ML23171A980: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(StriderTol Bot change)
(StriderTol Bot change)
Line 15: Line 15:


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:June 20, 2023 MEMORANDUM TO:                 Matthew A. Mitchell, Chief Piping and Head Penetrations Branch Division of New and Renewed Licenses Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation FROM:                           Ali Rezai, Materials Engineer         /RA/
{{#Wiki_filter:June 20, 2023
Piping and Head Penetrations Branch Division of New and Renewed Licenses Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
 
MEMORANDUM TO: Matt hew A. Mitchell, Chief P iping and Head Penetrations Branch Divis ion of New and Renewed Licenses OfficeofNuc lear Reactor Regulation
 
FROM: AliRezai,Mater ials Engineer /RA/
P iping and Head Penetrations Branch Divis ion of New and Renewed Licenses OfficeofNuc lear Reactor Regulation


==SUBJECT:==
==SUBJECT:==
==SUMMARY==
==SUMMARY==
OF JUNE 14 AND 15, 2023, ANNUAL INDUSTRY /
OF JUNE 14 AND 15, 2023, ANNUAL INDUSTRY /
U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION MATERIALS PROGRAMS TECHNICAL INFORMATION EXCHANGE PUBLIC MEETING On June 14 and 15, 2023, the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) held a hybrid observation public meeting with representatives from the nuclear industry for an exchange of technical information on the industrys ongoing materials programs, in particular as related to the integrity of reactor pressure vessels, reactor vessel internals, and piping. During the meeting, the passive component materials related program updates, issues, operational experience, and ongoing research were discussed. The industry representatives included staff from the Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI), the Pressurized Water Reactor (PWR)
U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION MATERIALS PROGRAMS TECHNICAL INFORMATION EXCHANGE PUBLIC MEETING
Owners Group (PWROG), the Boiling Water Reactor (BWR) Owners Group (BWROG),
 
licensees and vendor companies. Many of the licensee representatives also hold advisory roles to the EPRI Materials Reliability Program (MRP), EPRI BWR Vessel and Internals Project (BWRVIP), PWROG Materials Committee (MSC), EPRI Welding Repair and Technology Program (WRTC) and EPRI International Materials Research (IMR) committee. In addition, members of the public also participated by teleconference.
On June 14 and 15, 2023, the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) held a hybrid observation public meeting with representatives from the nuclea r industry for an exchange of technical information on the industrys ongoing materials progr ams, in particular as related to the integrity of reactor pressure vessels, reactor vessel inter nals, and piping. During the meeting, the passive component materials related program update s, issues, operational experience, and ongoing research were discussed. The industry r epresentatives included staff from the Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI), the Pressuri zed Water Reactor (PWR)
The list of attendees is provided in the Appendix. All presentations and other information related to this public meeting (e.g., agenda and presentations) are available on the NRCs Agencywide Documents Access and Management System (ADAMS), Accession No. ML23163A003. The agenda file provides the identifier number for the presentation file(s) that were used for each agenda topic.
Owners Group (PWROG), the Boiling Water Reactor (BWR) Owners Gr oup (BWROG),
CONTACTS: Ali Rezai, NRR/DNRL/NPHP                    David Rudland, NRR/DNRL 301 415-1328                          301 415-1896 Ali.Rezai@nrc.gov                    David.Rudland@nrc.gov
licensees and vendor companies. Many of the licensee representa tives also hold advisory roles to the EPRI Materials Reliability Pr ogram (MRP), EPRI BWR Vesse l and Internals Project (BWRVIP), PWROG Materials Co mmittee (MSC), EPRI Welding Repair and Technology Program (WRTC) and EPRI International Materials Research (IMR) committee. In addition, members of the public also participated by teleconference.


M. Mitchell                                 2
The list of attendees is provided in the Appendix. All presenta tions and other information related to this public meeting (e.g., agenda and presentations) are ava ilable on the NRCs Agencywide Documents Access and Management System (ADAMS), Accession No. M L23163A003. The agenda file provides the identifier number for the presentation file(s) that were used for each agenda topic.
 
CONTACTS: Ali Rezai, NRR/DNRL/NPHP David Rudland, NRR/DNRL 301 415-1328 301 415-1896 Ali.Rezai@nrc.gov David.Rudland@nrc.gov M. Mitchell 2


==SUBJECT:==
==SUBJECT:==
==SUMMARY==
OF JUNE 14 AND 15, 2023, ANNUAL INDUSTRY / U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION MATERIALS PROGRAMS TECHNICAL INFORMATION EXCHANGE PUBLIC MEETING. DATED: JUNE 20, 2023


==SUMMARY==
DISTRIBUTION:
OF JUNE 14 AND 15, 2023, ANNUAL INDUSTRY / U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION MATERIALS PROGRAMS TECHNICAL INFORMATION EXCHANGE PUBLIC MEETING. DATED: JUNE 20, 2023 DISTRIBUTION:
BSmith BThomson JWise AHiser DRudland MMitchell SBloom SRuffin RIyengar RTregoning LGibson ARezai RKalikian SBailey KManoly JCirilli@epri.com
BSmith BThomson JWise AHiser DRudland MMitchell SBloom SRuffin RIyengar RTregoning LGibson ARezai RKalikian SBailey KManoly JCirilli@epri.com ADAMS Accession Numbers:
 
Package: ML23163A003 Summary: ML23171A980                                             NRR-106 OFFICE                 NRR/DNRL               NRR/DNRL/NPHP NAME                   DRudland               ARezai DATE                   6/20/2023               6/20/2023 OFFICIAL RECORD COPY
ADAMS Accession Numbers:
Package: ML23163A003 Summary: ML23171A980 NRR-106 OFFICE NRR/DNRL NRR/DNRL/NPHP NAME DRudland ARezai DATE 6/20/2023 6/20/2023 OFFICIALRECORDCOPY
 
APPENDIX
 
ATTENDEES AT JUNE 14 AND 15, 2023 MATERIALS PROGRAMS TECHNICAL INFORMATION EXCHANGE PUBLIC MEETING (HYBRID)
 
