ML21266A065: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(StriderTol Bot change)
(StriderTol Bot change)
 
(3 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 15: Line 15:


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:Feedback on proposed ROP changes September 23, 2021
{{#Wiki_filter:©2021 Nuclear Energy Institute September 23, 2021 Feedback on proposed ROP changes
©2021 Nuclear Energy Institute
 
©2021 Nuclear Energy Institute
 
NEI understands the direction that NRC is headed with current strategy but we have questions on actions & engagement
 
We agree that there are improvements that could be gained through incorporation of operating experience including more recent experience
 
We agree that there are areas that were included in the SECYs that are no longer being recommended or were already completed We appreciate the opportunity to provide any new insights and provide perspectives on relative importance


==SUMMARY==
==SUMMARY==
©2021 Nuclear Energy Institute
We do not see any new information that would change our position on the original recommendations


NEI understands the direction that NRC is headed with current strategy but we have questions on actions & engagement We agree that there are improvements that could be gained through incorporation of operating experience including more recent experience We agree that there are areas that were included in the SECYs that are no longer being recommended or were already completed
We acknowledge that use of licensee self-assessments are no longer being pursued
* We appreciate the opportunity to provide any new insights and provide perspectives on relative importance
 
©2021 Nuclear Energy Institute
As a result of the NRC request during the last public meeting, NEI has identified an area that warrants additional consideration for the scope of the triennial fire protection inspection (TFPI)


SECY-18-0113 We do not see any new information that would change our position on the original recommendations We acknowledge that use of licensee self-assessments are no longer being pursued As a result of the NRC request during the last public meeting, NEI has identified an area that warrants additional consideration for the scope of the triennial fire protection inspection (TFPI)
The NEI fire protection task force will reach out to the applicable technical staff to discuss SECY-18-0113
The NEI fire protection task force will reach out to the applicable technical staff to discuss
©2021 Nuclear Energy Institute


TRIENNIAL FIRE PROTECTION INSPECTION (TFPI)
©2021 Nuclear Energy Institute 4 NEI Fire Protection Task Force re-evaluated Fire Protection recommendations in SECY-18-0113 and SECY-19-0067 Attributes of the TFPI are redundant to attributes of other NRC inspections IP 71111.05, Fire Protection IP 71111.18, Plant Modifications IP 71111.21M, Design Basis Assurance Inspection (Team)
NEI Fire Protection Task Force re-evaluated Fire Protection recommendations in SECY-18-0113 and SECY-19-0067 Attributes of the TFPI are redundant to attributes of other NRC inspections
* IP 71111.05, Fire Protection
* IP 71111.18, Plant Modifications
* IP 71111.21M, Design Basis Assurance Inspection (Team)
Continuing to see low numbers of Fire Protection findings based on industry performance Ready to engage NRC staff with the following recommendation:
Continuing to see low numbers of Fire Protection findings based on industry performance Ready to engage NRC staff with the following recommendation:
* Reallocate unique TFPI inspection criteria to CETI and IP 71111.05, Fire Protection                                             ©2021 Nuclear Energy Institute 4
Reallocate unique TFPI inspection criteria to CETI and IP 71111.05, Fire Protection TRIENNIAL FIRE PROTECTION INSPECTION (TFPI)


SECY-19-0067 We do not see any new information that would change our position on the original recommendations We do have some questions on actions and engagement
©2021 Nuclear Energy Institute
©2021 Nuclear Energy Institute


Status of Plans for Reporting Guidance Applicable to Plants with Risk-Informed Licensing Bases September 23, 2021
We do not see any new information that would change our position on the original recommendations
  ©2021 Nuclear Energy Institute
 
We do have some questions on actions and engagement SECY-19-0067
 
©2021 Nuclear Energy Institute September 23, 2021 Status of Plans for Reporting Guidance Applicable to Plants with Risk-Informed Licensing Bases


REPORTING GUIDANCE NEI task force is developing guidance on how to apply reporting requirements for licensees with risk-informed licensing bases For example, 50.69(b)(1)(vii) and (viii) provide an explicit exemption to 10 CFR 50.72 and 50.73 respectively for RISC-3 and RISC-4 components 50.69(g) requires LER under 50.73(b) for any event or condition that prevented, or would have prevented, a RISC-1 or RISC-2 SSC from performing a safety significant function.
Other risk informed initiatives would also benefit from additional reporting guidance
©2021 Nuclear Energy Institute
©2021 Nuclear Energy Institute


