ML20010B574
| ML20010B574 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Wolf Creek, Callaway  |
| Issue date: | 08/12/1981 |
| From: | Petrick N STANDARDIZED NUCLEAR UNIT POWER PLANT SYSTEM |
| To: | Harold Denton Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| SLNRC-81-65, NUDOCS 8108170257 | |
| Download: ML20010B574 (20) | |
Text
5f
/.
ir P k
SNUPPS ffV c
'h h[JLl L
monderdized Nucleer Unit l
'"*'"*"'8"'*"'
l0L
\\U G 1 4 I30I " "4 Nicholas A. Petrick 5 Choke Cherry Road j
Rockville, Meryloed 20050
,,M g.s. # g '
Executive Director
{
g (30H 86e.4010 t 12, 1981 g
SLNRC 81-65 FILE: 0278 SUBJ: Human Factors Evaluation of the SNUPPS Control Room Mr. Harold R. Denton, Director Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washingtcr, D.C.
20555 Docket Nos. STN 50-482, STN 50-483, and STN 50-486
Reference:
SLNRC 81-51, June 26, 1981: Same subject
Dear Mr. Denton:
The referenced letter discussed a detailed human factors evaluation of the SNUPPS control room that had been performed. During a visit to the Callaway site on July 29-31, 1981 by NRC personnel from the Human Factors Engineering Branch, SNUPPS was requested to provide the resolution of each of the human engineering findings identified in the attachment to the referenced letter. The enclosed table provides the requested information.
Ver truly yours,
\\e%c Nicholas A. Petrick RLS/vas cc:
J. K. Bryan UE G. L. Koester KGE D. T. McPhee KCPL W. A. Hansen FRC/ Cal T. E. Vandel
'RC/WC Attachment g
I 0108170257 810812 D PDR ADOCK 05000482)
A PDR
l i
HUMAN ENGINEERING FINDINGS (HEF)
HEF Priority Subject Disposition 1
2 Feactor Trip Breakers he Reactcr Trip Breaker indicators will be revised to indi-cate red when closed and green Wien cpen.
2 1
ESF Status Light Panels his panel is currently undergoing design changes as a result of this HEr'.
l 3
4 Directicn of Movement of Process h e controllers are not safety-related nor the primary indi-Controller caticn used by the cperator (flow rate is the primary indica-ticn). No acticn is deemed necessary.
4 4,2 Height vs. 5th Percentile Operator he probability that all cperators in the ccntrol rom will be less than 5 3" tall is negligibly small. No acticn is deemed necessary.
5 3
' System Sunmary Labels Further action cn identifying Functicnal or Systen labels is not reccmnended at this time. D e Main Control Board is i
sectionalized such that ccntrols and indications are grouped i
functionally. R ese groupings are so obvious to trained per-smnel that additicn of labels would be redundant. Additicn-ally, these labels would add visual clutter, and retract fran other, more useful signs and labels.
6' 3
J-Handles Guardrails will be provided as needed cn the rear panels.
Switchguards will be provided as necessary cn the front panels.
7 NA-Withdrawn by Essex 8
4 Location of Controllers hese ccntrollers are manipulated infrequently (used during startup) and are not safety-related. No acticn is deened ne ssary.
9 1
Legend Lights - Partial Trip Panel We legend plates will have and adhesive to prevent them frcan falling out. We panel has been rearranged more logically so that a mislocated legend plate would be cbvious.
10 3
Pushbuttcn Identificaticn Modificaticns will be made to either the legend lights or the pushbuttons cn the EHC so that there is a clear dis-tincticn between the two.
HUMAN EtCINEERI?G FINDINGS (HEF)
Page 2 HEF Priority Subject Disposition 11 2
Labels for Multipen Chart Recorders
'Ihis findityj was found to be simulator-specific. No further actico is demed necessary.
12 3
Indicator Lights Since the worst possible scenario is a delay in startup due to a restarting sequence for the turbine, no actica is demed necessary.
In addition, these controls are used infrequently.