Name Affiliation Contact Aaron A Diaz PNNL Aaron.Diaz@pnnl.gov Adam Brooks ORNL brooksal@ornl.gov Ali Rezai NRC Ali.Rezai@nrc.gov Allen Hiser NRC Allen.Hiser@nrc.gov Amit Kalia Amit.Kalia@luminant.com Amy Freed EPRI Amy G. Aughtman AGAUGHTM@SOUTHERNCO.COM Amy Hull NRC Amy.Hull@nrc.gov Andrew J Burgess ABurgess@ameren.com Anees Udyawar Westinghouse udyawaa@westinghouse.com Angel Reyes-Cruz Constellation Angel.Reyes-Cruz@constellation.com Nuclear Angie Buford NRC Angela.Buford@nrc.gov Annessa Lippincott GSES annessa.lippincott@gses.com Atif Shaikh NRC Atif.Shaikh@nrc.gov Attila Z. Szabo Westinghouse szaboaz@westinghouse.com Austin Young NRC Austin.Young@nrc.gov Bart Fu NRC Bart.Fu@nrc.gov Bernie Thomson NRC Bernie.Thomson@nrc.gov Beth Kehler Haluska Dominion Energy beth.kehler.Haluska@dominionenergy.com Bill Rogers NRC Bill.Rogers@nrc.gov Bob Kalinowski rpkalinowski@aep.com Brett Titus NEI bat@nei.org Brian Allik NRC Brian.Allik@nrc.gov Brian Bowker NRC Brian.Bowker@nrc.gov Brian Cohn NRC Brian.Cohn@nrc.gov Bruce Lin NRC Bruce.Lin@nrc.gov Bruno Vieira Lopes brunovl@eletronuclear.gov.br Bryan M. Wilson Westinghouse wilsonbm@westinghouse.com Carol Moyer NRC Carol.Moyer@nrc.gov Carol Nove NRC Carol.Nove@nrc.gov Carolyn Fairbanks NRC Carolyn.Fairbanks@nrc.gov Chris Wax EPRI cwax@epri.com Christopher Nellis NRC Christopher.Nellis@nrc.gov Christopher R Koehler Xcel Energy christopher.r.koehler@xcelenergy.com Christopher Ulmer NRC Christopher.Ulmer@nrc.gov Corey Thomas Southern Nuclear BRCThoma@southernco.com Cory Parker NRC Cory.Parker@nrc.gov Cotasha Wilson Blackburn CWILSON@southernco.com Craig Harrington EPRI charrington@epri.com Daisuke Nio


APPENDIX ATTENDEES AT JUNE 14 AND 15, 2023 MATERIALS PROGRAMS TECHNICAL INFORMATION EXCHANGE PUBLIC MEETING (HYBRID)
1 Dale E Turinetti deturinetti@aep.com Dale Matthews Framatome dale.matthews@framatome.us Dale Turinetta AEP deturinetti@aep.com Dan Patten Dan Widrevitz NRC Dan.Widrevitz@nrc.gov Daniel Klein Framatome daniel.klein@framatome.us Daniel Lamond Daniel.Lamond@gses.com Daniel Patten Energy Harbor dpatten@energyharbor.com Darren Mount Paul.Mount@evergy.com David C Radonovich Westinghouse radonod@westinghouse.com David Dijamco NRC David.Dijamco@nrc.gov David Rudland NRC David.Rudland@nrc.gov Dev Ray NRC Devendra.Ray@nrc.gov Dilip Dedhia Ddedhia@Structint.com DJ Shim EPRI DShim@epri.com Donna Slivon Donna.Slivon@fpl.com Donnamarie Bush PSEG Nuclear Donnamarie.Bush@pseg.com Doug Kull EPRI dkull@epri.com Dylan Cimock EPRI dcimock@epri.com Eiji Machida Elliot Emma Haywood NRC Mary.Haywood@nrc.gov Eric Focht NRC Eric.Focht@nrc.gov Eric M. Benacquista Westinghouse benacqem@westinghouse.com Eric Reichelt NRC Eric.Reichelt@nrc.gov Ernest Deemer Westinghouse Frank Gift EPRI FGift@epri.com Frederick Garcia Heras Maria Luisa mheras@tecnatom.es Garry Young EPRI garyoung@epri.com Gary Park Gikas Theodossiou Constellation Gikas.Theodossiou@constellation.com Nuclear Glenn Chatterton wgchatterton@aep.com Glenn White Dominion Gwhite@domeng.com Engineering Glunt, Nathan EPRI nglunt@epri.com Gordon Hall Westinghouse hallgz@westinghouse.com Greg A. Fischer Westinghouse fischega@westinghouse.com Heather Malikowski EPRI Hmalikowski@epri.com Hiroyuki Kobayashi EPRI HKobayashi@epri.com Ila Collins icollins@enercon.com Isaac Anchondo-Lopez NRC isaac.anchondo-lopez@nrc.gov J. Brian Hall Westinghouse halljb@westinghouse.com Jacky Shoulders Constellation Jacky.Shoulders@constellation.com Nuclear James Drake NRC James.Drake@nrc.gov
Name                        Affiliation      Contact Aaron A Diaz              PNNL              Aaron.Diaz@pnnl.gov Adam Brooks                ORNL              brooksal@ornl.gov Ali Rezai                  NRC               Ali.Rezai@nrc.gov Allen Hiser                NRC                Allen.Hiser@nrc.gov Amit Kalia                                    Amit.Kalia@luminant.com Amy Freed                  EPRI Amy G. Aughtman                              AGAUGHTM@SOUTHERNCO.COM Amy Hull                  NRC                Amy.Hull@nrc.gov Andrew J Burgess                              ABurgess@ameren.com Anees Udyawar              Westinghouse     udyawaa@westinghouse.com Angel Reyes-Cruz            Constellation    Angel.Reyes-Cruz@constellation.com Nuclear Angie Buford              NRC               Angela.Buford@nrc.gov Annessa Lippincott        GSES              annessa.lippincott@gses.com Atif Shaikh                NRC               Atif.Shaikh@nrc.gov Attila Z. Szabo            Westinghouse      szaboaz@westinghouse.com Austin Young              NRC               Austin.Young@nrc.gov Bart Fu                    NRC              Bart.Fu@nrc.gov Bernie Thomson            NRC                Bernie.Thomson@nrc.gov Beth Kehler Haluska        Dominion Energy  beth.kehler.Haluska@dominionenergy.com Bill Rogers                NRC                Bill.Rogers@nrc.gov Bob Kalinowski                                rpkalinowski@aep.com Brett Titus                NEI                bat@nei.org Brian Allik                NRC               Brian.Allik@nrc.gov Brian Bowker              NRC               Brian.Bowker@nrc.gov Brian Cohn                NRC                Brian.Cohn@nrc.gov Bruce Lin                  NRC               Bruce.Lin@nrc.gov Bruno Vieira Lopes                            brunovl@eletronuclear.gov.br Bryan M. Wilson            Westinghouse      wilsonbm@westinghouse.com Carol Moyer                NRC                Carol.Moyer@nrc.gov Carol Nove                NRC                Carol.Nove@nrc.gov Carolyn Fairbanks          NRC                Carolyn.Fairbanks@nrc.gov Chris Wax                  EPRI               cwax@epri.com Christopher Nellis        NRC                Christopher.Nellis@nrc.gov Christopher R Koehler      Xcel Energy      christopher.r.koehler@xcelenergy.com Christopher Ulmer          NRC                Christopher.Ulmer@nrc.gov Corey Thomas                Southern Nuclear  BRCThoma@southernco.com Cory Parker                NRC               Cory.Parker@nrc.gov Cotasha Wilson Blackburn                      CWILSON@southernco.com Craig Harrington          EPRI              charrington@epri.com Daisuke Nio 1


