ML20069B851

Submits List of Environ Qualification Info Designated as Proprietary & Nonproprietary.Westinghouse to Util Requesting That Util Not Submit Westinghouse Proprietary Info to Franklin Encl.Encl Withheld (Ref 10CFR2.790)

ML20069B851
Person / Time
Site:	Farley
Issue date:	03/02/1982
From:	Clayton F ALABAMA POWER CO.
To:	Varga S Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
NUDOCS 8203080067
Download: ML20069B851 (5)

Text

Mailmg Addr:ss S

Alabama Power Company 600 North 18th Street g

Post Office Box 2641

?

og g,.7'.g'

' l -a - * * '

Birmingham. Alabama 35291 Telephone 205 783-E081 F. L Clay ton, Jr.

R":'JZ:Tl"'

j, "ClK.r' [

Alabama Power

!!c stnethtwile:ltttix'sg.b rTI

\\

March 2, 1982 Docket No. 50-364 O

u O

Director, Nuclear Reactor Regulation 9f U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission p

Washington, D. C.

20555 g

Attention:

Mr. S. A. Varga o

Joseph H. Farley Nuclear Plant - Unit 2 k

Environmental Qualification O

Gentlemen:

>f b4 Alabama Power Company has reviewed your letter dated February 1,1982 requesting additional qualification information and has contacted the vendors that have provided the information identified in your Item 1.

Certain vendors have stated that their qualification information is proprietary and expressed concern to the possible unfair trade advantage and conflict of interest regarding the review by Franklin Research Center.

Specifically, Westinghouse has requested (Attachment) that Alabama Power Company not submit their proprietary information to Franklin Research Center.

Pursuant to an agreement reached between Westinghouse and Mr. E. C.

Shomaker of the NRC Office of the Executive Legal Director, who has discussed this matter with Mr. Z. Rosztoczy of the Equipment Qualification Branch, Westinghouse will ensure that the requested information is, or has been, submitted to the NRC on a timely basis.

Therefore, the information other than proprietary Westinghouse qualification documents has been retrieved from our auditable central file and is forwarded directly to your of fice to ensure the proprietary understandings between Alabama Power Company and the vendors have not been disregarded or neglected.

Alabama Power Company requests that the entire submittal be reviewed by your office and only information which is not proprietary, as designated below, be submitted to Franklin Research Center.

Additionally, no part of this submittal should be released for public disclosure or reproduced, and the entire submittal must be returned to Alabama Power Company upon completion of the review.

Alabama Power Company has reconciled this matter wit Mr. E. C. Shomaker of the NRC Office of the foA4 p

,9 f

to Gs y

\\ S.

od/c/(

t D

8203080067 820302 DRADOCK05000g g

a

1 l

i Mr. S. A. Varga March 2, 1982 Director, Nuclear Reagtor Regulation Page 2 U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Executive Legal Director.

If affidavits are required for withholding the proprietary information from public disclosure in accordance with 10 CFR Section 2.790 of the Commission's rulemaking, Alabama Power Company is r:qu::ted to be notified before such disclosure.

The following is a listing of the enclosed qualification information designated as proprietary (P) or non-proprietary (N):

1.

Qualification Documents a.

General Electric Company Report, (P)

Low Voltage Electrical Containment Penetration Qualification Test Report b.

Wyle Labs. NEQ Test Report 44354-1 (Previously dated 3-8-79 submitted for Unit 1) c.

Boston Insulated Wire and Cable Co.

(Previously Test Report 73E062 dated 9-7-73 submitted for Unit 1) d.

Boston Insulated Wire and Cable (Previously Co. Test Report 74A023 dated 1-24-74 submitted for Unit 1) e.

NAMC0 Test Report dated November 21, (Latest re-1977 vision pre-viously submitted for Unit 1) f.

The Okonite Co. Engineering Report (Previously No. 143 dated 3-20-72 submitted for Unit 1) 9 Bechtel/ Gems Telecon of 4-3-80 (N) h.

Isomedix Test Report dated (N)

November, 1975 1.

Joy Manufacturing Company Report (P)

X-604 j.

WCAP 7820, Supplements 1-4 (To be pro-vided by Westinghouse)

Mr. S. A. Varga March 2, 1982 Director, Nuclear Reactor Regulation Page 3 U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission k.

No qualification document was requested for this item.

l.

