ML20006F414
| ML20006F414 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | 07000025 |
| Issue date: | 02/19/1990 |
| From: | Lit E, Raskin J LIT, E., RASKIN, J.E. |
| To: | Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| References | |
| CON-#190-9918 89-594-01-ML, 89-594-1-ML, ML, NUDOCS 9002280007 | |
| Download: ML20006F414 (5) | |
Text
Q y,
}
[f/$-
j-
. DOCKETED l
2 /19/1995HRC BEFORE Tile
'90 FEB 20 P12 50 l
ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD
'E' O.S.
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSIO!1 (gfr!CE OF SECRETARY 90CKElitui A Sl avlCL
- i!RAN06i Yb In the Matter.of
)
Docket No. 70-25 ROCKWELL INTERNATIONAL
)
CORPORATION
)
ASLBP No.. 89-594-01-ML Rocketdyne Division
)
)
License No. SNM-21)
)
l
}
a 4
AMENDMENT TO INTERVEt10RS' EVIDENTIARY FIllHG
.[
~.
1-The following' constitutes an Amendment to Estelle Lit's and I
Prof essor Jerome E.
Raskin's Full Evidentiary Statement filed on
.I Pebruary 13, 1990.
This pleading wi11 serve as the legal suppott t-i L
and a request for. relief to our expressed concerns regarding
.l '
health and safety.
I Within.the February 13, 1990 Full Evidentiary Statement we i
expressed concern by stating the following:
(1)
Rocketdyne will l
jeopardize the health and saf ety of the surrounding communities if l.
-i.
they continue to use radioactive materia 3s; (2)
Rocketdyne uses j
outdated t esting procedures t o monitor possible contamination;'
l (3)
Rocketdyne uses misleading data supporting their conclusion-that the population'is not at rink; (4)
The ext,ent of i
radioactive contamination already documented, justifies non-j i
renewal of Rocketdyne's license; and (5)
Reports lowering the
. threshold exposure to carginogenous materials war rant non-renewal fI p
K 1
C 5
1 i
- 7., -
u ggppr 4 l>g.
,,,n,
, j(
r dp G li s ' of ;Rocketdyne's license.
(Full Evidentiary Statement, Lit and
}.
1; fi.
LRaskin, 2-13-90)
NRC regulations address these five, concerns.
l f:
1
- s.
,. pursuant to 10 CPR 70. 23(a )( 3 ) and (4), an application can be "7
approved if the Commission determines, among other things, that the ' applicant's proposed equipment, procedures and faci'.ities are i
" adequate to protect health and minimize danger to life or l
"~
i B
. property."
The NRC regulations further provide that:
i.
.a, l
- 1(
l No license will be i.ssued by the Commission to any i
-person within the United States if the Commisssion finds U
3 that the issuance of such license would be inimical to i
y p
~;;
the common defense and security or would constitute an unreasonable risk to the health and safety of'the j
(d: b public.
10 CPR 7 0.31(d).
.j-i l
The regulations also require Rocketdyne to "make every reasonable j
1 i
effort to maintain radiation exposures, and releases of radioactive materials in ef fluent s to unrestricted areas."
10 CPR s
1 20.1(c).
f.,
<Rocketdyne has violated these safeguards mandated by t he i
t.
l,,y l
' regulations..
As stated-in our third and fourth concerns,;
Rocketdyne's past failures to control radioactive contamination l'
r coupled with their problematic monitoring procedures indicate.
that Rocketdyne will not change its behavior, Additionally,10 CFR 70.9 requi res tha t Rocketdyne provide-1
,e complete and accurate.information to the Commission.
As stated 5
1 in our original complaint, Rocketdyne has not, supplied the
]
Commission with complete and accurate information.
l$
Therefore, intervenors, Estelle Lit and Jerome Raskin!
l lt
.l,
! g.
request ~ that Rocketdyne's renewal application be denied.
This in the l
t V'
' %p;7 only relief that can ensure safety in our community, especially
- ('
Y i
given'Rocketdyne's gross safety violations,.
j, El >
g
+
l j
i 6 hm 2
g
w an d,, N ; m n.; w~ a g~, y p~ e #
9 5
% %ghu f ; ym, ye em u, Ws
" n.
w m
+.
