ML052590338

Handout to Francis Cameron by Lisa Rainwater at the Emergency Preparedness Meeting on August 31, 2005

ML052590338
Person / Time
Site:	Indian Point
Issue date:	08/31/2005
From:	- No Known Affiliation
To:	Picciano J Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation, Federal Emergency Management Agency
References
Download: ML052590338 (24)

Text

Joseph F. Picciano Acting Regional Director Federal Emergency Management Agency RE: INDIAN POINT RADIOLOGICAL EVACUATION PLAN We, the undersigned are First Responders. We include Police Officers, Fire Fighters, EMS Workers, Transportation Workers, School Administrators, Educators, Doctors and Nurses in the communities within the 10-mile Emergency Evacuation Zone or the 50-mile peak injury zone around the Indian Point Nuclear Power Facility.

The Report by James Lee Witt Associates commissioned by Governor Pataki, has clearly determined that the existing emergency evacuation plan in inadequate to protect the public health and safety. The four surrounding counties - Westchester, Rockland, Orange and Putman - and the State of New York have refused to certify the evacuation plan because of the broad range of deficiencies identified.

We will do our utmost to make sure that the evacuation plan is executed as best as is humanly possible.

However, the large population, the lack of infrastructure, and the limited resources of this region make it hard to foresee a successful evacuation without casualties, regardless of the cause of a significant radiological release.

We are concerned that even our best efforts may not be enough to adequately protect the public health and safety of the citizens of this region.

In conclusion, we request that the Federal Emergency Management Agency ("FEMA") and the Nuclear Regulatory Commission ("NRC") not certify the emergency evacuation plan for Indian Point.

>Please return to Susan Shapiro, 21 Perlman Dr., Spring Valley, NY 10977

Joseph F. Picciano Acting Regional Director Federal Emergency Management Agency RE: INDIAN POINT RADIOLOGICAL EVACUATION PLAN We, the undersigned are First Responders. We include Police Officers, Fire Fighters, EMS Workers, Transportation Workers, School Administrators, Educators, Doctors and Nurses in the communities within the 1 0-mile Emergency Evacuation Zone or the 50-mile peak injury zone around the Indian Point Nuclear Power Facility.

The Report by James Lee Witt Associates commissioned by Governor Pataki, has clearly determined that the existing emergency evacuation plan in inadequate to protect the public health and safety. The four surrounding counties - Westchester, Rockland, Orange and Putman -- and the State of New York have refused to certify the evacuation plan because of the broad range of deficiencies identified.

We will do our utmost to make sure that the evacuation plan is executed as best as is humanly possible.

However, the large population, the lack of infrastructure, and the limited resources of this region make it hard to foresee a successful evacuation without casualties, regardless of the cause of a significant radiological release.

We are concerned that even our best efforts may not be enough to adequately protect the public health and safety of the citizens of this region.

In conclusion, we request that the Federal Emergency Management Agency ("FEMA") and the Nuclear Regulatory Commission ("NRC") not certify the emergency evacuation plan for Indian Point.

>Please return to Susan Shapiro, 21 Perlman Dr., Spring Valley, NY 10977

I P.

Joseph F. Piocisno Acting Regional Director Federal Emergency Mansgement Agency RE: INDIAN POINT RADIOLOGICAL EVACUATION PLAN We, the undersigned are First Responders, We include Police Officers, Fire Fighters, EMS Workers, Transportation Workers, School Administrators, Educators, Doctors and Nurses In the communities within the 10-mile Emergency Evacuation Zone or the 50-mile peak injury zone around the Indian Pcint Nuclear Power Facility.

The Report by James Lee WItt Associates commissioned by Governor Pataki, has clearly determined that Ihe existing emergency evacuation plan In Inadequate to protect the public health and safety. The four surrounding countis - Westchester, Rockland, Orange and Pulman - and the State of New York have refused to certify the evacuation plan because of the broad range of deficiencies Identified.

We will do our utmost to make sure that the evacuation plan is executed as best as Is humanly possible.

However, the large population, the lack of Infrastructure, and the limited resources of this region make It hard to foresee a successful evacuation without cusualties, reg;rdlesg of the cause of a significant radiological release.

We are concerned that even our best eforts may not be enough to adequately protect the public health and safety of the cltizens of this region.

In concluslon, we request that the Federal Emergency Management Agency ("FEMA7) and the Nuclear Regulatory Commission CNRCII) not certfy the emergency evacuation plan for Indian Point.

TownNillacel

_ Slcnature OrganizatlonilG rou PoItlonrTItle CountY 2

/* <~-

~

/

LA41

__)

/i:t~w d )-7is~

/A 3

I' iit

-/t3tr

~-

'vi1R o1

/L 4

-7 IfVIIA'

/A I

/tk CJ'-*

/sed-.

