ML20203P077

1985 Radiological Environ Monitoring Rept

ML20203P077
Person / Time
Site:	Big Rock Point File:Consumers Energy icon.png
Issue date:	12/31/1985
From:	Johnson B CONSUMERS ENERGY CO. (FORMERLY CONSUMERS POWER CO.)
To:	James Keppler NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION III)
References
NUDOCS 8605060320
Download: ML20203P077 (53)

Text

o-4 ATTACHMENT-Consumers Power Company Big Rock Point Plant Docket 50-155 4

ANNUAL RADIOLOGICAL ENVIRONMENTAL OPERATING REPORT JANUARY THROUGH DECEMBER, 1985 April 21, 1986 l

l l

52 Pages t

.(

(/ p IC0386-0053-NLO4 v

k 8605060320 851231 i

i-PDR ADOCK 05000155 l

R PDR l-

1 This report provides information relating to radiological environmental monitoring at the Big Rock Point Plant during the period of January through December 1985 as required by Technical Specification 6.9.2.1.

1.

RADIOLOGICAL ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING A.

Report Summary Table RSD-E-06A addresses the number of sampling locations, total number of samples collected and the number of locations at which levels were found to be significantly above local concurrent back-ground. A listing of the highest, lowest and annual average cor.cen-tration for the sampling location with the highest average concen-tration is presented in Table RSD-E-06B.

Fish, sediment and algae control samples were collected at Ludington (approx. 175 mi. SW of Big Rock) and used in evaluating some of the Big Rock Point biota samples.

B.

Environmental Dose Estimates Levels of radioactive materials in environmental media demonstrate that 1% of 10 CFR 20 limits were not exceeded by plant radiological effluents based upon I-131 levels in milk and statistical evaluation of annual TLD stations.

C.

Statistical Model Statistical evaluation at the 95% confidence level was performed between the near-site and control locations as described in pro-cedure RSD-E-06.

Data evaluation was performed against two cri-teria: the statistical level (the level indicating that nample results obtained from the near sites are greater than those taken from control locations, but the difference is not significant); and the reporting level (minimum detectable difference that exceeds zero at the 95% confidence level).

The reporting level is twice the statistical level. Doses to the public are evaluated if any reporting levels are exceeded.

2.

DISCUSSION AND INTERPRETATION OF RESULTS f

A.

Air Samples: Comparison of airborne particulate sample results between the near-site and control locations were below the statis-tical level. A total of 364 air samples were collected and analyzed; however 6 samples were deleted from statistical evalua-tion due to low sample yield. The deleted sample results do not indicate any significant reduction in the overall program. The annual gross beta levels were also below the statistical level. All 3

I-131 activity was reported <0.02 pCi/m. This is consistent with expected results based on actual plant effluent data.

IC0486-0099A-HP01-NLO4

L

=

2 B.

Lake Water: Comparison of gross beta and tritium results between the plant intake and discharge were below the statistical level.

C.

Well Water (Drinking Water): Well water samples do not indicate the presence of other than natural background radioactivity. Gross beta comparisons between the site and Charlevoix Municipal wells were below'the statistical level.

D.

Milk: Strontium-90 was the only radionuclide detectable in milk samples collected during the reporting period (an absence of short-lived fission products such as I-131 indicates that the origin is not from BRP). Concentrations of Sr-90 are consistent with back-ground from past weapons testing fallout. The Sr-90 statistical level was not exceeded. There were a total of three missing samples from location GS (March, April and May) due to dry cows.

E.

Aquatic Biota: Samples of periphyton, algae, crayfish and fish are collected semiannually, when available. The gross beta and Sr-90 fish sample results from Big Rock Point and the Ludington control station were compared. The statistical levels were not exceeded.

All other gamma isotopic results are reported in Table RSD-E-06B.

F.

Bottom Sediments: Samples of bottom sediment are collected semi-annually from two locations at Big Rock Point. The gross beta and Sr-90 results from Big Rock Point and the Iudington control station were compared. The statistical levels were not exceeded. All other gamma isotopic results are reported in Table RSD-E-06B.

G.

Food Crops (vegetation): Samples of food crops grown in the proxim-ity of Big Rock Point were collected during 1985. The primary areas of collection were the SSE, ESE, SE and E sectors at the 2.0-2.5 mile limit. A total of 7 samples were obtained (2 samples per location per sector - except for the SSE sector, which had I sample collected) for analysis. Sample isotopic results are reported in Table RSD-E-06B.

H.

Gamma Dose (TLD): There was 1 monthly (April) TLD reported stolen during 1985 and 1 monthly (January) TLD data result deleted (for statistical purposes) due to suspected improper annealing of the TLD chip. In both cases, the af fected stations are located on-site. No TLD's were reported missing for the near-site or control locations.

Evaluation of the near-site and control TLD data indicated that the statistical level was not exceeded.

3.

ATTACHMENTS A.

Table RSD-E-06A; Big Rock Point Radiological Environmental Monitor-ing Sampling and Analysis Summary, January 1 to December 31, 1985.

B.

Table RSD-E-06B; Big Rock Point High, Low and Average Concentration for the Highest Sampling Location, January 1 to December 31, 1985.

IC0486-0099A-HP01

3 C.

Table C; Big Rock' Point Sampling Locations.

D.

Maps of Big Rock Point: site, near-site, and control locations.

E.

Big Rock Point 1985 Land Use Census F.

The 1985 Teledyne Isotopes Interlaboratory Comparison Program Results for Big Rock Point.

G.

Big Rock Point Radiological Environmental Trending Graphs.

2 IC0486-0099A-HP01 t

l, TABLE RSD-E-06A BIG ROCK POINT RADIOIDGICAL DIVIROIMDITAL MONITORING SAMPLING AIO ANALYSIS SUlmARY JANUARY I TO DECDEER 31, 1985 8 of 8 of Nust>er of Locations Sampling Samples Significantly Above Medium Description Type of Analysis Frequency Locations Collected concurrent Background Air Continuous Gross Beta, I-131 Weekly 7

364 None

@ approx 2 cfm Lake Composite Gross Beta, H-3 Monthly 2

24 None Water Well Grab Gross Beta Monthly 2

24 None Water Milk Grab I-131, Sr-89/90, Monthly 4

45 None m==a Continuous TLD Monthly 18 215 None Dose Quarterly 18 72 None Annual 18 18 None Aquatic Grab Gross Beta, Semiannually 5

42 None Biota Sr-89/90, Ca=== Isotopic Sediment Grab Gross Beta, Semiannually 2

4 None Sr-89/90, na==a Isotopic Vegeta-Grab Gross Beta, In season 4

7 None tion Sr-89/90, when available (food crops)

Ca=== Isotopic MIO486-0023A-HP01

o Page 1 of 2 TABLE RSD-E-06B BIG KOCK POINT HIGH, LOW AIO AVERAGE CONCDirRATION FOR THE HIGHEST AVERAGE SAMPLING IDCATION

' JANUARY I 70 DECnetzt 31, 1985 Lower Limit Media Type of Analysts of Detection location High tow Average Air Gross Beta 0.01 Traverse City 0.040 0.006 0.0 17 (pci/m )

I-131

<0.02 (50 mi SSW)

(LLD

< LID (LLD lake Water Gross Beta 1.0 Discharge 8.9 1.6 3.3 (pC1/1)

H-3 100.0 Discharge 616 (100.0 236.3 Well Water (pC1/1)

Gross Beta 1.0 Charlevoix 3.0 1.2 2.1 (4.5 mi SW)

Milk 1-131 0.5 All (LID (LtD

< LID (pC1/11 Cs-137 5.0 All (LID (LLD (LID Sr-89 5.0 All (LLD (LID (LID Sr-90 1.0 DK (2.5 mi E) 6.6 1.8 4.7 r - Dose TLD (Monthly)

Susan take 7.4 3.7 5.1 (mR/ month)

(3.5 mi SE)

(mR/ quarter)

Boyne City 7.8 3.6 5.1 (mR/ year)

(12 mi SE)

TLD (Quarterly)

Boyne City 18.6 13.1 16.1 (12 mi SE) 69.9 TLD (Annual)

Boyne City (12 mi SE)

Biota (pC1/g Wet)

Gross Beta (algae) 1.0 Mt. McSauba (3 mi WI 9.0 1.6 5.3 Sr-90 (crayfish)

.005 Mt. It:Sauba (3 mi W) 0.36 0.22 0.29 Sr-89 (crayfish)

.025 Discharge 0.28

<0.025 0.28 Cs-137 (periphyton)

.08 Discharge 0.84 0.56 0.70 Co-60 (periphyton)

.05 Discharge 1.51 0.45 0.98 Cs-134 (all locations)

.08 All (LID (LID (LID l

m -54 (periphyton)

.08 Discharge 1.41 0.55 0.98 1-131

.05 All (LID (LID

< LID MIO486-0023A-HP01

~

Pa p 2 of 2 TABLE RCD-E-06B BIG ROCK PolNT HIGH, LON AM) AVERAGE CONCDfTRATION FOR THE HIGHIST AVERAGE SAMPLING IDCATION JANUARY 1 TO DECDBDt 31, 1985 lower Limit Media Type of Analysis of Detection loc.2 t t on Htqh low Average Sediment (pC1/g dry)

Gross Beta 1.0 Discharge 9.0 7.9 8.5 Cs-134

.08 All (LLD (LLD (LLD Cs-137

.08 Discharge 0.62 0.58 0.60 Co-60

.05 A11

<LLD

< LID (LID Sr-89

.025

• Discharge 0.029

<0.025 0.029 Sr-90 0.005 9 mi pt (3 mi El 0.029

<0.005 0.029 Vegetaion (food Gross Beta 1.0 D Kuebler (2.5 mi E) 7.5 6.6 7.1 crops pC1/g wet)

Cs-134

.08 All (LID (LID (LLD Cs-137

.08 All (LID (LID (LLD Sr-90

.005 Hutterer (2.0 mi ESE) 0.168 0.054 0.111 Sr-89

.025 All (LID (LID (LID I-131

.05 All (Lib (LID (LID Co-60

.05 A11 (LID

< LID

< LID

a. Nominal lower limit of detection (LID) defined in HASL-300, pgs. D-08-01, 02 and 03.

