ML20069B534: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(StriderTol Bot insert)
 
(StriderTol Bot change)
 
(One intermediate revision by the same user not shown)
Line 2: Line 2:
| number = ML20069B534
| number = ML20069B534
| issue date = 11/30/1981
| issue date = 11/30/1981
| title = Rotterdam Drydock Reactor Vessel CRDM Weld Radiography.
| title = Rotterdam Drydock Reactor Vessel CRDM Weld Radiography
| author name =  
| author name =  
| author affiliation = WESTINGHOUSE ELECTRIC COMPANY, DIV OF CBS CORP.
| author affiliation = WESTINGHOUSE ELECTRIC COMPANY, DIV OF CBS CORP.
Line 17: Line 17:


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:}}
{{#Wiki_filter:4 S
t 0
9 $ N* 9,% *)l hMes MS o ge qM g A**9%
g nea em3 1
* kh,
. r e
,l.
g*y9 g
g
{ Qgg g
.O,* t,4 n' O_' O. 2.* 17. %. s'O?10RV 2
~
s
] y' f. ".. " d,. e, '.),) i
^ n e m. e..., ~. ;,..n N'StinC.hCGe= *1="'-3r
.va, e
8112240247 811200 PDR ADOCK 05000413 PDR s
 
i 4
J.-.
i i
J I
,f I
e j
n.' i ~,'
'.b a 2.~<V. : <. " ". i. c n ".
y' r a e. v. v i. r a
#,.1< c er
* 4 c m"
.o' # Nu k a.
^ wa r "..... 0.2.n. v l
u s.
.~
a m
a" ".. a. ^v #. '..L a
: 1. -
r e.w.,2 re *
* 2d 3 1 u l '.*,2. <. m~ q. i, 'e
'.a t' ' i nd i c 3 *w i o". s w a. *..n n~
n.1 c
~
m
.- ma,w 1
t r o _w + s,.
.p..c.. a. ', w.2 s.m l
x..r.]ac.-
3 e.
]
], m-a,..g. u. s. p.
suc t.
2,.,,, n 2
.t~., 3 3
.2 a
.. ~
o-4
' l 1
3 i
., #,.. d 2.
o u,. 4. c - ' n, ' 7 4 l..'.'' ^. f-1.
~,*.,m1
.,~;
a.e.r<s a.c., a,,. e....
.t.. s.,. g, i, r.a s 4.,
r.
3
,i v
.m 3
m 4
s' ass woide
.g. r. e ~,. s. 4 m.y 2.d.
f r. _.3 2.r e,..g i t 2. 3
.u. j %a. ~ y <. g. x.2 d 6.0
.e. 2 2,,. 4 n
.o
.. ~
1
-4 un 2
5 a
1 i
t2 ",./i w. r"'< s On er I-i n a.
-o_ * ",. 4 1 ^ #.
"v - " a.d. # c 2,. i. rn s.
r"-ing.54-4
: s. -
.- i s
~
s 1
-'m.cc#.w b.;:c.
'w=" b n 'tw"".a u a.c.d 'nu
"...a.
. A4
".c ' a d.
'..",u"
=.v~.. a '.T.=~,="..~..=
. ?.
%.~
^~
^
t e i 'a
.. o ".
c.
.2 r. i. #. #. ^ ' 1 7,,v t.,,.... 'ov w f '".. ' '1 1 o #.
-"u'i. m....n.2
~..c u i. ' '. n c. # i %... d a
c i N' ev.. e.c =.r. 2 4,
r.r li,pi G a r.
: i. c /. '.
.a,,2.s/. 2,.f - Ci una.
1 'l '1 svr t) 4 e
e v-g-41 r. 2 m
u ava I
i..
.m g
x f
b^
c n. e.4.,aa a.t i "2. o ".
s
-s
..us2ec"ar..
: p... 1 y wha e _,. s.s i
eqe,* 39
: m..y o 21. :_a
*.g. 3.+.
~2w-2 i
v y
i
.m s.
t 1'
+ g. vo,
'.,p..e.*. 4 u. m-c o....e. w i. i g no k..:c.wn.
o av a 7. u m.~:
"..a 2..' d. #. c -
ch e
a
~
a i
1 a
a
- iv
. i na
: c. a.n. u t. n a g. e..
~u w A,
:w, v a e. 2 n n..a h. n._
:. t. 'c,o.
~. y. =.,1
. n y v. 5. 5 e -. n c z s.m...
m o
a
- u s
A I
l Westinchcusa concurred that varicus radiccrachic/fik c':nditicns were 1
t i
I 3
e.
. a
.,4 s.h n*.cu.r e v, s.3,.
,-e.c n..reA..o c. u..
4 in S. 1C. c-,ADI43n e G O*w A.
- u t
.a t
i-u.
i i
a b
R v^' * ~ a ". d.,'.~a
* ",. " ~ ~ k (#
: 0. *.M. i.
^
: c.. 'D *. 4. C. M.
s O
..o.g e,s.'> g-.,.a r. e.
vV.
s.
s.
w w.
L f tne
,nv c.
e.m w..
.n-e.
r l
f v= c o - w m.
~5. n., p m a
: e. gG~n c.a
.w.. 3))
s-an g.., c. a..r 4,. c 3 nd uud a '4 4 +v,
4..
s i
roy4 y:. a.
i a m s.
i4 3 i
4 t y
4
?
i s
6 wnne od 2.3.s.rg*.4r))v ~ %...
- :.. c y,u., c-1. 3 m e.o u w +.n.a-c. ? K y U N.
-. ' o' a,. es c j n e_ o v a. o u g m.
i2 a m.
~
2c s
u
.w r
. 31 A, 2 1. '. h..C ' " b..
~. w' '. a O.f '. u'' '2
" ',' < " ' I -
p r < W 2.
q 4.,. * =,, w g i g. 2
,. *, 2 :. a
..>va u
o
.a w
..a w
s
- r J
'l. c " *0 n., p c ma r 1 j.,s.ar.c,Aj*4rne. o f As.c.y c
.c.a_r,. +w-i c n i '. 't.
.ger. e e @. 4 r,
* c d. t., g j., 6 2 s
i i
.t 0
>u i w,... ~
v o w.
w
~%a., :: ee.. as v., l' u -
.#.a_ r. a.
; a. a. n+.* *
* ad p.c..
r so s
.. i 1
.i.
2, Decu0,v, an irun1,. ?1
-,/n, i
T/A - Sequoyah -Unit !2 mer sk ~..-.=, w..
v, n a *. s.,
- t 4
s I
1
'n. f sG a a
'O
. n. ; j e 0 7
[
is
~*' 'n i-i i e c..
.a
'f 2f'.#,
,.' v', p-h..
8, e - 3..
. ? m. J a 3. i.
77 v
- 6.
7 5
a"v F,..w.
f.r.- 4 s 39
. I s
u ; C M,., v.,
..ini.
.aiw e.
1' f
.n
., f9&,, a i...
,,-., e,, n,
.'A
* j j' g m...
W.w
_.,m,
.,_,- m, rent-e vww- +- i w
 