X\\ (/LiI 6

en >'r

)4tf i4tz

.,/S

(

grm-,/l.^e 7 8 rvl~ t4 k'h,//i.6esr A D C~oso (tS/P

&Z/

JzI{

l

~~~I

,f,/i-J 4 / /a (7/)

I

_/;

>Please retd/rn to SJn Shapiro, 21 Perlman Dr., Spring Valley, NY 10977 (1/

A2/o512ee3 11:39 845371'721 r;LT4 D SHA1R F4GE 02 Joseph F. Picclano Acting Regional Director Federal Emergency Management Agency 26 Pederal Plaza, Suite 1311 New York, NY 1027$

RE-INDIAN POINT RADIOLOGICAL EVACUATION PLAN We, the undersigned are first responders, including police, fire, EMS and bus drivers, in the communities within the 50 mile pcak injury zone of the IndiUn Point Nuclear Facility.

The current evacuation plan is inadequate and Unworkable. Due to the large population of the region, limited resources and escape routes it will be impossible ',or even the best Cvacuatkon plfui to adequately protect the public health and safety.

We implore the Federal Emergency Management Agency ("FEMAW) rind the Nuclear Regulatory Commission ("NRC')* not to certify the emergency evacuation plan fol Indian Point, which the four surrounding countics Westchester, Rockland. Orange :ind Putrnan and New York State haye not certified.

SlGNATURE NNAMEIGROUP POSITJONJTITLE 7OWN/ COUNTY

Y i:=/

O MILIUN B !A1WW HeA.i Joseph F. Picciano Acting Regional Director Federal Emergency Management Agency RE: INDIAN POINT RADIOLOGICAL EVACUATION PLAN We, the undersigned are First Responders. We include Police Officers, Fire Fighters, EMS Workers, Transportation Workers, School Adminlstrators, Educators. Doctors and Nurses In the communities within the 10-mile Emergency Evacuation Zone or the 50-mile peak injury zone around the Indian Point Nuclear Power Facility.

The Report by James Lee Witt Associates commissioned by Governor Pataki, has clearly determined that the existing emergency evacuation plan in Inadequate to protect the public health and safety. The four surrounding counties - Westchester, Rockland, Orange and Putmar - and the State of New York have rehued to certify the evacuation plan because of the broad range of deficiencies identified.

We WIll do our utmost to make sure that the evacuation plan Is executed as best as Is humanly possible.

However, the large population, the lack of infrastructure, and the limited resources of this region make it hard to foresee a successful evacuation without casualties, regardless of the cause of a significant radiological release.

We are concerned that even our best efforts may not be enough to adequately protect the public health and safety of the citizens of this region.

In conclusion, we request that the Federal Emergency Management Agency CFEMA") and the Nuclear Regulatory Commission ("NRC') not certify the emergency evacuation plan for Indian Point.

21 Perlman Dr., Spring Valley, NY 10977 I

VIIlf-l 0

nM,.rIAMU VA(ah-U2 Joseph F. Plcclano Acting Regional Director Federal Emergency Management Agency RE: INDIAN POINT RADIOLOGICAL EVACUATION PLAN We, the undersigned are First Responders. We include Police Officers, Fire Fighters, EMS Workers, Transportation Workers, School Administrators, Educators, Doctors and Nurses in the communities within the 10-mile Emergency Evacuation Zone or the 50-mile peak injury zone around the Indian Point Nuclear Power Facility.

The Report by James Lee Witt Associates commissioned by Governor Pataki, has clearly determined that the existing emergency evacuation plan In inadequate to protect the public health and safety. The four surrounding countie - Westchooter, Rockiand, Orange and Putnan - and the State of Now York have refused to certify the evacuation plan because of the broad range of deficiencies Identified.

We will do our utmost to make sure that the evacuation plan Is executed as best as Is humanly possible.

However, the large population, the lack of Infrastructure, and the limited resources of this region make It hard to foresee a successful evacuation without casualties, regardless of the cause of a significant radiological release.

We are concerned that even our best efforts may not be enough to adequately protect the public health and safety of the citizens of this region.

In concluslon, we request that the Federal Emergency Management Agency ("FEMA!) and the Nuclear Reulatory Commission ("NRC") not certify the emergency evacuation plan for Indian Point.

TowrilViliapo(

,0-1 Orqanktlton)Grour Po-ltion/Title County I2~f

~I~n Kr 5--'

4e-,-

7iZ, 76 i

,9rJJY2=XrgoC--~fa i-At//--?6Vp<

2~~~R dSj iI I/ AlA

/L's-

)

4 Ftk n

£

,.~

Pc

>9 Fr S

C e L/

5 '

5

• k p1 6

I2--'.

-ktCpjk 7

1 S:t ll j4 S

1 tW l

§{S?

(iZr

(

{/(

J

PI I

>Please retum to Susan Shapiro, 21 Perlman Dr., Spring Valley, NY 10977 I

05/01/2003 13:46 8454252213 HATZOLOH EMS INC PAGE 01 pr 11 oa O3231p ell 914 4

I p.