13 NA Withdrawn by Essex 14 4
Telephone Locatims Unresolved 15 3
D earcation Lines No acticn is demed necessary. Demarcation lines are easily applied and altered in the field. Operaticns personnel should experiment with demarcation lines, using Appendix F of the Essex report as a guideline. This should be done after the operations group (W.C. & Callaway) have taken custody of their Main Control Boards. Mimics provide scoe mount of dmarcation.
16 2
Labeling No action is deemed necessary. It is understood that, in any situation involving operator stress, operaticn of the DG is autcmatic. 'Ibe meters identified by Essex are primarily for use in testing (when the key instrument is the synchroscope) or well into an accident sequence. A light cn tne control panel indicates to the cperator it safety equignent is powered frm the mergency bus.
17 3
Locaticn of Controllers No action is demed necessary. Demarcaticn lines are easily applied and altered in the field. Operaticos perscnnel should experiment with demarcation lines, using Appendix F of the Essex report as a guideline. This should be dcne after the cperaticms group (W.C. & _Callaway) have taken custody of their Main Control Boards. Mimics provide scme mount of d marcation.
18 NA Withdrawn by Essex l
HUMAN ENGINEERI?G FINDItOS (HEF)
Page 3
_ HEF '
Priority Subject Dispositicn 19 2,3 Pushbutton Arrang ment No prcbl es have been experienced by the ShUPPS operators at the simulator, therefore, no acticn is demed necessary.
20 3
Grouping of Controls and Displays he locaticns of the Boric Acid Totalizer (BG-FY-llCBB) ard the cmbined M/U and Boric Acid Totalizer (BG-FY-111BB) on RL002 will be reversed as reemmended by Essex.
21 NA Withdrawn by Essex 22 3
Labeling A decimal point will be added cn the boric acid counter.
The SNUPPS operators are trained to know that the unit of volume is gallcns.
23 1,3,5 Tolerance Zones cn Vertical Meters Tolerance zones will be marked cn most meters. The markings should be applied so that they are in the plane of the meter face to avoid parallax error. As this involves partial dis-assably of the meter, plant I&C perscnnel would be involved.
Action applicaticn of marking will follcw system turnover to operaticos.
24 3
Rotary Controls - Labels No probl ms have been experienced by the ShtPPS operators at the simulator, therefore, no acticn is deened necessary.
25 NA Withdrawn by Essex 26 3
Rotary Ccntrol A line will be ingraved cn the switen face of BG-HS-26 adjacent to "STOP" to indicate the stop pwiticn. Since this switch provides an input to the Westinghouse reactor makeup systs and controls the acticn of more than cne device.
Additicn of indicaticn lights cn the switch will not be made.
27 4
Accessability of Light Bulbs (Site-specific to Callaway). The probability that all operat. ors in the ccntrol roon will be less than 5'3" tall is negligibly snall. No acticn is demed necessa::y.
28 4
Locaticn of Labels (Site-specific to Callaway). Since this is a minor technical discrepancy coly, no acticn is deemed necessary.
i
liUMAN 120INEERING FINDINGS (fief)
Page 4 IIEF Priority Subject Disposition 29 4
I vs. 1 (Site-specific to Callaway). Since this is a minor technical discrepancy only, no acticn is deated necessary. Generally the context will clearly signify whether a vertical line is an "I" or a "1".
30 l 4
Labeling (Site-specific to Callaway). Since this is a minor technical discrepancy caly, no acticn is deened necessary.
31 NA Withdrawn by Essex 32 4
Meter Scales he significant factor is that the positicns of the pointers on left and right are to be matched, therefore, no actial is deened necessary.
33 3
Failure Mode of Vertical Meters
%e Lead A/E indicated that the Essex recomrendation is not technically feasible. No acticn is deened necessary.
34 3
Rotary Ccntrols he positicns of NIS recorder select switches SE US-1 and 2 on RIA03 will be reversed as suggested by the llEF.
35 3
Possible Dirt Collectim on Labels he utility cperating staffs will monitor the ccntrol roons for cleanliness.
