IR 05000461/2012007
| ML12214A348 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Clinton  |
| Issue date: | 08/01/2012 |
| From: | Daley R C Engineering Branch 3 |
| To: | Pacilio M J Exelon Generation Co, Exelon Nuclear |
| Mohammad Munir | |
| References | |
| IR-12-007 | |
| Download: ML12214A348 (16) | |
Text
UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION REGION III 2443 WARRENVILLE ROAD, SUITE 210 LISLE, IL 60532
-4352 August 1, 2012 Mr. Michael Senior Vice-President, Exelon Generation Company, LLC President and Chief Nuclear Officer (CNO), Exelon Nuclear 4300 Winfield Road Warrenville IL 60555
SUBJECT: CLINTON POWER STATIO N EVALUATION S OF CHANGES, TESTS, O R EXPERIMENTS AND PERMANENT PLANT MODIFICATIONS BASELINE INSPECTION REPORT 05000 461/20 1 2007
Dear Mr. Pacilio:
On July 12, 201 2, the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) completed an Evaluations of Changes, Tests, or Experiments and Permanent Plant Modifications inspection at your Clinton Power Station. The enclosed inspection report documents the inspection results
, which were discussed on July 12, 201 2, with you and other members of your staff.
The inspection examined activities conducted under your license as they relate to safety and compliance with the Commission's rules and regulations and with the conditions of your license. The inspectors reviewed selected procedures and records, observed activities, and interviewed personnel.
Based on the results of this inspection, no findings of significance were identifie d. In accordance with 10 CFR 2.390 of the NRC's "Rules of Practice," a copy of this letter and its enclosure will be available electronically for public inspection in the NRC Public Document Room or from the Publicly Available Records System (PARS) component of NRC's Agencywide Documents Access and Management System (ADAMS), accessible from the NRC Web site at http://www.nrc.gov/reading
-rm/adams.html (the Public Electronic Reading Room).
Sincerely,/RA/ Robert C. Daley, Chie f Engineering Branch 3 Division of Reactor Safety Docket Nos. 50
-461 License Nos. NPF-62
Enclosure:
Inspection Report 05000 461/2012007
w/Attachment:
Supplemental Information cc w/encl:
Distribution via ListServ
Ž Enclosure U. S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION REGION III Docket No: 50-461 License No
- NPF-62 Report No:
05000 461/20 1 2007 Licensee: Exelon Generation Facility: Clinton Power Station Location: Clinton , IL Dates: June 25 - July 12, 201 2 Inspectors:
M. Munir, Reactor Inspector (Lead) J. Gilliam, Reactor Inspector L. Jones, Reactor Inspector Approved by:
R. Daley, Chief Engineering Branch 3 Division of Reactor Safety 1 Enclosure
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS
IR 05000 461/20 1 2007; 0 6/25/201 2 - 07/12/201 2; Clinton Power Station; Evaluations of Changes, Tests, or Experiments and Permanent Plant Modifications.
This report covers a two-week announced baseline inspection on evaluations of changes, tests, or experiments and permanent plant modifications. The inspection was conducted by Region III based engineering inspectors.
The NRC's program for overseeing the safe operation of commercial nuclear power reactors is described in NUREG
-1649, "Reactor Oversight Process," Revision 4, dated December 2006.
A. No findings of significance were identified.
N RC-Identified and Self-Revealed Findings B. No violations of significance were identified.
Licensee-Identified Violations
1. REACTOR SAFETY
REPORT DETAILS
Cornerstone:
Initiating Events, Mitigating Systems, and Barrier Integrity 1R17 Evaluation s of Changes, Tests, or Experiments and Permanent Plant Modifications
.1
a. Evaluation of Changes, Tests, or Experiments From June 2 5, 20 1 2 through July12, 201 2, the inspectors reviewed 7 safety-evaluations performed pursuant to 10 CFR 50.59 to determine if the evaluations were adequate and that prior NRC approval was obtained as appropriate. The inspectors also reviewed 2 2 screenings where licensee personnel had determined that a 10 CFR 50.59 evaluation was not necessary. The inspectors reviewed these documents to determine if:
Inspection Scope the changes, tests, or experiments performed were evaluated in accordance with 10 CFR 50.59 and that sufficient documentation existed to confirm that a license amendment was not required; the safety issue requiring the change, tests or experiment was resolved; the licensee conclusions for evaluations of changes, tests, or experiments were correct and consistent with 10 CFR 50.59; and the design and licensing basis documentation was updated to reflect the change.
