ML16169A061: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
Line 18: Line 18:


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:NRC/SNC Meeting June 21, 2016 Plant Hatch NFPA 805 LAR Submittal Extension Request
{{#Wiki_filter:Plant Hatch NFPA 805 LAR Submittal Extension Request NRC/SNC Meeting June 21, 2016


Agenda Meeting Purpose and Schedule Request Reason for Schedule Extension NFPA-805 Transition Schedule Current Status of NFPA
Agenda
-805 Project
* Meeting Purpose and Schedule Request
-Fire PRA -Traditional FP Scope Summary / Questions / Actions
* Reason for Schedule Extension
* NFPA-805 Transition Schedule
* Current Status of NFPA-805 Project
  - Fire PRA
  - Traditional FP Scope
* Summary / Questions / Actions


Summary & Purpose NRC Granted Enforcement Discretion for 10 CFR 50.48(b) for Plant Hatch based on an NFPA
Summary & Purpose
-805 LAR submittal date of October 4, 2016 Fire PRA development and plant modifications have delayed the fire protection transition project SNC intends to request an 18
* NRC Granted Enforcement Discretion for 10 CFR 50.48(b) for Plant Hatch based on an NFPA-805 LAR submittal date of October 4, 2016
-month extension to the LAR submittal date
* Fire PRA development and plant modifications have delayed the fire protection transition project
-Demonstrate progress toward transition (SECY 12
* SNC intends to request an 18-month extension to the LAR submittal date
-0031) -Use NEI/Industry Template Purpose -Detail needed for extension request
  - Demonstrate progress toward transition (SECY 12-0031)
-Describe content and schedule of formal submittal
  - Use NEI/Industry Template
-Discuss Hatch NFPA
* Purpose
-805 Status to Date
  - Detail needed for extension request
  - Describe content and schedule of formal submittal
  - Discuss Hatch NFPA-805 Status to Date


Reasons for Schedule Change FPRA Peer Review completed April 2016 -Additional tasks remain to resolve facts and observations  
Reasons for Schedule Change
-Refine FPRA model Add recent and future planned plant modifications
* FPRA Peer Review completed April 2016
-Requires additional time for development and implementation FLEX modifications Degraded Grid Voltage Protection modifications Safe Shutdown Analysis re-baseline compliance analysis completed December 2015
  - Additional tasks remain to resolve facts and observations
-SSA subsequent evaluations still in progress [Potential risk for additional VFDRs]
  - Refine FPRA model
Information Notice 92
* Add recent and future planned plant modifications
-18 mechanical evaluation  
  - Requires additional time for development and implementation
- in progress Control Building HVAC heat up analysis updates  
* FLEX modifications
- in progress Additional Activities
* Degraded Grid Voltage Protection modifications
-FP Code Evaluations
* Safe Shutdown Analysis re-baseline compliance analysis completed December 2015
-FP System Hydraulic Calculations
  - SSA subsequent evaluations still in progress [Potential risk for additional VFDRs]
-Engineering Equivalency Evaluations
* Information Notice 92-18 mechanical evaluation - in progress
* Control Building HVAC heat up analysis updates - in progress
* Additional Activities
  - FP Code Evaluations
  - FP System Hydraulic Calculations
  - Engineering Equivalency Evaluations


FPRA Peer Review FPRA F&O Resolution /
Hatch NFPA 805 Transition Schedule 18 Month 2016                                              2017                                                          2018 Apr May   Jun Jul Aug Sep   Oct   Nov   Dec   Jan Feb   Mar   Apr   May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct   Nov   Dec   Jan Feb Mar   Apr Apr 25 - 29 FPRA Peer Review                                                                                                              LAR Submittal FPRA F&O Resolution / Model Refinement Additional Fire Protection Engineering Evaluations SNC Risk Reduction Final Review Fire Risk Evaluations NSCA Transition Transition Report Review Transition Report
Model Refinement Additional Fire Protection Engineering Evaluations Apr     May     Jun     Jul     Aug     Sep     Oct     Nov     Dec     Jan     Feb     Mar     Apr     May     Jun     Jul Aug     Sep     Oct     Nov     Dec     Jan     Feb     Mar     Apr 2016 2017 Fire Risk Evaluations Transition Report Apr 25 - 29 LAR Submittal 2018 Transition Report Review Risk Reduction SNC Final Review NSCA Transition Hatch NFPA 805 Transition Schedule 18 Month Project Status
- Fire PRA    Satisfactory FPRA Peer Review completed in April 2016
  -CDF and LERF are in E
-04 range  -Additional tasks remaining Facts and Observations resolution Reduce CDF and LERF to meet RG 1.174 criteria for total risk via model refinement (e.g., take credit for installed FLEX, Degraded Grid Voltage Protection modifications) and planned plant modification identification Perform Fire Risk Evaluations