. - - ~ -. -.-.-- - - -
4 1
1 1.
b J.
d.
I Duke sewer i!'.cGuire Unit #2 -
i 4
l F.N... io " *.. i '. 31 r,uk s.
O. cw *.
1
.h...y c r.
. q 4., qb,.1. 3 u q : s 37 A.,v a r.t. i c. h O. s.u.o.
u.
3 1
i 6
4 1
The iurry Unit 1 vessel was f abricatsd by RDM, hcwever, the CRCM icusing.
o n. c,, O n,.
. l w.2 7 c e s,2, o s a. ri r e.e s a
%...., w,.., a..m a. s ',/ : #,., w,, r,
i.
A
- w ww ~
~.4.
w wA 3 F
i 1
i l
4
. t i
: s. $ 66: a..,, s, i-w., a
: a. X <, 5. i.,, -
i t
+~w w J,. u v: e,,
.,.4
: n..a 8
.;,.e. 5. y.,..,w, <. _a
: n. 4,,. a :; = a u h a, s
v e s.
.6,
...w i
8 l.
t
~,.... a a.
1 c.
i.
O 2
i 1
i f
4 l
t An action clan f r resolutien of this issue was develcped and -he fol-t 4
1 Icwing -Ecricns wem camaieted.
I.
o re m u
A-n.g- [og y c.r w =w..n.pq
:,. c.y".".C '. h a V " h C O,..'l
~...S '.',
i
: 1..
3.1 7
A,w.t. r.. -.y 1 d y i; inn g. 3 v
.f y
e w
y t.
i l
the affected film was reviewed to ascartain,irrterpretability.
Tne reviews were cerfcrmed by Westinghcuse personnel who are highly i
o i
- ~~ ~ ~~ ~
~ ~ ~
'cuali~ied and excerienced in NDE techniques.
In most cases the fiim exhibited sensitivities such that.significant flaws would be
[
l detec ted. provides a sumary of these reviews.
t
' 2.
A weid acck-uc dualicatinc.' the ccnfic. uraticn of the welds in cues-tien was f abricaced.
The mock-ca was radiogr2 hed using the RCM i
I technicue in ceder to determine the cacabilities of the tachnicue.
i 9
-Informat.cn developed frcm this acck-c3 includes; j
-A.
A "c.17 (.017") cenetrameter placed en the !.0. of the tube P
l (scurce side) can be clearly defined, including the 27 hole.
* k ** O i 4.k Na9 p
I r-f6 2 b $ 9." 5I b e l O.
1 v.e$ k pae$ 3. P m,1.,.** 5 A b
* ?% '?*
JJ
.n
-v4 4 i A**
jt
?n i A k
Q.
ew s 4..r
*. Jg A4
-e >- Q-;, eJ aba V'
s 4
t L
f "s,. p a. ". +. m a,. ?.S f c.
l Zd
., t a
a.
4
+ > -
a v y e, a.
.m
+
q i
I t
t t
W-
- - ~ ~ -
-e
.__., ewe w.-
, r-w w.a r-- ~ r
 
