ML20024E304

Effect of Thermal Stress Analysis Procedure,Big Rock Point Plant

ML20024E304
Person / Time
Site:	Big Rock Point File:Consumers Energy icon.png
Issue date:	08/03/1983
From:	NUS CORP.
To:
Shared Package
ML20024E297	List: ML20024E296 ML20024E301 ML20024E304 ML20024E309 ML20024E312 ML20024E314
References
NUDOCS 8308100216
Download: ML20024E304 (18)

Text

-

Consumers Power Company Big Rock Point Plant Docket 50-155 ENCLOSURE 2 EFFECT OF THERMAL STRESS ANALYSIS PROCEDURE August 3, 1983 17 pages ic0783-0238bl42 8308100216 830803 PDR ADOCK 05000155 p

PDR

T~

ENCLOSURE 2 g

g DATE COFe Oi ATION CfC0- ESP riceno.5Id8-FA-06 By M kP CLIENT NO N6MI Cnecked By N'

SUBJECT 2, E 9fect of hvenal 54vess A nal sis

?vo ecclwc y

In he 4hevmel 44wss enelysis of te spect fvd pool 4 hot was

}oetjeremed earli ev, 4he %evrnel gvedierts were 40 appitec!

4 hot oJt %e. Afvuctwol elements c! &c pool t< ached 4 heir mod mum %trenal gradients at h Aarne.

Insbnl of ?irne - The esect of 4 cme was not consideve d in h

analysis.

I+ was believed 4het 4bc moemum 4hevmel grackenIs o.ffecf &c 44yuc4wal behav e<

c ond no4 &c ac4uol b e of 4 heir occatvencc. Et rcsun Ivem &c 4hermol analysis of ec Fool indi cale, howcv<v.

h at

% inner Walls reach 4 heir maximum eevmal qvadienis caviler 4 ban 4he -4hicker walls.

V3e e ff ect of 4his hvocedu ve ej a p plyi q h 1

on 4he 8inal testAlts is VeTy dificult 4hermol gvoclicnds 4e evalwale.

in 4he.

bresent analysis Thc Eveblero inv oI*:-

l conW nuous et-ac king cf 4hc 44vacture vcsui b g in 4he.

tekd and re dis h & d ion of 4hc t er m al w n w ts.

tNUS "llllC LL;HH > RATION CLIENT CPco - BRP FILE NO. 5/4 6 - FA-of gy W SUBJECT NRC Idems Checked By ML onalysis in which

%c 4bermai

%ctefore, a new are ab> lied followino ex ac.tly 4he.

4bermal g-radients g

gradrenf - krne

-reJaken4bik.s is petformed. %

hmot lead is o.bblied in 9 44ebs A wch h at 4hc hime instods a\\\\

od which maxirnum 4herrnal gradieni occv:ts in walis of diff ereni 4hickh esses are ir.cluded.

At each of 4hesc odd;4 tonal eguilibtium Nevallen

/aix firne.

insbanis an is heyformed and 4h e.

rnagins of Aasety ogainst local and averagc Ahear forces is clefevmined. At 4he final load Afeb 4hvec iterdions ave bev!ormed.

l h vnagins of Amfely againsf ba.nding rocyncnk, Ioco) Ahear force O.nd o.vevage 4heav 8orce o tc calev.lafed.

%e rn an ner in which

%c b ymolload b

op> lied, a Aumvnog f %e Aof ef y rn orgins cojcuiated b-resentea in aM a discusst er of wese tesults are 4he, following pqes.

tNUS l,",,s, DATE CXJFe;GRATION CP co-BRP pite no. 5/4 8 - F A,o d gy WP CLIENT SUBJECT NEO IhPMS Checked By

'd L h

time ins + ands

-from Ec skrF of 4be 4bevrn a\\

even4 af which each of

&c stabs of cl;& yen] 4hicknes 3

reach 4 heir maxi mum grac\\ierd atc dobujoded belo v/

Mab 4bickness Tirne of AT m Unch)

AT mo x G hs.S (t r) 24 ss 59 l

42 Bo

/o/o 45 38 80 67 48 8o 69 52 12.

(oo 49 56 85 too T0 M

G5.G2 tzo G'l

\\50

~(i TZ 150 Ti T8 (65 12 85 18 5 72 scnce ci,f{e.ven\\ woil elemenfs -reoch % eir mod mm 1

df mhetoh tATC g Yo clienks of Cl${trCnk dime IV15fonk s 'If is l

6 YOhYdCh6 h GNky Yhe rn 65 St/ Ch k n N#-

YUC LATO an alysis.