2 Josph F. Picclano ACt R90ional Director Federal Emergency Maanagement Agency RE: INDALN POINT RADIOLOGICAL EVACUATION PLAN W, the undersigned are First Reaponders. We Include Police Officers, Fire Figfters, EMS Workers, Transportion Workers, School Adminisators, Educators, Doctors and Nurmea In the communities within the 10-mile Emergency Evacuation Zone or the 50-mile peak Injury Zone around the Indian Point Nuclear Power Facily.

The Report by James Lee Witt Associates commissioned by Governor Pataki, has clearly eterminad that the xisting emergency evacuation plan Is Inadequate to prate ths public teat and afiety, The four surrounding counties - Westchestar, Rockland, Orange and Putman - and the State ci New York have refused to cartify the evacuition plan because of the broad range of deflcil iderrdnlod.

We wAll do our utmost to make sur that the evacuation plan is executed as best as Is humrninly possbio.

However, the large population, the lack of infraetruture, and the 1imited resources of this region make It hard to foresee a successful evacuation without casualties, regardless of the cause of a sig -iiicart radiological release.

We are concerned that even our best eforts may not be enough to adequataly protct th FUb hW MGal and WWy of the citizens of this region.

In conclusion, we requ eyti te, the Federal Emergency Management Agency ("FEMA") and Ihe Nuclear Aitgulatory Commission CINRC) not cerfy the emergency evacuation plan for Indian Point

-Please return to Susen Shapirm, 21 Perdman Dr., Spring Valley, NY 10977

Joseph F. Picciano Acting Regional Director Federal Emergency Management Agency RE: INDIAN POINT RADIOLOGICAL EVACUATION PLAN We, the undersigned are First Responders. We include Police Officers, Fire Fighters, EMS Workers, Transportation Workers/School Administrators, Educators, Doctors and Nurses in the communities within the 10-mile Emergency Evacuation Zone or the 50 mile peak injury zone around the Indian Point Nuclear Facility.

The Report by James Lee Witt Associates commissioned by Governor Pataki, has clearly determined that the existing emergency evacuation plan is inadequate to protect the public health and safety. The four surrounding counties, Westchester, Rockland, Orange and Putman, and the State of New York have refused to certify because of the broad range of deficiencies identified.

The large population, the lack of infrastructure, and the limited resources of this region render it impossible to have a successful evacuation regardless of the cause of a significant radiological release.

We are dedicated to our positions as public safety officers and we are also dedicated family members. We are concerned about the potential conflict of interest this could present in an emergency.

In conclusion, we request that the Federal Emergency Management Agency ("FEMA") and the Nuclear Regulatory Commission ("NRC") do not certify the emergency evacuation plan for Indian Point.

SIGNATURE GROUP/

POSITION/

TOWNNILLAGEI ORGANIZATION TITLE COUNTY 2

iv t

_r__/__-

2/

i, M8 *y.g1id."/*'

&..} !aS. s xv9........................

oC f.)f Please return to Susan Shapiro, 21 Perlman Dr., Spring Valley, NY 10977

Joseph F. Picciano Acting Regional Director Federal Emergency Management Agency RE: INDIAN POINT RADIOLOGICAL EVACUATION PLAN We, the undersigned are First Responders. We include Police Officers, Fire Fighters, EMS Workers, Transportation Workers School Administrators, Educators, Doctors and Nurses in the communities within the 10-mile Emergency Evacuation Zone or the 50 mile peak injury zone around the Indian Point Nuclear E aciliy..

The Report by James Lee Witt Associates commissioned by Governor Pataki, has clearly determined that the existing emergency evacuation plan is inadequate to protect the public health and safety. The four surrounding counties, Westchester, Rockland, Orange and Putman, and the State of New York have refused to certify because of the broad range of deficiencies identified.

The large population, the lack of infrastructure, and the limited resources of this region render it impossible to have a successful evacuation regardless of the cause of a significant radiological release.

We are dedicated to our positions as public safety officers and we are also dedicated family members. We are concerned about the potential conflict of interest this could present in an emergency.

In conclusion, we request that the Federal Emergency Management Agency ("FEMA") and the Nuclear Regulatory Commission ("NRC") do not to certify the emergency evacuation plan for Indian Point.

SIGNATURE GROUP/

POSITION/

TOWNNILLAGEI ORGANIZATION TITLE COUNTY 1~

I

• l'; /'

t.,.

Jr ii i

,!(( a1 i

ti,;.

2 7l~i^.cc4e /'L*;72c;&-

.de3dtc k en 47 f

4 i t L tcw' /&

/

t A

c'.,

ILi tit,(e 8 _ LaxC-tAo.

SA?;/1<-129t-VLl(J7'6 ~tL:AM-7 V~,i's <jc SLL/L4AA st3~~

no; @

10/fut ~n4 -