The inspectors used, in part, Nuclear Energy Institute (NEI) 96
-07, "Guidelines for 10 CFR 50.59 Implementation," Revision 1, to determine acceptability of the completed evaluations, and screenings. The NEI document was endorsed by the NRC in Regulatory Guide 1.187, "Guidance for Implementation of 10 CFR 50.59, Changes, Tests, and Experiments," dated November 2000. The inspectors also consulted Part 9900 of the NRC Inspection Manual, "10 CFR Guidance for 10 CFR 50.59, Changes, Tests, and Experiments."
This inspection constituted 7 samples of evaluations and 2 2 samples of changes as defined in IP 71111.17-04. b. No findings of significance were identified.
Findings
.2 a. Permanent Plant Modifications
From June 25, 201 2 through July 12 , 2012 , the inspectors reviewed 12 permanent plant modifications that had been installed in the plant during the last three years. This review Inspection Scope
3 Enclosure included in
-plant walkdown for a portion of the installed Division 1, 2 and 3 emergency diesel exhaust system and the newly installed Nuclear Steam Supply Protection System inverters 1C71
-S001A & 1C71
-3001B. The modifications were selected based upon risk significance, safety significance, and complexity. The inspectors reviewed the modifications selected to determine if:
the supporting design and licensing basis documentation was updated; the changes were in accordance with the specified design requirements; the procedures and training plans affected by the modification have been adequately updated; the test documentation as required by the applicable test programs has been updated; and post-modification testing adequately verified system operability and/or functionalit y. The inspectors also used applicable industry standards to evaluate acceptability of the modifications. The list of modifications and other documents reviewed by the inspectors is included as an Attachment to this report.
This inspection constituted t welve permanent plant modification samples as defined in IP 71111.17-04. b. No findings of significance were identified.
Findings
OTHER ACTIVITIES
(OA)
4OA2
.1 Identification and Resolution of Problems
a. Routine Review of Condition Reports From June 2 5, 201 2 through July 12 201 2, the inspectors reviewed 21 corrective action process documents that identified or were related to 10 CFR 50.59 evaluations and permanent plant modifications. The inspectors reviewed these documents to evaluate the effectiveness of corrective actions related to permanent pant modifications and evaluations for changes, tests, or experiments issues. In addition, corrective action documents written on issues identified during the inspection were reviewed to verify adequate problem identification and incorporation of the problems into the corrective action system. The specific corrective action documents that were sampled and reviewed by the inspectors are listed in the attachment to this report.
Inspection Scope b. No findings of significance were identified.
Findings 4 Enclosure
4OA6
.1 Meetings O n July 12, 201 2 , the inspector
s presented the inspection results to Mr. Noll and other members of the licensee staff. The licensee personnel acknowledged the inspection results presented and did not identify any proprietary content. The inspectors confirmed that all proprietary material reviewed during the inspection was returned to the licensee staff. Exit Meeting Summary ATTACHMENT:
SUPPLEMENTAL INFORMATION
KEY POINTS OF CONTACT
- W. Noll, Site Vice President
Licensee
- B. Taber, Plant Manager
- D. Kemper, Site Engineering Director
- S. Kowalski, Sr. Manager Design Engineering Manager
- J. Smith, Sr. Manager Plant Engineering
- K. Baker, Regulatory Assurance Manager
Nuclear Regulatory Commission
- B. Kemker, Senior Resident Inspector
LIST OF ITEMS
OPENED, CLOSED AND DISCUSS
ED Non eOpened, Closed, and
Discussed
Attachment
LIST OF DOCUMENTS REVIEWED
The following is a list of documents reviewed during the inspection.
- Inclusion on this list does not imply that the NRC inspectors reviewed the documents in their entirety, but rather, that selected sections of portions of the documents were evaluated as part of the overall inspection effort.
