ML17209B086
| ML17209B086 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Saint Lucie  |
| Issue date: | 05/15/1981 |
| From: | Nerses V Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8105220047 | |
| Download: ML17209B086 (12) | |
Text
~ ~ 2 MAY
{ 6 3981
-Docket=No.:50=389 APPLICANT:
Florida Power and Light Company (FPIL)
FACILITY:
Saint Lucie Plant, Unit 2 (S.L.2) eggy~-
WieW~r~
H
SUBJECT:
SUMMARY
OF MEETING HELD WITH FP&L ON MAY 5, 1981
-~r<i The staff discussed the transmitted draft fire protection questions to assure FP&L understood the information needed by the staff to complete their review.
Discussions were held regarding the staff position and the FP&L position on fire protection.
The staff acknowledges that there are differences between the two positions and these differences may not be readily resolvable for the staff to complete their review on time.
The staff noted the following areas that could impact the time to complete their review.
1.
Fire Mater S stem - FP&L relies on Unit 1 fire water systems.
- Thus, the review of the Unit 2 fire water system cannot be completed until the Unit 1 open items relative to Appendix R are resolved.
2.
~Fi 2
-Fdttd ti t dt
\\
t11 yi't d
2 t tt sy"stems required for nuclear safety.
This is not only a departure from our guidelines, but, also, a departure from the engineering philosophy expressed in the national fire codes.
3.
Fire Retardant Coatin
- FP&L relies on the effect of using the flame retardant cab e coat ng in combination with administrative control.
Therefore, FP&L assumes that fires.qi11 not propogate along flame retardant coated cables.
The staff does not agree with this assumption.
4.
A endix R - During this meeting, the staff stated that S.L.2 would be rev ewe against Appendix R and BTP 9.5-1.
The applicant is a member of a utility group which has filed a motion for partial stay pending judical review of Sections III.G, III.L, and III.) of Appendix R.
8105280 04 V
4i 9
O'
~9
~
PEP PQ
-II 'IUi ll
~ 9
~ P II 4 ~
~
9 ~ 4 P
~
4
~-
9 ~
S t
I.
14 P-9 J'~
~
4 9 P 9
~
9
,I
~ I'
~
9
~
9 99 44 (tj]
I IEN I", ~,.
I i ~
9 P
9 4
9 $
~ I
~ PPPI I
I 9
4 E
9 9
9
~
9 I
~"
9 It
In summary, until the above four items are resolved, the staff's review of the FSAR cannot be completed.
In addition, a site visit would not be productive until the above open items are resolved.
It was recommended that a near-future meeting be held between FP8L and the NRR management to discuss these differences.
The Division of Licensing will arrange a meeting date and agenda.
cc:
See next page.
Victor Nerses, Project Manager Licensing Branch No. 3 Division of Licensing OFFICE/
SURNAME)
DATEP NRC FORM 3IS (IOIBOINRCM 0240 DL:LB¹3 E
B I~.
VNtttIqsgjjb,.
I Sn
..5/Jd/.8.1.........5/A/81.....
DLi B¹
/
. g3.7a.
I t5/.
OFFICIAL RE ORD COPY=
9 USGFD: 198~29.824
V
~
~
l
. ~
~ '
a
~ t
<<0 d
~,
I 4
MEETING SlffiMARY I)(STRI BUT IA'l Dockei. File f'(C I'DI<
Local I'DR NSIC TERA LD/i 3 Reading II. Denton E.
Case D. Eisenhut P..
Purple B. J.
Youngblood A. Schwencer F. tIiraglia J. Miller G. Lainas R. Vollmer J.
P. Knight R.
Bosnak F. Schauer R.
E. Jackson Project I'Ianager
- Attorney, OELD J.'ee oiF (3)
ACRS (16)
R.
Tedesco NRC Parti ci pants:
G, gqf.risen S.
Hudson V. Nerses 0.
Chopra V. Nerses G. Lel I S.
V Z.
I.l D.
R.
I!.
R.
P.
Pa.; 1 i ck i lfena I oya Rusztoczy I(aas s I',;Il 1 er Bal 1 a rd Regan Mattson Check
- 0. Pa!r F.
Rosa I. Butler 4'. Kreger R. Il0(lston T. Ilurphy L. Rubenstein T. Speis I. Johnston J. Stolz S. )Ianauer Ii. faIImill T. tlurley I.
