ML20155G204

Summary of 880317-18 Meeting W/Util in Rockville,Md Re Fire Protection Programon Program in Response to Open & Unresolved Items in Insp Rept 50-445/87-22.Util Attends to Submit Advanced Draft FSAR Changes by Early May 1988

ML20155G204
Person / Time
Site:	Comanche Peak
Issue date:	09/30/1988
From:	Malloy M NRC OFFICE OF SPECIAL PROJECTS
To:	NRC OFFICE OF SPECIAL PROJECTS
References
NUDOCS 8810140127
Download: ML20155G204 (29)

See also: IR 05000445/1987022

Text

. _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ - .

'

'..

~ ..

. #*pn ** %,*o,, '

UNITED STATES

NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION

f"

g

g

y

.

WASHINGTON, D. C 20666

\,^****/

SEP 3 01988

Docket Nos. 50-445 --

and 50-446

. APPLICANT: Texas Utilities Electric Company (TV Electric)

FACILITY: Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station (CPSES), Units 1 and 2

SUBJECT: SUFFARY OF NEETING 01 MARCH 17-18,1988 -

COMANCHE PEAK FIRE PPOTECTION PRCGRAM

On March 17-18, 1988, tne staff met with representatives of TU Electric, lead

applicant for the CPSES, to discuss (1) the status of TU Electric actions

related to open and unresolved items in NRC Inspection Report 50-445/87-22 and

(2) information needed by the staff to complete its revised safety evaluation

on the fire protection program for the CPSES Units 1 and 2. The meeting

notice, agenda, and list of attendees are provided as Enclosures 1, 2, and 3,

respectively, to this summary. The handouts used by the applicant are included

as Enclosurc 4.

The applicant provided the status of each of the open and unresolved items

,

appearing in Inspection Report 50-445/67-22 which ducu.nents the results of

'

NRC's site inspection of CPSES Unit 1 during the period October 19-23, 1987.

TV Electric's responses to the items are documentea in a letter from W. G.

'

Counsil (TV Electric) to NDC dated March 11,1988(TXX-88309). Following this

i

status review, the staff and applicant discussed deviations frot Appendix A to

'

APCSB 9.51 and applicant evaluations (documentation) to demonstrate fire

protection program compliance. In addition to pages 16-18 of Enclosure 4 the

1 applicant provided scme preliminary information as a handout (Enclosure 5} on

i numbers and areas of evaluations and deviations.

l

Following an NRC caucus TV Electric advised the staff that tney planned to

submit an FSAR amendment describing recent changes in their evaluation process.

< These changes have been made since the letters of April 15, 1987 (TXX-6376) and

'

August 4,1987 (TXX-6582), which providad TV Electric :oments and clarificai, ions

a

on the CPSES Fire Protection Program as it e,;4tes to NRC's discussion in

'

Section 9.5.1 of Supplement #12 to the Comanche Peek Safety Evaluation Report

(SER). The staff advised TV Electric that it wanted to review some evaluations

i

on file at TV Electric demonstrating fire protection program Ocmpliance.

.

Following these discussions, the meeting broke into two working sessions, one

group discussed staff information needed for the revised CPSES SER on fire

protection and the other group reviewed several engineering evaluations

demonstrating fire protection program compliance.

DFol

_ _ _ _ _ - - _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ - _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ - _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ - _ - -

.. .,

TV Electric -3- SEP 3 01988

In closing discussion, the staff noted that formal review of the applicant's

responses to the open and unresolved itecis from Inspection Report 50-445/87-22

would take place at some time in the future. The staff expressed an intent to

spend some time at the site and off site auditing a sample of TV Electric's

fire protection program engineering evaluations. The staff also remarked that

it would like to see better cross referencing or more direct linking of the

engineering evaluations in the Comanche Peak Fire Protection Report to assure

a clear licensing basis. TU Electric stated that it intends to submit advanced

draft FSAR changes by early May 1988.

original signed by:

Melinda Malloy, Project Manager

Comanche Peak Project Division

Office of Special Projects

Enclosures:

1. Meeting Notice

2. Agenda

3. List of Attendees

4. TV Electric Handouts

5. Handouts on Engineering Evaluations

cc w/ enclosure:

See next page

4

OISTRIBUTION:

]~

cDocketFiles(50-445/446):

NRC FDR

Local POR

4 CPPD Reading

i' OSP Reading

JPartlow

1 CGrimes

! PNcKee

j JWilson

! JLyons

l RWarnick

PJtalloy

JWiebe

A51ngh

} OKubicki

OGC.WF

1

DCrutchfield -

i EJordan

1 BGricles

l ACRS(10)

!

.

:  :  :  :

OFC :FM:CPPD AD/P:CPPD

.. so M.::.............:............:............:............:...........:...........