Dale E Turinetti                        deturinetti@aep.com Dale Matthews            Framatome      dale.matthews@framatome.us Dale Turinetta          AEP            deturinetti@aep.com Dan Patten Dan Widrevitz            NRC             Dan.Widrevitz@nrc.gov Daniel Klein            Framatome      daniel.klein@framatome.us Daniel Lamond                            Daniel.Lamond@gses.com Daniel Patten            Energy Harbor  dpatten@energyharbor.com Darren Mount                            Paul.Mount@evergy.com David C Radonovich      Westinghouse    radonod@westinghouse.com David Dijamco            NRC             David.Dijamco@nrc.gov David Rudland            NRC             David.Rudland@nrc.gov Dev Ray                  NRC             Devendra.Ray@nrc.gov Dilip Dedhia                            Ddedhia@Structint.com DJ Shim                  EPRI           DShim@epri.com Donna Slivon                            Donna.Slivon@fpl.com Donnamarie Bush          PSEG Nuclear    Donnamarie.Bush@pseg.com Doug Kull                EPRI            dkull@epri.com Dylan Cimock            EPRI           dcimock@epri.com Eiji Machida Elliot Emma Haywood            NRC             Mary.Haywood@nrc.gov Eric Focht              NRC             Eric.Focht@nrc.gov Eric M. Benacquista      Westinghouse    benacqem@westinghouse.com Eric Reichelt            NRC             Eric.Reichelt@nrc.gov Ernest Deemer            Westinghouse Frank Gift              EPRI            FGift@epri.com Frederick Garcia Heras Maria Luisa                mheras@tecnatom.es Garry Young              EPRI            garyoung@epri.com Gary Park Gikas Theodossiou        Constellation  Gikas.Theodossiou@constellation.com Nuclear Glenn Chatterton                        wgchatterton@aep.com Glenn White              Dominion        Gwhite@domeng.com Engineering Glunt, Nathan            EPRI            nglunt@epri.com Gordon Hall              Westinghouse    hallgz@westinghouse.com Greg A. Fischer          Westinghouse    fischega@westinghouse.com Heather Malikowski      EPRI            Hmalikowski@epri.com Hiroyuki Kobayashi      EPRI           HKobayashi@epri.com Ila Collins                              icollins@enercon.com Isaac Anchondo-Lopez    NRC             isaac.anchondo-lopez@nrc.gov J. Brian Hall            Westinghouse    halljb@westinghouse.com Jacky Shoulders          Constellation  Jacky.Shoulders@constellation.com Nuclear James Drake              NRC             James.Drake@nrc.gov 2
2 James Medoff NRC James.Medoff@nrc.gov James R Molnar Constellation James.Molnar@constellation.com Nuclear Jana Bergman Curtisswright jbergman@curtisswright.com Janis Ossmann Westinghouse ossma1jl@westinghouse.com Jared Smith EPRI jarsmith@epri.com Jasmyn Bone Jason Daniel NRC Jason.Daniel@nrc.gov Jason Sisk jsisk@enercon.com Jason Tokey jason.tokey@nuclear.energy.gov Jay Collins NRC Jay.Collins@nrc.gov Jay Wallace NRC Jay.Wallace@nrc.gov Jean Smith EPRI jmsmith@epri.com Jeff Kulp NRC Jeffrey.Kulp@nrc.gov Jeff Poehler NRC Jeffrey.Poehler@nrc.gov Jianwei Chen Westinghouse chen1j@westinghouse.com Jim Chapman Jim Cirilli EPRI jcirilli@epri.com Jim Keiser ORNL keiserjr@ornl.gov Joel Jenkins NRC Joel.Jenkins@nrc.gov John Honcharik NRC John.Honcharik@nrc.gov John Hosler EPRI JHOSLER@epri.com John Tsao NRC John.Tsao@nrc.gov John Wise NRC John.Wise@nrc.gov Jolynn E Oquist jolynn.oquist@xcelenergy.com Jonathan Contreras NRC Jonathan.Contreras@nrc.gov Joshua A Meisel joshua.meisel@dteenergy.com Joshua Block Joshua.BLOCK@fpl.com Josiah Gifaldi NRC Josiah.Gifaldi@nrc.gov Julie Kulik NRC Julie.Kulik@nrc.gov Junichi Hakii Tokyo Electric Power Company Justin Hawkins j.hawkins@holtec.com Kaihwa Hsu NRC Kaihwa.Hsu@nrc.gov Kamal Manoly NRC Kamal.Manoly@nrc.gov Karen Sida NRC Karen.Sida@nrc.gov Keith J Miller Keith.J.Miller@dominionenergy.com Kemper Young Constellation Kemper.Young@constellation.com Nuclear Krishan Garg PSEG Nuclear Krishan.Garg@pseg.com Kyle Amberge EPRI kamberge@epri.com Leah Walters Leslie Terry NRC Leslie.Terry@nrc.gov Liang Y. Zhao INPO ZhaoLY@inpo.org Lori W Hekking Lori.Hekking@duke-energy.com Luis Colon Fuentes NRC Luis.ColonFuentes@nrc.gov Lydiana Alvarado NRC Lydiana.AlvaradoGuilloty@nrc.gov


