2CAN021906, Steam Generator Tube Inspection Report: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
(StriderTol Bot change)
 
Line 17: Line 17:
=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:Entergy Operations, Inc.
{{#Wiki_filter:Entergy Operations, Inc.
1448 S.R. 333 Russellville, AR 72802 Tel 479-858-7826 Timothy L. Arnold Manager, Regulatory Assurance Arkansas Nuclear One 2CAN021906 February 28, 2019 ATTN: Document Control Desk U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555-0001
1448 S.R. 333 Russellville, AR 72802 Tel 479-858-7826  
 
Timothy L. Arnold Manager, Regulatory Assurance Arkansas Nuclear One 2CAN021906 February 28, 2019 ATTN: Document Control Desk U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555-0001  


==Subject:==
==Subject:==
Steam Generator Tube Inspection Report Arkansas Nuclear One, Unit 2 Docket No. 50-368 Renewed Facility Operating License No. NPF-6
Steam Generator Tube Inspection Report Arkansas Nuclear One, Unit 2 Docket No. 50-368 Renewed Facility Operating License No. NPF-6  


==Dear Sir or Madam:==
==Dear Sir or Madam:==
Entergy Operations, Inc. (Entergy) inspected the Arkansas Nuclear One, Unit 2 (ANO-2) Steam Generator (SG) tubes during the Fall 2018 refueling outage (2R26) in accordance with ANO-2 Technical Specification (TS) 6.5.9, "Steam Generator (SG) Program." ANO-2 TS 6.6.7, "Steam Generator Tube Inspection Report," requires that the results of inspections performed during the report period be submitted to the NRC within 180 days after the initial entry into Mode 4. The initial entry into Mode 4 post-2R26 occurred on November 13, 2018. The required inspection report is provided as an Enclosure to this letter.
Entergy Operations, Inc. (Entergy) inspected the Arkansas Nuclear One, Unit 2 (ANO-2) Steam Generator (SG) tubes during the Fall 2018 refueling outage (2R26) in accordance with ANO-2 Technical Specification (TS) 6.5.9, "Steam Generator (SG) Program." ANO-2 TS 6.6.7, "Steam Generator Tube Inspection Report," requires that the results of inspections performed during the report period be submitted to the NRC within 180 days after the initial entry into Mode 4. The initial entry into Mode 4 post-2R26 occurred on November 13, 2018. The required inspection report is provided as an Enclosure to this letter.
The 2R26 inspection performed on both SGs involved an initial full-length bobbin coil examination of 100%.
The 2R26 inspection performed on both SGs involved an initial full-length bobbin coil examination of 100%.
This submittal completes the reporting requirements of the ANO-2 TSs for this inspection. This submittal contains no regulatory commitments.
This submittal completes the reporting requirements of the ANO-2 TSs for this inspection. This submittal contains no regulatory commitments.  


2CAN021906 Page 2 of 2 Should you have any questions, please Contact Timothy L. Arnold, Manager, Regulatory Assurance at 479-858-7826.
2CAN021906 Page 2 of 2 Should you have any questions, please Contact Timothy L. Arnold, Manager, Regulatory Assurance at 479-858-7826.
Respectfully, ORIGINAL SIGNED BY TIMOTHY L. ARNOLD TLA/rwc
Respectfully, ORIGINAL SIGNED BY TIMOTHY L. ARNOLD TLA/rwc  


==Enclosure:==
==Enclosure:==
Arkansas Nuclear One, Unit 2 Steam Generator 180 Day Inspection Report cc:   Mr. Scott A. Morris Regional Administrator U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Region IV 1600 East Lamar Boulevard Arlington, TX 76011-4511 NRC Senior Resident Inspector Arkansas Nuclear One P. O. Box 310 London, AR 72847 U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Attn: Mr. Thomas Wengert MS O-08B1A One White Flint North 11555 Rockville Pike Rockville, MD 20852
Arkansas Nuclear One, Unit 2 Steam Generator 180 Day Inspection Report cc:
Mr. Scott A. Morris Regional Administrator U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Region IV 1600 East Lamar Boulevard Arlington, TX 76011-4511 NRC Senior Resident Inspector Arkansas Nuclear One P. O. Box 310 London, AR 72847 U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Attn: Mr. Thomas Wengert MS O-08B1A One White Flint North 11555 Rockville Pike Rockville, MD 20852  


Enclosure 2CAN021906 Arkansas Nuclear One, Unit 2 Steam Generator 180 Day Inspection Report (17 pages)
Enclosure 2CAN021906 Arkansas Nuclear One, Unit 2 Steam Generator 180 Day Inspection Report (17 pages)  


Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 1 of 17 ARKANSAS NUCLEAR ONE, UNIT 2 STEAM GENERATOR 180 DAY INSPECTION REPORT 1       INTRODUCTION Arkansas Nuclear One, Unit 2 (ANO-2) Technical Specification (TS) 6.6.7 states that a report shall be submitted within 180 days after the initial entry into HOT SHUTDOWN following completion of an inspection performed in accordance with TS 6.5.9, Steam Generator (SG)
Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 1 of 17  
 
ARKANSAS NUCLEAR ONE, UNIT 2 STEAM GENERATOR 180 DAY INSPECTION REPORT 1
INTRODUCTION Arkansas Nuclear One, Unit 2 (ANO-2) Technical Specification (TS) 6.6.7 states that a report shall be submitted within 180 days after the initial entry into HOT SHUTDOWN following completion of an inspection performed in accordance with TS 6.5.9, Steam Generator (SG)
Program. The report shall include:
Program. The report shall include:
: a. The scope of inspections performed on each SG,
: a. The scope of inspections performed on each SG,
Line 43: Line 48:
: d. Location, orientation (if linear), and measured sizes (if available) of service induced indications,
: d. Location, orientation (if linear), and measured sizes (if available) of service induced indications,
: e. Number of tubes plugged during the inspection outage for each degradation mechanism,
: e. Number of tubes plugged during the inspection outage for each degradation mechanism,
: f. The number and percentage of tubes plugged to date, and the effective plugging percentage in each SG, and
: f.
The number and percentage of tubes plugged to date, and the effective plugging percentage in each SG, and
: g. The results of condition monitoring, including the results of tube pulls and in-situ testing.
: g. The results of condition monitoring, including the results of tube pulls and in-situ testing.
The operating period for this report includes one refueling outage inspection, 2R26, which started on September 29, 2018, and was the fifth In Service Inspection (ISI) following SG replacement. This report details the results of that inspection.
The operating period for this report includes one refueling outage inspection, 2R26, which started on September 29, 2018, and was the fifth In Service Inspection (ISI) following SG replacement. This report details the results of that inspection.
2       DESIGN The ANO-2 Replacement Steam Generators (RSGs) are Westinghouse Model Delta 109 SGs with 10,637 thermally treated Alloy 690 U-tubes. The tubes have a nominal outside diameter of 0.688 inch and a nominal wall thickness of 0.040 inch. The tubes are hydraulically expanded through the tubesheet thickness, and are supported by eight, broached-hole tube support plates (TSPs). In the U-bend region, the tubes are supported by five sets of staggered Type 405 stainless steel anti-vibration bars (AVBs).
2 DESIGN The ANO-2 Replacement Steam Generators (RSGs) are Westinghouse Model Delta 109 SGs with 10,637 thermally treated Alloy 690 U-tubes. The tubes have a nominal outside diameter of 0.688 inch and a nominal wall thickness of 0.040 inch. The tubes are hydraulically expanded through the tubesheet thickness, and are supported by eight, broached-hole tube support plates (TSPs). In the U-bend region, the tubes are supported by five sets of staggered Type 405 stainless steel anti-vibration bars (AVBs).  


Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 2 of 17 3      REPORT REQUIREMENTS 3.1    The scope of inspections performed on each SG Table 3.1 lists the inspection scope of 2R26.
Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 2 of 17  
TABLE 3.1 SGA Number of Examination Type                                  % Scope Extent Tested Inspections Bobbin                      11079            100%    Full Length 1455 + 20 tubes for Array Hot Leg (HL)                                13.31%    various deposit map Array Cold Leg (CL)                1372          12.38%    various Special Interest 32              -      various Array/+Point SGB Number of Examination Type                                  % Scope Extent Tested Inspections Bobbin                      11070            100%    Full Length 1391 + 20 tubes for Array HL                                    12.75%    various deposit map Array CL                      1340          12.10%    various Special Interest 30              -      various Array/+Point


Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 3 of 17 3.2     Degradation mechanisms found The primary tube degradation mechanism identified was wear at the AVB supports, with a total of two hundred thirty-six indications. Additionally, forty-three wear indications were identified at the TSP. Eleven loose part wear indications were identified, all of which were historical from prior inspections.
3 REPORT REQUIREMENTS 3.1 The scope of inspections performed on each SG Table 3.1 lists the inspection scope of 2R26.
TABLE 3.1 SGA Examination Type Number of Inspections
% Scope Extent Tested Bobbin 11079 100%
Full Length Array Hot Leg (HL) 1455 + 20 tubes for deposit map 13.31%
various Array Cold Leg (CL) 1372 12.38%
various Special Interest Array/+Point 32 various SGB Examination Type Number of Inspections
% Scope Extent Tested Bobbin 11070 100%
Full Length Array HL 1391 + 20 tubes for deposit map 12.75%
various Array CL 1340 12.10%
various Special Interest Array/+Point 30 various
 
Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 3 of 17  
 
3.2 Degradation mechanisms found The primary tube degradation mechanism identified was wear at the AVB supports, with a total of two hundred thirty-six indications. Additionally, forty-three wear indications were identified at the TSP. Eleven loose part wear indications were identified, all of which were historical from prior inspections.
The total number of wear indications in each generator is listed in Table 3.2.
The total number of wear indications in each generator is listed in Table 3.2.
TABLE 3.2 SG             AVB Wear                 TSP Wear                     Loose Part Wear A               124                       17                               8 B               112                       26                               3
TABLE 3.2 SG AVB Wear TSP Wear Loose Part Wear A
124 17 8
B 112 26 3  
 
Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 4 of 17
 
3.3 Nondestructive examination techniques utilized for each degradation mechanism TABLE 3.3 Degradation Mechanism(s)
Probe EPRI ETSS Demonstrated / Extended Applicability Detection Sizing Applicability Bobbin Probe Techniques Support Wear Bobbin 96041.1 (Rev. 5)
App. I AVBs/None Yes CMOA @ AVB 96004.1 (Rev. 13) AVBs, TSPs, and diagonal straps/None Yes CMOA @ TSP Foreign Object Wear Bobbin 27091.2 (Rev. 2)
PLP wear (Part not present)
/PLP Wear (Part present) and volumetric indications Yes Not Recommended.
Size with +Point TM or Array Wear AVB Wear
+Point TM 10908.4 (Rev. 1)
AVBs/Loose part wear with or without part present Yes CMOA @ AVB Array 17908.1 (Rev. 1)
App. I 17908.4 (Rev. 1)
App. I Yes TSP Wear
+Point TM 96910.1 (Rev. 11) Broached TSPs/Loose part wear with or without part present Yes CMOA @ TSP Array 11956.3 (Rev 2) 11956.4 (Rev 2)
Yes Foreign Object Wear
+Point TM 27901.1 (Rev. 1)
Circ groove, Note 1 Detection of Foreign Material based on material and proximity of foreign material to the tube based on EPRI reports 1020631 and 1018561.
For sizing of PLP wear when part is present based on EPRI Report 1020631 on an as needed basis.
CMOA Freespan, expansion transitions and at structures (Part not present) 27902.1 (Rev. 2)
Axial groove, Note 1 27903.1 (Rev. 1)
Tapered football, Note 1 27904.1 (Rev. 2)
Tapered round hole, Note 1 27905.1 (Rev. 2)
Flat wear, Note 1 27906.1 (Rev. 1)
Tapered wear, Note 1 27907.1 (Rev. 2) 45° tapered wear, Note 1
 
Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 5 of 17
 
TABLE 3.3 continued Degradation Mechanism(s)
Probe EPRI ETSS Demonstrated /
Extended Applicability Detection Sizing Applicability Wear Foreign Object Wear Array 17906.3 (Rev. 0) - Circ.
Circ groove, Note 3 Yes CMOA Freespan, expansion transitions and at structures (Part not present) 17902.1 (Rev. 0) - Ax.
Axial groove, Note 3 17903.1 (Rev. 0) - Ax.
Tapered football, Note 3 17904.1 (Rev. 0) - Ax.
Tapered round hole, Note 3 17905.1 (Rev. 0) - Ax.
Flat wear, Note 3 17906.1 (Rev. 0) - Ax.
Tapered wear, Note 3 Pitting Pitting
+Point TM 21998.1 (Rev. 4)
Volumetric in freespan /
Sludge pile Yes CMOA Array 24998.1 (Rev. 1)
Yes No - Size with +Point' Diagnostic Techniques (Note 2)
Various Bobbin Array Various All Locations N/A Notes:
: 1.
Demonstrated applicability for 2790x.1 series includes PLP wear (part not present) and extended applicability for 2790x.1 series includes PLP wear at TTS and TSP (part present).
: 2.
For the purposes of this document, diagnostic techniques are actually EPRI Appendix H and/or I qualified techniques that fall outside of the site validation process. The specific applications where diagnostic techniques will be utilized have been evaluated and determined to be consistent with industry practice. In addition, the data analysis instructions provided in the site Guidelines/ETSS provide the requisite assurance that unexpected degradation mechanisms will be detected and reported.
: 3.
Demonstrated applicability for 1790x.1 series includes PLP wear (part not present) and extended applicability for 1790x.1 series includes PLP wear at TTS and TSP (part present)


Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 4 of 17 3.3    Nondestructive examination techniques utilized for each degradation mechanism TABLE 3.3 Degradation                              Demonstrated / Extended Probe      EPRI ETSS                                          Detection            Sizing Applicability Mechanism(s)                                      Applicability Bobbin Probe Techniques 96041.1 (Rev. 5)
Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 6 of 17  
AVBs/None                      Yes                  CMOA @ AVB App. I Support Wear    Bobbin AVBs, TSPs, and diagonal 96004.1 (Rev. 13)                                        Yes                  CMOA @ TSP straps/None PLP wear (Part not present)                              Not Recommended.
Foreign Object Bobbin  27091.2 (Rev. 2)  /PLP Wear (Part present)              Yes              Size with +Point TM or Wear and volumetric indications                                      Array Wear TM
                +Point    10908.4 (Rev. 1)                                        Yes 17908.1 (Rev. 1) AVBs/Loose part wear with AVB Wear                    App. I                                                                    CMOA @ AVB Array                        or without part present              Yes 17908.4 (Rev. 1)
App. I TM
                +Point    96910.1 (Rev. 11)                                        Yes Broached TSPs/Loose part TSP Wear                11956.3 (Rev 2)    wear with or without part                                  CMOA @ TSP Array                                present                    Yes 11956.4 (Rev 2) 27901.1 (Rev. 1)    Circ groove, Note 1 27902.1 (Rev. 2)    Axial groove, Note 1 Detection of Foreign Tapered football,    Material based on material 27903.1 (Rev. 1)                              and proximity of foreign Note 1 material to the tube based Tapered round hole,      on EPRI reports 1020631      CMOA Freespan, 27904.1 (Rev. 2)
Foreign Object        TM                              Note 1                and 1018561.        expansion transitions and
                +Point Wear                                                                                            at structures (Part not Flat wear,                                            present) 27905.1 (Rev. 2)
Note 1            For sizing of PLP wear when part is present based Tapered wear,        on EPRI Report 1020631 27906.1 (Rev. 1)
Note 1            on an as needed basis.
45° tapered wear, 27907.1 (Rev. 2)
Note 1


Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 5 of 17 TABLE 3.3 continued Demonstrated /
3.4 Location, orientation (if linear), and measured sizes (if available) of service induced indications Service induced indications included wear at the AVBs, TSPs, and due to loose parts. Due to the large number of indications, these are included in Attachment 1 and Attachment 2.
Degradation Probe          EPRI ETSS                Extended                Detection          Sizing Applicability Mechanism(s)
3.5 Number of tubes plugged during the inspection outage for each degradation mechanism Nine tubes were plugged in SG A and three tubes were plugged in SG B during the 2R26 inspection. Details are listed in Table 3.5 below.
Applicability Wear Circ groove, 17906.3 (Rev. 0) - Circ.
TABLE 3.5 SG ROW COL Indication A
Note 3 Axial groove, 17902.1 (Rev. 0) - Ax.
132 73 PTP - 28% @A15 A
Note 3 Tapered football,                               CMOA Freespan, 17903.1 (Rev. 0) - Ax.
132 75 PTP - 33% @A11 A
Foreign Object                                                      Note 3                               expansion transitions and Array                                                              Yes Wear                                                  Tapered round hole,                            at structures (Part not 17904.1 (Rev. 0) - Ax.                                                           present)
133 82 PTP - 34% @A11 A
Note 3 Flat wear, 17905.1 (Rev. 0) - Ax.
138 83 PTP - 39% @ A11 A
Note 3 Tapered wear, 17906.1 (Rev. 0) - Ax.
124 95 PTP - 34% @A15 A
Note 3 Pitting TM
142 115 PTP - PLP @TSH A
                        +Point        21998.1 (Rev. 4)      Volumetric in freespan /        Yes                    CMOA Pitting Array        24998.1 (Rev. 1)            Sludge pile                Yes            No - Size with +Point' Diagnostic Techniques (Note 2)
141 116 PTP - PLP @TSH A
Bobbin Various                              Various              All Locations                            N/A Array Notes:
143 116 PTP - PLP @TSH A
: 1. Demonstrated applicability for 2790x.1 series includes PLP wear (part not present) and extended applicability for 2790x.1 series includes PLP wear at TTS and TSP (part present).
142 117 PTP - PLP @TSH B
: 2. For the purposes of this document, diagnostic techniques are actually EPRI Appendix H and/or I qualified techniques that fall outside of the site validation process. The specific applications where diagnostic techniques will be utilized have been evaluated and determined to be consistent with industry practice. In addition, the data analysis instructions provided in the site Guidelines/ETSS provide the requisite assurance that unexpected degradation mechanisms will be detected and reported.
142 83 PTP - 36% @A11 B
: 3. Demonstrated applicability for 1790x.1 series includes PLP wear (part not present) and extended applicability for 1790x.1 series includes PLP wear at TTS and TSP (part present)
142 91 TBP - 42% @A15 B
6 99 PTP - PLP @TSC


Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 6 of 17 3.4    Location, orientation (if linear), and measured sizes (if available) of service induced indications Service induced indications included wear at the AVBs, TSPs, and due to loose parts. Due to the large number of indications, these are included in Attachment 1 and Attachment 2.
Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 7 of 17  
3.5    Number of tubes plugged during the inspection outage for each degradation mechanism Nine tubes were plugged in SG A and three tubes were plugged in SG B during the 2R26 inspection. Details are listed in Table 3.5 below.
TABLE 3.5 SG        ROW              COL                          Indication A          132              73                        PTP - 28% @A15 A          132              75                        PTP - 33% @A11 A          133              82                        PTP - 34% @A11 A          138              83                        PTP - 39% @ A11 A          124              95                        PTP - 34% @A15 A          142              115                        PTP - PLP @TSH A          141              116                        PTP - PLP @TSH A          143              116                        PTP - PLP @TSH A          142              117                        PTP - PLP @TSH B          142              83                        PTP - 36% @A11 B          142              91                        TBP - 42% @A15 B            6              99                        PTP - PLP @TSC


Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 7 of 17 3.6     The number and percentage of tubes plugged to date, and the effective plugging percentage in each SG Tube plugging during 2R26 and prior outages is detailed below in Table 3.6.
3.6 The number and percentage of tubes plugged to date, and the effective plugging percentage in each SG Tube plugging during 2R26 and prior outages is detailed below in Table 3.6.
TABLE 3.6 SG A                                   SG B Year     Outage     Installed   Cumulative     % Plug     Installed   Cumulative       % Plug 2000     Fabrication     0             0         0.00         1               1           0.01 2000       Baseline       0             0         0.00         0               1           0.01 2002       2R15         0             0         0.00         0               1           0.01 2005       2R17         4             4         0.04         8               9           0.08 2009       2R20         1             5         0.05         4             13           0.12 2014       2R23         5             10         0.09         5             18           0.17 2018       2R26         9             19         0.18         3             21           0.20 3.7     The results of condition monitoring, including the results of tube pulls and in-situ testing All of the AVB, TSP, and foreign object wear indications were less than the condition monitoring limits and therefore met condition monitoring analytically. Additionally, the findings of the 2R26 SG examination were bounded by the behavior projected in the 2R23 operational assessment.
TABLE 3.6 SG A SG B Year Outage Installed Cumulative
There were no tube pulls or in-situ testing performed during 2R26.
% Plug Installed Cumulative  
% Plug 2000 Fabrication 0
0 0.00 1
1 0.01 2000 Baseline 0
0 0.00 0
1 0.01 2002 2R15 0
0 0.00 0
1 0.01 2005 2R17 4
4 0.04 8
9 0.08 2009 2R20 1
5 0.05 4
13 0.12 2014 2R23 5
10 0.09 5
18 0.17 2018 2R26 9
19 0.18 3
21 0.20 3.7 The results of condition monitoring, including the results of tube pulls and in-situ testing All of the AVB, TSP, and foreign object wear indications were less than the condition monitoring limits and therefore met condition monitoring analytically. Additionally, the findings of the 2R26 SG examination were bounded by the behavior projected in the 2R23 operational assessment.
There were no tube pulls or in-situ testing performed during 2R26.  


Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 8 of 17 Attachment 1 Wear Indications - SG A FLAW     ROW COL TWD     LOCATION         ELEVATION COMMENT 1         1 22   9         03C               0.43   TSP 2         2   1 17         02C             -0.07   TSP 3         3 28   9         A01             -0.12   AVB 4         4 181 19         03C                 0     TSP 5         5   2 12         02C                 0     TSP 6         5   2 16         03C             -0.07   TSP 7         43 148 17         A06             2.71     AVB 8         52 175 10         A06             -0.42   AVB 9         52 123   7         A07             0.62     AVB 10         52 39   9         A07             0.32     AVB 11         52 135   9         A07             0.47     AVB 12         52 143 12         A07             0.44     AVB 13         53 34   7         A07                 0     AVB 14         57 174   9         A17             -0.08   AVB 15         59 60 12         A07             -0.19   AVB 16         60 171 12         A07             0.09     AVB 17         60 171   8         A13             -0.23   AVB 18         60 173 15         A16             -0.25   AVB 19         62 13 15         A05               0.2     AVB 20         63 46 10         A14             -0.11   AVB 21         63 10 11         A15             -0.18   AVB 22         64 61   7         A08             0.34     AVB 23         64 67   7         A13             -0.01   AVB 24         65 144   8         A13             -1.63   AVB 25         66 13 10         A05             0.28     AVB 26         70 61   7         A13             -0.21   AVB 27         74 15   8         A05             -0.08   AVB 28         74 167   8         A07             0.14     AVB 29         74 15 16         A18             0.11     AVB 30         77 68   8         A13             0.08     AVB
Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 8 of 17 Wear Indications - SG A FLAW ROW COL TWD LOCATION ELEVATION COMMENT 1
1 22 9
03C 0.43 TSP 2
2 1
17 02C  
-0.07 TSP 3
3 28 9
A01  
-0.12 AVB 4
4 181 19 03C 0
TSP 5
5 2
12 02C 0
TSP 6
5 2
16 03C  
-0.07 TSP 7
43 148 17 A06 2.71 AVB 8
52 175 10 A06  
-0.42 AVB 9
52 123 7
A07 0.62 AVB 10 52 39 9
A07 0.32 AVB 11 52 135 9
A07 0.47 AVB 12 52 143 12 A07 0.44 AVB 13 53 34 7
A07 0
AVB 14 57 174 9
A17  
-0.08 AVB 15 59 60 12 A07  
-0.19 AVB 16 60 171 12 A07 0.09 AVB 17 60 171 8
A13  
-0.23 AVB 18 60 173 15 A16  
-0.25 AVB 19 62 13 15 A05 0.2 AVB 20 63 46 10 A14  
-0.11 AVB 21 63 10 11 A15  
-0.18 AVB 22 64 61 7
A08 0.34 AVB 23 64 67 7
A13  
-0.01 AVB 24 65 144 8
A13  
-1.63 AVB 25 66 13 10 A05 0.28 AVB 26 70 61 7
A13  
-0.21 AVB 27 74 15 8
A05  
-0.08 AVB 28 74 167 8
A07 0.14 AVB 29 74 15 16 A18 0.11 AVB 30 77 68 8
A13 0.08 AVB  


Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 9 of 17 Attachment 1 Wear Indications - SG A FLAW     ROW COL TWD     LOCATION         ELEVATION COMMENT 31         79 162   9         A15             0.28     AVB 32         80 73   7         A09             -0.23   AVB 33         80 117   8         A09             0.02     AVB 34         80 125   8         A09               0     AVB 35         80 115   9         A09             0.87     AVB 36         80 133   9         A09             0.37     AVB 37         80 121 14         A09             0.18     AVB 38         80 87 17         A09             0.98     AVB 39         80 89   8         A12             -0.81   AVB 40         81 62   8         A09             0.25     AVB 41         81 94   9         A09             0.35     AVB 42         83 18 14         A15               -0.2   AVB 43         83 18   7         A17             -0.02   AVB 44         84 111   7         A09               0     AVB 45         84 165 13         A15             0.15     AVB 46         87 108 18         A09             0.22     AVB 47         88 93   9         A09             0.26     AVB 48         89 110   7         A09             0.21     AVB 49         89 96   9         A09             0.03     AVB 50         89 162 13         A14             0.12     AVB 51         96 101 19         A10             0.35     AVB 52         99 82   9         A09             0.04     AVB 53         99 82   8         A16                 0     AVB 54       102 91 11         A09             -0.02   AVB 55       103 94 12         A09             0.05     AVB 56       104 81 13         A17             -0.03   AVB 57       105 50 15         08C               0.43   TSP 58       105 152 10         A12             0.11     AVB 59       105 90 12         A14             0.05     AVB 60       106 27 12         03C               0.46   TSP
Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 9 of 17 Wear Indications - SG A FLAW ROW COL TWD LOCATION ELEVATION COMMENT 31 79 162 9
A15 0.28 AVB 32 80 73 7
A09  
-0.23 AVB 33 80 117 8
A09 0.02 AVB 34 80 125 8
A09 0
AVB 35 80 115 9
A09 0.87 AVB 36 80 133 9
A09 0.37 AVB 37 80 121 14 A09 0.18 AVB 38 80 87 17 A09 0.98 AVB 39 80 89 8
A12  
-0.81 AVB 40 81 62 8
A09 0.25 AVB 41 81 94 9
A09 0.35 AVB 42 83 18 14 A15  
-0.2 AVB 43 83 18 7
A17  
-0.02 AVB 44 84 111 7
A09 0
AVB 45 84 165 13 A15 0.15 AVB 46 87 108 18 A09 0.22 AVB 47 88 93 9
A09 0.26 AVB 48 89 110 7
A09 0.21 AVB 49 89 96 9
A09 0.03 AVB 50 89 162 13 A14 0.12 AVB 51 96 101 19 A10 0.35 AVB 52 99 82 9
A09 0.04 AVB 53 99 82 8
A16 0
AVB 54 102 91 11 A09  
-0.02 AVB 55 103 94 12 A09 0.05 AVB 56 104 81 13 A17  
-0.03 AVB 57 105 50 15 08C 0.43 TSP 58 105 152 10 A12 0.11 AVB 59 105 90 12 A14 0.05 AVB 60 106 27 12 03C 0.46 TSP  


Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 10 of 17 Attachment 1 Wear Indications - SG A FLAW     ROW COL TWD     LOCATION         ELEVATION COMMENT 61       106 107   9         A12             0.18     AVB 62       109 90 17         A08             -0.01   AVB 63       109 90 15         A11             0.23     AVB 64       109 90 11         A16             -0.05   AVB 65       109 90 11         A20             -0.06   AVB 66       112 91   9         A07             0.02     AVB 67       112 91   9         A13             -0.06   AVB 68       114 81   7         A12             -0.08   AVB 69       117 100 13         A09             0.12     AVB 70       119 100 9         A08             -0.02   AVB 71       121 86 24         A09             0.02     AVB 72       121 138 19         A13               0     AVB 73       121 138 11         A16             0.05     AVB 74       123 46   9         A07             0.32     AVB 75       123 46 10         A13             -0.27   AVB 76       123 46 11         A15             -0.38   AVB 77       123 44   9         A17             -0.24   AVB 78       124 83   8         A07               0.6     AVB 79       124 91 10         A11             0.02     AVB 80       124 45 22         A13               0.2     AVB 81       124 47 22         A13             0.25     AVB 82       124 95 26         A13             0.67     AVB 83       124 47 16         A15             0.16     AVB 84       124 95 34         A15               0     AVB 85       124 95 11         A17               0     AVB 86       125 48 24         A13             -0.38   AVB 87       126 113   8         A09             0.08     AVB 88       127 78   9         A09               0     AVB 89       127 78 10         A15             0.45     AVB 90       128 75 18         A11             0.57     AVB
Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 10 of 17 Wear Indications - SG A FLAW ROW COL TWD LOCATION ELEVATION COMMENT 61 106 107 9
A12 0.18 AVB 62 109 90 17 A08  
-0.01 AVB 63 109 90 15 A11 0.23 AVB 64 109 90 11 A16  
-0.05 AVB 65 109 90 11 A20  
-0.06 AVB 66 112 91 9
A07 0.02 AVB 67 112 91 9
A13  
-0.06 AVB 68 114 81 7
A12  
-0.08 AVB 69 117 100 13 A09 0.12 AVB 70 119 100 9
A08  
-0.02 AVB 71 121 86 24 A09 0.02 AVB 72 121 138 19 A13 0
AVB 73 121 138 11 A16 0.05 AVB 74 123 46 9
A07 0.32 AVB 75 123 46 10 A13  
-0.27 AVB 76 123 46 11 A15  
-0.38 AVB 77 123 44 9
A17  
-0.24 AVB 78 124 83 8
A07 0.6 AVB 79 124 91 10 A11 0.02 AVB 80 124 45 22 A13 0.2 AVB 81 124 47 22 A13 0.25 AVB 82 124 95 26 A13 0.67 AVB 83 124 47 16 A15 0.16 AVB 84 124 95 34 A15 0
AVB 85 124 95 11 A17 0
AVB 86 125 48 24 A13  
-0.38 AVB 87 126 113 8
A09 0.08 AVB 88 127 78 9
A09 0
AVB 89 127 78 10 A15 0.45 AVB 90 128 75 18 A11 0.57 AVB  


Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 11 of 17 Attachment 1 Wear Indications - SG A FLAW     ROW COL TWD     LOCATION         ELEVATION COMMENT 91       128 75 17         A15             0.33     AVB 92       132 123 11         07C               0.35   TSP 93       132 127 13         A07             0.07     AVB 94       132 73 11         A09             -0.71   AVB 95       132 75 33         A11             0.46     AVB 96       132 73 28         A15             0.23     AVB 97       133 48 12         08H             -0.44   TSP 98       133 82   8         A09             -0.84   AVB 99       133 82 34         A11             0.38     AVB 100       133 68 15         A13             0.34     AVB 101       133 96 21         A13             0.47     AVB 102       133 68 24         A15             0.37     AVB 103       134 51 13         06H             -0.61   TSP 104       134 87 12         A11             -0.57   AVB 105       134 87 21         A15             0.18     AVB 106       134 87 13         A17             0.12     AVB 107       135 102 18         A07             0.59     AVB 108       135 86   8         A09             -0.67   AVB 109       135 98 13         A09             0.52     AVB 110       135 122 13         A09               0     AVB 111       135 102 26         A09             0.98     AVB 112       135 88 13         A13             0.29     AVB 113       135 102 17         A13             0.49     AVB 114       135 102 23         A15             -0.33   AVB 115       135 102 16         A17               -0.2   AVB 116       136 109 11         A13             0.33     AVB 117       137 74 23         A11             0.39     AVB 118       138 125 12         08H             -0.54   TSP 119       138 55 17         08H             -0.42   TSP 120       138 119 12         A05             0.32     AVB
Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 11 of 17 Wear Indications - SG A FLAW ROW COL TWD LOCATION ELEVATION COMMENT 91 128 75 17 A15 0.33 AVB 92 132 123 11 07C 0.35 TSP 93 132 127 13 A07 0.07 AVB 94 132 73 11 A09  
-0.71 AVB 95 132 75 33 A11 0.46 AVB 96 132 73 28 A15 0.23 AVB 97 133 48 12 08H  
-0.44 TSP 98 133 82 8
A09  
-0.84 AVB 99 133 82 34 A11 0.38 AVB 100 133 68 15 A13 0.34 AVB 101 133 96 21 A13 0.47 AVB 102 133 68 24 A15 0.37 AVB 103 134 51 13 06H  
-0.61 TSP 104 134 87 12 A11  
-0.57 AVB 105 134 87 21 A15 0.18 AVB 106 134 87 13 A17 0.12 AVB 107 135 102 18 A07 0.59 AVB 108 135 86 8
A09  
-0.67 AVB 109 135 98 13 A09 0.52 AVB 110 135 122 13 A09 0
AVB 111 135 102 26 A09 0.98 AVB 112 135 88 13 A13 0.29 AVB 113 135 102 17 A13 0.49 AVB 114 135 102 23 A15  
-0.33 AVB 115 135 102 16 A17  
-0.2 AVB 116 136 109 11 A13 0.33 AVB 117 137 74 23 A11 0.39 AVB 118 138 125 12 08H  
-0.54 TSP 119 138 55 17 08H  
-0.42 TSP 120 138 119 12 A05 0.32 AVB  


Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 12 of 17 Attachment 1 Wear Indications - SG A FLAW     ROW COL TWD     LOCATION         ELEVATION COMMENT 121       138 119 15         A09             -0.28   AVB 122       138 119 14         A11             0.44     AVB 123       138 83 39         A11             -0.49   AVB 124       138 123 15         A13             0.02     AVB 125       138 83 17         A13             -0.32   AVB 126       138 119 12         A15             -0.13   AVB 127       138 97 14         A15             0.34     AVB 128       138 119 10         A19             0.12     AVB 129       139 56   9         A07             0.23     AVB 130       139 114 10         A09             0.05     AVB 131       139 88 14         A09             -0.56   AVB 132       139 88 11         A11             -0.68   AVB 133       139 88 23         A13             -0.44   AVB 134       139 88 18         A15             -0.35   AVB 135       139 88   9         A19             0.06     AVB 136       141 118 10         A09             -0.25   AVB 137       142 61   9         06H               -0.7   TSP 138       142 61 15         08H             -0.41   TSP 139       142 111 26         TSH             27.22     PLP 140       142 119 12         TSH             30.92     PLP 141       142 119   6         TSH             30.26     PLP 142       143 112 11         04H             18.76     PLP 143       143 114 19         08C             0.27     TSP 144       144 119 13         TSH             28.48     PLP 145       146 113 13         TSH             26.83     PLP 146       146 115 11         TSH             26.61     PLP 147       146 115   7         TSH             25.88     PLP 148       148 71 12         03H             -0.52   TSP 149       150 105 13         06H             -0.66   TSP
Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 12 of 17 Wear Indications - SG A FLAW ROW COL TWD LOCATION ELEVATION COMMENT 121 138 119 15 A09  
-0.28 AVB 122 138 119 14 A11 0.44 AVB 123 138 83 39 A11  
-0.49 AVB 124 138 123 15 A13 0.02 AVB 125 138 83 17 A13  
-0.32 AVB 126 138 119 12 A15  
-0.13 AVB 127 138 97 14 A15 0.34 AVB 128 138 119 10 A19 0.12 AVB 129 139 56 9
A07 0.23 AVB 130 139 114 10 A09 0.05 AVB 131 139 88 14 A09  
-0.56 AVB 132 139 88 11 A11  
-0.68 AVB 133 139 88 23 A13  
-0.44 AVB 134 139 88 18 A15  
-0.35 AVB 135 139 88 9
A19 0.06 AVB 136 141 118 10 A09  
-0.25 AVB 137 142 61 9
06H  
-0.7 TSP 138 142 61 15 08H  
-0.41 TSP 139 142 111 26 TSH 27.22 PLP 140 142 119 12 TSH 30.92 PLP 141 142 119 6
TSH 30.26 PLP 142 143 112 11 04H 18.76 PLP 143 143 114 19 08C 0.27 TSP 144 144 119 13 TSH 28.48 PLP 145 146 113 13 TSH 26.83 PLP 146 146 115 11 TSH 26.61 PLP 147 146 115 7
TSH 25.88 PLP 148 148 71 12 03H  
-0.52 TSP 149 150 105 13 06H  
-0.66 TSP  


Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 13 of 17 Attachment 2 Wear Indications - SG B FLAW     ROW COL TWD     LOCATION         ELEVATION COMMENT 1         1 174 10         05C             -0.48   TSP 2         3 84   9         05C             -0.5   TSP 3         4 81 17         05C               0     TSP 4         8 99 14         05C             -0.52   TSP 5         40 177 14         A16             -0.07   AVB 6         42 177 13         A16             -0.03   AVB 7         44 177 14         A16               0     AVB 8         50 41 11         A14             -0.48   AVB 9         52 109   6         A07               0     AVB 10         53 142   7         A07             0.17     AVB 11         55 174   9         A15             -0.34   AVB 12         59 170   7         A07             -0.27   AVB 13         61 164 13         A14             -0.03   AVB 14         64 103   6         A08               0     AVB 15         64 47   8         A08             0.71     AVB 16         69 170 10         A07               0     AVB 17         70 169   7         A05               0     AVB 18         70 169 13         A07               0     AVB 19         75 14 13         03C             -0.45   TSP 20         77 168 12         05C             0.41   TSP 21         77 168   7         06C             0.41   TSP 22         79 118   9         A09             -0.27   AVB 23         80 79 10         A09             0.24     AVB 24         80 95 16         A09             0.33     AVB 25         81 82   7         A14             0.05     AVB 26         82 69   7         A08             -0.17   AVB 27         83 128   7         A09             0.19     AVB 28         86 91   6         A17             -0.49   AVB 29         90 163   8         05C             -0.6   TSP 30         92 161   8         04C             -0.45   TSP
Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 13 of 17 Wear Indications - SG B FLAW ROW COL TWD LOCATION ELEVATION COMMENT 1
1 174 10 05C  
-0.48 TSP 2
3 84 9
05C  
-0.5 TSP 3
4 81 17 05C 0
TSP 4
8 99 14 05C  
-0.52 TSP 5
40 177 14 A16  
-0.07 AVB 6
42 177 13 A16  
-0.03 AVB 7
44 177 14 A16 0
AVB 8
50 41 11 A14  
-0.48 AVB 9
52 109 6
A07 0
AVB 10 53 142 7
A07 0.17 AVB 11 55 174 9
A15  
-0.34 AVB 12 59 170 7
A07  
-0.27 AVB 13 61 164 13 A14  
-0.03 AVB 14 64 103 6
A08 0
AVB 15 64 47 8
A08 0.71 AVB 16 69 170 10 A07 0
AVB 17 70 169 7
A05 0
AVB 18 70 169 13 A07 0
AVB 19 75 14 13 03C  
-0.45 TSP 20 77 168 12 05C 0.41 TSP 21 77 168 7
06C 0.41 TSP 22 79 118 9
A09  
-0.27 AVB 23 80 79 10 A09 0.24 AVB 24 80 95 16 A09 0.33 AVB 25 81 82 7
A14 0.05 AVB 26 82 69 7
A08  
-0.17 AVB 27 83 128 7
A09 0.19 AVB 28 86 91 6
A17  
-0.49 AVB 29 90 163 8
05C  
-0.6 TSP 30 92 161 8
04C  
-0.45 TSP  


Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 14 of 17 Attachment 2 Wear Indications - SG B FLAW     ROW COL TWD     LOCATION         ELEVATION COMMENT 31         92 161 10         05C             0.39   TSP 32         94 161   9         04C             0.45   TSP 33         96 105   6         A10               0     AVB 34         97 158 11         04C             0.45   TSP 35       100 91   7         A07               0     AVB 36       100 25 23         TSC           12.67     PLP 37       105 86 11         A09             -0.37   AVB 38       109 102   7         A05             0.02     AVB 39       109 102 13         A13               0     AVB 40       109 102 26         A18             0.04     AVB 41       109 102 11         A19               0     AVB 42       110 133   8         A16             -0.09   AVB 43       111 108 10         A09             -0.12   AVB 44       111 92 16         A11             0.04     AVB 45       111 102   8         A13               0     AVB 46       111 96 23         A15               0     AVB 47       111 96 17         A16               0     AVB 48       111 96 10         A17               0     AVB 49       112 105   7         A07             0.02     AVB 50       112 149 10         A12             -0.19   AVB 51       112 149   7         A14             -0.21   AVB 52       112 149 17         A18             0.04     AVB 53       113 90 11         A07             0.21     AVB 54       113 92   8         A09               0     AVB 55       113 94 26         A13               0     AVB 56       113 92 15         A14               0     AVB 57       113 92 10         A17               0     AVB 58       115 104 13         A12             0.02     AVB 59       115 92 11         A13               0     AVB 60       115 104 11         A15             0.01     AVB
Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 14 of 17 Wear Indications - SG B FLAW ROW COL TWD LOCATION ELEVATION COMMENT 31 92 161 10 05C 0.39 TSP 32 94 161 9
04C 0.45 TSP 33 96 105 6
A10 0
AVB 34 97 158 11 04C 0.45 TSP 35 100 91 7
A07 0
AVB 36 100 25 23 TSC 12.67 PLP 37 105 86 11 A09  
-0.37 AVB 38 109 102 7
A05 0.02 AVB 39 109 102 13 A13 0
AVB 40 109 102 26 A18 0.04 AVB 41 109 102 11 A19 0
AVB 42 110 133 8
A16  
-0.09 AVB 43 111 108 10 A09  
-0.12 AVB 44 111 92 16 A11 0.04 AVB 45 111 102 8
A13 0
AVB 46 111 96 23 A15 0
AVB 47 111 96 17 A16 0
AVB 48 111 96 10 A17 0
AVB 49 112 105 7
A07 0.02 AVB 50 112 149 10 A12  
-0.19 AVB 51 112 149 7
A14  
-0.21 AVB 52 112 149 17 A18 0.04 AVB 53 113 90 11 A07 0.21 AVB 54 113 92 8
A09 0
AVB 55 113 94 26 A13 0
AVB 56 113 92 15 A14 0
AVB 57 113 92 10 A17 0
AVB 58 115 104 13 A12 0.02 AVB 59 115 92 11 A13 0
AVB 60 115 104 11 A15 0.01 AVB  


Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 15 of 17 Attachment 2 Wear Indications - SG B FLAW     ROW COL TWD     LOCATION         ELEVATION COMMENT 61       116 99   7         A06             0.02     AVB 62       116 99 20         A09             0.02     AVB 63       116 99 15         A12             -0.03   AVB 64       116 57 16         A16             -0.01   AVB 65       116 57   9         A18               0     AVB 66       117 70   8         A10               0     AVB 67       118 97   9         A12               0     AVB 68       120 63 12         A14             -0.01   AVB 69       120 63 11         A16               0     AVB 70       120 63   8         A18               0     AVB 71       122 91 19         A13             0.02     AVB 72       123 40 11         04C             0.43   TSP 73       124 99   7         A09             0.72     AVB 74       124 83   8         A09             0.07     AVB 75       125 46   9         A11             0.2     AVB 76       125 140   9         A11             -0.49   AVB 77       125 56   9         A13             0.43     AVB 78       125 46 13         A13             0.36     AVB 79       125 96 13         A13               0     AVB 80       125 82 14         A13             0.73     AVB 81       125 62 15         A15             0.29     AVB 82       125 96 20         A15               0     AVB 83       125 62 10         A19             0.11     AVB 84       126 85 12         A11             -0.93   AVB 85       128 93 13         A11               0     AVB 86       128 61 20         A11             0.61     AVB 87       128 93   9         A13               0     AVB 88       128 61 10         A15             -0.22   AVB 89       130 133 10         A17             -0.17   AVB 90       131 122   9         08C             0.34   TSP
Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 15 of 17 Wear Indications - SG B FLAW ROW COL TWD LOCATION ELEVATION COMMENT 61 116 99 7
A06 0.02 AVB 62 116 99 20 A09 0.02 AVB 63 116 99 15 A12  
-0.03 AVB 64 116 57 16 A16  
-0.01 AVB 65 116 57 9
A18 0
AVB 66 117 70 8
A10 0
AVB 67 118 97 9
A12 0
AVB 68 120 63 12 A14  
-0.01 AVB 69 120 63 11 A16 0
AVB 70 120 63 8
A18 0
AVB 71 122 91 19 A13 0.02 AVB 72 123 40 11 04C 0.43 TSP 73 124 99 7
A09 0.72 AVB 74 124 83 8
A09 0.07 AVB 75 125 46 9
A11 0.2 AVB 76 125 140 9
A11  
-0.49 AVB 77 125 56 9
A13 0.43 AVB 78 125 46 13 A13 0.36 AVB 79 125 96 13 A13 0
AVB 80 125 82 14 A13 0.73 AVB 81 125 62 15 A15 0.29 AVB 82 125 96 20 A15 0
AVB 83 125 62 10 A19 0.11 AVB 84 126 85 12 A11  
-0.93 AVB 85 128 93 13 A11 0
AVB 86 128 61 20 A11 0.61 AVB 87 128 93 9
A13 0
AVB 88 128 61 10 A15  
-0.22 AVB 89 130 133 10 A17  
-0.17 AVB 90 131 122 9
08C 0.34 TSP  


Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 16 of 17 Attachment 2 Wear Indications - SG B FLAW     ROW COL TWD     LOCATION         ELEVATION COMMENT 91       131 54   8         A13             -0.31   AVB 92       132 83   7         A07             -0.41   AVB 93       132 57   9         A09             -0.25   AVB 94       132 57 23         A11             0.52     AVB 95       132 53 11         A13             0.02     AVB 96       132 57 15         A13             -0.4   AVB 97       133 94 15         A13             0.38     AVB 98       136 53 14         05C             0.47   TSP 99       136 115 14         A09             -0.32   AVB 100       136 115 12         A11             0.56     AVB 101       136 115 22         A13             0.38     AVB 102       136 115 23         A15             -0.18   AVB 103       137 92 10         A09               0     AVB 104       137 92 10         A11             0.58     AVB 105       137 92 17         A15             0.36     AVB 106       138 91 12         A11             0.05     AVB 107       138 105 24         A11             0.5     AVB 108       138 119   9         TSH             1.13   PLP 109       138 119   8         TSH             0.25   PLP 110       139 126 15         08H             -0.64   TSP 111       140 123 13         06H             -0.43   TSP 112       140 121   7         A09             -0.32   AVB 113       140 77 24         A09             -0.45   AVB 114       140 71   9         A11               0     AVB 115       140 99 12         A11             0.54     AVB 116       140 77 13         A11             -0.47   AVB 117       140 77 19         A11             0.51     AVB 118       140 77 20         A13             -0.29   AVB 119       140 71   8         A15             -0.21   AVB 120       140 99   9         A15             0.05     AVB
Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 16 of 17 Wear Indications - SG B FLAW ROW COL TWD LOCATION ELEVATION COMMENT 91 131 54 8
A13  
-0.31 AVB 92 132 83 7
A07  
-0.41 AVB 93 132 57 9
A09  
-0.25 AVB 94 132 57 23 A11 0.52 AVB 95 132 53 11 A13 0.02 AVB 96 132 57 15 A13  
-0.4 AVB 97 133 94 15 A13 0.38 AVB 98 136 53 14 05C 0.47 TSP 99 136 115 14 A09  
-0.32 AVB 100 136 115 12 A11 0.56 AVB 101 136 115 22 A13 0.38 AVB 102 136 115 23 A15  
-0.18 AVB 103 137 92 10 A09 0
AVB 104 137 92 10 A11 0.58 AVB 105 137 92 17 A15 0.36 AVB 106 138 91 12 A11 0.05 AVB 107 138 105 24 A11 0.5 AVB 108 138 119 9
TSH 1.13 PLP 109 138 119 8
TSH 0.25 PLP 110 139 126 15 08H  
-0.64 TSP 111 140 123 13 06H  
-0.43 TSP 112 140 121 7
A09  
-0.32 AVB 113 140 77 24 A09  
-0.45 AVB 114 140 71 9
A11 0
AVB 115 140 99 12 A11 0.54 AVB 116 140 77 13 A11  
-0.47 AVB 117 140 77 19 A11 0.51 AVB 118 140 77 20 A13  
-0.29 AVB 119 140 71 8
A15  
-0.21 AVB 120 140 99 9
A15 0.05 AVB  


Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 17 of 17 Attachment 2 Wear Indications - SG B FLAW     ROW COL TWD     LOCATION         ELEVATION COMMENT 121       140 99 22         A17             0.15     AVB 122       141 60 15         04H             0.39   TSP 123       141 102 10         A09             0.33     AVB 124       142 83 12         A09             0.34     AVB 125       142 91 25         A11             0.02     AVB 126       142 83 36         A11             -0.48   AVB 127       142 83 16         A13             -0.36   AVB 128       142 91 34         A13             0.04     AVB 129       142 91 42         A15             0.07     AVB 130       142 91 20         A17             0.04     AVB 131       142 91 15         A19             0.02     AVB 132       143 62 18         05C             -0.54   TSP 133       143 94 10         A09             0.36     AVB 134       143 90 11         A11             -0.34   AVB 135       144 67   9         05C             0.45   TSP 136       144 67 12         05C             -0.58   TSP 137       144 63 15         05C             -0.54   TSP 138       146 113 11         05H             -0.58   TSP 139       148 109   8         04H             0.52   TSP 140       148 109 11         04H             -0.56   TSP 141       149 86 14         06H             0.37   TSP}}
Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 17 of 17 Wear Indications - SG B FLAW ROW COL TWD LOCATION ELEVATION COMMENT 121 140 99 22 A17 0.15 AVB 122 141 60 15 04H 0.39 TSP 123 141 102 10 A09 0.33 AVB 124 142 83 12 A09 0.34 AVB 125 142 91 25 A11 0.02 AVB 126 142 83 36 A11  
-0.48 AVB 127 142 83 16 A13  
-0.36 AVB 128 142 91 34 A13 0.04 AVB 129 142 91 42 A15 0.07 AVB 130 142 91 20 A17 0.04 AVB 131 142 91 15 A19 0.02 AVB 132 143 62 18 05C  
-0.54 TSP 133 143 94 10 A09 0.36 AVB 134 143 90 11 A11  
-0.34 AVB 135 144 67 9
05C 0.45 TSP 136 144 67 12 05C  
-0.58 TSP 137 144 63 15 05C  
-0.54 TSP 138 146 113 11 05H  
-0.58 TSP 139 148 109 8
04H 0.52 TSP 140 148 109 11 04H  
-0.56 TSP 141 149 86 14 06H 0.37 TSP}}

Latest revision as of 04:33, 5 January 2025

Steam Generator Tube Inspection Report
ML19059A440
Person / Time
Site: Arkansas Nuclear Entergy icon.png
Issue date: 02/28/2019
From: Arnold T
Entergy Operations
To:
Document Control Desk, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
2CAN021906
Download: ML19059A440 (20)


Text

Entergy Operations, Inc.

1448 S.R. 333 Russellville, AR 72802 Tel 479-858-7826

Timothy L. Arnold Manager, Regulatory Assurance Arkansas Nuclear One 2CAN021906 February 28, 2019 ATTN: Document Control Desk U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555-0001

Subject:

Steam Generator Tube Inspection Report Arkansas Nuclear One, Unit 2 Docket No. 50-368 Renewed Facility Operating License No. NPF-6

Dear Sir or Madam:

Entergy Operations, Inc. (Entergy) inspected the Arkansas Nuclear One, Unit 2 (ANO-2) Steam Generator (SG) tubes during the Fall 2018 refueling outage (2R26) in accordance with ANO-2 Technical Specification (TS) 6.5.9, "Steam Generator (SG) Program." ANO-2 TS 6.6.7, "Steam Generator Tube Inspection Report," requires that the results of inspections performed during the report period be submitted to the NRC within 180 days after the initial entry into Mode 4. The initial entry into Mode 4 post-2R26 occurred on November 13, 2018. The required inspection report is provided as an Enclosure to this letter.

The 2R26 inspection performed on both SGs involved an initial full-length bobbin coil examination of 100%.

This submittal completes the reporting requirements of the ANO-2 TSs for this inspection. This submittal contains no regulatory commitments.

2CAN021906 Page 2 of 2 Should you have any questions, please Contact Timothy L. Arnold, Manager, Regulatory Assurance at 479-858-7826.

Respectfully, ORIGINAL SIGNED BY TIMOTHY L. ARNOLD TLA/rwc

Enclosure:

Arkansas Nuclear One, Unit 2 Steam Generator 180 Day Inspection Report cc:

Mr. Scott A. Morris Regional Administrator U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Region IV 1600 East Lamar Boulevard Arlington, TX 76011-4511 NRC Senior Resident Inspector Arkansas Nuclear One P. O. Box 310 London, AR 72847 U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Attn: Mr. Thomas Wengert MS O-08B1A One White Flint North 11555 Rockville Pike Rockville, MD 20852

Enclosure 2CAN021906 Arkansas Nuclear One, Unit 2 Steam Generator 180 Day Inspection Report (17 pages)

Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 1 of 17

ARKANSAS NUCLEAR ONE, UNIT 2 STEAM GENERATOR 180 DAY INSPECTION REPORT 1

INTRODUCTION Arkansas Nuclear One, Unit 2 (ANO-2) Technical Specification (TS) 6.6.7 states that a report shall be submitted within 180 days after the initial entry into HOT SHUTDOWN following completion of an inspection performed in accordance with TS 6.5.9, Steam Generator (SG)

Program. The report shall include:

a. The scope of inspections performed on each SG,
b. Degradation mechanisms found,
c. Nondestructive examination techniques utilized for each degradation mechanism,
d. Location, orientation (if linear), and measured sizes (if available) of service induced indications,
e. Number of tubes plugged during the inspection outage for each degradation mechanism,
f.

The number and percentage of tubes plugged to date, and the effective plugging percentage in each SG, and

g. The results of condition monitoring, including the results of tube pulls and in-situ testing.

The operating period for this report includes one refueling outage inspection, 2R26, which started on September 29, 2018, and was the fifth In Service Inspection (ISI) following SG replacement. This report details the results of that inspection.

2 DESIGN The ANO-2 Replacement Steam Generators (RSGs) are Westinghouse Model Delta 109 SGs with 10,637 thermally treated Alloy 690 U-tubes. The tubes have a nominal outside diameter of 0.688 inch and a nominal wall thickness of 0.040 inch. The tubes are hydraulically expanded through the tubesheet thickness, and are supported by eight, broached-hole tube support plates (TSPs). In the U-bend region, the tubes are supported by five sets of staggered Type 405 stainless steel anti-vibration bars (AVBs).

Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 2 of 17

3 REPORT REQUIREMENTS 3.1 The scope of inspections performed on each SG Table 3.1 lists the inspection scope of 2R26.

TABLE 3.1 SGA Examination Type Number of Inspections

% Scope Extent Tested Bobbin 11079 100%

Full Length Array Hot Leg (HL) 1455 + 20 tubes for deposit map 13.31%

various Array Cold Leg (CL) 1372 12.38%

various Special Interest Array/+Point 32 various SGB Examination Type Number of Inspections

% Scope Extent Tested Bobbin 11070 100%

Full Length Array HL 1391 + 20 tubes for deposit map 12.75%

various Array CL 1340 12.10%

various Special Interest Array/+Point 30 various

Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 3 of 17

3.2 Degradation mechanisms found The primary tube degradation mechanism identified was wear at the AVB supports, with a total of two hundred thirty-six indications. Additionally, forty-three wear indications were identified at the TSP. Eleven loose part wear indications were identified, all of which were historical from prior inspections.

The total number of wear indications in each generator is listed in Table 3.2.

TABLE 3.2 SG AVB Wear TSP Wear Loose Part Wear A

124 17 8

B 112 26 3

Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 4 of 17

3.3 Nondestructive examination techniques utilized for each degradation mechanism TABLE 3.3 Degradation Mechanism(s)

Probe EPRI ETSS Demonstrated / Extended Applicability Detection Sizing Applicability Bobbin Probe Techniques Support Wear Bobbin 96041.1 (Rev. 5)

App. I AVBs/None Yes CMOA @ AVB 96004.1 (Rev. 13) AVBs, TSPs, and diagonal straps/None Yes CMOA @ TSP Foreign Object Wear Bobbin 27091.2 (Rev. 2)

PLP wear (Part not present)

/PLP Wear (Part present) and volumetric indications Yes Not Recommended.

Size with +Point TM or Array Wear AVB Wear

+Point TM 10908.4 (Rev. 1)

AVBs/Loose part wear with or without part present Yes CMOA @ AVB Array 17908.1 (Rev. 1)

App. I 17908.4 (Rev. 1)

App. I Yes TSP Wear

+Point TM 96910.1 (Rev. 11) Broached TSPs/Loose part wear with or without part present Yes CMOA @ TSP Array 11956.3 (Rev 2) 11956.4 (Rev 2)

Yes Foreign Object Wear

+Point TM 27901.1 (Rev. 1)

Circ groove, Note 1 Detection of Foreign Material based on material and proximity of foreign material to the tube based on EPRI reports 1020631 and 1018561.

