ML20086L199
| ML20086L199 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Peach Bottom  |
| Issue date: | 04/09/1974 |
| From: | Ullrich W PECO ENERGY CO., (FORMERLY PHILADELPHIA ELECTRIC |
| To: | James O'Reilly NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION I) |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20086L198 | List: |
| References | |
| AO-74-19, NUDOCS 8402070459 | |
| Download: ML20086L199 (2) | |
Text
,.,
- 7. m um a3m omemm.,,,;,pm.n,, y, p.,
y g@.y
..e o m..a F.M%W$$
.( leltat.: Pennsylvania.. W/
... lU '
. /. g..
. ;R,@.J.'@.6. t TN.M.'1ll W Ws.7 4
76!at$
.44 Q-l,17314,,
~
/.C -
,.Wh'.D.o..C April 9 ' 1974
' W.Rf2 5
i1.s; M, s.'
~.
.> ;, pp.. p; / :V.y w f.f ig;, 7 A.
v
.g. y.... u,%...~.. : y.,f y, a.. &,.
,,...;;M r > %
. i.l.r, '. e.O. s n_. 4
.w
,, l','s,p. : ly Mr[ James p." O'Ne111N DirectoE..,7g',",}A.,,,g.7,'[ Q /f"* M */- N N
..km E..j.' Q e
co-u p,.
y,V3s
. t..
h
- u
,we f 'M N " ], M M.j ' Q h
/Pe" United States Atomic Energy Commission. [f,( f C
. E...,
[C.m.7
.v.
. 'k
, Directorate of Regulatory Operations K 'Y#
.,. *w c. *~
u. e.
J.e
.631 Park Avenue
".l M.'iA,L h.,v.,i s,'
n.,
'a
+
e, n, g~., M,.:N : 'U',ii
. 3 J 1.y.( g y -
j.
. King of Prussia, PennsylvaM a' "C'. _
a4 4.
w, p.
' U d. I : ';.h;.- -,, b M,n.., d "
1 s
. v.
w.y o
i
,,e Bubject: DAbnorm1' Occurrence 24-Hour Mo'tification 1
{F-i.
,, ;..we -
_1 s
..y., y :..y,
r ~
i
-e, t
',..~ ' j_ y,
f '"
l Confirming Mr. Franz' converaation with Mr. R. A.: Feil A.B.C. Region I.
1
, ;$.DQ ' Q.hQ;C I
RegulatoryOperationaOfficeonApril9.l1974y e
c e v,,, c...,
3.. f.r. u. u a
y
.,,_n...
.,e th M ',,
E.' '; k '
, [4 $ % ' '
Wl~R !l j,
Reference:
License Number'DPR 44, Amendment Number 1' I
l '.,'., "
.. Technical Specificatio.n Table 3 1.1,
- v...
- ,, f {,h.. y - m a
,, A' D y,, Z W
~M'c,P,R.e[ 3..d'.9 N*.*
r} 'r X f ', ;'$"," 4 ' - y jd" M / d M?
', s,,
h a,' '6 7 t
n
,r Y L ~, A ',
/
. j,', $ O [, d. W[ h M "
t 0'
.i Report No.:
50-277-74-19
,T
' :,4
. April 9,19741" "M [l w. 7( ;[:p(: h i KQ J j
q Report Date:
. April 8,' 1974 FE Occurrence Date:
-(
~ ! "..'r Peach Botton Atomic' Power' Station'
.,Y
!..MQ'.n f.
Facility:
- l i.. ;J ',
. fl-j g:r rid.% Delta, ; Pennsylvania [1731,42 [ j.Q'$[.h.U.$%} h.,i m v p. h5. m..a s'.<
... m...w... m....: n,. a..x....,n, w., a m<a..
- ~
- n....;, n.;.
s,..
- c,
a y, y y, s.;
Aw3 f.
r 7:
r wm
.,4,
p,.c, ' -
,.,{
.o 3:
,p 2.m. 3
,2,
.g L..
g e g.g ", j r
1
....+ 3,n t_.
i j.
t
, ; Identification of; Occurrence:".. ~ ~, ~ M );;,,' W X " j s,e 3 q.C,9 ' ' ih $.J f6 77
?.2 i.'~. q%z.
'y.
c),.;..Ml.m 4'
Setpoint, shift,on PS-2-5.-11A condenser.lov' vacuum scram.
.,.. r e c,..
n x n:
., L ~ 8 c:n 9,;\\.',,wlL '! :p W,..j. [;; 3 >y y.fJ.p ;.:
o o..
e r.
.<g u
~..
.. n
,i ;; y l 4 j.-
.A.,
[.
@..;.E. ' is t '!M.o4
- [C d.
,1:" M, '.:?o;. ( 1 ; .,.,., m.w t'
' Conditions Prior to Occurrence:
%,e< e, u
..n e
- a..
a
.,, T,j,
.V ?
.P.lant in cold 'ahutdown.,.
, S!G, R,,!w.J '
.u
]
s
.. ;,.g.
