ML19329D020
| ML19329D020 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Beaver Valley, Davis Besse, Perry  |
| Issue date: | 08/05/1974 |
| From: | Jonathan Brown, Palmer F AMERICAN MUNICIPAL POWER-OHIO, INC., AMP, INC., DUNCAN, BROWN, WEINBERG & PALMER |
| To: | US ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION (AEC) |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8002240033 | |
| Download: ML19329D020 (10) | |
Text
cp v
/t acc Eits 3 s auEc 1
h jf 7
11NITED STATES OF AMl!RICA ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION 0
AUG 57974 i""er**arw
's2.* ?" S
[4 1 6 in the Matter of
)
d'
) n Fredr' D. Palmer
- y c K._ J'%._ . , - ~
. ii T . lipokn '
DlINCAN, BROWN, WEINBERG G PALMER 17 10 Pennsylvania Avenue , N. W.
Suite 777
. W:i,hinniein, 11 (: . 2 tit 106 )
{ .!(12 ) .!!!b l .i /. !,
i:inin so I fo r AMi' 01110 ;
l 1
m
Exhibit A
'?.T.[~.*" iI.3 s viNGINEiEi%. INC. .
March 29, 1974
~
l John T. Brown, Esq.
Duncan, Brown & Palmer :
The Mills Building 1700 Fennsylvania Avenue, N.W. ,
Washing ton , D.C. 20006 ,
Re: Amp-Ohio, Inc. !
PASNY Power ,
File: 1243.001 l
Dear Ri ck:
We are making the following comments at your request concerning the March 15, 1974 Memorandum and Order of the Atomic Energy i Commission relative to the proposed Perry Nuclear Power Station. l 1
On Page 10 of the Memorandum, the Board states that "the peti- l tioner seems to be saying that the sole nexus involved here is that the Perry Plant would merely affect the ' wheeling' capacity of CEI's transmission system." This is not the sole nexus; i there is alra the question of overall power system stability l ,
that was raised in our letter of February 28, 1974. ,
We shall comment first on the question of wheeling. Refer to the guidelines in Waterford which the Board says must be met to establish a nexus. On Page 1170 of Waterford, allegations i (2) and (5) most certainly apply in the case at issue. The Cleveland Electric does control the bulk power transmission system which is the last vital link for the wheeling of PASNY power and with the installation of the major Perry Plant may i be in the position to load transmission circuits to preclude :
the delivery of power from the Power Authority of the State of New York to the City of Cleveland. ;
i l
l l
John T. Brown , Esq. .
Ma rch 29,,1974 Page Two As mentioned above, the question of stability must also be reviewed.
The author has had considerable experience in power system analysis, having served as a utility representative on a special Federal Power Commission study of the November 1965 Northeast power interruption.
It is almost the universal practice in power sys tem planning to fully represent area transmission and generating facilities in system transient stability studies to determine if the addition of a major gonerating plant could result in condi tions following a system dis-turbance tha t would result in sys tem ins tability and the break-up ,
of the area transmission system. 1 i
In this instance , there is the danger of the Cleveland Municipal '[
- System, radial to the transmission f acilities of the Cleveland
Electric Illuminating Company on a tie ordered by the Federal ;
Power Commission , separating f rom the interconnected system. i This separation would not only interrupt the delivery of PASHY. !
power but i t would also sever the system from the availability :
o f eme rgency power. The Cleveland Electric . Illuminating Company ;
is a member of ECAR, the area transmitting reliability group, and l has access to all pertinent system data; whereas, AMP-Ohio is l not a member of this group and does not have access to the neces-sary information to test the sys tem for a load and stabili ty con-ditions. The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company must dem- ,
onstrate that computer model simulation has included the vital ;
wheeling facilities for PASNY power and of full representation .
of the Municipal Generating Facilities in stability studies.
l l
Very truly yours, f
f O'BRIEN & GERE ENGINEERS, INC. j i
,, w\ s J -
l C arles H.\ eW Illingwo th , P.E.
Managing Engineer i l
! l CHI /fc cc: Mr. John C. Engle !
