ML20249C544

Documents Ongoing Problems State Having in Obtaining Relevant Info That Applicant,Private Fuel Storage,Submits to Nrc.W/Certificate of Svc.Related Correspondence

ML20249C544
Person / Time
Site:	07200022
Issue date:	06/26/1998
From:	Chancellor D UTAH, STATE OF
To:	Silberg J AFFILIATION NOT ASSIGNED, SHAW, PITTMAN, POTTS & TROWBRIDGE
References
CON-#298-19263 ISFSI, NUDOCS 9806300279
Download: ML20249C544 (6)

Text

__

e r "es, l

l STATE OF UTAH l [93N OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENER AL I

l p "*g DOCKETED USNRC cf'

'Mt0W#

\\.,,,,. [o 98 JUN 29 P4 :55 J AN GR AH AM Q[g ATTORNEY GENER AL

, %, I l

CAROL CLAWSON REED RicHARDS

' '~

PALMER DEPALIus Soicrior General Chief Deputy Anorney General Chetof Staff June 26,1998 I

Sent Via first class mail and e-mail to: Jay _Silberg@shawpittman.com Jay Silberg, Esq Shaw, Pittman, Potts & Trowbridge 2300 N Street, N. W.

Washington, DC 20037-8007 i

l Information Submitted to NRC Staff By and On Behalf of PFS re:

DearJay:

l l

It was my understanding that once the State was admitted as a party to the PFS licensing proceeding, the State would receive a copy of everything the Applicant submitted to the NRC. The purpose of this letter is to document the ongoing problems the State is having l

in obtaining relevant information that the Applicant submits to the NRC. Initially, the State l

did not receive the Applicant's responses to the Staff's first Request for Additional l

Information (RIA). I think Stone and Webster has forwarded to me all the responses l

submitted on behalf of the Application, except the proprietary information. You confirmed l

to me that the Applicant's corporate counsel is drawing up an agreement between the State and the Applicant to allow the State access to proprietary and confidential information submitted by Applicant to the NRC Staff.

During the June 17,1998, safeguards prehearing conference, the State found out that l

the Applicant wrote to NRC on May 18,1998, about scheduling prioritization of fuel storage at the PFS facility. The Applicant did not send a copy of the letter to the State. The State does not have a copy of the following documents, including the foregoing letter, which have y

recently been accessioned in the Public Document Room (PDR):

I 1.

May 18,1998. J. D. Parkyn to Office of Material Safety & Safeguards. Confirms oral information responsive to Item 1 on 3/11/98 RAI and response to Item 2 of letter re appropriate scheduling prioritization of PFS, LLC application review (estimated 6 pages).

l 9906300279 990626 4

i PDR ADOCK 07200022

(

C PM f

160 East 300 South,5th Floor, P.o. Box 140873, Salt Lake City, Utah 84114 0873 l

Telephone: (801) 366-0290 Facsimile: (801) 366-0292 i

]

Jay Silberg, Esq June 26,1998 Page 2 I

I

. 2.

May 22,1998. J. D. Parkyn to the Office of Nuclear Materials Safety & Safeguards forwarding replacement pages to Rev 1 of PFS's SAR and Emergency Plan.

j 3.

May 22,1998.. Replacement pages to Rev.1 of the PFS SAR (estimated 42 pages).

4.

May 22,1998. Replacement pages to Rev.1 of the PFS Emergency Plan (estimated 211

- pages).

A copy of a printout from the PDR showing the above four items is enclosed.-

There can be absolutely no doubt that all four items are necessary to the State's

- effective participation in this proceeding. It is obvious that whatever system you have devised j

for forwarding to the State (and for that matter, other panies to the proceeding) information submitted by o; on behalf of the Applicant to the NRC Staffisn't working. It is tedious to have to review the PDR listings and make ongoing requests to you for information. Please -

advise what can be done to rectify this problem.

Sincer y,

>A Denise Chancellor Assistant Attorney General l

enclosure: as stated

, cc:

PFS Service List 3

1 i

-e 1

l-u L-

L

)

+

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

-00CKETj USNRs L

I hereby certify that a copy of Denise Chancellor's June 26,1998 letter to Jay Silberg

'98 JN 29

~ re information Submitted to NRC Staff By and On Behalf of PFS was served on the persons l

listed below by electronic mail (unless otherwise noted) with conforming copies by United Ogg.