• NOTE: Positive result reported due to low chemical recovery in discharge sample.

MIO486-0023A-HP01

I Page 1 of 2 1ABLE C BIG ROCK POINT SAMPLING IDCATIONS

-Air Sedi-Particu-Air take Well Station Code Location ment lates Iodine Water Water Milk Biota TID Fish 1

ST Big Rock Point Nuclear Plant I

X X

X

-X X

X X

2 NM Nine Mile Point, 3 miles E.

X X

X X

X 3

CH Charlevoix, Michigan X

X X

X 4-1/2 miles SW 4

SL Susan Lake, 3.5 miles SE X

X X

5 PT Petoskey, Michigan X

X X

10-1/2 miles E 6

BC Boyne City, Michigan X

X X

12 miles SE 7

TR Traverse City, Michigan X

X X

50 miles SSW 8

D Control (Imad Cave)

X W Woods, Charlevoix, Michigan 9

A Meteorological Tower X

10 B

West Site Boundary on X

Lake Michigan 11 C

South Site Boundary, X

Shanahan's Orchard 0.8 miles SW 12 E

Southeast Boundary X

0.9 miles SSE, US-31 Near Railway Spur 13 F

First CPCo Pole in Right X

of Way South of US-31 14 G

Information Center Site X

15 H

Vent Shet (South Side) Site I

16 J

Susan Creek Hear Lake X

Michigan MIO486-0023A-HP01

Page 2 of 2 TABLE C BIG ROCK POINT SAMPLING LOCATIONS Air Sedi-Particu-Air Lake Well Station Code Location ment lates Iodine Water Water Milk Biota TID Fish 17 K

Discharge Canal (T1sherman)

X 18 Access Control X

19 MS Mt McSaube, 3 miles W X

20 GS G Smith - Old Highway 31 X

Charlevoix, Michigan 2.3 miles SE t

21 LK D.L. Kuebler, Upper Bay X

Shore Road, Charlevoix Michigan, 2.5 miles E 22 TD R McCraney, Horton Bay Road I

Charlevo.'.x, Michigan 6.5 miles SSE 23 BB B Bochniak, Resort Pike X

Road, Petoskey, Michigan 11.5 miles E LP Ludington Pump Storage Plt I

X X

MIO486-0023A-HP01

(

1 l

l 5

g 3

.)

.5I 8

=

=s-

=

0 1

I I I-s g"

i U

h 5:3ff

. e

' g i 33 2

=

s N

e o XX

=g h,

=

\\

I I m

,,p :

ee

\\.

9 I

I d

I e

p U

Fr J

35 4

s a$,

..q O

5_

935 i

s a

s e

e R

x

{

g 3

I@

'u y

een 5

8

=

I s

e 1 ell A.La N eed

. {_

a t

I L

w#

i

[

f_ w

.i

-VM=

ii :,'

m e-A x,s l,

,. 3, P n 91 11 e

3, e, e

i,<i;l i

,.1 :.b y- _

L (x

(1*

u u f

'. t. M..3,w i r

-r e

..n.-F r

c I

_a_

c e.

.r,.

s d.

i e

p,,

m y..

..y

-. ;g..

r b;, 4 t, i,,t

.=

t. A

(.... rL,a

s...u:.....

c

?

r.

ia r.

~

m.4-sam,7.g 1,. L.

.... -...mO

. s,*.. :.

...n -

n e

t.

1%

.1 j

i w

s. /-kdis w,

i l

~

~

'.A.,Q,m.~_m a) {i.,

M y M g\\

M...I

g...,g s,_.h..,

m g

. /....;..

.i.

w, u,,,

4

\\

.g 2 -.... :

.. :. ym+;- 3Y m. r.?

,1.

...... e..

n+.,.c.a

.. )... i. v

.,,c

.~.,..

T r.

's..

.........d.

,.1.w. -l:

.4 i

...A.

! 1,..

d.,,

.%-J

..jf..

3,.

g,,....

r 8-

.$.4 %.,h i _.y j.t.,'d.*.I

...w w

.l,

.- z.... u s ;..gg

.;.s...

-,.9

.....x..

p. &

.... x

.... w_ i !,i

=

,. s.

3

-__-,_o__.~-_____-_-

v

/

Big Rock Point 1985 Land Us.t Census The attachwd tables and map are the results of the Big Rock Point Land Use Survey conducted on June 18, 1985. Table 1 references the distance from Big Rock Point to the nearest residence, garden, beef / dairy cattle and gbat per meteorological sector. Table 2 identifies the locations of-the nearest residence; of all gardens (greater than 500 square feet) within a three mile radits of plant; and all beef / dairy cattle within a five mile radius of plant.

No goats were located while conducting the 1985 Land Use Survey. An Accompanying map illustrates Table 2.

Prior to conducting the 1985 BRP Land Use Survey, both the Charlevoix County Agricultural Extension Office and the Consumers Power Northern Regional Manager's Office were contacted on June 12, 1985 as specified in Procedure RSD-E-01.

There were no significant changes between the 1984 and 1985 Land Use Surveys.

MIO486-0023A-HP01

2 BIG ROCK POINT PLANT ~

TABLE 1 i

Discance to the nearest residence, garden, milk cow, beef cow and goat in each

-sector.

SECTOR RESIDENCE GARDEN DAIRY COW BEEF CATTLE GOAT WSW 2.5 mi

>5 mi

>5 mi

>5 mi

>5 mi SW 1.1 mi 2.5 mi

>5 mi

>5 mi

>5 mi SSW-1.3 mi 2.1 mi

>5 mi

>5 mi

>5 mi S

1.9 mi 2.2 mi 2.3 mi 2.3 mi

>5 mi SSE 1.7 mi 1.8 mi 3.5 mi 3.5 mi

>5 mi SE 1.7 mi 1.9 mi 2.3 mi 1.9 mi

>5 mi ESE 1.5 mi 1.9 mi 2.2 mi-3.2 mi

>5 mi E

1.4 mi 3.0 mi 2.5 mi 2.5 mi

>5 mi ENE 2.3 mi

>5 mi

>5 mi

>5 mi -

>5 mi IC06SS-017SA-HP01

-' O 3~

BIG ROCK POINT PLANT TABLE 2 Locations of nearest residence; of all gardens greater than 500 square feet within a three mile radiums of plant; and all beef / dairy cattle within a five mile radius of plant. No goats were located while conducting the 1985

~

Land Use Survey.

4 Sector and Road Location Description Item Number / Comment l

WSW Birchwood Ranch Shores Residence 1

McSauba North Point SW Lackin's residence Residence 1

~

Dirt Road (Birchwood Ranch Shores)

Dirt trail off of Martin Rd SW North Point Developraent, Gardens 3

Mercer Road North of Waller Road SW F. Durance, Garden 1

Intersection of Southeast corner of Waller & Mercer Rds f r.te rsection SSW Eoward K. Shanahaa, Residence 1

Private Drive Private drive north of US-31 SSW Open plot Garden 1

Intersection of North side of intersection Waller Road & US-31 SSW Robert Burns Garden 1

Boyne City Road South side of road adj.

to Mfg Nat'l Bank property S

G. Skeel Residence 1

North (dead) end North of Boyne City Road of See Road S

Willis Keiser, Rt. 3, Cattle 1-beef Intersection of Northeast corner of Garden 1

Boyne City and See intersection Roads I

IC0685-017SA-HP01 y * -

,s

-+---

+ - -

• r

• r7d------W----7-*F*

-i*'--W-

--e--*

w

~ - -

' - ~ -

+

'"+FTT-e r*^'67p"---

Table.1 (cont'd)

- Sector and Road Location Descripti,on Item Number / Comment S

S. Wilson, southeast Cattle

'2-dairy Intersection of corner of intersection Garden 1

Boyne City and See Roads-S Susan Shores Subdivision Garden 1

. Boyne City Road West side of road SSE Robert Dyksterhouse, Residence 1

- Private drive West of Old US-31, adj Garden 1

Susan Lake

- SSE Susan Shores Subdivision Gardens 4

Old US-31 West and east sides of Old US-31 adj. Susan Lake SSE W.H. Harvey Garden 1

Old US-31 West side of Old US-31, adj. Susan Lake SSE W. Karl Purdy Garden 1

Old US-31 East Side of Old US-31, adj. Susan Lake SSE Greensky Hill Garden 1

Intersection of Indian Church, east Boyne City Road side of intersection and Old US-31 SSE H. Tunison Garden 1

