ML17037B534

Letter Regarding NRC Staff Review of Addendum 3 to the Mark I Containment Evaluation Short Term Program Report Which Was Submitted on 08/17/1976 by GE Company on Behalf of the Mark I Owner'S Group

ML17037B534
Person / Time
Site:	Nine Mile Point
Issue date:	09/14/1976
From:	Lear G Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
To:	Rhode G Niagara Mohawk Power Corp
References
Download: ML17037B534 (8)

Text

r,'SEP 1 4576 Dis&rbution NRC PDR Local PDR ORB k3 File KGoller TJCarter OELD OI8E (5)

Docket No. 50-220 GLear JGuibert CParrish DEisenhut Niagara Mohawk Power Corporation TBAbernathy ATTN: Mr. Gerald K. Rhode JRBuchanan Vice President - Engineering 'ACRS (16) 300 Erie Boulevard 1/est DRoss Syracuse, Hew York 13202 Gentlemen:

The NRC staff has completed its review of Addendum 3 to the Hark I Containment Evaluation Short Term Program Report (NEDC-20989-P) which was submitted to the NRC on August 17, 1976 by General Electric Company on behalf of the Mark I Owner's Group. The Addendum 3 report describes the methods used to determine the vent header and vent pipe pool swell impact loads which were considered in the "Plant Unique Analysis Report For Torus Support System and Attached Piping For Nine Mile Point Nuclear Power Station" dated July 26, 1976.

'lfe have concluded that the methods used to determine plant unique pool swell velocities from the reference plant velocity, as described in Addendum 3, are, acceptable; however, we have further concluded that the determination of vent-header and vent pipe impact loads using impulse/

velocity data obtained from 1/12 scale test facility strain gage measure-ments is not acceptable since we believe these strain gage measurements do mot provide an adequate arid reliable data base. Consequently, we require that you provide a supplement to the Nine Mile Point Unit No. 1 plant unique analysis report which considers vent header and vent pipe impact loads which have been determined using the impulse/velocity relationship derived from the Mark III- Pressure Suppression Text Facility (PSTF) data.

In order for us'o complete our review of the Mark I Containment Short Term-Program in a timely manner, we require that you provide your written response'.,'y October l. 1976. One signed original and 39 copies of your response will be necessary.

OPPICS~

SURNAMR ~

OATS~

Form AEC.S18 (Rer. 9-S j) hEChf 0240 4 UOVRRNMSNT.'PRINTINO OPXICKI IOT4 424 !44

H ~ W", ) We 1 ff !

4 ~

IJ

'uu kk \r I II II 4 I

,) l Ik rr

~ 4 t

) ~ r 4

~ 1 1' r~~

1!'

33 4 It It 4 ~

4 rk 4

1I ~,

W 4

II 4

Niagara Mohawk Power - 2- SEP j. < 816 Corporation

'I If you have any questions regarding the requested information, we would be pleased to meet with you. l Sincerely, Original signed by George Lear, Reactors Branch 83 Chief'perating Division of Operating Reactors cc: Arvin E. Upton, Esquire LeBoeuf, Lamb, Leiby 8 MacRae 1757 N Street, -N. W, Washington, D. C. 20036 Anthony Z. Roisman, Esquire Roisman, Kessler and Cashdan 1712 N Street, N. W.

Washington, D. C. 20036 Oswego City Library 120 E. Second Street Oswego, New York 13126 OPPICE~ 0843 .....O.RB: .8.3...........

SURNAME~ CPa 'sh JGui zt.; .f, ...Gl.eaI:...

DATE ~ 9/ / 9//gjI,>6 9/I.gl.Z6..

Pofse hEC-318 (Rev. 9.$ 3) CM 0240 4 U, SI OOVERNMENT PRINTINO OPPICEI IST4 520 ISS

e

~ A d li( ~'

~

C

Distribution SEP l 4 I976 4-..=-Docket ORB P3 Local PDR NRC PDR KGo1ler TJCarter OELD OI8IE (5)

Docket No. 50-220 GLear JGuibert CParrish DEisenhut Niagara t5ohawk Power Corporation TBAbernathy ATTN: ter. Gerald K. Rhode ACRS (16)

Vice President - Engineering DRoss 300 Erie Boulevard West Syracuse, Hew York 13202 Gentlemen:

In a June 18, 1976 letter from ter. E. A. Ilughes, General Electric Company (GE), to ftr. V. Stello of the NRC staff, GE! provided responses on behalf of the Hark I Owner's Group to NRC staff questions on the Mark I Containment Evaluation Short Term Program final report. The response to Containment Systems Branch (CSB) guestion No. 9 provided information regarding potential damage to critical torus internal structures and components from missiles generated as a result of post-LOCA pool swell impact loads on the solid catwaTk, inside the f<ine tiile Point Unit No. 1 (t<HP-1) suppression pool (torus). In your letter of July 23, 1976 you stated that, although containment integrity would be maintained for the most probable missile impact orientations and target areas, NtlPC would remove the solid catwalk at Nt<P-1 and replace it with a grating catwalk during the scheduled Spring 1977 refueling outage in order to alleviate the potential for damage.

In order to complete our review and evaluation of the continued use of a solid catwalk at HtlP-1 until Spring 1977, the HRC staff requires that you provide a study which determines the probability of loss of contain-ment integrity at HMP-1 due to a postulated LOCA and subsequent catwalk missile damage. The study should consider the probability of a pipe break resulting in a LOCA which in turn results in the failure of the solid catwalk. It should also consider the orientations of the catwalk missiles which result in failure of the torus wall, vent pipe and bellows assembly. Since much of the catwalk may fail. the study should include the effects of multiple missiles.

In order to complete our review of the Mark I Containttletft Short Term Progi.am in a timely fashion, we require that the abovementi ed information be provided by October 1, 1976. One signed original and opies of your response will be necessary.

ORSICd ~

SURIrANd~

OATS+

Form AEC-318 (RST. 9.53) hZCM 0240 k U; SI OOVdRNMdNT PRINTINO OFFICdl IST4 Sdo ISS

bf 4 I I It I I b 4 II II b ~

~ 4

~- ~ hrbf 4 r II ~

UF bi f 'll b I I II ~ 4

~,4. ,4 h i

I '4ht 1 I r

~ I bl F

I FF b

4 f

, II f(l, 'il .

II U

h I ~

IUFU 4 II 4

4 4 4 f~

'4 f

I I I I I',

If II 4\ ~ V.

I 4 4 ll

4 SEP 1 4 $ 76 Niagara f<ohawk Power Corporation - 2-If you have any questions regarding the requested information, we would be pleased to meet with you.

Sincerely, Origina( sign g i,y George Lear, Chief Operating Reactors Branch 83 Division of Operating Reactors cc: Arvin E. Upton, Esquire LeBoeuf, Lamb, Leiby 5 HacRae 1757 N Street, H. W.

.Washington, D. C. 20036 Anthony Z. Roisman,'squire Roisman, Kessler and Cashdan 1712 N Street, N. W.

Washington, D. C., 20036 Oswego City Library 120 E. Second Street Oswego, New York 13126 orrIcc3r RB 83 ORB 8 ORB 0'3 SVRNAMC3r'ATc3r

......CRa J.Gui.bert.:mj

.....,9 ... IJ'. ..W j..'ll.7.6.........

PoIm hEC-318 (ReT. 9-S3) hZCM 0240 0U $ 'OOVCRNMCNT.PRINTINO OrrICCI IST4 52d 1dd

41 >

el a

'1 l 8 R