j/L/zX.(A

.ill 86r ~ si'zttXfc-Xde 7Xg.,.,

,4@1J,,'hi -tl:

10~j Ck J

L2 4~

ya -]A1zBe 2 vv~

K4 U y mI\\--aC Please return to Susan Shapiro, 21 Perlman Dr., Spring Valley, NY 10977

Joseph F. Picciano Acting Regional Director Federal Emergency Management Agency RE: INDIAN POINT RADIOLOGICAL EVACUATION PLAN We, the undersigned are First Responders. We include Police Officers, Fire Fighters, EMS Workers, Transportation WorkersSchool Administrators, Educators Doctors and Nurses in the communities within the 10-mile Emergency Evacuation Zone or the 50 mile peak injury zone around the Indian Point Nuclear Facility.

The Report by James Lee Witt Associates commissioned by Governor Pataki, has clearly determined that the existing emergency evacuation plan is inadequate to protect the public health and safety. The four surrounding counties, Westchester, Rockland, Orange and Putman, and the State of New York have refused to certify because of the broad range of deficiencies identified.

The large population, the lack of infrastructure, and the limited resources of this region render it impossible to have a successful evacuation regardless of the cause of a significant radiological release.

We are dedicated to our positions as public safety officers and we are also dedicated family members. We are concerned about the potential conflict of interest this could present in an emergency.

In conclusion, we request that the Federal Emergency Management Agency ("FEMA") and the Nuclear Regulatory Commission ("NRC") do not certify the emergency evacuation plan for Indian Point.

Please return to Susan Shapiro, 21 Perlman Dr., Spring Valley, NY 10977

Joseph F. Picciano Acting Regional Director Federal Emergency Management Agency RE: INDIAN POINT RADIOLOGICAL EVACUATION PLAN We, the undersigned are First Responders. We include Police Officers, Fire Fighters, EMS Workers, Transportation WorkersSchool Administrators, Educators, Doctors and Nurses in the communities within the 10-mile Emergency Evacuation Zone or the 50 mile peak injury zone around the Indian Point Nuclear Facility.

The Report by James Lee Witt Associates commissioned by Governor Pataki, has clearly determined that the existing emergency evacuation plan is inadequate to protect the public health and safety. The four surrounding counties, Westchester, Rockland, Orange and Putman, and the State of New York have refused to certify because of the broad range of deficiencies identified.

The large population, the lack of infrastructure, and the limited resources of this region render it impossible to have a successful evacuation regardless of the cause of a significant radiological release.

We are dedicated to our positions as public safety officers and we are also dedicated family members. We are concerned about the potential conflict of interest this could present in an emergency.

In conclusion, we request that the Federal Emergency Management Agency ("FEMA") and the Nuclear Regulatory Commission ("NRC") do not certify the emergency evacuation plan for Indian Point.

Please return to Susan Shapiro, 21 Perlman Dr., Spring Valley, NY 10977

Joseph F. Picciano Acting Regional Director Federal Emergency Management Agency RE: INDIAN POINT RADIOLOGICAL EVACUATION PLAN We, the undersigned are First Responders. We include Police Officers, Fire Fighters, EMS Workers, Transportation WorkersSchool Administrators, Educators, Doctors and Nurses in the communities within the 10-mile Emergency Evacuation Zone or the 50 mile peak injury zone around the Indian Point Nuclear Facility.

The Report by James Lee Witt Associates commissioned by Governor Pataki, has clearly determined that the existing emergency evacuation plan is inadequate to protect the public health and safety. The four surrounding counties, Westchester, Rockland, Orange and Putman, and the State of New York have refused to certify because of the broad range of deficiencies identified.

The large population, the lack of infrastructure, and the limited resources of this region render it impossible to have a successful evacuation regardless of the cause of a significant radiological release.

We are dedicated to our positions as public safety officers and we are also dedicated family members. We are concerned about the potential conflict of interest this could present in an emergency.

In conclusion, we request that the Federal Emergency Management Agency ("FEMA") and the Nuclear Regulatory Commission ("NRC") do not certify the emergency evacuation plan for Indian Point.

SIGNATURE GROUP/

POSITION/

TOWNNILLAGEI ORGANIZATION TITLE COUNTY 1~ ~

],

1...

iV' t('Sk 2

lr v3 A%

__I_

__e C.

3

/

fto /.A Lac hat P661is 9Job 6P l

&fls

-reo.s dv lClaz w./L k~ silt A

2

/

.g C

-1 L 8/ L'

$0 A

hab Iy7<iJ.;i1 C'. I R~tI(j

.)IILi.,

fivr.

-iTrk~r-- I s...

