ML20083C914: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(StriderTol Bot insert)
 
(StriderTol Bot change)
 
Line 16: Line 16:


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:,
{{#Wiki_filter:L Jp-y M 9'2 5 - W H fnl97
L Jp- y M 9'2 5 - W H                             fnl97                           ,/'{}
,/'{}
DOCKETfr0 Exnia:T to USHPflCCOY EX. H i                               TROUTMANSANDERS
DOCKETfr0 Exnia:T to USHPflCCOY EX. H i
                                ^
TROUTMANSANDERS
                                . 7.J,.?? .".N.."..*..*o   , ^..! :..h.^g tmY -3 P Z 4 I NATIONSSANM PLAZA n.c-ine svarer ~ s . swer uw 4rca~ta. croaoi* suos 2:a   0FFICE.cf SECRETARY recepwoNe 4o ens ' "       00CKEIING i q- RVICE racsets som ses **
. 7.J,.??.".N.."..*..*o, ^..! :..h.^g tmY -3 P Z 4 I
        .&N LAMBER $wl BRAHCH OIRECT 404 885 3360 August 3, 1992 Mr. Donnie H. Grimsley, Director Division of Freedom of Information i           and Publications Services l
^
Office of Administration U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 Re:   Freedom Of Information Act Recuest
NATIONSSANM PLAZA 0FFICE.cf SECRETARY n.c-ine svarer ~ s. swer uw 4rca~ta. croaoi* suos 2:a 00CKEIING i q-RVICE recepwoNe 4o ens ' "
BRAHCH racsets som ses **
.&N LAMBER $wl OIRECT 404 885 3360 August 3, 1992 Mr. Donnie H. Grimsley, Director Division of Freedom of Information i
and Publications Services l
Office of Administration U.
S.
Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 Re:
Freedom Of Information Act Recuest


==Dear Mr. Grimsley:==
==Dear Mr. Grimsley:==
I hereby request, pursuant to the federal Freedom of Information Act ("FOIA"), 5 U.S.C.
S 552, as amended, and Nuclear j
Regulatory Commission ("NRC") regulations, 10 C.F.R. Part 9, copies of all " records," as that term is defined in 10 C.F.R.
9.13, constituting, or relating to, eight (8) specific documents which were provided by Georgia Power Company ("GPC") employees to j
the NRC Incident Investigation Team ("IIT") which investigated the March 20, 1990 site area emergency at Plant Vogtle.
The eight specific records I am requesting are identified on the September 14, 1990 " bibliography," provided by NRC to GPC and identifying documents collected by the IIT, as follows:
17.
Order to quarantine 1
31.
Maintenance Work Order (MWO) 19001576, 3/28/90 (D/G 1A) j 34.
List of Quarantined Equipment (Revised 3/29/90 Rev. 2) 155. Quarantined Equipment List, Rev. 4 - 4/2/90 l
178. D/G Temperature Switch Calibration Data Received from Licensee - 4/6/90 180. D/G (1A/1B) Start Logs l
210. Failures of Calcon Temperature & Pressure Sensors at Vogtle 1 & 2 336. Draft " Corrective Actions for Site Area Emergency" and Unit 1 Status Report from 3-18 to 4-1-90 (submitted by licensee) 9505230077 950417 PDR ADOCK 05000424 g
PDR


I hereby request, pursuant to the federal Freedom of Information Act ("FOIA"), 5 U.S.C. S 552, as amended, and Nuclear                                    j Regulatory Commission ("NRC") regulations, 10 C.F.R. Part 9,                                        i copies of all " records," as that term is defined in 10 C.F.R. $                                    l 9.13, constituting, or relating to, eight (8) specific documents                                    l which were provided by Georgia Power Company ("GPC") employees to                                    j the NRC Incident Investigation Team ("IIT") which investigated the March 20, 1990 site area emergency at Plant Vogtle.
g 4
The eight specific records I am requesting are identified on                                !
,t L'
the September 14, 1990 " bibliography," provided by NRC to GPC and                                  I identifying documents collected by the IIT, as follows:                                              l
: 17. Order to quarantine 1
: 31. Maintenance Work Order (MWO) 19001576, 3/28/90 (D/G 1A)                                j
: 34. List of Quarantined Equipment (Revised 3/29/90 Rev. 2) 155. Quarantined Equipment List, Rev. 4 - 4/2/90 l                178. D/G Temperature Switch Calibration Data Received from Licensee - 4/6/90 180. D/G (1A/1B) Start Logs l
210. Failures of Calcon Temperature & Pressure Sensors at Vogtle 1 & 2 336. Draft " Corrective Actions for Site Area Emergency" and Unit 1 Status Report from 3-18 to 4-1-90 (submitted by licensee) 9505230077 950417 PDR    ADOCK 05000424 g                   PDR
 
g                  ,
4
                                                              ,t L'
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ss~nas-oLA-2 Docket No._ k 12 5
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ss~nas-oLA-2 Docket No._ k 12 5
* 4                         10 Official Exh. No. 5" in the matter of_ Uen t le 4,;+s   n2 Staff
* 4 Official Exh. No. 5" 10 in the matter of_ Uen t le Staff 4,;+s n2 IETNTiflED s-Applican!
,                                IETNTiflED       s-Applican!       #          RECElVED       r Intervenor                 REJECTED Contg Otfr Contractor D ATE _ __ 09-/7-9s-Other                       Wit;:ess   & (o .,
RECElVED r
Repotter         1 2,'/t.4 3 A .*
Intervenor REJECTED Contg Otfr Contractor D ATE _ __ 09-/7-9s-Other Wit;:ess
& (o.,
Repotter 1 2,'/t.4 3 A.*


r.-
r.-
TROUTMAN SANDERS
TROUTMAN SANDERS
      .u.: .sa wa In addition to the above request for eight specific records, I request copies of all records, as defined above, evidencing or relating to the date and time when each of the eight specific     i records listed above were received by the NRC.
.u.:.sa wa In addition to the above request for eight specific records, I request copies of all records, as defined above, evidencing or relating to the date and time when each of the eight specific i
For your information, I understand that the requested records are or may be in the possession of the administrative assistant to the IIT, Ms. Cherie Siegel, or one of the IIT members: Al Chaffee, Rick Kendall, Bill Lazarus, Bill Jones, Mike Jones, Warren C. Lyon, Harvey Wyckoff, Paul E. Dietz, Garmon West or Gene Traeger.
records listed above were received by the NRC.
I am willing to pay the applicable charges for production of the requested records in accordance with 10 C.F.R. Part 9 up to a maximum amount of $500.00 and those charges in excess of $500.00 of which I am notified, and which I approve, in advance.
For your information, I understand that the requested records are or may be in the possession of the administrative assistant to the IIT, Ms. Cherie Siegel, or one of the IIT members: Al Chaffee, Rick Kendall, Bill Lazarus, Bill Jones, Mike Jones, Warren C.
Lyon, Harvey Wyckoff, Paul E. Dietz, Garmon West or Gene Traeger.
I am willing to pay the applicable charges for production of the requested records in accordance with 10 C.F.R.
Part 9 up to a maximum amount of $500.00 and those charges in excess of $500.00 of which I am notified, and which I approve, in advance.
If you have any questions concerning this FOIA request, please feel free to contact me.
If you have any questions concerning this FOIA request, please feel free to contact me.
Very ruly   urs John Lamberski 4
Very ruly urs John Lamberski 4
1


f                                                                                                                                                                                                 1 I
f 1
i
i v,..,n..~,.-...'..
                  .                                                                  v,..,n..~,.-...'..                         .. ..__.m..             . . , .                                ;
....__.m..
FOlA - p -3Srf                                                   i
FOlA - p -3Srf i
        /"*g                                                                                                                                       u seO~si n ,.                                 t
/"*g t
      !      e          -
u seO~si n,.
RESPONSE TO FREEDOM OF                                         .ki w'                 I l e=='
RESPONSE TO FREEDOM OF
i,                                                     INFORMATION ACT (FOIA) REQUEST                                     o*15 SEP 9 - 1992 s 's        -
.ki w' I l e=='
oOCoT ~uMaimisi mme,
e i,
        ~~'Wa- Nn 2d sN                               .
INFORMATION ACT (FOIA) REQUEST o*15 s 's SEP 9 - 1992 oOCoT ~uMaimisi mme,
V PdRT 3.-AGENCY RECORDS RELEASED OR NOT LOCATED iSee enecaea conesi No agency records subject to the request have been located.
~~'Wa-Nn 2d sN V
PdRT 3.-AGENCY RECORDS RELEASED OR NOT LOCATED iSee enecaea conesi No agency records subject to the request have been located.
No additional agency records subject to the request have been located.
No additional agency records subject to the request have been located.
Requested records are available through another pubhc distribution program. See Comments section.
Requested records are available through another pubhc distribution program. See Comments section.
Agency records subject to the request that are identified in Apper@ utes)                   M          are already available for pubhc inspection and copying at tne
M are already available for pubhc inspection and copying at tne Agency records subject to the request that are identified in Apper@ utes)
[     NRC Pubhc Document Room,2120 L Street. N W.. Washmgton. DC.
[
are being made avaitable for pubhc mspection and copymg Agency records subject to tre request that are identified in Appendiatesi at the NRC Pubhc Document Room. 2120 L Street. N W., Washington, DC. 6n a folder under this FOI A number.
NRC Pubhc Document Room,2120 L Street. N W.. Washmgton. DC.
Agency records subject to tre request that are identified in Appendiatesi are being made avaitable for pubhc mspection and copymg at the NRC Pubhc Document Room. 2120 L Street. N W., Washington, DC. 6n a folder under this FOI A number.
The nonproprietary version of the proposal (s) that you agreed to accept m a telephone conversation with a member of my staff is now bemg made availaole for pubhc mspection and copymg at the N RC Public Document Room 2120 L Street, N.W., Washmgton, OC,in a folder under this FOI A number.
The nonproprietary version of the proposal (s) that you agreed to accept m a telephone conversation with a member of my staff is now bemg made availaole for pubhc mspection and copymg at the N RC Public Document Room 2120 L Street, N.W., Washmgton, OC,in a folder under this FOI A number.
Agency records subject to the request that are identified in Appendix (es)                       may be inspected and copied at the N RC Local Public Document Room identified in the Comments esction.
Agency records subject to the request that are identified in Appendix (es) may be inspected and copied at the N RC Local Public Document Room identified in the Comments esction.
E nclosed is mformation on how you may obtam access to and the charges for copymg records located et the NRC Public Document Room,2120 L Street, N W . Washmoton, DC.
E nclosed is mformation on how you may obtam access to and the charges for copymg records located et the NRC Public Document Room,2120 L Street, N W. Washmoton, DC.
Agency records subiect to the request are enclosed.
Agency records subiect to the request are enclosed.
Records subject to the request have been referred to another Federal agencylies) for review and direct response to you.                                                         i f
Records subject to the request have been referred to another Federal agencylies) for review and direct response to you.
Fees You will be billed by the NRC for fees totaling 5 l
i f
You will receive a refund from the NRC in the amount of 5                                                                                                                 l l
Fees You will be billed by the NRC for fees totaling 5 You will receive a refund from the NRC in the amount of 5 In view of N R C*s response to this request, no further action is bemg taken on appeal letter dated
In view of N R C*s response to this request, no further action is bemg taken on appeal letter dated                               , No.
, No.
i PART 11. A-INFORMATION WITHHELD FROM PUBLIC DISCLOSURE Certain information in the requested records is being withheld from public disclosure pursuant to the euomptions described in and for the reenons stated in Part 11, B, C, and D. Any rolessed portions of the documents for which only part of the record is being withheld are beme made evellable for public inspection and copying in the NRC Pubelc Document Room,2120 L Street, N.W., Washington, DC in a folder under th6s FOIA number, COMMENTS                                                                                                                                                     ,
i PART 11. A-INFORMATION WITHHELD FROM PUBLIC DISCLOSURE Certain information in the requested records is being withheld from public disclosure pursuant to the euomptions described in and for the reenons stated in Part 11, B, C, and D. Any rolessed portions of the documents for which only part of the record is being withheld are beme made evellable for public inspection and copying in the NRC Pubelc Document Room,2120 L Street, N.W., Washington, DC in a folder under th6s FOIA number, COMMENTS g i := -;'
g i := -;'                                                             Mw A                                                                                                         '
Mw A i
1 i
1 51G E. DIR ECTOR. Olvisa F REEDOM OF INFORMATION AND PUBLICATIONS SERvlCES A
1 51G           E. DIR ECTOR. Olvisa                     F REEDOM OF INFORMATION AND PUBLICATIONS SERvlCES A     -
p 3..
p                                                                                         3..
.T
              .T                                                                                         - *s 4.
- *s 4.
V=                                                                                           a., O                                                                   .
V=
                      ' a'                                                                               .e..  ;                      $,
a., O
                                                                                                                  *.v.            .,[.                                   * '' r I
.e..
* s
' a'
.,[.
* '' r I *
{[f
{[f
                                                                                                                                              ,                  , . , ,e NAC FORM 464 IPart il (t.gt)
*.v.
(
s
1 l
,.,,e NAC FORM 464 IPart il (t.gt)


Ret   FOIA-92-388 APPENDIX A RECORDS MAINTAINED AMONG PDR FILES G/
Ret FOIA-92-388 APPENDIX A RECORDS MAINTAINED AMONG PDR FILES G/
NUMBER QAIR                     DESCRIPTION
NUMBER QAIR DESCRIPTION 1.
: 1. 3/28/90       Order to quarantine (#17) (2 pages)
3/28/90 Order to quarantine (#17) (2 pages) 2.
: 2. 3/28/90       Maintenance Work Order (MWO) 19001576
3/28/90 Maintenance Work Order (MWO) 19001576
(#31) (4 pages)
(#31) (4 pages) 3.
: 3. 3/29/90       Quarantined Equipment List, Rev. 2 (#34)
3/29/90 Quarantined Equipment List, Rev. 2 (#34)
(2 pages)
(2 pages) 4.
: 4. 4/2/90         Quarantined Equipment List, Rev. 4
4/2/90 Quarantined Equipment List, Rev. 4
(#155) (1 page)
(#155) (1 page) 5.
: 5. Undated       D/G Temperature Switch Calibration Data
Undated D/G Temperature Switch Calibration Data
(#178) (2 pages)
(#178) (2 pages) 6.
: 6. Undated       DG (1A/1B) Start Logs (#180) (6 pages)
Undated DG (1A/1B) Start Logs (#180) (6 pages) 7.
: 7. Undated       Failures of Calcon Temperature &     .
Undated Failures of Calcon Temperature &
Pressure Sensors at Vogtla Units 1 & 2
Pressure Sensors at Vogtla Units 1 & 2
(#210) (3 pages)
(#210) (3 pages) 8.
: 8. Undated       Draft Corrective Actions for Site Area Emergency with attached Unit 1 status from 3/18 - 4/1/90 (#336) (10 pages)
Undated Draft Corrective Actions for Site Area Emergency with attached Unit 1 status from 3/18 - 4/1/90 (#336) (10 pages)


[
[
C 5 -l }- 9 ^-
C 5 -l }- 9 ^-
(<_.
(<_.
12:40 p.m.         3/28/90 I ordered Jiany Cash to quarantine the following:
12:40 p.m.
3/28/90 I ordered Jiany Cash to quarantine the following:
Trip disk pack for Unit 1 ERF that was collected during, immediately prior to, and-immediately following the event.
Trip disk pack for Unit 1 ERF that was collected during, immediately prior to, and-immediately following the event.
                                                                -=         -
-=
Jimmy will check if any proteus data exist. Hisunderstandingisthath the data have been overwritten.       If these data exist, they are also quarantined.
Jimmy will check if any proteus data exist. Hisunderstandingisthath the data have been overwritten.
If these data exist, they are also quarantined.
Warren L' yon s
Warren L' yon s
                                      ,' 9;f /f/
&$h
c>wn         &$h
,' 9;f /f/
                        -y       . < , - n.c                     &- f du.- u                   //.s, j       h           A ?L.
c>wn
&- f
-y
. <, - n.c du.- u
//.s, j h A ?L.
l
l


e f
e daA' zr : =
daA' zr : =   _?           A$
_? = f a n k A $
                    =fank 4   D pdf           Um ar An           sind Ap, MMSf               M, d&-Q
f 4 D pdf Um ar An sind Ap, MMSf M, d&-Q
  $1 A" W-M       ? 4f      e u ~-,45e'?
$1 A" W-M
a                      M 6 &.
? 4fe u
e,               ~s
~-
  /"             '
a6 &.
l
,45e'?
                      $ka l
M e,
l l
~s
1
/"
$ka


                                                      %*o COVER SHEET l
%*o COVER SHEET l
M'403     19001576           DATE: 03/28/90 SYSTEM:                                     2403 --     FORIMAN:     Mwo OVIAGE REQUIRED:                                                       CLEARANCE:
M'403 19001576 DATE: 03/28/90 SYSTEM:
YES                   No         X PARTS REQUIRED:                       NO I
2403 --
o f- U- ?C 5 TATJS i __6 0 C     RCN1 JCOP PRIORITY CODE:           1                     4 PRIORITY               MODE                   PIANT ~ -             STATUS     RESTRAINT RESTR CONTROL FIELD:             *
FORIMAN:
* g                                              YA S             C -4   S q           g, gy
Mwo OVIAGE REQUIRED:
                                                                                                                                      .;. x ,
CLEARANCE:
STATUS                                                                                                 p -wwgg -tc COMMENTS                               '          '
YES No X
G - - -
PARTS REQUIRED:
D   u. .u               m
NO o f-U- ?C I
          ^-
5 TATJS i
__6 0 C RCN1 JCOP PRIORITY CODE:
1 4
PRIORITY MODE PIANT ~ -
STATUS RESTRAINT RESTR CONTROL FIELD:
YA S C
-4 S q g, gy g
.;. x,
STATUS p -wwgg -tc COMMENTS G - - -
D
: u..u m
^-
6W 89
6W 89
* h 95 ' M teme         e9 .ess -                   6 m.
* h 95 ' M teme e9.ess -
eMG* 4.
6 m.
eMG*
4.
3
3


