ML20070D259
| ML20070D259 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Davis Besse, Perry, 05000000 |
| Issue date: | 12/02/1982 |
| From: | Pandy J CLEVELAND, OH |
| To: | Toalston A Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8212150012 | |
| Download: ML20070D259 (37) | |
Text
S0
- Jt$
~
fo - Y Yo A fiq sf $6rbetant.
taskus w
+
2 ALL-AMERIC A CTY GEORGE V. VOINOVICH, MAYOR 1982 DivissON OF UGHT & POWER DIEPARTMENT OF PUBUC UTIUTIES 1201 LAKE 3tDE AVENUE EDWARD H. RICHARD CL EVFL AND, OHIO 44114 DIRECTOR JOSEPH PANDY JR.
g j g/3/h December 2, 1982 United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D. C. 20555 ATTENTION: Mr. Argil Toalston, Chief and Anti-Trust &
Economic Analysis Branch, Division of Engineering Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Re: Operating License -Anti-Trust Review of Perry and Davis Besse Nuclear Plants
Dear Mr. Toalston:
Since our meeting of November 18, 1982, in Arlington Virginia, several significant developments have occurred.
On November 19, 1982, the Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, filed an application for Increase In Rates For Firm Power Service, with the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC).
In this application, C.E.I. claims that the wholesale power rate would increase our firm power costs by 1.71%, and that the trans-mission tariff would increase our wheeling costs by 48%. The most damaging aspect of this filing is a demand rachet of 50% of the highest actually demand during the previous 12 months. This effectively makes our seasonal (9 month) use of Buckeye Power less economical, unless an alternate source can be fcand to fill the short-term (3 month) requirement without the impact of a rachet such as C.E.I. applies to their increasingly high demand charges. A copy of the filing is enclosed.
Our preliminary anaylsis of this filing, indicates that the impact on our annual budget could be in excess of $4 million dollars, a cost increase which would severely impact our cost of providing power and virtually eliminate our ability to compete.
In effect, we believe this filing is essentially modeled on C.E.I.'s retail rates for large industrial users, and is not truly a wholesale rate.
The filing also redefines " Emergency Power", and forces us to either accept a higher billing demand racheted for 12 months or use our very expensive gas turbines to cover unexpected peaks.
It is our opinion that C.E.I.'s strategy is to address some of the concerns which we raised by letter of September 8, 1982, to you through the vehicle of this filing with FERC.
If FERC finds in support of C.E.I.'s application, they would then be a position to turn to the NRC and claim that these matters have already been resolved by appropriate regulatory agency review.
2 977 8212150012 821202 PDR ADOCK 05 GOO 346 M
e Accordingly, we respectfully request your pror.pt review of this filing,
.and consideration of the filing of a petition to intervene in this matter by the NRC.
The potential impact upon the City of Cleveland's Division of Light and Power in this matter is most serious, and we would welcome any thoughts, suggestions, or questions which you may have in this regard.
I also wish to advise you that on November 30, 1982, representatives of the City, including myself, Deputy Commissioner George S. Pofok, Assistant Commissioner Lawrence H. Wilhite, and Operations Manager Jerome W. Salko, met with representatives of C.E.I., and presented to them an agenda dated November 30, 1982, requesting agreement and services consistant with the CAPCO Basic Operating Agreement and the Perry License Conditions. A copy of the agenda of this meeting is enclosed for your information. We are waiting C.E.I.'s formal response to these requests, and will continue to keep you informed on these matters.
I have also enclosed correspondence between the City and C.E.I. relative to, C.E.I.'s refusal to bank or pay for scheduled deliveries of power from Buckeye and P.A.S.N.Y. that exceed the Division of Light and Power's load. I did not have a copy of these documents with me during our discussion of these matters on November 18th.
The City of Cleveland appreciates your attention to and review of these matters, and especially urges your intervention in the November 19th rate filing before FERC.
Very truly yours eta.cM b
(
Jo eph Pandy, Jr., Comm ioner Division of Light and Power JP/mm cc: Edward H. Richard, Director of Public Utilities William Lambe, U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission June Weiner, Law Department George S. Pofok, Deputy Commissioner Lawrence H. Wilhite, Assistant Commissioner Jerome W. Salko, Manager of Trans, & Dist. Operations File
.h
RECEIVED.
r
.,.it 2 J 1982 DIRECTOR OF LAW THE CIEVELAND EIECTRIC IIIUMINATING COMPANY BEFORE THE FEDERAL ENERGY REGUIATORY COMMISSION DOCKET NO.
APPLICATION FOR INCREASE IN RATES FOR FIRM POWTR SERVICE l
l l
VOIUME I CONTAINING FILING IETTER, PROPOSED RATES 1
l BILLING COMPARISONS AND TESTIMONY e
4
b REID & PRIEST '
e 1111 197 = STREET,N.W.
WA9HINGTON, D. c. 2 0036 aos see.Oloo ygw vosa astDToww OFFICE 1ELEX*CMM e4aOF wave Toma DowWTowN OFFICE 30 ROCMEFELLER FLAEA WAalMINGTON D.C. OFFICE 40 WALL STREET MEW YORE, N.Y. 30113 NEW YORE, N. Y.10005
- c>
November 19, 1982 Federal Energy Regulatory Commission 825 North Capitol Street, N.E.
Washington, D.C. 20426 Attention: Kenneth F. Plumb, Secretary i
Re: The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company Revisted Rates for Emergency Service, Firm Power, Service, and Transmission Service i
Gentlemen:
Pursuant to the provisions of Section 35.13 of the Regulations under the Federal Power Act, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company (CEI) submits herewith for filing six copies of the following volumes:
1.
Volume I, consisting of the following items:
a.
This transmission letter; b.