M r. Adam W. Kubik l l
s t
l
b d
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE J
I hereby certify that service of the foregoing pleading has been made.on the following parties listed on the attachment hereto, this .[D ' day of August, 1974, by depositing copies thereof in the United States mail, first class or air mail, postage repaid. l l /# /
ETA') i WP ,' " /m.., ;
}
Fredrick D. Palmer I
i t
i -
1 i
i
- t i
a w , - - , - -
-c- e , , _ , - - ,
ATTACHMENT i
/w,.aic Safety and Licenning Board Jasoph J. Saunders, Esq.
L.S. Atomic Encegy Commission Steven Charno, Esq.
Vla:.hin;; ton, D. C . 20545 Antitrust Division Department of Justico Mr. Frank W. Karas, Chief ,
Washington, D. C. 20530 INblic Proceedings Branch Office of the Secretary Abraham Braitman, Esq.
U. S. Atomic Energy Commission Office of Antitrust and Indemnity Washington, D. C. 20545 U. S. Atomic Energy Commission
. Washington, D. C. 20545 John B. Farmakidos, Esq.
Chairman William T. Clabault, Eaq.
inomic Safety and Licensing Board David A. Leckie, Esq.
U. S. Acomic Energy Commission Department of Justice Washington, D. C. 20545 Post Office Box 7513 John H. Brebbia, Esq.
Atomic Saicty and Licensing Board Gerald Charnoff, Esq.
Alston, Miller & Gaines Shaw, Pittman, Potts & Trowbridge 1776 K Street, N. W. 910 - 17th Street, N. W. ,
Wa shington, D. C. 20006 Washington, p. C. 20006 1
Dr. Georgo R. Hall Frank R. Clokey, Esq.
Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Special Assistant Attornoy General U. S. Atomic Energy Conunission Room 219 - Towno Houso Aparanem Washington, D. C. 20545 . Harriuburg, Ponasylvania 17105 acnjamin d. Voglar. Esq. Thomas J. Munsch, Jr. , Eaq.
Joseph Rutberg, Esq. General Attorney Office of the General Counsel Duquosno Lisa: Company 1 Regulation 435 Sixth Avenue -
U. S. Atomic Energy Commission Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 15419 Washington, D. C. 20545
, David McNeil Olds, Esq.
Robert J. Verdisco, Esq. John McN. Cramer, Eaq.
Office of the General Counsel Reed, Smith, Shaw k McClay acgulation 747 Union Trust Duilding j U. S. Atomic Energy Commission Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 15219 Washington, D. C. 20545 John R. White, Esq.
Andrew F. Popper, Esq. Vice President and General Counsol Office of the General Counsel Ohio Edison Company Regulation 47 North Main Street U. S. Atomic Energy Commission Akron, Ohio 44308 .
Washington, D. C. 20545 ,
t ,
..q:c 2 ATTACHMENT (Continue.1)
Pennsylvania Powe: Company Reuben Goldberg, Esquire i East Washington Street 1700 Pennsylvania Avenue, N. W.
New Castic, Pennsylvania 16103 Suite 550 Washington, D. C. 20006 Leslie Henry, Esq.
Fuller, Henry, Hodge & Snyder ,
300 Madison Avenue Toledo, Ohio 43604 Donald H. Hauser, Esq.
The C1cveland Elcetric Illuminating Co.
Post Office Bo:: 5000 Cleveland, Ohio 44101 John Lansdale, Jr. , Esq.
Cox, Langford & Brown 21 Dupont Circle, N.W.
Washington, D. C. 20036 Alan S. Rosenthal, Chairman Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeals Board U. S. Atomic Encrgy Commission Washington, D. C. 20545 .
Dr. John H. Buck , .
Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeals Board U. S. Atomic Energy Commission Washington, D. C. 20545 Dr. Lawrence K. Quarles Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeals Board '
U. S. Atomic Energy Commission Washington, D. C. 20545 C. Raymond Marvin, Esq.
Deborah M. Powell, Esq.
- Antitrust Section 8 East Long Street Suite 510 -
Columbus, Ohio 43215 .
s l
1