m.
4 4
3.
~ A 1/32" gr:ove (.032")imachined in the I D of'the inconel par-i 4
s
* "e a ' i s A T. = = r 'i,v d i s s-s_. ab '%a
: i. n ' " a.
r _' H i, n_ - r. 's 5 f
i.
'.'.cn o# '."o, h
a i
m 1
)'
'. h 3 '.
_a c. c_ a.'
1 1-A '1/ gn (r. c. g " ) s j _= m
: r. =_.-
.o,. 2_
: 4.,.
s.u_ -+2:nt_s3 2 co.,
.-...r.n o
3..
n
.u
~2 a
2 l '.
{.
the tuce is cleari.v discernible througn a densit.y area of a.52 f
1 4
i.
muu,in one n,c.
.i r
1 f
,i f
i e.
6 L
Th i s i n f vr. ~2. 4. u n ". a.. #. #. i. m s '-.h ' '.h a
_= _ "a n :., u o_ s'.,.. d
: 4. n
* s_. ~ _o
_' w 'i _. # 4 '. a a
o e s 1
1 i
-esulting fred its use) is suf#iciently sensitive to detec any "lar I
: x. 4,a. c.
r_ - o a_.,,. us
'."..a. d_ a s i, n.
e
'hi3 i2 - n e. i
*m
* c.. 's,o' '.h
: r. a s u 'i '. c #.
i
.s a.
~
m l
the RDd #ilm review:wherein acrosity sizes of approximately 1/04" i
i f.n.i.c a s a4
,a 2 -m_
s 2 a r_ _ s_ s_ i. n e -. 2_
i n c.
a nr _2 s.
- o_2,.. a u c. -
i ov m
f i
4,.. '. a_. 3 rc_ F_ _= % 1 =. cn 'mh. e_ =_
i i
7
: y. o l a_.e e, c.r w. h :. c.x. - ;1,
: e. am :i v 3., p'n s wa r. a.
a ---
ou.
t
.nen-occratinc piants were ~ radicc.rach.ed ac.ain in the field by ' des-t i
tinc.houss.
The results of these r,ew radio raphs are acceptable and s
I a
are included in Attachment 1.
1 4
t i
i m a.
. e n
2-na -
.o u b i. t..~ L.a.
sJ +o. '1 i r. =. A._k.,., + u z_ e,
.- a. a_ ~. e r
,v 2 3. 1
<m., n o..
-m e, c 3
.n%. l C s
-e,
; e v, o
o
.. e-i. w - w a s n_ y > e_w a.d.
ho t ee.k p. 3 y c_ e. o - j ] i. ~- ad by l
s i
l 2 r. +. o.
2_
2
#. a. r swa_a2_
u s
4
_ o 4 vw s
mo 4
l I.
uqar : 3 3.r :. C ' '.C
~a a. '. v# # #. #.3
* a_ n *w
#"^^
^ h ' '.
"w ' a_ d. "sf' U F. "-.'..n a
""v"p a r 2 5_ '4.
vu.
iw i
4
<.a m.
a d _ -
s l'
.R f A k 'l am. 3
.A. w. n
.A. n *
# c_ e a_ n Y..
l
. a ra.
v.
i a
+
i
[
t i.
+
_.:nese ac tiCnS SUD3crt tn.e COnClusiCG tn.at GC 51gni 1 cant defect is pres-t li
~
One in the welds under consideration, inis is baseu cn; l
a I
, O ls. UGOY v.'l t
inO 3
ROY w _O O_.
m u. v w.
.) O.
P fD O_
^D
.- i L" ". - f N
-.O..
a a v)f..,)
O
: n. P2 q
_s o
+
i
.e.
v.
o I
u. e m~ u _ e v,... a i '.- 4 y. t. y~
. c_ a/ 3 ],
c.y c.q w i '-.".
4
.n
:.i g t.u 9p,94.u.do ad rn~e
~ +3
> 2-
?-m a
4 us
.e s
w u
a u ?. k - R
#,f* *,*^ b 3 l
N
,,.e._n.m C ', 3_.e ",
hp 3
>y)4 e
s.,.
.,o
.i 3
p
!I e
I I.
3
: 1.. -
5o s j.a. '. a b l a.
d a '. ar. *. d u' - = disc =raikla. i n r e. s h c'.
# i 't m-und O. *t y. n * '6
=
i a
ww 4
us.
i u
fi'm four.d to be intercretable.
This is a total of 721 welds of 723
~
.e2
: d. a-.a v i c.t.e. d..
7ho.. o.m 2, n i. n o. 7 #.i l.m<.
wa r. a.
d =. o~- a.d.
: r. v '. i.
'.a.ro. =...abl =.
4 257,,
.am, j.ia.a.
: s. 3.- s.
v.
n f
.w.a.' e..a y s..,' r.;. ~ a. h. ^ u - 4.,
#il
'.m'- 4, w-h n., 2
.H a c.'w r~a '. '.o
" a.
v'. n - - 2 *. -
s u
s ad
.= b l. a, 'so
: b..^.u s i. e s 3.. o. i n s ' ' '. l =d
: i. n 'Mv. *. h r' rt u. l.'n i. '. 1 e..n.d
#. i. ". a.
=.. =.
in
-a 2
4
: r. rws a. 'amo i' 4'.-
.' r a.
o - a,.
a 'u... c,
', a q r.
i o.
: a.. m n. o,
: o.., 4,
: 9..
j. c.. i, 2.t.o 4.o-n-
n oui 2 2
u.
.~
. r.s. nno. so. -e..r, die %. 2. - b. a. r..
y, a. s'. i. n f.e u s a 'h = <. ""..c l u.d c.d.
'. h.' '. s a f o u
u
,a s
~-
u n. '. a. ' n c".q *. i nu s w #. '."o ^t'. 3 v" d '. '. i. c n.= 1. a. r. i n e, b =.. a = d i.e u
e a
m a g e.
.,. 4.. v-,o of.gn2, en the fclicwing.
^
il T. h. a. -o. s u '.'.c.
'.*.e v a..v m <..a.n s i, v =.= d i. c...s w i. r ~- a v i c. a. s.,e c.
. = d
.n c
herein demonstrate that the manuf acturing processes used by ROM provite a sound we,:a. wnicn is tree or sign 1ricant der.e:ts.
2 2)
Other non-destructive tests performed during f abricatica and n ro.. c. o.-v i c.= i. n. e.. a.. ' '. v^.q
*'v c a. l a.d.
n.o "m o a r. = '.' b i n.
i o-d i.., H.. wa o.
.sv u
W. '! d 4 :d i. v.' *. a 3
*"2-
-s J1
; : s c..n.. s.
.. 2. c. w.,.. 2 2,/,.,. o..,. 4 r n
: e. :i *gja
. va. v a
c ti
-o 1 >.. s-a. c. 'i ui
..~n u '4 s2 a n.
,,.,ee
:.,l iu,,. c :,
.n,.
a 1..a, s.
A
~
u.
r, 4.ne.ns u,,./
a
.a ny,-
a 3,. a.n.e. a n... c:. - + a.
u u... -., n u..,., ~I ; - : -.. o :.=. <. =. n. ;..,,t
:,,.cl a.a ~ =,a. ;6 s
s iy vare.
we,.
a
: c. " = b 'i u o ". a. r '.h a. wors'. ".'es
'No ' d, i r. a., 3 -
u.rc.u m.
: a. -c.o.~ s. wi 'i l. a " = i. n,
-i a
o.
u e3 m.
wouid a three ;. ncn through-wa,il ax;. l r..iaw, or a acu cegree inside
- m, a
s u #. $ c a. -..$'<
ax ' = q d 4.. yc 'O m~ 'r _ a_.r. "e
'.h.. o u c k.. 'mh a.e. l l.
2 m
di Based On orevicus evaluations of these materials in ;ther acolica-
.e wa:
s. a s<
.. =. c..s.,.. e. mea 3.mJ 114,, n l,y.
i v.e. a, u s a.
:2 2.,
n -
ia s..
. a.
s..
v
.g
: 9. f
.'. S. ** i *. I '". *7
~ i.'.
.a. ' ".I} l k h
".'0*t. a e.
* p
** h. i 0 r,M ie i..e a.'(..*. c '*. *.a
.I I.
Yh a.
Jl
.4 i
2 a
i
. "s b. t i -
27.1: r, v~ u. :
a
~
z
.,. -.,. z_e. e n -4v.
.u jfA
_hd o.
r9
(
*M.
: f. M.
N3i.
. h.
4 O
MOM C.N.. O 9
....a,
. 1 s.
.,s.
s s -
i
.< v
..w a
ar. s n e e. e. s. '. n % ' =..
an'a
'.1 :,1 a.
4 c e n e..s + n.n n.a c
a..
u---
e mm..-.."
o
 
f:
1 t.
a I
I. q C t.q... 3=.= 7/, +. h. a.
e s.d 4. m q c.s n'q y
: m. a r #. e r. m.. a,j u. s
.'.4
.m d g a
* 3.
F0F
.s.SAs n
vg '. h 4 a.
.a w e
a
.u t
.O]C]+T 3.k, f s u^.1 * $ d b y
)d,,N.
: d.
* O. a* Mf.
: 9. 0 :.3 3
O, O.
f00**
".Q 2.". ', v ". t/ Q. Q.
* A. ) ">
f b
. 4 w
w.
e S
.- a s,
t VIeha
,4. 'L, v "3 3 F G.
-3 N
Ja,r e r _9 p f. s A.A 4@ub
' hi } ?.
php
.. = -.
ev -. 0,
- A.
O.n
.. s p ad
.3
.t g a O
^ '
l V
4 w
.ti,
4
'ev a
.q
,ns.
... '. o i m...a cng.vo.
nm..
g f
_u..
.1..
3m..
..y_.
-~
4 i
s, 4
t it 1
il i
l' t
l l
l l
l l
l
~
6 i
i e
l l
6 l
lt l
t I
i 7
I 4
 