36 3
Labels Colored by Separaticn Group No prcblens have been experienced by the SNUPPS operators at the simulator, therefore, no action is deened necessary.
37 1
Pushbuttcns Acknowledge pushbuttcns will continue to have mushroan heads (one pushbuttcn per board). All acknowledge buttcns will be capable of acknowledging all annunciators including first out.
Test aid reset buttcns will be recessed (in lieu of mushroan heads) to distinguish them fran the other buttcns. All buttcns will be arranged consistently.
38 4
Placenent of Indicator Lights The locaticn of the Air Caupressor indicatcr lights for Ccur-presscr A (QL-3) and Caupressor C (QIc1) will be reversed.
HJMiW ENGINEERING FINDItGS (HEF)
Page 5 HEF Priority Subject
! Dispositicn 39 2
Trend Recorders his meter will normally be used during startups where there will generally be an additicnal cperator in the Control Roan who could mcnitor this panel up close if need be. h erefore, no acticn is demed necessary.
40 3
Pushbuttons Shrouds will be a6ded to p2shbuttons SE-HS-5 and SE-HS-10.
41 3
Meter Scale he meter (MA-JI-4) will Le revised to a zero centered scale and provide indicaticn of VARS "IN" or "Olff".
42 2
Trend Recorders h e scales and nameplates for the recorders identified in this HEF were reviewed at the Callaway jobsite. In all cases the units and applicable pen color are identified cn the recorder labels. As these recorders are used for trend information, we feel that sufficient identificaticn of the scales has been provided to the operator. No acticn is demed necessary.
l 43 1
Mimics UE and KGE will meet to develop and subinit mimic changes and l
corrections.
I 44 2
LED Display of Control Rod Position No action is deemed necessary. Space, locaticn and panel design are such that no modificaticn can be made.
I 45 3
Covers cn Process Controllers his prcblm is unique to ccnstruction. his tyle of prd>lm s5culd be noticed and corrected during turnover.
46 1
Fressurizer Pressure Indicaticn his HEF notes the lack of Reactor Coolant pressure indica-I ticn cn RIA02 between 700 and 1700 PSIG. Were are indica-tors available for the 0-700 and 1700 2500 pressure ranges.
{
Indicaticn of Eeactor Coolant pressure between 700 and 1700 l
is available to the cperator at the ccnsole by puttire the wide range pressure indicaticn on the ccznputer trend recorder on RIAC2 or the CRT display cn RID 04.
he (perators deem no changes to be necessary.
I
i IR. NAN ENGINEERING FIEINGS (HEF)
Page 6 HEF '
Priority Subject Disposition 47 3
Direction of Control Movement he SYNC Check Relay Bypass Switch MA-HS-7 will be revised to allow the key to be removed in the lett (auto) positicn, provided prcper switch acticn is available.
48 1
J-Handles No problems have been experienced by the SNUPPS operatcrs ac tne simulator. Mministrative procedures will be enployed '
to cover proper use of controls, thereby preventing the occurrence of this finding. No further action is demed necessary.
49 NA Withdrawn by Essex l
50 2
Pushbuttcn Guards h e only potential safety issue is reset of the signal.
51 1
Mimics UE and KGE will meet to develop and submit mimic changes and-correcticns.
52 1
Mimics UE and KGE will meet to develop and st.anit mimic changes and corrections.
53 NA Withdrawn by Essex 54 3
. Meter Scales he relative positicn of the pointer is more important than the exact value indicated for this non-safety-related instru.
ment. No acticn is deemed mcessary.
55 4'
Horizontal Meter Scales (Site-specific _ Callaway). Since'this is a minar tecnnical j.
cliscrepancy only, no acticn is 'desned' necessary. In addi-l tion, all of this infomaticn is available cn the BOP j
ccraputer.
I 56' 4
Cover Obscuring Display Boron is injected via a counter when 'a parameter change is desired. After injecticn, parameters will be checked by the operators. We borcncneter can be cilecked fcr anounts of l
- boren additicn, if desired.. Therefore,' no acticn is deemed necessary..
l l
l l
w p
s HUMM ENGINEEREG FDODOS (HEF)
Page 7' i
HEF '
Priority Subject Dispositicn 57.