Tr.c 4hemcd gYochcrd - timt grephs

)>yes e nkd 1

in E'q teYe s 12-2 3 fo 12-53 Ahow 4 hoi o,jfe-v (6 5 hout5

P:g3 d of

/7 o7,/05/83 DATE CORPORATION CLIENT C.PCO -

BRP FILE NO. NA6-YA-O BY MKE SUBJECT NRC I~~d M S Checked By

/d L frorn 4he 44ott of 4hc 4hernncd evend 4he 4hetrn al gradienIs in all 4he Walls

.eHhe +-

vem oin Mexdy of dec-reose ve.Yf SloWIy EeTeheYe ihC hirne hetiod US*3 s

jov 4he nonlineov 4he.vrnal cxnalysis is (65 heavs.

dev4ain

.6udc&le Nmc inskants in 4his time bevied m+e 6o 4 lec}e.d 4hed 4 hey c.over %e fire.e instonis of maxi rnum 4he+moJ geodients of all 4he w alls. Tnc.

4hetrnal gtodiends anci 4he Oss o c.io.4ed mean demhevedvyts 4c

\\

of 4he. Walls cttc_ clefevmined cot-respencling co.ch of 4he delecfe.cl Mime insfonds. cand abblied ho be-rform 4he 4he-vmal 44Yess cLnaly si s by on incte rn e ntal b roce d uve-in eveose

-Yo.hidly cbrino

%e 4hetrnal g-radients 4he Sivst (oo ho wys 4roro 4hc 4 tort cf 4he 4beven al 4be l

event.

Beyond ice hou.ts kroe bevied

-they ovt very l

necyly 44eacly.

Tnere fove, rne re firne steps att used during fbe

$wsf 4o0 houss of -lhe 4vansic n4 eon 4he lost as hovers.

%e fimc ins' onle al wh'*ch 4he movi mum r

tNUS 07,/05/A:2, DATE CCn 0;CRATION CLIENT Cpco - ERP FILE NO._5 ( A 6 - FA - o $

By MKP NR C - IE6PA5 M'b Checked By SUBJECT l

4betmal gradied occu.vs in any Wall ate.inchded. The

)

4hevmol gradien) af which evacking is flyM inWahd is appyoximal ely 0 4 AT, (4T is h e. 4emhevo)ute gvedJ.

le fifSt Cy ac.ks cccur in ibe 24 inch 4 hick WOMs ej i

ee. hoc,1 d

c h ) fo %i m N ely h.n howti addev 4ht MT.'Y k Of b6 OCT rdo, e.V C nh. EcvefoYr kg i YSk hqCyc en t ef dht, ke?W')c loadiVig ch \\ied C.on$iSh5 of Ne gYodienk and e'ks

%5ccd O.fecl M4 an kcrnhevoh(ATC CcVY'Cs honcling b $s The 4absguent 4ienc insknfs 4 irne. Instan4 ei to houts.

a} Which 4hc 4herrnal loacl incTernen}s GTc o@ plied ate as}s}lcN.

he (Hys) co mmen4s.

Io CYoC.kinel Inihaled in a fen 5 o Co.hons__.._. _ _.

2R Cracke'n[ in pit 0Tess kv5 5ess

_ _ Ao Cveckind in 9

55 24 in. hek Wall teaches ATrnox.

80 42in.,45 38in. and 48 in. 4 hick Walls <coch ATrnox 100

52. t 2 in. and, 58. SS j'n._4 hic.k _ walls W.ach a Tgf _

12o G S. 6 2 in. 4Wck Wa!\\ reaches dTeax 1so GOn o n el 'Ta in. 4hich vveib teach 4T res a -

M5 18 in. and si in. 4 hick ells

-reach 4Ty,,

[

P:g' b of 07 ' F/ ' "

DATE

/

CCRFORATION CLIENT CP co - BRP FILE NO. 5/46-FA-o6 sy MKP N8 C - N6M S W

Checked By SUBJECT Ee T

,n, AT, T;n and T,4

{cv 4he diEerend wolis o3-he selec4ed bc Mslonfs ove Os 8citoWs:

Top Po4(en of East and south Woil (i = 2 4 ind y---

i Ime(Hn.)

to 25 4e 55 ao too

\\2o iso 18 5 ssN 4a.zl 4g 4T F) 24 38 54 59 si 49 1

t08 11 4

\\?o 12 3 124 tas t? 6 T

(t) 94

'P{

Tly (*F)

'o6 14 6 '135 143 5 1476 I43 5 lie.5 (49.f Isro l

T,3(op) 8a 80 61 gu.s cgz.3 71 s qq.s soc 9, fo2.

i

(

WesF Wall and Tc? Pot 4;on of N v4h Wall 6= 4 6 in-)

l Ime (Hrs) io 25 4o 55 8o too

\\2o Iso 18 5 4T (*F) 26 36 sz 63 69 48 46 A5 42.s g($) 90 94 98 102 107 f(O

((2 11 4 11 5 Ty (*F) 10 3 lie 124 133 5 14b 5 144 14E I4G3 ly.3 T,3(.p) Ti 76 72

'to 5 tz 5 %

Tl 81 8 63 8

tNUS 4, E-

"* 7 DATE CORPORATION CLIENT cPco-BRP FILE NO. bb - b4 "Od BY MK7 Mb A/RC -IddM6 Checked By SUBJECT Soulb Wa\\l Ich Ectfion (Y' d 2 in-)

Lican) io 25 4o ss So too

\\2o iso 18 s 4T (*F) 2 5*E 56 54 43 5 66 45 5 44 4t.s 39 h jy) 92 4s 99 to4 no tiz (14 116 us Tn('F)

Ick.g its (26 135 6 143 14 8'146 146 8 147 5 I j(8p)' 79 3. 17 ll 12 3 17 19 3 82 gg.3 gg.3 Setdh Well boHom povben beMo$2 o.vg. 46 375/c)

Imc(Hn) io 25 4o 55 So too

\\2o 15o 16 s 4T (*F) 26 36 54

/oS lo7 44.S 66

$3 5 di 5 (ggt)

H to3 to8 iti ti3 tis

((7 92.

9ft Ty ('F) los itz 12 6 13 4.s g4t.5 t yh.3 I46 146 8 li+15 T,.3(7)

T9 76

72. 7t.s ws la.g go g3 3 g g,3

tNUS 0 7,/O-f 5 #

CORPORATION DATE CLIENT CPco-BRP pite no. 5'/4B - FA -05 BY MK7 bb NNC-IfC M6 Checked By SUBJECT Souk wall bobm perhon (tobing 3 kvq,=- 52. tzis in.)

Imi(Hrs) to 25 4o 55 8o too

\\2o Iso 18 s 4T (*F) 2 fo 36 5 2-

42. dT.s

(#1 46.s 44 5 64 5 I Tl,gt) 91 94 96 toa icro m3 WJ ea u4

.r

..n.

I T, (*F) kl 10l, fik 124 133 lSTSI42& (4M1453 IM3 t

T;g,

~16 72 11 72 3 13 5 15 8 ts.g gr s Souab woll bonovn vo v4(on ( 4akeveng, t

= 58 6T5 in.)

Tmi(Hrs) to 2s 4o ss 80 too 12o iso las 4T (*F) 27 36 sz.

foo 48 To M.s 46

/oT l

Tmggt) 90 42.

10 0 604 1c55 107 409 11 2 -

T, ( e> sos.s

<<o izz iso iss i40.s (41.s 443 ics.s T,g,g u.s t4 To lo 70 ws tz.3 7s Ts.s

Nus O,7,!

CORPORATION DATE CLIENT CPdo - BRP site na._ $46-FA 0 6 sy Mix p blO C' 1 +f M6 b

Checked By SUBJECT Sotab wall boHom pov4 ion ( topeving, kg.= 45 62.s in.)

Ime (Hvs) to 23 4o ss ao Ico

\\2o 15o 18 5 4T(*F) n.5 36 5t do 61 5 695 lo 44.s 69

($)

89 9L d4 98 102.

104 to6 108 idi q

7

},(*P) ic2.s (og it9.s t 2.8 135 8 138 8 141 IL2 8 14 3..

Tg/,c) 1s.3 13 r,s.s ros 43 3 49 3 71 73 3 14.s Scu4b v4o)l behm portion (t = 69 in.)