NAME .MHalloy: sam :JWil  :  :

t qqd  :  :  :

.....:............:......r......:............:............:............:...........:...........  :  :  :

DATE :9 4 @ 88 :9/30/88  :  :

OFFICIAL RECORD COPY

_

.

..

.

.. , i

SEP 3 01988

/

'

W. G. Counsil Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station

Texas Utilities Electric Company Units 1 and 2

cc: Asst. Director for Inspec. Programs

Jack R. Newman, Esq.

Newman & Holtzinger, P.C. Comanche Peak Project Division ,

Suite 1000 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission l

,

1615 L Street, N.W. P. O. Box 1029 -

!

Washington, D.C. 20036 Granbury, Texas 76048

Robert A. Wooldridge, Esq. Regional Administrator, Regi' IV  !

,

1 Worsham, Forsythe, Sampels & U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Consa;sion

Wooldridge 611 Ryan Plaza Drive, Suite 1000

2001 Bryan Tower, Suite 2500 Arlington, Texas 76011 i

Dallas, Texas 75201 .

Lanny A. Sinkin

'

Mr. 8,omer C. Schmidt Christic Institute ,

Dirtctor of Nuclear Services 1324 North Capitol Street '

i

Texas Utilities Electric Company Washington, D.C. 20002

Skyway Tower

400 North Olive Street, L.B. 81 Hs. Billie Pirner Garde. Esq.

,

Dallas, Texas 75201 Government Accountability Project

Midwest Office

Mr. R. W. Ackley 104 East Wisconsin Avenue i

. Stone & Webster Appleton, Wisconsin 54911

j

l Comanche Peak Steam Electric Staticn

P. O. Box 1002 David R. Pigott, Esq.  ;

i

J Glen Rose, Texas 76043 Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe  !

600 Montgomery Street

l

Mr. J. L. Vota San Francisco, California 94111

!

l Westinghouse Electric Corporation

'

P. O. Box 355 Anthony Z. Roisman, Esq.

Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 15230 , Suite 600

'l 1401 New York Avenue, NW

i Susan M. Theisen Washington, D.C. 20005  ;

'

l

Assistant Attorney General

Environmental Protection Division Robert Jablon

!

P. O. Box 12548, Capitol Station Bonnie S. Blair

j Austin, Texas 78711-1548 Spiegel & McDiarmid t

1350 New York Avenue, NW ,

Mrs. Juanita Ellis, President Washington, D.C. 20005-4798 i

?

Citizens Association for Sound Energy

1426 South Polk George A. Parker, Chairnan i

l

Dallas, Texas 75224 Public Utility Committee t

Senior Citizens Alliance Of  !

Tarrant County, Inc. o

Ms. Nancy H. Williams i

CYGNA Energy Services 6048 Wonder Drive

2121 H. California Blvd., Suite 390 Fort Worth Texas 76133 [

Walnut Creek, CA 94596  ;

I

.

.

'

! ,

4 ,

l _- l

_ _ _ - _ - _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

L

• '

. . . . . .

'

SEP 3 01988

W. G. Counsil -2- Comanche Peak Elat.tric Station

. Texas Utilities Electric Company Units 1 and 2

CC* .

.

Joseph F. Fulbright

Fulbright & Jaworski

1301 McKinney Street

Houston, Texas 77010

P.oger D. Walker

Manager Nuclear Licensing

Texas Utilities Electric Company

Skyway Tower

400 North Olive Street. L.B. 81

Dallas, Texas 75201

Texas Utilities Electric Company

c/o Bethesda Licensing

3 Hetro Center, Suite 610

Bethesda, Maryland 20614

William A. Burchette, Esq.

Counsel for Tex-La Electric Cooperative

of Texas

Heron, Burchette, Ruckert & Rothwell

Suite 700

1025 Thomas Jefferson Street, NW

Washington, D.C. 20007

GDS ASSOCIATES, Ific.

Suits 720

1650 Parkway Place

Marietta, Georgia 30067-8237

_

' '

.. ..

0*C

/ '%; UNITED STATES

NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION

i -'( ~, , ' i 8 W A$mNGTON, D C. 20555

March 3, 1988

,,, .$(/

.....

Docket Nos. 50-445

and 50-446

MEMORANDUM FOR: Christopher 1. Grimes, Director

Comanche Peak Project Division

Office of Special Projects

THRU: James H. Wilson, Assistant Directo

for Projects

Comanche Peak Project Division

Office of Special Projects

FROM: Melinda Malloy, Project Manager

Comanche Peak Project Division

Office of Special Projects

SUBJECT: FORTHCOMING MEETING WITH TV ELECTRIC

Date & Time: Thursday, March 17, 1988, 1:00 pm - 5:00 pm

Friday, March 18, 1988, 8:30 am - 12:00 Noon

Location: One White F1jnt North

11555 Rockville Pike

Room 10 8 13

Rockville, MD 20852

Purpse: For Applicant and Staff to discuss:

1. information related to open and

unresolved items in NRC Inspection .

.