NA Withdrawa by Essex 58 4
-Scales cn Vertical Meters No prchlens have been experienced by the SNUPPS operators at the simulator, therefore, no acticn is~deened necessary.
59 4
Breaker Location No acticn is desned necessary. Control locatico cn this i
panel is tight, howewr, a mimic does exist. 'Ine anneter has only a limited associaticn with the indicated switch.
60 3
J-Handles
'Ihe labu " Bod. Drive Power Supplp will be placed with the indicated ccntrol (PG-HIS-16 and,18) and the existing handles will be replaced with red handles.
61 NA Withdrawn by Essex 62 NA Withdrawn by Essex 63 3
Mimics UE and KGE will meet to dewlop and subnit mimic changes and ccrrecticns.
64 NA.
Withdrawn by Essex 65 3
J-Handle Iabels he label for NB-HIS-1 will be revised to read XMR01 to XNB02 Breaker 252PA0201.
~66 3
Mimics-UE and KGE will meet to develop and subnit mimic changes and:
ccrrecticns.
l 67 4
- Labeling Operatcrs will te trained to understand positicn indicaticn, therefcre, no acticn is deemed necessary.
68 3
Pointer Length his HEF states that the pointer cbscures the minor. grad-i uaticn nwrks cn the recorder scale for the RHR heat exchanger -
tenperatures.. It appears that this should 'cause no cpera.
l tional problens and the Iead A/E reccanends no changes be l'
made.
If the cperator requires accurate readings of RHR
~
tenperature, they are available cn the cmputer CRP.
l l'
I HJMAN ENGINEERDG FItOItGS (HEF)
Page 8 HEF ! Priority '
Subject Dispositicn 69-3 Mimics UE and KGE will meet to develop and subnit mimic changes and corrections.
70 2
J-Handles No problens have been experienced by the SNUPPS operators at the simulator, therefcre, no action is deemed necessary.
i 71 2
Height of Controls he probability that all cperators in the Control Roan will I
be less than 5'3" tall is negligibly snall. No ation is drened necessary.
l-72 1
Labeling he label for switch SB-HS-47 will be revised to read "Cco-l tairunent Isolaticn Phase A".
l l
73 1
Labeling he label for indicatcr BG-FI-183A will be revised to read j
" Emergency Borate Flow".
74 NA Withdrawn by Essex l
75 4
Pushbuttcns (Site-specific to Callaway). Since this is a minor tecnnical i
discreparcy only, no action is desned necessary.
76 3
Rotary Control he process is a controlled evoluticn and the cperator has j
other indicatcrs for his use. No acticn is deemed necessary.
l l
'77 4
Labelirs he recorder identified in this HEF has not been installed in the control panels at Callaway. After installation, they will i
be reviewed to insure that sufficient infonnatico regardin3 l
the scales has been provided to the operatx.
78 4
Labeling As this finding represents _a technical deviaticn to the guide-lines and a fix would cnly be a nicety, no acticn is deemed necessary.
l 79 NA Withdrawn by Essex 80 2
Labeling he SNUPPS operators advise that the lights are self-explanatory. Were is also direct ccmnunica"icn when these l
valves cpen. No acticn is desned necessary.
l l
l
.~.
HUMAN ENGINEERING FIbDIM3S (HEF)
Page 9' HEF !
Priority '
Subject Dispositicri 81 NA Withdrawn by Essex
~l l
82L 3-Labeling Labels will be reviewed for sufficient and cmsiitent infor-mation and where confusing and redundant, the labels cn
-l
+
Westinghouse-su[plial Hagen Controllers will be removed and replaced with. blank plates.
i 83 3
Hagen Process Controllers Because the relative.positicn of the pointer is more important.
than the exact valve indicated, no action is desned necessary.
~l 7
84 NA Withdrawn by Essex 4
F5 NA WitMrawn by Essex 86 1
Labeling m e labels for indicators BasrI-421A, 431A and 441A will be revised to indicate AT.'