James Medoff      NRC              James.Medoff@nrc.gov James R Molnar    Constellation   James.Molnar@constellation.com Nuclear Jana Bergman      Curtisswright    jbergman@curtisswright.com Janis Ossmann      Westinghouse    ossma1jl@westinghouse.com Jared Smith        EPRI            jarsmith@epri.com Jasmyn Bone Jason Daniel      NRC             Jason.Daniel@nrc.gov Jason Sisk                          jsisk@enercon.com Jason Tokey                        jason.tokey@nuclear.energy.gov Jay Collins        NRC             Jay.Collins@nrc.gov Jay Wallace        NRC              Jay.Wallace@nrc.gov Jean Smith        EPRI            jmsmith@epri.com Jeff Kulp          NRC             Jeffrey.Kulp@nrc.gov Jeff Poehler      NRC              Jeffrey.Poehler@nrc.gov Jianwei Chen      Westinghouse    chen1j@westinghouse.com Jim Chapman Jim Cirilli        EPRI             jcirilli@epri.com Jim Keiser        ORNL            keiserjr@ornl.gov Joel Jenkins      NRC             Joel.Jenkins@nrc.gov John Honcharik    NRC             John.Honcharik@nrc.gov John Hosler        EPRI            JHOSLER@epri.com John Tsao          NRC             John.Tsao@nrc.gov John Wise          NRC             John.Wise@nrc.gov Jolynn E Oquist                    jolynn.oquist@xcelenergy.com Jonathan Contreras NRC             Jonathan.Contreras@nrc.gov Joshua A Meisel                    joshua.meisel@dteenergy.com Joshua Block                        Joshua.BLOCK@fpl.com Josiah Gifaldi    NRC             Josiah.Gifaldi@nrc.gov Julie Kulik        NRC              Julie.Kulik@nrc.gov Junichi Hakii      Tokyo Electric Power Company Justin Hawkins                      j.hawkins@holtec.com Kaihwa Hsu        NRC             Kaihwa.Hsu@nrc.gov Kamal Manoly      NRC             Kamal.Manoly@nrc.gov Karen Sida        NRC             Karen.Sida@nrc.gov Keith J Miller                      Keith.J.Miller@dominionenergy.com Kemper Young      Constellation   Kemper.Young@constellation.com Nuclear Krishan Garg      PSEG Nuclear    Krishan.Garg@pseg.com Kyle Amberge      EPRI            kamberge@epri.com Leah Walters Leslie Terry      NRC             Leslie.Terry@nrc.gov Liang Y. Zhao      INPO            ZhaoLY@inpo.org Lori W Hekking                      Lori.Hekking@duke-energy.com Luis Colon Fuentes NRC              Luis.ColonFuentes@nrc.gov Lydiana Alvarado  NRC              Lydiana.AlvaradoGuilloty@nrc.gov 3
3 Mark E Weis Constellation Mark.Weis@constellation.com Nuclear Mark Richter NEI mar@nei.org Markus Burkardt DEI Mburkardt@domeng.com Martin Kolar Framatome martin.kolar@framatome.us Mat Burton NRC mathew.burton@nrc.gov Matt White mcwhite@aep.com Matthew Gordon NRC Matthew.Gordon@nrc.gov Matthew King Matthew.King@gses.com Matthew Mitchell NRC Matthew.Mitchell@nrc.gov Matthew S Prowant PNNL Matthew.Prowant@pnnl.gov Mattson, Dick Rmattson@Structint.com McCracken, Steve EPRI smccracken@epri.com McGill, Robert EPRI RMcGill@epri.com Meimei Li ANL mli@anl.gov Mekonen Bayssie NRC Mekonen.Bayssie@nrc.gov Mel Gray NRC Mel.Gray@nrc.gov Michael Benson NRC michael.benson@nrc.gov Michael Magyar NRC Michael.Magyar@nrc.gov Michele Sampson NRC Michele.Sampson@nrc.gov Nat Cofie Ncofie@Structint.com Nathan Palm EPRI Npalm@epri.com Nicholas Hansing NRC Nicholas.Hansing@nrc.gov Nicholas Morgan PWROG-APS Nicholas.Morgan@aps.com Omar Khan NRC Omar.Khan2@nrc.gov On Yee NRC On.Yee@nrc.gov Osvaldo Cruz Constellation Osvaldo.Cruz@constellation.com Nuclear Pl Efsing Vattenfall Pal.Efsing@vattenfall.com Pat Purtscher NRC Patrick.Purtscher@nrc.gov Patrick Raynaud NRC Patrick.Raynaud@nrc.gov Paul Cataldo NRC Paul.Cataldo@nrc.gov Paul Gunter Beyond Nuclear paul@beyoundnuclear.org Paula Cooper NRC Paula.Cooper@nrc.gov Rachel Lee Doss Rachel.Doss@duke-energy.com Randy Stark EPRI rstark@epri.com Rebecca J Nealis Constellation Rebecca.Nealis@constellation.com Nuclear Rich T Giachetti richard.t.giachetti@sargentlundy.com Richard E Jacob PNNL Richard.Jacob@pnnl.gov Richard J. Rogalski rjrogalski@energy-northwest.com Robert Davis NRC Robert.Davis@nrc.gov Robert Grizzi EPRI rgrizzi@epri.com Robert Tregoning NRC Robert.Tregoning@nrc.gov Russ L. Wenzl rlwenzl@nppd.com Russell J Lidberg russell.lidberg@xcelenergy.com Russell, Michael ORNL russellms@ornl.gov


