ML19209C006
| ML19209C006 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | North Anna  |
| Issue date: | 08/21/1979 |
| From: | Jay Dougherty CITIZENS ENERGY FORUM |
| To: | |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 7910110387 | |
| Download: ML19209C006 (5) | |
Text
r@ # "
UNITED dTATES OF AMERICA
/
N NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION O
w AUG 241979 > d BEFORE THE
.w
' ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING APPEAL BOARD g
'#d 4e j,
,C In the Matter of
)
)
Docket Nos. 50-338 SP VIRGINIA ELECTRIC AND POWER CO.
)
50-339 SP
)
(North Anna Power Station
)
Proposed Amendment to Units 1 and 2)
)
Operating License NPF-4 INTERVENORS' STATEMENT OF EXCEPTIONS The Potomac Alliance, on behalf of itself and Citizens Energy Forum, Inc. ("Intervenors"), takes exception to two rulings of the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board ("the Board")
embodied in a document entitled " Board Decisions" and dated August 6, 1979.
In that document the Board determined,, inter alia, to grant n motion for summary disposition submittecl by the Virginia Electric and Power Co. ("VEPCO") on May ll, 1979, and to deny a motion to amend its petition to
.ervene sub-mitted by Intervenors on June 15, 1979.
With respect to these two rulings:
- 1. The Board erred in granting VEPCO's motion for summary disposition in that the schedule extablished for the proceeding was so unduly abbreviated that Intervenors were rendered unable to conduct adequate discovery or otherwise present an adequate defense' to VEPCO's motion.
1130 051 2910110387
I
..2. The Board erred in granting VEPCO's motion because there t
existed genuine issues of fact material to each of the contentions in controversy.
- 3. Even if there were no genuine issues of material fact, The Board erred in granting VEPCO's motion because VEPCO was not entitled to judgement in its favor as a matter of law.
- 4. The Board erred in denying Intervenors' motion to amend its petition for leave to intervene as a matter of Iw.
Intervenors acknowledge that the foregoing list of exceptions is brief and somewhat vague.
This is due to the fact that the Order of August 6 conveyed the Board's determination cursorily and without explanation or justification, making ! t impossible for Intervenors to specify the nature of their,exceptio:ns thereto.
?. tile under 10 CFR 552.762 and
- 2. 788 appeals and requests for stays must generally be filed within 10 days of the challenged ruling, 15 days have now passed without a shred of elaboration by the Board.
Thus faced with the imminent loss of procedural rights, Intervenors submit this statement of exceptions. and concurrently request that they be permitted to revise the stated exceptions in light of future pronouncements by the Board in this connection, and that time limitations relating to the filing of a brief in support of exceptions and the filing of a request for a stay of the Board's order under 10 CFR S2.708 be reestablished to relate back to the date on which the Board provides sufficient guidance as to the basis of its August 6 order to enable Intervenors to present a sub-stantive response thereto.
a-n k
Respectfully submitted, A
%%R A3 J a r.u M!i B. Doug $ ty y
307 Eleventh St.,
NE Dated: August 21, 1979 Washington, D.C.
20002 (202) 452-9600 (202) 547-5244 Counsel for Intervenors 1JU U)
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby affirm that copies of the foregoing INTERVENORS' STATEMENT OF EXCEPTIONS were served this 21 day of August, 1979, by deposit in United States Mail, First Class, upon the following:
Valentine B.
Deale, Esq.,
Michael W. Maupin, Esq..
Chairman, Atomic Safety Hunton & Williams and Licensing Board P.O. Box 1535 1001 Connecticut Ave., NW Richmond, VA 23212 Washington, DC 20036 Steven C. Goldberg, Esq.
Mr. Ernest Hill Of fice of the Executive Lawrence Livermore Laboratory Legal Director University of California U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission P.O.
Box 800, L-123 Washington, DC 20555 Livermore, CA 94550 Alan S.
Rosenthal, Esq.
Dr. Quentin J.
Stober Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Fisheries Research Institute U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission University of Washington Washington, D.C.