For sizing of PLP wear when part is present based on EPRI Report 1020631 on an as needed basis.

CMOA Freespan, expansion transitions and at structures (Part not present) 27902.1 (Rev. 2)

Axial groove, Note 1 27903.1 (Rev. 1)

Tapered football, Note 1 27904.1 (Rev. 2)

Tapered round hole, Note 1 27905.1 (Rev. 2)

Flat wear, Note 1 27906.1 (Rev. 1)

Tapered wear, Note 1 27907.1 (Rev. 2) 45° tapered wear, Note 1

Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 5 of 17

TABLE 3.3 continued Degradation Mechanism(s)

Probe EPRI ETSS Demonstrated /

Extended Applicability Detection Sizing Applicability Wear Foreign Object Wear Array 17906.3 (Rev. 0) - Circ.

Circ groove, Note 3 Yes CMOA Freespan, expansion transitions and at structures (Part not present) 17902.1 (Rev. 0) - Ax.

Axial groove, Note 3 17903.1 (Rev. 0) - Ax.

Tapered football, Note 3 17904.1 (Rev. 0) - Ax.

Tapered round hole, Note 3 17905.1 (Rev. 0) - Ax.

Flat wear, Note 3 17906.1 (Rev. 0) - Ax.

Tapered wear, Note 3 Pitting Pitting

+Point TM 21998.1 (Rev. 4)

Volumetric in freespan /

Sludge pile Yes CMOA Array 24998.1 (Rev. 1)

Yes No - Size with +Point' Diagnostic Techniques (Note 2)

Various Bobbin Array Various All Locations N/A Notes:

1.

Demonstrated applicability for 2790x.1 series includes PLP wear (part not present) and extended applicability for 2790x.1 series includes PLP wear at TTS and TSP (part present).

2.

For the purposes of this document, diagnostic techniques are actually EPRI Appendix H and/or I qualified techniques that fall outside of the site validation process. The specific applications where diagnostic techniques will be utilized have been evaluated and determined to be consistent with industry practice. In addition, the data analysis instructions provided in the site Guidelines/ETSS provide the requisite assurance that unexpected degradation mechanisms will be detected and reported.

3.

Demonstrated applicability for 1790x.1 series includes PLP wear (part not present) and extended applicability for 1790x.1 series includes PLP wear at TTS and TSP (part present)

Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 6 of 17

3.4 Location, orientation (if linear), and measured sizes (if available) of service induced indications Service induced indications included wear at the AVBs, TSPs, and due to loose parts. Due to the large number of indications, these are included in Attachment 1 and Attachment 2.

3.5 Number of tubes plugged during the inspection outage for each degradation mechanism Nine tubes were plugged in SG A and three tubes were plugged in SG B during the 2R26 inspection. Details are listed in Table 3.5 below.

TABLE 3.5 SG ROW COL Indication A

132 73 PTP - 28% @A15 A

132 75 PTP - 33% @A11 A

133 82 PTP - 34% @A11 A

138 83 PTP - 39% @ A11 A

124 95 PTP - 34% @A15 A

142 115 PTP - PLP @TSH A

141 116 PTP - PLP @TSH A

143 116 PTP - PLP @TSH A

142 117 PTP - PLP @TSH B

142 83 PTP - 36% @A11 B

142 91 TBP - 42% @A15 B

6 99 PTP - PLP @TSC

Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 7 of 17

3.6 The number and percentage of tubes plugged to date, and the effective plugging percentage in each SG Tube plugging during 2R26 and prior outages is detailed below in Table 3.6.

TABLE 3.6 SG A SG B Year Outage Installed Cumulative

% Plug Installed Cumulative

% Plug 2000 Fabrication 0

0 0.00 1

1 0.01 2000 Baseline 0

0 0.00 0

1 0.01 2002 2R15 0

0 0.00 0

1 0.01 2005 2R17 4

4 0.04 8

9 0.08 2009 2R20 1

5 0.05 4

13 0.12 2014 2R23 5

10 0.09 5

18 0.17 2018 2R26 9

19 0.18 3

21 0.20 3.7 The results of condition monitoring, including the results of tube pulls and in-situ testing All of the AVB, TSP, and foreign object wear indications were less than the condition monitoring limits and therefore met condition monitoring analytically. Additionally, the findings of the 2R26 SG examination were bounded by the behavior projected in the 2R23 operational assessment.

There were no tube pulls or in-situ testing performed during 2R26.

Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 8 of 17 Wear Indications - SG A FLAW ROW COL TWD LOCATION ELEVATION COMMENT 1

1 22 9

03C 0.43 TSP 2

2 1

17 02C

-0.07 TSP 3

3 28 9

A01

-0.12 AVB 4

4 181 19 03C 0

TSP 5

5 2

12 02C 0

TSP 6

5 2

16 03C

-0.07 TSP 7

43 148 17 A06 2.71 AVB 8

52 175 10 A06

-0.42 AVB 9

52 123 7

A07 0.62 AVB 10 52 39 9

A07 0.32 AVB 11 52 135 9

A07 0.47 AVB 12 52 143 12 A07 0.44 AVB 13 53 34 7

A07 0

AVB 14 57 174 9

A17

-0.08 AVB 15 59 60 12 A07

-0.19 AVB 16 60 171 12 A07 0.09 AVB 17 60 171 8

A13

-0.23 AVB 18 60 173 15 A16

-0.25 AVB 19 62 13 15 A05 0.2 AVB 20 63 46 10 A14

-0.11 AVB 21 63 10 11 A15

-0.18 AVB 22 64 61 7

A08 0.34 AVB 23 64 67 7

A13

-0.01 AVB 24 65 144 8

A13

-1.63 AVB 25 66 13 10 A05 0.28 AVB 26 70 61 7

A13

-0.21 AVB 27 74 15 8

A05

-0.08 AVB 28 74 167 8

A07 0.14 AVB 29 74 15 16 A18 0.11 AVB 30 77 68 8

A13 0.08 AVB

Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 9 of 17 Wear Indications - SG A FLAW ROW COL TWD LOCATION ELEVATION COMMENT 31 79 162 9

A15 0.28 AVB 32 80 73 7

A09

-0.23 AVB 33 80 117 8

A09 0.02 AVB 34 80 125 8

A09 0

AVB 35 80 115 9

A09 0.87 AVB 36 80 133 9

A09 0.37 AVB 37 80 121 14 A09 0.18 AVB 38 80 87 17 A09 0.98 AVB 39 80 89 8

A12

-0.81 AVB 40 81 62 8

A09 0.25 AVB 41 81 94 9

A09 0.35 AVB 42 83 18 14 A15

-0.2 AVB 43 83 18 7

A17

-0.02 AVB 44 84 111 7

A09 0

AVB 45 84 165 13 A15 0.15 AVB 46 87 108 18 A09 0.22 AVB 47 88 93 9

A09 0.26 AVB 48 89 110 7

A09 0.21 AVB 49 89 96 9

A09 0.03 AVB 50 89 162 13 A14 0.12 AVB 51 96 101 19 A10 0.35 AVB 52 99 82 9

A09 0.04 AVB 53 99 82 8

A16 0

AVB 54 102 91 11 A09

-0.02 AVB 55 103 94 12 A09 0.05 AVB 56 104 81 13 A17

-0.03 AVB 57 105 50 15 08C 0.43 TSP 58 105 152 10 A12 0.11 AVB 59 105 90 12 A14 0.05 AVB 60 106 27 12 03C 0.46 TSP

Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 10 of 17 Wear Indications - SG A FLAW ROW COL TWD LOCATION ELEVATION COMMENT 61 106 107 9

A12 0.18 AVB 62 109 90 17 A08

-0.01 AVB 63 109 90 15 A11 0.23 AVB 64 109 90 11 A16

-0.05 AVB 65 109 90 11 A20

-0.06 AVB 66 112 91 9

A07 0.02 AVB 67 112 91 9

A13

-0.06 AVB 68 114 81 7

A12

-0.08 AVB 69 117 100 13 A09 0.12 AVB 70 119 100 9

A08

-0.02 AVB 71 121 86 24 A09 0.02 AVB 72 121 138 19 A13 0

AVB 73 121 138 11 A16 0.05 AVB 74 123 46 9

A07 0.32 AVB 75 123 46 10 A13

-0.27 AVB 76 123 46 11 A15

-0.38 AVB 77 123 44 9

A17

-0.24 AVB 78 124 83 8

A07 0.6 AVB 79 124 91 10 A11 0.02 AVB 80 124 45 22 A13 0.2 AVB 81 124 47 22 A13 0.25 AVB 82 124 95 26 A13 0.67 AVB 83 124 47 16 A15 0.16 AVB 84 124 95 34 A15 0

AVB 85 124 95 11 A17 0

AVB 86 125 48 24 A13

-0.38 AVB 87 126 113 8

A09 0.08 AVB 88 127 78 9

A09 0

AVB 89 127 78 10 A15 0.45 AVB 90 128 75 18 A11 0.57 AVB

Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 11 of 17 Wear Indications - SG A FLAW ROW COL TWD LOCATION ELEVATION COMMENT 91 128 75 17 A15 0.33 AVB 92 132 123 11 07C 0.35 TSP 93 132 127 13 A07 0.07 AVB 94 132 73 11 A09

-0.71 AVB 95 132 75 33 A11 0.46 AVB 96 132 73 28 A15 0.23 AVB 97 133 48 12 08H

-0.44 TSP 98 133 82 8

A09

-0.84 AVB 99 133 82 34 A11 0.38 AVB 100 133 68 15 A13 0.34 AVB 101 133 96 21 A13 0.47 AVB 102 133 68 24 A15 0.37 AVB 103 134 51 13 06H

