ML20005E393
| ML20005E393 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Comanche Peak  |
| Issue date: | 12/28/1989 |
| From: | William Cahill TEXAS UTILITIES ELECTRIC CO. (TU ELECTRIC) |
| To: | NRC OFFICE OF INFORMATION RESOURCES MANAGEMENT (IRM) |
| References | |
| GL-86-14, TXX-89858, NUDOCS 9001050167 | |
| Download: ML20005E393 (13) | |
Text
_ _ - _
f) fI A
MEN Log # TXX-89858 n
O.
File # 10305, 913.1-O C
10035 (GL 86-14) ggg[gg7g/C Ref. # 10CFR2.102(a)
December 28, 1989 William J. Caldil, Jr.
Executive We Pres. tent U. S.' Nuclear Regulatory Commission Attn: Document Control Desk Washington, D. C.
20555 l
SUBJECT:
COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION (CPSES)
DOCKET N05. 50 445 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ' ADDITIONAL INFORMATION RELATED T0 PLANT STAFF EXPERIENCE Gentlemen:
The-.TU Electric response to the request for information are provided in the following attachments.- is a more detailed version of the information sent to the NRC, logged TXX 89753, dated October 26, 1989.
It includes the amount of time above 20% full power and the average power levels for those individuals obtaining-six months hot operating experience.
-! addresses the individuals required to have six weeks hot operating experience above 20% full power requested in paragraph two, item j
(1) of the request.
H addresses the requested startup and shutdown experience of paragraph two, item (2) of the request for all crew supervision,
Attachment 4 is presented to consolidate the hot operating and startup and shutdown experience for each specific operating crew in a functional format.
It relates the total crew experience level, i provides the supporting and explanatory information necessary in using the various attachments.
Section (A) presents the information on two SR0s that the reviewer requested. This information is necessary to support the credit taken for their previous license at other plants.
Y f
9001050.167 891228 i
PDR ADOCK 05000445 A
PNV l
400 North Olive Street LB. 81 Dallas, Texas 75201
s.
n..
l' TXX-89858 L
December 28, 1989 Page'2 of 2 h
Based on TU Electric's evaluation of the enclosed data, the experience n
. requirements endorsed in Generic Letter 86 14 have been met.
Should you need-rnre information, please contact Mr. Greg Bell at (214) 812-4373.
Sincerely.
Wil J.-Cahill, Jr.
B..~
8'. S. Marshall
' Generic Licensing Manager GLB/vid:
Attachments (5) i c - Ms. Melinda Malloy (NRR 0SP)
Mr. R. D. Martin, Region IV Resident Inspectors. CPSES (3) l
p'5:
- Attachment 1 to TXX-89858-
=a Pago 1 of-2
~ CPSES SUPERVISORS OBTAINING SIX MONTHS HOT OPERATING EXPERIENCE -.
NAME TIME PERIOD PLANT
(>20%)
AVG. POWER DAYS j
DASKAM, THOMAS J. 03-15-85 TO 04-12-85 SALEM 15 100%
SHIFT SUPERVISOR 04-29-85 TO 11-21-85 DIABLO CANYON 93 92%
l (CREW 16) 07-06-88 TO 07-15-88 RANCHO SECO 8
60%
10-09-89 TO 10-14-89 DIABLO CANYON 5
100%
l TOTAL 121 DEEN, MICHAEL D. 01-01-82 TO 01-15-82 D. C. COOK 4
100%
SHIFT SUPERVISOR 03-16-84 TO 04-13-84 TROJAN 15 100%
(WORK CONTROL) 03-25-85 TO 04-11-85 NORTH ANNA' 15 100%
07-30-85 TO 08-02-85 PRAIRIE ISLAND 4
95%
04-23-86 TO 05-08-86 PRAIRIE ISLAND 12 100%
06-02-86 TO 09-12-86 PRAIRIE ISLAND 68 100%
04-06-87 TO 04-09-87 PRAIRIE' ISLAND 3
88%
TOTAL 121 I
NOTE:
MR. DEEN 2S PRESENTLY ASSIGNED TO OTHER DUTIES TO SUPPORT PLANT STARTUP,BUT WILL BE UTILIZED AS NEEDED FOR LICENSED OPERATOR ACTIVITIES.