STATUS Actions complete/in-progress Draft guidance developed Initial regulatory affairs review completed Industry operations tabletop performed Incorporate feedback from tabletop -in progress Next Steps NEI regulatory and legal review of updated draft guidance - Oct, 2021 NEI/NRC workshop - Late Fall We are interested in engaging the NRC staff for feedback
NEI task force is developing guidance on how to apply reporting requirements for licensees with risk-informed licensing bases
©2021 Nuclear Energy Institute}}
 
For example,
 
50.69(b)(1)(vii) and (viii) provide an explicit exemption to 10 CFR 50.72 and 50.73 respectively for RISC-3 and RISC-4 components
 
50.69(g) requires LER under 50.73(b) for any event or condition that prevented, or would have prevented, a RISC-1 or RISC-2 SSC from performing a safety significant function.
 
Other risk informed initiatives would also benefit from additional reporting guidance REPORTING GUIDANCE
 
©2021 Nuclear Energy Institute Actions complete/in-progress
 
Draft guidance developed
 
Initial regulatory affairs review completed
 
Industry operations tabletop performed
 
Incorporate feedback from tabletop -in progress Next Steps
 
NEI regulatory and legal review of updated draft guidance - Oct, 2021
 
NEI/NRC workshop - Late Fall
 
We are interested in engaging the NRC staff for feedback STATUS}}

Latest revision as of 22:40, 27 November 2024

NEI Presentation - ROP Public Meeting 09232021 (002)
ML21266A065
Person / Time
Site: Nuclear Energy Institute
Issue date: 09/23/2021
From:
Nuclear Energy Institute
To:
NRC/SECY
References
Download: ML21266A065 (8)


Text

©2021 Nuclear Energy Institute September 23, 2021 Feedback on proposed ROP changes

©2021 Nuclear Energy Institute

NEI understands the direction that NRC is headed with current strategy but we have questions on actions & engagement

We agree that there are improvements that could be gained through incorporation of operating experience including more recent experience

We agree that there are areas that were included in the SECYs that are no longer being recommended or were already completed We appreciate the opportunity to provide any new insights and provide perspectives on relative importance

SUMMARY

©2021 Nuclear Energy Institute

We do not see any new information that would change our position on the original recommendations

We acknowledge that use of licensee self-assessments are no longer being pursued

As a result of the NRC request during the last public meeting, NEI has identified an area that warrants additional consideration for the scope of the triennial fire protection inspection (TFPI)

The NEI fire protection task force will reach out to the applicable technical staff to discuss SECY-18-0113

©2021 Nuclear Energy Institute 4 NEI Fire Protection Task Force re-evaluated Fire Protection recommendations in SECY-18-0113 and SECY-19-0067 Attributes of the TFPI are redundant to attributes of other NRC inspections IP 71111.05, Fire Protection IP 71111.18, Plant Modifications IP 71111.21M, Design Basis Assurance Inspection (Team)

Continuing to see low numbers of Fire Protection findings based on industry performance Ready to engage NRC staff with the following recommendation:

Reallocate unique TFPI inspection criteria to CETI and IP 71111.05, Fire Protection TRIENNIAL FIRE PROTECTION INSPECTION (TFPI)

©2021 Nuclear Energy Institute

We do not see any new information that would change our position on the original recommendations

We do have some questions on actions and engagement SECY-19-0067

©2021 Nuclear Energy Institute September 23, 2021 Status of Plans for Reporting Guidance Applicable to Plants with Risk-Informed Licensing Bases

©2021 Nuclear Energy Institute

NEI task force is developing guidance on how to apply reporting requirements for licensees with risk-informed licensing bases

For example,

50.69(b)(1)(vii) and (viii) provide an explicit exemption to 10 CFR 50.72 and 50.73 respectively for RISC-3 and RISC-4 components

50.69(g) requires LER under 50.73(b) for any event or condition that prevented, or would have prevented, a RISC-1 or RISC-2 SSC from performing a safety significant function.

Other risk informed initiatives would also benefit from additional reporting guidance REPORTING GUIDANCE

©2021 Nuclear Energy Institute Actions complete/in-progress

Draft guidance developed

Initial regulatory affairs review completed

Industry operations tabletop performed

Incorporate feedback from tabletop -in progress Next Steps

NEI regulatory and legal review of updated draft guidance - Oct, 2021

NEI/NRC workshop - Late Fall

We are interested in engaging the NRC staff for feedback STATUS