Attachment showing certain addresses; c.
Preposed Notice for publication in the Federal Register; 7
d.
Rate Schedule FERC No. 12, Revised Service Schedule A - Emergency Service; e.
Rate Schedule FERC No. 12, Revised Service Schedule B - Firm Power Service; f.
Second Revised Sheet Nos. 4 and 5 to CEI's FERC Electric Tariff, Original Volume No. 1; g.
Statements comparing the sales and service and revenues under Rate Schedule FERC No. 12, Service Schedule B for Firm; Power Service, for service to the City of
~
c
~
l i
Cleveland, Ohio (City) at present and proposed revenues.
This information is furnished for the twelve months ending December 31, 1981, which is Period I, and the twelve months ending December 31, 1983, which is Period II; h.
Statements comparing sales and service and revenues for transmission service under CEI's FERC Electric Tariff, Original Volume No. 1, at present and proposed revenues for Period I and Period II; i.
The testimony.
2.
Volume II, containing Statements AA through BL for Period I (12 months ending December 31, 1981) and Period II (12 months ending December 31, 1983).
3.
Volume III, containing the work papers for Period I and Period II.
The Company proposes to place its Revised service Schedules A and B to Rate Schedule FERC No. 12 for emergency service and firm power service and Second Revised Sheet Nos. 4 and 5 to its FERC Electric Tariff Original Volume No. 1 into effect as of January 18, 1983.
The Company believes that the rates proposed herein are just and reasonable and fully supported by the testimony and exhibits of its witnesses.
If the Com-mission deems it necessary to suspend the effectiveness of the Company's proposed rates, the Company respectfully requests that they be suspended, if at all, for a maximum of one day.
The City obtains its power and energy requirements from various sources, some of which have required that the City schedule its purchases of power from them in advance.
(
In the past, the City has purchased power from CEI under Service Schedule A - Emergency Service, during those times in which it had f ailed to schedule the purchase of sufficient power from other sources to meet its needs.
Under Revised Service Schedule A - Emergency Service to Rate Schedule No. 12, emer-gency service will be available to the City only in the event of a breakdown in or on the City's system or in the generation j
or transmission to which the City has firm entitlement, which l
impairs or jeopardizes the City's ability to meet the leads l
of its system.
i The rates and terms of revised Service Schedule A -
Emergency Service are similar to emergency service agreements CEI has with other utilities (see, e.g., " Interconnection Agreement Between CEI and the PJM Group" dated September 30, 1965, as amended).
CEI will continue to provide any power and energy needed by the City during non-emergency times under Service Schedule B - Firm Power Servit;.
l The present rates for firm power service under Service Schedule B to Rate Schedule FERC No. 12, are inade-In the testimony and exhibits accompanying this quate.
filing, the Company has supported rates which would enableThe the Company to earn a rate of return of 13.91 per cent.
proposed rates for firm pcwer service have been designed to enable the Company to have the opportunity to earn a rate of return of only 12.54 per cent.
The proposed rates represent an increase of 1.71 per cent in the rates for firm power service during Period II.
In addition, Service Schedule B - Firm Power Service has been modified to simplify administration of that rate and to reflect the fact that CEI must supply the City with Firm Power whenever the City's other sources of supply become unavailable.
Because the City purchases power from a variety of sources, its demands for power from CEI may fluctuate substantially during the year.
Therefore, CEI has eliminated the existing requirement that the City notify it in advance of increases or decreases in its contract demand, and has proposed instead a minimum billing provision pursuant to which the billing demand of the City is no less than 50% of the highest billing demand during the previous twel"e months.
The Company's Rate Schedule FERC No. 12 contains language which specifically allows CEI to seek changes unilaterally in the rates, terms and conditions of service to all customers affected by this filing.
The present rates for transmission service are also inadequate.
Although transmission service is available under CEI's FERC Electric Tariff, Original Volume No. 1, to municipalities or cocperatives within the combined CAPCO company territories, the City is the only customer using transmission service at the present time.
The propcsed transmission rates will provide CEI with a rate of return for transmission service of 12.86%, and will result in an increase in revenues of 48% for transmission service rendered to the City during Period II.
In addition, the Sheet No. 5 has been corrected to reflect the use of 1% losses which was originally established in Docket No. ER79-399.
A check payable to the Treasurer of the United States, in the amount of $7,162.23 is enclosed in accordance with Part 36 of the Commission's Rules and Regulations.
Copies of this application have been mailed to the persons shown on the attachment to this letter.
Copies have also been mailed to the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.
A comparison of the proposed rate schedules with other rates of the Company for similar services is omitted since the Company offers at this time no other services of sufficiently similar character to be comparable.
There are no expenses or costs included in the cost of service statement for Period I or Period II that have been alleged or judged in any administrative or judicial proceeding to be illegal, duplicative, or unnecessary costs that are demonstrably the product of discriminatory employ-ment practices.
No facilities will be installed or modified in order to supply the service to be furnished.
In accordance with Section 35.8(a) of the Regula-tions, a form of notice suitable for publication in the Federal Register is attached hereto.
It is requested that copies of all notices and correspondence relating to this filing be sent to:
Donald H. Hauser The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company P.O. Box 5000 Cleveland, Ohio 44101 Robert T. Hall, III Reid & Priest 40 Wall Street l
Richard M. Merriman JameL K. Mitchell l
Reid & Priest 1111 19th Street, N.W.
l, Washington, D.C.
20426 Ve truly yours, klf
,/
t James K. Mitchell Attorney for The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company l
{
r
U l'
The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company FERC Docket No.
ADDRESSES 1.
Public Utilities Commission of Ohio 375 S. High Street Columbus, Ohio 43215 4
2.
City of Cleveland 601 Lakeside Avenue, N.E.
