ML20150E983: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(StriderTol Bot insert)
 
(StriderTol Bot change)
 
Line 2: Line 2:
| number = ML20150E983
| number = ML20150E983
| issue date = 11/30/1978
| issue date = 11/30/1978
| title = Licensee Ge'S Answers to Intervenor R Dellum'S Interrogs 780803.Questions Concern Fuel Flooding Sys,Containment Pressure,Vacuum Relief Sys & Other Topics Re Safety of Subj Facil.Affidavits & Cert of Svc Encl
| title = Licensee GEs Answers to Intervenor R Dellums Interrogs 780803.Questions Concern Fuel Flooding Sys,Containment Pressure,Vacuum Relief Sys & Other Topics Re Safety of Subj Facil.Affidavits & Cert of Svc Encl
| author name = Darmitzel D, Gilliland D, Hoggatt G
| author name = Darmitzel D, Gilliland D, Hoggatt G
| author affiliation = GENERAL ELECTRIC CO.
| author affiliation = GENERAL ELECTRIC CO.
Line 17: Line 17:
=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:_
{{#Wiki_filter:_
i                   .
i NRC PUBL:C DOCUdNI MM
NRC PUBL:C DOCUdNI MM
;i
                                              ;i
[
[                                                                                     -11/30/78 p                      o  ,.M ' ,O                                                                       .
-11/30/78
                    .z.         ,, f     ~j
,.M ',O p
                    '9 T. . nT'
o
                              .$ /p     . f5             UNITED STATES OF AMERICA gT' #                           NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
.z.
                        -In the Matter.of-                                             )
,, f
                                                                                      .)     Docket No. 50-70.
~j T.. nT'
GENERAL ELECTRIC COMPANY                                     )
'9.$ /p
                                                                                        )   Operating License (Vallecitos Nuclear Center -                                 )         No. TR-1 General' Electric Test Reactor)                         )     .(Show Cause)
. f5 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA gT' #
LICENSEE'S ANSWERS TO INTERVENOR'S AUGUST 3, 1978 INTERROGATORIES General' Electric (GE) hereby. responds to.. Inter-ivenor Congressman Dellums' interrogatories                             , dated August 3,
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
                                    ./*
-In the Matter.of-
1978           :as follows:
)
: 1.       The heat generation rate following such a postulated accident is discussed in detail in the Safety Analysis Re' port (NEDO 12622) at pages 9-84:through 9-93.
. )
                          */
Docket No. 50-70.
GE had originally objected to these interrogatories re-
GENERAL ELECTRIC COMPANY
;                                      lated to the GETR containment systems'on the grounds.that i
)
continued. containment integrity is not required in order 4
)
to assure the safe shutdown of GETR following.the occur-rence of the maximum postulated-seismic event and that the information sought'through these interrogatories was there-
Operating License (Vallecitos Nuclear Center -
,                                    -fore irrelevant to the resolution of any.of the three L                                     specific issues. identified in the Commission's February 13, l'                                     1978 Memorandum and Order.                 These answers are being-provided in accordance with the directive contained in the Licensing Board's November 13, 1978 Order in which the Board expressed--
)
                                      .the view that these interrogatories were permissible since-responses "may lead to the discovery of- 7 '- m ^ -" 4 A - ~ a "
No. TR-1 General' Electric Test Reactor)
pursuant to 10 CFR S '2.740(b)(1) .                           THIS. DOCUMENT CONTAINS.
)
g   P00R QUAUTY PAGES
.(Show Cause)
                                                                                                    ?S132sios7s~                   (,
LICENSEE'S ANSWERS TO INTERVENOR'S AUGUST 3, 1978 INTERROGATORIES General' Electric (GE) hereby. responds to.. Inter-ivenor Congressman Dellums' interrogatories dated August 3,
y               .p                     <w= 4   m   e p- w <-   es - e<-ae   ew           --i-'n,,e   m - w
./
1978
:as follows:
1.
The heat generation rate following such a postulated accident is discussed in detail in the Safety Analysis Re' port (NEDO 12622) at pages 9-84:through 9-93.
*/
GE had originally objected to these interrogatories re-lated to the GETR containment systems'on the grounds.that continued. containment integrity is not required in order i
to assure the safe shutdown of GETR following.the occur-4 rence of the maximum postulated-seismic event and that the information sought'through these interrogatories was there-
-fore irrelevant to the resolution of any.of the three L
specific issues. identified in the Commission's February 13, l'
1978 Memorandum and Order.
These answers are being-provided in accordance with the directive contained in the Licensing Board's November 13, 1978 Order in which the Board expressed--
.the view that these interrogatories were permissible since-responses "may lead to the discovery of-7 '- m ^ -" 4 A - ~ a "
pursuant to 10 CFR S '2.740(b)(1).
THIS. DOCUMENT CONTAINS.
g P00R QUAUTY PAGES
?S132sios7s~
(,
y
.p
<w=
4 m
94 e
p-w <-
es -
e<-ae ew r
--i-'n,,e m - w
+a e
~w e
* w 4e-v -
m