ai...
t 9
4 t
1 n +.., c...., n....
4.
w l
i 1
l J
=
't g 4 nme : v co.~ry e r. u.u o, r_ n q,
_ u
. u. r s
4-1-
i I
e Secucyah #1 All #ilms are.intercretable and f'
4-
..t e u -, i. w, 2
: o..(- 4. 3 :s + -
.,3 2, y, j e j,,..
a m n u-u sfi 1
o I
h t
)
.s. a_ c o a _v, w, s, e C n ', 4, '_. i. d = q. i #. i. o.d = #
r.a..
' n..',
.?" O.
4 m
2 v
i.
,t -
a.nd
'1.1 P. c u s-4, -a, - 1. 7,
L.',
.'.c_
o a 7
j we d areas could not be ocsitively I
i i d.2.9 *. i #.iad.
on -=dinc.
=o..y c.
*.haea.
2
~,.
x a
i
'ev e >
-a.o'..'."ala.-
* 1d
''s l o 'r. h =-
t s =. = m -.ab
-. 1 w
Ie film exhibits no significant r
i I nd..ications.
4 i
l i
i a
I McGuire #2-Eleven films sxhibit densities such I
i'
'[
i 1
that cro.cer wald avaluatico cannct-
.t s o., o e, c a. e.s..
i,,,adi.4cr. #,ilm-i meu i
s y
v, e,nDOu % a.
'IxC o, +u c+ A n o d <. ~ 1' C n g.
wm w v v
s a vi
.n t
number 44, inese 1;m ar9
...cb
.wa wJ.
.e 4
f -
W g-4 M n
.20
.- Q. b 63, - 1, %,
f8W,
.St $
4 r
sq S
- 4*
99Q
]Q F 4 "l - i c.]
O"U.
"MI-liv
.w "A
-i-4 a fan-s cs-see f".-T i
nt*AN
\\OuO) uni *S*A
\\ l) a.d' s.'v.vw v.t, "
d
/,
u.g g m19 * /
' l 4
v a *g ge g
a.
)
4 j
3 s
f t
en; 2 3.. :.. < -. r:n
- m-mal-1Abd7g _s!
i.+/
s 5
A O
~hi-LLL \\LL)
\\ ~u,
b i* * 'i b k ($ 'a'* v. * ". B. b.)t 'NO u. - a'
* O : 2 2.]. O ' %' 3 #s
/"%v ""
~
a <
-u > v a
~f *. 2, r -~. z k ?, 3.
C..u.o. 6. %3 n.ee $ 4 1.~.
s
_; 1 '.1 "6 -% ** k y.<
i.
_m-._,.-_.
 
m _.._ __.. _ _ _. _ _ _.. _ _ - _. _ _ _ _ _ _... _. _ _.. _. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ -
t e. mi s. m, u. m,
: n. nj.t. qw. co..nv> en v c :y 7 : x-r, e
v a
4 t
l I
^atawba 41.
inirteen films exhibit densities i'
1 l
,4 c_y o. Lr. e.,
s J s
%..,,., r,.m, m m., _ 1 5 n
_. s
: m.. a - 2
: 3..,. a.
..a-nno u s2 - 3. :.,.. s. -.
m 1
.u s
..w identified as; j
t.
i
:.4.a - -; (u)-
tu - se., e e,,n3 re-
-y,
.4 l.
,j s e
, d-)
.a, - +
f.9. )
i tu,. 3- :m ie s :
t 1.
r--
t 23,
: s. c o )
-,,J- ::- (i -- ;
t.w,,a,-. na e
t t
'1 i
1
( :-,/ )
:8a-o f,c, )
e s,.., 3 s
i
. v. a -.
i-
;ra 2,/. f *,,,,J
:nd.-*O
( cy) 4-s 1
s r,n
-.J.:- --O.
(w,n)
..-a-9
;_c; i
c.t.-l p0 t' 77 )
4
?
Re-radiograchy of these seams was 4.
ace.- ap h b l o..
R.e.'.$. i r, 4,~
f, i. l n~.
s.4'<.h i b i '.
F 4
i 43 ei t
no sicn171 cant. indications.
i 1
~
r Watts Bar #1
-All films exhibit no significant t.
(
u.
[
i nd i c a,.1_on s.
5
..o 3
n4,:4 r. s.., 3 4
a31
....s,_m,4,s.u 2
va s4 i
.ga--3 2.2,
9 3
; r e
1 indications.
1 i
i 1:
j
'forth. Anna 31 Two films exhibit densities ;uch t
i
[
j.
that ; roper evaluation canno: ce 3:
3
?.?)_
i.n.. :-
i %. s e. 4, A n.d.
.w a t. Q m. e.2 d,
i n-me s
[
t i
.s gm 7
4 zu 10c: r
( :, U ~a i n,. ~ T,
: e.,
w c o - :,,i j N
Liu
.ww.
se4a:
1 L
j$
5 MQ
,?. V 9 1N j
[h)J, h 0..M
.i t _ i a 4, 6.. M i
2!.
.o4 t
v.
,v.
s.
y 8
j t,.
.~.v..w.
f t-t J.
t.-,
-. - -. =..
 