Mark E Weis        Constellation  Mark.Weis@constellation.com Nuclear Mark Richter        NEI            mar@nei.org Markus Burkardt    DEI            Mburkardt@domeng.com Martin Kolar        Framatome       martin.kolar@framatome.us Mat Burton          NRC            mathew.burton@nrc.gov Matt White                          mcwhite@aep.com Matthew Gordon      NRC            Matthew.Gordon@nrc.gov Matthew King                        Matthew.King@gses.com Matthew Mitchell    NRC             Matthew.Mitchell@nrc.gov Matthew S Prowant  PNNL            Matthew.Prowant@pnnl.gov Mattson, Dick                      Rmattson@Structint.com McCracken, Steve    EPRI            smccracken@epri.com McGill, Robert      EPRI            RMcGill@epri.com Meimei Li          ANL            mli@anl.gov Mekonen Bayssie    NRC            Mekonen.Bayssie@nrc.gov Mel Gray            NRC             Mel.Gray@nrc.gov Michael Benson      NRC             michael.benson@nrc.gov Michael Magyar      NRC            Michael.Magyar@nrc.gov Michele Sampson    NRC             Michele.Sampson@nrc.gov Nat Cofie                          Ncofie@Structint.com Nathan Palm        EPRI            Npalm@epri.com Nicholas Hansing    NRC             Nicholas.Hansing@nrc.gov Nicholas Morgan    PWROG-APS      Nicholas.Morgan@aps.com Omar Khan          NRC            Omar.Khan2@nrc.gov On Yee              NRC            On.Yee@nrc.gov Osvaldo Cruz        Constellation  Osvaldo.Cruz@constellation.com Nuclear Pl Efsing          Vattenfall      Pal.Efsing@vattenfall.com Pat Purtscher      NRC             Patrick.Purtscher@nrc.gov Patrick Raynaud    NRC             Patrick.Raynaud@nrc.gov Paul Cataldo        NRC            Paul.Cataldo@nrc.gov Paul Gunter        Beyond Nuclear  paul@beyoundnuclear.org Paula Cooper        NRC            Paula.Cooper@nrc.gov Rachel Lee Doss                    Rachel.Doss@duke-energy.com Randy Stark        EPRI            rstark@epri.com Rebecca J Nealis    Constellation   Rebecca.Nealis@constellation.com Nuclear Rich T Giachetti                    richard.t.giachetti@sargentlundy.com Richard E Jacob    PNNL            Richard.Jacob@pnnl.gov Richard J. Rogalski                rjrogalski@energy-northwest.com Robert Davis        NRC             Robert.Davis@nrc.gov Robert Grizzi      EPRI           rgrizzi@epri.com Robert Tregoning    NRC            Robert.Tregoning@nrc.gov Russ L. Wenzl                      rlwenzl@nppd.com Russell J Lidberg                  russell.lidberg@xcelenergy.com Russell, Michael    ORNL            russellms@ornl.gov 4
4 Ryan Hosler EPRI Rhosler@epri.com Sam Tulloch Sam.Tulloch1@Rolls-Royce.com Samer Mahmoud Framatome samer.mahmoud@framatome.us Sarah Davidsaver Framatome sarah.davidsaver@framatome.us Scott Chesworth Schesworth@Structint.com Seung Hwan Oh EPRI SOh@guestresearcher.epri.com Seung Min NRC Seung.Min@nrc.gov Shah Malik NRC Shah.Malik@nrc.gov Shane Webb Shane.Webb@fpl.com Stacy Yoder Framatome stacy.yoder@framatome.us Stanford E Davis Stanford.Davis@talenenergy.com Stephen Cumblidge NRC Stephen.Cumblidge@nrc.gov Steve Brown Steve Clair Steve Ruffin NRC Steve.Ruffin@nrc.gov Steve Williams EPRI SWilliams@epri.com Steven Bloom NRC Steven.Bloom@nrc.gov Steven K. Richter Energy Northwest SKRICHTER@energy-northwest.com Steven Levitus NRC Steven.Levitus@nrc.gov Steven Williams EPRI Swilliams@epri.com Sue Lesica sue.lesica@nuclear.energy.gov Ted Hilston PNPP Theresa M Willson tmwillson@aep.com Thomas Basso NEI tbb@nei.org Thomas Hartman NRC Thomas.Hartman@nrc.gov Thomas Magee NRC Thomas.Magee@nrc.gov Tiffany A. Baban Entergy Services tbaban@entergy.com Tim Giles Tim Wiger Framatome tim.wiger@framatome.us Timothy Adams tadams@jensenhughes.com Todd Evans Todd.Evans@luminant.com Todd L Davis Constellation Todd.Davis@constellation.com Nuclear Tom Roberts POMO18 Consult tom@pomo18.com V Sreenivas NRC V.Sreenivas@nrc.gov Varoujan Kalikian NRC Roger.Kalikian@nrc.gov Wayne Lunceford EPRI Walunceford@epri.com Wijay C Heinemann wcheinemann@aep.com Will Blankenship wblankenship@domeng.com William L. Moody Westinghouse moodywl@westinghouse.com Xiang Chen ORNL chenx2@ornl.gov Yiren Chen ANL yiren_chen@anl.gov Yiu Law NRC Yiu.Law@nrc.gov


