ML20083J327: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(StriderTol Bot insert)
 
(StriderTol Bot change)
 
Line 16: Line 16:


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:The NRCs Proposal on Use Data for HRA
{{#Wiki_filter:The NRCs Proposal on Use Data for HRA  
- 2020 HRA Data Workshop Roundtable Discussion Jing Xing, PhD.
- 2020 HRA Data Workshop Roundtable Discussion Jing Xing, PhD.
NRC/RES/DRA/HFRB
NRC/RES/DRA/HFRB


Where we were 10 year ago?
Where we were 10 year ago?
(Jings HRA gray box diagram for ACRS in 2011-2018)
2 Why How Why this much not that much Human event HEP (Jings HRA gray box diagram for ACRS in 2011-2018)
Human event Why How                  HEP Why this much not that much 2


Where are we now?
Where are we now?
Data       Data     Data Use in     HRA sources  Analysis  HRA methods    applications ECA -
3 SACADA Halden experiments Other simulation /
SACADA      IDHEAS    IDHEAS-ECA
operational data Literature IDHEAS
* At-power
-DATA Data sources Data Analysis Data Use in HRA methods HRA applications IDHEAS-ECA IDHEAS-G FLEX Expert elicitation IDHEAS-AtPower Cognitive Basis for HRA ECA -
              -DATA Halden
At-power LPSD Crediting FLEX NMSS Others
* IDHEAS-G
* LPSD experiments
* FLEX Expert
* Crediting Other elicitation       FLEX simulation /
operational
* IDHEAS-
* NMSS data                  AtPower Literature
* Cognitive
* Others Basis for HRA 3


Where are we going?
Where are we going?
Data       Data   Data Use in   HRA sources  Analysis HRA methods  applications ECA -
4 SACADA Halden experiments Other simulation /
SACADA      IDHEAS  IDHEAS-ECA At-power
operational data Literature IDHEAS
              -DATA Halden LPSD experiments Crediting Other FLEX simulation /
-DATA Data sources Data Analysis Data Use in HRA methods HRA applications IDHEAS-ECA ECA -
operational                              NMSS data Literature                              Others 4
At-power LPSD Crediting FLEX NMSS Others


What are in IDHEAS-DATA
What are in IDHEAS-DATA 5
* IDHEAS-DATA has 27 tables documenting generalized human error data and empirical evidence.
IDHEAS-DATA has 27 tables documenting generalized human error data and empirical evidence.
* Human error data are generalized to IDHEAS-G CFMs and PIF attributes IDHEAS-DATA Tables Tables 1-5   Environment and situation Table 22 PIF interaction effect PIFs Tables 6-9   System PIFs               Table 23 Time factors Tables 10-14 Personnel PIFs           Table 24 Recovery factors Tables 14-20 Task PIFs                 Table 25 Dependency factors Tables 21     Lowest (nominal) HEPs   Table 26 Main drivers in human events (Empirical evidence for base PIFs)
Human error data are generalized to IDHEAS-G CFMs and PIF attributes IDHEAS-DATA Tables Tables 1-5 Environment and situation PIFs Table 22 PIF interaction effect Tables 6-9 System PIFs Table 23 Time factors Tables 10-14 Personnel PIFs Table 24 Recovery factors Tables 14-20 Task PIFs Table 25 Dependency factors Tables 21 Lowest (nominal) HEPs Table 26 Main drivers in human events (Empirical evidence for base PIFs)
Table 27 No-context human error rates 5
Table 27 No-context human error rates