10 8'i C,v % >--

S cs C.Cuv 5\\e: 5t,:

L) k.

Please return to Susan Shapiro, 21 Perlman Dr., Spring Valley, NY 10977

Joseph F. Picciano Acting Regional Director Federal Emergency Management Agency RE: INDIAN POINT RADIOLOGICAL EVACUATION PLAN We, the undersigned are First Responders. We include Police Officers, Fire Fighters, EMS Workers, Transportation Workers.,School Administrators, Educators, Doctors and Nurses in the communities within the 10-mile Emergency Evacuation Zone or the 50 mile peak injury zone around the Indian Point Nuclear Facility.

The Report by James Lee Witt Associates commissioned by Governor Pataki, has clearly determined that the existing emergency evacuation plan is inadequate to protect the public health and safety. The four surrounding counties, Westchester, Rockland, Orange and Putman, and the State of New York have ref used to certify because of the broad range of deficiencies identified.

The large population, the lack of infrastructure, and the limited resources of this region render it impossible to have a successful evacuation regardless of the cause of a significant radiological release.

We are dedicated to our positions as public safety officers and we are also dedicated family members. We are concerned about the potential conflict of interest this could present in an emergency.

In conclusion, we request that the Federal Emergency Management Agency ("FEMA") and the Nuclear Regulatory Commission ("NRC") do not certify the emergency evacuation plan for Indian Point.

IT T

T Please return to Susan Shapiro, 21 Perlman Dr., Spring Valley, NY 10977

Joseph F. Picciano Acting Regional Director Federal Emergency Management Agency RE: INDIAN POINT RADIOLOGICAL EVACUATION PLAN We, the undersigned are First Responders. We include Police Officers, Fire Fighters, EMS Workers, Transportation WorkersSchool Administrators, Educators, Doctors and Nurses in the communities within the 10-mile Emergency Evacuation Zone or the 50 mile peak injury zone around the Indian Point Nuclear Facility.

The Report by James Lee Witt Associates commissioned by Governor Pataki, has clearly determined that the existing emergency evacuation plan is inadequate to protect the public health and safety. The four surrounding counties, Westchester, Rockland, Orange and Putman, and the State of New York have refused to certify because of the broad range of deficiencies identified.

The large population, the lack of infrastructure, and the limited resources of this region render it impossible to have a successful evacuation regardless of the cause of a significant radiological release.

We are dedicated to our positions as public safety officers and we are also dedicated family members. We are concerned about the potential conflict of interest this could present in an emergency.

In conclusion, we request that the Federal Emergency Management Agency ("FEMA") and the Nuclear Regulatory Commission ("NRC") do not certify the emergency evacuation plan for Indian Point.

F SIGNATURE GROUP/

POSITION/

TOWNNILLAGE/

ORGANIZATION TITLE COUNTY.

F A.

e l

3 oz g)-y4

/Cl

_Huf g 4_

,~' ~ r 7

4 l -

7 5"AS(etA 6\\J Please return to Susan Shapiro, 21 Perlman Dr., Spring Valley, NY 10977

Joseph F. Picciano Acting Regional Director Federal Emergency Management Agency RE: INDIAN POINT RADIOLOGICAL EVACUATION PLAN We, the undersigned are First Responders. We include Police Officers, Fire Fighters, EMS Workers, Transportation WorkersSchool Administrators, Educators, Doctors and Nurses in the communities within the 10-mile Emergency Evacuation Zone or the 50 mile peak injury zone around the Indian Point Nuclear Facility.

The Report by James Lee Witt Associates commissioned by Governor Pataki, has clearly determined that the existing emergency evacuation plan is inadequate to protect the public health and safety. The four surrounding counties, Westchester, Rockland, Orange and Putman, and the State of New York have refused to certify because of the broad range of deficiencies identified.

The large population, the lack of infrastructure, and the limited resources of this region render it impossible to have a successful evacuation regardless of the cause of a significant radiological release.

We are dedicated to our positions as public safety officers and we are also dedicated family members. We are concerned about the potential conflict of interest this could present in an emergency.

In conclusion, we request that the Federal Emergency Management Agency ("FEMA") and the Nuclear Regulatory Commission ("NRC") do not certify the emergency evacuation plan for Indian Point.

irn to Susan Shapiro, 21 Perlman Dr., Spring Valley, NY 10977