Ime(Hrs) to 25 4o 55 8o too

\\2o Iso 18 5 4T (*F) 28 36 50 do 68 69.s 10 5 Tt 1o.5 4

(,(t) 139 9i 94 98 tot 10 3 (04 106 toS i

Ty (F)

(0B 101 ii9 128 13 5 137 8 139 3 14t.5 14 3 s Tg(op) 15 13 Gi 68 67 4e.3 r,s.g go.s 1a.3

~" "

tNUS CORPORATION DATE O

OO CLIENT CPco-BRP FILE NO. 5/4 b ~ bM ~ O # BY MNE NN C ~ IYCM8 b

Checked By SUBJECT Pool Fioor (t= 1a in.)_

i i

Imi(Hrs) to 25 4o 55 8o 10 0

\\2o 15o 18 5 AT (*F) 28 36

,50 566 (o7 70 7L 7\\ 5' Ti 3_.

Ik(t) 66 90 94 96 i ')t>

toz to3 les, go7 Ty (*F)102.

K2 it1 las 3 15 5 13 7 t%5 il o.8 lth3 5 2

=.

72 5 M ff 66 5 G7,6T5 Md U-

[T,,y(ap) y Eas4 Wall behorn bylion

(-b = T 6 in. )

l Ime(Hrs) to 25 Ao 55 8o foo

\\2o Iso 16 5 4T (*F) 28 5 36 49 57 66

/o8 5 To 7t T2.

kgn(t) 88 89 5 91 5 %d 98 5 too to2 10 4 to6 Ty ("F) to2a go7 5 its.s 12s 1315 I303 137 395 (42 T,,,(.7) n.s 7i s a5 (8

es s 45 8 67 4s 5 To l

\\

tNUS 07,! O E,!b.

CORPORATION DATE CLIENT

d. P co-BR P rite no. Ela B-FA- 06 sy uK0 NEl*-IMOMS Ik b' SUBJECT Checked sy WoM wall boitorn borh'on (i= 84 in.)

l b (tirs) to 2s 4o ss ao too 12o iso iss 4T (*F)

EM 38 46 57 65 5 48 44.s{ 71 u.

i 1

[ %.,wp.)

8T clo ctz $

98 im;let l tos 40 4 1 (*F) ist Si 109 uG 12 2.s 1306 '34 IG5 8 138 5 140 L

g(op)]a.s71 68 ss 6s 3 GG

/23 nsj 68 T

valuce o f T;n and Toa,

-Pnd o."

+bc inner 6avf ace a nd ouAer A v.y f o :c 4em p e tm+uvG of A

Wall and Nor slabs ave caled o4d os:

I I=

T,n g, n +(

in

1. 1 Toul = T rneon z.

l l

EE lE T

Lcos4 Wypn lov 4hc rooi slabs _

n n

~

7 0

R n

2 o

n Be.nding Bending

. Local Avengc Avc q e 2)evelop-t m

-j Mornent Morned shest sheat 6 hen.t

-ment M

f Mx My Tcyceg Vx Vy lenq%

Wesi Wall t.4/o 22.7 3.,;.z

4. 3a.

3,35 t14 Worth Wall t. 7(o 1 27 z.%

2 59 E tz IX1 k

3 Eosk Wall t 32.

2 19 40o 2 82 3 26

\\,( o g

south Wall 0 23 blZ 3 57 3.14 2 22 I OG

. b u

=

3

?

1 n

Poo\\ Floor I 4 2.

2. 43 3,32. '

3.zo z.47 1so (

i Ow O

2 9Q 3

$2 a

a 54 k

o.,

y w+

~

F

-k N

-tNUS

~ ";d-DATE mg CLIENT dEM EEE FILE NO. 8[4b ~bA" O Mr4' BY NOC - I~fCM6 Checked By IFL SUBJECT Sh e 0.T Mowqins du ttnq he. Jsransienk Wes4 Wall IiM "

5s 8o too

( 2.0 (so

<ss (Mcur)

Local shay 2 40 2 52.

3. (6 E.26 3 33 3 4z Fcyce Av g.

shear

3. o 2.

4. t z.

4..h 4.zi

4. 26 4 5 2.

l VS l

Avg.

l shat z'E 3 08 3 17 3'

4-3 E9 VY bloRTH WALL-l Time 5s Bo-too

< 2.o (so

<ss (Hous)

Loca\\

2'd sh eo.y 3 42.