Where we are in IDHEAS-DATA
Where we are in IDHEAS-DATA 6
* IDHEAS-DATA has 27 tables documenting generalized human error data and empirical evidence on human errors.
IDHEAS-DATA has 27 tables documenting generalized human error data and empirical evidence on human errors.
* Human error data are generalized to IDHEAS-G CFMs and PIF attributes IDHEAS-DATA Tables Tables 1-5   Environment and situation Table 22 PIF interaction effect PIFs Tables 6-9   System PIFs               Table 23 Time factors Tables 10-14 Personnel PIFs           Table 24 Recovery factors Tables 14-20 Task PIFs                 Table 25 Dependency factors Tables 21     Lowest (nominal) HEPs   Table 26 Main drivers in human events (Empirical evidence for base PIFs)
Human error data are generalized to IDHEAS-G CFMs and PIF attributes IDHEAS-DATA Tables Tables 1-5 Environment and situation PIFs Table 22 PIF interaction effect Tables 6-9 System PIFs Table 23 Time factors Tables 10-14 Personnel PIFs Table 24 Recovery factors Tables 14-20 Task PIFs Table 25 Dependency factors Tables 21 Lowest (nominal) HEPs Table 26 Main drivers in human events (Empirical evidence for base PIFs)
Table 27 No-context human error rates 6
Table 27 No-context human error rates


Which areas are missing in IDHEAS-DATA Tables                   Areas Env. PIFs   PIF weights on Team Coordination System PIFs Digit I&C, Equipment and Tools Personnel   Procedures, Training, Work process, PIFs        Organization factors Task PIFs   Information, Familiarity Lowest HEPs Team coordination PIF         Lots of data for analysis interaction Time factors Data for effects of factors ( e.g.
Which areas are missing in IDHEAS-DATA 7
environment) on time needed Recovery     Very limited data Dependency   No data Drivers     Lots of data for analysis           7
Tables Areas Env. PIFs PIF weights on Team Coordination System PIFs Digit I&C, Equipment and Tools Personnel PIFs Procedures, Training, Work process, Organization factors Task PIFs Information, Familiarity Lowest HEPs Team coordination PIF interaction Lots of data for analysis Time factors Data for effects of factors ( e.g.
environment) on time needed Recovery Very limited data Dependency No data Drivers Lots of data for analysis


What we are looking forward to Tables                   Areas             SACADA Halden Others Env. PIFs   PIF weights on Team Coordination
What we are looking forward to 8
                                                              ?
Tables Areas SACADA Halden Others Env. PIFs PIF weights on Team Coordination System PIFs Digit I&C, Equipment and Tools Personnel PIFs Procedures, Training, Work process, Organization factors
System PIFs Digit I&C, Equipment and Tools Personnel   Procedures, Training, Work process, PIFs        Organization factors Task PIFs   Information, Familiarity Lowest HEPs Team coordination PIF         Lots of data for analysis interaction Time factors Data for effects of factors ( e.g.
 
environment) on time needed Recovery     Very limited data Dependency   No data Drivers     Lots of data for analysis                   8
Task PIFs Information, Familiarity
 
Lowest HEPs Team coordination
 
PIF interaction Lots of data for analysis
 
Time factors Data for effects of factors ( e.g.
environment) on time needed
 
Recovery Very limited data
 
Dependency No data
 
Drivers Lots of data for analysis
 
?


The NRCs Proposal on Use Data for HRA Change of context - We means not just the NRC staff, but this broad HRA community
The NRCs Proposal on Use Data for HRA Change of context - We means not just the NRC staff, but this broad HRA community


Mindset on HRA data sharing, exchanging, and using To fill out the gaps - Vision beyond the NRC (Notes from 2020 HRA Data Workshop)
Mindset on HRA data sharing, exchanging, and using
Organization /             Data                     Data           Data Program                source                    analysis        use NRC             All sources of human error Generalization to     IDHEAS-ECA IDHEAS-       data                        IDHEAS-G taxonomy DATA NRC             Operator simulator training
 