HARVEY, SCOTTY E. 06-04-84 TO 06-15-84 BEAVER VALLEY 0
SHIFT SUPERVISOR 03-04-85 TO 03-15-85 MCGUIRE 8
75%
(CREW 14) 03-10-86 TO 03-28-86 DIA3LO CANYON 14 100%
04-21-86 TO 05-09-86 SALEM 12 100%
05-28-86 TO 11-21-86 ST. LUCIE 79 100%
05-27-87 TO 06-12-87 CATAWBA 13 100%
08-25-87 TO 09-05-87 MCGUIRE 7
100%
TOTAL 133 APPLE, K. C.
07-22-85 TO 07-26-85 DIABLO CANYON 3
100%
UNIT SUPERVISOR 01-06-86 TO 11-21-86 BYRON 109 90%
(CREW 11) 06-01-87 TO 06-15-87 DIABLO CANYON 20 100%
TOTAL 132 BROUGHTON, T. W. 03-04-85 TO 03-22-85 MCGUIRE 14 60%
UNIT SUPERVISOR 04-12-85 TO 05-03-85 SAN ONOFRE 13 93%
(CREW 13) 04-21-86 TO 11-21-86 ST. LUCIE 96 90%
TOTAL 123 BRYAN.
G. C.
11-04-85 TO 11-15-85 CALLOWAY 7
60%
UNIT SUPERVISOR 07-29-86 TO 09-12-86 SAN ONOFRE 15 60%
(CREW 12) 11-04-86 TO 08-28-87 ARK. NUCLEAR 1 111 80%
TOTAL 133
- BURNETT, S.
P.
06-05-84 TO 07-02-84 SURRY 30 90%
UNIT SUPERVISOR 02-27-89 TO 03-10-89 BYRON O
5%
(CREW 15) 08-84 TO 06-86 WOLF CREEK 130
>20%
TOTAL 160 1
NOTE: MR. BURNETT WAS PREVIOUSLY LICENSED (SRO) AT WOLF CREEK.
HE IS CREDITED WITH 130 DAYS ABOVE 20% POWER DURING THIS PERIOD.
.f'-
- Attcchm:nt-11to TXX-89858' l
(f
.Pago'2 of 2
.)
p <<
CPSE5 SUPERVISORS OBTAINING SIX MONTHS HOT OPERATING EXPERIENCE NAME TIME PERIOD PLANT.
(>204)
AVC. POWER DAYS ECCEMEYER.
N.
C.
12-02 85 TO 12 13 85 CATAWBA 8
73%
UNIT SUPERVISOR 08 10 87 TO 08 29 87 DIABLO CANYON 13 1004 (CREW 16) 07 05 88 TO 07-15 88 ARK.
NUCLEAR 1 5
85%
01 23 89 TO 02-01-89 ST.
LUCIE 6
75%
03 83 TO 03-84 ARK.
NUCLEAR 1 130
>20%
TOTAL 162 NOTE:
MR. ECGEMEYER WAS PREVIOUSLY LICENSED (RO) AT ARKANSAS NUCLEAR ONE.
HE IS CREDITED WITH 130 DAYS ABOVE 20% POWER DURINC'THIS PERIOD.
e e
e
[
~
Attachm:nt'2 to TXX-89858-
,Page 11of 2 y
e 1
CPSES SUPERVISORS OBTAINING: SIX WEEKS HOT PARTICIPATION EXPERIENCE NAME TIME PERIOD PLANT
(>20%)_
AVG. POWER
-i DAYS j
MARSH, TERRY L.
03-25-85 TO 04-12-85 NORTH ANNA 14 100%
i SHIFT SUPERVISOR 04-29-85 TO 05-25-85 DIABLO CANYON 16 87%
(CREW 11) 01-06-86 TO 01-17-86 MCGUIRE 8
100%
04-20-86 TO 05-03-86 ST.
LUCIE 9
100%
i 02-28-88 TO 03-09-88 DIABLO CANYON 7
98%
11-27-88 TO 12-09-88 PALO VERDE 7
99%
TOTAL 61 SMITH, M. R.