Shrigley Road East side of road SSE H. Westenbrock Garden 1

Shrigley Road East side of road SSE G. Johnson Garden 1

Shrigley Road East side of road

-SSE-R.B. Ayer Garden 1

Shrigley Road East side of road (dead end)

SSE Lester Umlar Farms Cattle 30-beef Intersection of Southwest corner of

. Boyne City and intersection Quarterline Roads IC0685-0178A-HP01 4

t 5

Tabic 2 (cont'd)

Sector and Road Location Description Item Number / Comment

'SSE Jerry & Hazel Haggerty Cattle 8-dairy Intersection of Farms, southeast corner Boyne City and of intersection Quarterline Roads SSE Betty Straw Cattle 7-beef Intersection of Northwest corner of Burgess and intersection Quarterline Roads SE Daniel & Rebecca Berg Residence 1

Intersection of Old Route 3; southwest corner Garden 1

US-31 and Smith Road of intersection SE George Smith Cattle 2-beef Smith Road End of Smith Road, south 10-dairy of Old US-31 SE R.M. Jess, 407 Shrigley; Cattle 8-beef Intersection Old southeast corner of US-31 & Shrigley Rd intersection SE Laurren & Marion Williams, Garden 1

Burgess Road Williams, 1\\ mile south of Upper Bay Shore Road SE E. Knight, Rt 33, Box 290B, Cattle 10-dairy Burgess Road 2 miles north of Quarterline Road SE Alfred Allison, Quarterline Cattle 1-dairy Intersection of Road; 1 mile east of Quarterline and intersection McNally Roads SE Lee Sneathen, Jr. Farms, Cattle 24-beef Intersection of west side of intersection

!!aple Grove and Dalton Road SE John and Shirley Colovich, Cattle 13-dairy Intersection of east side of intersection 20-beef Maple Grove and Quarterline Roads ESE J. Bowman, Burgess Road, Residence 1

Burgess Road 1 mile south of US-31 ICOLS5-01 SA-HP01

6

)

Table 2 (cont'd)

Sector and Road Location Description Item Number / Comment ESE B.G. Morgan Garden 1

Old US-31 2 miles southwest of Burgess ESE J. Rivard Garden 1

Intersection of North side of intersection Upper Bay Shore and Burgess Roads ESE TRS Garden 1

Intersection of West side of intersection Upper Bay Shore and Burgess Roads ESE Robert Dyksterhouse Garden 1

Intersection of Southwest side of intersection Upper Bay Shore and Burgess Roads ESE G. Wood, \\ mile east of Upper Garden 1

Upper Bay Shore Road Bay Shore and Burgess Road

~

intersection (south side of road)

ESE CM Garden 1

Upper Bay Shore Road I mile east of Upper Bay Shore and Burgess Road intersection (south side of road)

ESE Raymond Conley,1\\ mile Garden i

Upper Bay Shore Road east of Upper Bay Shore and Burgess Road intersection (south side of road)

ESE George Melke Cattle 3-dairy Burgess Road 3/4 miles south of Upper Bay Shore and Burgess Road intersection (east side of road)

ESE Merle Hand, 304 Upper Bay Cattle 6-beef Upper Bay Shore Road Shore Rd, mile west of Upper Bay Shore and Maple Grove Road (south side of road)

IC06SS-0175A-liPG1

.a

'"'t P

Table 2 (cont'd)

Sector and Road Location Description Item Number / Comment

' ESE Ed Smally, Box 314B, west Cattle 18-beef Stolt Road end (turnaround area) of Stalt Road, 3/4 mi from intersection of Stolt and Maple Grove Road ESE' Thomas Hamlin, northeast Cattle 1-dairy Stolt Road corner intersection of Stolt and Murry Roads E

Ralph J. Purvis, \\ mile Residence 1

Burgess Road south of intersection of Burgess and US-31

- E -

Leo Burnett, northwest Garden 1

Maple Grove Road corner of intersection of short dead-end road and Maple Grove Road; \\ mile south of US-31 E

ban Kuebler Farms Cattle 43-beef Upper Bay Shore Road 1\\ mile east of Upper Bay 10-dairy Shore and Burgess Road.

Garden 1

intersection (north side of roa'd)

E T. McClellan, east corner.

Cattle 1-beef Intersection of Maple of intersection of Maple Grove 1-dairy Grove and Upper Bay and Upper Bay Shore Road Shore Road E

F.P. Foltz, west side of Cattle 2-dairy Maple Grove Road Maple Grove Road, mile south of Maple Grove and Old US-31 intersection E

Hiram & !!argaret Steward, Cattle 7-dairy Upper Bay Shore Road mile east of intersection of Upper Bay Shore Road and Burnett Road E

Raymond Griffin, northeast Cattle 3-dairy Intersection of Upper corner of intersection 30-beef Bay Shore and Murry Roads ICC685-0178A-HP01 n

i P

+

- ~ -.. -

e.

g

.s.

i' Table 2 (cont'd) j Sector and Road Location Descript"ibn Item

.. Number / Comment j

)

E John Speigel, west corner Cattle 2-beef Intersection of Murry of intersection Road and Old US-31 V

E C.C. Hand, 332 E. Pin Chrry;

^ C3ttle 4-dairy

~

Pin. Cherry Road 1 mile south of intersection l

at Upper Bay Shore and Pin-Cherry Road

- ENE Werney Cunningham, south side Residence 1

US-31 of US-31, 2.3 miles east of BRP Plant e

r l

+

t s

t 4

5 4

1 7

1

.4 T

E I 4

4 1

[

IC0685-0178A-HP01 4'

P p

s f

i 1

q-

+

g n

-g

,.-,.rs,r,er m.s.rw-w m--s.r--r'~e-e-=,

• -<~--","r^=

• - - * ~ ' ' $

'^*v'

~* "*~~*'

' ~ ' ' ^ ' " ' '

~ ' " ' ~

L

%e z

I

k. w w

(-

9 w

s I

't i j'

, y i

l l

s 7 ej / r c.

g....~

{

l

.;j f' " M 8

\\

4:,

Q

.- e

)

/

s v

q g

' =Yg~".

/ \\.

m...v... n

.z -

te)

/

\\

{

I W

/

t N

f+

4 4

u.m.

.r..>.

/

+

y4

-y#

'%.,4.t y-

-c

)

O t

I s

I 4

Q

/

~

\\e})

~

gi 1

,T,%,g

-V ~,..

o 2

l

%tu, wr,

,,)'

5 2

5h

)

n

~

z a

s.

s.

a -y s

i g

%;ct 4

r

~

~_

\\

sn

-8 L

E v[

h ll5 a

} {==

a g

1 3

0 4 e *

.a Appendix A Interlaboratory Comparison Program Results A-1

Appendix A Interlaboratory Cogarison Program Results Teledyne Isotopes Midwest Laboratory (formerly Hazleton Environmental Sciences) has participated in interlaboratory comparison (crosscheck) programs since the formulation of its quality control program in December 1971.

These programs are operated by agencies which supply environmental-type sagles (e.g., milk or water) containing concentrations of radionuclides known to the issuing agency but not to participant laboratories.

The purpose of such a program is to provide an independent check on the laboratory's analytical procedures and to alert it to any possible problems.

Participant laboratories measure the concentrations of specified radionuclides and report them to the issuing agency.

Several months later, the agency reports the known values to the participant laboratories and specifies control limits.

Results consistently higher or lower than the known values or outside the control limits indicate a need to check the instruments or procedures used.

The results in Table A-1 were obtained through participation in the environ-mental sample crosscheck program for milk, water, air filters, and food sagles during the period 1980 through June 1985.

This program has been conducted by the U.

S.

Environmental Protection Agency Intercogarison and Calibration Section, Quality Assurance Branch, Environmental Monitoring and Support Laboratory, Las Vegas, Nevada.

The results in Table A-2 were obtained for thermoluminescent dosimeters (TLD's) during the period 1976, 1977, 1979, 1980, and 1981 through parti-cipation in the Second, Third, Fourth, and Fif th International Intercomparison of Environmental Dosimeters under the sponsorships listed in Table A-2.

A-2 J

~

Table A-1.

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency's crosscheck program, com-parison of EPA and Teledyne Isotopes Midwest Laboratory results for milk, water, air filters, and food samples,1980 through 1984.a Concentration in pCi/lb Lab Sangle Date TIML Result EPA tesuit Code Type Collected Analysis 12aC i3o, n=ld STW-206 Water Jan. 1980 Gross Alpha 19.0*2.0 30.Di8.0 Gross Beta 48.012.0 45.0*5.0

' STW-208 Water Jan. 1980 Sr-89 6.lil.2 10.0*0.5 Sr-90 23.9tl.1 25.511.5 STW-209 Water Feb. 1980 Cr-51 112*14 10115.0 Co-60 12.712.3 1115.0 Zn-65 29.712.3 25t5.0 Ru-106 71.711.5 5115 I

Cs-134 12.0 2.0 10*5.0 Cs-137

30. 0* 2. 7 3015.0 STW-210 Water Feb. 1980 H-3 1800*120 1750i340 STW-211 Water March 1980 Ra-226 15.7*0.2 16.012.4 Ra-228 3.510.3 2.620.4 STM-217 Milk May 1980 Sr-89 4.412.69 Si5 Sr-90 10.0*1.0 1211.5 STW-221 Water June 1980 Ra-226 2.0*0.0 1.710.8 Ra-228 1.6i0.1 1.710.8 STW-223 Water July 1980 Gross Alpha 31i3.0 3815.0 Gross Beta 4414 3515.0 STW-224 Water July 1980 Cs-137 33.9*0.4 3515.0 Ba-140

<l2 0

K-40 1350160 1550*78 I-131

<5.0 0

STW-225 Water Aug. 1980 H-3 1280150 1210t329 STW-226 Water Sept. 1980 Sr-89 22il.2 24t8.6 Sr-90 1210.6 15t2.6 STW-228 Water Sept. 1980 Gross Alpha nae 32.018.0 Gross Beta 22.510.0 21.015.0 STW-235 Water Dec. 1980 H-3 2420t30 22401604 A-3 L

Table A-1.