Project Status  
Project Status - Fire PRA
- Traditional FP Fundamental FP Program and Design Elements
* Satisfactory FPRA Peer Review completed in April 2016
-NFPA 805 Chapter 3 Requirements
  - CDF and LERF are in E-04 range
- review completed -NFPA Code Compliance Evaluation
  - Additional tasks remaining
- review completed
* Facts and Observations resolution
-Existing Engineering Equivalency Evaluations for adequacy
* Reduce CDF and LERF to meet RG 1.174 criteria for total risk via model refinement (e.g., take credit for installed FLEX, Degraded Grid Voltage Protection modifications) and planned plant modification identification
-review completed
* Perform Fire Risk Evaluations
-GL 86-10s -Licensing Actions
- no exemptions will be retained


NFPA-805 Status LAR/TR R efer ence Topic % Co m p lete N/A Safe shutd own Analysis U pdate (pre-r equi site ta s k) 90% 4.1, Atta chment A Fund amental FP Program Elements a nd Minimum D esign Re q u i r em en ts (T a b l e B-1) 75% 4.2.1, Atta chment B N ucle ar Safety Capability Ass e ssm ent - Methodolo g y (Tab l e B-2) 70%  Section 4.2.2, Atta chment C N ucle ar Safety Capability Ass e ssm ent - Fire Area  
Project Status - Traditional FP
- by - Fire Ar e a R eview (T able B-3) 50%  Section 4.3, Atta chment D Non P o w e r Operati onal M o des (Tab l e F-1) 60% Section 4.4, Atta chment E Rad i o active Rel ease (T able G-1) 90% Section 4.1.3, Attachment I Definition of Power Block and Plant 100% Section 4.2.2 Existing Engineering Equivalency Evaluation Transition 30% Section 4.2.3, Attachment K Licensing Action Transition 90% Section 4.1.2.3, Attachment L NFPA 805 Chapter 3 Requirements Not Met and Not Previously Approved by NRC 55%  N/A Fire PRA Peer Review 100% N/A Fire PRA Peer Review F&O Closure 25% Section 4.5.2.2 Fire Risk Evaluations 0% Section 4.6 Monitoring Program 0% Section 4.7 Program Documentation, Configuration Control, and Quality Assurance 0%   Transition Report 5%
* Fundamental FP Program and Design Elements
Non-conformances & Compensatory Measures Existing Non- conformances
  - NFPA 805 Chapter 3 Requirements - review completed
-NFPA code deviations
  - NFPA Code Compliance Evaluation - review completed
-NSCA cable separation issues Compensatory Measures: -Fire watches for code deviations
  - Existing Engineering Equivalency Evaluations for adequacy -
  -Combination of fire watches and Alternative Compensatory Measures -NRC review of alternate comp measures during TFPI found program to be in conformance with RIS 2005-07 Summary / Questions Additional time is needed to submit the NFPA
review completed
-805 LAR -complete the FPRA and incorporate scope of currently planned plant modifications  
      - GL 86-10s
-Refine model and conduct Fire Risk Evaluations
      - Licensing Actions - no exemptions will be retained
-Perform conceptual design studies for any other necessary modifications Propose request for 18 month extension to submit the LAR -Use NFPA-805 template to document project status
 
-Submit request to NRC by July 15, 2016}}
NFPA-805 Status LAR/TR Reference                                    Topic                       % Complete Safe shutdown Analysis Update N/A                                                                           90%
(pre-requisite task)
Fundamental FP Program Elements and Minimum Design 4.1, Attachment A                                                                     75%
Requirements (Table B-1)
Nuclear Safety Capability Assessment - Methodology 4.2.1, Attachment B                                                                   70%
(Table B-2)
Nuclear Safety Capability Assessment - Fire Area - by -
Section 4.2.2, Attachment C                                                               50%
Fire Area Review (Table B-3)
Section 4.3, Attachment D           Non Power Operational Modes (Table F-1)             60%
Section 4.4, Attachment E               Radioactive Release (Table G-1)                 90%
Section 4.1.3, Attachment I             Definition of Power Block and Plant             100%
Section 4.2.2           Existing Engineering Equivalency Evaluation Transition     30%
Section 4.2.3, Attachment K                   Licensing Action Transition                 90%
NFPA 805 Chapter 3 Requirements Not Met and Not Section 4.1.2.3, Attachment L                                                             55%
Previously Approved by NRC N/A                               Fire PRA Peer Review                     100%
N/A                         Fire PRA Peer Review F&O Closure                 25%
Section 4.5.2.2                           Fire Risk Evaluations                     0%
Section 4.6                               Monitoring Program                       0%
Section 4.7         Program Documentation, Configuration Control, and Quality     0%
Assurance Transition Report                     5%
 
Non-conformances & Compensatory Measures
* Existing Non- conformances
  - NFPA code deviations
  - NSCA cable separation issues
* Compensatory Measures:
  - Fire watches for code deviations
  - Combination of fire watches and Alternative Compensatory Measures
  - NRC review of alternate comp measures during TFPI found program to be in conformance with RIS 2005-07
 
Summary / Questions
* Additional time is needed to submit the NFPA-805 LAR
  - complete the FPRA and incorporate scope of currently planned plant modifications
  - Refine model and conduct Fire Risk Evaluations
  - Perform conceptual design studies for any other necessary modifications
* Propose request for 18 month extension to submit the LAR
  - Use NFPA-805 template to document project status
  - Submit request to NRC by July 15, 2016}}