Cleveland, Ohio 44114 e
l l
i I
i
=~
i UNITED STATES OF AMERICA FEDERAL ENERGY REGULATORY COMMISSION The Cleveland Electric Illuminating
)
Docket No. ER Company l
i Notice of Filing Of Chances in Rates and Charges Take notice that The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company (CEI) on November 19, 1982, tendered for filing Revised Service Schedule A - Emergency Service and Revised Service Schedule B - Firm Power Service to its Rate Schedule FERC No. 12, containing revised rates and charges applicable to CEI's emergency and firm power service to the City of Cleveland.
In addition, CEI tendered for filing Second Re-i vised Sheet Nos. 4 and 5 to its FERC Electric Tariff, providing I
for revised rates and charges for transmission service.
CEI proposes to place the Revised Service Schedules A and B to its 4
Rate Schedule FERC No. 12 and Second Revised Sheet Nos. 4 and 5 to its FERC Electric Tariff into effect as of January 18, 1983.
The revised rates and charges would increase revenues from sales under Service Schedule B to Rate Schedule FERC No.
12 by $225,768 based on calendar year 1983.
The revised rates and charges for transmission service to the City of Cleveland, the only customer presently receiving service under CEI's FERC Electric Tariff, would increase revenues S490,455 based on calendar year 1983.
Due to the nature of emergency service, no revenues have been projected for service under Revised Service Schedules A - Emergency Service.
The proposed rates contained in Revised Service Schedule B to Rate Schedule FERC No. 12 have been designed to enable CEI to have the opportunity to earn a rate of return of 12.54 percent, while the proposed rates for trans-mission service under the FERC Electric Tariff have been designed to enable CEI to have the opportunity to earn a rate of return of 12.86 percent.
CEI states that copies of the filing have been served upon the City of Cleveland and the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.
i Any person desiring to be heard or to protest said application should file a petition to intervene or protest with the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission 825 North Capitol Street, N.E., Washington, D.C.
20426, in accordance
..-m,,
,..,_-.___--__---,--,-e-
with Sections 385.212 and 385.207 of the Commission's Rules of Practice and Procedure.
All such petitions or protests should be filed on or before
, 1982.
Protests will be considered by the Commission in determining the appropriate action to be taken, but will not serve to make protestants parties to the proceeding.
Any person wi'shing to become a party must file a petition to intervene.
Copies of this application are on file with the Commission and are available for public inspection.
e l
l l
EMERGENCY SERVICE SCHEDULE CHANGES 6
.~
SERVICE SCHEDULE A ENERGENCY SERVICE Under Agreement dated April 17, 1975 Between The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The City of Cleveland, Department of Public Utilities SECTION 1 - DURATION 1.1 This Service Schedule, a part of an agreement dated April 17, 1975, between The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and the City of Cleveland, shall become eff+ective on the interconnection date as defined in Article 8.1 and shall continue in effect for one year, and thereafter for similar periods unless changed, modified or superseded.
1.2 This Schedule shall be subject to the jurisdiction of the governmental bodies having jurisdiction. This Schedule, the services to be rendered, compensation and the terms, conditions and rates included herein are subject to being superseded, changed or modified either in whole or in part, made from time to time by a legally effective filing of CEI with or by order of the regulatory authority having jurisdiction, and both CEI and the City shall have the right at any time to seek unilaterally superseding services, compensation, terms, conditions and rates from such authority.
SECTION 2 - SERVICES TO BE RENDERED 2.1 Subject to the provisions of Subsection 2.2 of this Section 2, in the event of a breakdown in or on the system of either Party or in the gene' ration or transmission to which either Party has fire entitlement, which impairs or jeopardizes the ability of the Party suffering the emergency to meet the loads of its system, the other Party shall deliver to such Party electric service in amounts up to and including 100 MVA, which 100 MVA is hereby designated and herein called Emergency Capacity. Such capacity limitations l
may be changed from time to time as the capacity of the interconnection may be increased pursuant to determination of the Operating Committee established by Article 3.
2.2 The Parties recognize that the delivery of electric service up to an includ-ing the Emergency Capacity as provided for in Subsection 2.1 of this Section 2 is subject to two conditions which preclude the delivery of the total energy requested:
(1) the system of a Party may be suffering an emergency in or on its own system as described in said Subsection 2.1, or (2) the system of a Party may be delivering electric energy, under a mutual emer-gency interchange agreement, to the system of another interconnection com-pany which is suffering an emergency in or on its system. Under conditions as cited under (1) above, neither Party shall be considered to be in default l
hereunder if unable to comply with the provisions of said Subsection 2.1.
Under conditions as cited under (2) above, neither Party shall be considered to be in default hereunder it it is unable to comply with the provisions of
(
said Subsection 2.1 provided that the aforesaid interconnected company has i
j.
suffered said emergency in or on its system prior to and within forty-eight hours of that of the other Party hereto and that if requested by said other Party, such delivery of electric energy to said interconnected company shall be discontinued within forty-eight hours following the start of such deliv-ery, except to the extent precluded by the terms of a mutual emergency inter-change agreement entered into prior to the date of this agreement, and a subsequent delivery shall be made to said other Party in accordance with the provisions of said Subsection 2.1.
SECTION 3 - BILLING 3.1 Billing of and compensatica for demand charges under this agreement shall be based on scheduled deliveries of power, unless actual deliver'ies exceed sched-uled deliveries, in which case actual metered deliveries shall provide the basis for billing and compensation, or unless the Party is unable to provide the amounts scheduled, in which case actual deliveries shall be the basis for billing and compensation. Billitg of and compensation for energy charges shall be based upon actual metered quantities except as provided for in Article 4.3.2 of the Agreement.
