ML20004B702: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
 
(StriderTol Bot change)
 
Line 2: Line 2:
| number = ML20004B702
| number = ML20004B702
| issue date = 05/19/1981
| issue date = 05/19/1981
| title = Responds to 810428 Ltr Re Motion to Compel Answers to Porter County Chapter Intervenors' First Set of Interrogatories to Util.Ltr Is Not Proper Substitute for Answer to Interrogatory
| title = Responds to Re Motion to Compel Answers to Porter County Chapter Intervenors First Set of Interrogatories to Util.Ltr Is Not Proper Substitute for Answer to Interrogatory
| author name = Whicher J
| author name = Whicher J
| author affiliation = PORTER COUNTY CHAPTER INTERVENORS, VOLLEN, R.J. & WHICHER, J.M.
| author affiliation = PORTER COUNTY CHAPTER INTERVENORS, VOLLEN, R.J. & WHICHER, J.M.
Line 11: Line 11:
| contact person =  
| contact person =  
| document report number = NUDOCS 8105290319
| document report number = NUDOCS 8105290319
| title reference date = 04-28-1981
| package number = ML20004B703
| package number = ML20004B703
| document type = CORRESPONDENCE-LETTERS, EXTERNAL CORRESPONDENCE, EXTERNAL LETTERS ROUTED TO NRC
| document type = CORRESPONDENCE-LETTERS, EXTERNAL CORRESPONDENCE, EXTERNAL LETTERS ROUTED TO NRC
Line 17: Line 18:


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:_ - - - _ _             -__-___________-- - -___
{{#Wiki_filter:_ - - - _ _
m e (    P.
m(
                                                                                                                                                                                      )
)
i:
e P.
        .- n Dd;} Business and Professional People for the Public Interest Chicago. tilinois 60602             Telephone: (312; G41-5570 u              109 North Dearborn Street. Suite 1300             -
i: n Dd;}
                                                                                      ._ . ,.. s--,,s. w m y
Business and Professional People for the Public Interest Chicago. tilinois 60602 Telephone: (312; G41-5570 109 North Dearborn Street. Suite 1300 y
m,                                                           _
u s--,,s. w m m,
Q
_- t I m.
                                                                                                                                        - t I m.i May 19, 1981                                                                                         N 6             oocETO                                         g.
Q i
usstsc 2      g>X 2 2 $ 8\ * %;                                       -
May 19, 1981 N
a.
6 oocETO g.
Mr. William H. Eichhorn                                                                               i                                                                 7 Eichhorn, Eichhorn & Link                                                                                                        ' Myra                                g
usstsc g>X 2 2 $ 8\\ * %;
(@ Q..wrwcr; 5243 Hohman Avenue Hammond, Indian m
2 a.
1      C)
7 Mr. William H. Eichhorn i
                                                                                                                      %                    M , 3/                          ''
(@ Q.. wcr;
(;,                                                                         *M I GP 27' b     e:       Northern Indiana Publ c' Service Company (Bailly Generating Station
' Myra g
                                      -        /,                    h  U            Nuclear-1) Docket No. 50-367 lp u.,y;y ,,0 ISBN h
Eichhorn, Eichhorn & Link M, 3/
                                                        ~
5243 Hohman Avenue m
(Construction Permit Extension)
wr Hammond, Indian 1
C)
*M I GP
(;,
27' b
e:
Northern Indiana Publ c' Service h
Company (Bailly Generating Station U
Nuclear-1) Docket No. 50-367
/,
lp u.,y;y,,0 ISBN h (Construction Permit Extension)
~
' a/. %>
3


