ML20002D280

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Forwards Rept of ECCS outages,1976-80,per NUREG-0737,Item II.K.3.17.ECCS Outage Frequency Does Not Constitute Excessive Unavailability.No Tech Spec Changes Are Warranted
ML20002D280
Person / Time
Site: Prairie Island  Xcel Energy icon.png
Issue date: 01/16/1981
From: Mayer L
NORTHERN STATES POWER CO.
To:
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
RTR-NUREG-0737, RTR-NUREG-737, TASK-2.K.3.17, TASK-TM TAC-12428, TAC-12429, NUDOCS 8101200241
Download: ML20002D280 (2)


Text

t

'^

NORTHERN STATES POWER COMPANY 1

usussanous.wissueQTA 55401 January 16, 1981 Director of Nuclear Reactor Regulation US Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 PRAIRIE ISLAND NUCLEAR GENERATING PLANT Docket Nos. 50-282 License No. DPR-22 50-306 DPR-60 NUREG-0737 Item II.K.3.17, Report on Outages of Emergency Core-Cooling Systems NUREG-0737, " Clarification of TMI Action Plan Requirements," issued by the NRC Staff on October 31, 1980 contains the requirement (Item II.K.3.17) to submit a report detailing outage dates and length of outages for all emergency core-cooling (ECC) systems for the last five years of operation.

The purpose of the report is to provide the Staf f with data on unreliability due to test and maintenance outages which will be used to determine if cumulative outage requirements are needed in the Technical Specifications.

Attached is the tabulation of outage information for the Prairie Island Nuclear Generating Plant. The data represents all outages of ECC systems from January 1,1976 through December 31, 1980 except during refueling.

The Prairie Island ECC systems include the high-head safety injection system, the low head safety injection system, and the accumulators.

We believe the outage times reported on the attached table do not constitute excessive unavailability. There is no case where accumulation of short permissible outages resulted in unacceptable overall system availability.

No Technical Specification changes are warranted.

Please contact us if you have any questions concerning the information we have provided.

L 0 Mayer, PE Manager of Nuclear Support Services cc: J G Keppler G Charnoff NRC Resident Inspector I

At tachment i

I 8101200 N

e d

a Director of NRR, USNRC January 16, 1981 At tachment Prairie Island Units 1 and 2 Report of Outage of ECC Systems From January 1,1976 to December 31, 1980 Outage Re ference Date Duration Cause and System (Work Reg) 12-19-80 L hr 44 min Modify W-2 Control Switch (RH)

D6980 12-15-80 3 hrs.58 min Modify W-2 control Switch (SI)

D6946 12-12-80 4 hrs 59 min Modify W-2-Control Switch (RH)

D6981 11-5-80 19 hrs 5 min Preventative Maintenance, RHR Pump (RH)

Note 1 11-3-80 19 hrs 28 min Preventative Maintenance, RHR Pump (RH)

Note 1 9-13-80 1 hr 30 min Maintenance on Motor Valve (RH)

D5423 9-10-80 15 hrs (EST)

Preventative Maintenance, RHR Pump (RH)

Note 1 9-11-80 15 hrs (EST)

Preventative Maintenance, RHR Pump (RH)

Note 1 8-5-80 8 hrs 38 min Gasket Leak Repair (RH)

D3366 8-4-80 8 hrs Gasket Leak Repair (RH)

D1697 7-29-80 21 hrs 5 min Gasket Leak Repair (RH)

D3055 3-31-80 13 hrs 45 min Preventative Maintenance, RHR Pump (RH)

P3124-1 1-8-80 15 hrs (EST)

Preventative Maintenance, RRR Pump (RH)

Note 1 12-10-79 7 hrs 30 min Radiograph Inspection, RHR Pump (RH)

C6655 10-1-79 11 hrs 20 min Gasket Leak (RH)

C4853 9-26-79 11 hrs 55 m n Preventative Maintenance, RHR Pump (RH)

P3124-1 i

9-25-79 15 hrs 5 mir.

Preventative Maintenance, RHR Pump (RH)

P3124-1 4-18-79 18 hrs Gasket Leak (RH)

A7836 1-31-79 13 hr 56 min Preventative Maintenance, RHR Pump (RH)

P3124-1 1-30-79 6 hrs 40 min Preventative Maintenance, RHR Pump (RH)

P3124-1 8-29-78 7 hrs 15 min Preventative Maintenance, RHR Pump (RH)

P3124-1 8-28-78 14 hrs 50 min Preventative Maintenance, RHR Pump (RH)

P3124-1 2-23-77 7 hrs 46 min Gasket Leakage (RH)

A0871 1-29-77 12 hrs 35 min Gasket Leakage (RH)

A0463 7-30-79 3 hrs 22 min Modification (SI)

C4186 & A4187 11-28-77 22 min Testing to Determine Leakage (SI)

A7186 11-1-77 3 hrs Testing to Determine Leakage (SI)

A7135 10-20-77 20 hrs Testing to Determine Leakage (SI)

A6880 6-18'-77 4 hrs 57 min Replace Leaking Safety Valve (SI)

A4223 6-8-77 3 hrs 30 min Testing for Possible Pump Damage (SI)

A3790 6-8-77 8 hrs Testing for Possible Pump Damage (SI)

A3564 10-6-76 7 hrs 46 min 21 RH Loop Leakage Check (RH) 3128 9-16-76 7 hrs 19 min 22 RH Loop Leakage Check (RH) 3099 Notes:

1.

Record of Outage date and duration based upon PM schedule 2.

This tabulation does not include work done on ECCS components during refueling outages 3.

RH - RHR (Low Mead Safety Injection)

SI - Safety Injection (High Head) and accumulators I

i i

l