87
'l Vettical Meter he locatione of indicators AB-PI-507 and AB-UI-500 will be.
interchanged as noted.
2 88 2
Labeling of Trend becorders Since the letters "A-B-C-D" ca respond directly with "l-2-3-4",
this is considered a minor technical discrepancy and no. action is deemed.necessary.
l-89 NA Withdrawn by Essex 90 4
Labeling Utilities will develop' desired label formats and provide to
- the Lead A/E for installation and incorporation in drawings.'
91 3
Direction of Motion tor Controls
' Control switch BG-HS-27 will-be revised (as indicated in the HEF) to have the OFF position between " Dilute" and " Borate" provided concurrence is received fran Westinghouse. Since this is a maintained contact switch and the switch indicates the mode of operation (borate cr dilute), there will be no j
addition of an indicating limht.
92 NA-Withdrawn by Essex l
+
HUMAN ENGINEERING FINDINGS (HEF)
Page 10 HEF '
Priority Subject Dispositicn 93 4
Consiscency of Abbreviatims The pushbutton for HB-HIS-7176 will be revised to read'" Nom"
[
in crder to provide consistency with other pushbuttcn labeling.
l 94 1
Pishbuttcns he purpose of this switch is to provide testing of the auto-l-
matic switcht mr fran RWST to ccntairinent sump for the RHR pmp suction. Operaticn of this testing circuit is described in Westinghouse procedure E-EPS3139. One pushbutton closes the l
valve in the RWST line and is labeled " Test". h e other push-buttcn tests the interlock with the sump isolation valve and l
the pushbutton label reads " Test Lamp". h is buttcn will be revised to read " Valve Test".
.- 95 3
Scales for Process Controllers he dispositicn is still under review by SNUPPS.
l 3
Legend Light.
Labeling will % checked by '.he utilities prior to turnowr.
No further acticn is deemed necessary.
97l
'l Pushbuttons he wording on the label will be citanged to " bypass".
98 NA Withdrawn by Essex 99 1
Light Bult Replacenent he utilities will provide any tools necessary to change light bulbs in Cutler Hamner Switches.
100 1
Labe. ling cn Trend Recorders he labals on recorders FJ-TR-613 and 612 will be manged to read "A" and "B" in lieu of "1"'and "2".
101-NA Withdrawn by Essex 102 1
RM17 Arrangement A mock-up of RM17 and RM18 will be made for utility input and review as a result of this HEF.
103 3
Locaticn of Controllers (Site-specific to Callaway). Unresolved at this time.
104 NA Withdrawn by Essex 105.
3 Legend Lights' (Site-specific to Callaway). Unresolved at this time.
106 4
Labeling of' Horizontal Meters (Site-specific to Callaway). _ Unresolved at this time.
IfUMAN DGINEERItG FINDI?ES (itEF)
Page 11 llEF Priority '
Subject Dispositicn 107 1
Pennissive/ Partial Trip / Block Status his panel has been redesigned to correct the prchlens identi-Panel fied by this llEF.
108 NA Withdrawn oy Essex 109 NA Withdrawn by Essex 110 4
Scales for Process Controllers We cperatcrs have not experienced any prooluus with the pointer obscuri m the nunerals. W ese controllers are set periodically ano most are normally not changed. No acticn is deaned necessary.
111 3
Labeling (Site-specific to Callaway). Unresolved at this time, 112 2
, Light Bulb Replacarent Either long life bulbs will be used cr bulbs will be at lower operating voltages.
113 3
Pushbuttcms A guarded switch will be used to replace BG-HIS-8145.
114 4
Rotary Control he switch in questicn is only a meter select switen ard not a control function. No action is deened necessary.
115 3
Vertical Meters
%e locaticos of indicators PC-PI-164A and FC-PI-68A will be interchanged as indicated by this 11EF.
116 4
Grouping of Controls Since this lief is ccnsidered a minor technical discrepancy, no acticn is deemed necessary.