Ryan Hosler      EPRI            Rhosler@epri.com Sam Tulloch                        Sam.Tulloch1@Rolls-Royce.com Samer Mahmoud    Framatome        samer.mahmoud@framatome.us Sarah Davidsaver  Framatome        sarah.davidsaver@framatome.us Scott Chesworth                    Schesworth@Structint.com Seung Hwan Oh    EPRI            SOh@guestresearcher.epri.com Seung Min        NRC              Seung.Min@nrc.gov Shah Malik        NRC              Shah.Malik@nrc.gov Shane Webb                        Shane.Webb@fpl.com Stacy Yoder      Framatome        stacy.yoder@framatome.us Stanford E Davis                  Stanford.Davis@talenenergy.com Stephen Cumblidge NRC              Stephen.Cumblidge@nrc.gov Steve Brown Steve Clair Steve Ruffin      NRC              Steve.Ruffin@nrc.gov Steve Williams    EPRI            SWilliams@epri.com Steven Bloom      NRC              Steven.Bloom@nrc.gov Steven K. Richter Energy Northwest SKRICHTER@energy-northwest.com Steven Levitus    NRC              Steven.Levitus@nrc.gov Steven Williams  EPRI            Swilliams@epri.com Sue Lesica                        sue.lesica@nuclear.energy.gov Ted Hilston      PNPP Theresa M Willson                  tmwillson@aep.com Thomas Basso      NEI              tbb@nei.org Thomas Hartman    NRC              Thomas.Hartman@nrc.gov Thomas Magee      NRC              Thomas.Magee@nrc.gov Tiffany A. Baban  Entergy Services tbaban@entergy.com Tim Giles Tim Wiger        Framatome        tim.wiger@framatome.us Timothy Adams                      tadams@jensenhughes.com Todd Evans                        Todd.Evans@luminant.com Todd L Davis      Constellation    Todd.Davis@constellation.com Nuclear Tom Roberts      POMO18 Consult  tom@pomo18.com V Sreenivas      NRC              V.Sreenivas@nrc.gov Varoujan Kalikian NRC              Roger.Kalikian@nrc.gov Wayne Lunceford  EPRI            Walunceford@epri.com Wijay C Heinemann                  wcheinemann@aep.com Will Blankenship                  wblankenship@domeng.com William L. Moody  Westinghouse    moodywl@westinghouse.com Xiang Chen        ORNL            chenx2@ornl.gov Yiren Chen        ANL              yiren_chen@anl.gov Yiu Law          NRC              Yiu.Law@nrc.gov 5}}
5}}

Revision as of 20:14, 13 November 2024

Summary of Industry / NRC Materials Programs Technical Information Exchange Public Meeting, June 14 - 15, 2023
ML23171A980
Person / Time
Issue date: 06/20/2023
From: Ali Rezai, David Rudland
NRC/NRR/DNRL/NPHP
To: Matthew Mitchell
NRC/NRR/DNRL/NPHP
References
Download: ML23171A980 (7)
v • d • e


Text

June 20, 2023

MEMORANDUM TO: Matt hew A. Mitchell, Chief P iping and Head Penetrations Branch Divis ion of New and Renewed Licenses OfficeofNuc lear Reactor Regulation

FROM: AliRezai,Mater ials Engineer /RA/

P iping and Head Penetrations Branch Divis ion of New and Renewed Licenses OfficeofNuc lear Reactor Regulation

SUBJECT:

SUMMARY

OF JUNE 14 AND 15, 2023, ANNUAL INDUSTRY /

U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION MATERIALS PROGRAMS TECHNICAL INFORMATION EXCHANGE PUBLIC MEETING

On June 14 and 15, 2023, the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) held a hybrid observation public meeting with representatives from the nuclea r industry for an exchange of technical information on the industrys ongoing materials progr ams, in particular as related to the integrity of reactor pressure vessels, reactor vessel inter nals, and piping. During the meeting, the passive component materials related program update s, issues, operational experience, and ongoing research were discussed. The industry r epresentatives included staff from the Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI), the Pressuri zed Water Reactor (PWR)

Owners Group (PWROG), the Boiling Water Reactor (BWR) Owners Gr oup (BWROG),

licensees and vendor companies. Many of the licensee representa tives also hold advisory roles to the EPRI Materials Reliability Pr ogram (MRP), EPRI BWR Vesse l and Internals Project (BWRVIP), PWROG Materials Co mmittee (MSC), EPRI Welding Repair and Technology Program (WRTC) and EPRI International Materials Research (IMR) committee. In addition, members of the public also participated by teleconference.

The list of attendees is provided in the Appendix. All presenta tions and other information related to this public meeting (e.g., agenda and presentations) are ava ilable on the NRCs Agencywide Documents Access and Management System (ADAMS), Accession No. M L23163A003. The agenda file provides the identifier number for the presentation file(s) that were used for each agenda topic.

CONTACTS: Ali Rezai, NRR/DNRL/NPHP David Rudland, NRR/DNRL 301 415-1328 301 415-1896 Ali.Rezai@nrc.gov David.Rudland@nrc.gov M. Mitchell 2

SUBJECT:

SUMMARY

OF JUNE 14 AND 15, 2023, ANNUAL INDUSTRY / U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION MATERIALS PROGRAMS TECHNICAL INFORMATION EXCHANGE PUBLIC MEETING. DATED: JUNE 20, 2023

DISTRIBUTION:

BSmith BThomson JWise AHiser DRudland MMitchell SBloom SRuffin RIyengar RTregoning LGibson ARezai RKalikian SBailey KManoly JCirilli@epri.com

ADAMS Accession Numbers:

Package: ML23163A003 Summary: ML23171A980 NRR-106 OFFICE NRR/DNRL NRR/DNRL/NPHP NAME DRudland ARezai DATE 6/20/2023 6/20/2023 OFFICIALRECORDCOPY

APPENDIX

ATTENDEES AT JUNE 14 AND 15, 2023 MATERIALS PROGRAMS TECHNICAL INFORMATION EXCHANGE PUBLIC MEETING (HYBRID)