i                            ,                        -2
-2 i
    .                            2. The heat generation rate referenced in Interrogatory No. 1 is identical to that. assumed in the containment analysis               (i.e., NEDO 12622, p. 9-84).
2.
: 3. The primary function of the vacuum relief system is to assure that pressure outside containment does not exceed the pressure inside containment by more than approximately 0.1 psi.                     This system is also designed to main-tain containment integrity at or above the containment design pressure.                                      .
The heat generation rate referenced in Interrogatory No. 1 is identical to that. assumed in the containment analysis (i.e., NEDO 12622, p. 9-84).
: 4. The containment pressure associated.with the maximum postulated accident (4.1 psi) is less than the containment design pressure (5 psi).
3.
          ,,                      5. No, nor is one required to avoid possible shell rupture and maintain building integrity.
The primary function of the vacuum relief system is to assure that pressure outside containment does not exceed the pressure inside containment by more than approximately 0.1 psi.
: 6. The Fuel Flooding System is being designed and installed to assure safe shutdown of GETR in case of the occurrence of the maximum postulated seismic event.                       Contain-ment integrity is not needed to assure safe shutdown of GETR in such an event.
This system is also designed to main-tain containment integrity at or above the containment design pressure.
: 7. No.
4.
: 8. The equation is Charles Law (Thermodynamics ,
The containment pressure associated.with the maximum postulated accident (4.1 psi) is less than the containment design pressure (5 psi).
Virgil Moring Faries, 3rd Ed. 1959, McMillan & Co., p. 56).                                 !
5.
It is appropriate to use this ideal gas law for an air l environment in situations where the volume remains constant, i                                                                                           l l
No, nor is one required to avoid possible shell rupture and maintain building integrity.
l
6.
The Fuel Flooding System is being designed and installed to assure safe shutdown of GETR in case of the occurrence of the maximum postulated seismic event.
Contain-ment integrity is not needed to assure safe shutdown of GETR in such an event.
7.
No.
8.
The equation is Charles Law (Thermodynamics,
Virgil Moring Faries, 3rd Ed. 1959, McMillan & Co., p. 56).
It is appropriate to use this ideal gas law for an air l environment in situations where the volume remains constant, i


                                                                                                        -3
-3 9.
: 9.         The assumptions which are used in the cal-culation of maximum containment pressure are in the Safety Analysis Report (NEDO 12622) pp. 9-84 through 9-93.
The assumptions which are used in the cal-culation of maximum containment pressure are in the Safety Analysis Report (NEDO 12622) pp. 9-84 through 9-93.
: 10.       The " actual" containment volume.of 250,000                               ,
10.
cubic feet was determined by calculations wherein all structures -(including all pools at maximum levels, etc.).
The " actual" containment volume.of 250,000 cubic feet was determined by calculations wherein all structures -(including all pools at maximum levels, etc.).
were taken into account.
were taken into account.
: 11.       No tests which measure the heat transfer rate through the actual GETR containment shell have been-performed.
11.
: 12.       No '.
No tests which measure the heat transfer rate through the actual GETR containment shell have been-performed.
: 13.       The filter media that are now'in use are Model lE-1000-2 and lE-1250-1(S), manufactured by Cambridge Filter Company.           Filter media are tested by the manufacturer with dioctyl phthalate at 20% and 100% of rated flow.
12.
No '.
13.
The filter media that are now'in use are Model lE-1000-2 and lE-1250-1(S), manufactured by Cambridge Filter Company.
Filter media are tested by the manufacturer with dioctyl phthalate at 20% and 100% of rated flow.
Minimum efficiency must be 99.97% retention of 0.3 um dioctyl phthalate particles with a maximum penetration less than 0.03%.
Minimum efficiency must be 99.97% retention of 0.3 um dioctyl phthalate particles with a maximum penetration less than 0.03%.
: 14.       There are a total of four steel cabinets con-taining decontamination supplies such as mop heads, masslin cloths and wooden handles located throughout the three floors of the containment building.                     Occasionally, wooden                       i planks are used for scaffolding and gasolinepowered forklift trucks are used when required.                   No flammable liquids are stored in the containment, i
14.
, , - , -      -,  ,--,-y       ,  .y~-,-       --.,..,_#
There are a total of four steel cabinets con-taining decontamination supplies such as mop heads, masslin cloths and wooden handles located throughout the three floors of the containment building.
                                                              .- ,y. w.     ,  , _ . , ., ,e . . - , m ,, ,4 ,, _ . ..,
Occasionally, wooden i
planks are used for scaffolding and gasolinepowered forklift trucks are used when required.
No flammable liquids are stored in the containment, i
,--,-y
.y~-,-
,y.
w.
,e m
,4