(continued) b Concentration in pCi/l TIML Result EPA Result d

Lab Sample Date t2aC

• 3o, n=1 Code Type Collected Analysis Jan. 1981 Sr-89 13.Dil. 0 16t8.7 Sr-90 24.0*0.6 3412.9 STW-237 Water STM-239 Milk Jan. 1981 Sr-89

<2.0 0

Sr-90 15.712.6 20i3.0 I-131 30.914.8 26i10.0 Cs-137 46.912.9 4319.0 8a-140

<21 0

K-40 1330tS3 15501134 STW-240 Water Jan. 1981 Gross alpha 7.312.0 915.0 Gross beta 41.0i3.1 4415.0 STW-243 Water Mar. 1981 Ra-226 3.5i0.06 3.410.5 Ra-228 6.5t2.3 7.311.1 32101115 2710t355 STW-245 Water Apr. 1981 H-3 STW-249 Water May 1981 Sr-89 51i3.6 3618.7 Sr-90 22.7i0.6 2212.6 STW-251 Water May 1981 Gross alpha 24.0i5.3 21i5.2 Gross beta 16.lil.9 1415.0 STW-252 Water Jun. 1981 H-3 2140195 19501596 STW-255 Water Jul. 1981 Gross alpha 2011.5 22 9.5 Gross beta 13.012.0 1518.7 STW-259 Water Sep. 1981 Sr-89 16.lil.0 2315 Sr-90 10.310.9 1111.5 STW-265 Water Oct. 1981 Gross alpha 71.2i19.1 80 20 Gross beta 123.3 16.6 11115.6 Sr-89 14.912.0 2115 13.1tl.7 14.411.5 Sr-90 Ra-226 13.0i2.0 12.7 1.9 2516 181 27001355 Dec. 1981 H-3 STW-269 Water A-4

1 Table A-1.

(continued)

Concentration in pCi/lb Lab Sample Date TIML Result EPA tesult Code Type Collected Analysis tage t3o, n=ld STW-270 Water Jan. 1982 Sr-89 24.3i2.0 21.015.0 Sr-90 9.4i0.5 12.011.5 STW-273 Water Jan. 1982 I-131 8.6i0.6 8.4tl.5 STW-275 Water Feb. 1982 H-3 1580tl47 1820i342 STW-276 Water Feb. 1982 Cr-51

<61 0

Co-60 26.0t3.7 20f5 Zn-65

<13 15t5 Ru-106

<46 20i5 i

Cs-134 26.8t0.7 22i5 Cs-137 29.7tl.4 23t5 STW-277 Water Mar. 1982 Ra-226 ll.9tl.9 11.6tl.7 STW-278 Water Mar. 1982 Gross alpha 15.6tl.9 1915 Gross beta 19.2t0.4 1915 STW-280 Water Apr. 1982 H-3 2690t80 2860*360 STW-281 Water Apr. 1982 Gross alpha 75t7.9 85t21 Gross beta 114.115.9 106t5.3 Sr-89 17.4tl.8 24t5 Sr-90 10.Si0.6 12tl.5 Ra-226 11.4t2.0 10.9tl.5 Co-60

<4.6 0

STW-284 Water May 1982 Gross alpha 31.516.5 27.5t7 Gross beta 25.9t3.4 2915 STW-285 Water June 1982 H-3 1970t1408 1830t340 STW-286 Water June 1982 Ra-226 12.6t1.5 13.413.5 Ra-228 11.112.5 8.7t2.3 STW-287 Water June 1982 I-131 6.510.3 4.410.7 STW-290 Water Aug. 1982 H-3 3210tl40 28901619 STW-291 Water Aug. 1982 I-131 94.612.5 87t15 A-5

}

Table A-1.

(continued)

Concentration in pCi/lb Lab Sample Date TIML Result EPA Result Code Type Collected Analysis 2ac i3a, n=1d STW-292 Water Sept 1982 Sr-89 22.7t3.8 24.518.7 Sr-90 10.910.3 14.5t2.6 STW-296 Water Oct. 1982 Co-60 20.0tl.0 2018.7 Zn-65 32.315.1 24i8.7 Cs-134 15.311.5 19.018.7 Cs-137 21.011.7 20.018.7 STW-297 Water Oct. 1982 H-3 2470120 2560t612 STW-298 Water Oct. 1982 Gross alpha 32130 55124 Gross beta 81.716.1 81i8.7 Sr-89

<2 0

Sr-90 14.110.9 17.212.6 Cs-134

<2 1.818.7 Cs-137 22.710.6 2018.7 Ra-226 13.6i0.3 12.5t3.2 Ra-228 3.911.0 3.610.9 STW-301 Water Nov. 1982 Gross alpha 12.011.0 19.018.7 Gross beta 34.012.7 24.018.7 STW-302 Water Dec. 1982 I-131 40.0i0.0 37.0110 STW-303 Water Dec. 1982 H-3 1940120 1990t345 STW-304 Water Dec. 1982 Ra-226 11.710.6 11.011.7 Ra-228

<3 0

STW-306 Water Jan. 1983 Sr-89 20.0t8.7 29.2 5 Sr-90 21.718.4 17.2 1.5 STW-307 Water Jan. 1983 Gross alpha 29.014.09 29.0113 Gross beta 29.310.6 31.018.7 STM-309 Milk Feb. 1983 Sr-89 35t2.0 37 8.7 Sr-90 13.710.6 1812.6 I-131 55.7 3.2 55110.4 Cs-137 29t1.0 2618.7 Ba-140

<27 0

K-40 1637t5.8 1512 131 A-6

\\

Table A-1.

(continued)

Concentration in pCi/lb Lab Sample Date TIML Result EPA Lesult Code Type Collected Analysis

• 2cc i3o, n=1d STW-310 Water Feb. 1983 H-3 2470*80 2560i612 STW-311 Water March 1983 Ra-226 11.9tl.3 12.7*3.3 Ra-228

<2.7 0

STW-312 Water March 1983 Gross alpha 31.614.59 31*13.4 Gross beta 27.0i2.0 2818.7 STW-313 Water April 1983 H-3 3240i80 3330*627 STW-316 Water May 1983 Gross alpha 9417 64t19.9 Gross beta 133i5 149112.4 Sr-89 1911 24t8.7 Sr-90 1211 13i2.6 Ra-226 7.9i0.4 8.5*2.25 Co-60 30t2 30i8.7 Cs-134 27 2 33i8.7 Cs-137 29t1 2718.7 STW-317 Water May 1983 Sr-89 59.7*2.1 57t8.7 Sr-90 33.7*1.5 3813.3 STW-318f Water May 1983 Gross alpha 12.811.5 11i8.7 Gross beta 49.413.9 5718.7 STM-320 Milk June 1983 Sr-89 2010 25*8.7 Sr-90 10t1 16*2.6 I-131 30i1 30i10.4 Cs-137 5212 47i8.7 K-40 1553157 14861129 STW-321 Water June 1983 H-3 1470189 1529tS83 STW-322 Water June 1983 Ra-226 4.310.2 4.8 1.24 Ra-228

<2.5 0

STW-323 Water July 1983 Gross alpha 311 718.7 Gross beta 2110 2218.7 STW-324 Water August 1983 1-131 13.310.6 14*10.4 I

A-7 l

Table A-1.

(continued)

Concentration in oCi/lb Lab Sample Date TIML Result EPA Result Code Type Collected Analysis i2cc 130, n=1d STAF-326 Air August 1983 Gross beta 42i2 36t8. 7 Filter Sr-90 14t2 10i2.6 Cs-137 19t1 1518.7 STW-328 Water Sept. 1983 Gross alpha 2.310.6 5t8.7 Gross beta 10.7tl.2 918.7 STW-329 Water Sept. 1983 Ra-226 3.Di0.2 3.110.81 Ra-228 3.210.7 2.0i0.52 STW-331 Water Oct. 1983 H-3 1300i30 12101570 STW-335 Water Dec. 1983 I-131 19.6tl.9 20110.4 STW-336 Water Dec. 1983 H-3 28701100 2389i608 STAF-337 Air Nov. 1983 Gross alpha 18.010.2 1918.7 Filter Gross beta 58.611.2 5018.7 Sr-90 10.910.1 1512.6 Cs-137 30.112.5 20i8.7 STW-339 Water Jan. 1984 Sr-89 47.2il.9 3618.7 Sr-90 22.Si4.0 24i2.6 STW-343 Water Feb. 1984 H-3 2487t76 23831607 STM-347 Milk March 1984 I-131 5.311.1 611.6 STW-349 Water March 1984 Ra-226 4.010.2 4.111.06 Ra-228 3.620.3 2.0 0.52 STW-350 Water March 1984 Gross alpha 3.811.1 5 8.7 Gross beta 24.212.0 20i8.7 STW-354 Water April 1984 H-3 3560150 3508 630 STW-355 Water April 1984 Gross alpha 21.014.1 35:15.2 Gross beta 127.814.1 147 12.7 Sr-89 29.3t2.0 2318.7 Sr-90 16.610.7 26 2.6 Ra-226 4.011.0 4.0 1.04 Co-60 32.311.4 30i8.7 Cs-134 33.6t3.1 30 8.7 Cs-137 33.312.2 26 8.7 A-8

lable A-1.