~.
_ _ _ _ _. _.... _. _. ~ _ _
1
-n r,-
e.,O., ' La v'*$ - (",t..',. 511,,1
.1 n '-
~,r.
e k I,v,a g L U.,} 4 l a.,g;U i 3I iv
::dch Anna #2-
.ive i ks exhibit densities such t
that ::rocer evaluatien cannot be r
_2_ n r 4. Z { a_d.
a,e
. n a.e* w... e d,
4,,4 we 4.
se i
(.'
e q. 1 m.. t' cc i, r..a.v.. t ra ( na )
e
~
+.
rna
_e s s,t.. t.o ( 0.'01, s,,;
tv.)
: y.n.o w
. s
.. s.
1
: y._Tr#. 06 ).
Remaining' fibs exhibit no
,c l
significant indications.
1
'N Sdery;=2 All' fibs exhibit
,o signific:n-g
\\
indications.
v
.:a w
Ringnals #2 ~
-All films'. exhibit no significant s
indications.
I i
(.
e i
w i
b v.
b
.e v.
. ~,
m,
.g i
u k,
.g
\\
^^^~^
...}}

Latest revision as of 11:11, 16 December 2024

Rotterdam Drydock Reactor Vessel CRDM Weld Radiography
ML20069B534
Person / Time
Site: Catawba Duke Energy icon.png
Issue date: 11/30/1981
From:
WESTINGHOUSE ELECTRIC COMPANY, DIV OF CBS CORP.
To:
Shared Package
ML20069B503 List:
References
NUDOCS 8112240247
Download: ML20069B534 (9)


Text

4 S

t 0

9 $ N* 9,% *)l hMes MS o ge qM g A**9%

g nea em3 1

  • kh,

. r e

,l.

g*y9 g

g

{ Qgg g

.O,* t,4 n' O_' O. 2.* 17. %. s'O?10RV 2

~

s

] y' f. ".. " d,. e, '.),) i

^ n e m. e..., ~. ;,..n N'StinC.hCGe= *1="'-3r

.va, e

8112240247 811200 PDR ADOCK 05000413 PDR s

i 4

J.-.

i i

J I

,f I

e j

n.' i ~,'

'.b a 2.~<V. : <. " ". i. c n ".

y' r a e. v. v i. r a

  1. ,.1< c er
  • 4 c m"

.o' # Nu k a.

^ wa r "..... 0.2.n. v l

u s.

.~

a m

a" ".. a. ^v #. '..L a

1. -

r e.w.,2 re *

  • 2d 3 1 u l '.*,2. <. m~ q. i, 'e

'.a t' ' i nd i c 3 *w i o". s w a. *..n n~

n.1 c

~

m

.- ma,w 1

t r o _w + s,.

.p..c.. a. ', w.2 s.m l

x..r.]ac.-

3 e.

]

], m-a,..g. u. s. p.

suc t.

2,.,,, n 2

.t~., 3 3

.2 a

.. ~

o-4

' l 1

3 i

., #,.. d 2.

o u,. 4. c - ' n, ' 7 4 l..'. ^. f-1.

~,*.,m1

.,~;

a.e.r<s a.c., a,,. e....

.t.. s.,. g, i, r.a s 4.,

r.

3

,i v

.m 3

m 4

s' ass woide

.g. r. e ~,. s. 4 m.y 2.d.

f r. _.3 2.r e,..g i t 2. 3

.u. j %a. ~ y <. g. x.2 d 6.0

.e. 2 2,,. 4 n

.o

.. ~

1

-4 un 2

5 a

1 i

t2 ",./i w. r"'< s On er I-i n a.

-o_ * ",. 4 1 ^ #.

"v - " a.d. # c 2,. i. rn s.

r"-ing.54-4

s. -

.- i s

~

s 1

-'m.cc#.w b.;:c.

'w=" b n 'tw"".a u a.c.d 'nu

"...a.

. A4

".c ' a d.

'..",u"

.v~.. a '.T.=~,="..~..

. ?.

%.~

^~

^

t e i 'a

.. o ".

c.

.2 r. i. #. #. ^ ' 1 7,,v t.,,.... 'ov w f '".. ' '1 1 o #.

-"u'i. m....n.2

~..c u i. ' '. n c. # i %... d a

c i N' ev.. e.c =.r. 2 4,

r.r li,pi G a r.

i. c /. '.

.a,,2.s/. 2,.f - Ci una.

1 'l '1 svr t) 4 e

e v-g-41 r. 2 m

u ava I

i..

.m g

x f

b^

c n. e.4.,aa a.t i "2. o ".

s

-s

..us2ec"ar..

p... 1 y wha e _,. s.s i

eqe,* 39

m..y o 21. :_a
  • .g. 3.+.

~2w-2 i

v y

i

.m s.

t 1'

+ g. vo,

'.,p..e.*. 4 u. m-c o....e. w i. i g no k..:c.wn.

o av a 7. u m.~:

"..a 2..' d. #. c -

ch e

a

~

a i

1 a

a

- iv

. i na

c. a.n. u t. n a g. e..

~u w A,

w, v a e. 2 n n..a h. n._
. t. 'c,o.

~. y. =.,1

. n y v. 5. 5 e -. n c z s.m...

m o

a

- u s

A I

l Westinchcusa concurred that varicus radiccrachic/fik c':nditicns were 1

t i

I 3

e.

. a

.,4 s.h n*.cu.r e v, s.3,.

,-e.c n..reA..o c. u..

4 in S. 1C. c-,ADI43n e G O*w A.

- u t

.a t

i-u.

i i

a b

R v^' * ~ a ". d.,'.~a

  • ",. " ~ ~ k (#
0. *.M. i.

^

c.. 'D *. 4. C. M.

s O

..o.g e,s.'> g-.,.a r. e.

vV.

s.

s.

w w.

L f tne

,nv c.

e.m w..

.n-e.

r l

f v= c o - w m.

~5. n., p m a

e. gG~n c.a

.w.. 3))

s-an g.., c. a..r 4,. c 3 nd uud a '4 4 +v,

4..

s i

roy4 y:. a.

i a m s.

i4 3 i

4 t y

4

?

i s

6 wnne od 2.3.s.rg*.4r))v ~ %...

- :.. c y,u., c-1. 3 m e.o u w +.n.a-c. ? K y U N.

-. ' o' a,. es c j n e_ o v a. o u g m.

i2 a m.

~

2c s

u

.w r

. 31 A, 2 1. '. h..C ' " b..

~. w' '. a O.f '. u '2

" ',' < " ' I -

p r < W 2.

q 4.,. * =,, w g i g. 2

,. *, 2 :. a

..>va u

o

.a w

..a w

s

- r J

'l. c " *0 n., p c ma r 1 j.,s.ar.c,Aj*4rne. o f As.c.y c

.c.a_r,. +w-i c n i '. 't.

.ger. e e @. 4 r,

  • c d. t., g j., 6 2 s

i i

.t 0

>u i w,... ~

v o w.

w

~%a., :: ee.. as v., l' u -

.#.a_ r. a.

a. a. n+.* *
  • ad p.c..

r so s

.. i 1

.i.

2, Decu0,v, an irun1,. ?1

-,/n, i

T/A - Sequoyah -Unit !2 mer sk ~..-.=, w..

v, n a *. s.,

- t 4

s I

1

'n. f sG a a

'O

. n. ; j e 0 7

[

is

~*' 'n i-i i e c..