Joy Manufacturing Company Report (P)

X-604 m.

WCAP-9885 (To be pro-vided by Westinghouse) n.

NAMC0 Test Report QTR-105 (Previously dated August 21, 1909 submitted for Unit 1) o.

Okonite Co. Engineering (P)

Report No. N-1 dated July 3, 1978 p.

WCAP-9885 (Identified as (To be pro-WCAP-9985 in NRC letter) vided by Westinghouse)

The qualification documents for Items 1.b, c, d, f, and n were previously submitted for your review by our Unit I letter dated February 19, 1982 and, therefore, are not enclosed.

For Item 1.e, NAMCO Test Report dated November 21, 1977 is superceded by a revision dated September 5, 1978.

The 1978 revision was submitted by the Unit I letter in lieu of the 1977 report.

In order to provide for a proper review, Alabama Power Company has enclosed the most complete and latest qualification information that, for certain items, amends or enhances your request.

Qualification documents identified in your Items 1.h, i, and 1 are not applicable to Farley - Unit 2 as stated in our letter dated February 20, 1981, " Environmental Qualification Review";

consequently, the requested qualification documents are not included in the Farley auditable central file.

For Items 1.1 and 1, the applicable document, Joy Manufacturing Company Test Report X-604, is enclosed.

For Item 1.h, Franklin Institute Research Lab (FIRL) Test Report F-C3834 dated March, 1974, Bechtel/ Gems telecon of April 3,1980 and Isomedix Test Report dated November,1975 verify qualification for the Delaval GEMS level transmitters.

The FIRL Test Report should be available from your contractor for review.

The Bechtel/ Gems telecon requested by your Item 19 and Isomedix Test Report are enclosed for your review.

As a note of clarification, our NUREG-0588 response, Section C.2.4, sheet 10 inappropriately referenced WCAP-9985, which is requested by your Item 1.p.

The proper reference is WCAP-9885

Mr. S. A. Varga March 2, 1982 Director, Nuclear Reactor Regulation Page 4 U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission and is requested by your Item 1.m.

As atorementioned, this is a proprietary qualification document to be provided by Westinghouse.

This letter provides the complete response to your request.

If you have any questions, please advise.

Yours very truly, hab /.<v s

F. L. Clayton, J r.

FLCJ r/ MAL :jc Attachment Enclosures cc:

Mr. R. A. Thomas Mr. G. F. Trowbridge Mr. J. P. O'Reilly Mr. E. A. Reeves Mr. W. H. Bradford I

i r

P_w i

UW4.1 ATTACHt1ENT JGE W

~

Westinghouse Water Reactor war sma aimma Electr!:Cor;crat!cn O!vls!cns e, =.

P?st"rg* Peqar/vaa's 1789 February 19, 1982 ALA-82-506 Mr. H. O. Thrash, Manager

' Nuclear Generation Alabama Power Company 600 North Eighteenth Street Birmingham, Alabama 35291

Dear Mr. Thrash:

Alabama Power Company J. M. Farley Unit 1 and 2 SAFETY EVALUATION ON EQUIPMENT QUALIFICATION Recently the NRC has issued letters to some utilities regarding the results of the staff review of the utility response to the Safety Evaluation on Equipment Qualification. The letters (samples attached) request certain EQ information from the utility central file be forwarded to Franklin Research Center to facilitate the NRC contractor review.

Where the requested information is not proprietary to Westinghouse, it is appropriate for utilities to submit such information directly to Franklin.

Pursuant to an agreement reached between Westinghouse and Mr. E. Shomaker of the NRC Office of the Executive Legal Director, who has discussed this matter with Mr. Z. Rosztoczy of the Equipment Qualification Branch, we ask that you not submit Westinghouse proprietary information to Franklin. Westinghouse will ensure that any such requested material is, or has been, submitted directly to the NRC on a timely basis.

Should you have any questions concerning this advice, please contact myself or Mr. George Butterworth of our Nuclear Safety Department (412) 373-5761.

Very truly yours, t

J.

. Mil r, Manager eirating P ant Service Southern Region VLM/93L Attachment cc:

R. P. Mcdonald J. R. Crane

//

4 O. D. Kingsley, Jr.

W. G. Hairston, III

[2 g y902 O. Batum R. W. Wise

-W R. H. Baulig l.

EECElwp h'ETS k

1

~:. _.

-.