n 4
n 4
                                                                                                      -4
-4 15.
: 15.             In-service inspection program for safety-re-                                                         l lated systems may be found in Section 8 of the Safety Analysis Report (NEDO 12622) and Appendix 10 of the June 1978 Re-                                                                           l sponse to the Show~Cause Order.                   This program is reviewed                                                       1 and' updated'en a routine basis.                                                                                                 ;
In-service inspection program for safety-re-lated systems may be found in Section 8 of the Safety Analysis Report (NEDO 12622) and Appendix 10 of the June 1978 Re-sponse to the Show~Cause Order.
: 16.             The' criterion is' designed to assure that                                                         ,
This program is reviewed and' updated'en a routine basis.
a given sat     ._f         related system continues to operate properly during and ;;i.ter the off-normal or ' accident condition it was
16.
            ' designed _to mitigate.
The' criterion is' designed to assure that a given sat
                        ~
._f related system continues to operate properly during and ;;i.ter the off-normal or ' accident condition it was
l
' designed _to mitigate.
: 17.             The indepencent review of the maintenance                                                             :
~
I plan is performed by the Reactor Analyst and the Nuclear Safety and Quality Assurance organization,-with periodic
l 17.
          , audit reviews: performed by the Vallecitos Technological Safety Council and the Nuclear Energy Business Group's Nu-clear Energy Product and' Quality Assurance Operation.
The indepencent review of the maintenance I
: 18.               See'the response to Interrogatory No. 15.                                                           I
plan is performed by the Reactor Analyst and the Nuclear Safety and Quality Assurance organization,-with periodic
: 19.               Table 3-1 is more thoroughly described in'EDAC                                                       ,
, audit reviews: performed by the Vallecitos Technological Safety Council and the Nuclear Energy Business Group's Nu-clear Energy Product and' Quality Assurance Operation.
report 117.08 previously forwarded tu all parties .
18.
See'the response to Interrogatory No. 15.
I 19.
Table 3-1 is more thoroughly described in'EDAC report 117.08 previously forwarded tu all parties.
i l
i l
I I
I s-u...-.
l s-l u_.._.-.___        , . _ , . . . _ . . . _ _      _ . , . . . . , - . . . . . _ . _ _ , _ . .    . - - - . - . ~ . . . . _ . _ . .
. - - -. -. ~....


UNITED STATES OF APERicA NUCLEAR REGULATORY C089tISS104 in the Matter of                                                                             DOCKET NO. 50-70 GENERAL ELECTRIC CDFAW OPERATING LICERSE
UNITED STATES OF APERicA NUCLEAR REGULATORY C089tISS104 in the Matter of DOCKET NO. 50-70 GENERAL ELECTRIC CDFAW OPERATING LICERSE
                      -(Vallecitos Muclear Center -                                                                           to. TR-1 General Electric Test Re?@r)                                                                           (SHOW CAltSE)
-(Vallecitos Muclear Center -
AFF10MIT OF GEORE D. MXJATT
to. TR-1 General Electric Test Re?@r)
                                                                                                            >                                                        1 George D. Hoggatt, being duly sworn. W and'says as f'oilows:                                                                     j i
(SHOW CAltSE)
l
AFF10MIT OF GEORE D. MXJATT 1
: 1.         That he is employed as Manager. EETR License Renewal. General Electric Company. Vallecitus Nuclear Center. Pleasanton California.                                                                             1 1
George D. Hoggatt, being duly sworn. W and'says as f' ilows:
and wat he is duty authorized to esecute the foregoing answers to the                                                                 . , . I interrogatories 1 through 12.15.16,18 and 19 propounded ty cor.y esman.';'
o j
i 1.
That he is employed as Manager. EETR License Renewal. General Electric Company. Vallecitus Nuclear Center. Pleasanton California.
1 1
and wat he is duty authorized to esecute the foregoing answers to the interrogatories 1 through 12.15.16,18 and 19 propounded ty cor.y esman.';'
OcIluss under date of August 3.1976, on behalf of the L1censee.
OcIluss under date of August 3.1976, on behalf of the L1censee.
: 2. That the ahore mentioned and attached answers are true afd correct to the t.ast of his krxmledge and helief.                                                                   ,
2.
l l
That the ahore mentioned and attached answers are true afd correct to the t.ast of his krxmledge and helief.
J       *
J Georg6 D. MpW
                                                                                                                                      $                ~
~
                                                                                          ,        Georg6 D. MpW                                                     ;
Sutrscribed and sworn to before me this Mt M day of Novester,192.
Sutrscribed and sworn to before me this Mt M                                                         day of Novester,192.
76.~, u d&,~,
76.~, u d&,~,                                             . notar, %uc. Av eaa county, seate or Caurwa.
. notar, %uc. Av eaa county, seate or Caurwa.
r My ccustission expires March 8. M31.
r My ccustission expires March 8. M31.
      ~ - -- . ~ ..._ ,                 .
~ - --. ~..._,
      .'-.' D -              ' Of rh MAL,3           ...'~
WGrJ1A C CNT r 'r } -
      ' ; 'j '(, tWGrJ1A  ' =t Mu: . csC              CNT            r 'r } -
' Of rh MAL,3
      .-l'                                                                                                                    <
... ' ~
        .                  -                    .m ur, s .       >
..' D -
b f * ,' /             ' A L AVLJ L f '/ - ;-
.-l'
' ; 'j
'(, t ' =t Mu:. cs.m ur, s.
b f *,' /
' A L AVLJ L f '/ - ;-
F
F
                          ,, a .a                                                                              -
. ~ m ---,....
      ** - <* *              . .    . ~ m --- , ....
,, a
                                                                                      ,                                               .j
.a
.j