* Statistics         IDHEAS-ECA SACADA
To fill out the gaps - Vision beyond the NRC (Notes from 2020 HRA Data Workshop) 11 Organization /
* IDHEAS-DATA Halden
Program Data source Data analysis Data use NRC IDHEAS-DATA All sources of human error data Generalization to IDHEAS-G taxonomy IDHEAS-ECA NRC SACADA Operator simulator training Statistics IDHEAS-DATA IDHEAS-ECA Halden Microtasks Full-scope simulation Statistics Insights HuRex Operator simulator data collection for HRA Statistics Insights HEPs and PIF multipliers Czech Rep.
* Microtasks
Operator simulator data collection for HRA Statistics Insights on PIFs THERP and others INL Microworld Microworld NASA HH&P data Statistics Insights on PIFs
* Statistics
: CREAM, NASA HRA (?)
* Full-scope simulation
UMD BBN Dependency
* Insights HuRex           Operator simulator data
* Statistics         HEPs and PIF collection for HRA
* Insights            multipliers Czech Rep.     Operator simulator data
* Statistics          THERP and collection for HRA
* Insights on PIFs   others INL
* Microworld
* Statistics          CREAM, Microworld
* NASA HH&P data
* Insights on PIFs   NASA HRA (?)
UMD
* BBN             11
* Dependency


HRA Data Proposal - Lets work together IDHEAS-ECA     SACADA Halden HuRex Czech MicroW UMD EPRI, Others, Env. PIFs             __    __    __    __    __  __
HRA Data Proposal - Lets work together 12 IDHEAS-ECA SACADA Halden HuRex Czech MicroW UMD
System PIFs           __    __    __    __    __  __
: EPRI, Others, Env. PIFs System PIFs Personnel PIFs Task PIFs Lowest HEPs PIF interaction Time factors Recovery Dependency Drivers
Personnel             __    __    __    __    __  __
PIFs Task PIFs             __    __    __    __    __  __
Lowest HEPs           __    __    __    __    __  __
PIF interaction       __    __    __    __    __  __
Time factors           __    __    __    __    __  __
Recovery               __    __    __    __    __  __
Dependency             __    __    __    __    __  __
Drivers               __    __    __    __    __
12 __


Where are we going together?
Where are we going together?
Data               Data     Data Use in sources          Analysis  HRA methods Framewrok NPP operation and simulation IDHEAS-ECA NPP human performance IDHEAS-DATA experiments                 Methods and applications Data in other fields of Data in Literature Your own 13
13 NPP operation and simulation IDHEAS-DATA Data sources Data Analysis Framewrok Data Use in HRA methods IDHEAS-ECA Methods and applications of Your own NPP human performance experiments Data in other fields Data in Literature


The Dream-HRA-DATA Data               Data     Data Use in sources            Analysis  HRA methods Framewrok NPP                          IDHEAS-ECA operation and IDHEAS-DATA simulation                        Methods and applications NPP human performance experiments                       of Data in other fields Your Data in Literature own 14}}
The Dream-HRA-DATA 14 NPP operation and simulation IDHEAS-DATA Data sources Data Analysis Framewrok Data Use in HRA methods IDHEAS-ECA Methods and applications of Your own NPP human performance experiments Data in other fields Data in Literature}}

Latest revision as of 05:41, 14 December 2024

Roundtable P2 - NRC
ML20083J327
Person / Time
Issue date: 03/12/2020
From: Jing Xing
Office of Nuclear Regulatory Research
To:
J. Chang
Shared Package
ML20083J304 List:
References
Download: ML20083J327 (14)
v • d • e


Text

The NRCs Proposal on Use Data for HRA

- 2020 HRA Data Workshop Roundtable Discussion Jing Xing, PhD.

NRC/RES/DRA/HFRB

Where we were 10 year ago?

2 Why How Why this much not that much Human event HEP (Jings HRA gray box diagram for ACRS in 2011-2018)

Where are we now?

3 SACADA Halden experiments Other simulation /

operational data Literature IDHEAS

-DATA Data sources Data Analysis Data Use in HRA methods HRA applications IDHEAS-ECA IDHEAS-G FLEX Expert elicitation IDHEAS-AtPower Cognitive Basis for HRA ECA -

At-power LPSD Crediting FLEX NMSS Others

Where are we going?

4 SACADA Halden experiments Other simulation /

operational data Literature IDHEAS

-DATA Data sources Data Analysis Data Use in HRA methods HRA applications IDHEAS-ECA ECA -

At-power LPSD Crediting FLEX NMSS Others

What are in IDHEAS-DATA 5

IDHEAS-DATA has 27 tables documenting generalized human error data and empirical evidence.