- Inclusion of a document on this list does not imply NRC acceptance of the document or any part of it, unless this is stated in the body of the inspection report.
- CALCULATIONS
- Number Description or Title
- 2011-04 3 Date or Revision Application of TRACG04P Version 4.2.600.3 for OPM Setpoint Determination at Clinton December 10, 2011
- 2009-057 Application of TRACG04P for OPRM Setpoint Determination at Clinton Power Station January 8, 2010
- 01FP14 Effects of Initiation of Fire Suppression Systems on Safe Shutdown Equipment at CPS
- Revision 1
-C
- IP-C-0069 Setpoint Calculation for Turbine Control Valve Fast Closure Scram 1C71
-N005 A, B, C, D
- Revision 02
- 19-AN-30 ERAT Protective Relay Settings Revision 0
- CORRECTIVE ACTION PROGRAM DOCUMENTS REVIEWED
- Number Description or Title
- Date or Revision
- CPS Review of OE340092
- Vital Battery Loss of Capacity August 25, 2011
- AR 01119021 Full Down Limit Switches for F15 and F11 are Unreliable September 28, 2010
- AR 01020200 F 15 Full Down Limit Switch Requires Frequent Adjustment January 23, 2010
- AR 00837146 1C71S001C:
- Received MCR Annunciator 5002
-5N NSPS INV Trouble October 29, 2008
- AR 01010271 Revise 3509.01 and C003 to Remove Fuse Blown Light December 29, 2
- 009 AR 01128037
- Actions for EC379450 (D2)
and 381281(D1) Inv. Replacement October 19, 2010
- AR 01283729 Potential Design Problem with NSPS P/S MOD EC
- 383951 October 31, 2011
- AR 01301072 Div 2 NSPS Inverter Test Results did not Meet Acceptance Criteria December 11 , 2011
- AR 00837140 1C71S001C:
- Received MCR Annunciator 5002
-5N NSPS INV Trouble October 29 , 2008
- AR 00936869 Common Configuration Issue with Divisional Inverters June 29 , 2009 AR 01364492
- FASA Review Identified Weakness in 10CFR50.59 Screening Doc March 21, 2012
- CDBI NRC Inspector Challenges Information in IR
- 1037486 March 28, 2012
- Attachment
- CORRECTIVE ACTION PROGRAM DOCUMENTS REVIEWED
- Number Description or Title
- Date or Revision
- DG Fuel Oil Consumption Rate February 19, 2010
- Possible Problem with C1
-R12 IA Mod December 22, 2009 AR 00122958
- Containment Isolation for Instrument Air September 13, 2002
- Issue with Auto Start of Div 3 Diesel Following Manual Stop September 25, 2009
- ENS 47510 Retraction Evaluation January 12, 2012
- DC Ammeter Circuit Deficiency Appendix R Issue December 8, 2011
- CORRECTIVE ACTION PROGRAM DOCUMENTS GENERATED Number Description or Title
- Date or Revision
- NRC 50.59 Insp:
- NRC 50.59 Insp:
- Observation 50.59 Screening not Stand-Alone
- July 12, 2012
- NRC ID
- MOD 50.59 No Tracking Mech. In
-Place for CALC Update June 27, 2012
- NRC 50.59 Insp:
- Coating Loss on External DG Exhaust July 10, 2012
- Door 1DR1-781 is Missing Some Components July 10, 2012
- Incorrect Marking On Danger/Caution Sign on Door July 10, 2012
- DRAWINGS Number Description or Title
- 20-112392 Date or Revision Schematic 7.5 KVA Inverter Alarms 125VDC, Sht. 1
- Revision C 20-112391 Schematic 7.5 KVA Inverter 125 Vdc, 120 Vac, Sht. 1