s
s q
* q UMITEIl $TATES OF MERICA                             ,
UMITEIl $TATES OF MERICA IUCLEAR REGJLATUdY COPMISSION In the 76atter of
IUCLEAR REGJLATUdY COPMISSION In the 76atter of                                                 )                                 Dotket 5o                       "" M GEKIRAL EECTRIC COWMY                                                                               Opera, 5
)
(Vallecttos Muclear Center -                                                                                                           .)
Dotket 5o
"" M GEKIRAL EECTRIC COWMY
: Opera, 5
(Vallecttos Muclear Center -
General Electric Test Reactor)
General Electric Test Reactor)
                                                                                                                                                                                  ~
.)
AFFIGAYETOFDVy_MT_
AFFIGAYETOFDVy_MT_
(hright L. Gfililand, heA                   , ,, sworn, deposes and says as follom L.     That he is engleyed as' Wr, Reactw Irradiatforts. GenersT Electric Coman'f. Vallecitos % clear Center, Pleasanten. Californf a, and' that he is duly authorized to execute the foregoing answers to the interrogatories, propounded by Congressaan Dellums mder date of August 3.1978, on behalf of tSe 1imnsee,
~
: 2. That the above mentioned and attached answers art truet and correct to the test of his knowledge and belief, bl[L Derfght L. Gifliland i
(hright L. Gfililand, heA
Subscribed and sworn to before me thfs                                 J #8 day of hh .1978.
,,, sworn, deposes and says as follom L.
7 t f< *<., 6 d u ,ge,ff                               , notary Public, Alameda County, State of
That he is engleyed as' Wr, Reactw Irradiatforts. GenersT Electric Coman'f. Vallecitos % clear Center, Pleasanten. Californf a, and' that he is duly authorized to execute the foregoing answers to the interrogatories, propounded by Congressaan Dellums mder date of August 3.1978, on behalf of tSe 1imnsee, That the above mentioned and attached answers art truet and correct to the 2.
                            ,                          e Callfornia. fty cow 2ission .expf res March 8, h41.                                                                                                             ~
test of his knowledge and belief, bl[L Derfght L. Gifliland i
l                       :                  ,
Subscribed and sworn to before me thfs J #8 day of hh.1978.
a, 1
7 t f< *<., 6 d u,ge,ff
m~a ,e        .
, notary Public, Alameda County, State of e
                                    - nn, . ..t o r Fr q A L : r. L                                                                                   -
Callfornia. fty cow 2ission.expf res March 8, h41.
ff% 3 .3 wmu                   A . c.. v r.- S gf i
~
i        .              : u. r m . ci, , r A ,
l a,
      ,...e,., s'                   Nsur   t <<*:.I.
1 m~a
                                        , , . m c.. . . . . .    {
- nn,...t
v., y.
,e o r Fr q A L : r. L ff%
l-         a. .       . . . ~     p. p ea..           .,
i 3. wmu A. c.. v r.- S f 3 : u. r m. ci,, r A g
                                                                                                                                                          ,s
i
' s' Nsur t
<<*:.I.
{
,...e,.,
v., y.,,. m c.......
l-
: a..
... ~
: p. p ea..
,s