(continued) b Concentration in pCi/l TIML Result EPA Result Lab Sample Date i20c f3a, n=1d Code

. Type Collected Analysis STW-358 Water May 1984 Gross alpha 3.0*0.6 318.7 Gross beta 6.7tl.2 618.7 21t3.1 2518.7 STM-366 Milk June 1984 Sr-89 13i2.0 1712.6 Sr-90 46i5.3 43110.4 I-131 Cs-137 38i4.0 3518.7 15771172 1496t130 K-40 STW-368 Water July 1984 Gross alpha 5.111.1 618.7 Gross beta 11.9i2.4 1318.7 STW-369 Water August 1984 I-131 34.315.0 34.0t10.4 30032253 28171617 STW-370 Water August 1984 H-3 STF-371 Food July 1984 Sr-89 22.0i5.3 25.0t8.7 Sr-90 14.713.1 20.0 2.6 I-131

<172 39.0110.4 Cs-137 24.0*5.3 25.0i8.7 K-40 2503t132 2605t226.0 STAF-372 Air August 1984 Gross alpha 15.3tl.2 1718.7 Gross beta 56.010.0 51 8.7 Filter 14.3*1.2 18t2.4 Sr-90 Cs-137 21.0i2.0 1518.7 STW-375 Water Sept. 1984 Ra-226 5.li0.4 4.911.27 2.2 0.1 2.3 0.60 Ra-228 STW-377 Water Sept. 1984 Gross alpha 3.3 1.2 5.0 8.7 Gross beta 12.7t2.3 16.018.7 l

2860 312 2810 356 STW-379 Water Oct. 1984 H-3 l

<36 4028.7 STW-380 Water Oct. 1984 Cr-51 Co-60 20.3 1.2 20 8.7 15018.1 147 8.7 Zn-65 4718.7

<30 Ru-106 Cs-134 31.3 7.0 31 8.7 Cs-137 26.711.2 24 8.7 A-9 i

Table A-1.

(continued)

Concentration in aci/lb Lab Sample Date TIML Result EPA Result Code Type Collected Analysis

• 2aC i3o, n=1d STM-382 Milk Oct. 1984 Sr-89 15.714.2 2218.7 Sr-90 12.7tl.2 16 2.6 I-131 41.713.1 42110.4 Cs-137 31.3t6.1 32i 8. 7 K-40 1447i66 1517*131 STW-384 Water Oct. 1984 Gross alpha 9.7tl.2 14i8.7 (Blind)

Sample A Ra-226 3.310.2 3.0i0.8 Ra-228 3.4tl.6 2.110.5 Uranium nae 5t10.4 Sample 8 Gross beta 48.315.0 6418.7 Sr-89 10.714.6 1118.7 Sr-90 7.3tl.2 12i2.6 Co-60 16.311.2 1418.7 Cs-134

<2 Zi8.7 Cs-137 16.7*1.2 1418.7 STAF-387 Air Nov. 1984 Gross alpha 18.711.2 15i8.7 Filter Gross beta 59.015.3 5218.7 Sr-89 18.3tl.2 21i2.6 Cs-137 10.311.2 1018.7 STW-388 Water Dec. 1984 I-131 28.012.0 36i10.4 STW-389 Water Dec. 1984 H-3 3583t110 3182i624 STW-391 Water Dec. 1984 Ra-226 8.4tl.7 8.6*2.2 Ra-228 3.110.2 4.lil.1 STW-392 Water Jan. 1985 Sr-89

<3.0 3.018.7 Sr-90 27.315.2 30.0*2.6 STW-393 Water Jan. 1985 Gross alpha 3.311.2 5 8.7 Gross beta 17.3i3.0 1518.7 STS-395 Food Jan. 1985 Sr-89 25.316.4 34.015.0 Sr-90 27.018.8 26.0t1.5 1-131 38.012.0 35.016.0 Cs-137 32.712.4 29.015.0 K-40 1410i212 13821120 A-10

{

O Table A-1.

(continued)

Concentration in pCi/lb Lab Sample Date TIML Result EPA tesult Code Type Collected Analysis

• 2 c i3, n=1d STW-397 Water Feb. 1985 Cr-51

<29 48i8.7 Co-60 21.3t3.0 20t8.7 Zn-65 53.7t5.0 55t8.7 Ru-106

<23 25i8.7 Cs-134 32.3tl.2 35i8.7 Cs-137 25.3i3.0 25t8.7 STW-398 Water Feb. 1985 H-3 38691319 3796t634 STW-400 Milk March 1985 I-131 7.3i2.4 9.010.9 STW-402 Water March 1985 Ra-226 4.610.6,

5.0 1.3 Ra-228

<0;8 9.0t2.3 Reanalysis Ra-228 9.0t0.4 STW-404 Water March 1985 Gross alpha 4.7i2.3 6i8.7 Gross beta 11.311.2 15i8.7 STW-405 Air March 1985 Gross alpha 9.3tl.0 10.0t8.7 Filter Gross beta 42.0il.1 36.0t8.7 Sr-90 13.3tl.0 15.0 2.6 Cs-137 6.3tl.0 6.018.7 STW-407 Water April 1985 I-131 8.0t0. 0 7.Sil.3 STW-408 Water April 1985 H-3 3399t150 35591630 l

STW-409 Water April 1985 (811nd)

Gross alpha 29.7tl.8 32.0t5.0 Sagle A Ra-226 4.410.2 4.110.6 Ra-228 nae 6.210.9 Uranium nae 7.016.0 Sample B Gross beta 74.3til.8 72.015.0 Sr-89 12.317.6 10.015.0 Sr-90 14.7t2.4 15.0tl.5 Co-60 14.7t2.4 15.015.0 r

1 Cs-134 12.012.0 15.015.0 l

Cs-137 14.0t2.0 12.015.0 l

A-11

4 Table A-1.

(continued)

Concentration in pCi/lb Lab Sample Date TIML Result EPA Result Code Type Collected Analysis t2aC t3a, n=1d STW-413 Water May 1985 Sr-89 36.0il2.4 39.0i5.0 Sr-90 14.314.2 15.0tl.5 STW-414 Water May 1985 Gross alpha 8.3i4.1 12.0i5.0 Gross beta 8.7tl.2 11.025.0 STW-416 Water June 1985 Cr-51 44.7i6.0 44.0i5.0 Co-60 14.3tl.2 14.0t5.0 Zn-65 50.317.0 47.0i5.0 Ru-106 55.315.8 62.015.0 Cs-134 32.7tl.2 35.0i5.0 Cs-137 22.7t2.4 20.0i5.0 STW-418 Water June 1985 H-3 2446i132 2416t351 a Results obtained by Teledyne Isotopes Midwest Laboratory as a participant in the environmental sagle crosscheck program operated by the Intercomparison and Calibration Section, Quality Assurance Branch, Environmental Monitoring and Support Laboratory, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, (EPA), Las Vegas,

Nevada, b All results are in pCi/1, except for elemental potassium (K) data, which are in ag/1; air filter sagles, which are in pCl/ filter; and food, which is in pCi/kg.

Unless otherwise indicated, the TIML results are given as the mean t2 standard C

deviations for three determinaticos.

d USEPA results are presented as the known values t control limits of 30 for

• n=1.

NA = Not analyzed.

Analyzed but not reported to the EPA.

9 Results after calculations corrected (error in calculations when reported to EPA).

l A-12 i

I

4 Table A-2.

Crosscheck program results, thermoluminescent dosimeters (TLDs).

mR Teledyne Average 12a d Lab TLD Result Known (all Code Type Measurement 120a Value participants) 2nd International Intercouparisonb CaF :Mn Gaasna-Fleid 17.011.9 17.lc 16.417.7 115-2b 2

Bulb Gaassa-Lab 20.814.1 21.3C 18.8t7.6 3rd International Intercomparisone CaF :Mn Gansna-Field 30.713.2 34.914.8f 31.513.0 115-3e 2

hlb 4

Gaauna-Lab 89.616.4 91.7tl4.6f 86.2124.0 w

4th International Intercomparison9 CaF :Mn Gaauna-Fleid 14.111.1 14.lil.4f 16.019.0 115-49 2

Bulb Gaassa-Lab (Low) 9.311.3 12.212.4f 12.017.6 Gaauna-Lab (High) 40.411.4 45.819.2f 43.9113.2 Sth International Intercouparisonb CaF :Mn Gaauna-Field 31.411.8 30.016.0I 30.2114.6 ll5-SAh 2

Bulb Gansna-Lab 77.415.8 75.217.61 75.8140.4 at beginning Gaauna-Lab 96.615.8 88.418.81 90.7131.2 at the end

Table A-2.