,

Report 50-445/87-22, and

2. information needed by NRC to complete

a revited safety evaluation for the

implementation of the fire protection

progrem for Comanche Peak, Units 1 and 2

Participants *: NRC Applicant

C McKee R. Walker

A. Singh

J. Seawright

R. Layton

M.Malley(contractor)

T. Storey et al.

A. Fresco (contr . /

A&,y,f

• s.

M in Malloy, P oject Many r

Comanche Peak Project Divisten

Office of Special Projects

cc: See next page ,

.

CONTACTS: Melinda Malloy or James H. Wilson

(301)492 0738 (301)492-3306

• Meetings between NRC technical staff and applicants for licenses are open

for interested members of the public, petitioners, intervenors, or other

parties to attend as observers pursuant to "Open Meetings and Statement of

" 43 Federal Register 28058,6/28/78.

OD$ ~fr aff Policyh0/2

~

t$~T

.

• *

.,

., . ,

.

.

.

W. G. Counsil

'

Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station

Texas Utilitics Electric Company Units 1 and 2

cc:

Jack R. Newman, Esq. Asst. Director for Inspec. Prograns i

Newman & holtzinger, P.C. Comar.che Peak Project Division

Suite 1000 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comission

1615 L Street, N.W. P. O. Box 1029

Washington. 0.C. 20036 - Granbury Texas 76048

Robert A. Wooldridge, Esq. Regional Administrator, Region IV

Worsham, Forsythe, Sampels & U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comission '

Wooldridge Gil Ryan Plaza Drive, Suite 1000

2001 Bryan Tower, Suite 2500 Arlington, Texas 76011

Dallas, Texas 75201

Lanny A. Sinkin

Mr. Homer C. Schmidt Christic Institute

Of rector of Nuclear Services 1324 North Capitol Street

Texas Utilities Electric Company Washington 0.C. 20002 ,

'

Skyway Tower

400 North Olive Street, L.B. 81 Ms. Billie Pirner Garde, Esq. *

Dallas, Texas 75201 Governrent Accountability Project

Midwest Office

Mr. Robert E. Ballard, Jr. 104 East Wisconsin Avenue

Director of Projects Appleton, Wisconsin 54911

Gibbs and Hill, Inc.

11 Penn Plaza

New York, New York 10001 David R. Pigott, Esq. .

.

)

l

Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe

~

600 Montgomery Street

r Mr. R. S. Howard San Francisco, California 94111

Westinghouse Electric Corporation

P. O. Box 355 Anthony Z. Roisman, Esq.

Pittsburgh, Pennsyl.:anta 15230 Suite 600

' 1401 New York Avenue, NW

, Renea Hicks Esq. Washington 0.C. 20005

Assistant Attorney General

Environmental Protection Division Robert Jablon

P. O. Box 12548, Capitol Station Bonnte S. Blair

Austin, Tuas 78711 Spiegel & McDiarmid

1350 New York Avenue, NW

Mrs. Juanita Ellis, President Washington, 0.t. 20005-4798

Citizens Association for Sound Energy

1426 South Polk George A. Parker, Chairman

Callas, Texas 75224 Public Utility Cemittee

Senior Citizens Alliance Of

Ms. Nancy H. Williams Tarrant County, Inc.,

CYGNA Energy Services 6048 'noncer Drive

2121 N. California Blvd., Suite 390 Fort Worth, Texas 76133

Walnut Creek, CA 94596

'

._- - . -_- - ._- -- .-

_ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ .

• *

.. .. .

,

• .

W. G. Counsil

~

-2- Cemanche Peak Electric Staticn

Texas Utilities Electric Company Units 1 and 2

.

cc:

Joseph F. Fulbright

Fulbright & Jaworski

1301 McKinney Street

Houston, Texas 77010

Roger D. Walker

Manager Nuclear Licensing

Texas Utilities Electric Company

Skyway Tower .

!

400 North Olive Street, L.B. 81 .

Dallas, Texas 75201

i

Mr. Jack Redding

c/o Bethesda Licersing

Texas Utilities Electric Company

3 Metro Center Suite 610

Bethesda, Maryland 20814  ;

William A. Burchette. Esq.

Counsel for Tex-La Electric Cooperative

of Texas

! Heron, Burchette, Ruckert & Rothwell

Suite 700

1025 Thomas Jefferson Street, NW

'

Washington, D.C. 20007

,

GOS ASSOCIATES, INC. ..

Suite 720 ~

' 1850 Parkway place

Marietta, Georgia 30067-8237 i

Administrative Judge Peter Bloch

U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comission

Washington. 0.C. 20555

i Elizabeth B. Johnson r

'

Administrative Judge l

j Oak Ridge National Labora',orj ,

,

i

P. O. Box X. Building 3500  !

i Oak Ridge, Tennessee 37830

4

Dr. Xenneth A. McCollom

1107 West Knapp

Stillwater, Oklahorra 74075

Dr. Walter H. Jordan .