(MITH1 iTATG OF AERTIA N'JCLEAR REGJLATORY C@ttf!SSIOPL In the Matter- of                                         )                                   Docket Mo. 50 7G
(MITH1 iTATG OF AERTIA N'JCLEAR REGJLATORY C@ttf!SSIOPL In the Matter-of
                                                                        )
)
GENERAL ELECTRIC C@FMY                                     1                                 @ ratf M License j                                           Mo. TR-1 (Vallecitos Maclear Center -                               5                                   (shoe cause)
Docket Mo. 50 7G
)
GENERAL ELECTRIC C@FMY 1
@ ratf M License j
Mo. TR-1 (Vallecitos Maclear Center -
5 (shoe cause)
General ETectric Test Reactor 3
General ETectric Test Reactor 3
AFFIGAVTT OF ROBERT W._DMMITZEL RotMert W. DaruitzeT, be.ing du2y smorrr. deposes and sgys as follows:
AFFIGAVTT OF ROBERT W._DMMITZEL RotMert W. DaruitzeT, be.ing du2y smorrr. deposes and sgys as follows:
: 1. That he is espToyed as knager, Trradiation Processing Operatforr, General
1.
        - Electric Company. Va31ecitos hefear Center., Pleasanton, CaTifornia, and tirat he fr duly authorized to exacute th foregning answtrs to the interrogatorter, propounded by Congressaarr De11ues. m6er date of August 3.1973. on behalf crf the Lfcensee.
That he is espToyed as knager, Trradiation Processing Operatforr, General
: 2.     That the above sentioned and attached answery are true amt cortwet to the j         best of his knowledge and belfer.
- Electric Company. Va31ecitos hefear Center., Pleasanton, CaTifornia, and tirat he fr duly authorized to exacute th foregning answtrs to the interrogatorter, propounded by Congressaarr De11ues. m6er date of August 3.1973. on behalf crf the Lfcensee.
hhG m ,e ..                           . i Subs ribed and sworn tc before sne thist                           #4                                   d4y of November.1978.
2.
                    <t,,,,            dyem/ud                   Notary Public, Alameda County, $ tate of CalifSrnia. My condission expires Nrch 8,1931.
That the above sentioned and attached answery are true amt cortwet to the j
w s a_r                           ,            ;                                            ~
best of his knowledge and belfer.
(
hhG m,e..
                  ..          omCIAL 1. . /..,
. i Subs ribed and sworn tc before sne thist
    -($-g;17 i              \ VIPG#N"A       C.. (It&Jtic sotwr rukc . cxvces;A          *
#4 d4y of November.1978.
                                                                ~     ~
dyem/ud Notary Public, Alameda County, $ tate of
                                                                                ~                                       <
<t,,,,
    , L       ~gy,                                                       .
CalifSrnia. My condission expires Nrch 8,1931.
c N*#'
w s a_r
            , .j/
~
                                          '*?
\\ VIPG#N"A C.. (It&Jtic (
~
~
-($-g;17 omCIAL 1.. /..,
i
~
L
~gy, sotwr rukc. cxvces;A c
N*#'
,.j/
'*?