+
v et -
+ -....
s sm%a.m@%yMh *'
? -3' N t h-M M
,A mW9 yi
.y.-
g;
s 6
1 5,. s 4
- v? a,
'.}D l "
- i
~QM:.
- 1. - 3 9 -
.lDM
'm d ?'
-. -'w
')
' i^
9,
.w.:& p&.A s v,. m.;
y-W gr
- <4 7 y &..:p; 8
- rm G
m :; &y 'r..,y,34 u, -
y m
t.%;
J a.:
" ;- i D.-
a, 1;
- n. %.. 4p ipM. t..
v.
L g}dg@% ; n g m i n
,'Jy.t.djgghisi pleadin'gisupplemen ts ' the Full : Evi den t i a ry g,vifp : y
,jj9. 5~
- u -.4
).p p p.urg.,u,1
- K,...
n V, s
e
,. g 3
p -
.t -
n:
x q
my naa
-a, '
n;),-,'
_o t,
- j,'
,h, 9
='-
NE Q.aer p.g,.,3Ap$$@fih, d{on 'Fe,bruary(13p1990i. LWe Eswea r ; under '
M M.
. Mon 6 a WCM ddthatYthis[ Amendment and :the original Fu111EvidentiaryJ Statement"..n n
?
W.
% W" N_+.
4-p 8
d+$,.%. 7 m@m.RpfiledTFebruary 13H19.90f age 'true and correct 4 to ttho best r Li$
m..
4.
o L..
c o
x 4 9 % c. n -
^
~
J s t m x[knoN1e'dde~and dS11e.f.
.[c,7' S'S w
hMbh o
e e
L V
3 W
,: w 5
s.
,9,
s, s s
7,
, a v;, s w ^
u.
- - o J ',,
C..D.,. * "
A v
+q i?
i.
.(
p.
- y_1 a
O y
s
- il'
%) F l
f=. 'y-
.W-4
?
c 3,3Ejg
,.4 y.
s
- @2 y,,~;
y 4,
. [
).so s [ L" -
r
+
1 i
7 _t I.
{o
,d 9% hgs A Ij
-(
]#
r i
Jj W~F w) M m.%
o!?
e NMDN@@d@s&
4'.
., a o
MP M9' Dr. Estelle Lit dyyu p.
n.
s es-s, u fn. r1 o
t.y Sit:.I + i ' [}. -,, n. - 1
~/
y;t
' a f f, ' L p" ' -
@'q.y
' }?, '; f).
f>;
J UB-6 J
r
- 3 M,@p:M,; SW,.
?,1'. ~..,
a.
1-
,yc*
<, s,ic o.
i ~
.~s,.e
. 3.., h,.
j
~
mq q._#p@wn,
M h, <,t p alff { ^
' ol E e
y eu.;p q;s a,m y
i W-
,4 s
4 4" a
>.p_A
- q
> J. 9 NV Q:
Wv11aq ;R ghN dt
+
e mm _
.c li c
v.,
m.a
- d; c f.
l
. ') y
, p m,
.=l c.c
.r w c
i,
s s
m 3-
' W, ( [. I h 0hI (o mm kh p %,k/ [ n e,'
' b b (, '
IN 3
-W mh wwa m
. [.
- MM '
y.n
- s. C,M. A w.b M' m
'~
cgMr a1 a
, n a
Prof esso. Merome'. IC RasNin;-
. yt N
o
. e t m _ a g r.
'j b, - f 37 s taw "I b
y MM N[1%::, ! !Q -W ',
J v
t
~~
h:Qmp)y5 11 I
l 3 %.. H,
.b m.
i 5'
'..i.
y l yY
,r s,
4 :
hlY h IN '
dk, h I
-l hyl b5
' i' a
,4 a 4
= n"t c u a, g
- v...
w ; q,.
ar
-h 2
vv 4r.u m# +:
+,
r W,m n s
s s
2 M Ely J W dated?arDL6sLAngeles,; california' a; w >p 4
3%wAm b;k n wd w; g, a.
J ;, -.
e
,n,
^
sd a,
a w wn }p
,q '
~.,,;
y s
.n my
6
- ^
1 Yls
-)S; 2 =i i ^
,?&- l t '.f.- - {-d
.,J,,
s,.A, y
p t is day of t*p v,11990 z
@+ $
O w'k j d '.p g(i
-p i
3 3,.s v
t L \\({[f,
' y& {if-Q'i, f,
'b e
y e -
y,;
3
- f 'ii c;
- s e i
- [
I' A
g pg
'l.
dh (
i
.3
. -p[
C ij
[r4 '
-, 2
. -}M spl l
4 um q
4 s
%[1
. W i, x,,,wn.,
3
.p%
L O % as 1,
M.x, % v
.o m..