06-04-84 TO 06-15-84 BEAVER VALLEY 5
50%
SHIFT SUPERVISOR 03-04-85 TO 03-22-85 MCGUIRE 14 73%
(CREW 12) 04-21-86 TO 05-02-86 DIABLO CANYON 9
100%
04-27-87 TO 05-01-87 PCGUIRE 4
77%
06-29-87 TO 07-03-87 MCGUIRE 5
100%
l 01-25-88 TO 02-05-88 ST.
LUCIE 10 100%
08-23-88 TO 09-02-88 PALO VERDE 8
95%
TOTAL 55 BAIN, THOMAS E.
04-03-84 TO 04-19-84 TROJAN 12 88%
SHIFT SUPERVISOR 03-25-85 TO 04-05-85 SALEM 9
100%
(CREW 13) 09-30-87 TO 10-06-87 SALEM 5
100%
06-27-88 TO 07-01-88 WOLF CREEK 3
100%
10-23-89 TO 11-04-89 SALEM 7
100%
TOTAL 36 UEAUDIN, T.
J.
04-03-84 TO 04-19-84 TROJAN 12 88%
SHIFT SUPERVISOR 03-25-85 TO 04-05-85 SALEM 9
100%
(CREW 15) 03-17-86 TO 03-27-86 DIABLO CANYON 8
100%
05-26-87 TO 06-12-87 CATAWBA 13 100%
09-30-87 TO 10-05-87 SALEM 5
100%
07-05-88 TO 07-14-88 RANCHO SECO 7
57%
10-23-89 TO 11-04-89 SALEM 7
100%
TOTAL 61
- COTTON, C.
R.
07-28-87 TO 09-09-87 BRAIDWOOD 9
26%
UNIT SUPERVISOR 01-18-88 TO 01-29-88 ST.
LUCIE 10 99%
(CREW 14) 07-05-88 TO 07-21-88 RANCHO SECO 11 67%
08-08-88 TO 08-17-88 DIABLO CANYON 8
91%
11-27-88 TO 11-28-88 SAN ONOFRE 1
90%
11-30-88 TO 12-08-88 DIABLO CANYON 8
100%
TOTAL 47
7
-Attcchm:nt 2-to TXX-89858 Pagaf2 of'2 e
CPSES; SUPERVISORS OBTAINING-SIX WEEKS HOT PARTICIPATION EXPERIENCE NAME.
TIME PERIOD PLANT
(>20%)'
AVC. POWER DAYS DAVIS, KYLE R.
07 20 87'TO 08 29 87 DIABLO' CANYON 30 986 UNIT SUPERVISOR 02-29 88 TO 03 09-88 DIABLO CANYON 7
62%
(CREW-12) 01 16 89 TO 01 26 89 PALO VERDE 4
724 TOTAL 41-JANK', JAMES'T.
03-30 87~TO 04 13 87 DIABLO CANYON 9
784 UNIT SUPERVISOR 05 30-87 TO 07 16 87 DIABLO CANYON-27 100t (CREW 16) 02-27 89 TO 03-09-89 PALO VERDE O
06-26-89 TO 07 05-89 MCGUIRE 5
1004 TOTAL 41 SMITH, BART J.
08-04-85 TO 08 10 85 DIABLO CANYON 2
100%
4 UNIT SUPERVISOR 03-29 87.TO 04-13-87 DIABLO CANYON-9 964 i
(CREW 15) 08 09-87 T0-08-29 87 DIABLO CANYON 15 99%
02-28 88 TO 03-10 88 DIABLO CANYON 7
68t' TOTAL 33 1
SMITH,.RUSSEL A.
06 14 84 TO 06-29-84 ZION 5
>20%
UNIT SUPERVISOR 10-21-84 TO 12-14 84 PRAIRIE ISLAND 30 1004 (CREW 14) 06 26 89 TO 07-14 89 CATAWBA 14 964 10-26 89 TO 11-04 89 SALEM 7
1004 TOTAL 56 i
MARTINEZ, RAUL 09-26-88 TO 10-07 88 PALO VERDE 8
99%
UNIT SUPERVISOR-11-07-88 TO 11-18-88 BRAIDWOOD
.6 64%
I (CREW 13) 12 04-89 TO 12 22-89 SAN ONOFRE 15
>20%
TOTAL 30 3
i l
=
g I
l l'
{
t-1,.
l i
7
> Atitischinint 3Tio'TXX-89850'~
~ ~ ~
~~
~
~~
~
^
[]
iPags liof 2 1
_1 i
CPSES SUPERVISORS STARTUP AND SHUTDOWN-EXPERIENCE
[
NAME~
DATE PLANT STARTUP SHUTDOW 4
BAIN, THOMAS.E.