3.2 When the City buys emergency power from CEI, the amount of the Ohio Excise Tax that CEI is required to pay resulting from such sales to the City shall be governed by the provisions of Article 12 of the Agreement of which this Service Schedule is a part.
l l
i
.. _ _. - _ _... - - - ~
3.3 Each separately identified emergency shall be communicated to the other Party under the rules and procedures established by the Operating Committee and shall be treated as a separate emergency and billed accordingly.
SECTION 4 - EMERGENCY ENERGY 4.1 An Emergency Energy transaction is a scheduled transaction wherein one Party supplies energy to the other Party which said other Party cannot sup-ply because of a breakdown in or on the system of either Party or in the generation or transmission to which either Party has firm entitlement, which impairs or jeopardizes the ability of the Party suffering the emergency to meet the loads of its system.
4.2 For supply of Emergency Energy, the receiving Party shall pay to the sup-plying Party the sum of the following:
4.2.1 For Emergency Energy provided on the supplying Party's own system:
(a) the cost of generating such energy; plus (b) $1.40 per negawatthour for any such energy supplied; plus 4.2.2 For Emergency Energy obtained for this purpose from other systems not a party to this Agreement:
(a) the amount paid therefor by the supplying Party; plus (b) $0.50 per negawatthour for any such energy supplied.
.4-
=
-r w-
SECTION 5 - EXTENDED EMERGENCY SERVICE 5.1 Extended Emergency Service is provided whenever Emergency Energy is supplied by one Party to the other Party on two or more consecutive days.'
5.2 Except for the first day on which Extended Emergency Service begins, the Party receiving such service shall pay the supplying Party the sum of the following charges in addition to those described in Section 4 above:
5.2.1 An Extended Emergency Generation Service Charge of $5.00 per megawatt-hour of Emergency Energy provided on the supplying Patty's own system; plus 5.2.2 An Extended Emergency Transmission Service Charge of $1.20 per mega-watthour of Emergency Energy obtained by a Party from other systems not party to this agreement for supply to the other Party.
5.3 Any Emergency Energy supplied by one Party to the other which is scheduled for delivery to a system not a Party to this agreement shall be considered to be Extended Emergency Service and the above mentioned additional charges shall be applied on the first day of such supply and all subsequent days thereafter.
m e
9 6
9 9
8 e
O 9
FIRM POWER RATE CHANGES 3
ur SERVICE SCHEDULE B FIRM POWER SERVICE Under Agreement dated April 17, 1975 Between The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The City of Cleveland, Department of Public Utilities SECTION 1 - DURATION 1.1 This Service Schedule, a part of an agreement dated April 17,1975 (Agree-ment) between The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and the City of Cleveland, shall become effective upon the filing and approval hereof and shall remain in effect until five years after notice of cancellation shall have been given by either Party.
1.2 This Schedule shall be subject to the jurisdiction of the governmental bodies having regulatory authority over services rendered hereunder.
This Schedule, the services to be rendered, compensation and the terms, condi-tions and rates included herein are subject to being superseded, changed or modified either in whole or in part, made from time to time by a legally effective filing of CEI with or by order of the governmental regulatory au-thority having jurisdiction, and both CEI and the City shall have the right at any time to seek unilaterally superseding services, compensation, terms and conditions and rates from such regula, tory authcrity.
SECTION 2 - SERVICES TO BE RENDERED 2.1 CEI shall be obligated to provide and the City shall be entitled to receive and be obligated to pay for on the terms and conditions set forth* in this Service Schedule B electric power (Fire Power) and associated electric energy (Fire Energy). Throughout the duration of this Service Schedule B, i
CEI shall stand ready to provide Firm Power and deliver Fire Energy to the City subject to the provisions of this Service Schedule B, in any amount desired by the City up to a maximum rate of delivery of 100 MW.
2.2 The number of kilowatthours of Fire Energy to be delivered to the City and the time of delivery thereof, subject to the rate of delivery limit speci-fied in Paragraph 2.1 of this Service Schedule B, shall be scheduled by the City pursuant to rules and procedures agreed upon by the Operating Committee, established under Article 3.2 of the Agreement dated April 17, 1975. Each of the Parties shall exercise due diligence and reasonable care and fore-sight in arranging for and operating their respective power sources so that amounts of Fire Energy shall be delivered and taken in accordance with the delivery schedules.
2.3 For purposes of this Service Schedule B, Fire Power shall be defined as power which shall be made available to the City by CEI unless CEI finds it necessary to curtail or interrupt delivery of power to its firm retail cus-toners, in which case the delivery to the City under this Service Schedule B may be curtailed to the same degree as are deliveries to CEI's firm re-tail customers. An inability,to continue the delivery to the City may result from the loss of production or transmission capacity or area
-- =.
restrictions. In the event of curtailment of service hereunder, the City will be required to curtail service to its own firm retail customers by a like amount if its own dependable generating capacity or purchase of power from others is not sufficient to meet the electric power and energy require-ments of the City's retail customers.
SECTION 3 - COMPENSATION - RATE 3.1 The rates for electrical power and energy supplied hereunder shall be as follows:
MONTHLY RATES 3.1.1 DEMAND CHARGE For each kilowatt of Billing Demand
$12 96 I
3.1.2 ENERGY CHARGE t
l For each kilowatthour of Fire Energy 2 36p l
l 3.1.3 FUEL ADJUSTMENT (a) The energy charge shall be increased or decreased by an adjust-l l
ment amount per kilowatthour of sales (to the nearest.0010) equal to the difference between the fuel cost per kilowatthour C
I l
C <
L
of sales in the most recent calendar' month preceding the bill-ing date and the base fuel cost of 2.1260 per kilowatthour.