(Continued) mR Teledyne Average i 2a d Lab TLD Result Known (all Code Type Measurement 12ba Value participants)

II5-5Bh LIF-100 Gamma-Field 30.314.8 30.0161 30.2114.6 Chips Gamma-Lab 81.117.4 75.217.61 75.8140.4 at beginning Ganna-Lab 85.4111.7 88.418.81 90.7131.2 at the end y

a Lab result given is the mean 12 standard deviations of three determinations.

g Second International Intercomparison of Environmental Dostmeters conducted in April of 1976 by the Health b

and Safety Laboratory (GASL), New York, New York, and the School of Public Health of the University of Texas, Houston, Texas.

c Value determined by sponsor of the intercomparison using continuously operated pressurized ion chamber.

d Mean 12 standard deviations of results obtained by all laboratories participating in the program.

e Third International Intercomparison of Environmental Dosimeters conducted in summer of 1977 by Oak Ridge National Laboratory and the School of Pubite Health of the University of Texas, Houston, Texas.

f Value 12 standard deviations as determined by sponsor of the intercomparison using continuously operated pressurized ion chamber.

9 Fourth International Intercomparison of Environmental Dosimeters conducted in summer of 1979 by the School of Pubile Health of the University of Texas Houston, Texas.

h Fifth International Intercomparison of Environmental Dosimeter conducted in fall of 1980 at Idaho Falls, Idaho and sponsored by the School of Public Health of the University of Texas Houston, Texas and Environmental Measurements Laboratory, New York, New York, U.S. Department of Energy.

I Value determined by sponsor of the intercomparison using continuously operated pressurized ion chamber.

l

O Appendix 8 Data Reporting Conventions B-1

Data Reporting. Conventions 1.0.

All activities are decay corrected to collection time.

2.0.

Single Measurements 1

Each single measurement is reported as follows:

xis where x = value of the measurement; s = 2a counting uncertainty (corresponding to the 95% confidence level).

In cases where the activity is found to be below the lower limit of detection L it is reported as

<L.

where L = is the lower limit of detection based on 4.66 uncertainty for a background sample.

3.0.

Duolicate Analyses 3.1.

Individual results:

x1 t s1 x2 2 52 Reported result:

xis where x = (1/2) (x1 + x2) s=(1/2)fs2+s2 3.2.

Individual results:

<L1

<L2 Reported result:

<L where L = lower of L1 and L2 3.3.

Individual results:

xis

<L Recorted result:

x i s if x > L;

<L otherwise l

l l

I B-2 1

L

s e

4.0.

Comoutation of Averages and Standard Deviations 4.1 Averages and standard deviations listed in the tables are computed from all of the individual measurements over the period averaged; for example, an annual standard deviation would not be the average of quarterly standard deviations.

The average x and standard deviations of a set of n numbers x1, x2,... x are defined n

as follows:

Y=hIx L(*'*I2 s=

n-1 4.2 Values below the highest lower limit of detection are not included in the avera58-4.3 If all of the values in the averaging group are less than the highest LLD, the highest LLD is reported.

4.4 If all but one of the values are less than the highest LLD, the single value x and associated two sigma error is reported.

4.5. In rounding off, the following rules are followed:

4.5.1. If the figure following those to be retained is less than 5, the figure is dropped, and the retained figures are kept unchanged.

As an example,11.443 is rounded off to 11.44.

4.5.2 If the figure following those to be retained is greater than 5, the figure is dropped, and the last retained figure is raised by 1.

As an example,11.446 is rounded off to 11.45.

4.5.3. If'the f.igure following those to be retained is 5, and if there are no figures other than zeros beyond the five, the figure 5 is dropped, and the last-place figure retained is increased by one if it is an odd number or it is kept unchanged if an even number.

As an example, 11.435 is rounded off to 11.44, while 11.425 is rounded off to 11.42.

B-3

e

, g

-e

-- -+

+

.~~-*-e

-= =. - = +

a g

b it l

f i.

4 r.

I' g,#*p.s

'l P

6[

k,f.-'

l

~_

e*4 a j e

+ ". =-

6

% %~~-

I l

e w s

,f*

t-r l

% h s " p*'"*

. g EP" N

~

..e o

q#

?

s)

~ h-w-i k

• -- --. ' *y,',f

,A, I

>ej

- -.. ~ + -

5 w1

• w t

o 4,

h',

. ; r.;

g'-

4

'go

', a [ *

'7., - -

. m 5 *

- i c

. 4.5 4

i

.. k.

}

, Am= O

O g

h

, EJ

==~~

. g= N

. y%,;

<I

, h e.4

-1*

• .j' I

'e (y e '( '. ~ #

E

<4 ffg

)md". #

s i

b.

--..s.,,,

4 i

)

.o&*' -- "

~

,o y

s b

k' w

e r

J i

4, 4,

g i

t *

• ' W H.-

- L*a T" M 3

". -.. +

I-I,1 w-a g*

[.$

l,;'

. i)

,A,......

L-,

I*

I1

,V

1. ~

p.

t

. t

+ '.

,3 6 I o

• ~

I*g b(

. 'j

, ~ - *. * +..

g r

i.-

q y-7

~*

c.

4 y)

f. *'* *s s

'g 6

O s

a, 'N i

e 4,

3. e -

+-

a m * ?*+.e y.

4 F *)

r u,-

y /. x A.

e.

v,,

• /,1

, _ _ ~..

t 5

68 8 e b *

"V I

I I

I I

L

9

• D (D\\

ea O

s %

O

~

.a

'IW.

p*.~^~

Q o

s

- ~

a.

~.

,~ x-,

w c2 1

4

(' %w g

g1

-c-==.x *h ic.

1 99 3

g.. -g,gg -> ""'

b.=

% (~

m

,M

(",..

~_ ~

'3 I

H 4

4 h

_ TC%

(1,1 *A, m 4>N *..

p~

N

~-

s O E, a

k, L. N 4

- i.

hr 5 3'*

s, Q1' '

,~1' Q 0

4 b dy,

. g_.

' =., ',s r,a g g,._-~ w

-r.

- m' s,n ~.

<- nc ' %

L. g W

q g.

,... p '-

a w

r

~[. ]

~*

ei e*.

4, r9

)y L

^ _.

s.

~, :, Q

(,) '... A

/,h s-

• i ;~;

0 s it)

,%_M'^*

i Tr3

I.

r3

.;; 7 s..

I

(,*

k-

• 9- *. ~ ~.

1

~h t.

...w,,

.L}

-f t.,j c,..

p%

~

,t y v, L _l N. ? b 3_ %;,s"

. s

{ *.. f2 Q

'*** % y-.

..,.g

- s t.

a r.

-kI 1

-' Q s

L *t.* :

Y*",.-

t t

.yl g4

.(b a

g-

)>

N

.I W",'...d '

• e.

, c, 4)

\\-

t

}

.ng

% g. >

.4-J

==

s ae 4 s

=

L [, j -

+V+ ~ -

in

%w In

'D

- na

<{

i..

Qe se

'me

~ - ~ ~.,

m m.

4,h 3 _ _ 7 _...,..- _ 3.-... y _. y _.

3

-(

7 N

O u) u'a ce uT

(>

u)

Q

.s

-t~

rr r n '.

tJ

?l r-r Co Q

1 O

a.'.

0 0

0 C/

O O

U Y

d./

%.i

$9

{,)

{

.h d

A

<D l

<D l

w s,-

\\'

e O

g t,

.m..

--*=N'f~

LL:

p f ""~~,,

W~

?.e Fg*.

s.a..

g w

(

I h

C**:.[-~

~

--.-..__;,c'..__

.1 4

ee.

Wu ft,;,-..

g%

~

L.

a' 5

_. Q

~.- - a -

aC u)

.. :-n.

s

-l

.3 k.,

I N

%-~%

o.

(, ' '/-

<% L

' ' *1 y -)[, '

J h

s it 1'

-- Eq

>q d b'

+

t:n-

'T

_g

s.,. "

,., t.)

-r Cb

[.r # Id,%

~}% s O..

LM, p jDJ

• =.

-e'

i ID,I,)

$~'

f t

s g,.

s'*.

I le l L' O

e.. [J c's.> -

J, e

n

>aW t-4 4

L: [.,%

~r

~

3, L4

^ '-

+..

Lf4 i,_',..

• 9, i, i 3

f, )

..[4 q

A._~..~

', b*

' N,.

,.'., t

,.s

__, w ~~

1*'

I, f.) f I i

~*

r~ A wn.~ x - '

.i j

., nI

---.. M

,'.'

• L, ;

,4-p T.

• s a

r p

w i

'8

• tg

'.)

~ ~ 4

^i p..

..I u_N-4 i,,,,

l*k

~ p

-- *"~

u"*e.,

. Q fh f**"?.

,.4 L

A a

N 3 -. ---~.3.e--

7~~

,w-.

o.--,.

y.

t.

a.

LJ ')

y.

ea T

re F *.

( j

'l

.~r r.L C,.

t.

. ~.,

e.. s C.

~;

s J. <

O 6,

6 <

'D

!D N

OJ$N+o

-g h

.p

--W*' U%

r

.p%

3

.y b

- y

,[,e, IM s q 0

'.e 4

.^s

% - 5b.%

6,.

]

u

.- __..g {f "

~ O V ~ y_

. Q..

~,.g.

l

-t %

A+ ' '

W 9 E9 k-r

• .. 3 -- %

-../

i

~M)

.'s M

6-4 kQ 3

..g 4

YW LJ 4;

l '-

e q VG

% D.

b

.- a 9y

(, _.Q~-

E.)

ys w,_ -_

~

~,.