10-02-87 SALEM 1
SHIFT' SUPERVISOR 11-03-89 SALEM 1
(CREW 13).
TOTAL 1
1 BEAUDIN, T. J.
10-02-87 SALEM 1
SHIFT' SUPERVISOR 11-03-89 SALEM 1
(CREW 15)
TOTAL 1
1 DASKAM, T. J.
04-10-85 SALEM 1
SHIFT' SUPERVISOR 02-19-86 DIABLO CANYON 1
(CREW 16)
TOTAL-2 0
HARVEY,.S..E.
05-07-86 SALEM 1
SHIFT SUPERVISOR 06-04-86 ST. LUCIE 1
.(CREW 14) 06-19-86 ST. IUCIE 1
09-04-87 MCGUIRE 1
TOTAL 3
1 MARSH, TERRY L.
05-03-85 DIAB 10 CANYON 1
SHIFT SUPERVISOR 05-20-85 DIABLO CANYON 1
(CREW 11) 01-16-86 MCGUIRE 1
03-08-88 DIABLO CANYON 1
TOTAL 3
1 SMITH, M. R.
06-14-84 BEAVER VALLEY 1
SMIFT SUPERVISOR 06-15-84 BEAVER VALLEY
-1 (CREW 12) 05-01-87 MCGUIRE' 1
L 07-03-87 MCGUIRE 1
TOTAL 2
2 DEEN, MICHAEL D.
07-28-86 PRAIRIE ISLAND 1
SHIFT SUPERVISOR 04-07-87 PRAIRIE ISLAND 1
- (WORK CONTROL)
TOTAL 1
1 APPLE, K. C.
07-04-86 BYRON 1
j.
UNIT SUPERVISOR 10-03-86 BYRON 1
l
- (CREW 11)
TOTAL 1
1 BROUGHTON, T. W.
05-01-85 SAN ONOFRE 1
L UNIT SUPERVISOR 06-02-86 ST. LUCIE 1
- (CREW 13) 06-19-86 ST. LUCIE 1
09-06-86 ST. LUCIE 1
09-05-86 ST. LUCIE 1
TOTAL 3
2 BRYAN, G.
C.
11-12-85 CALLAWAY 1
UNIT SUPERVISOR 09-04-86 SAN ONOFRE 1
(CREW 12) 11-09-86 ARK. NUCLEAR 1 1
07-16-87 ARK. NUCLEAR 1 1
TOTAL 3
1 l
'r-r w
+
(
,Attachmont'3 to'TXX-89858 L'
'.Paga-2cof 2 CPSES SUPERVISORS'STARTUP AND SHUTDOWN EXPERIENCE NAME DATE PLANT STARTUP SHUTDOW m e1.
BURNETT, S.
P.
08-84 TO.
WOLF CREEK 1
'l n
UNIT SUPERVISOR 06-86 TOTAL ~
1 1
(CREW 15)_'
NOTE: -MR._BURNETT WAS PREVIOUSLY LICENSED (SRO) AT WOLF CREEK.
HE=IS CREDITED WITH ONE STARTUP AND ONE SHUTDOWN DURING THIS PERIOD.
~
COTTON, C. R.
07-30-87 BRAIDWOOD 1
UNIT SUPERVISOR 08-10-88 DIABLO CANYON 1
(CREW 14) 11-28-88 SAN ONOFRE 1
12-05-88 DIABLO CANYON 1
TOTAL 3
1 DAVIS, K. R.
03-06-88 DIABLO CANYON 1
-1 UNIT SUPERVISOR 01-21-89 PALO VERDE 1
(CREW 12)
TOTAL 2
1 EGGEMEYER, N.
C.
