr.,
1; squire Daher & Bottn i;noi r
'J.
Plucknott 3000 One Shall Pl m.a 1.xecutive Director flo u n t o n,
'2 e.as 77002 Com'itten on Power for the S o u t.ra n. L, Inc.
1;evin D.
P r t. t t, Laguire 5541 L
- Skolly Drive Annistant Attornty General Tul.s.a, Uclahoma 74135 P.O.
Box.32548 Capital Ltclion J o h n..'. DaviOLon, Unquiro Auutin, Ter.c 3 78711 Sautelle, Goode, Dnvianon
& 'i i c i l o Frederich H.
Rittu, Osquiro 1100 St,. Antonio Savinga Law Officon of lio r tucu L L hly Building Watergate 600 du i l a i r.j S a n /m e. :>n i o, Tor:n.
78205 ilachington, D.C.
20037 h.
S.
f;obnon Donald i4. C1eaenta, i:ng.
Gcnerc1 Anager Gul f S tatec Ut i l i t inn Coi:q>any Sou t h '.6 :an El ect r i c P.O.
Hon 2951 Coop;>rM ive, Inc.
Beaumont, Texas 77704 HouLe C, E.slding 102 i
Victeria nogional Airport lir.
G.
Holman Xing Victoria, Texas 77901 Uest Texac Utilities Co.
P.
O.
Bo.: 841 1:obe r t ti. nager,..nquire Abilene, Texan 79604 Connor, I;oore & Corber 174 7 Pennsyl vani a l.vo., !). W.
W.
11. Goolney, Usquire itac h i ng t o n,
D.C.
20006 1:] c be r g, Dyer, nedford & i-lo i l 1030 Petrelnuu To.<er R.
Gordon Gooch, Unquire Corpus Chricti, Texas 78474 Jonn P.
Itathin, Enquire Daher a DotLG
' /b,.,,,. [' gg ;, [,,,,.6,, 7.f' 1701 Penncylvania Avenue, U W.
Hannington, D.
C.
20006
/^"*<
t
/ Susan b.
Cypnert; Attorney
[
Eneigy Section Antit. runt Division Department of Juntice
-