4
4
              *
*
* COPY *
* COPY *
* 0 "?Y *
* 0 "?Y *
Line 159: Line 199:
* CCPY ** C;7.
* CCPY ** C;7.
NUCLEAR PLAS! MAINTENANCE WORK ORDER (1 CF 3)
NUCLEAR PLAS! MAINTENANCE WORK ORDER (1 CF 3)
: 1. CONTROL NO. 19001576 00 2.DATE 03/28/90                                                           3. UNIT 1               4. SYSTEM LIST 5.MPI/ TAG NO. LIST SA. REPAIR TAG MPL/ TAG (S) ASSOCIATED WITH SPECIAL INDICATORS                                                                             4*vt
: 1. CONTROL NO. 19001576 00 2.DATE 03/28/90
: 6. WORK PRO 5/ DIESEL   START CONDITIONS.GENERATOR 1A TRIPPED TWICE FOLLOWING 'IVO ACTJAL IDSS OF O REQ.                                                           THE TRIPS ACCURRED AFTER APPROXIMATELY 80 SECONDS AND 70 SECONDS OF OPERATION.
: 3. UNIT 1
: 4. SYSTEM LIST 5.MPI/ TAG NO. LIST SA. REPAIR TAG MPL/ TAG (S) ASSOCIATED WITH SPECIAL INDICATORS 4*vt
: 6. PRO 5/ DIESEL GENERATOR 1A TRIPPED TWICE FOLLOWING 'IVO ACTJAL IDSS OF O WORK START CONDITIONS.
THE TRIPS ACCURRED AFTER APPROXIMATELY 80 SECONDS REQ.
AND 70 SECONDS OF OPERATION.
e.NPRDe*
e.NPRDe*
C0HT.       __
C0HT.
N
N
: 7. INITIATOR KEN STOKZS                                                     8.SUPRV JP REDDING                                 IDC LIST 9.NWO 12.DCR N CIASS S EQP CLASS LIST 10. UNIT STA'f ,,, ,, _ ,, _ ,,                                                                     11.FIM PR07BCT N 13.HCR/DR H                                         14. TYPE MAI ET P                    15.DURATICH
: 7. INITIATOR KEN STOKZS 8.SUPRV JP REDDING IDC LIST 9.NWO CIASS S EQP CLASS LIST 10. UNIT STA'f,,,,, _,, _,,
: 16. CRAFT MICH(EST/
ET P 11.FIM PR07BCT N 12.DCR N 13.HCR/DR H
CREW                    0                AC"fi ELEC(EST/ACT)'I!EST/ACT)                                                 CONT (EST/ACT) HP/0T(EST71"E.
: 14. TYPE MAI 15.DURATICH
0                                 6                                 0 HRS.                                                                                                                                                         0 EXP.                    0                                0
: 16. CRAFT MICH(EST/ AC"fi ELEC(EST/ACT)'I!EST/ACT)
                                                                                                                                #                                                    _~
CONT (EST/ACT) HP/0T(EST71"E.
                                                                                                      -0'                                  ON. ~~~~   -
CREW 0
                                                                                        ~
0 6
SCKED EN                                                                                 *
0 0
                                                                                                    ~
HRS.
                                                                                                                                                      ~
ON. ~~~~
                                                                                        ,,,,,,,                                                                  %  .,,,f
_~
            =JT 19.QC HOLD PTS QC REVIEWED SY ~ 20. PROC ' ,,,_/,,,,f,,,, 21. PRI 14 e,Etr,-                                e w aan-23.WORX
EXP.
* 33.3.40         _ - -
0 0
INST. .                                       -
-0' SCKED EN
SEE CONTINUATION SHEET CCHT.      COOPER ENERGY TO PERFORM WORK UNDER P.0 $6002124.
~
Y     _
~
            ------ ----- 2 4 . I N ITI ATE REVI EW ------------                                                                     25.8PEC REV REQ H OPS         DATE                                                      DATE             j HP          DATE ,,,f           ,,,ff [ MNT
~
                                      ,,,j ,,,,       ENG ,__,, DATE __f,,,,,,,f[                     j S I C .= = = = 2 6.MWO RELEAS E-- FOR WO 21 AT        _ - . . -
.,,,f
=JT QC REVIEWED SY ~ 20. PROC '
e,Etr,-
e w aan-19.QC HOLD PTS
,,,_/,,,,f,,,, 21. PRI 14 33.3.40 23.WORX
* INST..
SEE CONTINUATION SHEET COOPER ENERGY TO PERFORM WORK UNDER P.0 $6002124.
CCHT.
Y
------ ----- 2 4. I N ITI ATE REVI EW ------------
25.8PEC REV REQ H OPS DATE DATE,,,f,,,f [ MNT DATE j
,,,j,,,, f ENG,__,, DATE __f,,,,,,,f[S I C.= = = = 2 6.MWO RELEAS E FOR WO HP j
DATE _ /,,,/.,
DATE _ /,,,/.,
wcu                                                 _ _ . . . _ . _ .
21 AT wcu PERTRMED ~
                                                                        ~
_, i__
PERTRMED ~                                                _ , i__
,,,,,,,,,,[
                                                                                                                                                ,,,,,,,,,,[                     ,,,, , [, ,'7,~
,,,,, [,,'7,~
                      ,                                                                                                            .              . . =         .                  . . _ . . . . .
~
N HIST SUN '                                                                                                                                                                       ~
.. =
28.HTRL RIQD                                                                                                                                                                         ~
N HIST SUN '
: 29. PERSON PERFORMINo woRx(NAME)                                                   DATE 30.nAIFITWKRCE roRIMAN                                                 DAff"
~
                                                                                                                                                                      ,,,,jd 31.YRDY27Y5K 7tKFORxtD sY                                                                                    - - -
28.HTRL RIQD
~
: 29. PERSON PERFORMINo woRx(NAME)
DATE 30.nAIFITWKRCE roRIMAN DAff" 31.YRDY27Y5K 7tKFORxtD sY
,,,,jd 32.NETHOD OF F.T.
DAT:
DAT:
32.NETHOD OF F.T.                                                                                __
: 33. PROCEDURE f -
: 33. PROCEDURE f -                                                             34.FERTOMED BY
34.FERTOMED BY 35.DATE,,,,j,,,) ~
* 35.DATE             ,,,,j,,,) ~
34.PROYES OPERABILITY ~ 39.!P UN8AT.COM. ACTION 37.METH00 USED TO PRON 30.8ATISTY./UNSAT18FY
37.METH00 USED TO PRON 34.PROYES OPERABILITY ~ 39.!P UN8AT .COM. ACTION 30.8ATISTY./UNSAT18FY                                                                                                                     _ _ _ __
: 40. UNIT STATUS AT TIHt*0P FA! LURE '
41.TYPt FAlt.
41.TYPt FAlt.
: 40. UNIT STATUS AT TIHt*0P FA! LURE '                                                                                                43. MODE OF FAIL 43.CAUs2 or FAILURE                                                                         44.DE'ttCT BY
: 43. MODE OF FAIL 43.CAUs2 or FAILURE 44.DE'ttCT BY (l.tFFECT CH 8V8 "~~
                                                                                                                                      ~~
~~
                                                                                                                                      "~      (l.tFFECT CH 8V8 "~~~
4 6.27P ON PLANT ~ ~ II.0PER. ACCEPT ST a *-477M90 STAT 40 48
4       6.27P ON PLANT ~ ~ II.0PER. ACCEPT lo.NEW MWO 53.0808 APPROVAL
"~
                                                                                                                      "" ~ '"" ST      49.CORA a *-477M90
~
                                                                                                                                            -****            ACT. OA TE STAT,
"" ~ '"" 49.CORA ACT. TE ~,,"fD,,,,
                                                                                                                                                                                    ~,,"fD,,,,40 48 S3.8PEC MV COMP
lo.NEW MWO OA 53.0808 APPROVAL DATE,,,j j S3.8PEC MV COMP DATE
_        DATE ,,,j j DATE             /,,,/,,,, 54.MIET.f                                               BKT5 ,,,,j.,/...,
/,,,/,,,, 54.MIET.f BKT5,,,,j.,/...,
SS.CIAst OUT APPROVAL BY QC
SS.CIAst OUT APPROVAL BY QC


a
a
          ** copy ** 7:TY ** COPY ** CCPY ** COPY ** CCT- ==C0py
** copy ** 7:TY ** COPY ** CCPY ** COPY ** CCT-
              ,                                                                  e. :7   ,, ecpy .. e;p NUCLEAR PLANT MAINTENANCE WORK CRDER (CONTINUII,e                                         (2 0F 3)
 
CONTROL No. 19001576 00 MPL/ TAC No.         SYSTEM EQP CLS           DESCRUPTION                 L::CCATION 12403G4001           2403 015     DIESEL GENERA!TDR                   1DCGB1-12403PSDC2           2403 11J     DG 1A ENGINE C:2lTRL PNL             10cGB1
==C0py e.
                                                                        ~," Ar ,
:7
'I
,, ecpy.. e;p NUCLEAR PLANT MAINTENANCE WORK CRDER (CONTINUII,e (2 0F 3)
                                                                              .                a.
CONTROL No. 19001576 00 MPL/ TAC No.
SYSTEM EQP CLS DESCRUPTION L::CCATION 12403G4001 2403 015 DIESEL GENERA!TDR 1DCGB1-12403PSDC2 2403 11J DG 1A ENGINE C:2lTRL PNL 10cGB1
~," Ar,
'I a.
l
l


1 y: ;y n w ?                                                               - - -- ' -                                : e'                      i v
y: ;y n w ?
                                  ** COPY **
: e i
v
** COPY **
NUCLfAR P:.J.:;T MAINTENANCE WORK ORDER::PY *
NUCLfAR P:.J.:;T MAINTENANCE WORK ORDER::PY *
* C PY * *CCTY                                                             COPY  ** ::* T* *.COPY *
* C PY *
* CC (CONTINUED)
* COPY *
* COPY *
* CC CCTY ** :: T *.
(CONTINUED)
(3 CT 3)
(3 CT 3)
CONTROL No. 19001576 00 WORK INSTR.crIONS:
CONTROL No. 19001576 00 WORK INSTR.crIONS: PERFORM ENGINE 14GIC TESTING PER PROCIDURE 27563-C, C00PER ENERGY SERVICES PERSONNEL WILL BE PERFORMI REV 2.
PERFORM ENGINE 14GIC TESTING PER PROCIDURE 27563-C,                                                   REV 2.
ABLE PROTIONS OF THE PROCEDURE WITH ASSISTANCE FROM O FIRSONNEL, AS REQUIRED.
C00PER ENERGY SERVICES PERSONNEL WILL BE PERFORMI ABLE FIRSONNEL,PROTIONS             OF THE PROCEDURE WITH ASSISTANCE FROM O AS REQUIRED.
PROCEDURE NEED NOT BE RETESTED.THE ELECTRICAL PORTI ADDITIONAL INSTRUNENTATION MAY BE CONNECTED BY TEST PERSONNEL TO AID IN TROUBL ANY INSTRUMENTATION CONNECTED OR Ath.USTMENTS MADE S 7
PROCEDURE NEED NOT BE RETESTED.THE                                       ADDITIONAL INSTRUNENTATION ELECTRICAL PORTI MAY BE CONNECTED BY TEST7PERSONNEL TO AID IN TROUBL ANY   INSTRUMENTATION CONNECTED OR Ath.USTMENTS MADE S DOCUMENTED COMPLETELY ON THIS MWO.
DOCUMENTED COMPLETELY ON THIS MWO.
ENCOUNTERED WHILE PERFORMING THIS TEST. DOCUMENT ANY ITEP 1:
ENCOUNTERED WHILE PERFORMING THIS TEST. DOCUMENT ANY ITEP 1:
FOI24 WING THE IAGIC TEST THE ENGINE WILL BE STARTED IN THE LINES:   it. *EMERGENCY
FOI24 WING THE IAGIC TEST THE ENGINE WILL BE STARTED IN THE EMERGENCY MODE AND A LEAX TEST PERFORMED ON TH LINES: it. * '''.*
                                                                              ''' .*                           MODE AND A LEAX TEST PERFORMED ON TH E-ICA 3-
E-ICA
* TRIP
* TRIP I4N PRESSURE 2 8E OIL 3-C-
* I4N
E-16A - TRIP HIGH TEMPERATURE JACRET MATER 2-j C-
* PRESSURE 2 8E OIL C-           *          *    *                      *
{
* E-16A2- - TRIP
I-68
* HIGH
- TRIP HICH PRESSURE CRANKCASE E-92
* TEMPERATURE         *
- TRIP I4W PRESSURE TURSO OIL E TRIP IAN PRE 85URE JACKET NATER E-23H - TRIP HICH VIBRATION E-19
* JACRET MATER j
- TRIP MIGH TEMPERATURE ENGINE IEARINCS E 18
C-         *          *                        *                  *
- TRIP HIGH TEMPERATURE WBE CIL.
* I-68                                                                                                                             {
TEST FOR LEARAGE SY DISCONNECTING ttit!NC AT CONTR BULIQlEAD AND CONNEC'?!NC PNEUMATIC SUBI*.E TESTER.
E-92  - TRIP HICH PRESSURE CRANKCASE
CBSERVE TESTER FOR AIR F14W WHEN LINE IS PREsf*!RIZED.
                                                                - TRIP I4W PRESSURE TURSO OIL E TRIP IAN PRE 85URE JACKET NATER E-23H E-19
RESTORE TUSING CONNECTION AT BU1.$NEAD AND CONIINUE WITH NEXT INSTRUMENT LINE.
                                                                - TRIP HICH VIBRATION E 18 - TRIP MIGH TEMPERATURE ENGINE IEARINCS
IIEP 92 NCRMAL START
                                                                - TRIP HIGH TEMPERATURE WBE CIL.
-IRIP SY HI-TEMP WSE O!L IIEP $3 LosP START (JUMPER IN CEN CONTPOL PANEL 211 70 2132
TEST FOR LEARAGE SY DISCONNECTING ttit!NC AT CONTR BULIQlEAD AND CONNEC'?!NC PNEUMATIC SUBI*.E                                   .                      TESTER.
-IRIP SY HIGH VI& RATION ItEP #4 NORMAL START
CBSERVE TESTER FOR AIR F14W WHEN LINE IS PREsf*!RIZED.                                                   RESTORE TUSING INSTRUMENT      CONNECTION LINE.                            AT BU1.$NEAD AND CONIINUE WITH NEXT IIEP 92 NCRMAL START
-TRIP BY H!cH PRESS CRANECASE ITEP $5 SI START (JUMPER IN CEN. CONTROL PANEL 20
                                                        -IRIP SY HI-TEMP WSE O!L IIEP $3 LosP START (JUMPER IN CEN CONTPOL
-TRIP SY 2 0F 3 L.O. PRES 8URE
                                                      -IRIP SY HIGH VI& RATION                                                                           211 70 PANEL 2132 ItEP #4 NORMAL START
~
                                                      -TRIP BY H!cH PRESS CRANECASE ITEP
NOTE fME AREA 0F TESTING SHALL RE R0 PED AND ENTRANCE EastNTIAL PERSONNEL AS OtTERM!NED BY C00PF.R MPRE8ENTA AND GPC EN0!NEERING.
                                                      -TRIP SY $5 2 0F       SI3 START L.O. PRES 8URE             (JUMPER IN CEN. CONTROL PANEL 20
8PC ENGINEERING SHALL DE PRt3ENT FOR ALL TESTING REPRESENTATIVE PRESENT AS REQUIRED.
                                                      ~
*/p.
NOTE fME AREA 0F TESTING SHALL RE R0 PED AND ENTRANCE
'1lWlU l
,                                                    EastNTIAL AND    GPC EN0!NEERING. PERSONNEL AS OtTERM!NED BY C00PF.R MPRE8ENTA 8PC ENGINEERING SHALL DE PRt3ENT FOR ALL TESTING REPRESENTATIVE PRESENT AS REQUIRED.
                                                                                                                                              */p.
                                                                                                                                                      '1lWlU                             '
l


Page 1 of 2 QUARANTINED EQUIP 9ENT LIST REY. 2 NA J7140 ATTENTION oI-3'l-9o At all times, the licensee is responsible for quarantined equipment and can take ar. tion involving this equipment it deems necessary to:
Page 1 of 2 QUARANTINED EQUIP 9ENT LIST REY. 2 NA 7140 J
ATTENTION oI-3'l-9o At all times, the licensee is responsible for quarantined equipment and can take ar. tion involving this equipment it deems necessary to:
Achieve or maintain safe plant conditions.
Achieve or maintain safe plant conditions.
              - ' Prevent further equipment degradation, or Test or inspect, as required by the plant's Technical Specifications.
- ' Prevent further equipment degradation, or Test or inspect, as required by the plant's Technical Specifications.
(
To the maximum degree possible, these actions should be coordinated with the i
l              To the maximum degree possible, these actions should be coordinated with the                               i l
l Team Leader in advance, or notification made as soon as possible.
Team Leader in advance, or notification made as soon as possible.                                           I Effective Time: 241000 MAR 90 The Licensee is maintaining the following Items Quarantined:
I Effective Time: 241000 MAR 90 The Licensee is maintaining the following Items Quarantined:
1.
1.
POL Truck (A11ouable to use for normal deliveries) 2.
POL Truck (A11ouable to use for normal deliveries) 2.
230 KV Insulator to Reserve Auxiliary Transformer IA (Broken on 20 MAR 90)
230 KV Insulator to Reserve Auxiliary Transformer IA (Broken on 20 MAR 90) 3.
: 3.         All replaced CALCON Switches for IA 818 Olesel Generators
All replaced CALCON Switches for IA 818 Olesel Generators 4.
: 4.         ERF recorded Tri by J. P. Cash.) p Package - Unit 1 (NOTE: Database memory tape meintained The testing and          following arerestrictions agree to: concerning         Of esel generator troubleshootirig, repair, (This appites to DG A 4 DG B except as noted) 1.
ERF recorded Tri by J. P. Cash.) p Package - Unit 1 (NOTE: Database memory tape meintained The following restrictions concerning Of esel generator troubleshootirig, repair, and testing are agree to:
Any     componentthe to perfoming          replacements work.          will be concurred with by the Team Leader prior released by the Tome Leader.
(This appites to DG A 4 DG B except as noted) 1.
All replaced components vill be retained until
Any component replacements will be concurred with by the Team Leader prior to perfoming the work.
: 2.         The followin             test procedures will be reviewed by t w team prior to perfomance: g
All replaced components vill be retained until released by the Tome Leader.
: a. 1B UV Test
2.
: b. IA UV Test (#1)
The followin test procedures will be reviewed by t w team prior to perfomance: g a.
: c. 1A UV Test (#2) 3.
1B UV Test b.
The following tests will be announced to the team leader, or a designated representative. 4 hours prior to initiation.                   It will not be performed untti approved by the Team Leader.
IA UV Test (#1) c.
: a. It Sequencer Test
1A UV Test (#2) 3.
: b. IB UV Test
The following tests will be announced to the team leader, or a designated representative. 4 hours prior to initiation.
: c. IA UV Test (#1)
It will not be performed untti approved by the Team Leader.
: d. 1A UV Test (#2)
a.
  --            .,-r--                       ,c-     =                                   -
It Sequencer Test b.
IB UV Test c.
IA UV Test (#1) d.
1A UV Test (#2)
.,-r--
,c-
=


Page 2 of 2 QUARANTINED EQUIP 9ENT LIST The following personnel will not take vacation untti approved by the Team Leader (normal off days are not restricted):
Page 2 of 2 QUARANTINED EQUIP 9ENT LIST The following personnel will not take vacation untti approved by the Team Leader (normal off days are not restricted):
: a. All Operations Department Management
All Operations Department Management a.
: b. All   operators   (Itcensed and non-Itcensed) in the C,arations Department who were on duty during the 20 Mar 90 event
b.
: c. All Event critique Team members SUBMITTED BY:
All operators (Itcensed and non-Itcensed) in the C,arations Department who were on duty during the 20 Mar 90 event c.
Mapser fixgr DATE:   77/d 29 /990 EXTENSION:   3759     BEEPER: /JB I
All Event critique Team members SUBMITTED BY:
0
Mapser fixgr DATE:
77/d 29 /990 EXTENSION:
3759 BEEPER: /JB 0


Cb 5-/Sf~9' QUARANTINED EQUIPMENT LIST Revision 4, Dated April 2, 1990 ATTENTION At all times, the licensee is responsible for quarantined equipment and can take action involving this equipment it deems necessary to:
Cb 5-/Sf~9' QUARANTINED EQUIPMENT LIST Revision 4, Dated April 2, 1990 ATTENTION At all times, the licensee is responsible for quarantined equipment and can take action involving this equipment it deems necessary to:
Achieve or maintain safe plant conditions, Prevent further equipment degradation, or Test or inspect, as required by the piant's Technical Specifications.
Achieve or maintain safe plant conditions, Prevent further equipment degradation, or Test or inspect, as required by the piant's Technical Specifications.
To the ma ximum degree possible, these actions should be coordinated with the Team Leader in advance, or notification made as soon as possible.
To the ma ximum degree possible, these actions should be coordinated with the Team Leader in advance, or notification made as soon as possible.
Except for the above, no licensee action is authorized on quarantined equipment without IIT team approval. The IIT team will concur in the licensee's action plan for each trouble shooting quarantine item.               '
Except for the above, no licensee action is authorized on quarantined equipment without IIT team approval.
The IIT team will concur in the licensee's action plan for each trouble shooting quarantine item.
Upon approval the licensee will implement this plant and ensure the IIT team leader or designee is informed as agreed to in each action' plan.
Upon approval the licensee will implement this plant and ensure the IIT team leader or designee is informed as agreed to in each action' plan.
The licensee is maintaining the following items Quarantined:
The licensee is maintaining the following items Quarantined:
: 1. All suspect components identified after initiation of the event associated with the starting or tripping of the 1A and 18 D/G.           ;
1.
I I
All suspect components identified after initiation of the event associated with the starting or tripping of the 1A and 18 D/G.
l IIT TEAM LEADER                 4-2.-10 Al Cha'ffee     Date SUBMITTED BY H. L. Beacher     Date EXTENSION 3769     BEEPER 138 4
I IIT TEAM LEADER 4-2.-10 Al Cha'ffee Date SUBMITTED BY H. L. Beacher Date EXTENSION 3769 BEEPER 138 4
4
4


j     . .
7 j
7                  -
f.
f.
ITSH19153 LUBE OIL HIGH TEMPERATURE SWITCH DG1B Prior calibration was performed on 3/14/90. At that time the switch was found out of tolerance with an as found of 300 'F to trip and 199 'F to reset. It was                     l calibrated ar d returned to semcc with a trip of 199 ;? and a reset of 191 'F. It                           ,
ITSH19153 LUBE OIL HIGH TEMPERATURE SWITCH DG1B Prior calibration was performed on 3/14/90.
was removec from service on 3/23/90 as the suspectec, cause of DG1B tri                                   I switch , calibration was checked and would not calibrate within tolerance.                   It wasp. The l placed in storage on 3/23/90.                                                                               I SWITCH TWO This switch was placed in service on 3/23/90 with a trip of 203.4 'F and a reset of 198.0 'F. On 3/27/90 it was removed from service and it's calib checked. As found was 203.5 'F to trip ar d 199.5 degrees to reset. However,it ration            was found to be venting continuously anc, suasequently replaced. The old switch was                             l placed in storage on 3/27/90.                                                                             !
At that time the switch was found out of tolerance with an as found of 300 'F to trip and 199 'F to reset. It was calibrated ar d returned to semcc with a trip of 199 ;? and a reset of 191 'F. It was removec from service on 3/23/90 as the suspectec, cause of DG1B tri switch, calibration was checked and would not calibrate within tolerance. p. The It was placed in storage on 3/23/90.
l 1THS19146                                                   !
SWITCH TWO This switch was placed in service on 3/23/90 with a trip of 203.4 'F and a reset of 198.0 'F.
LUBE OIL HIGH TEMPERATURE SWITCH                                               l DGIA                                                     l Prior calibration was performed on 3/3/90. At that time it was found out of                       l tolerance with a trip point of 211.0 *;? and a reset of 203.1 'F The switch was                           1 I calibrated and returned to service wita a trip point of 200.2 'F and a reset of 193                       i degrees                                                                                                   1 On 3/30/90 the switch was removed for calibration ar.d found out of tolerance                     i Tne switch also o,erated           l with   a trip sluggishly.      $ointt    of was  190.4 'F replaced  and with a a reset new    of 188.0 switch      'F.
On 3/27/90 it was removed from service and it's calib checked. As found was 203.5 'F to trip ar d 199.5 degrees to reset. However, ration it was found to be venting continuously anc, suasequently replaced. The old switch was placed in storage on 3/27/90.
calibrated  to trip point of 201.27 'F         '
1THS19146 LUBE OIL HIGH TEMPERATURE SWITCH l
and a reset of 196.20 'F.             The new   switch was returned     to service. The original         j switch is in storage.                                                                                       -
DGIA Prior calibration was performed on 3/3/90. At that time it was found out of tolerance with a trip point of 211.0 *;? and a reset of 203.1 'F The switch was I
ITSH19117                                                   l JACKET WATER HEATER OUT HIGH TEMPERATURE SWITCH                                                   l DG1B                                                     !
calibrated and returned to service wita a trip point of 200.2 'F and a reset of 193 degrees On 3/30/90 the switch was removed for calibration ar.d found out of tolerance i
Prior calibration on 3/14/90 was within tolerance with a trip point pf 201 'F                     '
Tne switch also o,erated with a trip $oint of 190.4 'F and a reset of 188.0 'F. d to trip point of 201.27 'F sluggishly.
and a reset of 193 'F.
t was replaced with a new switch calibrate and a reset of 196.20 'F. The new switch was returned to service. The original j
On 3/26/90 switc h was found out of tolerance with a trip point of 190.6 and a reset of 182.4. Further investigation determined a small leak. A new switch also                         ,
switch is in storage.
failed leak test. A third switc3 calibrated correctly with a trip noint pf 200.67                         <
ITSH19117 JACKET WATER HEATER OUT HIGH TEMPERATURE SWITCH DG1B Prior calibration on 3/14/90 was within tolerance with a trip point pf 201 'F and a reset of 193 'F. h was found out of tolerance with a trip point of 190.6 and a On 3/26/90 switc reset of 182.4. Further investigation determined a small leak. A new switch also failed leak test. A third switc3 calibrated correctly with a trip noint pf 200.67 degrees and a reset of 196.93 'F and was returned to service. The o'ld switches are i
degrees and a reset of 196.93 'F and was returned to service. The o'ld switches are                       i in storage.
in storage.
1TSH19119                                                   l JACKET HEATER OUT HIGH TEMPERATURE SWITCH 1
1TSH19119 JACKET HEATER OUT HIGH TEMPERATURE SWITCH 1
r calibration on 3/14/90 was t n tolerance with a trip point of 200f int of188.2 y andOneseta3/26/90 reset    theof 194 'F' switch was found out of
n tolerance with a trip point of 200f r calibration on 3/14/90 was t
                      .of 180.6 'F. Further investigation determinect a smali             .A tolerance        w Was ino'aerable due to a missin gasket. A third switch was ca point of T.98.57 and a reset 191.f0 and returned to service. Old swt ge.                                                                         ;;
and a reset of 194 'F' switch was found out of tolerance w int of188.2 y On 3/26/90 the eset.of 180.6 'F. Further investigation determinect a smali
A                               .
.A Was ino'aerable due to a missin gasket. A third switch was ca point of T.98.57 and a reset 191.f0 and returned to service. Old swt ge.
A m
--w