ADJUDCATON.

l States mail first class, this 26th day of June,1998:

i Attn: Docketing & Services Branch.

Sherwin E. Turk, Esq.

, Secretary of the Commission Catherine L. Marco, Esq.

U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission -

Office of the General Counsel-L.

Mail Stop: 016G15 Mail Stop 15 B18 l

11555 Rockville Pike, One White Flint U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Northu Washington, DC 20555 Rockville, MD 20852-2738 E-Mail: pfscase@nrc. gov.

(two copies) l l-E-mail: secy@nrc. gov Ernest L. Blake,Jr.

l-Shaw, Pittman, Potts & Trowbridge G. Paul Bollwerk,III, Chairman.

2300 N Street, N. W.

L AdministrativeJudge Washington, DC 20037-8007 ;

p Atomic Safety and Licensing Board E-Mail: Jay _Silberg@shawpittman.com l

U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 Clayton J. Parr, Esq.

- E-Mail: gpb@nrc. gov '

Parr, Waddoups, Brown, Gee & Loveless 185 South State Street, Suite 1300 j

~Dr. Jerry R. Kline ~

P. O. Box 11019 i

. AdministrativeJudge Salt Lake City, Utah 84147-0019

' Atomic Safety and Licensing Board E-Mail: karenj@pwlaw.com

U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission l

Washington, DC 20555 John Paul Kennedy, Sr., Esq.

j L

1 L

E-Mail: jrk2@nrc. gov 1385 Yale Avenue -

~

Salt Lake City, Utah 84105 Dr. Peter S. Lam E-Mail: john @kennedys.org AdministrativeJudge Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Richard E. Condit, Esq.

~ U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Land and Water Fund of the Rockies i

Washington, DC 20555 2260 Baseline Road, Suite 200 1

i E-Mail: psl@nrc. gov Boulder, Colorado 80302 E-Mail: rcondit@lawfund.org 4

I-l L

I 1

l 1.

' Joro Walker, Esq.

Richard ' Wilson

. Land and Water Fund of the Rockies Department of Physics 165 South Main, Suite 1 -

Harvard University Salt Lake City, Utah 84111 Cambridge, Massachusetts 02138

.E-Mail: joro61@inconnect.com E-mail: wilson @huhepl. harvard.edu Danny Quintana, Esq.

James M. Cutchin Danny Quintana & Associates, P.C.

Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel 50 West Broadway, Fourth Floor U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Salt Lake City, Utah 84101 Washington, D.C. 20555-0001 E-Mail: quintana @xmission.com E-Mail: jmc3@nrc. gov (electronic copy only)

Martin S. Kaufman, Esq.

L Atlantic Legal Foundation Office of the Commission Appellate 205 E. 42nd Street Adjudication New York, New York 10017 Mail Stop: 16-G-15 OWFN E-mail: mskaufman@ yahoo.com U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 (United States mail,first class only)

)

s

~

Denis'e ChancelloF Assistant Attorney General State of Utah i

k 1

8

_-,,,,c l

BRS Printout from the 3TRC Public Document Room 8:30 AM MON., 15 JUNE, 1998 PRIVATE FUEL STORAGE ACCESSIONED 5/24/98 - 5/30/98 9

10217/6248#1 L

ACN 9805290259 DATE:

980515 EST PAGES:

1

~

L1:

DISCUMES SECURITY ARRANGEMENTS TO BE PROVIDED AT 980602 L2:

ENVIRONMENTAL SCOPING MEETING RE PRIVATE FUEL STORAGE

.L3:

FACILITY.

RN#1:

DELLIGATTI M AN#1:

DONNELL J L RA#1:

NOMA /90FFICE OF NUCLEAR MATERIAL SAFRTY & SAFEGUARDS AA#1:

E*******/?

10217/6247#2 ACN:

9805290258.

DATE:

980522' g

EST PAGES:

42

~

L1:

REPLACEMENT PAGES TO REV 1 OF ' PRIVATE FUEL STORAGE FACILITY L2:

EMERGENCY PLAN.'

AA#1:

E*******/?

10217/6246#3 ACN:

9805290257 DATE:

980522 EST PAGES:

211

~

L1:

REPLACE!GNT PAGES TO REV 1 OF ' PRIVATE FUEL STORAGE FACILITY L2:

SAR.'