117 4
Vertical Meters and Simple Indicators he labelirs for indicators AC-FI-64, 82, 91 and 87 will be revised as follows:
AC-F T-84 "lef1R C 1st f"U Steam Flow" AC-FI-82 "RitTR C 2nd S'IU Stean Flow" AC-FI-81 "tuTIR D lst SIG Steam Flow" AC-FI-87 "Rir1R D 2nd SIG Steam Flow" This change makes the latels consistent with the flow indica-tcrs for reheaters A & u.
HLNAN DGINEERING FI!OINGS (HEF)
Page'12 HEF Priority Subject I Disposition 118 NA Withdrawn by Essex 119 3
Labeling of Process' Controller his HEF was corrected with the mimic changes cn RLOl7 and 18 mock-up. A directicn label will be addeo to the mimic indicating "To Acctznulata Tanks' A & C".
i 120 l NA Withdrawn by Essex
-121 NA Withdrawn by Essex 122 '
3 Inccnsistency of Labels Annunciators, controls, and labels will be reviewed for ccn-sistency and corrections will be made w ere necessary.
123 NA Withdrawn 124 4
Pushbuttons his HEF was inplemented as-requested with the mimic changes on RIAL 7 and 18 mock-up.
125-
.NA Withdrawn-by Essex 126 NA Withdrawn by Essex t
127-4 Labeling The (peratas have not experien d any problems with unntsnbered minor marks cn the meter faces. - mese controllers f
are set periodically and most are normaUy not changes..No acticn is deemed necessary.
128 4
Labeling Since this is considered a minor technical discrepancy, no I
acticn is deemed necessary.
129 3
Rotary Controls he SYNC Check Belay Bypass Switch MA-HS-7 will be revised to
-I allow the key..to be removed in the left (auto) position, pecr
-vided proper switch action is available.
130 3
Labeling Since this finding is ccnsidered to be a minor technical dis-
- crepancy, no action is deened necessary.
HUMAN ENGINEERlfG FINDINGS (HEF)
Page 13 HEF Priority Subject Disposition 131 4
Horizontal Meters (Site-specific to Callaway). Unresolved at this time.
132 3
Location of Controllers No acticn is desned necessary. Denarcaticn lines are easily aIplied and altered in the field. Operations personnel should experiment with demarcation lines, using Appendin F of.the Essex report as a guideline. h is should be done after the operations grcup (W.C. & Callaway) have taken custcr2y of their -
Main Control Boards. Mimics provide sone anount of demarca-ticn. M1ile switch AB ULS-500Z is not 2mnediately adjacent to the Stean Header Pressure pressure controller, it is located.
within a small cluster of congcnents devoted to stean dunp control. Se low priority of this HEF does not justify the expense of relocating caugx:nents.
133 4
Height w. 5th Percentile. Operator he probability that all cperators in the ccntrol room will be less than 5'3" tall is negligibly anall. No acticn is deemed necessary.
.134
'NA.
Withdrawn by Essex.
i 135:
NA Withdrawn by Essex r
136 NA
. Withdrawn by Essex 137 NA Withdrawn by Essex l
138 NA Withdrawn bf Essex 139 4
Multipen Trend Recorders he noters cannot. easily be changed because all indications have redundant indicatcrs except " Seal Injecticm Flcw to Reactor Collant Pumps", which has a ccuputer point and alarm.
No acticn is deened necessary.
140 4
Trend Recorders Trend recorders are generally used' for approximation diereas meters are used for accurate measurements. No action is deemed necessary, i
.m-
l HUMAN EtGINEERING FINDI!CS (HEF)
Page 14
\\
HEF Priority '
Subject L Disposition i
l 141 1
Annunciatcr Windows A method of iden'ifying each window is currently under in wsti-l gaticn.
l l
142 1
Annunciator Prioritizaticn Annunciat 3r pricritizaticn is currently beirg developed for i
review by the utilities.