(b) Fuel costs shall be the cost of:
(i) Fossil and nuclear fuel consumed in CEI's own plants, i
and CEI's share of fossil and nuclear fuel consumed in jointly owned or leased plants; plus (ii) The actual identifiable fossil and nuclear fuel costs associated with energy purchased for reasons other than identified in Paragraph (b) (iii) below; plus (iii) The net energy cost of energy purchases, exclusive of capacity or demand charges (irrespective of the designa-tion assigned to such transaction) when such energy is purchased on an economic dispatch basis.
Included there-in may be such costs as the charges for economy energy purchases and the charges as a result of scheduled out-age, all such kinds of energy being purchased by CEI to i
l substitute for its own higher cost energy; and less i
(iv) The cost of fossil and nuclear fuel recovered through l
intersystem sales including the fuel costs related to i
economy energy sales and other energy sold on an economic j
i dispatch basis.
l I
i i
l L
I i I
(c) Sales shall be all kWh's sold, excluding intersystem sales.
Sales shall be equated to the sum of (i) generation, (ii) pur-chases, (iii) interchange-in, less (iv) energy associated with pumped storage operations, less (v) intersystem sales' referred i
to in Paragraph (b) (iv) above, less (vi) total system losses.
(d) The total system losses referred to in Paragraph (c) above shall be modified to reflect the level of losses associated only with wholesale sales for resale.
(e) The adjustment factor developed according to this procedure will be further modified to allow the recovery of gross receipts and other similar revenue based tax charges occasioned by the fuel adjustment revenues.
(f) The cost of fossil fuel shall include no items other than those listed in Account 151 of the Commission's Uniform System of Ac-counts for Public Utilities and Licensees. The cost of nuclear i
fuel shall be that as shown in Account 518, except that if Ac-count 518 also contains any expense for fossil fuel which has already been included in the cost of fossil fuel', it shall be
(
deducted from this Account.
l l
3.1.4 FIRM KILOWATT BILLING DEMAh3 l
The Fira Kilowatt Billing Demand in any billing period is the maximum Firm Demand which occurs in the Billing Period. The Firm Demand for l.
.--.. ---n-
w each hour equals the 60-minute integrated demand supplied over the interconnections with the City less the amount of power, adjusted for losses, scheduled to be wheeled to the City in the same hour.
3.1.5 FIRM ENERGY Subject to the limitation in Paragraph 2.1 hereof, the Fire Energy delivered in any hour shall be equal to the kilowattLours delivered to the City under this Service Schedule B.
3.1.6 HINIM'JM BILLING DEMAND For billing purposes, the Minimum Kilowatt Billing Demand in any month shall not be less than 50 percent of the highest Firm Kilowatt Billing Demand incurred during the previous twelve months.
1 i
l I
c i
l C
w
1 I
O TRANSMISSION TARIFF CHANGES I
l I
TH Oleveinni Tlectric Fe:nni Eevise~. Sheet No. L
'Illt=l int. ting Ccminny -
Oancels Tirst Fevired Sheet No. k FERC Electric Tariff Effectiva:
Original Volume so.1 E
D.
Cer:censation Ost:mer shall, with respect to transmission services which shall be reserved during any period of one week or longer (the Rese.'ved Period) under this Service Tariff, pay to CEI nanthly, an mount calcu-lated separately for each Transmission Reservatico equal to 'the product of (i) the prorated nonthly rate, $2 50 and (ii) the nexim.za arount of kilowatts which shall have been reserved (the Reserved Quantity) for transmission frt:rn or to suca inti-m.mion point ib-ing the Reserved Period; provided, however, that if at any ti.e during saic Rese:ved Period the anount of power and energy actually delivered at the delivery point, adjusted for losses thereon frcrn or to the inter =r:nection goint for which such transmissica service shall be so rese_ved, shall ex::eed the actual accunt of power and energy received at the receiving point, the excess shall be d d to be and shall be paid for by Os'a:er as an unscheduled inadvertent power delivery. Any such ex=ess delivery shall be settled for either by the return of equivalent power and energy or payant of the out-of-pocket cost in=2rred by CEI, plus 10% of such cost. Out-of-pocket cost shall compensate CEI for costs incsred that would otherwise not have been incurnd and shall be as of the delivery point specified in the a,s m,4 1 ate Service A,- - rnt.
If equivalent energy is returned, it shall be returned at times when the load condi-tions of CEI are equivalent to the load conditicas of CEI at the ti:ae the energy for which it is retsned was delivered or, if m elects
.d to have equivalent energy ret'sned uW different==nditions, it
~
shall be ret =ned in such a cunt, to be agreed upon by CEI and the Cust: mer, as will ccreensate for the difference in conditiens.
Ihere shall be added to any arount calculated pursuant to any of the foregoing provisicos of this Secticn an ancunt in dellars suffi-cient to reirburse m for any anounts paid or payable by it as sales, ex=ise or sirilar taxes (other than taxes based upon er reasured by net in==:e).
E.
Arrance::ents With other Svstems If the recuested Transmission Service involves transr.ission t
directly or indirectly on the facilities of a third utility system, est=mer will nake arrangements for use of those facilities directly with that third systa=, and i ~ shall not be obliged to c:rmance trans-I missien service until such arrange =ents have been nade. <-i shall be fu=ished pr=:=tly with copies of all a,.m.r.; relating thereto and any a:=ange ents or supple:ents thereto.
Osamr e.vressly agrees to inde=:ify and save har=less and defend CEI against all clairs, de ends, costs, er expenses arising out of providing the Transrissien Service, inclomg, without W'tation, clai.s er de: ands asserted by any supplying utility er any third party in c =nnection with the delivery of power t:
f=r est=ner's ac==nt.
e I
'i ht 3 ma evt.i 1.e.. sed O.a t *:9. 5 n1.:.ir45- :.:p.y ceneels First Revised Sheet No. 5 TETsc Electri:';ariff Effective:-
Original Volume'No. 1
</ '
F.