        .                                                                                                        1
g g, g y -y
        ,.  ..w             .--..:        . ..      . ;.
..w
                                                            . n .. . ..  .
. ;. n...
g g, g y -y 05-/7i-99 i                                                                                                               l l                        ..
05-/7i-99 i
1"SH19153 LUBE OIL HIGH "gPgRATURE SWITCH Prior , calibration .vas cerformed on 3/14/90. At that time che switch was found out or tolerance with ah as found of 300 'F to tric and 199 'F to reset. It was calibrated and returned to aenice with a trip of 199 'T and a reset of 191 'F. It was removed from service on 3/23/90 as he suspectea cause of DG1B trip. The switch calibration was checked sad woul not calibrate within tolerance. It was placed in storage on 3/23/90.
l 1"SH19153 LUBE OIL HIGH "gPgRATURE SWITCH Prior, calibration.vas cerformed on 3/14/90.
SWITCH TWO This switch was placed in service on 3/23/90 with a trip of 203.4 'F and a reset o 198.0 'F. On 3/27/90 it was removed from senice and its calibration chec'.se . As found was 203.5 'F to tno ar}d 199.5 degrees to reset. Swever. it was founc                                                                           The old swicen was       i
At that time che switch was found out or tolerance with ah as found of 300 'F to tric and 199 'F to reset. It was calibrated and returned to aenice with a trip of 199 'T and a reset of 191 'F. It was removed from service on 3/23/90 as he suspectea cause of DG1B trip. The switch calibration was checked sad woul not calibrate within tolerance. It was placed in storage on 3/23/90.
    ' placea.to       be venting     continuously in storage on 3/27/90.                and    suosequently      raplaced.
SWITCH TWO This switch was placed in service on 3/23/90 with a trip of 203.4 'F and a reset o 198.0 'F.
1THS19148 LUBE OIL HIGH TEMPERATURE SWITCH DGIA                                                   :
On 3/27/90 it was removed from senice and its calibration chec'.se. As found was 203.5 'F to tno ar}d 199.5 degrees to reset. Swever. it was founc The old swicen was
Prior calibration was per~ormed on 3/3/90. At that time it was found out of                     l r.oierance with a :np point of 211.0 *F ano a reset of 203.1 'F The switch was                             l l    calibrated and returned to sen-ice with a trip point of 200.2 *F and a reset of 193                       '
' placea.to be venting continuously and suosequently raplaced.
degrees with a  On trip3/30/90     the switch oint of 190.4   'F anc awas  resetrfmoved      ford calibration of 188.0 'F. to trip comt ofand    found The switch also coeratea 201.27 *.* out o sluggishly.        t was replaced with a new switch calibrate ano a reset of 196.20"F. The new switch was returned to service. The originat switch is in storage.           <
in storage on 3/27/90.
1THS19148 LUBE OIL HIGH TEMPERATURE SWITCH DGIA Prior calibration was per~ormed on 3/3/90. At that time it was found out of r.oierance with a :np point of 211.0 *F ano a reset of 203.1 'F The switch was l
calibrated and returned to sen-ice with a trip point of 200.2 *F and a reset of 193 degrees On 3/30/90 the switch was rfmoved for calibration and found out o The switch also coeratea oint of 190.4 'F anc a reset of 188.0 'F. d to trip comt of 201.27 *.
with a trip t was replaced with a new switch calibrate sluggishly.
ano a reset of 196.20"F. The new switch was returned to service. The originat switch is in storage.
ITSH19117 JACKET WATER HEATER OUT HIGH TEMPERATURE SWITCH DG1B Prior calibration on 3/14/90 was within tolerance with a trip point pf 201 'F
ITSH19117 JACKET WATER HEATER OUT HIGH TEMPERATURE SWITCH DG1B Prior calibration on 3/14/90 was within tolerance with a trip point pf 201 'F
      .ina a reset of 193 'F.
.ina a reset of 193 'F.
On 3/26/90 switch was found out of tolerance with a trip                               da     ;
On 3/26/90 switch was found out of tolerance with a trip da f,aileo.of 152.4. Further investigation determined a sm reset A new switch also leax, test. A thira awiten calibrated correctly with a trio goint of 200.67 cegrees anc a reset of 196.93 'F and was returned to service. The old switches are m storage.
A new switch also f,aileo.of reset 152.4.
ITSH19119 JACKET HEATER OUT HIGH TEMPERATURE SWITCH DG1B Prior calibration on 3/14/90 was within tolerance with a trip point of 200 (F and a reset of 194 F.
leax , test.           Further A thira awiten           investigation calibrated                         determined correctly with a trio goint of 200.67 a sm cegrees anc a reset of 196.93 'F and was returned to service. The old switches are m storage.
'th a t '
ITSH19119                                                   I I
oint of 188.2 'F and a,On 3/26/90 the switch was found out of tolerancereset of 180.6 'F. Furthe ak. A new switen was inoaerable due to a missin asket. A third switch was calibrated with a tnp point of 1.98.57 and a reset 191.
JACKET HEATER OUT HIGH TEMPERATURE SWITCH DG1B                                                   l Prior calibration on 3/14/90 was within tolerance with a trip point of 200 (F and a reset of 194 F.
and returned to service. Old switches are in storage.
                                                                              'th a t ' oint of 188.2 'F and a,On 3/26/90 the switch was found out of tolerancereset                         ak.ofA180.6 new 'F. Furthe switen was inoaerable due to a missin               asket. A third switch was calibrated with a tnp point of 1.98.57 and a reset 191.           and returned to service. Old switches are in storage.


1
)
                                                                                                          )
c S-/Pc-)
      ,                                                                                                  l
+
      !                                                                                      c S-/Pc-)
O 5 -i10 -] C s-es-se w ee
    +
-3. :. s. a 3:e-:
s-es-se w ee -3. :. s. a         3:e-:           -2n .c2           O 5 -i10 -] C  ;
-2n.c2 DGIA 1
DGIA 1
1TI T':I S ;'JCED s.12-90 0 00 iTARID 3 17 TID TO GRID 1345
1 T':I                   S ;'JCED 1TI s.12-90                 0 00             iTARID 3 17             TID TO GRID 1345             '.cADC TO 7600 W u.
'.cADC TO 7600 W u.
3 55             Car 145 To eS*o W 1;25               RDDVD FP/m PAM IL ~0 GC::
3 55 Car 145 To eS*o W 1;25 RDDVD FP/m PAM IL ~0 GC::
:D SLTTYE4 BUS W.C::                   l
:D SLTTYE4 BUS W.C::
                                                . !.3             7APr ' " "O CRID
l
                                                .:125             OL'ITLTI 2PJJFI?. WC3 r.! NL!.
. !.3 7APr ' " "O CRID
FO3 FER ! CG-90-3 2127               >M
.:125 OL'ITLTI 2PJJFI?. WC3 r.! NL!.
                        .' . I ' - f)           n09               STAR *c                             ,
FO3 FER ! CG-90-3 2127
UO!?               0*JIFLT BRFA:CR CLD3ED 3032               F. O. PIACED 0:1 REC;74. PCR 00 5. SIRY (257               C#2 0'.*:CT D3007 M712. CPI?.COR C' C0:frTC R02: .r.ACO MQ: Of PAPp'"- 005, AND BEGd:
>M
CGEASING *.4AD IC 7000 W 0301               tc/O > 6800 W 0310               IT ',AS DLTC9tDED TET DG'A sVITQ*D 10 C.*IT lODI AS A RIS'/ T OF SPFC.AL SE.**. WJER TEl" ?DCDUPI BY CiGO EEP.EU.
.'. I ' - f) n09 STAR *c UO!?
0502               0'JI?LT 3RIA>2R OPD:
0*JIFLT BRFA:CR CLD3ED 3032 F. O. PIACED 0:1 REC;74. PCR 00 5. SIRY (257 C#2 0'.*:CT D3007 M712. CPI?.COR C' C0:frTC R02:.r.ACO MQ: Of PAPp'"- 005, AND BEGd:
0506               5;C7?ID C509               P".ACD IN !fAC.T DWC DDI W
CGEASING *.4AD IC 7000 W 0301 tc/O > 6800 W 0310 IT ',AS DLTC9tDED TET DG'A sVITQ*D 10 C.*IT lODI AS A RIS'/ T OF SPFC.AL SE.** WJER TEl" ?DCDUPI BY CiGO EEP.EU.
                                                              .. -1*HE TAKn! 077 RECIRC. -
0502 0'JI?LT 3RIA>2R OPD:
1320 RE5LI.T SAT.
0506 5;C7?ID C509 P".ACD IN !fAC. DWC DDI T
              *;CT E : 411 starts unless ot.,erwise noteo are                           cp C' -
W 1320
.. -1*HE TAKn! 077 RECIRC. -
RE5LI.T SAT.
*;CT E : 411 starts unless ot.,erwise noteo are cp C' -
fec't the Control Asom 1
fec't the Control Asom 1


ye.     -
ye.
04-04-30 ;4: M T-r ',; Et. "a       52 ~T:':' mI31. 50:
04-04-30 ;4: M T-r ',; Et. "a 52
DG1A Tilt               TE E                       CMitD 3390                     03;C
~T:':' mI31. 50:
                                                                    !4SP 'IC'JFJiED . IDST "A" PAT
DG1A Tilt TE E CMitD 3390 03;C
                                                                    - DCIA UE AND ~RIPPE '          '
!4SP 'IC'JFJiED. IDST "A" PAT
(SE'.DA:. A!A4!J* T - lCT
- DCIA UE AND ~RIPPE '
(SE'.DA:. A!A4!
* T - lCT J
:DTI2) 2: DGE :DG) 084'.
:DTI2) 2: DGE :DG) 084'.
AUIO ST/JtITD /JTER SEC2CER RESET A!O ~1t1FPC CN 10.!
AUIO ST/JtITD /JTER SEC2CER RESET A!O ~1t1FPC CN 10.!
Line 371: Line 453:
_0CU1.Y "O ?IAII/IP. 95WWt = ="
_0CU1.Y "O ?IAII/IP. 95WWt = ="
STA~':C:1 Best Cl.T. D/G IS
STA~':C:1 Best Cl.T. D/G IS
                                                                  %TTd'ING THt', 4100 KV TPAO' "A" : nap N wi
%TTd'ING THt', 4100 KV TPAO' "A" : nap N wi
                                              .'029               tRAT "B" DEI *ID) 10I.0 (13A03 ENDG:ZD !?2 "S" ?AT) l 1155                                                 -i Dic 1A P! ACED McK C( hh%I           l l
.'029 tRAT "B" DEI *ID) 10I.0 (13A03 ENDG:ZD !?2 "S" ?AT) 1155 Dic 1A P! ACED McK C( hh%I
1157
-i l
                                                                . IAA02 A1.15.M: 0:CQEG 3REAXDL CIDSD ::i PARAlil:.tc DICG1A) l
l 1157
                                            .211             '.AADD ':0 6800 cl 10 SE Ett           '
. IAA02 A1.15.M: 0:CQEG 3REAXDL CIDSD ::i PARAlil:.tc DICG1A) l
i IIR 45 MU.*Cs.S Dt.T TO LIE
.211
                                                              'DD CFDAUCN 1324             TIE BRLy3R C?D 1326             SHtC OWN 1405             FLACD :: STA!;DBY ?IADC.TSS 1700             D/C DECIARED OD?ERAF.1.E 1741 (BAT "A" DEIID) 2031             D/C Of .Mf:E;ANCE !CI TCR
'.AADD ':0 6800 cl 10 SE Ett IIR 45 MU.*Cs.S Dt.T TO LIE
'DD CFDAUCN 1324 TIE BRLy3R C?D 1326 SHtC OWN 1405 FLACD :: STA!;DBY ?IADC.TSS 1700 D/C DECIARED OD?ERAF.1.E 1741 (BAT "A" DEIID) 2031 D/C Of.Mf:E;ANCE !CI TCR
:CISIGI CHEC BEFORE E'll 2
:CISIGI CHEC BEFORE E'll 2


Line 383: Line 466:
(
(
4
4
                                                                                                                      ~
' W i-tC N n 7-i < i.f. ~i iii. T :_:a
                            ' W i-tC N n 7-i < i .f. ~i
~
                                .                              iii . T :_:a             ..
t DCIA xW tw wD1) 3-it, - D 1 14 3 D.RC 21:2 CLT.T SFf/03 51f5.c s'C;;,.7 W.02 2205
t DCIA xW               tw                       wD1)                   _
'7EFtt" 5AF#3. 07E:i t2:6 3Ht.D3.11 12:3 mT/J.TC 1:23 SECL1E 2231 ST/JL"ED 225'.
3-it, - D           1 14                 3 D.RC 21:2                 CLT.T SFf/03 51f5 .c s'C;;, .7 W.02 2205                 '7EFtt" 5AF#3. 07E:i t2:6                 3Ht.D3.11
SECL'FE 3-2; 90 2210 JAOr ETER AND LL3I 0*I. }ZE?
  .                                                    12:3                 mT/J.TC 1:23                 SECL1E 2231                 ST/JL"ED 225'.                 SECL'FE 3-2; 90                 2210                 JAOr ETER AND LL3I 0*I. }ZE?
*;iGCl 3YSTO3 SifJitA?! TO SU??37 MAUWWK2
                                                                              *;iGCl
.:: lEC'.%"I :DDE 7;.'R :D"ST.?E A
                                                                              .        3YSTO3 SifJitA?! TO SU??37 MAUWWK2
> L2 0 0227 CYD*
                                > L2 0                  0227                    .:: lEC' .%"IA :DDE 7;.'R :D"ST.?E CYD*
0251
0251                 : DIS'It?2 OEQ* Jt712"I 40
: DIS'It?2 OEQ* Jt712"I 40
                                                                              ?I.AC"D h'J. 1:::0 STR O2Y 0256                   SJRITD FOR !!A.2TDM'"I TRO'.T.I.
?I.AC"D h'J. 1:::0 STR O2Y 0256 SJRITD FOR !!A.2TDM'"I TRO'.T.I.
5 DOT 3G '
5 DOT 3G '
0219                 0'.~73 22J23. SFR dig ~1ED "C CRID
0219 0'.~73 22J23. SFR dig ~1ED "C CRID
                                                          % 50                   PLCD BAQ* ON 5".RO3Y 1100E 1714                 1".'ARTD NC !WCAtl.Y $~IU??ID.
% 50 PLCD BAQ* ON 5".RO3Y 1100E 1714 1".'ARTD NC !WCAtl.Y $~IU??ID.
tRai C.R.
tRai C.R.
s
s.
                                                                .      es -                                       M
es -
M


Oa-N -92 .4: 01 *-E ; 5'.!?     f *,: ~~ i :. ' -e_
Oa-N -92.4: 01
DGlB DATE                   THE                     SJJtIED 3-13-90                       1440               TAKD: TO IDCAL mR l01SRlRE OECK 1512               IN AUIO STR4DBY .' DIS ~~M CHECK 00tf L T 1518               START MR MAIhT. TEST                           ,
*-E ; 5'.!?
1634               T'.D TO GRID - ICFM INCQUNG BREAKER RD DVED TO -'BA03 1717               IDAD 6800 KW 1838               RtMTING l
f *,: ~~ i :. ' -e_
l 3-14-90                     0120               BECAN LMDADriG D/G 13 0142               DISCONNECTED TAG 4 i*dE GRID 0146               STOPPED 0149               TOOK 10 IDCAL AND P'_ ACED Hi RAINT. WILL BE TAGGED GJT 0401               OPERAB2.I"*Y TEST CCtT*R AND SAT FOR D/G 1B l
DGlB DATE THE SJJtIED 3-13-90 1440 TAKD: TO IDCAL mR l01SRlRE OECK 1512 IN AUIO STR4DBY.' DIS ~~M CHECK 00tf L T 1518 START MR MAIhT. TEST 1634 T'.D TO GRID - ICFM INCQUNG BREAKER RD DVED TO 'BA03 1717 IDAD 6800 KW 1838 RtMTING l
3-21-90                     2149               FAILED TO START DUF. 20 DISLTFICIENT WEL IN FUEL LINES               l AFIER MAIh7ENANCE.
3-14-90 0120 BECAN LMDADriG D/G 13 0142 DISCONNECTED TAG 4 i*dE GRID 0146 STOPPED 0149 TOOK 10 IDCAL AND P' ACED Hi RAINT. WILL BE TAGGED GJT 0401 OPERAB2.I"*Y TEST CCtT*R AND SAT FOR D/G 1B 3-21-90 2149 FAILED TO START DUF. 20 DISLTFICIENT WEL IN FUEL LINES AFIER MAIh7ENANCE.
2156               FAILED 10 START AGAIN 2202               STARTED AND 00'ER:0 VEhTED                   l l
2156 FAILED 10 START AGAIN 2202 STARTED AND 00'ER:0 VEhTED 2217 STOPPED 1
2217               STOPPED 1
NOTE: All stnets unless otherwise noted are from the Control Room
NOTE: All stnets unless otherwise noted are from the Control Room


DG1B t
DG1B t
DATE                         TI!E               STARTD 03-21-90                             2259         STARID D/G 1B FOR OVERSPEED TRIP TEST 2301         STOPPED MA1CAI.LY DUE TO IDJ i.UBE OIL PRESSURE AND HIGi OIL ,
DATE TI!E STARTD 03-21-90 2259 STARID D/G 1B FOR OVERSPEED TRIP TEST 2301 STOPPED MA1CAI.LY DUE TO IDJ i.UBE OIL PRESSURE AND HIGi OIL FILTER AP 2314 STARTED 2318 STOPPED
FILTER AP 2314         STARTED 2318         STOPPED                         +
+
3-22-90                             0017         STAItIED 0023         SIDPPED 70R !!AINIEWICE 0350         IN !%DT? ANCE ! ODE EDR         I IOISIURE QECK 0428         OUT OF MAIICENAt:CE I4XIOUI, MOISIURE CHECK CQ7LUED 0428         STARIED FDR TESTLNG 0429         STOPPED                         l 0714         IDCALI.Y STARTD FOR :'AINTD ANCE AND E2iGI1ERING TESTH1G 1030         IDCALLY SHUIIXAH 1106         STAICED FROM C.R.
3-22-90 0017 STAItIED 0023 SIDPPED 70R !!AINIEWICE 0350 IN !%DT? ANCE ! ODE EDR I
1112         TIE BREAKER C:ESED '
IOISIURE QECK 0428 OUT OF MAIICENAt:CE I4XIOUI, MOISIURE CHECK CQ7LUED 0428 STARIED FDR TESTLNG 0429 STOPPED l
l 1135         LOAD > 6800 %*                   1 1243         TRIPP D ON D/G HIGH LUBE OIL TD2                               \
0714 IDCALI.Y STARTD FOR :'AINTD ANCE AND E2iGI1ERING TESTH1G 1030 IDCALLY SHUIIXAH 1106 STAICED FROM C.R.
1112 TIE BREAKER C:ESED '
1135 LOAD > 6800 %*
1 1243 TRIPP D ON D/G HIGH LUBE OIL TD2
\\
l l
l l
4 2
4 2
1