!

) 881 West Cuter Drive

Oak Ridge, TN 37830 l

l

!

[

!

'

'

o

'~

\ /

l

FIRE PROTECTION MEETING AGENDA .

,

I. INTRODUCTION .

II. COMPLETE

G u-04 ,

9 O-04

9 O-08

111. PLAN COMPLETE WORK IN PROGRESS

S O-01

O O-06

9 O-07

4 O-09

IV. PLANNED ACTIONS

e U-02

6 U-03

V. UPCOMING FSAR AMENDMENT

e O-05

9 O-02

9 U-01 E

o

e O-03 {

4 EVALUATIONS E

V!. CONCLUSIONS [

7 :oK

. ._ .__ - _

__ _ _

- _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

.

.

'. . .

.

ENCLOSURE 3

NRC/TU ELECTRIC HEETING ON FIRE PROTECTION

HARCH 17-18, 1988

ATTENDEES t

NRC TU Electric

_

0. Kubicki R. O. Babb

J. E. Lyons* R. C. Howe

M. Halloy R. Layton

P. F. McKee 0. Lowe

l A. Singh B. K. Riggs

J. Wiebe J. D. Seawright

J. H. Wilson N. L. Terrel

R. D. Walker

D. R. Woodlan

Brookhaven National Laboratory (NRC Contractor)

i

A. Fresco

H. Thenas

SAIC (NRC Contractor) Impell (TV Electric Contractor)

T. Storey C. A. Banning

J. Echternacht

J. H. Wawrzeniak

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . __

-

..

/ c

-

\

.. .

87-22 OPEN/ UNRESOLVED ITEMS

9 9 OPEN ITEMS

S 4 UNRESOLVED ITEMS

EVALUATIONS USED AT CPSES

'

4 POSITION

G UP COMING AMENDMENT OF FSAR

.

l o

I

o

m

u

-l 15

l Page 1

_ _ . _ . _ _ _ . _ ,

'

..

~

\ _/ -

'

UNREs'OLVED ISSUE 445/8722-U-04

ACCUMULATOR ISOLATION VALVES 1-8808A,B,C AND D ARE

MANUALLY OPERATED UTILIZING JUMPERS DURING HOT STANDBY.

RESPONSE:

O CPSES PROCEDURE ABN-803A USES MANUAL ACTIONS TO CLOSE

THESE VALVES PRIOR TO RHR CUT-IN. JUMPERS ARE NOT USED TO

CLOSE THESE VALVES.

SCHEDULE:

O COMPLETE

.

Page 2

=_

. - _ _ _ - - - - - -

-

.

)

~

'

..-

[

OPEN ITEM 445/8722-0-04

-

COMMITMENT TO ENSURE THAT ALL FIRE DOOR MODIFICATIONS ,

!

WILL CONFORM TO UNDERWRITERS LABORATORIES GUIDANCE.

I

RESPONSE:

9 UNDERWRITERS LABORATORIES GUIDELINE FOR ATTRIBUTES

HAVE BEEN ADDED TO SPECIFICATIONS.

e FIELD VERIFICATION WILL BE PART OF THE POST

CONSTRUCTION HARDWARE VALIDATION PROGRAM.

SCHEDULE:

O SPECIFICATION UPDATE COMPLETE

G PCHVP AND RECONCILIATION SCHEDULES CALL FOR ALL

WALKDOWNS BY AUGUST 1988

.

'

/ '\

Page 3

_

-

..

-

.i

\

r

-

//

l

..

1

l OPEN ITEM 445/8722-0-08

l

\

i LACK OF FUSE COORDINATION IN DIESEL GENERATOR

i CONTROL CIRCUlT

'

RESPONSE:

'

j

4 ADEOUATELY COORDINATED FUSES INSTALLED.

i

,

I

ij

I

]

i SCHEDULE:

1

! e COMPLETE

/ 9\

Page 4

- _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ - .

-

.

'

..

\ / f

OPEN lTEM 445/8722-0-01

,

.

THE REACTOR COOLANT PUMP LUBE OIL COLLECTION SYSTEM SEISMIC

ANALYSIS HAD NOT BEEN COMPLETED.

RESPONSE:

SEISMIC OUALIFICATION ACTIVITIES

S WESTINGHOUSE INTERNAL TO MOTOR

4 SWEC COLLECTION PIPING AND TANK

9 IMPELL COLLECTION COWLINGS

SCHEDULE:

ENGINEER,.<G ANALYSIS - JULY 31,19 88

,

CONSTRUCTION SCHEDULES CALL FOR MODIFICATIONS BY - OCTOBER 1,1988

ti!\

Page 5

---

- -- -

.

,

~>

. .