Joseph F. Picciano Acting Regional Director Federal Emergency Management Agency RE: INDIAN POINT RADIOLOGICAL EVACUATION PLAN We, the undersigned are First Responders. We include Police Officers, Fire Fighters, EMS Workers, Transportation Workers School Administrators, Educators, Doctors and Nurses in the communities within the 10-mile Emergency Evacuation Zone or the 50 mile peak injury zone around the Indian Point Nuclear Facility.

The Report by James Lee Witt Associates commissioned by Governor Pataki, has clearly determined that the existing emergency evacuation plan is inadequate to protect the public health and safety. The four surrounding counties, Westchester, Rockland, Orange and Putman, and the State of New York have refused to certify because of the broad range of deficiencies identified.

The large population, the lack of infrastructure, and the limited resources of this region render it impossible to have a successful evacuation regardless of the cause of a significant radiological release.

We are dedicated to our positions as public safety officers and we are also dedicated family members. We are concerned about the potential conflict of interest this could present in an emergency.

In conclusion, we request that the Federal Emergency Management Agency ("FEMA") and the Nuclear Regulatory Commission ("NRC") do not certify the emergency evacuation plan for Indian Point.

SIGNATURE GROUP/

POSITION/

TOWNNILLAGE/

ORGANIZATION TITLE COUNTY 1

f£ eC v'S Alo a C f.1,

v. A or Igtr -- arm--

t~r?) <

ia T AT-

___T_

__A-T

-(d(

4 rt. 1 ct 6

>1 T

7 47d4 ra A,4 7

8 8_

/{U1'-? 7r

> 4 1 WN 7,,

JS

_Ng X_ -1 1

A 9, 'd-8 10 si/

C°ad~~g/oh^

Please return to Susan Shapiro, 21 Perlman Dr., Spring Valley, NY 10977

Joseph F. Picciano Acting Regional Director Federal Emergency Management Agency RE: INDIAN POINT RADIOLOGICAL EVACUATION PLAN We, the undersigned are First Responders. We include Police Officers, Fire Fighters, EMS Workers, Transportation Workers,School Administrators, Educators, Doctors and Nurses in the communities within the 10-mile Emergency Evacuation Zone or the 50 mile peak injury zone around the Indian Point Nuclear Facility.

The Report by James Lee Witt Associates commissioned by Governor Pataki, has clearly determined that the existing emergency evacuation plan is inadequate to protect the public health and safety. The four surrounding counties, Westchester, Rockland, Orange and Putman, and the State of New York have refused to certify because of the broad range of deficiencies identified.

The large population, the lack of infrastructure, and the limited resources of this region render it impossible to have a successful evacuation regardless of the cause of a significant radiological release.

We are dedicated to our positions as public safety officers and we are also dedicated family members. We are concerned about the potential conflict of interest this could present in an emergency.

In conclusion, we request that the Federal Emergency Management Agency ("FEMA") and the Nuclear Regulatory Commission ("NRC") do not certify the emergency evacuation plan for Indian Point.

Please return to Susan Shapiro, 21 Perlman Dr., Spring Valley, NY 10977

Joseph F. Picciano Acting Regional Director Federal Emergency Management Agency RE: INDIAN POINT RADIOLOGICAL EVACUATION PLAN We, the undersigned are First Responders. We include Police Officers, Fire Fighters, EMS Workers, Transportation Workers,School Administrators, Educators, Doctors and Nurses In the communities within the 10-mile Emergency Evacuation Zone or the 50 mile peak injury zone around the Indian Point Nuclear Facility.

The Report by James Lee Witt Associates commissioned by Governor Pataki, has clearly determined that the existing emergency evacuation plan is inadequate to protect the public health and safety. The four surrounding counties, Westchester, Rockland, Orange and Putman, and the State of New York have refused to certify because of the broad range of deficiencies identified.

The large population, the lack of Infrastructure, and the limited resources of this region render it impossible to have a successful evacuation regardless of the cause of a significant radiological release.

We are dedicated to our positions as public safety officers and we are also dedicated family members. We are concerned about the potential conflict of interest this could present in an emergency.

In conclusion, we request that the Federal Emergency Management Agency ("FEMA") and the Nuclear Regulatory Commission ("NRC") do not ' certify the emergency evacuation plan for Indian Point.

SIGNATURE GROUP/

POSITION/

TOWNNILLAGE/

ORGANIZATION TITLE COUNTY 2

61, l

o I

.1

.s§c( -. Z t-.'v i' I

i.

/tr ek' af W24v 0

Ae YK!&AN,>4 oWat fc.d 4

l 5

7 8

9 r

tD Please return to Susan Shapiro, 21 Perlman Dr., Spring Valley, NY 10977