2 20 2 16 32.3 3 15 Force Avg.

shear ZAz.

2. 05 2 13 2 14 2 66 a 5t Vx Avg.

s hca.t

i. T5 2.ci 2 0 2.

Z. o S 2 03 2 \\Z.

VY l

4

-tNUS

~ *;7!,f!&5 mg DATE CPco-BRF pite no 5/48-FA -o/o urf ey CLIENT NRC-Ifems

^' '

checked By susaecT Eash Wall l

Tim

• ss so too

<2.o tso

<sg (Hou.c) t L 0 C.llLl sh eo.t 3 t6 2 56 4.. !4 4 o7 4.co 4 oo Fer:c j

l Avg.

shear

2. lG

2.. o9 i

1.qc 2 91 1266 a 8?

V, i

I 3

Avg.

g g,g, 2 5E "s. Z$

3'46 3.SS 3 3t 3 2ro YY l

l

- __ a.

i i

%v%

Wo\\\\

l l

Time gg go too

<2.o zgo

<sg (Hov.t)

L o ca.\\

sh eo.t 1 82.

3 9L 3 77 3 65

3. /oo 3 57 Force.

Avg.

Shear

z. 84.

3.Z2.

3 2l

3. (i 3.og

3. t z.

Vx Avg.

shco.t 2' 3/o 2 25 2.23 2 21

2. 2 0

2. z 2.

Vy

P W l 5 of l?

DATE

g. mg CLIENT cPcn-BRP giteno S/46-FA - 0 6 Mr-P By NRO Ih6M6 Checked By

/A' SUBJECT Pool Floor Time ss so too (2.o m

<ss (Hout)

L o co.1 3 32 sheo.v 3 31 3 36 3 49 3 69 3 32.

i Force _r_

Avg-j shear 4 19 3, 15 5 Zo 3.t8 3-18 3 20 l

w L__

l Avg.

4 a.34 2 52 2'49 2 46 P 45 2 47 i

gh,y.

l I

l YY l

l ihe mar e, ins for locod cnd cRvev o.gc AheSr fevces to bou-vs info the tvansient our given in +he Table beist.

West N ov+b Ea5+

scum Pool l

wali Woil wol) w g))

pg,,y Local shear

2. 8 o 2 49 3 40 2 4G 3 53 l

' Force.

Avg.

i i

shear 3 38 3 16 2 67 3.28 3 80 l

Avg.

she a.-r 3 28 245 z.81 2 23 2 5G vy 1

I l

I 1

1

tNUS 07/ 28/ M CORPORAT1ON DATE CLIENT CPCO-BRP FILE NO.

5I4 8 -FA-o 6 sy MKP SUBJECT N80 IYfMS Checked By The Abeat mcwgins both fot local Gnd avevegt jveder 4 hen 40 indicakng o<deguodc 4 hear lovces ctre bofeh og air.5)

,6bcore. 'Ec momenl maygins cwe pedc~

kn b0 exec %

jov 4he sc Ah Wali elemerd

\\7 Tne Akech below shows

% d 4hc

<Iem ents swmu.nding 4 bis elemed arc.

e.i4het uncvac ked et have.lovge nSiegu of Adebg il 4hy Gve Cracked-If is at:2 served 4hed 4he neigh bovinge

-j

- 5 ::a% W ell Eork Wall Ted EL T El. 8 E4 4 El 2 Unct.

Uncy.

Uncr.

u ner.

El.15 E l.16 Efl. 9 Ef. (0 Uncy.

Uncr-4 47' U ncr.

El.23 El.24 Ed.17 El. (6 El.19 Bnce.

25 47*

02.3*

9 88*

Uncy.

(

El. 31 El. 32 El.25 El. 2G El.27 Unct.

U nct.

(.oq' Uncr.

Uncy.

EA. 40 El.33 Ef 34 U ncr.

2.. (g' Un cr.

l EL 54 1

2.. \\ 4. *

' Colc.ula ed rnovnen} morgt'as hot Cyached e.lemer35.

1

r of P:g:

07/28[63 CCRPQFiATION DATE CLIENT CPCo - Eh R P FILE NO.

5148 -F A - 06 BY MKP SUBJECT NRc-I+ EMS Checked By e.lem enfs have.

ad eguate veserve co}acMy to e sorb oddikono.)

be.nding moments redis4ributed

+o 4bem by 4he element 17-l l

l