20555 Seattle, WA 98195 Dr. John H.
Buck Secretary Atomic Safety And Licensing Appeal U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 Washington, D.C.
20555 ATTN: Chief, Docketing and Serice Section Dr. Lawrence R. Quarles Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Atomic Safety and Licensing U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Appedl Board Washington, D.C.
20555 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comm'n Washington, D.C.
20555 3
Jdads B. DoughVrty V
g<tl 19e ep Counsel for Intervenors Y
ll sS* $
5 ge5f' lla_J 054 w
=
~_
.m jQ;fD-y-....m.L.
u M9
. ;9;7
~~
- p d.. a t.
,.; t 9'4,,4,yes.. y
.. e n>:
p y s 9-memammasas 4
{:t
?. i 1.
} C'..
.,;, j '. ~ 0.j.
4[
"J' g_,w,memy
,, y w,,
maammmmmm eur
. v,.
[e[,. Q' h.... '>. p l Jpo.,g,.o g?am,museamanumassen - --
I m
E $
1_
==*ra ' -
f..
g "o
,s.
r y
20 a
o y
"p"a*y**, a*'aus 2
w,i.
r, i
7
,,,,,,,,,,,3 g y;,
.g-9
.,. s.
'd 4)h,@ %p;,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
j..nt
" ra j; g,,.,
gatcu---
,y mamaerr
[' i m..
....o..w q a..
~.*.,a Cin->
a
. u f T" V > %
z,,. I,';c 4y;g,.t 1;2:hp j%
3,5
<4>!
rw\\.. u.
.r 9*
Y' a missarsy M us;sens w p u# 4 M :
ty.
. a.,. m a v o u,y
,,.~
3'/
r A"tw" ""
, ? ',
IF W<
. P S.3
'?-
W
- lI,1:
i 3
M
't i
- f 7.jc hh j.I
.p 3 l g '..' W,h jl.d r
..: m I(g. lh#I r fangpp v
.k y'
., l :<f..
.n ht. h'.,,.
..i, t ':e..,
.:s,; h,'s
'. e$.',..
u uy i
a.3-a,,
ls,,.
.Q &'
,3
't 4'r ;4. g '?.
. n4
- a.. - - ;u. -
ti,
- ; 4,:\\.. c,dp f, s,t1
~
i p! -
o b1 -
bl ^ ; 0.d. ?.
p.'f !'-
,i... ;. '
'i*
i 'Q f'T. N>
- s, s t 4
'~
,s f) l a..
ca
.e. 9,,s.,W.. T '[
4 jb h, ' 8 4 ti (if p..@,dT'."[yt...,f,.e.,.
fl
. rv n
rn j'j"j..a;r.go<d, f,pf b;.pl ;. ~ >(. ! $.s.-
.f, ;, g
'i 2'
4 e.,'.2
- p. y, y -
~
npg;. :j.'
41 I
secretary
' r.
~
u.s. nuclear Regulatory comm'r
! W fl f Y '.p.& w, (:k...l.)!
j washington, D.c. 20555
{
[
.h,d.jddff'h'n - l.3h;jg,.- ]i4 M #
)
y.
l ATTN: Chicf, Docketing and I
L a6 service section
{
fiV N d 4 $ C
' y M[!jjf d.
M*
l
'd
@L,N~.U},&;?j(. W,@o ;, - )?M
'0R0lWk WV.
f.w.fUMM.i
,;g.
l y
.-1 k.$&.r.I,TTl.M
(
V n. &..ff.,
< a t.5
..a.. -
s
,u n,
-..:. a e.b.
@W.*$em. A' >.,,f '
s*
4 4.
j'. ~.4 ;
.,g.
m {j..
t
'k - '
$ g.. '1.
.i & =
f G,.f y.6,q;};
p.. l
- l'...r
(; 'sv.
.w.
v:
- l. ) p ;. c...
.?
mq. s* +tu.Jc,j',
t
,.?
i
-y
'n}j_t' - f ;. c '
.,i k;
t r*
D 9
N l
e
>r i