i UNITED STATES OF' AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION c
i UNITED STATES OF' AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION c
In the' Matter of                             )
In the' Matter of
                                                            )     Docket No. 50-70 GENERAL ELECTRIC COMPANY                       )
)
                                                            )     Operating License (Vallecitos Nuclear Center -                 )             No. TR-1 General Electric Test Reactor)               )         (Show Cause)
)
Docket No. 50-70 GENERAL ELECTRIC COMPANY
)
)
Operating License (Vallecitos Nuclear Center -
)
No. TR-1 General Electric Test Reactor)
)
(Show Cause)
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that the foregoing has been-served as of this date by personal delivery.or first class mail, postage prepaid, to the following:
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that the foregoing has been-served as of this date by personal delivery.or first class mail, postage prepaid, to the following:
Edward Luton, Esq., Chairman               .
Edward Luton, Esq., Chairman
                                                                . Lawrence Chandler, Esq.               ,
. Lawrence Chandler, Esq.
Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel U. S. Nuclear Regulatory U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission                       Commission Washington, D. C.         20555                       17171H. Street, N.W.
Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel U. S. Nuclear Regulatory U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Commission Washington, D. C.
Washington,     D..C.       20555 Mr. Gustave A. Linenberger-Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel Ms. Barbara Shockley                                 ;
20555 17171H. Street, N.W.
U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commiss. ion                   1890 Bockman Road Washington, D. C.         20555                       San Lorenzo, California 94580 Dr. Harry Foreman                                     Docketing:& Service Section Direttor of Center for                                 Office:of the Secretary.
Washington, D..C.
Population Studies                                 U. S. Nuclear Regulatory University of Minnesota                                   Commission Minneapolis, Minnesota 55455                           Washington, D. C.         -20555 Rep. Ronald V..Dellums, M.C.           _
20555 Mr. Gustave A. Linenberger-Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel Ms. Barbara Shockley U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commiss. ion 1890 Bockman Road Washington, D. C.
Atomic Safety and Licensing' Attention: Ms. Nancy Snow, A.'A.                         Board Panel General Delivery, Civic Center Station- U. S. Nuclear' Regulatory Oakland, California 94604                                 Commission Washington, D. C.           20555 Andrew Baldwin, Esq.
20555 San Lorenzo, California 94580 Dr. Harry Foreman Docketing:& Service Section Direttor of Center for Office:of the Secretary.
c/o Friends of the Earth                               Atomic Safety and Licensing 124 Spear Street                                         Appeal Board San Francisco, California           94105             U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Daniel Swanson,.Esq., OELD                             Washington, D. C. 20555 U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D. C.         20555 Edward A. Firestone, Esq.                                   m/
Population Studies U. S. Nuclear Regulatory University of Minnesota Commission Minneapolis, Minnesota 55455 Washington, D. C.
General Electric Company                       George L y.       -
-20555 Rep. Ronald V..Dellums, M.C.
                                                                                            /
Atomic Safety and Licensing' Attention:
: Nuclear Energy Division                       .Attorne7 for               /any 175 Curtner Avenue                             General Electric         o San Jose, California         95125 CMail Code 822)<
Ms. Nancy Snow, A.'A.
Datedi     November 30, 1978
Board Panel General Delivery, Civic Center Station-U. S. Nuclear' Regulatory Oakland, California 94604 Commission Washington, D. C.
_ .                  .m.           . _      -  -    .      --        .  .      _.        . ..}}
20555 Andrew Baldwin, Esq.
c/o Friends of the Earth Atomic Safety and Licensing 124 Spear Street Appeal Board San Francisco, California 94105 U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Daniel Swanson,.Esq., OELD Washington, D. C.
20555 U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D. C.
20555 Edward A.
Firestone, Esq.
m/
General Electric Company George L y.
/
: Nuclear Energy Division
.Attorne7 for
/
175 Curtner Avenue General Electric any o
San Jose, California 95125 CMail Code 822)<
Datedi November 30, 1978
.m.
...}}

Latest revision as of 07:28, 11 December 2024

Licensee GEs Answers to Intervenor R Dellums Interrogs 780803.Questions Concern Fuel Flooding Sys,Containment Pressure,Vacuum Relief Sys & Other Topics Re Safety of Subj Facil.Affidavits & Cert of Svc Encl
ML20150E983
Person / Time
Site: Vallecitos File:GEH Hitachi icon.png
Issue date: 11/30/1978
From: Darmitzel D, Gilliland D, Hoggatt G
GENERAL ELECTRIC CO.
To:
References
NUDOCS 7812280275
Download: ML20150E983 (8)


Text

_

i NRC PUBL:C DOCUdNI MM

i

[

-11/30/78

,.M ',O p

o

.z.

,, f

~j T.. nT'

'9.$ /p

. f5 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA gT' #

NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION

-In the Matter.of-

)

. )

Docket No. 50-70.

GENERAL ELECTRIC COMPANY

)

)

Operating License (Vallecitos Nuclear Center -

)

No. TR-1 General' Electric Test Reactor)

)

.(Show Cause)

LICENSEE'S ANSWERS TO INTERVENOR'S AUGUST 3, 1978 INTERROGATORIES General' Electric (GE) hereby. responds to.. Inter-ivenor Congressman Dellums' interrogatories dated August 3,

./

1978

as follows:

1.

The heat generation rate following such a postulated accident is discussed in detail in the Safety Analysis Re' port (NEDO 12622) at pages 9-84:through 9-93.

  • /

GE had originally objected to these interrogatories re-lated to the GETR containment systems'on the grounds.that continued. containment integrity is not required in order i

to assure the safe shutdown of GETR following.the occur-4 rence of the maximum postulated-seismic event and that the information sought'through these interrogatories was there-

-fore irrelevant to the resolution of any.of the three L

specific issues. identified in the Commission's February 13, l'

1978 Memorandum and Order.

These answers are being-provided in accordance with the directive contained in the Licensing Board's November 13, 1978 Order in which the Board expressed--

.the view that these interrogatories were permissible since-responses "may lead to the discovery of-7 '- m ^ -" 4 A - ~ a "

pursuant to 10 CFR S '2.740(b)(1).

THIS. DOCUMENT CONTAINS.

g P00R QUAUTY PAGES

?S132sios7s~

(,

y

.p

<w=

4 m

94 e

p-w <-

es -

e<-ae ew r

--i-'n,,e m - w

+a e

~w e

m

-2 i

2.