.a

'f 2f'.#,

,.' v', p-h..

8, e - 3..

. ? m. J a 3. i.

77 v

- 6.

7 5

a"v F,..w.

f.r.- 4 s 39

. I s

u ; C M,., v.,

..ini.

.aiw e.

1' f

.n

., f9&,, a i...

,,-., e,, n,

.'A

  • j j' g m...

W.w

_.,m,

.,_,- m, rent-e vww- +- i w

. - - ~ -. -.-.-- - - -

4 1

1 1.

b J.

d.

I Duke sewer i!'.cGuire Unit #2 -

i 4

l F.N... io " *.. i '. 31 r,uk s.

O. cw *.

1

.h...y c r.

. q 4., qb,.1. 3 u q : s 37 A.,v a r.t. i c. h O. s.u.o.

u.

3 1

i 6

4 1

The iurry Unit 1 vessel was f abricatsd by RDM, hcwever, the CRCM icusing.

o n. c,, O n,.

. l w.2 7 c e s,2, o s a. ri r e.e s a

%...., w,.., a..m a. s ',/ : #,., w,, r,

i.

A

- w ww ~

~.4.

w wA 3 F

i 1

i l

4

. t i

s. $ 66: a..,, s, i-w., a
a. X <, 5. i.,, -

i t

+~w w J,. u v: e,,

.,.4

n..a 8

.;,.e. 5. y.,..,w, <. _a

n. 4,,. a :; = a u h a, s

v e s.

.6,

...w i

8 l.

t

~,.... a a.

1 c.

i.

O 2

i 1

i f

4 l

t An action clan f r resolutien of this issue was develcped and -he fol-t 4

1 Icwing -Ecricns wem camaieted.

I.

o re m u

A-n.g- [og y c.r w =w..n.pq

,. c.y".".C '. h a V " h C O,..'l

~...S '.',

i

1..

3.1 7

A,w.t. r.. -.y 1 d y i; inn g. 3 v

.f y

e w

y t.

i l

the affected film was reviewed to ascartain,irrterpretability.

Tne reviews were cerfcrmed by Westinghcuse personnel who are highly i

o i

- ~~ ~ ~~ ~

~ ~ ~

'cuali~ied and excerienced in NDE techniques.

In most cases the fiim exhibited sensitivities such that.significant flaws would be

[

l detec ted. provides a sumary of these reviews.

t

' 2.

A weid acck-uc dualicatinc.' the ccnfic. uraticn of the welds in cues-tien was f abricaced.

The mock-ca was radiogr2 hed using the RCM i

I technicue in ceder to determine the cacabilities of the tachnicue.

i 9

-Informat.cn developed frcm this acck-c3 includes; j

-A.

A "c.17 (.017") cenetrameter placed en the !.0. of the tube P

l (scurce side) can be clearly defined, including the 27 hole.

  • k ** O i 4.k Na9 p

I r-f6 2 b $ 9." 5I b e l O.

1 v.e$ k pae$ 3. P m,1.,.** 5 A b

  • ?% '?*

JJ

.n

-v4 4 i A**

jt

?n i A k

Q.

ew s 4..r

  • . Jg A4

-e >- Q-;, eJ aba V'

s 4

t L

f "s,. p a. ". +. m a,. ?.S f c.

l Zd

., t a

a.

4

+ > -

a v y e, a.

.m

+

q i

I t

t t

W-

- - ~ ~ -

-e

.__., ewe w.-

, r-w w.a r-- ~ r

m.

4 4

3.

~ A 1/32" gr:ove (.032")imachined in the I D of'the inconel par-i 4

s

  • "e a ' i s A T. = = r 'i,v d i s s-s_. ab '%a
i. n ' " a.

r _' H i, n_ - r. 's 5 f

i.

'.'.cn o# '."o, h

a i

m 1

)'

'. h 3 '.

_a c. c_ a.'

1 1-A '1/ gn (r. c. g " ) s j _= m

r. =_.-

.o,. 2_

4.,.

s.u_ -+2:nt_s3 2 co.,

.-...r.n o

3..

n

.u

~2 a

2 l '.

{.

the tuce is cleari.v discernible througn a densit.y area of a.52 f

1 4

i.

muu,in one n,c.

.i r

1 f

,i f

i e.

6 L

Th i s i n f vr. ~2. 4. u n ". a.. #. #. i. m s '-.h ' '.h a

_= _ "a n :., u o_ s'.,.. d

4. n
  • s_. ~ _o

_' w 'i _. # 4 '. a a

o e s 1

1 i

-esulting fred its use) is suf#iciently sensitive to detec any "lar I

x. 4,a. c.

r_ - o a_.,,. us

'."..a. d_ a s i, n.

e

'hi3 i2 - n e. i

  • m
  • c.. 's,o' '.h
r. a s u 'i '. c #.

i

.s a.

~

m l

the RDd #ilm review:wherein acrosity sizes of approximately 1/04" i

i f.n.i.c a s a4

,a 2 -m_

s 2 a r_ _ s_ s_ i. n e -. 2_

i n c.

a nr _2 s.

- o_2,.. a u c. -

i ov m

f i

4,.. '. a_. 3 rc_ F_ _= % 1 =. cn 'mh. e_ =_

i i

7

y. o l a_.e e, c.r w. h :. c.x. - ;1,
e. am :i v 3., p'n s wa r. a.

a ---

ou.

t

.nen-occratinc piants were ~ radicc.rach.ed ac.ain in the field by ' des-t i

tinc.houss.

The results of these r,ew radio raphs are acceptable and s

I a

are included in Attachment 1.

1 4

t i

i m a.

. e n

2-na -

.o u b i. t..~ L.a.

sJ +o. '1 i r. =. A._k.,., + u z_ e,

.- a. a_ ~. e r

,v 2 3. 1

<m., n o..

-m e, c 3

.n%. l C s

-e,

e v, o

o

.. e-i. w - w a s n_ y > e_w a.d.

ho t ee.k p. 3 y c_ e. o - j ] i. ~- ad by l

s i

l 2 r. +. o.

2_

2

  1. . a. r swa_a2_

u s

4

_ o 4 vw s

mo 4

l I.

uqar : 3 3.r :. C ' '.C

~a a. '. v# # #. #.3

  • a_ n *w
  1. "^^

^ h ' '.

"w ' a_ d. "sf' U F. "-.'..n a

""v"p a r 2 5_ '4.

vu.

iw i

4

<.a m.

a d _ -

s l'

.R f A k 'l am. 3

.A. w. n

.A. n *

  1. c_ e a_ n Y..

l

. a ra.

v.

i a

+

i

[

t i.