- Revision A
- MO6-1035 P&ID Diesel Generator System Piping Clinton Power Station Unit 1
- Revision
- Z
- M0-1056 P&ID Plant Service Water (WS)
- Revision AR
- M-1DG06017S DG Shock Assy
- Sheet 1 of 2
- Revision D
- M05-1035 Diesel Gen Aux System (DG) Starting Air Exhaust & Combustion Sys; Sheet 1
- Revision
- AE
- M05-1035 Diesel Gen Aux System (DG) Starting Air Exhaust & Combustion Sys; Sheet 2
- Revision AB
- Revision AB
- A30-10000-01C Control Building; Intermediate Floor Plan
- Area 1 Revision F
- M05-1054 P&ID Control Building Floor Drain System (TF)
- Revision E
- 40075 SX Strainer April 22, 1977
- Attachment
- DRAWINGS Number Description or Title
- M05-1040, Sheet 5
- Date or Revision
- Revision S
- E02-1HP99, Sheet
- 2 High Pressure Core Spray (HP) Div 3 Diesel Generator Revision M
- E02-1AP12 Relaying and Metering Diagram Emergency Reserve Aux Transformer Revision V
- E02-1RI99 Reactor Core Isolation Cooling System Revision L
- E02-1RH99 Residual Heat removal Sys RHR/SSW Cross Tie Valves 1E12
-F094 and 1E12-F096 Revision H
- CFR 50.59 EVALUATIONS
- Number Description or Title
- CL-2011-E-043 Date or Revision Application of TRACG04P Version 4.2.600.3 for OPM
- Setpoint Determination at Clinton December 10 , 2011
- CL-2009-E-057 Application of TRACG04P for OPRM Setpoint Determination at Clinton Power Station January 8 , 2010
- CL-2009-E-013 Deferral of Division 3 DG Fuel Oil Storage Tank Cleaning to September 2009 and a 25 percent Interval Extension to Reg Guide 1.137 10
-Year FOST Cleaning Frequency for All 3 Divisions.
- Revision 0
- CL-2011-E-002 Defeat Turbine Thrust Bearing Wear Detection Trip Revision 0
- CL-2009-E-030 Defeat Turbine Thrust Bearing Wear Detection Trip Revision 0
- CL-2012-E-002 Open Breaker and Defeat OOS Alarm for 1E12F094
-MSO Revision 0
- Revision 1
- CFR 50.59 SCREENINGS
- Number Description or Title
- CL-2010-S-008 Date or Revision MR90 Type Temp Power Feed Due Date Extension March 8 , 2010
- CL-2010-S-037 Revise O.R.M Section 2.6.3 to Delete Testing
- Requirement 4.6.3.d November 7, 2 011
- CL-2011-S-034 TMOD to Bypass Full Down Limit switch in the Refueling Platform November 14, 2011
- CL-2010-S-028 Replacement of Safety-Related NSPS Inverters 1C71
-S001A and 1C71-S001B November 10 , 2010 CL- 2011-S-048 Remote Monitoring System (RMS)
- January 4 , 2012 CL- 2011-S-004 Remove X12 Relay From Division IV
- Inverter 1C71S001D March 30 , 2011
- Attachment
- CFR 50.59 SCREENINGS
- Number Description or Title
- CL-2010-S-026 Date or Revision Temporary 5VDC Power Supply to Division II Self Test in MCR NSPS Panel 1H13
-P662 September
, 2010
- CL-2011-S-038 Revise O.R.M
- Section 2.6.3 to Delete Testing Requirement 4.6.3.d November 10 , 2011
- EC 3771228 Permanent Removal of EDG
- Outside Exhaust Piping Insulation and Application of High Temperature Coating Revision 0
- GE14 Fuel Changes Beginning With C1C13
- Revision 0
- CL-2009-S-042 RHR Flow Calculation Revision and Tech Spec Bases Change Revision 3