-m.
g
.y g
- ,un & m.M n &j' fM M 6 @+
n o.:.. F, O W ?.:
l
.V w
' Description of Occurrence:
.W. ;A -
@i.N.,.,
y:
t w During instrument surveillance (testing,c'PS-2-3-ll,i:R%l
[3.r A tripped at 22 3 inches Eg~',' _
L.
[
, vacuum, decreasing instead of.the Technical Specification' limit cf greater than:, ;
Ai Y, e'...'
",..,;alM. n...l:e',;,.j
., r$:lgg. %..;.;c :
U,...
,.23_ inches Eg.
W u
3 A
v :m,d[,. 9 v.,~,-.
y.
w..
o
<t: qp-i,
,, j s,
?
l-O+3
. y' j.g j
- I._i
! t,K n.c.j~
m
. Designation of Apparent Cause of Occurrence: ( ;ij,., "3 :
.c
,.. CM*
e 9MM.W(.W,"V$
Cify
[
c
,9:.y1<&,;gf. wlQ yk[m;%;j%u.(,%:g;-y,y M
iMinor instrum.ent setpoint shift. -
~
e p ii-t iA'.
...:'~
n.
. ;. gr.
y
,. mw
..... g ;. a,..e 1,
There were no safety implicatio? '"
h l,.. 1, i;.,,,2 0, MYlC tr@p..c M;.V;Q ' i
- ;_..,_ sy m,
1
' f' Analysis of Occurrence:
A ns associated with the'~aetpoint 'nMf t.of 'this ' '. 4 T
.,1 m
.instnment am.it is in a one-out-of-two twice logic and the plant was in' ~ QC j.
.... / J ;., N1%y.. [ %l m.". M<c) =O Jr7 % '. M h %< i W f
' i 'N eoid shutdown condition. "..
ps
. +.
, 4. y ' &
~',x,;M :n., ycud Ed.W l.N.a:t %:1m m77%- m
,o
- 3. s tx W@N.,*
-..s.M...i'd NeQ. Mh. id. W... :,,G,..
, Corrective Action tMq.
. Th.e switch was recalibrated,' tested.a.'W..
w, t
8 nd restored 't. o.. service. ". As ~an. 'addded...,i.
.m.1.c l P.g '
o i
/ conservatism, the..other3 switches which perform the esse. function',Twere. M.J-g4
- I
calibrated and functionally. tested and found to bei.within:noceptable.y T@dh l y y..
1 Technihl' Sp4cifi' cation limits. P..' t 7 W J T M.W T 9@. W WW'?
Ni ^.A.
c @ ' v 4~;. '.:.. ::.W=M... n c
Ci bc,
- b...;. 3. :., @o. n. 6... W-u..
t.,.,
,u.
n.
.,.. n., v y ~
M..
<M
\\
- v.,,.B,. iMw. :.,W.--
n...,s....c. N. \\ :G M.-.cr,..,G.,n-s
- 7. Failure Data:'.
.,.>. " A OM e-y
. ~. -
u Jhis,'asse switch.experiend anfout of epec'setpoint:.shitt on{1/5M4k FiveW$.'K
%c ' ;.;Q; f' "y[ 4other d=Nr switches used i fa'jj%.
p i. 3l,'Z.6 abnormalf. occurrences ; due ;to' sEtpoint;shittttof dated 8402070456 f g "
- N 5 @ k M5fd "}Mdly
~
%,'. y
@F@4, g;;. llQ;.
b.
3.
gF.O..yg,o s-g
- g...,,t 'n.,,4M,...._.d. {,3.w.q.
- ..u.%;,g;g.gegg y;nh..
goanoocaosoooM7 ygg w,
gun g,gyegge s
s.
p., a
.e
,, : j.q. ph;.yc u i.
., g e...
g/p
..er.- auo. m.a u n u <,w,4 &,a %w,m.4n.
g ",f tendent bpif 5 p m:h.
9 t, Y... d i W.
c Su
-~*.
- x. s: m. " a,o,ttom.i., t.,
st mmw e
a
4537..
unn to srA rrs
/.Y D
ATOMIC ENF.RGY COMMISSIOM
/i
' j ' TY j'i mm c ions. o r n t r.o.n i o n, o,.,
,, a r j
<g )
- ((,,.,Rl m 1, u m,
- c. u e A u x n v r N u t
\\v,<,_m - ;. ' 'j K I N G O f P l? U
>'_,1 A, l'L rJ N t;y LV A N I A 1 %10 6 v,-
e
-f
~lhaLch dcu. f 2
I Chief, Field Servicea and Enforcement Branch, EQ AEI;0D.L OCCUPIE:CE s
W Lieet.cee: ~ YL, C/J%, $ Ac O M Lt*~
2 r
J l
Doci:e t I,'a. :
6'C - 2 7 7 Atnormal Occurrence: 7 V-/ }
Ine attached report frc the subject liccncee is forwarded in accordance with R0 Manual Chapter 1000. Follow-up will be perfor'.".ed during the next incpection, as appropriate.
Copies of the report have been forwarde l to the PDR, Local PDH, I SIC, DTIE, and State representatives. The licenste vill submit a lO-day written report to Licencinc.
e
(
e' s
l sf A s (' S)
. : a 1
hL'q
)
m
.