        .g                   .    ._            .                . - _ . - - -                          4 .,  .                            . - - - .. ,    _.        , _                  . .
.g 4
J
J
                                .c
.c
+.                               ,                                                                                                                                                                        .;
+.
z
z
:          ,;4-+1 ..:.;+ -i~;5 3                         ~ M+-: 3 :IM W L
,;4-+1..:.;+ -i~;5 3
                                                  ..                                                                                                                                                        i DC1B
~ M+-: 3 :IM W L
i DC1B
:'.C
:'.C
* 71E Shw
* 71E Shw
                                                      ~
~2-24-D 0443
2-24-D                                           0443
?UISn3Z CIC: STKn22D 0500 inIsn:RE CHE s 03:FLt'.'r.
                                                                                                                                  ?UISn3Z CIC: STKn22D 0500 inIsn:RE CHE s 03:FLt'.'r .
0!M SU.RD FOR lR".*J2WC FF.; AlfD SW~~d UFERAZR lCTITID 0514 T.*C C) GtID. CJIF:T BPE/u"ZR I
0!M                       SU.RD FOR lR".*J2WC FF.; AlfD SW~~d UFERAZR lCTITID 0514 T.*C C) GtID. CJIF:T BPE/u"ZR,                                              I E1C 0329 CL**.* IMDED (7000 n!)
E1C 0329 CL**.* IMDED (7000 n!)
1145 l4AD '.f.'CRFASE M ?$00 i~d I;53 LCAD .U.LA?E T3 63M C
1145 l4AD '.f.'CRFASE M ?$00 i~d I;53 LCAD.U.LA?E T3 63M C
                                                                                                      '.153                       TIE 1ET. DR ;002 lmD'                                                       1 FEJE.'TIO:s TFE' 1B IE2mG                     .,
'.153 TIE 1ET. DR ;002 lmD'
                                                                                                    '.202                       EE??!2)
'1 FEJE.'TIO:s TFE' 1B IE2mG
                                                                                                    '..' y-STARTD s'ut t let, m                                                       ,
'.202 EE??!2)
U~1 "RIPPC rh LW JAS"!.T"ATIF.                                                   I PREE5'3E/2:280 L'.*BE 02, PRE 55'24 Lui                                                               )
' ' y-STARTD s'ut t let, m U~1 "RIPPC rh LW JAS"!. "ATIF.
JM                         ~ STARTD FtR 4 ICL RLt:
T PREE5'3E/2:280 L'.*BE 02, I
1755                         TID E QtID 1819 U%DED 10 6803 KW 1%2                                                                                                           i KJt :::G "DR PADCIWC ?$                                                     i i
PRE 55'24 Lui
2222 ATIER *.ADI:3 II t*AS                                                         i i
)
DISCO::iElfi E r M THE G ID KO DIIl5EL 18 S"C??E;                                                         1 222=                                                                                                     '
JM
~ STARTD FtR 4 ICL RLt:
1755 TID E QtID 1819 U%DED 10 6803 KW i
1%2 KJt :::G "DR PADCIWC ?$
i i
2222 ATIER *.ADI:3 II t*AS i
DISCO::iElfi E r M THE G ID i
KO DIIl5EL 18 S"C??E; 1
222=
EIA@ 2lIMUIRU78.Q2!EE FOR 1R'.27112u:CE
EIA@ 2lIMUIRU78.Q2!EE FOR 1R'.27112u:CE
                                                                                              .:3 7
.:3 7
                                                                                                                              'DISRIE CFIG STARIE 3
'DISRIE CFIG STARIE 3
l
l
, . , - . , , , - - . - - - -      ..y     - - - , -    7 7.w.,--   . - , ,  c-,-. ..r   - , ,, --              ,,,,.,,.m,                                       . ,,- -      ,,--.,w-----,---    -
..y 7
7.w.,--
c-,-.
..r
,,,,.,,.m,
,,--.,w-----,---


OS-eve I      !      i                                        !
OS-eve
                          *!s!!*$
*!s!!*$
  .                                                              i s-        !                  !                  81
I i
                                                                                              ;ln I
i 81 I
r                        i':!is:I! .i                     i veng it!5-     avi a                               -e                                  gan .3
veng
                          !!!t     I         a                                                          .
;ln i':!is:I!
I          II E8 3          $
. i i
                                                                                  ,l'glg            lj!g=jg
it!5 avi s-r a
    -g.                  ws5g58l          !!tl s3g 8              s5Es]                        g            ai
a gan.3
    .^                    EE 35E F egIstN s *!gw .           ! ~!g ,           i ,g       I_I','
-e
g;3 D                                 u    g E s :.. gE :-     g l s c..N *y F                   I           E ae:
!!!t I I
la!iils                                                             3,sijl g
s5Es]
s!iiii             niiil;             lia! sisialisl!
,l'gl lj!g=jg ws5g58l
si 5
!!tl 3
                  .m:
II E8 ai
E55 s
-g.
                            !~l ls s                   E
s3g 8 EE 35E F s *!g.
                                                                                              !g 2NA                          !' s! I;Ii                                       !5!
g
5tt i!
! ~!g,
E i5 198 8 instt                alttstt                                  _      5ts!,,
i,g I_I','
Eng i !!EXE               sgIEg!E           5!8lER g
g;3 g
5EEg :
D egIstN g E s :.. E :-
l5En EEEE!EE                   ESEEEEE             Ei!IEE             E=jji=sEEI!!!
g l s c..
s el                  as                 i                 i         21 l
* F w
IIli l                 !!!                1                             it I               EIR                 s                 l          SI i      gg I
.^
g        e-a !                   I             e I j      s I I         s la s i i             al i               e-nl =i              s e
I E
e-al =i I                              me i               nui!                     I   an I Is                    -al s      ,        in!ii!_
u g
                              .                              is
N y 3,sijl ae:
                                                              .ji                 ...        a il !!ltii'" I s
la!iils s!iiii niiil; lia!
Ba       ssal4E:       N isi las anI! III ii!
sisialisl!
          !              il             55 sigI-i
g si 5
          =     a gI            ga, lI E                    !!*                !a                 g II g
.m:
3 j
E55 2NA !~ll s!
gg ii                   us!                 n=I               e n=       e s: Ii                   Ifl                 ill               asNs'     E l         E              E EzlI    S              $                  $
!g s
s E
i 198 8 instt alttstt I;Ii i!
!5!
s E
5tt 5ts!,,
5 Eng i !!EXE sgIEg!E 5!8lER E=jji=sEEI!!!
g 5EEg :
l5En EEEE!EE ESEEEEE Ei!IEE s
e l as i
i 21 l IIli l 1
l it I
EIR i
s SI I
a !
I e I s I gg I
si g
al i nl =i j
al =i e-e-
e e-I la s i me i nui!
I an I s
-al Is in!ii!_
is.ji a
s s il
'!!ltii'"
I isi ii!
Ba ssal4E:
N las anI!
III il 55 gI ga, sigI-i
=
a
!a g II 3
lI E gg ii us!
n=I g
j e n=
e s: Ii Ifl ill asNs' E
EzlI l
E E
E E
E 5s                  s                   s                 =         =
E E
                    ~.
E S
s .,
5 s s
t          it s ..               I .iC              gt         et
s
[E                                                            .i           i I! b                 !k                 ik is E                 si                 as;               .;        11 ss                is                 is                 is         is
=
                    !in                 !!                  sti               !!        !!
=
[E
~.
t it C
s.,
s..
I.i gt t
e
.i i
I! b
!k i k is E si as; 11 s s is is is is
!in sti


    -                          I    "
! s*u*s*sisi!gg!EI!9"5g.32!ajg,,,!eg
                                                      -3
-!I*ggg I
                  ! s*u*s*sisi!gg!EI!9"5g.32!ajg,,,!eg 8 saI      tit Ia st-                    -!I*ggg g gg.
- 3 g
instisiil; 12                 siill=:i;l a
8 saI tit Ia st-instisiil; 12 siill=:i;l gg.
g fgIl e
! !s 5 5 g fgIl e
                  !*3!s 5I5                5     =       !              !!E
a j!E
                ! e:!!ig3                 s
!!E I
                                          ! y  e8Est     j!E
5
                                                            =In         y=Rs ngm!*e5       5 =,i!
=
: j. 51353m:isa pl                553as 3    g*l:E
! e:!!ig3
                                                          = In          =l:5 i In               :
*3 s
EliiGI: n       =954           9554               )
e8Est
15'-                                                                             i li 5: 5                                                                               !
=In y=Rs
Ese                                                                               i e:N H j               !
! y ngm!*e5 5 =,i! as g*l:E
                            =           , *:
=l:5
E
= In j
* a is  *=j=si5****Em
553 pl
          !35        =l45:l
. 51353m:i i In sa 3
                      $EE tt 2
EliiGI: n
                                          =E5:f          g85;ua             E!iE5ji i
=954 9554 15'-
                                          $18
li i
          - =5
5: 5 Ese i
          $=as gniga,n In              =I"I, g gg.I" 5
e:N H
                                                        -        Isi
E j
                                                                      $ I dil I in g       3 , 33 .l3     ,  .,
=l45:l 5****Em
9     sE                 s5
=E5:f g *=j=si E!iE5j i a
            !! k!!
=
              -      ---                k!!
is 2
!35 85;ua i
$EE tt
- =5
$18 5
=I"I g gg.I" In Isi $ dil in I
I
$=as gniga,n g
3, 33.l3.
9 sE s5 i
i
!! k!!
k!!
,i I
m--
m--
i
a il R19 RIE i
                                                        ,i i
i sg!
Ia                  ;
as!
il       R19                 RIE           i             i sg!                 as!             as!
as!
l! 5 c
ss!
lE=          :El=i               ~i -
l!
n' ss!
lE al'II
i la      al'II NE ma HEII n
:El=i c
if l" !       mil!
~i i
iff
l" !
                                                                              .=
mil!
.          I g           2 :e               h =a             a 223                                    h:
n' 5
223           223 El'                          IN I           IN I 15       Illh Is                  III           IEI           i i                   i             5
=
          !1 in i                 !              I i                 e               e
ma n
          ==
.=
E w                 u               I             I g           R                  R el=
HEII if la NE iff I
:xs R
g 2 :e h =a a
u                  R R
El' h:
223 223 223 Illh IN I IN I 15 III IEI i
Is i
i 5
!1 i I
in i
e e
 
==
w u
I I
E g
R R
R S
R S
R u               u             u I     5                   2             5             5 5                   5 E     nr
el=
                                        't l         I'                 I' ls i     li 8                   li B.             41
R R
                                                                      $s 41                     1 E     n a.               va            !=,           !=
R R
l E                   E:             as             sa                     l
:xs u
            .h                           h               h
u u
u I
5 2
5 5
5 5
E n r
't l li li ls
$s I'
I' i
8 B.
41 41 E n a.
1
!=,
!=
va E
E:
as sa
.h h
h


2   A.
2 A.
k 9
k 9
2 lis=1 - .           -
2 lis=1 -.
s.
s.
estf{a,:IIla.in =]
g!"-
g!"-
la.a!!!i; estf{a,:IIla
la.a!!!i; 38
                ,s 38        -a
-a
                                                .in =]
,s sis $3 hP 8N ir
sis ir  $3                     hP 8N
.sgig wg mE
                                            .sgig wg mE                         *a=g 5      I                    !'5cg, Ilia,f                       slisalt      .
*a=g
li 5
!'5cg, slisalt 5
i!!
I Ilia,f li 5 i!!
g                   ,                !!...
g
:s       EE         SE               IEEE$'
:s EE SE IEEE$'
ii"si 3!ii8!ii 8
ii 3!ii8!ii E8?Y8!==
E8?Y8!==
i 81l sddland 8!Isit II "s
81l   = sddland 8!Isit II eSBa ssisis sisisins; i                             S ll e !
8 B ssisis isisins;
                                          ~I li sE s                               =
=
ssE                               I I CE                          SE       E lEGElE        -
a e
DEI'm Im    III!                       Eta!I a
s i S S
l l
~I e
li sE s
=
ssE I
lE I GElE DEI'm SE E
CE ImIII!
Eta!I a
8 15'in
8 15'in
        !8                               la     si
!8 la si
:l la    i 3 ~ g=
:l 3 ~ g=
il mE a                               nan
la i il mE nan a
        *)
*)
lI8l
lI8 l
        !! I                             lie
!! I lie
    ,i ,                                ,
,i eEw 4 2
eEw 4                               2 eaa n                               a IS                            E s
eaa n a
EN                            " 7, 9 E2 l ii                          l_*"2 8E l ii                         ili
I S E
s E N
" 7, 9 E2 l_*"2 l ii 8 E l ii ili


                                                                                              .O 5'- 33 (,   J   l d 0* 3M RAFT                                           i l
.O 5'- 33 (,
l ATTACHMENT l
J d 0* 3M RAFT i
V0GTLE ELECTRIC GENERATTNG PLART CORRECTIVE ACTIONS FOR SITE AREA ENERcENCY                           l2 I
ATTACHMENT V0GTLE ELECTRIC GENERATTNG PLART CORRECTIVE ACTIONS FOR SITE AREA ENERcENCY 2
                  'On March 20,1990, a $1te Area Emergency was declared due to a loss of offstte l
'On March 20,1990, a $1te Area Emergency was declared due to a loss of offstte power concurrent with a loss of onsite Emergency Diesel Generator capability.
power concurrent with a loss of onsite Emergency Diesel Generator capability.
In accordance with VEGP Procedures, an Event Review Team has investigated the events leading up to and following the Site Area Emergency. This review team identified four main problem areas associated with the event. These problems involved low voltage switchyard access controls. Olesel Generator failures, Emergency Plan implementation, and procedures for shutdown plant conditions. A sumary of the findings and completed or planned corrective actions follows.
In accordance with VEGP Procedures, an Event Review Team has investigated the                 l events leading up to and following the Site Area Emergency. This review team identified four main problem areas associated with the event. These problems involved low voltage switchyard access controls. Olesel Generator failures, Emergency Plan implementation, and procedures for shutdown plant conditions. A sumary of the findings and completed or planned corrective actions follows.
The low voltage switchyard access control problems were the result of inadequate
    ^
^
The low voltage switchyard access control problems were the result of inadequate procedures. This wes compounded by a lack of attention on the part of the driver of the truck. These were the direct cause of the event. Furthermore, while site procedures required a security officer to accompany the vehicle-in 9
procedures. This wes compounded by a lack of attention on the part of the driver of the truck. These were the direct cause of the event. Furthermore, while site procedures required a security officer to accompany the vehicle-in ons he was unable to assist the the protected area, due to vi 9
the protected area, due to vi                             ons he was unable to assist the driver,                                       q n    I    r recurrin To prevent this type of inittcorrective actions have been or are being implem               '
: driver, q
o    The truck driver was disciplined for lack of attention and alertness in backing the truck when visibility was impaired.
To prevent this type of inittcorrective actions have been or are being implem n
o      A management directive on control and operation of vehicles was issued to all site employees. Administrative procedures have been revised to incorporate this management directive.
I r
o      Security officer training will be revised to emphasize that officers have authority and responsibility to assist vehicle operators to assure safe vehicle operation. Specifically, security escorts will ensure that ground guides (flagaen) are used when large vehicles are maneuvered inside the protected area. These changes wil, be implemented by 8-1-90.
recurrin The truck driver was disciplined for lack of attention and alertness in o
o      Outage Area Coordinators have been instructed to stage welding machines and other materials on the east and west ends of the Turbine tut 1 ding, whenever possible, to avoid unnecessary equipment and vehicle traffic in the low 4                            voltage switchyard.
backing the truck when visibility was impaired.
1
A management directive on control and operation of vehicles was issued to o
all site employees. Administrative procedures have been revised to incorporate this management directive.
Security officer training will be revised to emphasize that officers have o
authority and responsibility to assist vehicle operators to assure safe vehicle operation. Specifically, security escorts will ensure that ground guides (flagaen) are used when large vehicles are maneuvered inside the protected area. These changes wil, be implemented by 8-1-90.
Outage Area Coordinators have been instructed to stage welding machines and o
other materials on the east and west ends of the Turbine tut 1 ding, whenever possible, to avoid unnecessary equipment and vehicle traffic in the low voltage switchyard.
4 1


j l
j l
l DRAFT                                                   l
DRAFT ATTACHMENT (CONTINUED)
      ,                                      ATTACHMENT (CONTINUED)
V0GTLE ELECTRIC GENERATING PLANT C0ARICTIVE ACTIONS FOR 11TE AREA _DIERGENCY i
V0GTLE ELECTRIC GENERATING PLANT                               l C0ARICTIVE ACTIONS FOR 11TE AREA _DIERGENCY                           i
.o Maintenance procedures will be revised to restrict staging of equipment in the low voltage switchyard. The procedures will be revised by 6-15-90.
            .o   Maintenance procedures will be revised to restrict staging of equipment in the low voltage switchyard. The procedures will be revised by 6-15-90.               I o   Barriers were installed with signs which require authorization from the Unit Shift Supervisor for vehicle access to the low voltage switchyard.
o Barriers were installed with signs which require authorization from the Unit Shift Supervisor for vehicle access to the low voltage switchyard.
I o   Plant procedures have been revised to control hazardous materials and transient combustibles in the low voltage switchyard and other sensitive             ,
o Plant procedures have been revised to control hazardous materials and transient combustibles in the low voltage switchyard and other sensitive plant areas.
plant areas.
The most significant problem area identified by the review team involved the j
    '        The most significant problem area identified by the review team involved the               j failure of Diesel Generator 1A to remain running to provide emergency power.             l The event team utilizing utility and vendor tecuitcal experts, reviewed the two           l sequential failures of the diesel engine. The cause of the first trip can only           !
failure of Diesel Generator 1A to remain running to provide emergency power.
be postulated, but most likely is the same as the second trip. The ongoing         .
The event team utilizing utility and vendor tecuitcal experts, reviewed the two sequential failures of the diesel engine. The cause of the first trip can only be postulated, but most likely is the same as the second trip. The ongoing investigation indicates the most likely cause of the second trip was intermittent actuation of the jacket water temperature switches. A problem with restarting the diesel occurred because the Engineered Safety Features Actuation System (E5FAS) sequencer logic and diesel generator start logic (as designed) resulted in the diesel engine bein d out following the initial trip until the sequencer logic was reset.
investigation indicates the most likely cause of the second trip was                     l intermittent actuation of the jacket water temperature switches. A problem with           ,
As a result of the event investiga ing actions have been or are j
restarting the diesel occurred because the Engineered Safety Features Actuation           l System (E5FAS) sequencer logic and diesel generator start logic (as designed)             l resulted in the diesel engine bein           d out following the initial trip until       :
being implemented to ensure a high state of diesel generator reliability.
the sequencer logic was reset.
)
l As a result of the event investiga                   ing actions have been or are       j being implemented to ensure a high state of diesel generator reliability.                 )
o The suspected switches were replaced and extensive diesel generator testing was performed to ensure operability prior to return to service.
o   The suspected switches were replaced and extensive diesel generator testing         ,
1 o
was performed to ensure operability prior to return to service.                     1 o   Investigation of the suspect-temperature switches has been performed by an           !
Investigation of the suspect-temperature switches has been performed by an independent testing laboratory and a report is expected by 5 18-90. The investigation revealed that the temperature switetes are sensitive to 1
independent testing laboratory and a report is expected by 5 18-90. The             '
calibration techniques and foreign material within the switches.
investigation revealed that the temperature switetes are sensitive to               1 calibration techniques and foreign material within the switches.                   i o   Maintenance procedures for temperature switches have been revised to include lessons learned from laboratory testing. All jacket water high temperature switches will be cleaned and calibrated using the revised procedure by               j 5-31-90. Other non-essential trip temperature switches will cleaned and calibrated at their nomal calitpration cycle.
i o
o   Vendor failure analysis of a low lube oil pressure switch will be conducted and results of this analysis will be used to detemine if procedure changes, cleantng or re-calibration is necessary for various pressure trip switches on the DG.
Maintenance procedures for temperature switches have been revised to include lessons learned from laboratory testing. All jacket water high temperature switches will be cleaned and calibrated using the revised procedure by j
e   The Corporate Maintenance Support Department will perform a design review of the diesel instrumentation. Corrective actions or im if appropriate. The review will be completed by90.       9-1 provements will be made 2
5-31-90. Other non-essential trip temperature switches will cleaned and calibrated at their nomal calitpration cycle.
l l---..------.
o Vendor failure analysis of a low lube oil pressure switch will be conducted and results of this analysis will be used to detemine if procedure changes, cleantng or re-calibration is necessary for various pressure trip switches on the DG.
e The Corporate Maintenance Support Department will perform a design review of The review will be completed by 9-1 provements will be made the diesel instrumentation.
Corrective actions or im if appropriate.
90.
2 l
l---..------.