S tW 7,9 M@bMy ;. 3,g
,a 4;.y,
p.
- &s h y.
'p g
a a
fq nt
.~
'3
>Y
]t]i' 47N
- qe y m
r
,+ q 6,gn%m.y nM ;T w',+
,k h WW w
w(
o v,M.
m,4 Mmy%p _.ce v
4 ww -
j.m cwm 7 (.
s
- p i
4h y f. _ ",,..
m: My%;g -)g(c '
.v,
- p d
L x 4
1 t
du, 3
- 4
- m A.,,f:
- , Q n af
?
v h.p; mt 1
u 9 w
'b: w'U,e,v4 a-,-
.t c
v405+s 7-xp. ' Wa : y "
=
19:
ms
- a4 *p;...L.
- MW 4 1-Y< ' N ' '
t-
.i m
4 N !9 '
G'5
'i
" f T Y ^ #, Mn -
- p. ;
.v
-s v
j u
} ; i a:;
- 3. a m q:: <,
-],[3
.i
- s ry i
m
- [),
I -
1 h'f
- t. ~j o
p +he r-- v at
\\Y s;s 9.4;::y,.Je rf%.-
j._ z,.; ;
} u.
r 4 q la.y ' y:t V:u y'm a.m.:a 1 h i g, -
q, <
p pu :.n k
,.8
. st
,s a
s j>
5
- j. -
6 9
([,
~-
44-4 -,,
q:
,$ u
'O g t.N v, y; M,
>m:
- y
- 3
qm. s ;. ty wye.y y>
y mn. ;(
v:w
- n no ae a
N -l -
. 1. r-Y
~~v
- S -;;;w [- >
' hf
- [a
- 4 g %,[ [4(( b..-
,N
.h
- [% ;I a ;s. ~
s:.>
g w,
b. y N
. kikkb k k, sMd N <
- s 4
? M' W @P T Q @, N "T f, h ng*c,m 1Jessi==""* 'T fV i;' U k
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA M{j[a/ J G, ' y, ')
i NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION POMQ
[
' L i
jf, U5NHC j l An'the Matter of I
{
t 10 iFEB 20 P12:50 l' -i aCCKWELL INTERNAfl0NAL CORPORATION I
Docket No.(s) 70-25-ML 7
i i
1l :
3
'].;otocketdyneOlvision,Special fUC I
I NG
~
i
'lE,
,'] Nuclear, Materials License SNM-21)
I fiRANCH
~
q,;,
- i 1
,a,
2 4
.$h.
. i q
(
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I
1 (i I g.
)J W ;' i p
- 9; i
j jh.
i/p7
,[h'ereby certif y that copies of the f oregoing MEMO MCDOW FOR JULI AN DTD t/25,
h
,l
~
}
.i n
- have!been served upon the following persons by U.S. sail, first class, except' g;[i t
i las' otherwise' noted and in accordance with the requirements of 10 CFR Sec. 2.712' 1.I is
'j#{
x; -
c:
{!;)
C l
Administrative Judge Administrative Judge C'
Christine N.' Kohl, Chatraan G. Paul Bo!!werk, !!!
I
[ l. l Atomic. Saf ety' and Licensing Appeal Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal
,lp<
.;6 card Board
,. p'((',.'
.b.S.-. huclear Regul atory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Coseission j'j
,,:,['
{.
Washington, DC 20555 '
' i qshington,DC 20555 4
l t
y i
l administrative Judge Administrative Judge
. j t
- Howard A. Wilber Peter B. Bloch s
e p i
- tomic Saf ety and Licensing Appeal Presiding Officer i
Board
~
Atom'ic Safety and Licensing Board
' l l
'U.'S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Consission Washington, DC 20555 Washington, DC 20555
_ l
.tiustave A.-Linenberger, Jr.