- CL-2010-S-010 Isolate Floor Drain Line in LPCS Pump Room and Revise Flood Plan Accordingly Revision 3
- CL-2009-S-010 Camera Installed in ABST with Power/Feed Cable Running through Containment Shaker Space Revision 2
- CL-2009-S-032 Change to ORM Attachment 2 Table 7 Section 4d page 13 Revision 3
- CL-2010-S-038 Raise Setpoint for 1C71NOOSA
-D to Accommodate Drift Revision 3
- CL-2008-S-022 Add Time Delay Relays and Replace Control Switches to IA System Containment Isolation Valves Logic to Prevent Inadvertent Scram on Momentary Loss of Power to Valve Solenoids Revision 3
- CL-2012-S-004 Installation of Fuses in DC MCC 1A (1DC13E) for the Protection of Circuit for Ammeter 1 II
-DC006 in MCR Panel 1 H13
-P877-14B Revision 0
- CL-2011-S-032 Revise Calculation 19
-AN-30 and E02
-9AP99 to Change the Trip Time Setting for the ERAT Ground Fault Relay that Interfaces with the 138 kV Transmission System Revision 0
- CL-2011-S-042 Add Shorting Switch to Prevent Spurious Opening of 1E51F059-MSO Revision 0
- CL-2009-S-049 Alternate Negative Sequence Time Overcurrent (SGC
- Model) Relay for Main Generator Revision 0
- MODIFICATIONS
- Number Description or Title
- EC 373058 Date or Revision Remove Relay X12 from Division III Inverter 1C71S001C
- Revision 0
- Attachment
- MODIFICATIONS
- Number Description or Title
- EC 379450 Date or Revision Replacement of Safety
-Related NSPS Inverter 1C71
-3001B Revision 0 2009-018 USAR Update to Clarify Description of Exposed EDG Exhaust Pipe July 20, 2009
- ECN 6674 Delete Rupture Disc Per. Sargent and Lundy Letters SLMI
-18029 November 13, 1985
-A Pump Room and the Radwaste Pipe Tunnel Revision 0
- EC 373775 Raise Setpoint for 1C71N005A
-D to Accommodate Drift Revision 3
- EC 386361 Calculation and Setpoint Change in Support of License Amendment No.196 for DG Fuel Oil Consumption Revision 0
- EC 331623 Add Time Delay Relays and Replace Control Switches to IA System Containment Isolation Valves Logic to Prevent Inadvertent Scram on Momentary Loss of Power to Valve Solenoids Revision 7
- EC 385716 Revise Calculation 19
-AN-30 and E02
-9AP99 to Change the Trip Time Setting for the ERAT
- Ground Fault Relay that Interfaces with the 138 kV Transmission System Revision 0
- EC 387302 Installation of Fuses in DC MCC 1A (1DC13E) for the Protection of Circuit for Ammeter 1 II
-DC006 in MCR Panel 1 H13
-P877-14B Revision 0
- PROCEDURES
- Number Description or Title
- CC-AA-112 Date or Revision Temporary Configuration Changes Revision 18
- CC-AA-103 Configuration Change Control for Permanent Physical Plant Changes Revision 23
- GD (RS) - 20.00 Design Basis Hierarchy Revision 5
- OTHER DOCUMENTS
- Number Description or Title
- EC 382424 Date or Revision Clinton Unit 1 Cycle 14 Core Reload Design Letter from J. Michael Downs, GNF Customer Project Manager, to A. Wlezien, Exelon Nuclear Fuel Services, Subject: 10
- CFR 50.59 Error Correction Revision for TRACG04P and Evaluation Basis for Implementation of
- TRACG04P DIVOM.