DRAFT ATTACHMENT (CONTINUED)
DRAFT ATTACHMENT (CONTINUED)
V0GTLE ELECTRIC GENERATING PLANT C0ARECTIVE ACTfoN1 FOR SITE AREA fMfemfNtY o   The Under Voltage (UV) diesel start was changed in both Units 1 and 2 to be similar to a Safety injection emergency start. This provides a higher degree of reliability for UV bus conditions and eliminates the need for resetting the sequencer, o   Operators have been instructed on the emergency start modes of the Diesel Generator. Operating procedures have been revised to address Diesel Generator restart following trips. Training will be provided on the revised procedures by 9-15-90.
V0GTLE ELECTRIC GENERATING PLANT C0ARECTIVE ACTfoN1 FOR SITE AREA fMfemfNtY o
o   A policy detailing guidelines for logging pertinent alarms and indications to assist in evaluation of equipment or system malfunctions has been developed and applicable procedures have been revised.
The Under Voltage (UV) diesel start was changed in both Units 1 and 2 to be similar to a Safety injection emergency start. This provides a higher degree of reliability for UV bus conditions and eliminates the need for resetting the sequencer, o
o   Af ter engine overhauls, functional diesel testing will be enhanced to include pubble testing to e                                 h a lo c system has acceptable leakage, o   Trend program data is being                                     en re OG component failures are adequately included. The data review will be completed by 6-5-90.
Operators have been instructed on the emergency start modes of the Diesel Generator. Operating procedures have been revised to address Diesel Generator restart following trips. Training will be provided on the revised procedures by 9-15-90.
Notification of state and local government agencies was not timely due to a loss of power to the primary Emergency Notification Network (ENN). Communication errors, a lack of understand'ng of ENN power supplies, and inadequate supervision of the notification process were also identified as Emergency Plan implementation problems. Information flow to the General Office resulted in inaccurate information being provided to the media. There was confusion among plant personnel concerning assembly and accountability procedures.
o A policy detailing guidelines for logging pertinent alarms and indications to assist in evaluation of equipment or system malfunctions has been developed and applicable procedures have been revised.
o Af ter engine overhauls, functional diesel testing will be enhanced to include pubble testing to e h a lo c system has acceptable
: leakage, o
Trend program data is being en re OG component failures are adequately included. The data review will be completed by 6-5-90.
Notification of state and local government agencies was not timely due to a loss of power to the primary Emergency Notification Network (ENN). Communication errors, a lack of understand'ng of ENN power supplies, and inadequate supervision of the notification process were also identified as Emergency Plan implementation problems.
Information flow to the General Office resulted in inaccurate information being provided to the media. There was confusion among plant personnel concerning assembly and accountability procedures.
The following actions have been implemented.
The following actions have been implemented.
o   The State of Georgia ENN circuit and Burke County have been added to the Backup ENN.
o The State of Georgia ENN circuit and Burke County have been added to the Backup ENN.
1 o   The General Manager has issued memos to the plant staff to ensure proper                             i functioning of:                                                                                       )
o The General Manager has issued memos to the plant staff to ensure proper functioning of:
: 1. Assembly and Accountability procedures.
)
: 2. ENN Connunications procedures.
1.
Assembly and Accountability procedures.
2.
ENN Connunications procedures.
The following corrective actions will be implemented by the dates indicated.
The following corrective actions will be implemented by the dates indicated.
o   Battery backup power will be provided to the primary Del in the control room by 9-1-90.
o Battery backup power will be provided to the primary Del in the control room by 9-1-90.
o   An evaluation will be performed to review and reconeend further improvements                         ,
o An evaluation will be performed to review and reconeend further improvements in notification systems. This evaluation will be completed by 6-1-90.
in notification systems. This evaluation will be completed by 6-1-90.
3
3


                            .cy.cs ' M 1112e   *":5~.NOP O-vC3r.E                   .c %.. 4   2-o.,       .oo.           ._. __
.cy.cs ' M 1112e
e
*":5~.NOP O-vC3r.E
.                                                                DRAFT                                                                                     l, ATTACMENT(CONTINUE 0)                                                                       l V0GTLE ELECTRIC GENERATING PLANT                               '
.c 4
CORRECTIVE ACTfqNS FOR t!TE ArtA ENERCENCY The Manager Operations and the Nanager Training and Emergency Preparedness                                                 ;
2-o.,
willconducttrainingforallEmerpencyDirectors(ED's)toreviewtherole                                                           I and responsibilities of the ED inc ,uding lessons learned from this event by                                             1 4-1-90.                                                                                                                   !
.oo.
o   Control room comunicators and Emergency Directors will receive training in the operation of and power supplies for emergency comunication equipment.
e DRAFT ATTACMENT(CONTINUE 0)
V0GTLE ELECTRIC GENERATING PLANT CORRECTIVE ACTfqNS FOR t!TE ArtA ENERCENCY The Manager Operations and the Nanager Training and Emergency Preparedness o
willconducttrainingforallEmerpencyDirectors(ED's)toreviewtherole and responsibilities of the ED inc,uding lessons learned from this event by 1
4-1-90.
o Control room comunicators and Emergency Directors will receive training in the operation of and power supplies for emergency comunication equipment.
This will be accomplished by 4-1-30.
This will be accomplished by 4-1-30.
The Emergency preparedness group will establish a monthly test program to validate Emergency Response Facility (ERF) computer data by 6-15-go, o   The Corporate Emergency Response organization (ER0) will be included on the ENN by 7-15-30 to provide another means of ensuring the transmittal of.
The Emergency preparedness group will establish a monthly test program to o
accurate information to the Corporate Office during emergencies, o   The Corporate ER0 will be trained in the use of available communication systems to talk with the site by 6-15-g0.
validate Emergency Response Facility (ERF) computer data by 6-15-go, o
o A full-scale assembly and accountablitty                                         p fomed by 6-15-90.
The Corporate Emergency Response organization (ER0) will be included on the ENN by 7-15-30 to provide another means of ensuring the transmittal of.
o A full-scale assembly and accountability drill will be included as a regular
accurate information to the Corporate Office during emergencies, o
  -                                emergency plan objective. Procedure 91602-C "Emerlency Drills and Exercises", will be changed by 8-1-30 to reflect t11: comitment.
The Corporate ER0 will be trained in the use of available communication systems to talk with the site by 6-15-g0.
o                                                            in the Emergency Plan will be
o A full-scale assembly and accountablitty p fomed by 6-15-90.
                        -        Changes     to Emergency requested from  the NRC based Action on NUMARC's  Levels (EALs)EAL Report presently under review by the NRC. Appropriate changes to the EALs will be completed 6 months after NRC approval of the NUMARC report.
o A full-scale assembly and accountability drill will be included as a regular emergency plan objective. Procedure 91602-C "Emerlency Drills and Exercises", will be changed by 8-1-30 to reflect t11: comitment.
Plant procedures did not sufficiently address or control plant shutdown conditions encountered during the emergency.                                                                                 l o  The procedures covering loss of Residual Heat Removal (RNR) will be revised                                               )
in the Emergency Plan will be Changes to Emergency Action Levels (EALs)EAL Report presently under review o
requested from the NRC based on NUMARC's by the NRC. Appropriate changes to the EALs will be completed 6 months after NRC approval of the NUMARC report.
Plant procedures did not sufficiently address or control plant shutdown conditions encountered during the emergency.
The procedures covering loss of Residual Heat Removal (RNR) will be revised o
to include the various Reactor Coelant System (RCS) and containment conditionspresentduringanoutageoraLossofOffsitePower(LosP) event.
to include the various Reactor Coelant System (RCS) and containment conditionspresentduringanoutageoraLossofOffsitePower(LosP) event.
The Abnormal Operating Procedure (A0P) and Unit Operating Procedure (UDP)                                               i will include the fellowing:
The Abnormal Operating Procedure (A0P) and Unit Operating Procedure (UDP) i will include the fellowing:
For U0P at reduced inventory (less than or equal to 3 feet below the vessel flange) t)   One diesel and two offsite power supplies or two diesels and one offsite power source must be available to feed vital 4160 volt buses, gr,the equipment hatch must be in place, with 4 bolts installed.
For U0P at reduced inventory (less than or equal to 3 feet below the vessel flange) t)
One diesel and two offsite power supplies or two diesels and one offsite power source must be available to feed vital 4160 volt buses, gr,the equipment hatch must be in place, with 4 bolts installed.
A 4
A 4


8 e                 ,
8 e
DRAFT ATTACHMENT (CONTINUED)
DRAFT ATTACHMENT (CONTINUED)
V0GTLE ELECTRIC GENERATING PLANT COL lCI1Yi ACTIONS FDA SITE ARIA EMERGENCY
V0GTLE ELECTRIC GENERATING PLANT COL lCI1Yi ACTIONS FDA SITE ARIA EMERGENCY
                                                  ~
~
: 11) RCS must be cooled to 1100 degrees F for reduced inventory operation
: 11) RCS must be cooled to 1100 degrees F for reduced inventory operation with the equipment hatch open.
                                                  .                with the equipment hatch open.
ForADP(l.ossofRHR) i)
ForADP(l.ossofRHR) i) A loss of power condition will be specifically addressed in the procedure.
A loss of power condition will be specifically addressed in the procedure.
: 11) The time-to-boil curves will be adjusted to address a 1100 degree f starting point for accidents.
: 11) The time-to-boil curves will be adjusted to address a 1100 degree f starting point for accidents.
These procedures will be revised by 7-1 90.
These procedures will be revised by 7-1 90.
o A procedure will be written to address backfeed from the Unit Auxiliary Transformer (UAT)totheESFbusses. This procedure will be completed by 9-1-90.
o A procedure will be written to address backfeed from the Unit Auxiliary Transformer (UAT)totheESFbusses. This procedure will be completed by 9-1-90.
o The capability to close the equipment hatch without electrical power will be evaluated by the next refueling outage, o Training will be provided for licensed operators on the procedure revisions resulting from this event. In addition, Senior Reactor Operators ($Ros) will receive traininp on the mid-loop boiling and cooling mechanism.
o The capability to close the equipment hatch without electrical power will be evaluated by the next refueling outage, o
Initial training wil         be completed by 9-15-90.
Training will be provided for licensed operators on the procedure revisions resulting from this event. In addition, Senior Reactor Operators ($Ros) will receive traininp on the mid-loop boiling and cooling mechanism.
      ~
Initial training wil be completed by 9-15-90.
DRAFT 5
DRAFT
~
5


UNIT 1 STAIWS Fast 3-18 T3 4-I-90 ACTIVE LCS                           s/G est BA1E               WIT STAWS l-90-254 IFT-18. AFT-10848         NONE 3-18-90              INeli IN MIDE 6, UPPER INTERNALS SET AND RCCA's LATCHED, ECCS CHECK VALVES                                                             1-90-331 18 CREFS FLOW TEST ColfLETE, CAVilY DRAIN 00688                                                             1-90-333 FH8 RAD MON 110RS IN PROGRESS. UltlT AT MIDLOOP A1 0800.                                                         1-90-324 AIR-19910 SEISMIC
UNIT 1 STAIWS Fast 3-18 T3 4-I-90 ACTIVE LCS s/G est BA1E WIT STAWS 3-18-90 INeli IN MIDE 6, UPPER INTERNALS SET l-90-254 IFT-18. AFT-10848 NONE AND RCCA's LATCHED, ECCS CHECK VALVES 1-90-331 18 CREFS FLOW TEST ColfLETE, CAVilY DRAIN 00688 1-90-333 FH8 RAD MON 110RS IN PROGRESS. UltlT AT MIDLOOP A1 0800.
:                                                                                                                                        INSTRisENT i
1-90-324 AIR-19910 SEISMIC INSTRisENT i
i                                                                                                                                         l-90-254 IFT-18 AFT-10843          NOME 3-19-90               Ultli IN M00E 6. CAV11Y DRAINED AND i
i 3-19-90 Ultli IN M00E 6. CAV11Y DRAINED AND l-90-254 IFT-18 AFT-10843 NOME i
VESSEL HEAD SET, DECCINillIG OF VESSEL                                                           I-90-331 18 CREFS CLOSultE STUD HOLES III PROGRESS.                                                                 1-90-332 18 ESF CNILLER l
VESSEL HEAD SET, DECCINillIG OF VESSEL I-90-331 18 CREFS CLOSultE STUD HOLES III PROGRESS.
1-90-331 18 CREFS               DG18: OUT-OF-SERVICE (005) FOR OVEltHAUL 3-20-90          ' UNIT IN M00E 6 HEAD SET AND STUS                                                                                                            SINCE 2300 0F 3/13/90 TENSIGIllNG IN PROGRESS FILL Als                                                               1-90-332 18 ESF CHILLER 1-90-349 FHB PAVS A TRAIN       DGIA: 0820 BLACK 0UT STARI AIID 1 RIPPED VEllT OF LETD0001 IN Pfl0GRESS.                                                                                                              AFTER 80 SEC.
1-90-332 18 ESF CNILLER l
3-20-90
' UNIT IN M00E 6 HEAD SET AND STUS 1-90-331 18 CREFS DG18: OUT-OF-SERVICE (005) FOR OVEltHAUL TENSIGIllNG IN PROGRESS FILL Als 1-90-332 18 ESF CHILLER SINCE 2300 0F 3/13/90 VEllT OF LETD0001 IN Pfl0GRESS.
1-90-349 FHB PAVS A TRAIN DGIA: 0820 BLACK 0UT STARI AIID 1 RIPPED AFTER 80 SEC.
0841 BLACK 0UT STARTED AGAIN AND TRIPPED AFTER 70 SEC.
0841 BLACK 0UT STARTED AGAIN AND TRIPPED AFTER 70 SEC.
0856 LOCAL MR800AL EMERGENCY 8REAKGLASS START AIID MRilUAL STOP AT 1326.
0856 LOCAL MR800AL EMERGENCY 8REAKGLASS START AIID MRilUAL STOP AT 1326.
2119 START AND SIOPPED AT 2206 SWAPPING FROM " RAT 8" TO " RAT A"
2119 START AND SIOPPED AT 2206 SWAPPING FROM " RAT 8" TO " RAT A" 2223 SIART AND STOPPED AT 2228 08SERVA110ll/TROUBLESH00 TING 2233 START AII0 STOPPED AT 2254 OBSERVATI0ll/ TROUBLESHOOTING 3-21-90 Ultli IN MODE 6. HEAD SET. INVESTI-1-90-331 180REFS 0G18: START STOP GAfilIG DGIA PR06LEM, RES10 RING l-90-332 18 ESF CHILLER 2149 FAILED TO START 1-90-349 FH8 PAVS A 1 RAIN
                                                                                                                                                                          .        2223 SIART AND STOPPED AT 2228 08SERVA110ll/TROUBLESH00 TING 2233 START AII0 STOPPED AT 2254 OBSERVATI0ll/ TROUBLESHOOTING 1-90-331 180REFS              0G18: START STOP 3-21-90                   Ultli IN MODE 6. HEAD SET. INVESTI-                                                                                                   2149          FAILED TO START GAfilIG DGIA PR06LEM, RES10 RING                                                                 l-90-332 18 ESF CHILLER             '2156          FAILED TO SIART DGl8, CHARGilIG AIIS LETDOWit FILLED                                                            1-90-349 FH8 PAVS A 1 RAIN 2202   2217 STOPPED MAIIUALLY l-90-353 DGIA                         2259   2301 STOPPED MAIIUALLY VENTED Afl0 IN SERVICE DUE TO Le PESS.'
'2156 FAILED TO SIART
AIID HI F0GP                                         ,
'r DGl8, CHARGilIG AIIS LETDOWit FILLED 2202 2217 STOPPED MAIIUALLY l-90-353 DGIA VENTED Afl0 IN SERVICE 2259 2301 STOPPED MAIIUALLY DUE TO Le PESS.'
2314   2318 STOPPED MisA(LY DUE TO HI F0 n P t
AIID HI F0GP 2314 2318 STOPPED MisA(LY DUE TO HI F0 n P t
a
a
                                                                                                                                                                        ~
~
PAE l i
PAE l i


WIIIT 1 STATUS FAWI 3-13 T3 4-1-90                                               .  -  .
WIIIT 1 STATUS FAWI 3-13 T3 4-1-90 ATE apIIT STATUS ACTIVE LCO p/s 33 90 UNIT IN MODE b. HEAD IS FULLY TEN-1-90-331 18 CREFS DG18: SIART STOP SIONED. SET UP OF DGl8 IS IN PROGRESS 1-90-332 18 ESF CHILLER 0017 0023 TROU8tESH00TiltG 1-90-353 DG 1A MAIOUAL STOP 0428 0429 TROUBLESHOOTING MAlluAL STOP 0714 0730 TROUBLESHOOTING MANUAL STOP 0854 0857 TROUBLESHOOTIIIG i
apIIT STATUS                                               -
MANUAL STOP 0921 0926 TROUBLESHOOTING MANUAL STOP 0950 0955 TROUBLESHOOTING MANUAL STOP 1002 1011 TROUBLESHOOTING MAleUAL STOP 1101 1244 TRIPPE0 011 HI LO TEMP.
ACTIVE LCO                         p/s 33 ATE 90   UNIT IN MODE b. HEAD IS FULLY TEN-                               1-90-331 18 CREFS                 DG18: SIART   STOP 1-90-332 18 ESF CHILLER                   0017   0023 TROU8tESH00TiltG SIONED. SET UP OF DGl8 IS IN PROGRESS
1-23-90 UNII IN MODE 5. LOOPS NOT FILLED. PREPA-1-90-331 18 CREFS DGIA: 0254 0405 TROUBLESHOOTING RAll0NS FOR RCS FILL AND VENT ARE IN 1-90-332 18 ESF CHILLER MAIIUAL STOP 1-90-362 RCS INTEGRITY (RID 1724 1724 INADVERTANT PROGRESS.
-                                                                                  1-90-353 DG 1A                                       MAIOUAL STOP 0428   0429 TROUBLESHOOTING MAlluAL STOP 0714   0730 TROUBLESHOOTING MANUAL STOP 0854   0857 TROUBLESHOOTIIIG i
BYPASS VALVE REMOVAL)
MANUAL STOP 0921 0926 TROUBLESHOOTING MANUAL STOP 0950 0955 TROUBLESHOOTING MANUAL STOP 1002   1011 TROUBLESHOOTING MAleUAL STOP 1101   1244 TRIPPE0 011 HI
STARI CONTROL ROOM I-90-353 DGIA DG18: 0509 1202 RECEIVED 8 PHASE ISO UV RELAY ON START 1730 1733 TRIPPED Oft LO JACKET WAIER PRESS /TUR90 LO PRESS 1744 2221 1R008tESH00TIIIG MAIIUAL STOP 3-24-90 UlllT IN MODE 5. LOOPS fl0T FILLED l-90-331 18 CREFS DGIB: 0048 0121 RECEIVED TRIP CHARGING. LETDOINE A310 SEAL INJECTION 1-90-332 18 ESF CHILLER Oft HI JACKET MATER HI TEfr ALARet, ARE IN SERVICE. REPAIR TO THE RTO l-90-362 RCS INTEGRITY DGl8 SHOULD HAVE BVPASS MAllIFOLD IS C0frLETE. C018EllCING l-90-353 DGIA-TRIPPED BUT DID N01 FILL ANO VENT OF THE RCS.
* LO TEMP.
3-25-90 Utili IN MODE 5 LOOPS 110T FILLED. MID-LOOP l-90-331 18.CREFS OPERATIONS TEllMINATED AT 1900. RCS FILL I-90-332 18 ESF CHILLER AND VENT C0fetETE. PREPARING FOR ILRI.
1-90-331 18 CREFS            DGIA: 0254    0405 TROUBLESHOOTING 1-23-90   UNII IN MODE 5. LOOPS NOT FILLED. PREPA-                                                                               MAIIUAL STOP RAll0NS FOR RCS FILL AND VENT ARE IN                                 1-90-332 18 ESF CHILLER 1-90-362 RCS INTEGRITY (RID           1724 1724 INADVERTANT PROGRESS.                                                                                                               STARI CONTROL BYPASS VALVE REMOVAL)
1-90-362 RCS INTEGRITY PAGE 2 1-90-349 FHB HVAC TRAIN 8
ROOM I-90-353 DGIA                 DG18: 0509   1202 RECEIVED 8 PHASE ISO UV RELAY ON START 1730 1733 TRIPPED Oft LO JACKET WAIER PRESS /TUR90 LO PRESS 1744 2221 1R008tESH00TIIIG MAIIUAL STOP l-90-331 18 CREFS           DGIB: 0048   0121 RECEIVED TRIP               ,
3-24-90  UlllT IN MODE 5. LOOPS fl0T FILLED                                                                                      Oft HI JACKET MATER 1-90-332 18 ESF CHILLER                           HI TEfr ALARet, CHARGING. LETDOINE A310 SEAL INJECTION                                l-90-362 RCS INTEGRITY ARE IN SERVICE. REPAIR TO THE RTO                                                                                      DGl8 SHOULD HAVE l-90-353 DGIA-                                   TRIPPED BUT DID N01 BVPASS MAllIFOLD IS C0frLETE. C018EllCING FILL ANO VENT OF THE RCS.
3-25-90   Utili IN MODE 5 LOOPS 110T FILLED. MID-LOOP                                 l-90-331 I-90-332        18.CREFS 18 ESF CHILLER OPERATIONS TEllMINATED AT 1900. RCS FILL 1-90-362 RCS INTEGRITY                            PAGE 2 AND VENT C0fetETE. PREPARING FOR ILRI.                                 1-90-349 FHB HVAC TRAIN 8