AA#1:

E*******/?

10217/6245#4 ACN:-

9805290256 DATE:-

980522 EST_PAGES:,,

2 j

L1:

PORWARDS REPLACEMENT PAGES TO REV 1-OF PRIVATE FUEL L2 STORAGE FACILITY SAR & EMERGENCY PIAN INCORPORATING INPO L3 AS NOTED IN 980519 RESPONSE To RAI.

l L

RPT:

TAC-L22462 LAN#1:

PARKYN J D

.,u#1 :

NOMA /eOFFICE OF NUCLEAR MATERIAL SAFETY & SAFBGUARDS

'AA41:

B*******/?

10217/6150#5-ACN:

9805290164 DATEt 980519 EST_ PAG 88:

'140 L1: '

FORWARDS RESPONSES TO 980401 RAI RE PRIVATE FUEL STORAGE L2:

FACILITY. PROPRIETARY RESPONSES WILL BE SUBMITTED UNDER 1

L3:

SEPARATE COVER.

L, RPT:

TAC-L22462 L~

AN#12:

PARKYN J D I

,RA#13-NOMA /90FFICE OF NUCLEAR MATERIAL SAFETY E SAFEGUARDS

.AA#1 E*******/?

• =,

i I

V i

i i

i-i

<> ~ m mv e v m eu BRS Printout from the NRC Public Document Room 8:30 AM MON., 15 JUNE, 1998 PRIVATE FUEL STORAGE ACCESSIONED 5/24/98 - 5/30/98 9

10217/5781#6.

ACN:

9805280099

-.DATE:-

980519

. EST PAGES:

67

~

L1:

TRANSCRIPT OF PRIVATE FUEL STORAGE PREHEARING CONFERENCE ON L2 3.

980519.PP 836-900.

FICHE:

A3569:001-A3569:069 RPT:

ASB-300-293, ISPSI l

AA#1:

NASLP/4 ATOMIC SAFETY & LICENSING BOARD PANEL 10217/5773#7 ACN : '

9805280091 l

DATE:.

980526 EST PAGES:-

1

~

L1:

INFORMS.THAT FINAL RULE ADOPTING REVISED PHYSICAL SECURITY L2:

PLAN REQUIREMENTS FOR AMAY-FROM-REACTOR ISPSIS NAS RECENTLY L3:

- PUBLISHED IN FR '(63 FR26955 ON 980515). FINAL RULE IS

'L4:

EFFECTIVE. ON 981112.

FICHE:-

A3568:307-A3568:307

'RPT:

ISFSI-PSP-RN#1:

MOORE T S AN#1:

TURK S E.

RA#1:

NASLP/eATOMIC SAFETY-& LICENSING BOARD PANEL

~AA#1:

NRCGC/00FFICE OF THE GENERAL. COUNSEL (POST 860701)

\\

10217/5183#8 l

ACN:-

9805260289 DATE:

980518 EST PAGES:

6 k~~ j

~

.L1:

CCSTFIRMS ORAL INFO RESPONSIVE TO ITEM 1 ON 980311 RAI &

I

.L2:

RECPONSE TO ITEM 2'OF LTR RE APPROPRIATE SCHEDULING L3:

PRIORITIZATION OF PRIVATE FUEL STORAGE. LLC APPLICATION L4:'

REVIEN.

1 FICHE:

A3667:336-A3667:341 LRPT:

TAC-L22462 AN#1:-

PARKYN J D RAW 1: -

NOMA /eOFFICE OF NUCLEAR MATERIAL SAFETY & SAFEGUARDS AAW1 E*******/7 J

10217/5117#9 ACN -

9805260207 l

DATE:

980514 EST_PAGES:

_22 L1 ^ '

NRC STAFF BRIEF IN RESPONSE TO APPLICANT BRIEF ON APPEAL OF L2:

' ORDER GRANTING CONFEDERATED TRIBES PETITION FOR INTERVENTION L3 2 -

(LEP-98-7).W-CERTIFICATE OF. SVC ENCL.

FICHE:

A3667:188-A3667:231 RPT:-

LBP-98-7 AN#1:-

TURK S E ie RA#1:

NRCC/DCODMISSIONERS (POST 750119) l Ah#1: _

NROGC/40FFICE OF THE GENERAL COUNSEL (POST 860701)

.