Iosses subject to the provisions of Section I and J hereof, CII will,
, in each hour that power is delivered to it for transmission for Castcrar's accer.nt, transmit and deliver ninety-eight percent (99%) of such power (adjustad to the nearest whole ET) to delivery point of Custaner, it being agreed that 15 of su::h power fairly reflects losses on the CII systen.
G.
RM1ine and Pavment i
Bins for Transmission Service shan be rendered nonthly by CII and paid nonthly by Custcr:ar. All such bins shall be due and peyable within forty-five days from the receipt of the bin. Any anount due and unpaid after the due date shan be +="=* delincuent and there shall be added interest of one percent (1.0%). For each succeeding thirty day period an =mtional one percent (1.0%) of the then unpaid at:cr.mt shall be added until the arount is paid in full.
In order that bins nay be rendered pt.yly after the end of each renth, it ray be necessary from tine to tire to esti: rate certain fac:crs involved in calculating the renthly billing. Adjustrents for errors in such estirates shall be included in the bin for the nonth following the ti e when infc=ation becomes available to nake such corrections or adjust =ents in the billing for the pecsiing ncnth or ncntas.
^
E.
In**~.::tions of Trans 'ission Service It is u:derstood and agreed that the Transmission Service, if and when available, win be furnished %i. (1) for interrupdons or faductions due to forces h a ~ibed in Section I of this Service Tariff; (2) for intern:ptions or reductions due to action institutad by aut=:ratic or nanual control *.ich results in disc::mection for the pse of traintaining oven 11 reliability and contiracity of CII's transmission system or for the purpose of protecting its generation or transreission facilities; or (3) for te::corary in.arn.iptiens or l
ra^ ~.icos, W.ich, in the opinien of CII, are necessary or desirable for the pse of raintenance, repairs, replace ents3 or installa-tion of equi:r:ent, or investigation ard inspection. CII does not guarz.. tee that the Tra:um:ission Service delivered hereurder will be free frem interruption or drpai..::ent and CII shall not be liable to cust=cer for damages resulting therefrczn.
1 -., e.rept in case of emergency as deta=:ined.y CII, win give Cust :e.: reasonable advance notice of any seneduled tarporary interru=r. ions or incair-
- ent of Transmission Service Custa:er will notify CEI's dispatrhers of any unschied in e=.:ptien,cr i.cai.- en: cf Trz.s:.issien Service by telephene ard ccnfi_- a such netice in wri ing en the same date suc.
notice was given, w v11 use due dili p ce to rerove all causes of such ~inte=.:pted er inpaired service.
,,---.-w 1-
- -- +-
Mr.vt.nur. UAI A w Mr.t Lt.t,r utAnter.U RATES Total Fire Pow r Firm Power Firm Power Demand Charge Energy Charge Fuel Charge Revenue at Line Month Billing Demand Energy Revenue Revenue Revenue Changed Rates No.,
1983 (kW)
(kWh)
($)
($)
($)
($)
1 Jan.
73,200 45,079,000 948,672 1,063,864 (59,053) 1,953,483 T
2 Feb.
73,000 41,430,000 946,080 977,748 (32,315) 1,891,513 n
'e 3
Mar.
36,600 20,087,000 474,336 474,053 (22,096) 926,293 4
Apr.
36,600 19,441,000 474,336 458,808 (16,525) 916,679
?
5 May 36,600 16,620,000 474,336 392,232 (12,797) 853,771 6
June 36,600 10,392,000 474,336 245,251 (6,755) 712,832
[
F 7 -July 36,600 10,494,000 474,336 247,658 (3,778) 718,216 E
8 Aug.
36,600 13,378,000 474,336 315,721-(4,816) 785,241
?:*
9 Sep.
36,600 10,588,000 474,336 249,877 (11,124) 713,089 E
10 Oct.
36,600 20,133,000 474,336 475,139 36,211 985,686 11 Nov.
36,600 18,236,000 474,336 430,370 11,124 915,830 4
12 Dec.
75,700 43,979,000 981,072 1,037,904 6,157 2,025,133 13 Totals 551,300 269,857,000 7,144,848 6,368,625 (115,767) 13,397,706
O REVENUE DATA TO REFLECT PRESENT RATES Total
^
Fire Fire Power Power Firm Demand Energy Fuel Revenue at Billing Power Charge Charge Charge Existing Line 1983 Demand Energy Revenue Revenue Revenue Rates No.
Month (kW)
_ (kWh)
I 1
Jan.
73,200 45,079,000 840,336 991,738 101,879 1,933,953 2
Feb.
73,000 41,430,000 838,040 911,460 115,590 1,865,090 f
3 Mar.
36,600 20,087,000 420,168 441,914 49,615 911,697 b
E 4
Apr.
36,600 19,441,000 420,168 427,702 52,880 900,750 5
May 36,600 16,620,000 420,168 365,640 46,536 832,344 6
6 '
June 36,600 10,392,000 420,168 228,624 30,345 679,137 E*
7 July 26,600 10,494,000 420,168 230,868 33,686 684,722
[
r-8 Aug.
36,600 13,378,000 420,168 294,316 42,943 757,427
- f 9
Sep.
36,600 10,588,000 420,168 232,936 74,010 727,114 Z
10 Oct.
36,600 20,133,000 420,168 442,926 141,535 1,004,629 11 Nov.
36,600 18,236,000 420,168 401,192 53,979 875,339 12 Dec.