INIT STATIIS                                                           ACTIVE LCS                       3/G min SAIE 3-26-90                                   UNIT IN MODE 5.                           PREPARING FOR 'lLRI         l-90-331 IB CREFS 1-90-332 18 ESF CHILLER 1-90-353 DGIA/DGl8 PREPARING FOR ILRT.         1-90-331 18 CREFS               D618: START     STOP 3-27-90                                    IIIIIT IN MODE 5.                                                                                                  1649  1822 AIR LEAKAGE IIIVESTIGATING RI VESSEL HEAD FOR                                     l-90-332 IB ESF CHILLER 1-90-353 DGIA/0G18                                     TESillIG UPPER CAIIOPY SEAL LEAK                                                                                            1909   2009 CONTROL LOGIC TESIIIIG 1951   1954 CGIITROL LOGIC TESTING 1957   1959 CGIli1IOL LOGIC
SAIE INIT STATIIS ACTIVE LCS 3/G min 3-26-90 UNIT IN MODE 5.
                                                                                                                                  '                                                    TESTIIIG 2004   2010 LAST CGIITIl0L LOGIC TEST 2220   2317 UIIDERVOLTAGE TEST DGIB: 0403      0537 $URV. IESTING PREPARING FOR ILRT. 1-90-331 15 CREFS 3-28-90                                    UNIT IN M00E 5.                                                                                                   1350  1355 FUIICT. TESillIG 1-90-332 18 ESF CHILLER TESilIIG 011 DG18 CGItLETE AIS DGIS                                                                              1356   1400 EERGEIICY STARI 1-90-353 DGIA                                          MAIISAL STOP DECLARED OPERASLE AT 1527.
PREPARING FOR 'lLRI l-90-331 IB CREFS 1-90-332 18 ESF CHILLER 1-90-353 DGIA/DGl8 3-27-90 IIIIIT IN MODE 5.
DGIA      1109    1158 T-ENG- W il ILRT IN PROGRESS. 1-90-331 18 CIIEFS i             3-29-90                                     UIlli IN IWDE 5.                                                       I-90-332 18 ESF CHILLER UV TEST PItEPARING TO RUN UV TEST 011 DGIA                                     l-90-353 DGIA DGIA:     1920   2115 EElIGElICY i
PREPARING FOR ILRT.
ILRT C9FLETE. 1-90-353 DGIA                                           START TO
1-90-331 18 CREFS D618: START STOP IIIVESTIGATING RI VESSEL HEAD FOR l-90-332 IB ESF CHILLER 1649 1822 AIR LEAKAGE UPPER CAIIOPY SEAL LEAK 1-90-353 DGIA/0G18 TESillIG 1909 2009 CONTROL LOGIC TESIIIIG 1951 1954 CGIITROL LOGIC TESTING 1957 1959 CGIli1IOL LOGIC TESTIIIG 2004 2010 LAST CGIITIl0L LOGIC TEST 2220 2317 UIIDERVOLTAGE TEST 3-28-90 UNIT IN M00E 5.
!            3-30-90                                    UIllT IN seBE 5.                                                        I-90-373 A&S FHS HVAC DGIA flugt FOR ButSLE TEST                                                                                                    PERFORM l
PREPARING FOR ILRT.
1-90-331 15 CREFS DGIB: 0403 0537 $URV. IESTING TESilIIG 011 DG18 CGItLETE AIS DGIS 1-90-332 18 ESF CHILLER 1350 1355 FUIICT. TESillIG 1356 1400 EERGEIICY STARI DECLARED OPERASLE AT 1527.
1-90-353 DGIA MAIISAL STOP i
3-29-90 UIlli IN IWDE 5.
ILRT IN PROGRESS.
1-90-331 18 CIIEFS DGIA 1109 1158 T-ENG-W il UV TEST PItEPARING TO RUN UV TEST 011 DGIA I-90-332 18 ESF CHILLER l-90-353 DGIA i
DGIA:
1920 2115 EElIGElICY 3-30-90 UIllT IN seBE 5.
ILRT C9FLETE.
1-90-353 DGIA START TO DGIA flugt FOR ButSLE TEST I-90-373 A&S FHS HVAC PERFORM l
BUSBLE TEST.
BUSBLE TEST.
2235   2241 EIIGINE RUIl FOR LOGIC TEST         '
2235 2241 EIIGINE RUIl FOR LOGIC TEST IIGIWIRL START AIS TRIP FA0H HIGN TEfr.
IIGIWIRL START AIS TRIP FA0H
                                                                                                                                                              -                          HIGN TEfr.
LUSE GIL Sitel-LAT1011.
LUSE GIL Sitel-LAT1011.
i 2313   2316 EIIGIIIE FAMII FOR LOGIC TEST 1101t-IIRL START AIID TRIP FROM HIGH VIBRATICII SiteH AI1Get
i 2313 2316 EIIGIIIE FAMII FOR LOGIC TEST 1101t-IIRL START AIID TRIP FROM HIGH VIBRATICII SiteH AI1Get


                                                                                                                                                                                                                        -1 INIIT I STATUS FRWE 3-18 10 4-I-90                                             . '
-1 INIIT I STATUS FRWE 3-18 10 4-I-90 DATE IMIT STATUS ACTIVE LCO D/G ME 3-30-90 DGIA: START STOP (CONTINUED) 2328 2334 ENGINE RUN FOR LOGIC TEST 300RMAL START AND TRIP FROM LOW LUBE Olt PRESS.
DATE                                                                   IMIT STATUS                                                       ACTIVE LCO                       D/G ME 3-30-90                                                                                                                                                                   DGIA: START   STOP (CONTINUED)                                                                                                                                                                       2328   2334 ENGINE RUN FOR LOGIC TEST 300RMAL START AND TRIP FROM LOW LUBE Olt PRESS.
SIW LATION 2343 2347 FINICTIONAL TEST FOR 900 89-VIN 057 NORMAL START AND STOP.
SIW LATION 2343   2347 FINICTIONAL TEST FOR 900 89-VIN 057 NORMAL START AND STOP.
2348 2358 FullCT100tAL lEST FOR POD 89-VlM057 (L.O. TRIP CIR-CUIT) LOCAL ENER-GENCY 8REAKGLASS START.
2348   2358 FullCT100tAL lEST FOR POD 89-VlM057 (L.O. TRIP CIR-CUIT) LOCAL ENER-GENCY 8REAKGLASS START.
3-31-90 UNIT IN MODE 5.
1-90-373 A&8 FHB HVAC                 0012   0014 FUNCT. TESI FOR 3-31-90                                                                UNIT IN MODE 5. INITIAL BUBBLE TES1 1-90-353 DGIA                                       MD0 89-VIN 057 ON DGIA IS COMPLETE. STRUT INSTALLA-                                                      ,
INITIAL BUBBLE TES1 1-90-373 A&8 FHB HVAC 0012 0014 FUNCT. TESI FOR ON DGIA IS COMPLETE. STRUT INSTALLA-1-90-353 DGIA MD0 89-VIN 057 0016 0019 F.T. FOR PWO 11011 ON 'B' RHR PUNP 15 IN PROGRESS.
                                                                                  'B' RHR PUNP 15 IN PROGRESS.
89-VIM 057 LOCAL EE RG. BREAKGLASS START 1827 1837 ENGINE RUN FOR LOGIC TEST NORMAL START AND STOP 1846 1847 ENGINE RUN LOGIC TEST STARTED'Will 2 HIGil TEW. J.W.
0016    0019 F.T. FOR PWO 11011 ON 89-VIM 057 LOCAL EE RG. BREAKGLASS START 1827   1837 ENGINE RUN FOR LOGIC TEST NORMAL START AND STOP 1846   1847 ENGINE RUN LOGIC TEST STARTED'Will 2 HIGil TEW. J.W.
SENSORS VENTING.
SENSORS VENTING.
1856   1857 STARIED W 2 H.T.J.W. SENSOR 5 VENTING.
1856 1857 STARIED W 2 H.T.J.W. SENSOR 5 VENTING.
                                                                                                                                                                .                1904   1906 STARTED W 2 J.T.J.W. SENSORS VENilNG.
1904 1906 STARTED W 2 J.T.J.W. SENSORS VENilNG.


                                                                                                                                                                                      ~'
~'
UNIT I ST;TUS FMM 3-18 TO 4-1-90                                                               *        .
UNIT I ST;TUS FMM 3-18 TO 4-1-90 SAIE WIT STA1WS
                                                                                      ~
~
SAIE        WIT STA1WS                                                        ACTIVE LC0             D/s 33 3-38-90                                                                                               DGIA: START STOP (CONTINUED)                                                                                                   1921 1922 STARIED W LOW PRESS. J. W.
ACTIVE LC0 D/s 33 3-38-90 DGIA: START STOP (CONTINUED) 1921 1922 STARIED W LOW PRESS. J. W.
SENSOR VENTING.
SENSOR VENTING.
1955 2012 ENGINE RUN FOR                   f LOGIC TEST NOR-MAL START Alt           '
1955 2012 ENGINE RUN FOR f
SIfRILATED TRIP.         ,I t.-
LOGIC TEST NOR-MAL START Alt SIfRILATED TRIP.
2253 2320 UNDERVOLTAGE TESTi.1 4-01-90     UNIT IN MODE 5. UV TEST Oft DGIA IS                               1-90-373 A&B FHB HVAC         0423 0556 $URVEILLAllCE 1EST$
,I t.-
CWFLETE. PREPARIIIG FOR IBA03 SWITCH-                                                                             PROCEDURE 14980-1**
2253 2320 UNDERVOLTAGE TESTi.1 4-01-90 UNIT IN MODE 5.
GEAR OUIAGE DGIA OPERA 81LITY TE;ST IS CopFLETED AND DECLARED DGIA OPERA 8tE AT                                                                                                   "
UV TEST Oft DGIA IS 1-90-373 A&B FHB HVAC 0423 0556 $URVEILLAllCE 1EST$
1154.                                                                                                                                   i' E
CWFLETE. PREPARIIIG FOR IBA03 SWITCH-PROCEDURE 14980-1**
i:
GEAR OUIAGE DGIA OPERA 81LITY TE;ST IS CopFLETED AND DECLARED DGIA OPERA 8tE AT 1154.
i' E
.!i:
l'.
l'.
11 D
11 D
PAGE S
PAGE S
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ _________                                    _    _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _}}
>}}

Latest revision as of 06:06, 14 December 2024

Applicant Exhibit A-10,consisting of 920803 Request for FOIA documents,920909 Response Ltr & Documents Listed in App a
ML20083C914
Person / Time
Site: Vogtle  Southern Nuclear icon.png
Issue date: 04/17/1995
From: Lamberski J
TROUTMANSANDERS (FORMERLY TROUTMAN, SANDERS, LOCKERMA
To:
References
OLA-3-A-010, OLA-3-A-10, NUDOCS 9505230077
Download: ML20083C914 (34)


Text

L Jp-y M 9'2 5 - W H fnl97

,/'{}

DOCKETfr0 Exnia:T to USHPflCCOY EX. H i

TROUTMANSANDERS

. 7.J,.??.".N.."..*..*o, ^..! :..h.^g tmY -3 P Z 4 I

^

NATIONSSANM PLAZA 0FFICE.cf SECRETARY n.c-ine svarer ~ s. swer uw 4rca~ta. croaoi* suos 2:a 00CKEIING i q-RVICE recepwoNe 4o ens ' "

BRAHCH racsets som ses **

.&N LAMBER $wl OIRECT 404 885 3360 August 3, 1992 Mr. Donnie H. Grimsley, Director Division of Freedom of Information i

and Publications Services l

Office of Administration U.

S.

Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 Re:

Freedom Of Information Act Recuest

Dear Mr. Grimsley:

I hereby request, pursuant to the federal Freedom of Information Act ("FOIA"), 5 U.S.C.

S 552, as amended, and Nuclear j

Regulatory Commission ("NRC") regulations, 10 C.F.R. Part 9, copies of all " records," as that term is defined in 10 C.F.R. 9.13, constituting, or relating to, eight (8) specific documents which were provided by Georgia Power Company ("GPC") employees to j

the NRC Incident Investigation Team ("IIT") which investigated the March 20, 1990 site area emergency at Plant Vogtle.

The eight specific records I am requesting are identified on the September 14, 1990 " bibliography," provided by NRC to GPC and identifying documents collected by the IIT, as follows:

17.

Order to quarantine 1

31.

Maintenance Work Order (MWO) 19001576, 3/28/90 (D/G 1A) j 34.

List of Quarantined Equipment (Revised 3/29/90 Rev. 2) 155. Quarantined Equipment List, Rev. 4 - 4/2/90 l

178. D/G Temperature Switch Calibration Data Received from Licensee - 4/6/90 180. D/G (1A/1B) Start Logs l

210. Failures of Calcon Temperature & Pressure Sensors at Vogtle 1 & 2 336. Draft " Corrective Actions for Site Area Emergency" and Unit 1 Status Report from 3-18 to 4-1-90 (submitted by licensee) 9505230077 950417 PDR ADOCK 05000424 g

PDR

g 4

,t L'

NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ss~nas-oLA-2 Docket No._ k 12 5

  • 4 Official Exh. No. 5" 10 in the matter of_ Uen t le Staff 4,;+s n2 IETNTiflED s-Applican!

RECElVED r

Intervenor REJECTED Contg Otfr Contractor D ATE _ __ 09-/7-9s-Other Wit;:ess

& (o.,

Repotter 1 2,'/t.4 3 A.*

r.-

TROUTMAN SANDERS

.u.:.sa wa In addition to the above request for eight specific records, I request copies of all records, as defined above, evidencing or relating to the date and time when each of the eight specific i

records listed above were received by the NRC.

For your information, I understand that the requested records are or may be in the possession of the administrative assistant to the IIT, Ms. Cherie Siegel, or one of the IIT members: Al Chaffee, Rick Kendall, Bill Lazarus, Bill Jones, Mike Jones, Warren C.

Lyon, Harvey Wyckoff, Paul E. Dietz, Garmon West or Gene Traeger.

I am willing to pay the applicable charges for production of the requested records in accordance with 10 C.F.R. Part 9 up to a maximum amount of $500.00 and those charges in excess of $500.00 of which I am notified, and which I approve, in advance.

If you have any questions concerning this FOIA request, please feel free to contact me.

Very ruly urs John Lamberski 4

f 1

i v,..,n..~,.-...'..

....__.m..

FOlA - p -3Srf i

/"*g t

u seO~si n,.

RESPONSE TO FREEDOM OF

.ki w' I l e=='

e i,

INFORMATION ACT (FOIA) REQUEST o*15 s 's SEP 9 - 1992 oOCoT ~uMaimisi mme,

~~'Wa-Nn 2d sN V

PdRT 3.-AGENCY RECORDS RELEASED OR NOT LOCATED iSee enecaea conesi No agency records subject to the request have been located.

No additional agency records subject to the request have been located.

Requested records are available through another pubhc distribution program. See Comments section.

M are already available for pubhc inspection and copying at tne Agency records subject to the request that are identified in Apper@ utes)

[

NRC Pubhc Document Room,2120 L Street. N W.. Washmgton. DC.

Agency records subject to tre request that are identified in Appendiatesi are being made avaitable for pubhc mspection and copymg at the NRC Pubhc Document Room. 2120 L Street. N W., Washington, DC. 6n a folder under this FOI A number.

The nonproprietary version of the proposal (s) that you agreed to accept m a telephone conversation with a member of my staff is now bemg made availaole for pubhc mspection and copymg at the N RC Public Document Room 2120 L Street, N.W., Washmgton, OC,in a folder under this FOI A number.

Agency records subject to the request that are identified in Appendix (es) may be inspected and copied at the N RC Local Public Document Room identified in the Comments esction.

E nclosed is mformation on how you may obtam access to and the charges for copymg records located et the NRC Public Document Room,2120 L Street, N W. Washmoton, DC.

Agency records subiect to the request are enclosed.

Records subject to the request have been referred to another Federal agencylies) for review and direct response to you.

i f

Fees You will be billed by the NRC for fees totaling 5 You will receive a refund from the NRC in the amount of 5 In view of N R C*s response to this request, no further action is bemg taken on appeal letter dated

, No.

i PART 11. A-INFORMATION WITHHELD FROM PUBLIC DISCLOSURE Certain information in the requested records is being withheld from public disclosure pursuant to the euomptions described in and for the reenons stated in Part 11, B, C, and D. Any rolessed portions of the documents for which only part of the record is being withheld are beme made evellable for public inspection and copying in the NRC Pubelc Document Room,2120 L Street, N.W., Washington, DC in a folder under th6s FOIA number, COMMENTS g i := -;'

Mw A i

1 51G E. DIR ECTOR. Olvisa F REEDOM OF INFORMATION AND PUBLICATIONS SERvlCES A

p 3..

.T

- *s 4.

V=

a., O

.e..

' a'

.,[.

  • r I *

{[f

  • .v.

s

,.,,e NAC FORM 464 IPart il (t.gt)

Ret FOIA-92-388 APPENDIX A RECORDS MAINTAINED AMONG PDR FILES G/

NUMBER QAIR DESCRIPTION 1.

3/28/90 Order to quarantine (#17) (2 pages) 2.

3/28/90 Maintenance Work Order (MWO) 19001576

(#31) (4 pages) 3.

3/29/90 Quarantined Equipment List, Rev. 2 (#34)

(2 pages) 4.

4/2/90 Quarantined Equipment List, Rev. 4

(#155) (1 page) 5.

Undated D/G Temperature Switch Calibration Data

(#178) (2 pages) 6.

Undated DG (1A/1B) Start Logs (#180) (6 pages) 7.

Undated Failures of Calcon Temperature &

Pressure Sensors at Vogtla Units 1 & 2

(#210) (3 pages) 8.

Undated Draft Corrective Actions for Site Area Emergency with attached Unit 1 status from 3/18 - 4/1/90 (#336) (10 pages)

[

C 5 -l }- 9 ^-

(<_.

12:40 p.m.

3/28/90 I ordered Jiany Cash to quarantine the following:

Trip disk pack for Unit 1 ERF that was collected during, immediately prior to, and-immediately following the event.

-=

Jimmy will check if any proteus data exist. Hisunderstandingisthath the data have been overwritten.

If these data exist, they are also quarantined.

Warren L' yon s

&$h

,' 9;f /f/

c>wn

&- f

-y

. <, - n.c du.- u

//.s, j h A ?L.

l

e daA' zr : =

_? = f a n k A $

f 4 D pdf Um ar An sind Ap, MMSf M, d&-Q

$1 A" W-M

? 4fe u

~-

a6 &.

,45e'?

M e,

~s

/"

$ka

%*o COVER SHEET l

M'403 19001576 DATE: 03/28/90 SYSTEM:

2403 --

FORIMAN:

Mwo OVIAGE REQUIRED:

CLEARANCE:

YES No X

PARTS REQUIRED:

NO o f-U- ?C I

5 TATJS i

__6 0 C RCN1 JCOP PRIORITY CODE:

1 4

PRIORITY MODE PIANT ~ -

STATUS RESTRAINT RESTR CONTROL FIELD:

YA S C

-4 S q g, gy g

.;. x,

STATUS p -wwgg -tc COMMENTS G - - -

D

u..u m

^-

6W 89

  • h 95 ' M teme e9.ess -

6 m.

eMG*

4.

3

4

  • COPY *
  • 0 "?Y *
  • COPY *
  • COPY *
  • COPY *
  • COPY *
  • C0FY *
  • 0* FY *
  • CCPY ** C;7.

NUCLEAR PLAS! MAINTENANCE WORK ORDER (1 CF 3)

1. CONTROL NO. 19001576 00 2.DATE 03/28/90
3. UNIT 1
4. SYSTEM LIST 5.MPI/ TAG NO. LIST SA. REPAIR TAG MPL/ TAG (S) ASSOCIATED WITH SPECIAL INDICATORS 4*vt
6. PRO 5/ DIESEL GENERATOR 1A TRIPPED TWICE FOLLOWING 'IVO ACTJAL IDSS OF O WORK START CONDITIONS.

THE TRIPS ACCURRED AFTER APPROXIMATELY 80 SECONDS REQ.

AND 70 SECONDS OF OPERATION.

e.NPRDe*

C0HT.

N

7. INITIATOR KEN STOKZS 8.SUPRV JP REDDING IDC LIST 9.NWO CIASS S EQP CLASS LIST 10. UNIT STA'f,,,,, _,, _,,

ET P 11.FIM PR07BCT N 12.DCR N 13.HCR/DR H

14. TYPE MAI 15.DURATICH
16. CRAFT MICH(EST/ AC"fi ELEC(EST/ACT)'I!EST/ACT)

CONT (EST/ACT) HP/0T(EST71"E.

CREW 0

0 6

0 0

HRS.

ON. ~~~~

_~

EXP.

0 0

-0' SCKED EN

~

~

~

.,,,f

=JT QC REVIEWED SY ~ 20. PROC '

e,Etr,-

e w aan-19.QC HOLD PTS

,,,_/,,,,f,,,, 21. PRI 14 33.3.40 23.WORX

  • INST..

SEE CONTINUATION SHEET COOPER ENERGY TO PERFORM WORK UNDER P.0 $6002124.

CCHT.

Y


----- 2 4. I N ITI ATE REVI EW ------------

25.8PEC REV REQ H OPS DATE DATE,,,f,,,f [ MNT DATE j

,,,j,,,, f ENG,__,, DATE __f,,,,,,,f[S I C.= = = = 2 6.MWO RELEAS E FOR WO HP j

DATE _ /,,,/.,

21 AT wcu PERTRMED ~

_, i__

,,,,,,,,,,[

,,,,, [,,'7,~

~

.. =

N HIST SUN '

~

28.HTRL RIQD

~

29. PERSON PERFORMINo woRx(NAME)

DATE 30.nAIFITWKRCE roRIMAN DAff" 31.YRDY27Y5K 7tKFORxtD sY

,,,,jd 32.NETHOD OF F.T.

DAT:

33. PROCEDURE f -

34.FERTOMED BY 35.DATE,,,,j,,,) ~

34.PROYES OPERABILITY ~ 39.!P UN8AT.COM. ACTION 37.METH00 USED TO PRON 30.8ATISTY./UNSAT18FY

40. UNIT STATUS AT TIHt*0P FA! LURE '

41.TYPt FAlt.

43. MODE OF FAIL 43.CAUs2 or FAILURE 44.DE'ttCT BY (l.tFFECT CH 8V8 "~~

~~

4 6.27P ON PLANT ~ ~ II.0PER. ACCEPT ST a *-477M90 STAT 40 48

"~

~

"" ~ '"" 49.CORA ACT. TE ~,,"fD,,,,

lo.NEW MWO OA 53.0808 APPROVAL DATE,,,j j S3.8PEC MV COMP DATE

/,,,/,,,, 54.MIET.f BKT5,,,,j.,/...,

SS.CIAst OUT APPROVAL BY QC

a

    • copy ** 7:TY ** COPY ** CCPY ** COPY ** CCT-

==C0py e.