The heat generation rate referenced in Interrogatory No. 1 is identical to that. assumed in the containment analysis (i.e., NEDO 12622, p. 9-84).

3.

The primary function of the vacuum relief system is to assure that pressure outside containment does not exceed the pressure inside containment by more than approximately 0.1 psi.

This system is also designed to main-tain containment integrity at or above the containment design pressure.

4.

The containment pressure associated.with the maximum postulated accident (4.1 psi) is less than the containment design pressure (5 psi).

5.

No, nor is one required to avoid possible shell rupture and maintain building integrity.

6.

The Fuel Flooding System is being designed and installed to assure safe shutdown of GETR in case of the occurrence of the maximum postulated seismic event.

Contain-ment integrity is not needed to assure safe shutdown of GETR in such an event.

7.

No.

8.

The equation is Charles Law (Thermodynamics,

Virgil Moring Faries, 3rd Ed. 1959, McMillan & Co., p. 56).

It is appropriate to use this ideal gas law for an air l environment in situations where the volume remains constant, i

-3 9.

The assumptions which are used in the cal-culation of maximum containment pressure are in the Safety Analysis Report (NEDO 12622) pp. 9-84 through 9-93.

10.

The " actual" containment volume.of 250,000 cubic feet was determined by calculations wherein all structures -(including all pools at maximum levels, etc.).

were taken into account.

11.

No tests which measure the heat transfer rate through the actual GETR containment shell have been-performed.

12.

No '.

13.

The filter media that are now'in use are Model lE-1000-2 and lE-1250-1(S), manufactured by Cambridge Filter Company.

Filter media are tested by the manufacturer with dioctyl phthalate at 20% and 100% of rated flow.

Minimum efficiency must be 99.97% retention of 0.3 um dioctyl phthalate particles with a maximum penetration less than 0.03%.

14.

There are a total of four steel cabinets con-taining decontamination supplies such as mop heads, masslin cloths and wooden handles located throughout the three floors of the containment building.

Occasionally, wooden i

planks are used for scaffolding and gasolinepowered forklift trucks are used when required.

No flammable liquids are stored in the containment, i

,--,-y

.y~-,-

,y.

w.

,e m

,4

n 4

-4 15.

In-service inspection program for safety-re-lated systems may be found in Section 8 of the Safety Analysis Report (NEDO 12622) and Appendix 10 of the June 1978 Re-sponse to the Show~Cause Order.

This program is reviewed and' updated'en a routine basis.

16.

The' criterion is' designed to assure that a given sat

._f related system continues to operate properly during and ;;i.ter the off-normal or ' accident condition it was

' designed _to mitigate.

~

l 17.

The indepencent review of the maintenance I

plan is performed by the Reactor Analyst and the Nuclear Safety and Quality Assurance organization,-with periodic

, audit reviews: performed by the Vallecitos Technological Safety Council and the Nuclear Energy Business Group's Nu-clear Energy Product and' Quality Assurance Operation.

18.

See'the response to Interrogatory No. 15.

I 19.

Table 3-1 is more thoroughly described in'EDAC report 117.08 previously forwarded tu all parties.

i l

I s-u...-.

. - - -. -. ~....

UNITED STATES OF APERicA NUCLEAR REGULATORY C089tISS104 in the Matter of DOCKET NO. 50-70 GENERAL ELECTRIC CDFAW OPERATING LICERSE

-(Vallecitos Muclear Center -

to. TR-1 General Electric Test Re?@r)

(SHOW CAltSE)

AFF10MIT OF GEORE D. MXJATT 1

George D. Hoggatt, being duly sworn. W and'says as f' ilows:

o j

i 1.

That he is employed as Manager. EETR License Renewal. General Electric Company. Vallecitus Nuclear Center. Pleasanton California.

1 1

and wat he is duty authorized to esecute the foregoing answers to the interrogatories 1 through 12.15.16,18 and 19 propounded ty cor.y esman.';'

OcIluss under date of August 3.1976, on behalf of the L1censee.

2.

That the ahore mentioned and attached answers are true afd correct to the t.ast of his krxmledge and helief.

J Georg6 D. MpW

~

Sutrscribed and sworn to before me this Mt M day of Novester,192.

76.~, u d&,~,

. notar, %uc. Av eaa county, seate or Caurwa.

r My ccustission expires March 8. M31.

~ - --. ~..._,

WGrJ1A C CNT r 'r } -

' Of rh MAL,3

... ' ~

..' D -

.-l'

' ; 'j

'(, t ' =t Mu:. cs.m ur, s.

b f *,' /

' A L AVLJ L f '/ - ;-

F

. ~ m ---,....

