ML20030B413
| ML20030B413 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Perry  |
| Issue date: | 09/21/1973 |
| From: | Farmakides J, Hooper F, Linenberger G Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| To: | DUQUESNE LIGHT CO., PENNSYLVANIA POWER CO., TOLEDO EDISON CO. |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20030B411 | List: |
| References | |
| FOIA-81-114 NUDOCS 8108170211 | |
| Download: ML20030B413 (5) | |
Text
Lu..p.,.1b.x....
rp:
w 4
., s
.i.
aa
-=u.:. w x w w.
m a.w.:.c w :.~ m w
,r)
J Lj r
UNITED STATES OF AllERICc l;o[fgjj A103!IC ENERGY COSBIISSIC e, e L & T;8 aM In the 11atter of
)
- 4,,, 0
)
~f:
DUQUESNE LIGIIT CO31PANY,
)
OIIIO EDISON CO.',IPANY,
)
e' PENNSYLVANIA POWER-CO31P3NY'
)
Dc '~
.e" s
- 00-440 CLEVELAND ELECTRIC
)
W ILLU3!INATING CO3IPANY, AND
)
50-441 g.
TOLEDO EDISON COSIPANY
)
,Cs:
\\
.,, +.
/
- 4. ',..i.
(Perry Nuclear Power Plant,
)
$.1 Units 1 and 2)
)
e D
4.'. Q Y:p l
I' t
.M PREHEARING CONFERENCE ORE M b...
pn:
,w On Septembei 5,
1973, a Special Prd i.ng
- /.Ifl
',gh Conference was held in Painesville, Ohic asuant'to Y
Not'ich of this' Board issued on August !
~3.
A 1.'.
l...
i
(
Q..,
primary objective of said conference w; clarify iq a
t,
't.4 and determine the contentions submittc a'e Coali-
?
n 1.
l-,9 l X..
tion for Safe Electric Power in its pe'
. to
,,#s M,i '
intervene, dated Augus t 9, 1973, as se ented by
- c. 9 j
a:.
MS:
" Supplemental Petition for Leave to I:
ne",
dated Q,
- p. sX August 31, 1973 p
- 'a.;.
j :- =
The Board has reviewed and consid
.:oth the documen ts o f the Coalition and the or:.
- ements 1*
D'W and commitments made at the Special Pr ing l
r1' s
Conference, and accordingly' concludes
'. lows :
p.
')5
[i T
8108170211 810609
?
g ml ALEXAND81-114 PDR
.n
..,y-r ;v 1y 7..
+.[f 7.--. 7;- ~.y w
."'hw.v. ;~,.... ~.. ~,.- y e,.c
~7 m,
.--e,,w y., 9 -,,, m... ~N - -- -, -, -.*L 4.
r-
~
-- y 7--
7q,g,.. g,;
,j,
,j
()
MGB_.n.::L :- M C M - " ' * " " " ' * " " ' "
e f
O O,a
.,.'g.
.s.;
I y y
n 9a 9 ;e.
@b 1.
The Coalition for Safe Electric Power has
,,. u made suff'cient showing under 9 2.714 and v.f4 1;
will be admitted as a party intervenor.
l; ;
v
'C. :
2.
The " Statement of Contentions" set forth y
1
@hd.
in the " Supplemental Petition for Leave to a
e
.s f.
Intervene", submitted by the Coalition, e s;.
e,W dated Augus t 31, 1973, "as intended :.o P96j replace the contentions submitted in the
.! ' ~ j
..s 2'
petition da ted Augus t 9, 1973, and will be t
i ly so considered by the Board.
Each of these pp g-g
. contentions will be considered to relate
.37
.w 13 to the Perry Nitclear Facility for purposes S.
of discovery.
W
- .m
-,b
- h. a 3.
(a)
Contention 1 i.s admitted.
.e
. < :)
(b)
Contentions 2, 3,
and 4 are hereby g.ty -j consolidated and admitted as Contention 2A.
3i.J
.y.
q-(c)
Contention 5 is admitted, provided the Coalition presents "special considerations" 4
{d relating specifically to the Perry Facility.
,..-1
.. a.
t'. '. j w
,e s., ~,l 4
+3s.
6
. c.g,.-
m-n - -.- ~- -- ;
a :,,w-,,, - ~. ~,,-mm,,
mm
$[h[hhNheYbNadb O
i 1
. :,b -.
v/
3-J,. j
.?-
a j, (d)
Contention 6 is admitted, provided the
'Sx.