Revision as of 17:38, 30 October 2019

SNC Slides for 6-21-16 Public Meeting on Hatch NFPA 805 Extension
ML16169A061
Person / Time
Site: Hatch  Southern Nuclear icon.png
Issue date: 06/20/2016
From:
Southern Nuclear Operating Co
To: Michael Orenak
Plant Licensing Branch II
Orenak M, NRR/DORL/LPLII-1, 415-3229
References
CAC MF7736, CAC MF7737
Download: ML16169A061 (10)
v • d • e


Text

Plant Hatch NFPA 805 LAR Submittal Extension Request NRC/SNC Meeting June 21, 2016

Agenda

  • Meeting Purpose and Schedule Request
  • Reason for Schedule Extension

- Fire PRA

- Traditional FP Scope

  • Summary / Questions / Actions

Summary & Purpose

  • Fire PRA development and plant modifications have delayed the fire protection transition project
  • SNC intends to request an 18-month extension to the LAR submittal date

- Demonstrate progress toward transition (SECY 12-0031)

- Use NEI/Industry Template

  • Purpose

- Detail needed for extension request

- Describe content and schedule of formal submittal

- Discuss Hatch NFPA-805 Status to Date

Reasons for Schedule Change

  • FPRA Peer Review completed April 2016

- Additional tasks remain to resolve facts and observations

- Refine FPRA model

  • Add recent and future planned plant modifications

- Requires additional time for development and implementation

  • Degraded Grid Voltage Protection modifications
  • Safe Shutdown Analysis re-baseline compliance analysis completed December 2015

- SSA subsequent evaluations still in progress [Potential risk for additional VFDRs]

  • Control Building HVAC heat up analysis updates - in progress
  • Additional Activities

- FP Code Evaluations

- FP System Hydraulic Calculations

- Engineering Equivalency Evaluations

Hatch NFPA 805 Transition Schedule 18 Month 2016 2017 2018 Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr Apr 25 - 29 FPRA Peer Review LAR Submittal FPRA F&O Resolution / Model Refinement Additional Fire Protection Engineering Evaluations SNC Risk Reduction Final Review Fire Risk Evaluations NSCA Transition Transition Report Review Transition Report

Project Status - Fire PRA

  • Satisfactory FPRA Peer Review completed in April 2016

- CDF and LERF are in E-04 range

- Additional tasks remaining

  • Facts and Observations resolution
  • Reduce CDF and LERF to meet RG 1.174 criteria for total risk via model refinement (e.g., take credit for installed FLEX, Degraded Grid Voltage Protection modifications) and planned plant modification identification
  • Perform Fire Risk Evaluations

Project Status - Traditional FP

  • Fundamental FP Program and Design Elements

- NFPA 805 Chapter 3 Requirements - review completed

- NFPA Code Compliance Evaluation - review completed

- Existing Engineering Equivalency Evaluations for adequacy -

review completed

- GL 86-10s

- Licensing Actions - no exemptions will be retained

NFPA-805 Status LAR/TR Reference Topic  % Complete Safe shutdown Analysis Update N/A 90%

(pre-requisite task)

Fundamental FP Program Elements and Minimum Design 4.1, Attachment A 75%

Requirements (Table B-1)

Nuclear Safety Capability Assessment - Methodology 4.2.1, Attachment B 70%

(Table B-2)

Nuclear Safety Capability Assessment - Fire Area - by -

Section 4.2.2, Attachment C 50%

Fire Area Review (Table B-3)

Section 4.3, Attachment D Non Power Operational Modes (Table F-1) 60%

Section 4.4, Attachment E Radioactive Release (Table G-1) 90%

Section 4.1.3, Attachment I Definition of Power Block and Plant 100%

Section 4.2.2 Existing Engineering Equivalency Evaluation Transition 30%

Section 4.2.3, Attachment K Licensing Action Transition 90%

NFPA 805 Chapter 3 Requirements Not Met and Not Section 4.1.2.3, Attachment L 55%

Previously Approved by NRC N/A Fire PRA Peer Review 100%

N/A Fire PRA Peer Review F&O Closure 25%

Section 4.5.2.2 Fire Risk Evaluations 0%

Section 4.6 Monitoring Program 0%

Section 4.7 Program Documentation, Configuration Control, and Quality 0%

Assurance Transition Report 5%

Non-conformances & Compensatory Measures

  • Existing Non- conformances

- NFPA code deviations

- NSCA cable separation issues

  • Compensatory Measures:

- Fire watches for code deviations

- Combination of fire watches and Alternative Compensatory Measures

- NRC review of alternate comp measures during TFPI found program to be in conformance with RIS 2005-07

Summary / Questions

- complete the FPRA and incorporate scope of currently planned plant modifications

- Refine model and conduct Fire Risk Evaluations

- Perform conceptual design studies for any other necessary modifications

  • Propose request for 18 month extension to submit the LAR

- Use NFPA-805 template to document project status

- Submit request to NRC by July 15, 2016

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML16169A061&oldid=2019412"