,, a

.a

.j

s q

UMITEIl $TATES OF MERICA IUCLEAR REGJLATUdY COPMISSION In the 76atter of

)

Dotket 5o

"" M GEKIRAL EECTRIC COWMY

Opera, 5

(Vallecttos Muclear Center -

General Electric Test Reactor)

.)

AFFIGAYETOFDVy_MT_

~

(hright L. Gfililand, heA

,,, sworn, deposes and says as follom L.

That he is engleyed as' Wr, Reactw Irradiatforts. GenersT Electric Coman'f. Vallecitos % clear Center, Pleasanten. Californf a, and' that he is duly authorized to execute the foregoing answers to the interrogatories, propounded by Congressaan Dellums mder date of August 3.1978, on behalf of tSe 1imnsee, That the above mentioned and attached answers art truet and correct to the 2.

test of his knowledge and belief, bl[L Derfght L. Gifliland i

Subscribed and sworn to before me thfs J #8 day of hh.1978.

7 t f< *<., 6 d u,ge,ff

, notary Public, Alameda County, State of e

Callfornia. fty cow 2ission.expf res March 8, h41.

~

l a,

1 m~a

- nn,...t

,e o r Fr q A L : r. L ff%

i 3. wmu A. c.. v r.- S f 3 : u. r m. ci,, r A g

i

' s' Nsur t

<<*:.I.

{

,...e,.,

v., y.,,. m c.......

l-

a..

... ~

p. p ea..

,s

(MITH1 iTATG OF AERTIA N'JCLEAR REGJLATORY C@ttf!SSIOPL In the Matter-of

)

Docket Mo. 50 7G

)

GENERAL ELECTRIC C@FMY 1

@ ratf M License j

Mo. TR-1 (Vallecitos Maclear Center -

5 (shoe cause)

General ETectric Test Reactor 3

AFFIGAVTT OF ROBERT W._DMMITZEL RotMert W. DaruitzeT, be.ing du2y smorrr. deposes and sgys as follows:

1.

That he is espToyed as knager, Trradiation Processing Operatforr, General

- Electric Company. Va31ecitos hefear Center., Pleasanton, CaTifornia, and tirat he fr duly authorized to exacute th foregning answtrs to the interrogatorter, propounded by Congressaarr De11ues. m6er date of August 3.1973. on behalf crf the Lfcensee.

2.

That the above sentioned and attached answery are true amt cortwet to the j

best of his knowledge and belfer.

hhG m,e..

. i Subs ribed and sworn tc before sne thist

  1. 4 d4y of November.1978.

dyem/ud Notary Public, Alameda County, $ tate of

<t,,,,

CalifSrnia. My condission expires Nrch 8,1931.

w s a_r

~

\\ VIPG#N"A C.. (It&Jtic (

~

~

-($-g;17 omCIAL 1.. /..,

i

~

L

~gy, sotwr rukc. cxvces;A c

N*#'

,.j/

'*?

i UNITED STATES OF' AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION c

In the' Matter of

)

)

Docket No. 50-70 GENERAL ELECTRIC COMPANY

)

)

Operating License (Vallecitos Nuclear Center -

)

No. TR-1 General Electric Test Reactor)

)

(Show Cause)

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that the foregoing has been-served as of this date by personal delivery.or first class mail, postage prepaid, to the following:

Edward Luton, Esq., Chairman

. Lawrence Chandler, Esq.

Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel U. S. Nuclear Regulatory U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Commission Washington, D. C.

20555 17171H. Street, N.W.

Washington, D..C.

20555 Mr. Gustave A. Linenberger-Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel Ms. Barbara Shockley U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commiss. ion 1890 Bockman Road Washington, D. C.

20555 San Lorenzo, California 94580 Dr. Harry Foreman Docketing:& Service Section Direttor of Center for Office:of the Secretary.

Population Studies U. S. Nuclear Regulatory University of Minnesota Commission Minneapolis, Minnesota 55455 Washington, D. C.

-20555 Rep. Ronald V..Dellums, M.C.

Atomic Safety and Licensing' Attention:

Ms. Nancy Snow, A.'A.

Board Panel General Delivery, Civic Center Station-U. S. Nuclear' Regulatory Oakland, California 94604 Commission Washington, D. C.

20555 Andrew Baldwin, Esq.

c/o Friends of the Earth Atomic Safety and Licensing 124 Spear Street Appeal Board San Francisco, California 94105 U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Daniel Swanson,.Esq., OELD Washington, D. C.

20555 U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D. C.

20555 Edward A.

Firestone, Esq.

m/

General Electric Company George L y.

/

Nuclear Energy Division

.Attorne7 for

/

175 Curtner Avenue General Electric any o

San Jose, California 95125 CMail Code 822)<

Datedi November 30, 1978

.m.

...