Name Affiliation Contact Aaron A Diaz PNNL Aaron.Diaz@pnnl.gov Adam Brooks ORNL brooksal@ornl.gov Ali Rezai NRC Ali.Rezai@nrc.gov Allen Hiser NRC Allen.Hiser@nrc.gov Amit Kalia Amit.Kalia@luminant.com Amy Freed EPRI Amy G. Aughtman AGAUGHTM@SOUTHERNCO.COM Amy Hull NRC Amy.Hull@nrc.gov Andrew J Burgess ABurgess@ameren.com Anees Udyawar Westinghouse udyawaa@westinghouse.com Angel Reyes-Cruz Constellation Angel.Reyes-Cruz@constellation.com Nuclear Angie Buford NRC Angela.Buford@nrc.gov Annessa Lippincott GSES annessa.lippincott@gses.com Atif Shaikh NRC Atif.Shaikh@nrc.gov Attila Z. Szabo Westinghouse szaboaz@westinghouse.com Austin Young NRC Austin.Young@nrc.gov Bart Fu NRC Bart.Fu@nrc.gov Bernie Thomson NRC Bernie.Thomson@nrc.gov Beth Kehler Haluska Dominion Energy beth.kehler.Haluska@dominionenergy.com Bill Rogers NRC Bill.Rogers@nrc.gov Bob Kalinowski rpkalinowski@aep.com Brett Titus NEI bat@nei.org Brian Allik NRC Brian.Allik@nrc.gov Brian Bowker NRC Brian.Bowker@nrc.gov Brian Cohn NRC Brian.Cohn@nrc.gov Bruce Lin NRC Bruce.Lin@nrc.gov Bruno Vieira Lopes brunovl@eletronuclear.gov.br Bryan M. Wilson Westinghouse wilsonbm@westinghouse.com Carol Moyer NRC Carol.Moyer@nrc.gov Carol Nove NRC Carol.Nove@nrc.gov Carolyn Fairbanks NRC Carolyn.Fairbanks@nrc.gov Chris Wax EPRI cwax@epri.com Christopher Nellis NRC Christopher.Nellis@nrc.gov Christopher R Koehler Xcel Energy christopher.r.koehler@xcelenergy.com Christopher Ulmer NRC Christopher.Ulmer@nrc.gov Corey Thomas Southern Nuclear BRCThoma@southernco.com Cory Parker NRC Cory.Parker@nrc.gov Cotasha Wilson Blackburn CWILSON@southernco.com Craig Harrington EPRI charrington@epri.com Daisuke Nio

1 Dale E Turinetti deturinetti@aep.com Dale Matthews Framatome dale.matthews@framatome.us Dale Turinetta AEP deturinetti@aep.com Dan Patten Dan Widrevitz NRC Dan.Widrevitz@nrc.gov Daniel Klein Framatome daniel.klein@framatome.us Daniel Lamond Daniel.Lamond@gses.com Daniel Patten Energy Harbor dpatten@energyharbor.com Darren Mount Paul.Mount@evergy.com David C Radonovich Westinghouse radonod@westinghouse.com David Dijamco NRC David.Dijamco@nrc.gov David Rudland NRC David.Rudland@nrc.gov Dev Ray NRC Devendra.Ray@nrc.gov Dilip Dedhia Ddedhia@Structint.com DJ Shim EPRI DShim@epri.com Donna Slivon Donna.Slivon@fpl.com Donnamarie Bush PSEG Nuclear Donnamarie.Bush@pseg.com Doug Kull EPRI dkull@epri.com Dylan Cimock EPRI dcimock@epri.com Eiji Machida Elliot Emma Haywood NRC Mary.Haywood@nrc.gov Eric Focht NRC Eric.Focht@nrc.gov Eric M. Benacquista Westinghouse benacqem@westinghouse.com Eric Reichelt NRC Eric.Reichelt@nrc.gov Ernest Deemer Westinghouse Frank Gift EPRI FGift@epri.com Frederick Garcia Heras Maria Luisa mheras@tecnatom.es Garry Young EPRI garyoung@epri.com Gary Park Gikas Theodossiou Constellation Gikas.Theodossiou@constellation.com Nuclear Glenn Chatterton wgchatterton@aep.com Glenn White Dominion Gwhite@domeng.com Engineering Glunt, Nathan EPRI nglunt@epri.com Gordon Hall Westinghouse hallgz@westinghouse.com Greg A. Fischer Westinghouse fischega@westinghouse.com Heather Malikowski EPRI Hmalikowski@epri.com Hiroyuki Kobayashi EPRI HKobayashi@epri.com Ila Collins icollins@enercon.com Isaac Anchondo-Lopez NRC isaac.anchondo-lopez@nrc.gov J. Brian Hall Westinghouse halljb@westinghouse.com Jacky Shoulders Constellation Jacky.Shoulders@constellation.com Nuclear James Drake NRC James.Drake@nrc.gov

2 James Medoff NRC James.Medoff@nrc.gov James R Molnar Constellation James.Molnar@constellation.com Nuclear Jana Bergman Curtisswright jbergman@curtisswright.com Janis Ossmann Westinghouse ossma1jl@westinghouse.com Jared Smith EPRI jarsmith@epri.com Jasmyn Bone Jason Daniel NRC Jason.Daniel@nrc.gov Jason Sisk jsisk@enercon.com Jason Tokey jason.tokey@nuclear.energy.gov Jay Collins NRC Jay.Collins@nrc.gov Jay Wallace NRC Jay.Wallace@nrc.gov Jean Smith EPRI jmsmith@epri.com Jeff Kulp NRC Jeffrey.Kulp@nrc.gov Jeff Poehler NRC Jeffrey.Poehler@nrc.gov Jianwei Chen Westinghouse chen1j@westinghouse.com Jim Chapman Jim Cirilli EPRI jcirilli@epri.com Jim Keiser ORNL keiserjr@ornl.gov Joel Jenkins NRC Joel.Jenkins@nrc.gov John Honcharik NRC John.Honcharik@nrc.gov John Hosler EPRI JHOSLER@epri.com John Tsao NRC John.Tsao@nrc.gov John Wise NRC John.Wise@nrc.gov Jolynn E Oquist jolynn.oquist@xcelenergy.com Jonathan Contreras NRC Jonathan.Contreras@nrc.gov Joshua A Meisel joshua.meisel@dteenergy.com Joshua Block Joshua.BLOCK@fpl.com Josiah Gifaldi NRC Josiah.Gifaldi@nrc.gov Julie Kulik NRC Julie.Kulik@nrc.gov Junichi Hakii Tokyo Electric Power Company Justin Hawkins j.hawkins@holtec.com Kaihwa Hsu NRC Kaihwa.Hsu@nrc.gov Kamal Manoly NRC Kamal.Manoly@nrc.gov Karen Sida NRC Karen.Sida@nrc.gov Keith J Miller Keith.J.Miller@dominionenergy.com Kemper Young Constellation Kemper.Young@constellation.com Nuclear Krishan Garg PSEG Nuclear Krishan.Garg@pseg.com Kyle Amberge EPRI kamberge@epri.com Leah Walters Leslie Terry NRC Leslie.Terry@nrc.gov Liang Y. Zhao INPO ZhaoLY@inpo.org Lori W Hekking Lori.Hekking@duke-energy.com Luis Colon Fuentes NRC Luis.ColonFuentes@nrc.gov Lydiana Alvarado NRC Lydiana.AlvaradoGuilloty@nrc.gov

