ML24134A024: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
StriderTol (talk | contribs) (StriderTol Bot change) |
StriderTol (talk | contribs) (StriderTol Bot change) |
||
| Line 15: | Line 15: | ||
=Text= | =Text= | ||
{{#Wiki_filter:Path Forward for NRC Review of RNP Topical Reports for SLR | {{#Wiki_filter:Path Forward for NRC Review of RNP Topical Reports for SLR 1 | ||
May 22, 2024 | May 22, 2024 | ||
AGENDA Pressurize Thermal Shock Screening Criteria 2 | |||
Purpose of Request for Topical Report Review and Approval Regulatory Path Summary of Topical Reports | Purpose of Request for Topical Report Review and Approval Regulatory Path Summary of Topical Reports | ||
* WCAP- | * WCAP-18909-NP | ||
* WCAP-18933-NP Conclusion NRC Feedback | * WCAP-18933-NP Conclusion NRC Feedback | ||
PURPOSE Pressurize Thermal Shock Screening Criteria 3 | |||
To discuss path forward for review of topical reports Support timely submittal of the RNP SLR application in 2nd quarter 2025 Submit topical reports for NRC review/approval | |||
To discuss path forward for review of topical reports | |||
Support timely submittal of the RNP SLR application in 2nd quarter 2025 | |||
* Increase efficiency of SLR application review/approval | * Increase efficiency of SLR application review/approval | ||
* Allow staff to meet 18-month review schedule | * Allow staff to meet 18-month review schedule Provide demonstration of compliance to 10 CFR 50.61 for weld #W5214 for 70 Effective Full Power Years (i.e., 80 years of operation) | ||
Provide demonstration of compliance to 10 CFR 50.61 for weld #W5214 for 70 Effective Full Power Years (i.e., 80 years of operation) | |||
* Utilize an acceptable methodology to meet PTS screening criteria | * Utilize an acceptable methodology to meet PTS screening criteria | ||
* Utilize WCAP-18909 and WCAP -18933 as input to satisfy the PTS screening criteria | * Utilize WCAP-18909 and WCAP-18933 as input to satisfy the PTS screening criteria | ||
Utilize an acceptable methodology in 10 CFR 50.61 to develop RTNDT for weld | Regulatory Path Utilize an acceptable methodology in 10 CFR 50.61 to develop RTNDT for weld | ||
#W5214. | |||
* 10 CFR 50.61(a)(5) - | * 10 CFR 50.61(a)(5) - RTNDT(U) means the reference temperature for a reactor vessel material in the pre-service or unirradiated condition, evaluated according to the procedures in the ASME Code, Paragraph NB-2331 or other methods approved by the Director, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation. | ||
Develop RTT0 with 2019 Edition ASME Subsection NB-2331(a)(5) based on fracture toughness. | Develop RTT0 with 2019 Edition ASME Subsection NB-2331(a)(5) based on fracture toughness. | ||
Duke will illustrate in the SLR application that the RTNDT for weld #W5214 succeeds in satisfying the PTS screening criteria for 80 years. | Duke will illustrate in the SLR application that the RTNDT for weld #W5214 succeeds in satisfying the PTS screening criteria for 80 years. | ||
4 | |||
Summary WCAP-18909 NP | |||
==Purpose:== | ==Purpose:== | ||
Measure initial unirradiated fracture toughness-based reference temperature RTT0 for #W5214 weld material | Measure initial unirradiated fracture toughness-based reference temperature RTT0 for #W5214 weld material Develop T0 with fracture toughness test of unirradiated specimen | ||
Develop T0 with fracture toughness test of unirradiated specimen | |||
* ASTM E1921 Develop material specific RTT0 with fracture toughness results | * ASTM E1921 Develop material specific RTT0 with fracture toughness results | ||
* ASME Section III, NB-2331(a)(5) | * ASME Section III, NB-2331(a)(5) | ||
Duke will develop RTT0 for #W5214 and shows the PTS screening criterion are met for 80 years | Duke will develop RTT0 for #W5214 and shows the PTS screening criterion are met for 80 years | ||
* RTNDT(U) = RTT0 = T0 + 35F + 2 | * RTNDT(U) = RTT0 = T0 + 35F + 2 | ||
* RTPTS = RTT0 + Charpy Shift + Margin | * RTPTS = RTT0 + Charpy Shift + Margin 5 | ||
Summary WCAP-18933 NP | |||
==Purpose:== | ==Purpose:== | ||
Measure irradiated RTT0 for Robinson #W5214 weld material | Measure irradiated RTT0 for Robinson #W5214 weld material | ||
* Note: Duke will submit revised WCAP-18933 to focus review only on #W5214 material | * Note: Duke will submit revised WCAP-18933 to focus review only on #W5214 material Develop irradiated T0 with fracture toughness test | ||
Develop irradiated T0 with fracture toughness test | |||
* ASTM E1921 Develop material specific RTT0 with fracture toughness results | * ASTM E1921 Develop material specific RTT0 with fracture toughness results | ||