01-31-89 ST. LUCIE 1
i UNIT SUPERVISOR 03-08-83
.(CREW 16)
TO 03-15-84 ARK. NUCLEAR 1 1
1 TOTAL 1
2 NOTE:=-MR. EGGEMEYER WAS PREVIOUSLY LICENSED AT ARKANSAS NUCLEAR ONE.
HE IS CREDITED WITH ONE STARTUP AND ONE SHUTDOWN
.DURING THIS PERIOD.
JANK, JAMES. T.
07-15-87 DIABLO CANYON 1
UNIT SUPERVISOR 07-05-89 MCGUIRE 1
(CREW 16)
TOTAL 1
1
- SMITH, B.
J.-
03-06-88 DIABLO CANYON 1
1 UNIT SUPERVISOR TOTAL 1
1 (CREW 15)
SMITH, R. A.
10-27-84 PRAIRIE ISLAND 1
UNIT SUPERVISOR 10-28-84 PRAIRIE ISLAND 1
(CREW 14) 11-05-84 PRAIRIE ISLAND 1
TOTAL 2
1 3
z :.-- -
Attachment'4-to: TXX-89858-
~
m Page l'of.1 NUMARC HOT PARTICIPATION EXPERIENCE SUf9tARY
- *1
-CREW CREW.
CREW CREW-CREW CREW
-WCC 11 12 13 14 15 16 SHIFT HOT PARTICIPATION SUPERVISORS EXPERIENCE (DAYS) 61 55 36 133 61
- 121 121 STARTUPS 3-2-
1
-3 1
.2-1 SHUTDOWNS.
1 2
1 1
1 0.
1 UNIT HOT PARTICIPATION SUPERVISORS EXPERIENCE (DAYS) 132 133 123 47 160*
162*
STARTUPS 1
3 3
3 1*
1*
SHUTDOWNS 1
1 2
1 1*
2*'
UNIT HOT PARTICIPATION SUPERVISORS EXPERIENCE (DAYS) 41 30 56 33 41 i
STARTUPS 2
0 2
1 1
SHUTDOWNS 1
0 1
1 1
TOTALS HOT PARTICIPATION
^
EXPERIENCE (DAYS) 193 229 189 236 254 324 121 STARTUPS 4
7 4
8 3
4 1
SHUTDOWNS 2
4 3'
3 3
3 1
COMMITMENT HOT PARTICIPATION EXPERIENCE (DAYS) 150 150 150 150 150 150 STARTUPS 1
1 1
1 1
1 SHUTDOWNS 1
1 1
1 1
1
- PREVIOUSLY LICENSED PWR: CREDITED WITH 130 DAYS EXPERIENCE, 1 STARTUP, 1 SHUTDOWN f
w - -
-~.,*,.w-r
.2 a
..m.
____m1__m___._..___,,,,...__.m.
.m
w-c
(
T.
9.r
-. P;g:f-licf ? 21 '
1 sAttachm:nt-SEto TXX-89858-
- Ut -
0 r
l U
SUPPLEMENTAL-INFORMATION A.:
-Attachments 1, 3,
& 4 g
e Mr. Nick C. Eggemeyer was a'previously licensedeoperator.at
-Arkansas Nuclear One.
License Number --- OP-6273 Docket' Number
--- 55-9029-p Facility. Docket Number --- 50-313 i
I Mr.=Eggemeyer functioned as an Auxiliary Operator from L1 02/81 to 03/83.. He performed licensed Reactor-Operator b'
duties:in the Control. Room 1from 03/83 to 03/84,- During.
A this time.in the Control Room, he received fourteen 1(14)~
b weeks 1SRO training (11/83-to 3/84) with the on-duty-Shift' Supervisor.'
During these time frames he participated-bi in several'startups and shutdowns including refueling.
Mr.. Stanley P.. Burnett was a previously licensed Senior-
-Reactor Operator:at Wolf Creek Generating Station.
License Number --- SOP-43082 s
Docket Number- --- 55-40072.
t Facility ~ Docket-Number.--- 50-482 i
Mr. Burnett functioned as a non-licensed' Reactor Operator during the startup and construction phase of WCGS from
.11/80 to 6/84. HHe performed licensed Reactor Operator duties in the Control Room from 8/84 to 4/86.