7

,, ecpy.. e;p NUCLEAR PLANT MAINTENANCE WORK CRDER (CONTINUII,e (2 0F 3)

CONTROL No. 19001576 00 MPL/ TAC No.

SYSTEM EQP CLS DESCRUPTION L::CCATION 12403G4001 2403 015 DIESEL GENERA!TDR 1DCGB1-12403PSDC2 2403 11J DG 1A ENGINE C:2lTRL PNL 10cGB1

~," Ar,

'I a.

l

y: ;y n w ?

e i

v

    • COPY **

NUCLfAR P:.J.:;T MAINTENANCE WORK ORDER::PY *

  • C PY *
  • COPY *
  • COPY *
  • CC CCTY ** :: T *.

(CONTINUED)

(3 CT 3)

CONTROL No. 19001576 00 WORK INSTR.crIONS: PERFORM ENGINE 14GIC TESTING PER PROCIDURE 27563-C, C00PER ENERGY SERVICES PERSONNEL WILL BE PERFORMI REV 2.

ABLE PROTIONS OF THE PROCEDURE WITH ASSISTANCE FROM O FIRSONNEL, AS REQUIRED.

PROCEDURE NEED NOT BE RETESTED.THE ELECTRICAL PORTI ADDITIONAL INSTRUNENTATION MAY BE CONNECTED BY TEST PERSONNEL TO AID IN TROUBL ANY INSTRUMENTATION CONNECTED OR Ath.USTMENTS MADE S 7

DOCUMENTED COMPLETELY ON THIS MWO.

ENCOUNTERED WHILE PERFORMING THIS TEST. DOCUMENT ANY ITEP 1:

FOI24 WING THE IAGIC TEST THE ENGINE WILL BE STARTED IN THE EMERGENCY MODE AND A LEAX TEST PERFORMED ON TH LINES: it. * .*

E-ICA

  • TRIP I4N PRESSURE 2 8E OIL 3-C-

E-16A - TRIP HIGH TEMPERATURE JACRET MATER 2-j C-

{

I-68

- TRIP HICH PRESSURE CRANKCASE E-92

- TRIP I4W PRESSURE TURSO OIL E TRIP IAN PRE 85URE JACKET NATER E-23H - TRIP HICH VIBRATION E-19

- TRIP MIGH TEMPERATURE ENGINE IEARINCS E 18

- TRIP HIGH TEMPERATURE WBE CIL.

TEST FOR LEARAGE SY DISCONNECTING ttit!NC AT CONTR BULIQlEAD AND CONNEC'?!NC PNEUMATIC SUBI*.E TESTER.

CBSERVE TESTER FOR AIR F14W WHEN LINE IS PREsf*!RIZED.

RESTORE TUSING CONNECTION AT BU1.$NEAD AND CONIINUE WITH NEXT INSTRUMENT LINE.

IIEP 92 NCRMAL START

-IRIP SY HI-TEMP WSE O!L IIEP $3 LosP START (JUMPER IN CEN CONTPOL PANEL 211 70 2132

-IRIP SY HIGH VI& RATION ItEP #4 NORMAL START

-TRIP BY H!cH PRESS CRANECASE ITEP $5 SI START (JUMPER IN CEN. CONTROL PANEL 20

-TRIP SY 2 0F 3 L.O. PRES 8URE

~

NOTE fME AREA 0F TESTING SHALL RE R0 PED AND ENTRANCE EastNTIAL PERSONNEL AS OtTERM!NED BY C00PF.R MPRE8ENTA AND GPC EN0!NEERING.

8PC ENGINEERING SHALL DE PRt3ENT FOR ALL TESTING REPRESENTATIVE PRESENT AS REQUIRED.

  • /p.

'1lWlU l

Page 1 of 2 QUARANTINED EQUIP 9ENT LIST REY. 2 NA 7140 J

ATTENTION oI-3'l-9o At all times, the licensee is responsible for quarantined equipment and can take ar. tion involving this equipment it deems necessary to:

Achieve or maintain safe plant conditions.

- ' Prevent further equipment degradation, or Test or inspect, as required by the plant's Technical Specifications.

To the maximum degree possible, these actions should be coordinated with the i

l Team Leader in advance, or notification made as soon as possible.

I Effective Time: 241000 MAR 90 The Licensee is maintaining the following Items Quarantined:

1.

POL Truck (A11ouable to use for normal deliveries) 2.

230 KV Insulator to Reserve Auxiliary Transformer IA (Broken on 20 MAR 90) 3.

All replaced CALCON Switches for IA 818 Olesel Generators 4.

ERF recorded Tri by J. P. Cash.) p Package - Unit 1 (NOTE: Database memory tape meintained The following restrictions concerning Of esel generator troubleshootirig, repair, and testing are agree to:

(This appites to DG A 4 DG B except as noted) 1.

Any component replacements will be concurred with by the Team Leader prior to perfoming the work.

All replaced components vill be retained until released by the Tome Leader.

2.

The followin test procedures will be reviewed by t w team prior to perfomance: g a.

1B UV Test b.

IA UV Test (#1) c.

1A UV Test (#2) 3.

The following tests will be announced to the team leader, or a designated representative. 4 hours4.62963e-5 days <br />0.00111 hours <br />6.613757e-6 weeks <br />1.522e-6 months <br /> prior to initiation.

It will not be performed untti approved by the Team Leader.

a.

It Sequencer Test b.

IB UV Test c.

IA UV Test (#1) d.

1A UV Test (#2)

.,-r--

,c-

=

Page 2 of 2 QUARANTINED EQUIP 9ENT LIST The following personnel will not take vacation untti approved by the Team Leader (normal off days are not restricted):

All Operations Department Management a.

b.

All operators (Itcensed and non-Itcensed) in the C,arations Department who were on duty during the 20 Mar 90 event c.

All Event critique Team members SUBMITTED BY:

Mapser fixgr DATE:

77/d 29 /990 EXTENSION:

3759 BEEPER: /JB 0

Cb 5-/Sf~9' QUARANTINED EQUIPMENT LIST Revision 4, Dated April 2, 1990 ATTENTION At all times, the licensee is responsible for quarantined equipment and can take action involving this equipment it deems necessary to:

Achieve or maintain safe plant conditions, Prevent further equipment degradation, or Test or inspect, as required by the piant's Technical Specifications.

To the ma ximum degree possible, these actions should be coordinated with the Team Leader in advance, or notification made as soon as possible.

Except for the above, no licensee action is authorized on quarantined equipment without IIT team approval.

The IIT team will concur in the licensee's action plan for each trouble shooting quarantine item.

Upon approval the licensee will implement this plant and ensure the IIT team leader or designee is informed as agreed to in each action' plan.

The licensee is maintaining the following items Quarantined:

1.

All suspect components identified after initiation of the event associated with the starting or tripping of the 1A and 18 D/G.

I IIT TEAM LEADER 4-2.-10 Al Cha'ffee Date SUBMITTED BY H. L. Beacher Date EXTENSION 3769 BEEPER 138 4

4

7 j

f.

ITSH19153 LUBE OIL HIGH TEMPERATURE SWITCH DG1B Prior calibration was performed on 3/14/90.

At that time the switch was found out of tolerance with an as found of 300 'F to trip and 199 'F to reset. It was calibrated ar d returned to semcc with a trip of 199 ;? and a reset of 191 'F. It was removec from service on 3/23/90 as the suspectec, cause of DG1B tri switch, calibration was checked and would not calibrate within tolerance. p. The It was placed in storage on 3/23/90.

SWITCH TWO This switch was placed in service on 3/23/90 with a trip of 203.4 'F and a reset of 198.0 'F.

On 3/27/90 it was removed from service and it's calib checked. As found was 203.5 'F to trip ar d 199.5 degrees to reset. However, ration it was found to be venting continuously anc, suasequently replaced. The old switch was placed in storage on 3/27/90.

1THS19146 LUBE OIL HIGH TEMPERATURE SWITCH l

DGIA Prior calibration was performed on 3/3/90. At that time it was found out of tolerance with a trip point of 211.0 *;? and a reset of 203.1 'F The switch was I

calibrated and returned to service wita a trip point of 200.2 'F and a reset of 193 degrees On 3/30/90 the switch was removed for calibration ar.d found out of tolerance i

Tne switch also o,erated with a trip $oint of 190.4 'F and a reset of 188.0 'F. d to trip point of 201.27 'F sluggishly.

t was replaced with a new switch calibrate and a reset of 196.20 'F. The new switch was returned to service. The original j

switch is in storage.

ITSH19117 JACKET WATER HEATER OUT HIGH TEMPERATURE SWITCH DG1B Prior calibration on 3/14/90 was within tolerance with a trip point pf 201 'F and a reset of 193 'F. h was found out of tolerance with a trip point of 190.6 and a On 3/26/90 switc reset of 182.4. Further investigation determined a small leak. A new switch also failed leak test. A third switc3 calibrated correctly with a trip noint pf 200.67 degrees and a reset of 196.93 'F and was returned to service. The o'ld switches are i

in storage.

1TSH19119 JACKET HEATER OUT HIGH TEMPERATURE SWITCH 1

n tolerance with a trip point of 200f r calibration on 3/14/90 was t

and a reset of 194 'F' switch was found out of tolerance w int of188.2 y On 3/26/90 the eset.of 180.6 'F. Further investigation determinect a smali

.A Was ino'aerable due to a missin gasket. A third switch was ca point of T.98.57 and a reset 191.f0 and returned to service. Old swt ge.

A m

--w

g g, g y -y

..w

. ;. n...

05-/7i-99 i

l 1"SH19153 LUBE OIL HIGH "gPgRATURE SWITCH Prior, calibration.vas cerformed on 3/14/90.

At that time che switch was found out or tolerance with ah as found of 300 'F to tric and 199 'F to reset. It was calibrated and returned to aenice with a trip of 199 'T and a reset of 191 'F. It was removed from service on 3/23/90 as he suspectea cause of DG1B trip. The switch calibration was checked sad woul not calibrate within tolerance. It was placed in storage on 3/23/90.

SWITCH TWO This switch was placed in service on 3/23/90 with a trip of 203.4 'F and a reset o 198.0 'F.

On 3/27/90 it was removed from senice and its calibration chec'.se. As found was 203.5 'F to tno ar}d 199.5 degrees to reset. Swever. it was founc The old swicen was

' placea.to be venting continuously and suosequently raplaced.

in storage on 3/27/90.

1THS19148 LUBE OIL HIGH TEMPERATURE SWITCH DGIA Prior calibration was per~ormed on 3/3/90. At that time it was found out of r.oierance with a :np point of 211.0 *F ano a reset of 203.1 'F The switch was l

calibrated and returned to sen-ice with a trip point of 200.2 *F and a reset of 193 degrees On 3/30/90 the switch was rfmoved for calibration and found out o The switch also coeratea oint of 190.4 'F anc a reset of 188.0 'F. d to trip comt of 201.27 *.

with a trip t was replaced with a new switch calibrate sluggishly.

ano a reset of 196.20"F. The new switch was returned to service. The originat switch is in storage.

ITSH19117 JACKET WATER HEATER OUT HIGH TEMPERATURE SWITCH DG1B Prior calibration on 3/14/90 was within tolerance with a trip point pf 201 'F

.ina a reset of 193 'F.

On 3/26/90 switch was found out of tolerance with a trip da f,aileo.of 152.4. Further investigation determined a sm reset A new switch also leax, test. A thira awiten calibrated correctly with a trio goint of 200.67 cegrees anc a reset of 196.93 'F and was returned to service. The old switches are m storage.

ITSH19119 JACKET HEATER OUT HIGH TEMPERATURE SWITCH DG1B Prior calibration on 3/14/90 was within tolerance with a trip point of 200 (F and a reset of 194 F.

'th a t '

oint of 188.2 'F and a,On 3/26/90 the switch was found out of tolerancereset of 180.6 'F. Furthe ak. A new switen was inoaerable due to a missin asket. A third switch was calibrated with a tnp point of 1.98.57 and a reset 191.

and returned to service. Old switches are in storage.

)

c S-/Pc-)

+

O 5 -i10 -] C s-es-se w ee

-3. :. s. a 3:e-:

-2n.c2 DGIA 1

1TI T':I S ;'JCED s.12-90 0 00 iTARID 3 17 TID TO GRID 1345

'.cADC TO 7600 W u.

3 55 Car 145 To eS*o W 1;25 RDDVD FP/m PAM IL ~0 GC::

D SLTTYE4 BUS W.C::

l

. !.3 7APr ' " "O CRID

.:125 OL'ITLTI 2PJJFI?. WC3 r.! NL!.

FO3 FER ! CG-90-3 2127

>M

.'. I ' - f) n09 STAR *c UO!?

0*JIFLT BRFA:CR CLD3ED 3032 F. O. PIACED 0:1 REC;74. PCR 00 5. SIRY (257 C#2 0'.*:CT D3007 M712. CPI?.COR C' C0:frTC R02:.r.ACO MQ: Of PAPp'"- 005, AND BEGd:

CGEASING *.4AD IC 7000 W 0301 tc/O > 6800 W 0310 IT ',AS DLTC9tDED TET DG'A sVITQ*D 10 C.*IT lODI AS A RIS'/ T OF SPFC.AL SE.** WJER TEl" ?DCDUPI BY CiGO EEP.EU.

0502 0'JI?LT 3RIA>2R OPD:

0506 5;C7?ID C509 P".ACD IN !fAC. DWC DDI T

W 1320

.. -1*HE TAKn! 077 RECIRC. -

RE5LI.T SAT.

  • CT E
    411 starts unless ot.,erwise noteo are cp C' -

fec't the Control Asom 1

ye.

04-04-30 ;4: M T-r ',; Et. "a 52

~T:':' mI31. 50:

DG1A Tilt TE E CMitD 3390 03;C

!4SP 'IC'JFJiED. IDST "A" PAT

- DCIA UE AND ~RIPPE '

(SE'.DA:. A!A4!

  • T - lCT J
DTI2) 2: DGE :DG) 084'.

AUIO ST/JtITD /JTER SEC2CER RESET A!O ~1t1FPC CN 10.!

J/oI" k'A;Ilt PRESSt5tE 0S56 D E 34CY 3?J.AK G. ASS HAKI

_0CU1.Y "O ?IAII/IP. 95WWt = ="

STA~':C:1 Best Cl.T. D/G IS

%TTd'ING THt', 4100 KV TPAO' "A" : nap N wi

.'029 tRAT "B" DEI *ID) 10I.0 (13A03 ENDG:ZD !?2 "S" ?AT) 1155 Dic 1A P! ACED McK C( hh%I

-i l

l 1157

. IAA02 A1.15.M: 0:CQEG 3REAXDL CIDSD ::i PARAlil:.tc DICG1A) l

.211

'.AADD ':0 6800 cl 10 SE Ett IIR 45 MU.*Cs.S Dt.T TO LIE

'DD CFDAUCN 1324 TIE BRLy3R C?D 1326 SHtC OWN 1405 FLACD :: STA!;DBY ?IADC.TSS 1700 D/C DECIARED OD?ERAF.1.E 1741 (BAT "A" DEIID) 2031 D/C Of.Mf:E;ANCE !CI TCR

CISIGI CHEC BEFORE E'll 2

i l,

(

4

' W i-tC N n 7-i < i.f. ~i iii. T :_:a

~

t DCIA xW tw wD1) 3-it, - D 1 14 3 D.RC 21:2 CLT.T SFf/03 51f5.c s'C;;,.7 W.02 2205

'7EFtt" 5AF#3. 07E:i t2:6 3Ht.D3.11 12:3 mT/J.TC 1:23 SECL1E 2231 ST/JL"ED 225'.

SECL'FE 3-2; 90 2210 JAOr ETER AND LL3I 0*I. }ZE?

  • iGCl 3YSTO3 SifJitA?! TO SU??37 MAUWWK2

.:: lEC'.%"I :DDE 7;.'R :D"ST.?E A

> L2 0 0227 CYD*

0251

DIS'It?2 OEQ* Jt712"I 40

?I.AC"D h'J. 1:::0 STR O2Y 0256 SJRITD FOR !!A.2TDM'"I TRO'.T.I.

5 DOT 3G '

0219 0'.~73 22J23. SFR dig ~1ED "C CRID

% 50 PLCD BAQ* ON 5".RO3Y 1100E 1714 1".'ARTD NC !WCAtl.Y $~IU??ID.

tRai C.R.

s.

es -

M

Oa-N -92.4: 01

  • -E ; 5'.!?

f *,: ~~ i :. ' -e_

DGlB DATE THE SJJtIED 3-13-90 1440 TAKD: TO IDCAL mR l01SRlRE OECK 1512 IN AUIO STR4DBY.' DIS ~~M CHECK 00tf L T 1518 START MR MAIhT. TEST 1634 T'.D TO GRID - ICFM INCQUNG BREAKER RD DVED TO 'BA03 1717 IDAD 6800 KW 1838 RtMTING l

3-14-90 0120 BECAN LMDADriG D/G 13 0142 DISCONNECTED TAG 4 i*dE GRID 0146 STOPPED 0149 TOOK 10 IDCAL AND P' ACED Hi RAINT. WILL BE TAGGED GJT 0401 OPERAB2.I"*Y TEST CCtT*R AND SAT FOR D/G 1B 3-21-90 2149 FAILED TO START DUF. 20 DISLTFICIENT WEL IN FUEL LINES AFIER MAIh7ENANCE.

2156 FAILED 10 START AGAIN 2202 STARTED AND 00'ER:0 VEhTED 2217 STOPPED 1

NOTE: All stnets unless otherwise noted are from the Control Room

DG1B t

DATE TI!E STARTD 03-21-90 2259 STARID D/G 1B FOR OVERSPEED TRIP TEST 2301 STOPPED MA1CAI.LY DUE TO IDJ i.UBE OIL PRESSURE AND HIGi OIL FILTER AP 2314 STARTED 2318 STOPPED

+

3-22-90 0017 STAItIED 0023 SIDPPED 70R !!AINIEWICE 0350 IN !%DT? ANCE ! ODE EDR I

IOISIURE QECK 0428 OUT OF MAIICENAt:CE I4XIOUI, MOISIURE CHECK CQ7LUED 0428 STARIED FDR TESTLNG 0429 STOPPED l

0714 IDCALI.Y STARTD FOR :'AINTD ANCE AND E2iGI1ERING TESTH1G 1030 IDCALLY SHUIIXAH 1106 STAICED FROM C.R.

1112 TIE BREAKER C:ESED '

1135 LOAD > 6800 %*

1 1243 TRIPP D ON D/G HIGH LUBE OIL TD2

\\

l l

4 2

.g 4

J

.c

+.

z

,;4-+1..:.;+ -i~;5 3

~ M+-: 3 :IM W L

i DC1B

'.C
  • 71E Shw

~2-24-D 0443

?UISn3Z CIC: STKn22D 0500 inIsn:RE CHE s 03:FLt'.'r.

0!M SU.RD FOR lR".*J2WC FF.; AlfD SW~~d UFERAZR lCTITID 0514 T.*C C) GtID. CJIF:T BPE/u"ZR I

E1C 0329 CL**.* IMDED (7000 n!)

1145 l4AD '.f.'CRFASE M ?$00 i~d I;53 LCAD.U.LA?E T3 63M C

'.153 TIE 1ET. DR ;002 lmD'

'1 FEJE.'TIO:s TFE' 1B IE2mG

'.202 EE??!2)

' ' y-STARTD s'ut t let, m U~1 "RIPPC rh LW JAS"!. "ATIF.

T PREE5'3E/2:280 L'.*BE 02, I

PRE 55'24 Lui

)

JM

~ STARTD FtR 4 ICL RLt:

1755 TID E QtID 1819 U%DED 10 6803 KW i

1%2 KJt :::G "DR PADCIWC ?$

i i

2222 ATIER *.ADI:3 II t*AS i

DISCO::iElfi E r M THE G ID i

KO DIIl5EL 18 S"C??E; 1

222=

EIA@ 2lIMUIRU78.Q2!EE FOR 1R'.27112u:CE

.:3 7

'DISRIE CFIG STARIE 3

l

..y 7

7.w.,--

c-,-.

..r

,,,,.,,.m,

,,--.,w-----,---

OS-eve

  • !s!!*$

I i

i 81 I

veng

ln i'
!is:I!

. i i

it!5 avi s-r a

a gan.3

-e

!!!t I I

s5Es]

,l'gl lj!g=jg ws5g58l

!!tl 3

II E8 ai

-g.

s3g 8 EE 35E F s *!g.

g

! ~!g,

i,g I_I','

g;3 g

D egIstN g E s :.. E :-

g l s c..

  • F w

.^

I E

u g

N y 3,sijl ae:

la!iils s!iiii niiil; lia!

sisialisl!

g si 5

.m:

E55 2NA !~ll s!

!g s

s E

i 198 8 instt alttstt I;Ii i!

!5!

s E

5tt 5ts!,,

5 Eng i !!EXE sgIEg!E 5!8lER E=jji=sEEI!!!

g 5EEg :

l5En EEEE!EE ESEEEEE Ei!IEE s

e l as i

i 21 l IIli l 1

l it I

EIR i

s SI I

a !

I e I s I gg I

si g

al i nl =i j

al =i e-e-

e e-I la s i me i nui!

I an I s

-al Is in!ii!_

is.ji a

s s il

'!!ltii'"

I isi ii!

Ba ssal4E:

N las anI!

III il 55 gI ga, sigI-i

=

a

!a g II 3

lI E gg ii us!

n=I g

j e n=

e s: Ii Ifl ill asNs' E

EzlI l

E E

E E

E S

5 s s

s

=

=

[E

~.

t it C

s.,

s..