* ASME Section III, NB-2331(a)(5) | * ASME Section III, NB-2331(a)(5) | ||
Illustrate that the difference between the irradiated RTT0 and the Charpy-based RTPTS methods is minimal to demonstrate margin for the PTS screening criterion | Illustrate that the difference between the irradiated RTT0 and the Charpy-based RTPTS methods is minimal to demonstrate margin for the PTS screening criterion 6 | ||
6 | |||
Conclusion Provisions in 10 CFR 50.61(a)(5) allow the use of 2019 Edition ASME Subsection NB-2331(a)(5) to develop RTT0. | |||
Duke requests review and approval of WCAP-18909 and WCAP-18933. | Duke requests review and approval of WCAP-18909 and WCAP-18933. | ||
* Duke will resubmit WCAP-18933 to limit NRC review and approval of only the material associated with the weld #W5214. | * Duke will resubmit WCAP-18933 to limit NRC review and approval of only the material associated with the weld #W5214. | ||
Duke will utilize these WCAPs as input to demonstrate weld material #W5214 satisfies the 10 CFR 50.61 screening criterion in the SLR application for 80 years (70 EFPY). | Duke will utilize these WCAPs as input to demonstrate weld material #W5214 satisfies the 10 CFR 50.61 screening criterion in the SLR application for 80 years (70 EFPY). | ||
7 | |||
NRC Feedback NRC FEEDBACK 8}} | |||
NRC FEEDBACK | |||
8}} | |||
Latest revision as of 18:21, 24 November 2024
| ML24134A024 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Robinson  |
| Issue date: | 05/22/2024 |
| From: | Lingham S NRC/NRR/DNRL/NLRP |
| To: | |
| References | |
| Download: ML24134A024 (8) | |
Text
Path Forward for NRC Review of RNP Topical Reports for SLR 1
May 22, 2024
AGENDA Pressurize Thermal Shock Screening Criteria 2
Purpose of Request for Topical Report Review and Approval Regulatory Path Summary of Topical Reports
- WCAP-18933-NP Conclusion NRC Feedback
PURPOSE Pressurize Thermal Shock Screening Criteria 3
To discuss path forward for review of topical reports Support timely submittal of the RNP SLR application in 2nd quarter 2025 Submit topical reports for NRC review/approval
- Increase efficiency of SLR application review/approval
- Allow staff to meet 18-month review schedule Provide demonstration of compliance to 10 CFR 50.61 for weld #W5214 for 70 Effective Full Power Years (i.e., 80 years of operation)
- Utilize an acceptable methodology to meet PTS screening criteria
- Utilize WCAP-18909 and WCAP-18933 as input to satisfy the PTS screening criteria
Regulatory Path Utilize an acceptable methodology in 10 CFR 50.61 to develop RTNDT for weld
- W5214.
- 10 CFR 50.61(a)(5) - RTNDT(U) means the reference temperature for a reactor vessel material in the pre-service or unirradiated condition, evaluated according to the procedures in the ASME Code, Paragraph NB-2331 or other methods approved by the Director, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation.
Develop RTT0 with 2019 Edition ASME Subsection NB-2331(a)(5) based on fracture toughness.
Duke will illustrate in the SLR application that the RTNDT for weld #W5214 succeeds in satisfying the PTS screening criteria for 80 years.
4
Summary WCAP-18909 NP
Purpose:
Measure initial unirradiated fracture toughness-based reference temperature RTT0 for #W5214 weld material Develop T0 with fracture toughness test of unirradiated specimen
- ASTM E1921 Develop material specific RTT0 with fracture toughness results
- ASME Section III, NB-2331(a)(5)
Duke will develop RTT0 for #W5214 and shows the PTS screening criterion are met for 80 years
- RTNDT(U) = RTT0 = T0 + 35F + 2
- RTPTS = RTT0 + Charpy Shift + Margin 5
Summary WCAP-18933 NP
Purpose:
Measure irradiated RTT0 for Robinson #W5214 weld material
- Note: Duke will submit revised WCAP-18933 to focus review only on #W5214 material Develop irradiated T0 with fracture toughness test
- ASTM E1921 Develop material specific RTT0 with fracture toughness results
- ASME Section III, NB-2331(a)(5)
Illustrate that the difference between the irradiated RTT0 and the Charpy-based RTPTS methods is minimal to demonstrate margin for the PTS screening criterion 6
Conclusion Provisions in 10 CFR 50.61(a)(5) allow the use of 2019 Edition ASME Subsection NB-2331(a)(5) to develop RTT0.
Duke requests review and approval of WCAP-18909 and WCAP-18933.
- Duke will resubmit WCAP-18933 to limit NRC review and approval of only the material associated with the weld #W5214.
Duke will utilize these WCAPs as input to demonstrate weld material #W5214 satisfies the 10 CFR 50.61 screening criterion in the SLR application for 80 years (70 EFPY).
7
NRC Feedback NRC FEEDBACK 8