Joseph F. Picciano A-ting Regional Director Federal Emergency Management Agency RE: INDIAN POINT RADIOLOGICAL EVACUATION PLAN We. the undersigned are First Responders. We include Police Officers. Fire Fighters. EMS Workers ransoortation Workers,_School Administrators. Educators, Doctors and Nurses in the communities within the10-mile Emergency Evacuation Zone or the 50 mile peak iniury zone around the Indian Point Nuclear The Report by James Lee Witt Associates commissioned by Governor Pataki. has clearly determined that the existing emergency evacuation Alan is inadequale to protect the Dublic health and safety. The four suroundina counties. Westchester. Rockland, Orange and Putman, and the Slate of New York have refjsed to certify because of the broad range of deficiencies identified.

The Garge population, the lack of infrastructure. and the limited resources of this region render it impossible to have a successful evacuation regardless of the cause of a significant radiological release We are dedicated to our positions as public safety professionals and we are also dedicated familt members. We are concerned about the potential conflict of interest this could present in an emergency.

In conclusion. we request that the Federal Emeraencv Management Agency ("FEMA") and the Nuclear

&egulatorv Commission {"NRC") not certify the emergency evacuation plan for Indian Point.

Please return to Susan Shapiro. 21 Perlman Dr.. Spring Valley, NY 10977

Joseph F. Picciano Acting Regional Director Federal Emergency Management Agency RE: INDIAN POINT RADIOLOGICAL EVACUATION PLAN We, the undersigned are First Responders. We include Police Officers, Fire Fighters, EMS Workers, Transportation Workers, School Administrators, Educators, Doctors and Nurses in the communities within the 10-mile Emergency Evacuation Zone or the 50-mile peak injury zone around the Indian Point Nuclear Power Facility.

The Report by James Lee Witt Associates commissioned by Governor Pataki, has clearly determined that the existing emergency evacuation plan is inadequate to protect the public health and safety. The four surrounding counties -- Westchester, Rockland, Orange and Putnam -- and the State of New York have refused to certify the evacuation plan because of the broad range of deficiencies identified.

We will do our utmost to make sure that the evacuation plan is executed as best as is humanly possible.

However, the large population, the lack of infrastructure, and the limited resources of this region make it hard to foresee a successful evacuation without casualties, regardless of the cause of a significant radiological release.

We are concerned that even our best efforts may not be enough to adequately protect the public health and safety of the citizens of this region.

In conclusion, we request that the Federal Emergency Management Agency ("FEMA") and the Nuclear Regulatory Commission ("NRC") not certify the emergency evacuation plan for Indian Point.

TownNillagel Signature Orcanization/Group Position/Title County 11611 f

"I 1,4itzF P

41 A

A-A e

3 -

a

• 4._

'1.

r 2

h,

(

7 8.

qmg, I NW-46t?

Joseph F. Picciano Acting Regional Director Federal Emergency Management Agency RE: INDIAN POINT RADIOLOGICAL EVACUATION PLAN We, the undersigned are-First Responders. We include Police Officers, Fire Fighters, EMS Workers, Transportation Workers, School Administrators, Educators, Doctors and Nurses in the communities within the 10-mile Emergency Evacuation Zone or the 50-mile peak injury zone around the Indian Point Nuclear Power Facility.

The Report by James Lee Witt Associates commissioned by Governor Pataki, has clearly determined that the existing emergency evacuation plan is inadequate to protect the public health and safety. The four surrounding counties -- Westchester, Rockland, Orange and Putnam -- and the State of New York have refused to certify the evacuation plan because of the broad range of deficiencies identified.

We will do our utmost to make sure that the evacuation plan is executed as best as is humanly possible.

However, the large population, the lack of infrastructure, and the limited resources of this region make it hard to foresee a successful evacuation without casualties, regardless of the cause of a significant radiological release.

We are concerned that even our best efforts may not be enough to adequately protect the public health and safety of the citizens of this region.

In conclusion, we request that the Federal Emergency Management Agency ("FEMA") and the Nuclear Regulatory Commission ("NRC") not certify the emergency evacuation plan for Indian Point.

X-Sprlng,.V5lFe-V,-NYfTOD.7-'k

Joseph F. Picciano Acting Regional Director Federal Emergency Management Agency RE: INDIAN POINT RADIOLOGICAL EVACUATION PLAN We, the undersigned are First Responders. We include Police Officers, Fire Fighters, EMS Workers, Transportation Workers, School Administrators, Educators, Doctors and Nurses in the communities within the 10-mile Emergency Evacuation Zone or the 50-mile peak injury zone around the Indian Point Nuclear Power Facility.