Human error data are generalized to IDHEAS-G CFMs and PIF attributes IDHEAS-DATA Tables Tables 1-5 Environment and situation PIFs Table 22 PIF interaction effect Tables 6-9 System PIFs Table 23 Time factors Tables 10-14 Personnel PIFs Table 24 Recovery factors Tables 14-20 Task PIFs Table 25 Dependency factors Tables 21 Lowest (nominal) HEPs Table 26 Main drivers in human events (Empirical evidence for base PIFs)

Table 27 No-context human error rates

Where we are in IDHEAS-DATA 6

IDHEAS-DATA has 27 tables documenting generalized human error data and empirical evidence on human errors.

Human error data are generalized to IDHEAS-G CFMs and PIF attributes IDHEAS-DATA Tables Tables 1-5 Environment and situation PIFs Table 22 PIF interaction effect Tables 6-9 System PIFs Table 23 Time factors Tables 10-14 Personnel PIFs Table 24 Recovery factors Tables 14-20 Task PIFs Table 25 Dependency factors Tables 21 Lowest (nominal) HEPs Table 26 Main drivers in human events (Empirical evidence for base PIFs)

Table 27 No-context human error rates

Which areas are missing in IDHEAS-DATA 7

Tables Areas Env. PIFs PIF weights on Team Coordination System PIFs Digit I&C, Equipment and Tools Personnel PIFs Procedures, Training, Work process, Organization factors Task PIFs Information, Familiarity Lowest HEPs Team coordination PIF interaction Lots of data for analysis Time factors Data for effects of factors ( e.g.

environment) on time needed Recovery Very limited data Dependency No data Drivers Lots of data for analysis

What we are looking forward to 8

Tables Areas SACADA Halden Others Env. PIFs PIF weights on Team Coordination System PIFs Digit I&C, Equipment and Tools Personnel PIFs Procedures, Training, Work process, Organization factors

Task PIFs Information, Familiarity

Lowest HEPs Team coordination

PIF interaction Lots of data for analysis

Time factors Data for effects of factors ( e.g.

environment) on time needed

Recovery Very limited data

Dependency No data

Drivers Lots of data for analysis

?

The NRCs Proposal on Use Data for HRA Change of context - We means not just the NRC staff, but this broad HRA community

Mindset on HRA data sharing, exchanging, and using

To fill out the gaps - Vision beyond the NRC (Notes from 2020 HRA Data Workshop) 11 Organization /

Program Data source Data analysis Data use NRC IDHEAS-DATA All sources of human error data Generalization to IDHEAS-G taxonomy IDHEAS-ECA NRC SACADA Operator simulator training Statistics IDHEAS-DATA IDHEAS-ECA Halden Microtasks Full-scope simulation Statistics Insights HuRex Operator simulator data collection for HRA Statistics Insights HEPs and PIF multipliers Czech Rep.

Operator simulator data collection for HRA Statistics Insights on PIFs THERP and others INL Microworld Microworld NASA HH&P data Statistics Insights on PIFs

CREAM, NASA HRA (?)

UMD BBN Dependency

HRA Data Proposal - Lets work together 12 IDHEAS-ECA SACADA Halden HuRex Czech MicroW UMD

EPRI, Others, Env. PIFs System PIFs Personnel PIFs Task PIFs Lowest HEPs PIF interaction Time factors Recovery Dependency Drivers

Where are we going together?

13 NPP operation and simulation IDHEAS-DATA Data sources Data Analysis Framewrok Data Use in HRA methods IDHEAS-ECA Methods and applications of Your own NPP human performance experiments Data in other fields Data in Literature

The Dream-HRA-DATA 14 NPP operation and simulation IDHEAS-DATA Data sources Data Analysis Framewrok Data Use in HRA methods IDHEAS-ECA Methods and applications of Your own NPP human performance experiments Data in other fields Data in Literature

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20083J327&oldid=4365552"