N /

OPEN ITEM 445/8722-0-06 -

. P

I CABLE SPREADING ROOM HALON SUPRESSION SYSTEM

NFPA 12A COMPLIANCE

RESPONSE: i

l

1 O COMPLETE NFPA 12A CODE COMPLIANCE REVIEW.

1 ,

l

l

SCHEDULE:

O CONSTRUCTION SCHEDULES CALL FOR COMPLETION OF CURRENT

MODIFICATIONS BY JULY 15,1988.

<

9 NFPA 12A CODE COMPLIANCE REVIEW IS SCHEDULED FOR

AUGUST 5,19 88.

, \

Page 6

- _ _ - . - - ._. - .

.

'

..

.

\ /

.

i ..

,

! OPEN ITEM 445/8722-0-07 -

i

INSTRUMENT AIR VALVES ASSOCIATED WITH A COLD SHUTDOWN

!

REPAIR PROCEDURE WERE POORLY LABELED.

l >

'

!

i

RESPONSE:

!

O IDENTIFICATION AID REQUEST HAS BEEN INITIATED

TO PROPERLY LABEL VALVES.

i

!

.

SCHEDULE:

.

O INSTALLATION APRIL 29,1988

l

1

i

[ r\

Page 7

- - -- _ _ _- - - - - - - - - - - - _ - - - - - - - - - - _ - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - -

.-

.

..

'.'

\ /

-

..

OPEN ITEM 445 /8 7 22-0-0 9a .

COMPLETE FIRE SAFE SHUTDOWN ANALYSIS MODIFICATIONS

REQUIRING THERMO-LAG.

RESPONSE:

1. FIRE SAFE SHUTDOWN ANALYSIS !S REVISED AS REQUIRED

IN SUPPORT OF PLANT MODIFICATIONS.

SCHEDULE:

1. THERMO-LAG DESIGN REQUIREMENTS JUNE 1,19 88

.

/ A\

Page 8

- - - , - .. -- .-, - - - -

~

-

.

.

\ / f

'

.

.

OPEN ITEM 445/8722-0-09b .

,

1

AMPACITY EFFECTS DUE TO THERMO-LAG HAS NOT BEEN COMPLETED.

!

I

RESPONSE:

!

f 4 SDAR RESOLUTION

l - CABLE RESIZING OR REROUTE

- THERMO-LAG REMOVAL

SCHEDULE:

4 DCA TO ECE-M1-1700 COMPLETE

4 AMPACITY ANALYSIS CABLE RESIZING APRIL 29,1988

<

4 CONSTRUCTION SCHEDULES CALL FOR COMPLETION OF

. MODIFICATIONS BY OCTOBER 23,1988.

l

Page 9

.

~

.

\ / f

.

.

4

UNRESOLVED ISSUE 445/8722-U-02

1 MANUAL ACTIONS IN THE SAME FIRE AREA AS THE

POSTULATED FIRE

'

RESPONSE:

4 PROVIDE TABLE OF MANUAL ACTIONS IN THE SAME

]

l FIRE AREA AS THE POSTULATED FIRE.

I

i

i

SCHEDULE:

! O REVISION 4 OF THE FIRE SnFE SHUTDOWN ANALYSIS

i WILL BE AVAILABLE MAY 1,1988.

!

1

l / "\

1

Page 10

.,

-

-

/  :.

\

!

.

'

i UNRESOLVED ISSUE 445/8722-U-03

WCAP AND WESTINGHOUSE CALCULATIONS INDICATE CONSIDERING

SPURIOUS SAFETY INJECTION PRT RUPTURE MAY PRECEDE MANUAL

,

OPERATOR ACTIONS INSIDE CONTAINMENT

l

RESPONSE:

!

O PROVIDE A REVISED CALCULATION THAT DEMONSTRATES

l - PRT DOES NOT RUPTURE

- WESTINGHOUSE CALCULATION IS CONSERVATIVE.

'

SCHEDULE:

O CALCULATION IS COMPLETE.

!

l / ~\

Page 11

!

l _ _ _ _ _ - . _ - _ _ _ _

___

.-

.

.

~

y / .

OPEr4 r EM 445/8722-0-05 '

1. NEW' EMERGENCY LIGHTING REQUIREMENTS RESULTING FROM

REVISED FIRE SAFE SHUTDOWN ANALYSIS.

.

1. NRC CONCERNS WITH EMERGENCY LIGHTING ADEQUACY.

RESPONSE:

1. REVISION TO IMPELL CALCULATION WILL BE PERFORMED

AS REQUIRED BY REVISED FIRE SAFE SHUTDOWN ANALYSIS.

1. EMERGENCY LIGHTS ARE USED TO ILLUMINATE MANUAL

ACTIONS REQUIRED TO ACHIEVE AND MAINTAIN HOT STANDBY.

SCHEDULE: -

1. REVISED CALCULATIONS MAY 27,1988

9 FSAR WILL BE CLARIFIED TO REFLECT AN UP COMING '

THAT EMERGENCY LIGHTING IS PROVIDED FSAR AMENDMENT

- FOR MANUAL ACTIONS REQUIRED TO

ACHIEVE AND MAINTAIN HOT STANDBY.