Coalition presents "special considera-
.w
? [+;)..
tio,ns" relating specifically to the l
Perry Facility.
?%y l
?hhN gg (e)
Contention 7. is admitted.
p.
- 4. 'p (f)
Contention 8 is denied, without prejudice k 1:
[
to the Coalition to reassert it in com-h,jj pliance with the Rules;of the Commise, ion.
u.e w y4-
?
A' lj (g)
Contention 9 is admitted.
' f?
f (h)
Contentions 10, 11, and 12 are her.eby bb
,, 'v.t.$
consolidated and admitted as Contention
,h:[
10A.
hk
\\
@'(
4.
While the contentio'ns have. boon admitted for V1 s..
.'Qf; purposes of discovery, we fully expect.the W[:7 Q jk Coalition, with assistance from the other K-vu G.
F;'M i parties if possible, to restate the contentions y re.)
?m...tFM.,
' egg following. discovery in preparation for the-Evidentiary Hearing.
The parties are hereby r[ha#'"
h8s
~wj4
$L', i
. i[fS w [.
ik'
-M w<%
k
...-..-__-...y 7....
...r..-
~~.-----. -.--------as
_ }r:v s.. l b.$2,'.u k uu. w.a'.A5E~ A L "'
- O S'~" '.
f t
z.
~i
.e a.
- w r
ec cLj
~ ~ ' *
- g O
(/
,.l:;'y 4 -.
P ONU,L m
- .s. %,
k yr, directed to confer with each other for the
- t /._
, p.;s fe purpose of preparing and agreeing to a Joint c:.
,['
Statement of the Issues.
.v,,1 i ' 'im l ',_ '
5.
Following the Special Prehearing Conference, l c., s
.f,%
the Power Siting Commission, S tate of Ohio,
,:n p%j{
by petition dated September 19, 1973, has peg.
E,:,* '
communicated its reques t to participate
+
?.2;w
,jPf]
pursuant to the provisions of Section 2.715(c) uM;)
and has made a showing therefor., The Board
". W finds the showing adequate and hereby ad$its
- ws
- 3. u
. the Power Siting Commission, S tate of Ohio, f,f(
7, 1
- g,,
as a participant under the previsions of nj m -
Section 2.715(c).
It is expected that the h,t i,-
g 3..
matters raised by said Commission's letter m.u. >;
dd will be discussed by the parties and the
, N[ *'
N Power Siting Commission before the next uA 2[s g!,,,
Prehearing Conference.
,y-e r<
[
6.
Discovery, as permitted by the Regulations k'3 N,
(Section 2.740) may proceed on the contentions o
,.- s
, :.4 *. 'p }
7.f-f admitted.
If there is any objection to a h4;-
Y' Q:-, )
W, c.; r
, - "O b ~i sw j';:.jy,e& -,p-m m m-w w w - m y,
.S
- n ggc~g v v err - -m 7 ~
.;., ms m "r m
(['
?j d N. u L iI s & A N LL Y N M -~
"'- ~ ' "
e
/Y
/
hs y ::% ~
gj 1 5-
- h. 9
,q;.r 1
g y,
,.n f,
.l request for information made by a party C"d k.'
under the discovery procedures, such objection g
l i,1 pl will be reduced to writing and submitted to 14 f*
f.
}
the party seeking the information within five 5e-J Q".7,.
(5) working days.
If the objection is found J4 6 '
r 3
- l to be unsatisfactory, the party seeking w-II
- ~
discovery shall forthwith file appropriate b
k, 4 < <
motion with this Board.
The other parties e.
};;;, '
will have three (3) working; days.within which
. s.
r?':
to respond.
The Board will then rule on;said
%.Q1 g,
motion.
f f I,'
l.-
pj 7.
The Board expects to receive from each party fa a s tatus report on discovery reques ts made, L.
[..,.
and re turns' roccived on or about. December 31, J. c 1973.
Thereafter, the Board expects '
to 6:.
rg.
convene a Second Prehearing Conference on or l
- p..,
f.
abou t January 8, 1974, at which time the w' ' y h
Board expects a complete report from the t
1
,h parties on:
R'
~1" (a)
Prepara tion of a joint s ta tement of
.e, ',-
4.
- .r;J issues.
[r-p.-
F*.