75,700 43,979,000 869,036 967,538 163,162 1,989,736 13 Total 551,300 269,8,57,000 6,328,924 5,936,854 906,160 13,171 938 3
1 l
REVENUE TO RLrLECT CTint6tu hast.s Fire Total Power Firm Demand Energy Fuel Fire Power l
Billing Power Charge Charge Charge Revenue at Line Month Demand Energy Revenue Revenue Revenue Charged Rates I
No.
1981 (kW)
(kWh)
($)
($)
($)
($)
1 Jan 67,420 41,155,780 873,763 971,276 (157,215) 1,687,824
{
i 2
Feb 69,020 36,245,660 894,499 855,398 (123,434) 1,626,463 h
3 Mar 44,820 23,220,380 580,867 548,001 (77,556) 1,051,312 4
Apr 42,000 13,379,900 544,320 315,766 (33,717) 826,369 h
l 5
May 42,000 15,642,850 544,320 369,171 (58,348) 855.143 h
6 Jun 50,550 20,056,040 655,128 473,323 (24,669) 1,103,'782 7
Jul 50,160 17,791,990 650,074 419,891 7,473 1,077,438 E
I-8 Aug 42,000 16,557,190 544,320 390,750 (30,962) 904,108 g
o 9
Sep 42,256 14,160,840 547,638 334,196 (59,334) 822,500
{,
10 Oct 42,000 20,026,230 544,320 472,619 (89,517) 927,422 E
4 11 Nov 42,000 17,090,110 544,320 403,327 (51,612) 896,035 12 Dec 68,220 39,347,050 884,131 928,590 (169,586) 1,643,135 13 Total 602,446 274,674,020 7,807,700 6,482,308 (868,477) 13,421,531
_~
REVENUE DATA To REFIECT PRESENT RATES Total Firm Power Firm Demand Energy Fuel Firm Power Billing Power Charge Charge Charge Revenue at Line Month Demand Energy Revenue Revenue Revenue Existing Rates Nn.
1981 (W)
(Wh)
($)
($)
($)
($)
~
1 Jan.
67,420 41,155,780 555,541 864,271 (9,877) 1,409,935 g
2 Feb.
69,020 36,245,660 568,725 761,159 (61,980) 1,267,904 g
3 Mar.
44,820 23,220,380 369,317 487,628 5,573 862,518 h
I h
Apr.
42,000 13,379,900 346,080 280,978 14,183 641,2h1 5
May h2,000 15,6h2,850 346,080 328,500 (2,3h6) 672,234 3
f 6
June 50,550 20,056,040 416,532 421,177 47,132 884,841 7
July 50,160 17,791,990 413,318 373,632 71,168 858,118
{
E 8
Aug.
42,000 16,557,190 346,080 347,701 28,313 722,094 E
9 sep.
42,256 14,160,840 411,694 3m,672 (8,638) 705,728
{c 10 oct.
42,000 20,026,230 482,160 440,577 (19,025) 903,712
'I n
Nov.
42,000 17,090,110 482,160 375,982 9,571 867,713 12 Dec.
68,220 39,347,050 783,166 865,635 (28,723) 1,62o,078 13 TOTAL 602,hh6 274,674,0eo 5,520,853 5,849,912 45,351 11,416,116
~
REVENUE DATA TO REFIECT CHANGED WHEELING RATES Pasney Buckey Total
'Ibtal Revenue at
'Ibtal Revenue at Line Month Wheeled Wheeled Wheeled Present Rates Proposed Rates No.
1983 (kW)
(kW)
(kW)
($)
($)
1
.J ar.,
22,000 22,000 37,180 55,000 k
2 m '.
22,000 22,000 37,180 55,000 p
3 22,000 31,400 53,400 90,246 133,500 m
4
.T.
22,000 27,400 49,400 83,486 123,500 p
5 A-22,000 31,600 53,600 90,584 134,000 6
. Tun.
22,000 48,000 70,000 118,300 175,000 5
7 Jul.
22,000 51,800 73,800 124,722 184,500 p
8 Aug.
22,000 45,700 67,700 114,413 169,250 9
Sep.
22,000 46,000 68,000 114,920 170,000 h
10
&t.
22,000 27,100 49,100 82,979 122,750 6
11 Nov.
22,000 32,500 54,500 92,105 136,250 F
22,000 37,180 55,000
{
12 Dec.
22,000 13 Totals 264,0."
341,500 605,500 1,023,295 1,513, ISO
>0 l:
i h
e
~
REVENUE DATA TO REFLECTCilANGED WlEELING RATES Pasney Buckeye Tbtal
'Ibtal Revenue at
'IW 'l Revenue at Line Month Wheeled Wheeled Wheeled Present Rates Pr posed Rates No.
1981 (kW)
(kW)
(kW)
($)
($)
1 Jan.
22,000 22,000 37,180 55,000 p
2 Feb.
22,000 22,000 37,180 55,000 g
3 Mar.
22,000 20,000 42,000 70,980 105,000 p
4 Apr.
22,000 30,000 52,000 87,880 130,000 g
5 May 22,000 30,000 52,000 87,880 130,000 o
6 Jun.
22,000 30,000 52,000 87,880 130,000 P
7 Jul.
22,000 35,000 57,000 96,330 142,500 8
Aug.