143 2
Separaticn of Meters Since wide range reacter coolant pressure indication is pro-vided cn RLO22, no acticn is deemed necessary.
l
[
144 NA Withdrawn by Essex l
145 3
Labeling of Process Controller The label for process ccntroller EP-HC-93 will be changed to "Accm. N 8" W Y biU* Y*"t"*
1 2
i 146 5
Pushbuttcn Surface Since this is a minor technical discrepancy cnly, no action is demed necessary.
147 4
Trend Recorders Trend recorders are generally used for a@roximaticn whereas meters are used for accurate measurement. Therefore, no action is deemed necessary.
148 4
Trend Recorder Label There is no rom above the trend recorder for this label.
Also, the operators will use this recorder often and will
(
therefore rmember its functicn. No acticn is demed l
necessary.
149,
4 Graduaticn Marks As this finding represents a technical deviaticn to the guide-lines and a fix would cnly be a nicety, no action is deemed necessary.
150 4
Meter Scales As this finding represents a technical deviaticn to the guide-lines and a fix would cnly be a nicety, no acticn is cieemed l
necessary.
j 151 4
Trend Recorder Scale Trend recorders are generally used for a@roximaticn whereas meters are used for accIrate measurement. Iberefore, no l
acticn is demed necessary.
l t
l
~
v I
HLNAN ENGINEERING FI!OI!GS (HEF)
-Page 15 HEF Priority Subject Dispositica l
152 1
Annunciator Legends
%e annunciatcrs are currently under investigaticn and j
reevaluaticn.
153 1
Annunciator Legends he annunciatcrs are currently under inwstigation and reevaluaticn.
154 2
Labeling - Spacing of Characters Still under evaluation.
155 2
Height vs. 5th Percentile Operator he probability that all cperators in the Control Rocm will
- be less than 5 3" tall is negligibly snall. No acticn' is deemed necessary.
156 3
Scale cn Horizontal Meters (Site-specific to Callaway). Unresolved at this time.
l l
157' 3
Pushbuttcns
~ All pushbuttcns that require the cperator to hold the button until the valve or damper has ccupletely changed state or is used to jog the valve to a mid positicn will be changed to a l.
different color buttcn with contrasting lettering. This l
change will-be inplanented for all applicable motor cperated -
and air operated valves and dampers.
.158 2
Pushbuttons his switch (FC-HIS-332) is not required and will be deleted l
on the next revisicn of the MCB drawings.
l l
159 NA Withdrawn by Essex 160 NA-Withdrawn by Essex 161-NA Withdrawn by Essex 162
, NA Withdrawn by Essex l
l 163 NA Withdrawn by Essex l
164 NA Withdrawn by Essex F
165 NA Withdrawn by Essex I
l l
l
j HLNAN ENGINEERIfG FINDINGS (HEF)
Page 16
~.
HEF Priority '
Subject' Dispositim 166 4
Pushbuttcns and Simple Indicators he swit2 arrangment: for the feedwater heater isolation valves are different fa each heater train because the valving arrangements are different. Blind switches with separate indicating lights are used fa switches controlling w ltiple valms as on feedwater heaters 6 and 7 where all the scavenging cteam valves are controlled frm the extractim line isolation -
l valve control switch. Where the switch cnly controls the extraction line isolation valves, the valve indicaticn is l
integral to the switch. In all cases consistency is maintained for a given heater train. No actim is demed necessary.
l 167 3
J-Handles he Mimic label cn RID 15 will be revised to read "Frcm ESF i
.XFMR XNB01".
168 NA Withdrawn by Essex
'169 2
Pushbuttms his switch is not required and will be deleted cn the next revisicn of the 5tCB drawings.
170
'4 C-Handl.:s he cmtrol switch does not control the speed of the turning gear motor as indicated by the HEF.
Its functicn is to start and stop the motor. The fast and slow lights are pro--
vided fx operator informaticn. The switch operaticn is correct, therefa e, no action is deemed necessary.
171 NA Withdrawn by Essex 172 NA Withdrawn by Essex 173 2
Mimic Lines here is insufficient space to modify the mimic, therefwe, no action is deemed necessary.
'174 3
Arrangement of Process Con rollers (Site-specific to Callaway). Unresolved at this time.