~)

G

, Q k o.)

• w,- *,%. *'

~.>

t s>3 h., g

's,,r j gs=,. y

.t p

4.-

t,;

A, I(1

~l

- J 4

>J

• ,n w

s y

2 "j-ic N

' O., ' ?

w' T,. L2

. P-- f%,

3-F*t

<. L1 T

m3

..c-u, k,; r l< J

{ I')

• /

i

(

q, y ---.

_-___r_

. 6

{g g

"7 W %

8 b

.)

• e

~

ge*,y, t__",

f fg '

.y r

mo

-- r..

Y i,j L; m.

tq La

>c 4 h;J g

rb I

q > '.. 'e.

CU... -

4

=

s l4.t,

y" ;,

g b

h'g

• y N

k.,

~,

S E

e cr. - __ _.

- -- ~~ ~,r,-

k. L,.

.t2

• 4*

' Id

.s t lq

~

+-

g-,w-

.i r==.)

...-.3

.-...g--...q

._p q-k.)

t i:e

+=

,[ f u *=

s',

is '-

a,.*,

i1 '

(,#

be '

t W'e

.j e

r. fe l3

.w a,

4..,

a e

t.4.

,e-0.

/

$, d

,/

. I b

L.4 a

t

r

• a

.D (D

'N C*J O

s C'

t S

-- L4 o

/

c

-O L s1

/'

z

, c.

i l fI l

w v~

[Q lO e

O fI i

\\

ta I

g[

.7 t1 LC I

C au i N

d v

p' L

Ol

, **,/

qN %

4<

i

/~ 4 6.s

/

l - :

g m.

'- 6 gg

\\,' ;\\,

(

wg m 7 k,)

2

~

.s f*

• 4

' I t.,,'

• :q Qg

~.)

t s)

',, r,h d j/

i s 'i la -

- W 3 L.j

/ *f k-t' 8

w, l.

. k.]

c.

6,

{N C l

-)

<D i

n, t, L'

g 4

's, g

'D

'A

.L 1

k..[,J O

L1

.L

~,

a 3-

.1 ilj J.

u #t

~

e

,#-. L j?

. - [, n'

'J y l 2

i 3 g 4

[

t Th h

' I b]

i

~

y 4

k, m,

's i

/

'N s,

N

\\

{

t.

[

a i;

l

<' /

- r,

,/

)

5 ga

,I

- a u-.

/

i l

t l

--..p--

r----

g

.y

.y a,

C t

ci 3

~

~

=

. o G

Q N

04 ON t,

i1

.- w O

u 1

f

- O Z

LJ.E l

' \\ t !

7'

~I l

\\ l

.-g_

y

-- g l

%\\

o 4

t sa*

I tt.3 i

%l %

I Ll.

( r. ;l -

C r-W Q -L, hw 7

g' Q

/,-

Cll x

, :v

~

r Q

,f','

3<')l

?s' o Ih,R.;..

\\

,1, s

w,.,

m$

-O, ' -

m a'x

' \\ s.,

.~

% q ws m

1 33 wa p; ;,;

lg J g

.3 ll x.,

, ',/

L I

%,)

Q f ':

'f

' I

, 3 y' fi <

r L '.

r -'

f

., - ".s]

$41tD t- - 2 n.

. (g 4

Q a

i e ~

P T, N\\.,

a. a.

q

)-

~

-.k.t

\\

sI

}-I g

g

,,4 TE l

4

• • l G

)

i I '1

',ff*

/,

f i

i p

'~]

o gf lh.

[//

1

1. ]

1p-l. a

% 4 a

'g\\

/

A\\

Y,I l

h Lt.

t>

+-

a

[

Ii b-

/

c 4 '.e 71.

- ta

/ l<.

l/:lI

~

i l

r y

4 0,-

1 4

a.

-r

<s

.v e

ca y

~

O I

()

([t tO N

OJ O

x~

q',

T

.. _ y u

f a

l i

f 2

fl

- O

".C I

/

I:

m M

<l' l

'l

/

i o

6-.

L. ~n t e ',

j

.g

. g

.l O

fl

r. v j \\

.o" l

Ll. d.

s',

/

3.

W LL l 8'

".. '. * ['

<A1 60 (Lj C

4 %

W

//.-

gia-p%

//

Q e'y r

Nq t

o<1 t

.3 u,[ D Q

h

-- O Q < ].

<4 C*

N j k s$, '

I N

 %,s...~,.

4, y q

-n k

W I

3 %

gD3'-

1'--

. 5.

I D

l

~,

i' L;

' i

{,;4 qg 8 44 ni j

..i,i q

a.

t d

m. J E

.3 r

• P'-

.y

[

e ** w

,k

^

g i t,

g-

'4-I

.4 s.

y g

,b

'h

[

2 u

L-1 i

l -

u.

I, N

Oc.;

i so a :

I i

t

/\\

L

//j ' \\.

4 Q'

s I

1 I

if

's

'4

- s a

c

. './

3 g.

3 p

~'

l+3 O

a 4r, I^1 4

.\\

i

~

1 %-

l y-

\\. t.;.

i*

\\

\\.,,

l l

I j %,

(h I 2

e-c3

/

j n

/

V~

e

,,o

'i l ~/

5-N)

I WI,td ju

-J e

o l

r.'

/ /'

/r i

g f' [,1 y

j

,. d C $ _I _. - _.,

.g 7

I u

-t

'4 a ',

-J l'

N

j

/-

P 3

O

'D

'D x

bd O

o

-t-el [>.

~

O

..x '

L>

'q, ge 4

N

(

i

• m

[G

• 0

,A b,,.

i p

a q

. g' o

p 1

s i

s**

(

v-s L.J i

/

.A y

i4

/

- g

-)l o

t-'

~

=

\\,1 l

y

'1 h r

'l

4 m',

.- m(

g<.

w m....e s

e* t s i

q '-

s q*,

/

N t, g

~

J 51, fy*;

s.

j'

-3

,, g

,g,

,,, q a, e

• • 9

-3

~

t

, (q 8

f6

./

~

4 ".3' LQ

(

3

' >t f:)

1 t,

iD s. ),' ' l. ]

.a

,$ (3 g

s

' S. L t-e-

=

'E

)

i6 s

g

(.

, a

'y.

y

.T.j 5

,O

-l ss s

1 I' '9 e

'1 [

. ~ -

('

(.I 3

-;d j ',\\,

., {,. ;

g

s.,,

g

(

m.

~.

i

(

L t t,.

I

'e g

n r.

)'

g t

1. 'd e,

[

6Y, b

e

,e I

L.

4 i

, 7,o,'.

~

t

\\

, / l, y

Ty pq H 9'

&TN$O I

,7 r,,

~ J

~

e

T t

'O fD N

OJ Q

O N

l

• t i

- kl s

O O

(O Y

G

~-

r k1 N

w

{

)

-- O l

l O

N i

e

)

i

,&J s

d

,f y

-- Li

.I t

f ys

' /

L)[i E.

f

[.

C.q l

-- h 3

I I

bi "4 I

s,

- \\

\\

s i

\\

.( 1 e

s N

'\\

y l,4 4

J

~-~~.

c.

.. m Q N'

. k

~'

g t.2 l

Tg l

'.i

's 0,

6 d.h t

Y

== 4

- {:.

(.

l

,t

.d

]

y h ;,7 q h *,, "

"I c,

o[t e

ie.

l i

mm t

laa

{

.s

.a t 4

'd

• g j

i

,1 7

w me

(% b &*

l

) -l t

c r;

'.,J l

-F a.

• ),

.s k.

t 8

-F l

.V, k'i

.t t 1..,

j f

-- 4 o

b.

P ia j

u.

Q u;

c Q

6 k

[

f g

VJ l

./

l

)

L p. _.,_ _ _ 7 _,....,. _, __ y _..,_ m,

7_ -

t:,

.)

L e.

O O

C

..'s

.. )

C.e

.J s

.)

.?

C.

d.

r. ~. e de C.

T-

'Q f

• t tria C4 r-v--

O' t

a

![,

<D s.

OJ e

t

'~

u L'

'.$)

A

-- 11 1

/

a f

/

{

I/]

I

~ 9

\\

L.1 N

(

s a

N';

s

)

GI

. 1

-- o u.

e T

(

o to 4

%.a:

l

/

r,

.2

-- tw to 6.

i%

i 'o f.

q'

,li

-- w d_

i r

W c<

i e

N s'

/k Q

%)A c*

/ \\

'O. 1

/

c r,

a d

k-b-w gl

,_i ;,

f 6

• 4

~

,/.

p4

,/

• 9

/

/

' sW

/

- >N

/

..i

4 j [s U

,- :)

k, t,,

\\,

l bI L.

4'#

J j.'

=,

- 4 f) 5 --

6..., y' Q

\\

j c

~

N c.a o

l (J o L' E4 4,

- l t

l

, o la o

..a s

',4

.s

.l I - \\

{

./'/

.:-ai

'n ;..

.)

c5 j

i e%

!' s /

/

(j' s

. i 3

~

r,'*b, )

Y.

,/

4L l

f e

s it

')

'F l 3

/

t Q ;. //'s j

6, u.