I.i gt t

e

.i i

I! b

!k i k is E si as; 11 s s is is is is

!in sti

! s*u*s*sisi!gg!EI!9"5g.32!ajg,,,!eg

-!I*ggg I

- 3 g

8 saI tit Ia st-instisiil; 12 siill=:i;l gg.

! !s 5 5 g fgIl e

a j!E

!!E I

5

=

! e:!!ig3

  • 3 s

e8Est

=In y=Rs

! y ngm!*e5 5 =,i! as g*l:E

=l:5

= In j

553 pl

. 51353m:i i In sa 3

EliiGI: n

=954 9554 15'-

li i

5: 5 Ese i

e:N H

E j

=l45:l 5****Em

=E5:f g *=j=si E!iE5j i a

=

is 2

!35 85;ua i

$EE tt

- =5

$18 5

=I"I g gg.I" In Isi $ dil in I

I

$=as gniga,n g

3, 33.l3.

9 sE s5 i

i

!! k!!

k!!

,i I

m--

a il R19 RIE i

i sg!

as!

as!

ss!

l!

lE al'II

El=i c

~i i

l" !

mil!

n' 5

=

ma n

.=

HEII if la NE iff I

g 2 :e h =a a

El' h:

223 223 223 Illh IN I IN I 15 III IEI i

Is i

i 5

!1 i I

in i

e e

==

w u

I I

E g

R R

R S

el=

R R

R R

xs u

u u

u I

5 2

5 5

5 5

E n r

't l li li ls

$s I'

I' i

8 B.

41 41 E n a.

1

!=,

!=

va E

E:

as sa

.h h

h

2 A.

k 9

2 lis=1 -.

s.

estf{a,:IIla.in =]

g!"-

la.a!!!i; 38

-a

,s sis $3 hP 8N ir

.sgig wg mE

  • a=g

!'5cg, slisalt 5

I Ilia,f li 5 i!!

g

s EE SE IEEE$'

ii 3!ii8!ii E8?Y8!==

i 81l sddland 8!Isit II "s

8 B ssisis isisins;

=

a e

s i S S

l l

~I e

li sE s

=

ssE I

lE I GElE DEI'm SE E

CE ImIII!

Eta!I a

8 15'in

!8 la si

l 3 ~ g=

la i il mE nan a

  • )

lI8 l

!! I lie

,i eEw 4 2

eaa n a

I S E

s E N

" 7, 9 E2 l_*"2 l ii 8 E l ii ili

.O 5'- 33 (,

J d 0* 3M RAFT i

ATTACHMENT V0GTLE ELECTRIC GENERATTNG PLART CORRECTIVE ACTIONS FOR SITE AREA ENERcENCY 2

'On March 20,1990, a $1te Area Emergency was declared due to a loss of offstte power concurrent with a loss of onsite Emergency Diesel Generator capability.

In accordance with VEGP Procedures, an Event Review Team has investigated the events leading up to and following the Site Area Emergency. This review team identified four main problem areas associated with the event. These problems involved low voltage switchyard access controls. Olesel Generator failures, Emergency Plan implementation, and procedures for shutdown plant conditions. A sumary of the findings and completed or planned corrective actions follows.

The low voltage switchyard access control problems were the result of inadequate

^

procedures. This wes compounded by a lack of attention on the part of the driver of the truck. These were the direct cause of the event. Furthermore, while site procedures required a security officer to accompany the vehicle-in ons he was unable to assist the the protected area, due to vi 9

driver, q

To prevent this type of inittcorrective actions have been or are being implem n

I r

recurrin The truck driver was disciplined for lack of attention and alertness in o

backing the truck when visibility was impaired.

A management directive on control and operation of vehicles was issued to o

all site employees. Administrative procedures have been revised to incorporate this management directive.

Security officer training will be revised to emphasize that officers have o

authority and responsibility to assist vehicle operators to assure safe vehicle operation. Specifically, security escorts will ensure that ground guides (flagaen) are used when large vehicles are maneuvered inside the protected area. These changes wil, be implemented by 8-1-90.

Outage Area Coordinators have been instructed to stage welding machines and o

other materials on the east and west ends of the Turbine tut 1 ding, whenever possible, to avoid unnecessary equipment and vehicle traffic in the low voltage switchyard.

4 1

j l

DRAFT ATTACHMENT (CONTINUED)

V0GTLE ELECTRIC GENERATING PLANT C0ARICTIVE ACTIONS FOR 11TE AREA _DIERGENCY i

.o Maintenance procedures will be revised to restrict staging of equipment in the low voltage switchyard. The procedures will be revised by 6-15-90.

o Barriers were installed with signs which require authorization from the Unit Shift Supervisor for vehicle access to the low voltage switchyard.

o Plant procedures have been revised to control hazardous materials and transient combustibles in the low voltage switchyard and other sensitive plant areas.

The most significant problem area identified by the review team involved the j

failure of Diesel Generator 1A to remain running to provide emergency power.

The event team utilizing utility and vendor tecuitcal experts, reviewed the two sequential failures of the diesel engine. The cause of the first trip can only be postulated, but most likely is the same as the second trip. The ongoing investigation indicates the most likely cause of the second trip was intermittent actuation of the jacket water temperature switches. A problem with restarting the diesel occurred because the Engineered Safety Features Actuation System (E5FAS) sequencer logic and diesel generator start logic (as designed) resulted in the diesel engine bein d out following the initial trip until the sequencer logic was reset.

As a result of the event investiga ing actions have been or are j

being implemented to ensure a high state of diesel generator reliability.

)

o The suspected switches were replaced and extensive diesel generator testing was performed to ensure operability prior to return to service.

1 o

Investigation of the suspect-temperature switches has been performed by an independent testing laboratory and a report is expected by 5 18-90. The investigation revealed that the temperature switetes are sensitive to 1

calibration techniques and foreign material within the switches.

i o

Maintenance procedures for temperature switches have been revised to include lessons learned from laboratory testing. All jacket water high temperature switches will be cleaned and calibrated using the revised procedure by j

5-31-90. Other non-essential trip temperature switches will cleaned and calibrated at their nomal calitpration cycle.

o Vendor failure analysis of a low lube oil pressure switch will be conducted and results of this analysis will be used to detemine if procedure changes, cleantng or re-calibration is necessary for various pressure trip switches on the DG.

e The Corporate Maintenance Support Department will perform a design review of The review will be completed by 9-1 provements will be made the diesel instrumentation.

Corrective actions or im if appropriate.

90.

2 l

l---..------.

DRAFT ATTACHMENT (CONTINUED)

V0GTLE ELECTRIC GENERATING PLANT C0ARECTIVE ACTfoN1 FOR SITE AREA fMfemfNtY o

The Under Voltage (UV) diesel start was changed in both Units 1 and 2 to be similar to a Safety injection emergency start. This provides a higher degree of reliability for UV bus conditions and eliminates the need for resetting the sequencer, o

Operators have been instructed on the emergency start modes of the Diesel Generator. Operating procedures have been revised to address Diesel Generator restart following trips. Training will be provided on the revised procedures by 9-15-90.

o A policy detailing guidelines for logging pertinent alarms and indications to assist in evaluation of equipment or system malfunctions has been developed and applicable procedures have been revised.

o Af ter engine overhauls, functional diesel testing will be enhanced to include pubble testing to e h a lo c system has acceptable

leakage, o

Trend program data is being en re OG component failures are adequately included. The data review will be completed by 6-5-90.

Notification of state and local government agencies was not timely due to a loss of power to the primary Emergency Notification Network (ENN). Communication errors, a lack of understand'ng of ENN power supplies, and inadequate supervision of the notification process were also identified as Emergency Plan implementation problems.

Information flow to the General Office resulted in inaccurate information being provided to the media. There was confusion among plant personnel concerning assembly and accountability procedures.

The following actions have been implemented.

o The State of Georgia ENN circuit and Burke County have been added to the Backup ENN.

o The General Manager has issued memos to the plant staff to ensure proper functioning of:

)

1.

Assembly and Accountability procedures.

2.

ENN Connunications procedures.

The following corrective actions will be implemented by the dates indicated.

o Battery backup power will be provided to the primary Del in the control room by 9-1-90.

o An evaluation will be performed to review and reconeend further improvements in notification systems. This evaluation will be completed by 6-1-90.

3

.cy.cs ' M 1112e

  • ":5~.NOP O-vC3r.E

.c 4

2-o.,

.oo.

e DRAFT ATTACMENT(CONTINUE 0)

V0GTLE ELECTRIC GENERATING PLANT CORRECTIVE ACTfqNS FOR t!TE ArtA ENERCENCY The Manager Operations and the Nanager Training and Emergency Preparedness o

willconducttrainingforallEmerpencyDirectors(ED's)toreviewtherole and responsibilities of the ED inc,uding lessons learned from this event by 1

4-1-90.

o Control room comunicators and Emergency Directors will receive training in the operation of and power supplies for emergency comunication equipment.

This will be accomplished by 4-1-30.

The Emergency preparedness group will establish a monthly test program to o

validate Emergency Response Facility (ERF) computer data by 6-15-go, o

The Corporate Emergency Response organization (ER0) will be included on the ENN by 7-15-30 to provide another means of ensuring the transmittal of.

accurate information to the Corporate Office during emergencies, o

The Corporate ER0 will be trained in the use of available communication systems to talk with the site by 6-15-g0.

o A full-scale assembly and accountablitty p fomed by 6-15-90.

o A full-scale assembly and accountability drill will be included as a regular emergency plan objective. Procedure 91602-C "Emerlency Drills and Exercises", will be changed by 8-1-30 to reflect t11: comitment.

in the Emergency Plan will be Changes to Emergency Action Levels (EALs)EAL Report presently under review o

requested from the NRC based on NUMARC's by the NRC. Appropriate changes to the EALs will be completed 6 months after NRC approval of the NUMARC report.

Plant procedures did not sufficiently address or control plant shutdown conditions encountered during the emergency.

The procedures covering loss of Residual Heat Removal (RNR) will be revised o

to include the various Reactor Coelant System (RCS) and containment conditionspresentduringanoutageoraLossofOffsitePower(LosP) event.

The Abnormal Operating Procedure (A0P) and Unit Operating Procedure (UDP) i will include the fellowing:

For U0P at reduced inventory (less than or equal to 3 feet below the vessel flange) t)

One diesel and two offsite power supplies or two diesels and one offsite power source must be available to feed vital 4160 volt buses, gr,the equipment hatch must be in place, with 4 bolts installed.

A 4

8 e

DRAFT ATTACHMENT (CONTINUED)

V0GTLE ELECTRIC GENERATING PLANT COL lCI1Yi ACTIONS FDA SITE ARIA EMERGENCY

~

11) RCS must be cooled to 1100 degrees F for reduced inventory operation with the equipment hatch open.

ForADP(l.ossofRHR) i)

A loss of power condition will be specifically addressed in the procedure.

11) The time-to-boil curves will be adjusted to address a 1100 degree f starting point for accidents.

These procedures will be revised by 7-1 90.

o A procedure will be written to address backfeed from the Unit Auxiliary Transformer (UAT)totheESFbusses. This procedure will be completed by 9-1-90.

o The capability to close the equipment hatch without electrical power will be evaluated by the next refueling outage, o

Training will be provided for licensed operators on the procedure revisions resulting from this event. In addition, Senior Reactor Operators ($Ros) will receive traininp on the mid-loop boiling and cooling mechanism.

Initial training wil be completed by 9-15-90.

DRAFT

~

5

UNIT 1 STAIWS Fast 3-18 T3 4-I-90 ACTIVE LCS s/G est BA1E WIT STAWS 3-18-90 INeli IN MIDE 6, UPPER INTERNALS SET l-90-254 IFT-18. AFT-10848 NONE AND RCCA's LATCHED, ECCS CHECK VALVES 1-90-331 18 CREFS FLOW TEST ColfLETE, CAVilY DRAIN 00688 1-90-333 FH8 RAD MON 110RS IN PROGRESS. UltlT AT MIDLOOP A1 0800.

1-90-324 AIR-19910 SEISMIC INSTRisENT i

i 3-19-90 Ultli IN M00E 6. CAV11Y DRAINED AND l-90-254 IFT-18 AFT-10843 NOME i

VESSEL HEAD SET, DECCINillIG OF VESSEL I-90-331 18 CREFS CLOSultE STUD HOLES III PROGRESS.

1-90-332 18 ESF CNILLER l

3-20-90

' UNIT IN M00E 6 HEAD SET AND STUS 1-90-331 18 CREFS DG18: OUT-OF-SERVICE (005) FOR OVEltHAUL TENSIGIllNG IN PROGRESS FILL Als 1-90-332 18 ESF CHILLER SINCE 2300 0F 3/13/90 VEllT OF LETD0001 IN Pfl0GRESS.

1-90-349 FHB PAVS A TRAIN DGIA: 0820 BLACK 0UT STARI AIID 1 RIPPED AFTER 80 SEC. 0841 BLACK 0UT STARTED AGAIN AND TRIPPED AFTER 70 SEC. 0856 LOCAL MR800AL EMERGENCY 8REAKGLASS START AIID MRilUAL STOP AT 1326.

2119 START AND SIOPPED AT 2206 SWAPPING FROM " RAT 8" TO " RAT A" 2223 SIART AND STOPPED AT 2228 08SERVA110ll/TROUBLESH00 TING 2233 START AII0 STOPPED AT 2254 OBSERVATI0ll/ TROUBLESHOOTING 3-21-90 Ultli IN MODE 6. HEAD SET. INVESTI-1-90-331 180REFS 0G18: START STOP GAfilIG DGIA PR06LEM, RES10 RING l-90-332 18 ESF CHILLER 2149 FAILED TO START 1-90-349 FH8 PAVS A 1 RAIN

'2156 FAILED TO SIART

'r DGl8, CHARGilIG AIIS LETDOWit FILLED 2202 2217 STOPPED MAIIUALLY l-90-353 DGIA VENTED Afl0 IN SERVICE 2259 2301 STOPPED MAIIUALLY DUE TO Le PESS.'

AIID HI F0GP 2314 2318 STOPPED MisA(LY DUE TO HI F0 n P t

a

~

PAE l i

WIIIT 1 STATUS FAWI 3-13 T3 4-1-90 ATE apIIT STATUS ACTIVE LCO p/s 33 90 UNIT IN MODE b. HEAD IS FULLY TEN-1-90-331 18 CREFS DG18: SIART STOP SIONED. SET UP OF DGl8 IS IN PROGRESS 1-90-332 18 ESF CHILLER 0017 0023 TROU8tESH00TiltG 1-90-353 DG 1A MAIOUAL STOP 0428 0429 TROUBLESHOOTING MAlluAL STOP 0714 0730 TROUBLESHOOTING MANUAL STOP 0854 0857 TROUBLESHOOTIIIG i

MANUAL STOP 0921 0926 TROUBLESHOOTING MANUAL STOP 0950 0955 TROUBLESHOOTING MANUAL STOP 1002 1011 TROUBLESHOOTING MAleUAL STOP 1101 1244 TRIPPE0 011 HI LO TEMP.

1-23-90 UNII IN MODE 5. LOOPS NOT FILLED. PREPA-1-90-331 18 CREFS DGIA: 0254 0405 TROUBLESHOOTING RAll0NS FOR RCS FILL AND VENT ARE IN 1-90-332 18 ESF CHILLER MAIIUAL STOP 1-90-362 RCS INTEGRITY (RID 1724 1724 INADVERTANT PROGRESS.

BYPASS VALVE REMOVAL)

STARI CONTROL ROOM I-90-353 DGIA DG18: 0509 1202 RECEIVED 8 PHASE ISO UV RELAY ON START 1730 1733 TRIPPED Oft LO JACKET WAIER PRESS /TUR90 LO PRESS 1744 2221 1R008tESH00TIIIG MAIIUAL STOP 3-24-90 UlllT IN MODE 5. LOOPS fl0T FILLED l-90-331 18 CREFS DGIB: 0048 0121 RECEIVED TRIP CHARGING. LETDOINE A310 SEAL INJECTION 1-90-332 18 ESF CHILLER Oft HI JACKET MATER HI TEfr ALARet, ARE IN SERVICE. REPAIR TO THE RTO l-90-362 RCS INTEGRITY DGl8 SHOULD HAVE BVPASS MAllIFOLD IS C0frLETE. C018EllCING l-90-353 DGIA-TRIPPED BUT DID N01 FILL ANO VENT OF THE RCS.

3-25-90 Utili IN MODE 5 LOOPS 110T FILLED. MID-LOOP l-90-331 18.CREFS OPERATIONS TEllMINATED AT 1900. RCS FILL I-90-332 18 ESF CHILLER AND VENT C0fetETE. PREPARING FOR ILRI.

1-90-362 RCS INTEGRITY PAGE 2 1-90-349 FHB HVAC TRAIN 8

SAIE INIT STATIIS ACTIVE LCS 3/G min 3-26-90 UNIT IN MODE 5.

PREPARING FOR 'lLRI l-90-331 IB CREFS 1-90-332 18 ESF CHILLER 1-90-353 DGIA/DGl8 3-27-90 IIIIIT IN MODE 5.

PREPARING FOR ILRT.

1-90-331 18 CREFS D618: START STOP IIIVESTIGATING RI VESSEL HEAD FOR l-90-332 IB ESF CHILLER 1649 1822 AIR LEAKAGE UPPER CAIIOPY SEAL LEAK 1-90-353 DGIA/0G18 TESillIG 1909 2009 CONTROL LOGIC TESIIIIG 1951 1954 CGIITROL LOGIC TESTING 1957 1959 CGIli1IOL LOGIC TESTIIIG 2004 2010 LAST CGIITIl0L LOGIC TEST 2220 2317 UIIDERVOLTAGE TEST 3-28-90 UNIT IN M00E 5.

PREPARING FOR ILRT.

1-90-331 15 CREFS DGIB: 0403 0537 $URV. IESTING TESilIIG 011 DG18 CGItLETE AIS DGIS 1-90-332 18 ESF CHILLER 1350 1355 FUIICT. TESillIG 1356 1400 EERGEIICY STARI DECLARED OPERASLE AT 1527.

1-90-353 DGIA MAIISAL STOP i

3-29-90 UIlli IN IWDE 5.

ILRT IN PROGRESS.

1-90-331 18 CIIEFS DGIA 1109 1158 T-ENG-W il UV TEST PItEPARING TO RUN UV TEST 011 DGIA I-90-332 18 ESF CHILLER l-90-353 DGIA i

DGIA:

1920 2115 EElIGElICY 3-30-90 UIllT IN seBE 5.

ILRT C9FLETE.

1-90-353 DGIA START TO DGIA flugt FOR ButSLE TEST I-90-373 A&S FHS HVAC PERFORM l

BUSBLE TEST.

2235 2241 EIIGINE RUIl FOR LOGIC TEST IIGIWIRL START AIS TRIP FA0H HIGN TEfr.

LUSE GIL Sitel-LAT1011.

i 2313 2316 EIIGIIIE FAMII FOR LOGIC TEST 1101t-IIRL START AIID TRIP FROM HIGH VIBRATICII SiteH AI1Get

-1 INIIT I STATUS FRWE 3-18 10 4-I-90 DATE IMIT STATUS ACTIVE LCO D/G ME 3-30-90 DGIA: START STOP (CONTINUED) 2328 2334 ENGINE RUN FOR LOGIC TEST 300RMAL START AND TRIP FROM LOW LUBE Olt PRESS.

SIW LATION 2343 2347 FINICTIONAL TEST FOR 900 89-VIN 057 NORMAL START AND STOP.

2348 2358 FullCT100tAL lEST FOR POD 89-VlM057 (L.O. TRIP CIR-CUIT) LOCAL ENER-GENCY 8REAKGLASS START.

3-31-90 UNIT IN MODE 5.

INITIAL BUBBLE TES1 1-90-373 A&8 FHB HVAC 0012 0014 FUNCT. TESI FOR ON DGIA IS COMPLETE. STRUT INSTALLA-1-90-353 DGIA MD0 89-VIN 057 0016 0019 F.T. FOR PWO 11011 ON 'B' RHR PUNP 15 IN PROGRESS.

89-VIM 057 LOCAL EE RG. BREAKGLASS START 1827 1837 ENGINE RUN FOR LOGIC TEST NORMAL START AND STOP 1846 1847 ENGINE RUN LOGIC TEST STARTED'Will 2 HIGil TEW. J.W.

SENSORS VENTING.

1856 1857 STARIED W 2 H.T.J.W. SENSOR 5 VENTING.

1904 1906 STARTED W 2 J.T.J.W. SENSORS VENilNG.

~'

UNIT I ST;TUS FMM 3-18 TO 4-1-90 SAIE WIT STA1WS

~

ACTIVE LC0 D/s 33 3-38-90 DGIA: START STOP (CONTINUED) 1921 1922 STARIED W LOW PRESS. J. W.

SENSOR VENTING.

1955 2012 ENGINE RUN FOR f

LOGIC TEST NOR-MAL START Alt SIfRILATED TRIP.

,I t.-

2253 2320 UNDERVOLTAGE TESTi.1 4-01-90 UNIT IN MODE 5.

UV TEST Oft DGIA IS 1-90-373 A&B FHB HVAC 0423 0556 $URVEILLAllCE 1EST$

CWFLETE. PREPARIIIG FOR IBA03 SWITCH-PROCEDURE 14980-1**

GEAR OUIAGE DGIA OPERA 81LITY TE;ST IS CopFLETED AND DECLARED DGIA OPERA 8tE AT 1154.

i' E

.!i:

l'.

11 D

PAGE S

>