+

_.:nese ac tiCnS SUD3crt tn.e COnClusiCG tn.at GC 51gni 1 cant defect is pres-t li

~

One in the welds under consideration, inis is baseu cn; l

a I

, O ls. UGOY v.'l t

inO 3

ROY w _O O_.

m u. v w.

.) O.

P fD O_

^D

.- i L" ". - f N

-.O..

a a v)f..,)

O

n. P2 q

_s o

+

i

.e.

v.

o I

u. e m~ u _ e v,... a i '.- 4 y. t. y~

. c_ a/ 3 ],

c.y c.q w i '-.".

4

.n

.i g t.u 9p,94.u.do ad rn~e

~ +3

> 2-

?-m a

4 us

.e s

w u

a u ?. k - R

  1. ,f* *,*^ b 3 l

N

,,.e._n.m C ', 3_.e ",

hp 3

>y)4 e

s.,.

.,o

.i 3

p

!I e

I I.

3

1.. -

5o s j.a. '. a b l a.

d a '. ar. *. d u' - = disc =raikla. i n r e. s h c'.

  1. i 't m-und O. *t y. n * '6

=

i a

ww 4

us.

i u

fi'm four.d to be intercretable.

This is a total of 721 welds of 723

~

.e2

d. a-.a v i c.t.e. d..

7ho.. o.m 2, n i. n o. 7 #.i l.m<.

wa r. a.

d =. o~- a.d.

r. v '. i.

'.a.ro. =...abl =.

4 257,,

.am, j.ia.a.

s. 3.- s.

v.

n f

.w.a.' e..a y s..,' r.;. ~ a. h. ^ u - 4.,

  1. il

'.m'- 4, w-h n., 2

.H a c.'w r~a '. '.o

" a.

v'. n - - 2 *. -

s u

s ad

.= b l. a, 'so

b..^.u s i. e s 3.. o. i n s ' ' '. l =d
i. n 'Mv. *. h r' rt u. l.'n i. '. 1 e..n.d
  1. . i. ". a.

=.. =.

in

-a 2

4

r. rws a. 'amo i' 4'.-

.' r a.

o - a,.

a 'u... c,

', a q r.

i o.

a.. m n. o,
o.., 4,
9..

j. c.. i, 2.t.o 4.o-n-

n oui 2 2

u.

.~

. r.s. nno. so. -e..r, die %. 2. - b. a. r..

y, a. s'. i. n f.e u s a 'h = <. ""..c l u.d c.d.

'. h.' '. s a f o u

u

,a s

~-

u n. '. a. ' n c".q *. i nu s w #. '."o ^t'. 3 v" d '. '. i. c n.= 1. a. r. i n e, b =.. a = d i.e u

e a

m a g e.

.,. 4.. v-,o of.gn2, en the fclicwing.

^

il T. h. a. -o. s u '.'.c.

'.*.e v a..v m <..a.n s i, v =.= d i. c...s w i. r ~- a v i c. a. s.,e c.

. = d

.n c

herein demonstrate that the manuf acturing processes used by ROM provite a sound we,:a. wnicn is tree or sign 1ricant der.e:ts.

2 2)

Other non-destructive tests performed during f abricatica and n ro.. c. o.-v i c.= i. n. e.. a.. ' '. v^.q

  • 'v c a. l a.d.

n.o "m o a r. = '.' b i n.

i o-d i.., H.. wa o.

.sv u

W. '! d 4 :d i. v.' *. a 3

  • "2-

-s J1

s c..n.. s.

.. 2. c. w.,.. 2 2,/,.,. o..,. 4 r n

e. :i *gja

. va. v a

c ti

-o 1 >.. s-a. c. 'i ui

..~n u '4 s2 a n.

,,.,ee

.,l iu,,. c :,

.n,.

a 1..a, s.

A

~

u.

r, 4.ne.ns u,,./

a

.a ny,-

a 3,. a.n.e. a n... c:. - + a.

u u... -., n u..,., ~I ; - : -.. o :.=. <. =. n. ;..,,t

,,.cl a.a ~ =,a. ;6 s

s iy vare.

we,.

a

c. " = b 'i u o ". a. r '.h a. wors'. ".'es

'No ' d, i r. a., 3 -

u.rc.u m.

a. -c.o.~ s. wi 'i l. a " = i. n,

-i a

o.

u e3 m.

wouid a three ;. ncn through-wa,il ax;. l r..iaw, or a acu cegree inside

- m, a

s u #. $ c a. -..$'<

ax ' = q d 4.. yc 'O m~ 'r _ a_.r. "e

'.h.. o u c k.. 'mh a.e. l l.

2 m

di Based On orevicus evaluations of these materials in ;ther acolica-

.e wa:

s. a s<

.. =. c..s.,.. e. mea 3.mJ 114,, n l,y.

i v.e. a, u s a.

2 2.,

n -

ia s..

. a.

s..

v

.g

9. f

.'. S. ** i *. I '". *7

~ i.'.

.a. ' ".I} l k h

".'0*t. a e.

  • p
    • h. i 0 r,M ie i..e a.'(..*. c '*. *.a

.I I.

Yh a.

Jl

.4 i

2 a

i

. "s b. t i -

27.1: r, v~ u. :

a

~

z

.,. -.,. z_e. e n -4v.

.u jfA

_hd o.

r9

(

  • M.
f. M.

N3i.

. h.

4 O

MOM C.N.. O 9

....a,

. 1 s.

.,s.

s s -

i

.< v

..w a

ar. s n e e. e. s. '. n % ' =..

an'a

'.1 :,1 a.

4 c e n e..s + n.n n.a c

a..

u---

e mm..-.."

o

f:

1 t.

a I

I. q C t.q... 3=.= 7/, +. h. a.

e s.d 4. m q c.s n'q y

m. a r #. e r. m.. a,j u. s

.'.4

.m d g a

  • 3.

F0F

.s.SAs n

vg '. h 4 a.

.a w e

a

.u t

.O]C]+T 3.k, f s u^.1 * $ d b y

)d,,N.

d.
  • O. a* Mf.
9. 0 :.3 3

O, O.

f00**

".Q 2.". ', v ". t/ Q. Q.

  • A. ) ">

f b

. 4 w

w.

e S

.- a s,

t VIeha

,4. 'L, v "3 3 F G.

-3 N

Ja,r e r _9 p f. s A.A 4@ub

' hi } ?.

php

.. = -.

ev -. 0,

- A.