==Dear Bill:==
==Dear Bill:==
                  ' a/ . %>                        3' This lette                    (7 ges 'nse to your letter of April 28, 1981, which concerns our o                                       to Compel Answers to PCGI's First Set of Interrogatories to NIPSCO.
(7 ges 'nse to your letter of April 28, 1981, This lette which concerns our o to Compel Answers to PCGI's First Set of Interrogatories to NIPSCO.
While we share your desire to avoid unnecessary Board rulings, the method you have chosen in an effort to accomplish that leaves                                                                                                             _
While we share your desire to avoid unnecessary Board rulings, the method you have chosen in an effort to accomplish that leaves us somewhat confused.
us somewhat confused.                               Had the factual information in your letter been contained in NIPSCO's " Response" to the Interrogatories, our Motion to Compel probably would not have been necessary. However, a letter from counsel is not, it seems to us, an adequate substitute for sworn answers to interrogatories.
Had the factual information in your letter been contained in NIPSCO's " Response" to the Interrogatories, our Motion to Compel probably would not have been necessary.
If your letter is intended as an offer to submit amended reponses to Interrogatories 19, 20(a) and 20(c) to include the factual information contained in your letter, the matter can be quickly resolved. Upon receipt of such amended responses in proper form, we would be pleased to notify the Board that we withdraw our Motion to Compel.
: However, a letter from counsel is not, it seems to us, an adequate substitute for sworn answers to interrogatories.
If your letter is intended as an offer to submit amended reponses to Interrogatories 19, 20(a) and 20(c) to include the factual information contained in your letter, the matter can be quickly resolved.
Upon receipt of such amended responses in proper form, we would be pleased to notify the Board that we withdraw our Motion to Compel.
Very truly yours,
Very truly yours,
                                                                                      . .s m ._             .                                                                      %  ,
..s m._
JMW: beg                                                       Jane M. Whicher One of the Attorneys for Porter                                                                     p cc:       See attached                                                 County Chapter Intervenors
JMW: beg Jane M. Whicher One of the Attorneys for Porter p
(   o .eio,s             so-e w asa,ey h
cc:
av.,o o,n ..n s..                             sian
See attached County Chapter Intervenors
      ,,,,,,,,,,,,        Jone C s.:nman           va,,., -aosman     euc.ene    pe o.
(
i.e ance,po ,.ot.                                             non,sievens Jwhan Berman                                                                                                    A s,ae, rne Ceca C Burier F.oevn;e me,in,r   Awoo.on S Rasn           2;..a,,o, g, .ur,,, ,on.o..
h o.eio,s so-e w asa,ey av.,o o,n..n s..
p ,,efe,                 Aseng Agenda I
euc.ene pe o.
s eter ,*unt       memy Wa<tutg Russo                                                                                               l a                                   Dianae L_ Sautien                                 -
non,sievens sian Jone C s.:nman va,,., -aosman i.e ance,po,.ot.
[' sa s                 W D s[<es           encU o e na$N   b c 's.mc oN
A s,ae, rne Jwhan Berman F.oevn;e me,in,r Awoo.on S Rasn 2;..a,,o,,on.o..
* 8'        "''
g,
                                                                                                                                                  , [,3 Lora v..mams         Lws E 3 a:5 eru       . xsepn neaman       B n S ege-               CouG au W Casset J ue v,ce r es>cea's   Ca'L' ' Fa *eu           Ermitenman         Coco J Tro,               VFw Gado*a, James '                     Commun,tr Ceve.coment 1
.ur,,, p,,efe, Aseng Agenda Ceca C Burier s eter,*unt memy Wa<tutg Russo a
yeare a Lonert                                                                                                                       Derecrer T'e a s.<e'             a C    new              na Siaw ron C Fiancers Jonn t uc an,gni bi            isbe q uo son wn.s,,an J
Dianae L_ Sautien
F ancine G 'cA,ss' man 0
[' a s W D s[<es enc o e na$N b c 's.mc oN U
                                                                                                                                          *"C's,I'ga','
s
p8' e 1
, [,3 8'
Svev ia Sco nie.o   "*'Lae't B "''ed         E:en* O M,acany   Ree.naert %Hf             Headtd A Learne' i
Lora v..mams Lws E 3 a:5 eru xsepn neaman B n S ege-ue CouG au W Casset J v,ce r es>cea's Ca'L' ' Fa *eu Ermitenman Coco J Tro, VFw Gado*a, James '
5, cserarr         b "*'d   Go'"0"           W4He' A '*"thcn                                                                   Past Pres
Comm n,tr Ceve.coment u
* dents                                  l d"0'ners                           o,,ao, g   sn,,,,,                               1 Eis ot Lanman 810520 0 b@
1 Derecrer yeare a Lonert C
new na a
bi
*"C's,I'ga','
0 T'e a s.<e' isbe q J
Siaw ron C Fiancers Jonn t uc an,gni uo son wn.s,,an F ancine G 'cA,ss' man p8' e Sve ia Sco nie.o
"*'Lae't B "''ed E:en* O M,acany Ree.naert %Hf Headtd A Learne' Past Pres
* dents i
v 5, cserarr b "*'d Go'"0" W4He' A '*"thcn d"0'ners o,,ao, g sn,,,,,
1 Eis ot Lanman 810520 0 b@


O 2-Letter to William H. Eichhorn     May 19, 1981 Page 2 cc: Administrative Judge Herbert Grossman Administrative Judge Robert L. Holton Administrative Judge J. Venn Leeds Maurice Axelrad, Esq.
O 2-Letter to William H. Eichhorn May 19, 1981 Page 2 cc:
Administrative Judge Herbert Grossman Administrative Judge Robert L. Holton Administrative Judge J. Venn Leeds Maurice Axelrad, Esq.
Diane B. Cohn, Esq.
Diane B. Cohn, Esq.
George and Ann Grabowski George Schultz Richard L. Robbins , Esq.
George and Ann Grabowski George Schultz Richard L. Robbins, Esq.
Mike Olszanski Steven C. Goldberg, Esq.
Mike Olszanski Steven C. Goldberg, Esq.
Anne Rapkin, Esq.
Anne Rapkin, Esq.