During these time frames he participated in the: fueling and startup of WCGS.
Based on the previous experience of-Mr. Eggemeyer and Mr. Burnett, CPSES has credited to-them one hundred-thirty (130) days hot operating experience, one (1) startup and one-(l) shutdown.
B.
Attachment'2 and 4 Mr. Raul-Martinez is currently off-site completing his six weeks hot participation experience.
3 l'
7
[
EPage'2'of:2
' Attachment 5 toLTXX-89858:
o l
'Y C. -and 4 14r. Daskam has been unable to complete his shutdown-L experience.
During his many attempts the plants did not shutdown on schedule or they tripped prior to the shutdown date.
d While CPSES is still attempting to obtain the required shutdown.for Mr. Daskam, we bolleve the shutdown experience for this crew is acceptable based on the shutdown experience of the Unit Supervisors.
Furthermore, the-CPSES " Hot Participation Experience Program" required both startups and. shutdowns to include modes one.through five, with a minimum of modes two and three being observed.
Mr. Daskam although not meeting this specific requirement, participated in several shutdowns due.to reactor trips.
D.
Attachments-1, 2,'and 4 The Industry Working Group proposal accepted by-Generic Letter 84-16, only requires six weeks of the required'six months " hot participation" experience to be at greater than twenty percent power.
CPSES, in going a step further is taking credit only for those days when power wasLgreater than twenty percent in. calculating the six months (minimum of one hundred-twenty days).
This results in significantly more " power operations" experience being attained.
Additionally, credit was only
-taken in the time calculation'for eight hours per day, 5 days per week. -This also resulted in operators.having more experience than that which is indicated in the tables.
?
I l
l l
i 1
< -.s File No. : 10002 COMNITNENT TRACKING Page No. : _ 1 OUTGOING CORRESPONDENCE EVALUATION SHEET r
. DOCUMENT IDENTIFICATION Tit 16/ Subject :. RESPONSE TO RAI ON HOT OPERATING EXPERIENCE Log No. : TXX-89858-File.
.: 10035 913,1 Date'
- 12/29/1989 ITEN TRACKING Tracking Description Document /No.
No new commitments identified in letter : TXX-89858-l i
1 o Iteo Types : EA - External Action OB - Operational Basis DB - Design Basis IA - Internal Action DO - Description Only C - Committed Date P - Proposed Date COMPLETED BY :
REVIENED Date/2!2/!dl Initial Date/
Initials GLB 1
j g'
- BY SUBJECT 00CKETED W.
G.' Counsil m
J..Ellis (CASE)
~
L' D. Nace-J. L. Vota M. D. Spence /-
6 N. S. Reynolds J. D. Redding-F. A. Camp W. J. Cahill L. Kennedy N
R. D. Walker /
IAP. ASLB & CAP J. S. Marshall 6
N
'J.
E. Krechting 6
N W. G. Guidemond m
MAB R.
A'. Wooldridge m
m R. M. Fillmore m
T.-M. Wilson A. B. Scott M
J. J. Kelley SWWIWPlugge R. L. Ramsey 6
SumsumeegWmulS002 CPSES IR H. C. Schmidt m
WI1555555u15D T. Sprinkle M
M J. J. Allen N
' ' " ^ " - - ' --'
J. L. French h/
TXX Fil'e (Corp.)
ARMS TXX File (Site) t.
l TXX File (Bethesda)
OTHER 4)L*
======un mr 6
J. C. Hicks N
M) m uuuuuuuuugEP asummumuseumuman N
I exammeemumme enummmemmhumenMuim 6
N0DIL -
Correspondence related to material / component acceptability.
l-i 10ER -
Correspondence which pertains to 10ER program (e.g., generic l
1etters.- NRC information notices. NRC bulletins. etc.) and CPSES Inspection Reports.
CASE -
All filings and correspondence between the NRC staff and TU l'
Electric.
ORC -
All SDAR's, CPSES Inspection Reports and responses, and Generic Letters.
ISEG -
All 10ER material plus inspection reports for TV Electric and j
other plants.
l November 28, 1989 1
Fw' w
' i--