4 o
o, Ls
' 33 4
,ye-
- y=gre. e-ei y
.[ i a
w*m""""y6@ 7 4-ggl~~~
=t
(})
p M M Q Di&W05M62 M UD&4hd%2l5;i%.4A
./
-/-
L K...>
Y.
- 9 s
,as4
.t.i i 19 (b)
Agreements or stipulations of fact.
p%;
LY(:.
, (c)
Possibility of settlement.
>i....-
L (d)
Proposed schedule.
[
8.
The Board, with the full cooperation of the Why y
parties expects to conduct a full, impartial, m,)
and orderly hearing under the Rules of the i A*
ggN; U
commission.
To this end, the Board urges the nr
>v
- f]
parties to confer informally on all matters U ' R,;;
in dispute.
f'Q.l
.1
+
/t V
l6$
%.c f
Tile ' ATOMIC S AFETY AND
,d LICENSING BOARD
$g%
i by'; a
},,.
.)
.J w
G,\\ i
( Aj".L
/
%cr-t@' V
((;jf{ih IPrank F. Hooher', l \\ abo [ ;-
Me
.m M
]
j
[
/
2 Y?
{ Y *n >(...: c wMci.dA
~
,1;f,]
{GustavoA.Linenber.iger, Member
. i \\ A* }
- q
. n.
9,,
.y.
iram.A-vCo d n.W /
ohn B. Farm,akides, Chairman n
i 1
e::,
[p[ t
,, c.
W r, Issued at Washington, D.
C.,
b[-'
this 21st day of September, 1973.
j, bw w
r, *., p.,
x,'
l-
- k sI $hTiI
,,...m
- 1. W:ymsnw;memc ;m.nnrmrU gggyv;g. eacqm/7mqgmgt:may;wrmgggg1
& 0,U$ % K N k1lyMi$2%A%i6NEWY?NWiL M 800&itS M * * * ""^
"' ~ Q g
- -a
~.
i UNITED STATES OF AMERICA ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION In the bbtter of
)
)
~s.,
DUQUESNE LIGIT COMPANY, ET AL.
)
Docket Nos. JJ0-440)
)
50-4'4,1 (Perry Nuclear Power Plant,
)
Units 1 and 2)
)
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that copies of PREllEARING CONFERENCE ORDER dated September 21, 1973 in the captioned catter have been served per the attached Service List by deposit in the United States mail, first class or air amil, this 21st day of September 1973.
.
- 1 ;,. -
+
~
v
~f 'C % _%
<%i.
fa$A Of fich of tho ' Secretary of the Co=aission
Attachment:
Service List ec:
Mr. Farmakides Mr. Kaufman ASLBP M. Maigret S. Sheppard t.Res. Files ASLAB am 9
c
- ~~~K
- O
)
L) r UNITED SCATES OF AMERICA d
ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION D
i In the Matter of
)
)
CLEVELAND ELECTRIC ILLWINATING )
Docket Nos. 50-440 COMPANY, ET AL.
)
50-441
)
(Perry Nuclear Power Plant,
)
Units 1 and 2)
)
1 SERVICE LIST John B. Partakides, Esq., Chairman Dr. George A. Ferguson Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Professor of Nuclear Engineerin;;
U. S. Atem!c Energy Connis sion Houard University
)
Washington, D. C.
20545 Wach ington, D. C.
20001 P
l Dr. Frank F. Hooper Myron Kaufman, Esq.
I School of Natural Resources Robert Newton, Esq.
University of Michigan Regulatory Staff Counsel Ann Acbor, Michigan, 48104 U. S.Qtonic Energy Cocais sica Washingtor.. D.
C.
20545 John F. Wolf, Esq.
r Alternate Chairman, Willian !bssar, Esq.
Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Regulatory Staff Counsel 1015 18th Street, N. W.
U. S. Atomic Energy Connission Washington, D. C.
20005 Washington, D. C.
'20545 Mr. Gustave A. Linenberger Gerald Charnoff, Esq.
Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Shaw, Pittean, Potts & Trowbridge U.S. Atomic Energy Commissica 910 17th Street, N. W.
Washing:on, D. C.
20545 Washington, D.
C'.
20006 Perry Public Library 3753 Main Street Perry, Ohio 44081
,,.c w y's- ' S'!v,mmn$g
,.g.n,n g"
.g~ ^g^.,:
,.: n,.
SQ.,
~
~
O:
h
^'
^^
"~
'^
m
..