Latest revision as of 11:38, 23 December 2024

Responds to Re Motion to Compel Answers to Porter County Chapter Intervenors First Set of Interrogatories to Util.Ltr Is Not Proper Substitute for Answer to Interrogatory
ML20004B702
Person / Time
Site: Bailly
Issue date: 05/19/1981
From: Whicher J
PORTER COUNTY CHAPTER INTERVENORS, VOLLEN, R.J. & WHICHER, J.M.
To: Eichhorn W
EICHHORN, EICHHORN & LINK
Shared Package
ML20004B703 List:
References
NUDOCS 8105290319
Download: ML20004B702 (2)


Text

_ - - - _ _

m(

)

e P.

i: n Dd;}

Business and Professional People for the Public Interest Chicago. tilinois 60602 Telephone: (312; G41-5570 109 North Dearborn Street. Suite 1300 y

u s--,,s. w m m,

_- t I m.

Q i

May 19, 1981 N

6 oocETO g.

usstsc g>X 2 2 $ 8\\ * %;

2 a.

7 Mr. William H. Eichhorn i

(@ Q.. wcr;

' Myra g

Eichhorn, Eichhorn & Link M, 3/

5243 Hohman Avenue m

wr Hammond, Indian 1

C)

(;,

27' b

e:

Northern Indiana Publ c' Service h

Company (Bailly Generating Station U

Nuclear-1) Docket No. 50-367

/,

lp u.,y;y,,0 ISBN h (Construction Permit Extension)

~

' a/. %>

3

Dear Bill:

(7 ges 'nse to your letter of April 28, 1981, This lette which concerns our o to Compel Answers to PCGI's First Set of Interrogatories to NIPSCO.

While we share your desire to avoid unnecessary Board rulings, the method you have chosen in an effort to accomplish that leaves us somewhat confused.

Had the factual information in your letter been contained in NIPSCO's " Response" to the Interrogatories, our Motion to Compel probably would not have been necessary.

However, a letter from counsel is not, it seems to us, an adequate substitute for sworn answers to interrogatories.

If your letter is intended as an offer to submit amended reponses to Interrogatories 19, 20(a) and 20(c) to include the factual information contained in your letter, the matter can be quickly resolved.

Upon receipt of such amended responses in proper form, we would be pleased to notify the Board that we withdraw our Motion to Compel.

Very truly yours,

..s m._

JMW: beg Jane M. Whicher One of the Attorneys for Porter p

cc:

See attached County Chapter Intervenors

(

h o.eio,s so-e w asa,ey av.,o o,n..n s..

euc.ene pe o.

non,sievens sian Jone C s.:nman va,,., -aosman i.e ance,po,.ot.

A s,ae, rne Jwhan Berman F.oevn;e me,in,r Awoo.on S Rasn 2;..a,,o,,on.o..

g,

.ur,,, p,,efe, Aseng Agenda Ceca C Burier s eter,*unt memy Wa<tutg Russo a

Dianae L_ Sautien

[' a s W D s[<es enc o e na$N b c 's.mc oN U

s

, [,3 8'

Lora v..mams Lws E 3 a:5 eru xsepn neaman B n S ege-ue CouG au W Casset J v,ce r es>cea's Ca'L' ' Fa *eu Ermitenman Coco J Tro, VFw Gado*a, James '

Comm n,tr Ceve.coment u

1 Derecrer yeare a Lonert C

new na a

bi

  • "C's,I'ga','

0 T'e a s.<e' isbe q J

Siaw ron C Fiancers Jonn t uc an,gni uo son wn.s,,an F ancine G 'cA,ss' man p8' e Sve ia Sco nie.o

"*'Lae't B "ed E:en* O M,acany Ree.naert %Hf Headtd A Learne' Past Pres

  • dents i

v 5, cserarr b "*'d Go'"0" W4He' A '*"thcn d"0'ners o,,ao, g sn,,,,,

1 Eis ot Lanman 810520 0 b@

O 2-Letter to William H. Eichhorn May 19, 1981 Page 2 cc:

Administrative Judge Herbert Grossman Administrative Judge Robert L. Holton Administrative Judge J. Venn Leeds Maurice Axelrad, Esq.

Diane B. Cohn, Esq.

George and Ann Grabowski George Schultz Richard L. Robbins, Esq.

Mike Olszanski Steven C. Goldberg, Esq.

Anne Rapkin, Esq.

Stephen Laudig, Esq.

Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Board Panel Docketing and Service Section 6

9 4