'

[

Page 12

.

.

.

\ / i

.

OPEN IT M 445/8722-0-02 ,

UNRATED STEEL HATCHES ARE A DEVIATION TO

APPENDIX A TO BTP APCSB 9.5-1

RESPONSE:

9 THIS EVALUATION WILL BE IDENTIFIED AS A DEVIATION

IN SECTION 9.5.1.6.2 OF THE CPSES FSAR

SCHEDULE:

e THIS CHANGE WILL BE INCLUDED IN AN UP COMING

AIV.ENDMENT OF THE CPSES FSAR.

~

l

-

.

/ \

Page 13

. . _ _ . . _

_

- _ _ _ _ _ - - - . . _ . _ . - . ,

__ __ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ _____________________ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ___________ ___ __ ____ __

l

.

~

..

_

, \ /

l

l

l .

UNRESOLVED ISSUE 445/8722-U-01 -

ADEQUACY OF JUSTIFICATION TO SUPPORT A TWO HOUR

RATING FOR S!X STAIRWELL WALLS.

RESPONSE:

1. THIS EVALUATION WILL BE IDENTIFIED AS

DEVIATIONS IN SECTION 9-5.1.6.2.

SCHEDULE:

9 UP COMING AMENDMENT OF FSAR

.

'*

l

.

Page 14

Q

a

. _ _ . , _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ..___ ._ _ _____ __._ _ - . , _ _ _ , . , _ _ _ , . _ _

_ . _ _ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ _ . - _ , _ ,

-

-

.

.

-

.

\ / -

-

.

OPEN IT M 445/8722-0-03

COMM;T TO SEAL CONDUlTS FOUR INCHES AND SMALLER ON BOTH

SIDES AT THE FIRST OPENING. SEAL INSTALLATION COMPLETION

RESPONSE:

e UNRECOGNIZED COMMITMENT UNDER REVIEW

l SCHEDULE:

9 RESPONSE APRIL 29,1988

l

l

/ <\

Page 15

l

_ _ _ - _ -

. _ - - _ _ -- . _

_ - _ - _ _ _ _ , _ - , . __

._ - __- ._.

__-_ .- -__.. _.-- - _. . . _ - _ - _ - . . _ _ . - . - - _ .- . . _.

. . . . . . -- - - _ _ - - _

r

.

,

.

4

'

.

'

i ' " ' ' *

.S +. . ., ,<;-,s ..~.'~,<c.f...'l y ,ty-

fi4 6 y.; 'V

.,

,.

,

-

..v ?,- g3 ;.<.ks q- r ,

.

, ., - ~

-e *

~ .,

s ,-

. . . . - -

,

~

1

.

L, ,! *:e,p

.. s. +. Q' ,-

. _ .- 14 ..

10 CFR 50 ,

-

BTP APCSB 9.5-1

APPENDIX R

APPENDIX A

IDENTIFY

-.

{ COMMITMENT '

NONCONFO M ES ,M

DOCUMENT

l' . 1

I  :'

I a:'

u,

-

t . .. .. ,.

m. -w

"

l'- l

d FSAR ".

I.-

.. --

...........]........:

,

,

, ;l,

,' EVALUATIONS I

. s. .

,

• , 7: 4

l FPR ._

l9MAIUTAINED I. .1

.L

i . 15EVIATIONS l ON-FILE ,M

l 9 SUMMARY l

,

l........._..._..3 -I' ' . -

OF FHA i

S APPENDIX A ,

-

. .

. te-

AND FMA

.

l 9 APPENDIX R , f:

EVALUATIONS'a '..**

'.4  %

..

n.

1

'

/\ U A.

.

l

1

.o.'

_.......__..___...._ ,

FHA l 2.,

I l

,

AND FMA  !

n

.*

EVALUATIONS

---

..--.. ......---.

l

, _ __

..s.

.

. . .. .

.,-

.. , - . , , . . _; : , . -

. ,

<

. . .; . . . , -  : * .: . . r . a

- .

s e ; , , 7, $ *2 . ~ , g - ,

'

'~ '

l *

,

d

4,

'

.: . / . . A sMg; .

.

.. . . * i a ,c

.

. -

l

l

l

,

Page 16

- . - _ _ . - -__ - - - .- - .-- .- - - _-. _ _ _ _

- . _ _ _ _ - .- _ - _ - _.- - , . _, . - _ _ - - _ . .

' l

l

'.- ~

~-

/

-

\=

R

E

I

R 6 1 1 2

E R 3

T A

A B

R

T

S A N

N X O

O  ! I

M D T

E N C 0 _ _ 6

D E E 1 _ _

P T

H P E

C

I

A D

H H

WT

7

1

,

I e

S W N P

g

a

N O

E I

O C S

I

T N S

E 8 1 8

A A R 3

_

_

U L

I

P

L P P

A M U

V O S

E

C

R

A N

S.