- 06/15/2010
- Evaluation Report from GE Hitachi, Subject: TRACGO4P (Version 4.2.60.3) DIVOM 10
- CFR 50.59 Evaluation Basis April 2012
- Attachment
- OTHER DOCUMENTS
- Number Description or Title
-2 "Relocate the 10-Year Sediment Cleaning of the Fuel Oil Storage Tank to Licensee Control" September 2, 2008
- BE 417N Basic Engineers "Mechanical Shock Arrestor Extended Unit Assy" September 27, 1976 U-0110 Letter:
- From Clinton Power Station to NRC Harold Denton; Licensing December 1, 1979
- U-600595 Letter: From Clinton Power Station to NRC Harold Denton
- FSAR Amendment No. 38 May 29, 1986
- U-601279 Letter: From Clinton Power Station to NRC
- Submittal of the Updated Safety Analysis Report October 6, 1988
- U-601144 Letter:
- From Clinton Power Station to NRC RIII RA Bert Davis - Annual Operating Report February 29, 1988
- DC-DG-01-CP Diesel Generator Design Criteria
- Clinton Power Station Unit 1 Revision 08
- U-600436 Letter:
- From Clinton Power Station to NRC Harold Denton
- FSAR Amendment No. 36
- January 27, 1986
- CI-01.00 Instrument Setpoint Calculation Methodology Revision 04
- Group 17 Drift Update r3.xls (Demonstrates As
-Found and As-Left) July 10, 2012
- K-2878 Proposal Spec 70293
-A; Plant Service Water Strainers October 24, 1975
- U-602062 Station Blackout (SBO) Safety Evaluation for Clinton Power Station (CPS), Response to the Station Blackout Rule 10CFR50.63, "Loss of All Alternating Current Power"
- (Supplemental Response)
- October 30, 1992
- Response to Supplemental Safety Evaluation for the Station Blackout (SBO) Rule,
- U-601427 Clinton Power Station April 16, 1989
- Response to the Station Blackout Rule
- 01032794-02 Operability Evaluation
- Review of Administrative Controls as Compensatory Actions for EDG Fuel level Revision 3
- LER 2011-007-00 Unfused DC Ammeter Circuits Result in Unanalyzed Condition December 8, 2011
- EC Eval
- 387053 CPS
- ENS 47510 Retraction Evaluation Revision 1
- Attachment
LIST OF ACRONYMS
EQ Environmental Qualification
ENS Emergency Notification Sy
s t em
LPCS Low Pressure Core Spray
Mr. Michael J. Pacilio Senior Vice
-President, Exelon Generation Company,
CNO), Exelon Nuclear
4300 Winfield Road
Warrenville
- POWER [[]]
- OF [[]]
- OR [[]]
- AND [[]]
- PLANT [[]]
MODIFICATIONS BASELINE INSPECTION REPORT 05000461/2012007 Dear Mr. Pacilio:
On July 12, 2012, the
NRC) completed an Evaluations
of Changes, Tests, or Experiments and Permanent Plant Modifications inspection at your Clinton Power Station. The enclosed inspection report documents the inspection results, which were discussed on July 12, 2012, with you and other members of your staff.
The inspection examined activities conducted under your license as they relate to safety and compliance
with the Commission's rules and regulations and with the conditions of your license. The inspectors reviewed selected procedures and records, observed activities, and interviewed personnel.
Based on the results of this inspection, no findings of significance were identified.
In accordance with
NRC's "Rules of Practice," a copy of this letter
and its enclosure will be available electronically for public inspection in the NRC Public Document Room or from the
Publicly Available Records System (PARS) component of NRC's Agencywide Documents Access and Management System (ADAMS), accessible from the NRC Web site at http://www.nrc.gov/reading
-rm/adams.html
(the Public Electronic Reading Room).
Sincerely, /RA/ Robert C. Daley, Chief
Engineering Branch 3
Division of Reactor Safety
Docket Nos. 50
-461 License Nos. NPF
-62 Enclosure:
Inspection Report 05000461/2012007
w/Attachment: Supplemental Information
cc w/encl:
Distribution via ListServŽ
DISTRIBUTIONSee next page
- DOCUMENT NAME:
R:\INSPRPTS\POWERS\CLI\CLIN 2012\CLI 2012
MMM.docx
-Publicly Available
Non-Sensitive To receive a copy of this document, indicate in the concurrence box "C" = Copy without attach/encl "E" = Copy with attach/encl "N" = No copy
- OFFICE [[]]
- RIII [[]]
- RIII [[]]
- RECORD [[]]
COPY
Letter to Mr. Michael Pacilio from Mr. Robert Daley dated August
1, 20 12.
- POWER [[]]
- OF [[]]
- OR [[]]
- AND [[]]
- PLANT [[]]
MODIFICATIONS BASELINE INSPECTION REPORT 05
000 461/201
RidsNrrDorlLpl3
-2 Resource
RidsNrrPMClinton Resource
RidsNrrDirsIrib Resource
Chuck Casto
Cynthia Pederson Steven Orth
- DRSIII [[]]
DRPIII Patricia Buckley