3 Mark E Weis Constellation Mark.Weis@constellation.com Nuclear Mark Richter NEI mar@nei.org Markus Burkardt DEI Mburkardt@domeng.com Martin Kolar Framatome martin.kolar@framatome.us Mat Burton NRC mathew.burton@nrc.gov Matt White mcwhite@aep.com Matthew Gordon NRC Matthew.Gordon@nrc.gov Matthew King Matthew.King@gses.com Matthew Mitchell NRC Matthew.Mitchell@nrc.gov Matthew S Prowant PNNL Matthew.Prowant@pnnl.gov Mattson, Dick Rmattson@Structint.com McCracken, Steve EPRI smccracken@epri.com McGill, Robert EPRI RMcGill@epri.com Meimei Li ANL mli@anl.gov Mekonen Bayssie NRC Mekonen.Bayssie@nrc.gov Mel Gray NRC Mel.Gray@nrc.gov Michael Benson NRC michael.benson@nrc.gov Michael Magyar NRC Michael.Magyar@nrc.gov Michele Sampson NRC Michele.Sampson@nrc.gov Nat Cofie Ncofie@Structint.com Nathan Palm EPRI Npalm@epri.com Nicholas Hansing NRC Nicholas.Hansing@nrc.gov Nicholas Morgan PWROG-APS Nicholas.Morgan@aps.com Omar Khan NRC Omar.Khan2@nrc.gov On Yee NRC On.Yee@nrc.gov Osvaldo Cruz Constellation Osvaldo.Cruz@constellation.com Nuclear Pl Efsing Vattenfall Pal.Efsing@vattenfall.com Pat Purtscher NRC Patrick.Purtscher@nrc.gov Patrick Raynaud NRC Patrick.Raynaud@nrc.gov Paul Cataldo NRC Paul.Cataldo@nrc.gov Paul Gunter Beyond Nuclear paul@beyoundnuclear.org Paula Cooper NRC Paula.Cooper@nrc.gov Rachel Lee Doss Rachel.Doss@duke-energy.com Randy Stark EPRI rstark@epri.com Rebecca J Nealis Constellation Rebecca.Nealis@constellation.com Nuclear Rich T Giachetti richard.t.giachetti@sargentlundy.com Richard E Jacob PNNL Richard.Jacob@pnnl.gov Richard J. Rogalski rjrogalski@energy-northwest.com Robert Davis NRC Robert.Davis@nrc.gov Robert Grizzi EPRI rgrizzi@epri.com Robert Tregoning NRC Robert.Tregoning@nrc.gov Russ L. Wenzl rlwenzl@nppd.com Russell J Lidberg russell.lidberg@xcelenergy.com Russell, Michael ORNL russellms@ornl.gov

4 Ryan Hosler EPRI Rhosler@epri.com Sam Tulloch Sam.Tulloch1@Rolls-Royce.com Samer Mahmoud Framatome samer.mahmoud@framatome.us Sarah Davidsaver Framatome sarah.davidsaver@framatome.us Scott Chesworth Schesworth@Structint.com Seung Hwan Oh EPRI SOh@guestresearcher.epri.com Seung Min NRC Seung.Min@nrc.gov Shah Malik NRC Shah.Malik@nrc.gov Shane Webb Shane.Webb@fpl.com Stacy Yoder Framatome stacy.yoder@framatome.us Stanford E Davis Stanford.Davis@talenenergy.com Stephen Cumblidge NRC Stephen.Cumblidge@nrc.gov Steve Brown Steve Clair Steve Ruffin NRC Steve.Ruffin@nrc.gov Steve Williams EPRI SWilliams@epri.com Steven Bloom NRC Steven.Bloom@nrc.gov Steven K. Richter Energy Northwest SKRICHTER@energy-northwest.com Steven Levitus NRC Steven.Levitus@nrc.gov Steven Williams EPRI Swilliams@epri.com Sue Lesica sue.lesica@nuclear.energy.gov Ted Hilston PNPP Theresa M Willson tmwillson@aep.com Thomas Basso NEI tbb@nei.org Thomas Hartman NRC Thomas.Hartman@nrc.gov Thomas Magee NRC Thomas.Magee@nrc.gov Tiffany A. Baban Entergy Services tbaban@entergy.com Tim Giles Tim Wiger Framatome tim.wiger@framatome.us Timothy Adams tadams@jensenhughes.com Todd Evans Todd.Evans@luminant.com Todd L Davis Constellation Todd.Davis@constellation.com Nuclear Tom Roberts POMO18 Consult tom@pomo18.com V Sreenivas NRC V.Sreenivas@nrc.gov Varoujan Kalikian NRC Roger.Kalikian@nrc.gov Wayne Lunceford EPRI Walunceford@epri.com Wijay C Heinemann wcheinemann@aep.com Will Blankenship wblankenship@domeng.com William L. Moody Westinghouse moodywl@westinghouse.com Xiang Chen ORNL chenx2@ornl.gov Yiren Chen ANL yiren_chen@anl.gov Yiu Law NRC Yiu.Law@nrc.gov

5

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML23171A980&oldid=3700204"