F O

I 2

T a. c.

3

1

. C 1 1

.

D D F F

.

1

.

E

S

\ /

.

ll,!

_ - _ . - _ . _ _ - _ . -- . _ _ __ __ _ _- _-

~

.

9

l . --

\ /  :

FSAR APPENDIX A DEVIATIONS

. .

I

1

1. METAL HATCH COVERS IN AN UNTESTED CONFIGURATION -

i

l

l

l

l

2. DOOR / DAMPER CONFIGURATIONS OUTSIDE FIRE BARRIER

l

3. BUS DUCT PENETRATION IN AN UNTESTED CONFIGURATION

'

4. FLEXIBLE CONDUlT PENETRATIONS IN AN UNTESTED CONFIGURATION

5. GYPSUM BOARD WALLS IN AN UNTESTED CONFIGURATION

1

'

.

/ ==\

,

1 Page 18

l

-. - , _ _ - _ . . - - . - - . - , . _ _ - - _ _ _ - - - . - -- - . , - _ _

, ,_-

. _ . . - _ _ _ _

' . .-

'

-

Enclosure 5

.

EVALUATION VERSES DEVIATIONS PRELIMINARY REVIEW

.

.

Today 1984

Evaluations Deviations Evaluations Deviations

36 10 Suppression 31 31-

78 O III Detection O

I4I O

82(2) 24(3) Barriers 39 39(5)

.

196 34 Total 70 70

Notes:

(1) 34 Design Modifications Being implemented

(2) Engineering Evaluations Justifying the Acceptability of the 24

Deviations is included Within These Numbers

t

(3) Includes Five 20 Foot separation Deviations and 5 Proposed

Additional Deviations <

(4) Evaluation to Code 72E Not Required

(5) Included Four 20 Foot Separation Deviation and 18 Fire Damper Deviation f

i

,

6

e

f

!

i

f

I

k

! I

,

_,--.

___ __-_ __ _ _ _ .

, ,. , .

.

PRELIMINARY INFORMATION

4

III.G.2.b

BUILDING / FIRE AREA / ROOH  !!!.G.2.c CASE 1984

ELEVATION FIRE ZONE NUMBER lil.G.3 CLASSIFICATION DEVIATIONS

CONCERN .

l

i

Auxiliary AA21a 174  !!!.G.2.b & c 4 13a 1

790' 6" 175  !!!.G.2.b & c 3 !3

179  !!!.G.2.c 3

13

180  !!!.G.2.c 3 13

Auxiliary AAllb 203  !!!.G.2.b 3 13a 2

810' 6" 207 III.G.2.b & c 3 13a 2

Auxiliary AA27 198  !!!.G.2.b 4 13a

810' 6"

i

Auxiliary AA21c 209  !!!.G.2.c 4 29-1

822'-6"

Auxiliary AA21d 214 III.G.2.c 3 13a 3

831'-6" 226  !!!.G.2.c 3 13a-3

l

Auxiliary AA21f 241  !!!.G.2.b & c 3 13a-4 2a

852' 6"

i

E&C EA57 125  !!!.G.2.c 3 136

792' 0" EC50 118  !!!.G.2.c 4 2 r.

L .': 8 119 I!!.G.2.c 4 2m

EHb2 120  !!!.G.2.c 4 2m i

EH53 121 III.G.2.c 4 2m

l

E&C E065 135  !!!.G 3 4 IVa  !

830'-0"  :

E&C EA73 150  !!!.G.2.c 4 2L ,

854' 4" EA74 150a  !!!.G.2.c 4 IVb

I

Safeguards . SAlc 63 Ill.G.2.c 3 2b

I

790 -6"

i

810'-6" SA142 77N III.G.2.c 4 21 1

'

773'-0" & SB4 64  !!!.G.2.c 3 13d

790'-6" 71 III.G.2.c 3 29

l

l

}

i

f

!

t ,

I

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _

.

.

,,

.

PREllMINARY INFORMATION

111.G.2.b

BUILDING / FIRE AREA / ROOM  !!!.G 2.c CASE 1984

ELEVATION FIk, ZONE NUMBER III.C.3 CLASSIFICATION DEVIATIONS

CONCERN ,

- ,

Safeguards SB4 70  !!!.G.2.c 3 2j

790 -6" SB2c 65 III.G.2.c 4 2f

67  !!!.G.2.c 4

-

13d

810' 6" SB8 79  !!!.G.2.c 3 13d-l

82  !!I.G.2.c 3 13d-l

810' 6" S8143 77s III.G.2.c 3 21

831'-6" & SB15 94  !!!.G.2.c 3 13d l

841' 6" 95  !!!.G.2.c 3 13d

831'-6" SB144 88  !!!.G.2.c 3 13d

,

810' 6" SD9 83 Ill.G.2.c 3 2b

831' 6" SE16 96 III.G.2.c 4 2d

852' 6" SE18 103 III.G.2.c 4 2c

Safeguards SE18 104 4 2c

i.