175 NA Withdrawn by Essex 176 NA Withdrawn by Essex
HUMAN ENGINEERItU FINDINGS (HFE)
Page 17 HEF' Priority Subject Disposition 177 3
Pushbuttcns Unresol wd.
178 1
Mimics his HEF is beirg resolved by pending cnanges to RW17 and RID 18.
179 NA Withdrawn by Essex 180 NA Withdrawn by Essex 181 4
Trend Recorders his paper cmes with the recorder and therefore cannot be ordered differently. No acticn is deemed necessary.
182 3
Glass Cover for Trend Recorder his prcble is specific to construction and will be corrected at turnover. Wese panels are undergoing charges and review as a result of this finding.
183 1
RID 17 and RL018 Arrangements
'Ihese panels are undergoirs changes and review as a result of this finding.
184 1
RLD18 Panel Mimics Wese panels are undergoirg dianges and review as a result of this finding.
185 4
CRP Locaticns
'Ihe back panel CRP's have large screens (25") and are therefore visible. 'Ibe proble of glare is simulator-sg>.cific. No acticn is deemed necessary.
186 2
Location of Indicator Lights The purposes of the CCW Pump Reset lights will be 2ddressed through trainirg.
187 4
Labeling Control Switches CB-HIS-4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9 and 10 will be replaced with switch plates havirg "ALTIO" ergraved rather than stick-on labels.
1 188 NA Withdrawn by Essex 189 1
Vertical Indicators (psia vs. psig)
'Ihis HEF involves the ergineering units cn the indicators for contairment pressure provided by Westinghouse.
It has been requested that the irdicaticn be in PSIG. Confirmation j
frcm Westinghouse is beirq pursued.
l i
HUMAN DGINEERIEXi FINDINGS (HEF)
Page 18 HEF Priority '
Subject Divisitiari 190 1
Meter Labeling Meter labeling is ccnsistent at Callaway, therefore, this finding appears to be simulatcr-specific. No further action appears is demed necessary.
191 1
Mimics UE and KGE will meet to develop and submit mimic changes and correcticns.
192 3
Possible Glare frm Glass Covers Since this HEF represents a technical deviaticn to tne guide-lines, no actim is desed necessary.
193 4
Arrangment of Controls
'Ihe safety implicaticns are very low for the inadvertant operaticn of these surp pmps. No acticn is demed necessary.
194 4
Grouping of Trend Recorders Cmparing levels is more important than ccurbining levels and pressures, therefore, no acticn is deemed necessary.
195 4
Label Location Cn Trend Recorders Since this finding cnly represents a technical deviaticn to the guidelines, no action is deemed necessary.
196 4
Legend Light Arrangement
'Ihese indicatcrs cane as a package.
It is more important to recognize groups of colors rather than individual status.
No acticn is demed necessaty.
197 4
Cmputer Keyboard
'1he groupings and color codirgs are intenticnal and should therefore be allcwed to remain as is. No acticn is demed necessary.
198 NA Withdrawn by Essex 199 4
Ccanputer Keyboard As the finding is ccmsidered to be a technical discrepancy only, no acticn is deemed necessary.
200 3
Control of CRP Displays Training and administrative procedures will De used to prevent loss of display cn the BOP CRT's.
201 4
CRP Colors Unresolved.
RNAN ENGINEERI!C FIM)I!GS (HEF)
Page 19 HEF '
Priority Subject Disposition 202 4
CRP Colors mis finding was determined to be sinulator-specific and no further acticn is deemed necessary.
203 4
CRP Displays he CRP displays are limited tyf the sof* ware captility. As this finding is of a low priority, no acticn is deemed necessary.
2 1
204.
3 Ccuputer Systen Printer Alarm printer will be located in the Control Room.
205 4
Scale ca vertical Meters he meters in questicn are used infrequently and are not the sole indication. An alarm exists for the stean seal systen and the rest will alann indirectly. -21s, coupled with a low pricrity assignment warrants no acticm deemed i
to be necessary.
1 1
l
. Withdrawn
.l 206 NA
'l i
'l i
.--