The Report by James Lee Witt Associates commissioned by Governor Pataki, has clearly determined that the existing emergency evacuation plan is inadequate to protect the public health and safety. The four surrounding counties -- Westchester, Rockland, Orange and Putnam-and the State of New York have refused to certify the evacuation plan because of the broad range of deficiencies identified.

We will do our utmost to make sure that the evacuation plan is executed as best as is humanly possible.

However, the large population, the lack of Infrastructure, and the limited resources of this region make it hard to foresee a successful evacuation without casualties, regardless of the cause of a significant radiological release.

We are concerned that even our best efforts may not be enough to adequately protect the public health and safety of the citizens of this region.

In conclusion, we request that the Federal Emergency Management Agency ("FEMA") and the Nuclear Regulatory Commission ("NRC") not certify the emergency evacuation plan for Indian Point.

Town/illagel Sinnature rganizationlGroup Position/Title County 2

B y

/

8.

9 10

>Please return to Susan Shapiro, 21 Perlman Dr., Spring Valley, NY 10977

Joseph F. Picciano Acting Regional Director Federal Emergency Management Agency RE: INDIAN POINT RADIOLOGICAL EVACUATION PLAN We, the undersigned are First Responders. We include Police Officers, Fire Fighters, EMS Workers, Transportation Workers, School Administrators, Educators, Doctors and Nurses in the communities within the 10-mile Emergency Evacuation Zone or the 50-mile peak injury zone around the Indian Point Nuclear Power Facility.

The Report by James Lee Witt Associates commissioned by Governor Pataki, has clearly determined that the existing emergency evacuation plan is inadequate to protect the public health and safety. The four surrounding counties -- Westchester, Rockland, Orange and Putnam-and the State of New York have refused to certify the evacuation plan because of the broad range of deficiencies identified.

We will do our utmost to make sure that the evacuation plan is executed as best as is humanly possible.

However, the large population, the lack of infrastructure, and the limited resources of this region make it hard to foresee a successful evacuation without casualties, regardless of the cause of a significant radiological release.

We are concerned that even our best efforts may not be enough to adequately protect the public health and safety of the citizens of this region.

In conclusion, we request that the Federal Emergency Management Agency ("FEMA") and the Nuclear Regulatory Commission ("NRC") not certify the emergency evacuation plan for Indian Point.

TownNillaie/

Signature Organization/Group Position/Title County 21 A

~;t; W"l l

-\\ '\\t)A\\W C ((C&

k i p~r-lV-3 4

5 6

7 9

1 0

>Please return to Susan Shapiro, 21 Perlman Dr., Spring Valley, NY 10977

Joseph F. Picciano Acting Regional Director Federal Emergency Management Agency RE: INDIAN POINT RADIOLOGICAL EVACUATION PLAN We, the undersigned are First Responders. We include Police Officers, Fire Fighters, EMS Workers, Transportation Workers, School Administrators, Educators, Doctors and Nurses in the communities within the 10-mile Emergency Evacuation Zone or the 50-mile peak injury zone around the Indian Point Nuclear Power Facility.

The Report by James Lee Witt Associates commissioned by Governor Pataki, has clearly determined that the existing emergency evacuation plan is inadequate to protect the public health and safety. The four surrounding counties - Westchester, Rockland, Orange and Putnam-and the State of New York have refused to certify the evacuation plan because of the broad range of deficiencies identified.

We will do our utmost to make sure that the evacuation plan is executed as best as is humanly possible.

However, the large population, the lack of Infrastructure, and the limited resources of this region make it hard to foresee a successful evacuation without casualties, regardless of the cause of a significant radiological release.

We are concerned that even our best efforts may not be enough to adequately protect the public health and safety of the citizens of this region.

In conclusion, we request that the Federal Emergency Management Agency ("FEMA") and the Nuclear Regulatory Commission ("NRC") not certify the emergency evacuation plan for Indian Point.

TownlVillagel Siqnature Org anization/Group PositionlTitle CountW

-F 9-

._f C

__.AL.

a AILS' Ka'PL.

-s':a t21o 6

\\/4ol 10

>Please return to Susan Shapiro, 21 Perlman Dr., Spring Valley, NY 10977