S(.llrue(lcl'.
SknvlI(Ilt fl Er(Is I, R. Baer C.
lfeI linger K. KIllel (i.
K!ll(JIII.on A. Thadani D. Ton(li J.
Kramer D. Vassallo P. Collins D. Ziemann E.
Adensam bcc:
Applican t S Servi ce Lis t
gpss RECT (4
+4 0
0>
IC O
+~
~O
++**+
UNITEDSTATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION WASHINGTON, D. C. 20555 MAY > > t981 Docket No.:
50-389 APPLICANT:
Florida Power and Light Company (FP&L)
FACILITY:
Saint Lucie Plant, Unit 2 (S.L.2)
SUBJECT:
SUMMARY
OF MEETING HELD WITH FP&L ON MAY 5, 1981 The staff discussed the transmitted draft fire protection questions to assure FP&L understood the information needed by the staff to complete their review.
Discussions were held regarding the staff position and the FP&L position on fire protection.
The staff acknowledges that there are differences between the two positions and these differences may not be readily resolvable for the staff to complete their review on time.
The staff noted the following areas that could impact the time to complete their review.
1.
Fire Water S stem - FP&L relies on Unit 1 fire water systems.
- Thus, the review of the Unit 2 fire water system cannot be completed until the Unit 1 open items relative to Appendix R are resolved.
- 2. ~i-FPELd ti d
i t11 yfi d
p systems required for nuclear safety.
This is not only-a departure from
'ur guidelines, but, also, a departure from the engineering philosophy expressed in the national fire codes.
3.
Fire Retardant Coatin
- FP&L relies on the effect of using the flame retardant cable coating in combination with administrative control.
Therefore, FP&L assumes that fires will not propogate along flame retardant coated cables.
The staff does not agree with this assumption.
4.
A endix R - During this meeting, the staff stated that S.L.2 would be
. revsewe against Appendix R and BTP 9.5-1.
The applicant is a member of a utility group which has filed a motion for partial stay pending judical review of Sections III.G, III.L, and III.) of Appendix R.
MAY ~ 5 1981 In summary, until the above four items are resolved, the staff's review of the FSAR cannot be completed.
In addition, a site visit would not be productive until the above open items are resolved.
It was recommended that a near-future meeting be held between FP8L and the NRR management to discuss these differences.
The Division of Licensing will arrange a meeting date and agenda.
cc:
See next page.
Enclosure:
Meeting Attendees Victor Nerses, Project Manager Licensing Branch No.
3 Division of Licensing
, Or. Robert E. Uhrig, Vic~." ~sident Advanced Systems and Teciinulogy Florida Power 5 Light Company P. 0.
Box 529100 Miami, Florida 33152 ccs:
Harold F. Reis, Esq.
Lowenstein, Newman, Reis, Axelrad 5 Toll 1025 Connecticut Avenue, N.
W.
Washington, D. C.
20036 Norman A. Coll, Esq.
McCarthy, Steel, Hectory 5 Davis 14th Floor, First National Hank'uilding Miami, Florida 33131 Mr. Martin H. Hodder 1131 N.
E. 86th Street Miami, Florida 33138 Resident Inspector St. Lucie Nuclear Power Station c/o U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission
. 7900 South AlA Jensen Beach, Florida 33457
,F
ATTENDEES MEETING FPKL 5 NRE 5/5/81 - FIRE PROTECTION V. Nerses Greg Harrison Scott Hudson Leo Cook Mike Horrell Enoch Ziectiman S. T. Haig M. A. Jalil T. C. Qrozan John E. Sheetz Charles L. Fisher Erroll W. Dotson Om Chopra ORGANIZATION NRR/DOL/LB¹3 NRR/CMEB NRR/CMEB EBASCO-Fire Protection EBASCO-Licensing EBASCO-Project Engineer FP8L - Lead Mech., St. Lucie ¹1 EBASCO-Fire Protection FP8L-Nuclear Licensing FP8L=;Plant Technical Licensing FPSL-Lead Mechanical FP8L-Engr. Proj. Manager NRC-PSB-DS I
c4 o:1 II
$ ~
v S
C P
I e
t V
" sc 1
k r
~
c