F i ],

• ,)

'. C

/

q. 's,.

i m

s o

6

._..,s. s. -

I,;,,...,

o

~.,

~.

j

-. l ' r, i

r-a I

hN l

c'[d k

p,.-[', '

4 l

(

-e.,

.\\.

/

).

4--

d)

E.

/

"' ti !

g

[ s, /

I

'A y

t..

.s l

l N

i t\\

x.

r a

2 -

7-i

(-

2 g- -

r l

r.

.V u '*e

• f' l -

4 sJ Cr

- I d.

e Q

6 6

/-

20/

C 4

5 0

,g E

D D

V 5

,F 0

1 1

m1 l_

[a T

9 5

,g C

F 2

O E

il L4 T

ET 2 ff E

.- A P

U4

,_S 5

,t E

F4

%u R S

• c E

?i L

?.a B e

G E

r.s U 2

, g U

C a r.r - K A

Y

?s.2 EN 'L

,g U

L L

4 r

t i.

I f

e EC C

?... CP F:.

._ C T

T 7

r. _

I N

A3 O

1 l

S e

q.. L -

d l

V C

4-J S

F '-

C O

AE

? l R iN '-

7 IT lcE N

E A

rO

'l C'

C

)

.tv -

C '

B?

K 3

s

,_ A C.

• U P

l

\\.

• O

,, v H.

..,. C

• O O

nJ. __

B F

t 5

4t 3

t Pd C

~

9;1 E

E E

A yt I

C 1

O L

H E

,I A

.I ll -

e i.

7 5

4 Ib G

1 C

P m

1

' O O h

@N-NO u'>

N

+

1 o

- O II

/

- O l

u, l

• l H

] ]

~Z i

- 3 H

- 7 1

l

~

Z t

U

,o J ta.,

g

_. 4

- W D

\\

- m Z

t w

E Q,

- T

.n

~

s v

UM 3

3I

/

Cr) l (g'

- o

-a o <3

/

s 1

so f

IT. gl4 j

/

N s

Q\\

- to

.i

• J l

'*G N w

- O O,4 <34 g

[]

[k f.

i N.,

-4 t, s

-r C; 1

g

,')

b [,

s 1

p.

sn i r N.

w, s<3 (.4 j

ca 4

O 15!.

m s

i V

<o o.

-4:

r,a n

- a p-tj-(,, fel N ss4.NA

-W 4

OO n.

t M.s t-fbA4 s

i

&l m (3

't, 6'

4 i

t * /..

2";

-t. t i.

a

• []

s

. 4.,i 1

L t.

1

/

&( 3 iN

/ l,

- 1 6 (3 4

1

[

~ W 2;

i

\\

^

>,. y s

n e

o e 7'

- r.

i 6[

~

1

- o D

4

{

(

- 4

-J 1,

$ U F-d o

1 o

j i :

t 1

I

- O

/

y j

i

- =

p a

O us, 6_.

g3 C

u)

O

~ "

o

,o o

p c_

t.D NOf Q

u)

.o

• t'

~ k O

~ U

/

O l.

/

f u,

k Q

q'

C x

~ ]

b 5

N

's tt

~ )\\ j

~

.tr l

' 1 u

- n 4 (t,

~ (L

!!.y g

ta s

(/',

)*,*

l m

~

.c

r.

I j

.2

., ~

• 2 j

k.

'ill j

\\

I

,n A

7

]

4 U.)

s

1.,

l

. 93 0< T r

Qj %

f la lI

'n

• *, kN d

l q,,.

t,

- en

%,. * ~ d)~

t o

~

p

^ ','

,,f 7 ' 3 f,,

o.-

/ /[

'*l

/'[j /

t Ch4 j

'.<f J

J

~t.'

If,wQQ I

, 4-

,j W.' :

a I* )

f, r,,

er y'

o ::

.]g g 6.j

'Q

.o T:

e W Q (

f A'#':.N s

C 'a j

( [)'

n j v.{.

>r]'

l

'l 6w ]

i

[3.

l

, ;./ [

[ I,],

r

.o

• L s.sM 7.;

/

[,1.,

f.

"/.

,/ f ', '

'q

?'

i

. w't j

, +.

%..../

7, '\\

. 3 6

f* )

's I

s, I

s-s x I

t

\\.

l 4

6q

\\

M (m)

/

G l

- 3 i

Q' l

3

~ 4-

'~ =

O

\\

1 e

u '.

y) s J_

~

l w..,

o C 'J c.;

<~

(L L

j

=

.et O g f,0 N

N W

O g

W

/

~

~

/l l

a>

\\

s.

- Z s

- D p

- n L

se,

- y Ld

\\

G aw h,

- c) a

-w s-

- W 3s

- y !

)

,e

.r-i C

_9 1

{

a

)

- L g e' Q

- D 0'3 CL I*

i s

- O

<4

. o

- Ll.

o <I m

i

- W t

M IO '

N

. O i

1

- 4 m

1 i

.,, (i,,

.e

/

w

-s th -r, i

u 4

D k'1 t

./

Oh!

/.1

<8 DM M W, Ir1 i

t a>

~,

4 w, b-1 G.

m; M (, (73 Ts }

\\

- O n i

- U O Ti OO 1

C3 W,

\\.

<3 f-r; CL $ t3 I,

1 t

y

, y

'2 "_,

• ~i

~ -

r-

,E ~E g 3 '.

N i

kr 1

L ta' r,

6g

,.+..

a.

i

[

g. #'/

1 I,

-4

/"

I t

- D O.

s

'i

~*

O

... _,~~~~ ~ :;

a g

.x..

\\'

Q><

O N

g

~.;',\\.,.

j o i i

.-d

_a

,}

_ ~

g1

- - o

- o t

C.

/.-

- Q O__

~

C C

Q a

m Q

4,O ro cJ

%D l-

-..- o

(D

<D

's.

OJ O

uS

\\+

-s O

- o

/j o,

o

- O l

f-

}

- 3 p.-

o s.

LL

\\'

l v'

l

- t LJ

- e

.a w.

- it l

- U 2-

- m r

l)

(d

-r

=n

- e sj D')

5

'~

Eq gg?',

4

~~

e.

o a l

[

n cp{(

- a.

o q!

"5 l

tu N ie T @ Il e\\ ',k

- m s.

I k

N.

2 I

rn :c,

4

~

.< s c

s

!?,

i

~:-'

.a

+ 2 E'=

to i

>%' CN l

\\

3

..S u)

Q

4 A

/

i

-e c

- r..

lC I

G3 J

b t'-

M -i Ifjl'ro

,,* t rej i

\\

\\

\\

~ w 0 7-A

\\'

m

[h E g

t..

q.

l

\\.).4.s

't 4

4s Ng m r,3 c

s, I

ll

+

y a sii 1

-i n

h [;e

~

h( 3i

~

j i $

tL h

k

~

f A L-:

.C i)

N*1

%l

~ ~*

y

~

..r h

~

4 j

-3 Q

• C,

.J

~4 s'

y-

.p

>%.4

<3 i

U i

C)

- e

~

r e3 O

O U ')

O US O

~<

j O

ro ea c1 i

e l

a-q

[

L Y

~

==e,

'D.

T.

i N

NO V)

N o

+

i

-- w o-l

- o

- n I

- O i

.j

- u) j

<o 1l>

-Z

\\

- D H

d.

- t LU f

4)

_i

.. L

- td I

t

- 7 tal

- w 2

,/

- c l]

7. <

Z-Z

.~ 5, 9

LQ.

l

'g

- ro

\\

2) w

-- a.

l

\\

- td 1

-M to ?

- n

\\

% m-i

)

y Q' f.)Q t

- n

{

- o i

V1

-Z

{f t. Q.z 4 l

- O e

us

' ) b.

H tu

,-f.

- e3 4

C A

O kl

&~., b r Q%

l

.n s cs c.

.. i

,rn e

. to z

a

{.g n

'..,l'

.m

~.

- e;

. n C

03 O

%mt.

V q m tj L

l

-s

+

- - - ~

.s >

r.1 3

)

1 4

I t

/ ~)

k s

4.

-- d.

e I

- ta l N

i 7) t.

1. m

- o O

63 j

D i

~

.w q

. {.

. o c

g 2.5 8

r 1

- Q I

- o

- O

- c g

1 3

3 I

c c

a a

t<>

1. 9 CJ C4 N

1 i

I

D/Ild

@M Consumers Power FTICRITY RC'JTI!!G XX

$M M m F5 PumE8FEC a__C Genere; offices: 1945 West Parnall Road, Jackson. MI 49201 * (517) 788 0550

,[-

,-[

April 22, 1986 fni.3n i

1 i

i James G Keppler, Administrator Region III

[

US Nuclear Regulatory Commission l

799 Roosevelt Road l

Glen Ellyn, IL 60137 DOCKET 50-155 - LICENSE DPR BIG ROCK POINT PLANT -

1985 RADIOLOGICAL ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING REPORT Attached is the 1985 Radiological Environmental Monitoring Report for the Big

-l Rock Point Plant. This covers the period January 1 through December 31, 1985 and is submitted in accordance with Technical Specifications section 6.9.2.1.

l l

mu am</

l Brian D Johnson Staff Licensing Engineer l

CC Director, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation l

Director, Office of Inspection and Enforcement NRC Resident Inspector - Big Rock Point Attachment l

APR 2 81986 I

Y' OC0385-0053-NLO4 l

\\

l J

t_.