[ i Administrative Judge j
,;L 4
l Special Assistant Office of the General Counsel t'
t Atoalc' Safety and Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory. Commission l.:
LU.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 hashington, DC ~20555
.il
. -j.
s Iee
- 1.,
l N'
?-
Cirector K D. b I d# g
{
Daniel Hirsch
( "l..
Rockwell International Corporation President
. jj t '
+
Rocketdyne Division Committee to Bridge the Gap 6633 Canoga Avenue 1637 Butler Avenue, Suite 203
~
Canoga Park CA' 91304 Los Angeles, CA 90025 I
l i
s,.
I'
..t-
.,.lo n -
Scott Estelle Lit l,1 i
Oh l J
- C Roundup Road 19233 Bermuda Street 1
i 1
Hell: Canyon,,CA 91307, Northridge, CA 91326 j
,O l ; { d.. ^
L '
a a
e r
1
--}'k l'i-n i
p i
I ;,;r k pl bi
'f f
IE, i
l N'
W>
h i *ym
\\
%/
r-lm.
4
- u s m
' l..
BWW "w
,#,. q em w-u,
m ht h hi t
.h A
Ja M ".q p c O sete(".No.Isl70 25=NL idh 1-id. in
~
e m @n ev;En0lnC00W FOR 'JULIAN LTD 1/23
)
r c
au o l9 :l t
4 my uQ y:
y, g..
ia,,
+
y
&. &.." y G.; a y
+
v
\\ \\
a.
o
- y
.y'
. uA; yh s% r ' vi 4
i i
Jero,se'E..Aaskins, et.' al.
Donald W. Wallace ts t'
1 v iip u'
clo 19350 Los~Allaos 4
1710 North Cold Canyon Road i.
y g.1 l:
Northridge,CAj91326 Calabasas, CA 91302 i
o.i' y;
s e
db
\\,l-T A
Sheldon C. Plotkin, Ph.D. P. E.
j nC L-
,. Mary-
- Nichols, Esquire Executive Board Representative
' L, i
Counsel'for Natural Resources Southern California Federation of
'}i-y;" -
Li-'
_ !0efense Council Scientists
,lhln,N=1330iNewYorkAvenue,NW 3318 Colbert Avenue
. li
[k.. fi
- W,l Washington, DC !20005-Los Angeles, CA 90066
. i u n q.
u 3
3
!~
g. g., "
e 1;.
b i
3 ;
, Barbara.. Johnson
'Prestdonti lo Susana ' Knolls Homeowners Association 1
l'
.cle16714 Clear Springs Roso L
Susana Knolls, CA 93063
,p'
. t s ;;
- s i
,+
Q, i 6
.34
.i
)
~
?:
.l-O L.('l::;
..s l
p~,
3
\\-
ut 4 ih. s
' ? :) a',
,' n I
3>
i
+
- !v.
1 t
^'.
.' n s
q;':
.r,
.x
)t 3
Wl ;)
- 4 4r [;
i 1
t
.I.
Richard Saxon, M.D i
O p} j'V:f},,
t President
- P (n, gng,g,, Physicians for Social j
W q
f p
Responsibility 1
q _
D,j V 3 1431 Ocean Avenue, Sulto 8
- 's L
T
,,3 ny h.
Santa Monica,i CA 90401
- l,
+
a, y
't
,t..=
v 1
q@ n;h l' Cecella! ~
Riddle 1
4
- E. Senior)Librerian' u
s N,, %Chatsworth Branch Library
,i t i,:
21032 Devanshire! Street
- l
( g
'J p
y,Chatswerth, CA 91311-
,,4, 7
'Dr.
Estelle Lit f
i N
i k tdiat:" ora rio o, c..credroary 13, 2990
. [ # dOeO%
s ca2"-
erono E.
Raskin wa
{
a.
- {.ky t ( (
)
9 w
9'jp:
a -df }. i g g,, ; h g'<;p'i
[.
g
,gs
-%p'g-a s;
c tr 4
s i
'
- g:[s[]3[fl r-p t
Ih)/
'/
t t.
o c
- I f'
%p, tit ^ i;bQM r
(s3 p y
- fb, f[,,
yyy.. K G M, ?
1
^
?*
't fM tt J
]J y:;p F, Ma y _,.._
t f j Ws t,)
4IV < 'S s;
M; 1
.L i
q.
a W
-;n
.;f y r
, s. d N. >
,t,-,.^
s -
I f > < tjfh;
..