I

l

e

i

I-

i

,

b

_ .___-__

-

.. c

'

.

l

'

PRELIMINARY INFORMATION

.

DETECTION EVALUATIQB1 USED TO JUSTIFY CODE COMPLlahff .

Code Section Fire Area / Zone Room No, t

.

2 6.5 AA21a 168 i

2 6.5 AA21a 169  !

2-6.5 AA21a 170

2 6.5 AA21a 171 -  ;

2 6.5 AA21a 172

2 6.5 AA21a 173

2 6.5 AA21a 182

2 6.5 AA21b 191

2 6.5 AA21b 192

2 6.5 AA21d 211

2 6.5 AA21d 215

l 2 6.5 AA21d 217

2 6.5 AA21f 238

2 6.5 AA21f 240

2-6.5 AA21f 242

2 6.5 AA22 207A, 181

2-6.5 AA34 220

2 6.5 AA35 221

2 6.5 AA36 222 ,

2 6.5 AA37 224

2-6.5 AA98 254

2-6.5 AA98 269

2-6.5 AA99b 271A

2 6.5 AA99b 271b

2-6.5 AA100 271

! 2-6.5 Sala 57

2-6.5 Sala 58

-

2 6.5 Sala 61  :

2 6.5 SB2e 81

2 6.5 SB2f 86

2-6.5 SB2f 87

4-3.5.1 AA21b 202

4 3.5.1 AA21c 208 ,

4-3.5.1 AA21c 209 l

-

' 4 3.5.1 AA21d 210 l

'

4 3.5.1 SB2a 563

4 3.7.3 AA21a 162  :

4-3.7.3 AA21f 235 1

4 3.7.3 AA99b 247  !

4 3.7.3 AA99d 270 i

4-3.7.3 EAS4 122  !

j 4-3.7.3 EA57 125 i

4-3.7.3 WB104b 275  !

j 4 3.7.3 SA142 77N I

TOTAL 44 t

,

1

\

. i

. ,- ..

- PREllMINARY INFORMATION

PARRIER EVALUATIQfG

Sub_ieel IMZ 193 1

'

Serv. Water Pumps 20' Sep, la la

Chiller Units 20' Sep. Ib lb

Boric Acid Pumps (FSSA Eval.) Ic  ;

Boric Acid Sky Tanks (FSSA Eval.) 2e

Concrete Block Wall 3a . 3a  :

Concrete Block Wall 3a-1 3a.1

t Cont. Pen. Seals 3b 3b ,

~

Miss, Res. Doors 3c 3c

Cont Rm. Missile Resis. Doors 3c-1 3c 1

Watertight Dooi's 3d 3d

Containment Airlock 3e 3e

Cont Mech. Pen. Seals 39 39

Cable Spreading Rm. Barrier 3h 3h  ;

PRV 20' Separation 4a 4a

Cont. RHR Valves 20' Sep. 4a-1 4a 1 l

'

20' Separation (FSSA Eval.) 8a-1

20' Separation Bb Bb

20' Sep. SK MS!V's Deleted 8e t

HVAC Damper Penetrations By Upgrade lla

HVAC Damper Penetrations By Upgrade lib

HVAC Damper Penetrations By Upgrade lle  ;

HVAC Damper Penetrations By Upgrade lld

'

HVAC Damper Penetrations By Upgrade lle i

HVAC Damper Penetrations By Upgrade 12a ,

'

HVAC Damper Penetrations By Upgrade 12b

i HVAC Damper Penetrations By Upgrade 12c  !

i HVAC Damper Penetrations By Upgrade 12d l

l HVAC Damper Penetrations By Upgrade 12e ,

'

,

HVAC Damper Penetrations By Upgrade 12f

l HVAC Damper Penetrations By Upgrade 129

l HVAC Damper Penetrations By Upgrade 12h l

l HVAC Damper Penetrations By Upgrade 121 ,

l

HVAC Damper Penetrations BY Upgrade 12j

i HVAC Damper Penetrations By Upgrade 12k

l HVAC Damper Penetrations By Upgrade 121

l HVAC Damper Penetrations BY Upgrade 12m

2 Hour Rated Penetrations Seals 14 14

Bus Duct Penetrations FSAR 9 5.1.6.2 i

NRF #63, 64, 65, 66, 67, 68 <

Oampers & Doors with frame Outside Banners FSAR 9 5.1.6.2

NRF #41, 86

Flexible Conduit Penetration FSAR 9-5.1.6.2  !

NRF #39, 40

Metal Hatches with Protective Coating FSAR 9-5.1.6.2  !

NRF #35, 36, 37, 38  !

Gypsum Board Walls FSAR 9 5.1.6.2

NRF # 74. 75  ;

.

.

P

!