22,000 35,000 57,000 96,330 142,500 y
9 Sep.
22,000 35,000 57,000 96,330 142,500 a
10 Oct.
22,000 25,000 47,000 79,430 117,500 p
11 Nov.
22,000 30,000 52,000 87,880 130,000
[
12 Dec.
22,000 22,000 37,180 55,000 i
5 13 Totals 264,000 270,000 534,000 902,460 1,335,000 g
l 5
0
CITY OF CLEVELAND DIVISION OF LIGHT & POWER fj'
- CEI -
AGENDA
~
(1)
Short Term Power ( reference CAPCO Basic Operating Agreement - Schedule B)
(2)
Non-Displacement Power (reference CAPCO Basic Operating Agreement - Schedule C)
(3)
Economy Power (reference CAPCO Basic Operating Agreement - Schedule D)
(4)
Unit Power (reference CAPCO Basic Operating Agreement - Schedule E )
(5)
Out-of-Pocket Cost (reference CAPCO Basic Operating Agreement - Schedule F)
(6)
Emergency Power (reference CAPC0 Basic Operating Agreement - Schedule G)
(7)
Coordination Services - (reference Perry License Conditions - 11; page 64)
(8)
Wholesale power in amounts needed to meet all or part of such entity's requirements (reference Perry License conditions - 10. page 64)
(9)
Operating conditions (reference CAPCO Basic Operating Agreement -
Article 5.01. page 11) - Compensation for power delivered.
~(10)
Operating Conditions (reference CAPCO Basic Operating Agreement - Article 5.08; page 13) Full utilization with respect to capacity and energy.... its entillement to receive capacity from another Party's ownership share.
(11)
Wheeling - PASNY, etc.
(12)
Transmission Tariff Schedule (13)
Other interconnection points (14)
Request to AEP for Big Rivers Electric Corp. power for the account of Cleveland.
(15)
Communications and Interconnection Metering (reference CAPCO Basic Operating Agreement - Articles 7 and 11 respectively) i 11/30/82 JP/m l
F
.c
- 1. ;6
-
- s c
- e:
e-r, a r ie -
r 2 e
If
- 1. i L \\
Li '. s 6 L
e!
ILLUMINATING BLDG. - 55 PUBLICSQUARE TELEPHONE (216) 622-9600 P.o. BOX 5000 - CLEVELAND. oH!O 44101 Serving The Best Location in the Nation May 27, 1982 Mr. Jerome W. Salko Manager, Systems Operation Division of Light and Power 1201 Lakeside Avenue Cleveland, Ohio 44114
Dear Mr. Salko:
This letter is in response to your letter to me dated May 7, 1982.
Section 4.3 of the Agreement provides that the City shall control all flows of power and kilovars between the Parties.
Therefore, GI will not bank or pay for scheduled deliveries of power from Buckeye and PASNY that exceed the Division of Light and Power's system load.
Sincerely yours, 7 % T.( Q Thomas J. Kraynak General Supervisor of System Dispatch
(
l TJK:mkh l
l l
cc:
W. N. Bingham D. H. Hauser J. P. Fitzgerald i
l
4 O
d The two hours are summarized as follows:
2--3 Hour 3--4 Hour 57.4 Total Load to FELP 56.8
-90 Buckeye Schedule
-90
-90 PASNY Schedule
-9.o
-16.0 Backeye Inadvertent
-16.0
-8.0 PASNY Inadvertent
-8.0 15.4 Firm Load to IELP 14.8 (before losses) 15 58 Firm Load to bELP 14 98 (adjusted for losses)
If you agree to the above, please sign and return the enclosed copy to me.
Very truly yours,
%T. l Thomas J. Kraynak, General Supervisor r
System Operation & Test x
Department RD:drs
/AJ
/J-N-7/
/Jerome SaYdo, Manager of Operations Date 3
{
1 l
lc
{
't !
l l
of debclite i
GEORGE V. VOINOVICH. M AYOR g
DE^ARTMENT OF PUBuC UTrJTIES tast LAKESIDE AVENUE SOUW K
CLEVELAND,OHIOdeIIe 9
Mr. Thomas Kraynak, General Supervisor Systems Operation and Test Department The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Co 6896 Atiller Road Brecksville, Ohio 44141
Dear Mr. Kraynak:
Please confirm our verbal correspondence as to the CEI Company's position with respect to inadverent deliveries of energy, whereby the scheduled deliveries of wheeled energy is more than the Division of Light and Power's system load.
It is my understanding that the Company's position is that they are not required to reimburse or return in-kind to the Division any such energy received under present contract terms.
Very truly yours, erome W. Salko, Afgr Systems Oper Division of Light and Power JWS/el cc: J. Pandy, Jr., Commissioner G. Pofok, Administrative Comm S. Titus, Operating Committee Alternate File
.a 4
THE CLEVELAND ELECTRIC ILLUMIN ATING COMPANY P o Box $000 m CLEVELAND OHlo 44101 e TELEPHONE (216) 622-9800 m ILLUMINATING BLOG e 55 PUBLIC SoUARE Serving The Best Location in the Nation Nove=ber 30, 1981 Mr. Jerome Salho, Manager Division of Light & Power City of Cleveland 1201 Lakeside Avenue Cleveland, Ohio 44114
Dear Mr. Salho:
On Sunday, November 15, 1981 the cleveland lenicipal Syste:
experienced a total outage of all customers for one hour and eighteen minutes. During this time the Buckeye and PASIE Power deliveries iere not curtailed causing CEI to accumulate 48 ISim of inadvertent energy, 32 IMm fro = Buckeye and 16 Wrm from PASITY. As you and I verbally agreed, the following pro-visions were made to reduce GI's inadvertent accumulation to zero.
For the hours ended 0300 and 0400 on November 19, 1981 Buckeye Power reduced its schedule to !ELP from 25 W to 9 m and CEI supplied the difference (l@Yrm) from the GI system. This 32 le will not be billed but will be used to reduce GI's inadvertent accu =alation from 48 !MS to 16 IM.
Since the PASNY schedule could not be changed, GI reduced IGLP's firm energy by 8 mum for the same two hours thereby reducing GI's inadvertent accu =alation_to zero.
1 I
l l
l l
l I