O.n

.. s p ad

.3

.t g a O

^ '

l V

4 w

.ti,

4

'ev a

.q

,ns.

... '. o i m...a cng.vo.

nm..

g f

_u..

.1..

3m..

..y_.

-~

4 i

s, 4

t it 1

il i

l' t

l l

l l

l l

l

~

6 i

i e

l l

6 l

lt l

t I

i 7

I 4

ai...

t 9

4 t

1 n +.., c...., n....

4.

w l

i 1

l J

=

't g 4 nme : v co.~ry e r. u.u o, r_ n q,

_ u

. u. r s

4-1-

i I

e Secucyah #1 All #ilms are.intercretable and f'

4-

..t e u -, i. w, 2

o..(- 4. 3 :s + -

.,3 2, y, j e j,,..

a m n u-u sfi 1

o I

h t

)

.s. a_ c o a _v, w, s, e C n ', 4, '_. i. d = q. i #. i. o.d = #

r.a..

' n..',

.?" O.

4 m

2 v

i.

,t -

a.nd

'1.1 P. c u s-4, -a, - 1. 7,

L.',

.'.c_

o a 7

j we d areas could not be ocsitively I

i i d.2.9 *. i #.iad.

on -=dinc.

=o..y c.

  • .haea.

2

~,.

x a

i

'ev e >

-a.o'..'."ala.-

  • 1d

s l o 'r. h =-

t s =. = m -.ab

-. 1 w

Ie film exhibits no significant r

i I nd..ications.

4 i

l i

i a

I McGuire #2-Eleven films sxhibit densities such I

i'

'[

i 1

that cro.cer wald avaluatico cannct-

.t s o., o e, c a. e.s..

i,,,adi.4cr. #,ilm-i meu i

s y

v, e,nDOu % a.

'IxC o, +u c+ A n o d <. ~ 1' C n g.

wm w v v

s a vi

.n t

number 44, inese 1;m ar9

...cb

.wa wJ.

.e 4

f -

W g-4 M n

.20

.- Q. b 63, - 1, %,

f8W,

.St $

4 r

sq S

- 4*

99Q

]Q F 4 "l - i c.]

O"U.

"MI-liv

.w "A

-i-4 a fan-s cs-see f".-T i

nt*AN

\\OuO) uni *S*A

\\ l) a.d' s.'v.vw v.t, "

d

/,

u.g g m19 * /

' l 4

v a *g ge g

a.

)

4 j

3 s

f t

en; 2 3.. :.. < -. r:n

- m-mal-1Abd7g _s!

i.+/

s 5

A O

~hi-LLL \\LL)

\\ ~u,

b i* * 'i b k ($ 'a'* v. * ". B. b.)t 'NO u. - a'

  • O : 2 2.]. O ' %' 3 #s

/"%v ""

~

a <

-u > v a

~f *. 2, r -~. z k ?, 3.

C..u.o. 6. %3 n.ee $ 4 1.~.

s

_; 1 '.1 "6 -% ** k y.<

i.

_m-._,.-_.

m _.._ __.. _ _ _. _ _ _.. _ _ - _. _ _ _ _ _ _... _. _ _.. _. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ -

t e. mi s. m, u. m,

n. nj.t. qw. co..nv> en v c :y 7 : x-r, e

v a

4 t

l I

^atawba 41.

inirteen films exhibit densities i'

1 l

,4 c_y o. Lr. e.,

s J s

%..,,., r,.m, m m., _ 1 5 n

_. s

m.. a - 2
3..,. a.

..a-nno u s2 - 3. :.,.. s. -.

m 1

.u s

..w identified as; j

t.

i

.4.a - -; (u)-

tu - se., e e,,n3 re-

-y,

.4 l.

,j s e

, d-)

.a, - +

f.9. )

i tu,. 3- :m ie s :

t 1.

r--

t 23,

s. c o )

-,,J- ::- (i -- ;

t.w,,a,-. na e

t t

'1 i

1

( :-,/ )

8a-o f,c, )

e s,.., 3 s

i

. v. a -.

i-

ra 2,/. f *,,,,J
nd.-*O

( cy) 4-s 1

s r,n

-.J.:- --O.

(w,n)

..-a-9

_c; i

c.t.-l p0 t' 77 )

4

?

Re-radiograchy of these seams was 4.

ace.- ap h b l o..

R.e.'.$. i r, 4,~

f, i. l n~.

s.4'<.h i b i '.

F 4

i 43 ei t

no sicn171 cant. indications.

i 1

~

r Watts Bar #1

-All films exhibit no significant t.

(

u.

[

i nd i c a,.1_on s.

5

..o 3

n4,:4 r. s.., 3 4

a31

....s,_m,4,s.u 2

va s4 i

.ga--3 2.2,

9 3

r e

1 indications.

1 i

i 1:

j

'forth. Anna 31 Two films exhibit densities ;uch t

i

[

j.

that ; roper evaluation canno: ce 3:

3

?.?)_

i.n.. :-

i %. s e. 4, A n.d.

.w a t. Q m. e.2 d,

i n-me s

[

t i

.s gm 7

4 zu 10c: r

( :, U ~a i n,. ~ T,

e.,

w c o - :,,i j N

Liu

.ww.

se4a:

1 L

j$

5 MQ

,?. V 9 1N j

[h)J, h 0..M

.i t _ i a 4, 6.. M i

2!.

.o4 t

v.

,v.

s.

y 8

j t,.

.~.v..w.

f t-t J.

t.-,

-. - -. =..

~.

_ _ _ _ _. _.... _. _. ~ _ _

1

-n r,-

e.,O., ' La v'*$ - (",t..',. 511,,1

.1 n '-

~,r.

e k I,v,a g L U.,} 4 l a.,g;U i 3I iv

dch Anna #2-

.ive i ks exhibit densities such t

that ::rocer evaluatien cannot be r

_2_ n r 4. Z { a_d.

a,e

. n a.e* w... e d,

4,,4 we 4.

se i

(.'

e q. 1 m.. t' cc i, r..a.v.. t ra ( na )

e

~

+.

rna

_e s s,t.. t.o ( 0.'01, s,,;

tv.)

y.n.o w

. s

.. s.

1

y._Tr#. 06 ).

Remaining' fibs exhibit no

,c l

significant indications.

1

'N Sdery;=2 All' fibs exhibit

,o signific:n-g

\\

indications.

v

.:a w

Ringnals #2 ~

-All films'. exhibit no significant s

indications.

I i

(.

e i

w i

b v.

b

.e v.

. ~,

m,

.g i

u k,

.g

\\

^^^~^

...