-0.61 TSP 104 134 87 12 A11

-0.57 AVB 105 134 87 21 A15 0.18 AVB 106 134 87 13 A17 0.12 AVB 107 135 102 18 A07 0.59 AVB 108 135 86 8

A09

-0.67 AVB 109 135 98 13 A09 0.52 AVB 110 135 122 13 A09 0

AVB 111 135 102 26 A09 0.98 AVB 112 135 88 13 A13 0.29 AVB 113 135 102 17 A13 0.49 AVB 114 135 102 23 A15

-0.33 AVB 115 135 102 16 A17

-0.2 AVB 116 136 109 11 A13 0.33 AVB 117 137 74 23 A11 0.39 AVB 118 138 125 12 08H

-0.54 TSP 119 138 55 17 08H

-0.42 TSP 120 138 119 12 A05 0.32 AVB

Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 12 of 17 Wear Indications - SG A FLAW ROW COL TWD LOCATION ELEVATION COMMENT 121 138 119 15 A09

-0.28 AVB 122 138 119 14 A11 0.44 AVB 123 138 83 39 A11

-0.49 AVB 124 138 123 15 A13 0.02 AVB 125 138 83 17 A13

-0.32 AVB 126 138 119 12 A15

-0.13 AVB 127 138 97 14 A15 0.34 AVB 128 138 119 10 A19 0.12 AVB 129 139 56 9

A07 0.23 AVB 130 139 114 10 A09 0.05 AVB 131 139 88 14 A09

-0.56 AVB 132 139 88 11 A11

-0.68 AVB 133 139 88 23 A13

-0.44 AVB 134 139 88 18 A15

-0.35 AVB 135 139 88 9

A19 0.06 AVB 136 141 118 10 A09

-0.25 AVB 137 142 61 9

06H

-0.7 TSP 138 142 61 15 08H

-0.41 TSP 139 142 111 26 TSH 27.22 PLP 140 142 119 12 TSH 30.92 PLP 141 142 119 6

TSH 30.26 PLP 142 143 112 11 04H 18.76 PLP 143 143 114 19 08C 0.27 TSP 144 144 119 13 TSH 28.48 PLP 145 146 113 13 TSH 26.83 PLP 146 146 115 11 TSH 26.61 PLP 147 146 115 7

TSH 25.88 PLP 148 148 71 12 03H

-0.52 TSP 149 150 105 13 06H

-0.66 TSP

Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 13 of 17 Wear Indications - SG B FLAW ROW COL TWD LOCATION ELEVATION COMMENT 1

1 174 10 05C

-0.48 TSP 2

3 84 9

05C

-0.5 TSP 3

4 81 17 05C 0

TSP 4

8 99 14 05C

-0.52 TSP 5

40 177 14 A16

-0.07 AVB 6

42 177 13 A16

-0.03 AVB 7

44 177 14 A16 0

AVB 8

50 41 11 A14

-0.48 AVB 9

52 109 6

A07 0

AVB 10 53 142 7

A07 0.17 AVB 11 55 174 9

A15

-0.34 AVB 12 59 170 7

A07

-0.27 AVB 13 61 164 13 A14

-0.03 AVB 14 64 103 6

A08 0

AVB 15 64 47 8

A08 0.71 AVB 16 69 170 10 A07 0

AVB 17 70 169 7

A05 0

AVB 18 70 169 13 A07 0

AVB 19 75 14 13 03C

-0.45 TSP 20 77 168 12 05C 0.41 TSP 21 77 168 7

06C 0.41 TSP 22 79 118 9

A09

-0.27 AVB 23 80 79 10 A09 0.24 AVB 24 80 95 16 A09 0.33 AVB 25 81 82 7

A14 0.05 AVB 26 82 69 7

A08

-0.17 AVB 27 83 128 7

A09 0.19 AVB 28 86 91 6

A17

-0.49 AVB 29 90 163 8

05C

-0.6 TSP 30 92 161 8

04C

-0.45 TSP

Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 14 of 17 Wear Indications - SG B FLAW ROW COL TWD LOCATION ELEVATION COMMENT 31 92 161 10 05C 0.39 TSP 32 94 161 9

04C 0.45 TSP 33 96 105 6

A10 0

AVB 34 97 158 11 04C 0.45 TSP 35 100 91 7

A07 0

AVB 36 100 25 23 TSC 12.67 PLP 37 105 86 11 A09

-0.37 AVB 38 109 102 7

A05 0.02 AVB 39 109 102 13 A13 0

AVB 40 109 102 26 A18 0.04 AVB 41 109 102 11 A19 0

AVB 42 110 133 8

A16

-0.09 AVB 43 111 108 10 A09

-0.12 AVB 44 111 92 16 A11 0.04 AVB 45 111 102 8

A13 0

AVB 46 111 96 23 A15 0

AVB 47 111 96 17 A16 0

AVB 48 111 96 10 A17 0

AVB 49 112 105 7

A07 0.02 AVB 50 112 149 10 A12

-0.19 AVB 51 112 149 7

A14

-0.21 AVB 52 112 149 17 A18 0.04 AVB 53 113 90 11 A07 0.21 AVB 54 113 92 8

A09 0

AVB 55 113 94 26 A13 0

AVB 56 113 92 15 A14 0

AVB 57 113 92 10 A17 0

AVB 58 115 104 13 A12 0.02 AVB 59 115 92 11 A13 0

AVB 60 115 104 11 A15 0.01 AVB

Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 15 of 17 Wear Indications - SG B FLAW ROW COL TWD LOCATION ELEVATION COMMENT 61 116 99 7

A06 0.02 AVB 62 116 99 20 A09 0.02 AVB 63 116 99 15 A12

-0.03 AVB 64 116 57 16 A16

-0.01 AVB 65 116 57 9

A18 0

AVB 66 117 70 8

A10 0

AVB 67 118 97 9

A12 0

AVB 68 120 63 12 A14

-0.01 AVB 69 120 63 11 A16 0

AVB 70 120 63 8

A18 0

AVB 71 122 91 19 A13 0.02 AVB 72 123 40 11 04C 0.43 TSP 73 124 99 7

A09 0.72 AVB 74 124 83 8

A09 0.07 AVB 75 125 46 9

A11 0.2 AVB 76 125 140 9

A11

-0.49 AVB 77 125 56 9

A13 0.43 AVB 78 125 46 13 A13 0.36 AVB 79 125 96 13 A13 0

AVB 80 125 82 14 A13 0.73 AVB 81 125 62 15 A15 0.29 AVB 82 125 96 20 A15 0

AVB 83 125 62 10 A19 0.11 AVB 84 126 85 12 A11

-0.93 AVB 85 128 93 13 A11 0

AVB 86 128 61 20 A11 0.61 AVB 87 128 93 9

A13 0

AVB 88 128 61 10 A15

-0.22 AVB 89 130 133 10 A17

-0.17 AVB 90 131 122 9

08C 0.34 TSP

Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 16 of 17 Wear Indications - SG B FLAW ROW COL TWD LOCATION ELEVATION COMMENT 91 131 54 8

A13

-0.31 AVB 92 132 83 7

A07

-0.41 AVB 93 132 57 9

A09

-0.25 AVB 94 132 57 23 A11 0.52 AVB 95 132 53 11 A13 0.02 AVB 96 132 57 15 A13

-0.4 AVB 97 133 94 15 A13 0.38 AVB 98 136 53 14 05C 0.47 TSP 99 136 115 14 A09

-0.32 AVB 100 136 115 12 A11 0.56 AVB 101 136 115 22 A13 0.38 AVB 102 136 115 23 A15

-0.18 AVB 103 137 92 10 A09 0

AVB 104 137 92 10 A11 0.58 AVB 105 137 92 17 A15 0.36 AVB 106 138 91 12 A11 0.05 AVB 107 138 105 24 A11 0.5 AVB 108 138 119 9

TSH 1.13 PLP 109 138 119 8

TSH 0.25 PLP 110 139 126 15 08H

-0.64 TSP 111 140 123 13 06H

-0.43 TSP 112 140 121 7

A09

-0.32 AVB 113 140 77 24 A09

-0.45 AVB 114 140 71 9

A11 0

AVB 115 140 99 12 A11 0.54 AVB 116 140 77 13 A11

-0.47 AVB 117 140 77 19 A11 0.51 AVB 118 140 77 20 A13

-0.29 AVB 119 140 71 8

A15

-0.21 AVB 120 140 99 9

A15 0.05 AVB

Enclosure to 2CAN021906 Page 17 of 17 Wear Indications - SG B FLAW ROW COL TWD LOCATION ELEVATION COMMENT 121 140 99 22 A17 0.15 AVB 122 141 60 15 04H 0.39 TSP 123 141 102 10 A09 0.33 AVB 124 142 83 12 A09 0.34 AVB 125 142 91 25 A11 0.02 AVB 126 142 83 36 A11

-0.48 AVB 127 142 83 16 A13

-0.36 AVB 128 142 91 34 A13 0.04 AVB 129 142 91 42 A15 0.07 AVB 130 142 91 20 A17 0.04 AVB 131 142 91 15 A19 0.02 AVB 132 143 62 18 05C

-0.54 TSP 133 143 94 10 A09 0.36 AVB 134 143 90 11 A11

-0.34 AVB 135 144 67 9

05C 0.45 TSP 136 144 67 12 05C

-0.58 TSP 137 144 63 15 05C

-0.54 TSP 138 146 113 11 05H

-0.58 TSP 139 148 109 8

04H 0.52 TSP 140 148 109 11 04H

-0.56 TSP 141 149 86 14 06H 0.37 TSP