Regulatory Guide 8.35
| ML003739507 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 06/30/1992 |
| From: | Office of Nuclear Regulatory Research |
| To: | |
| References | |
| RG-8.35 | |
| Download: ML003739507 (7) | |
U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
June 1992 REGULATORY GUIDE
OFFICE OF NUCLEAR REGULATORY RESEARCH
REGULATORY GUIDE 8.35 (Draft was issued as DG-8008)
PLANNED SPECIAL EXPOSURES
A. INTRODUCTION
In the revised 10 CFR Part 20, "Standards for Protection Against Radiation,"
paragraphs
20.1201(b) and 20.1206 provide the conditions and limits for planned special exposures (PSEs) of adult workers, i.e., doses in addition to and accounted for separately from the doses received under the limits specified in 10 CFR 20.1201. In addition, 10 CFR
20.2104(b) and 20.2104(e)(2) specify the require ments for obtaining prior occupational dose informa tion, and 10 CFR 20.2105 and 20.2106 specify the requirements for exposure and monitoring records applicable to PSEs. The requirements for reporting PSEs are in 10 CFR 20.2202(e) and 20.2204.
PSEs have been included in the revised 10 CFR
Part 20 to provide for exceptional situations when al ternatives that might avoid the special exposure are unavailable or impractical.
The previous rule's
5(N-18) provision, which permitted accumulating un used annual exposures for use in dose averaging (or a dose bank), has been deleted. Under the revised rule, if the worker's exposure is under the 5-rem an nual dose limit, there is no way to recapture the dif ference between the actual dose and the limit for use in future years.
The PSE rule is designed to provide occupational dose flexibility similar to that provided by the previ ous 5(N-18) rule. Thus, even though doses cannot be
"banked" or saved as before, the revised rule will al- low 5 rems occupational exposure and 5 rems PSE for a total of 10 rems for the year, which is similar to the maximum amount of 12 reins allowed under the pre vious 5(N-18) rule. The difference is that there are additional conditions that must be satisfied prior to allowing the special exposure. These conditions are detailed in 10 CFR 20.1206, and this provision is in tended to be used only under very special circum stances, not as a routine measure for extending dose limits applicable to routine exposures. In addition, there are requirements for recording and reporting the PSE.
This regulatory guide provides guidance on the conditions and prerequisites for permitting PSEs al lowed by the revision to 10 CFR Part 20, the associ ated specific monitoring and reporting requirements, and examples of acceptable means of satisfying these requirements.
Any information collection activities mentioned in this regulatory guide are contained as requirements in 10 CFR Part 20, which provides the regulatory ba sis for this guide. The information collection require ments in 10 CFR Part 20 have been cleared under
0MB Clearance No. 3150-0014.
B. DISCUSSION
PSEs are restricted to those special situations that could result in a higher exposure than allowed by the normal limits of 10 CFR 20.1201 and that, if not provided for, could create a severe problem in the USNRC REGULATORY GUIDES
The guides are issued in the following ten broad divisions:
Regulatory Guides are issued to describe and make available to the pub lic methods acceptable to the NRC staff of Implementing specific parts of the Commission's regulations, to delineate techniques used by the
1. Power Reactors
6. Products staff in evaluating specific problems or postulated accidents, or to pro-
2. Research and Test Reactors
7. Transportation vide guidance to applicants. Regulatory Guides are not substitutes for
3. Fuels and Materials Facilities
8. Occupational Health regulations, and compliance with them Is not require
d. Methods and
4. Environmental and Siting
9. Antitrust and Financial Review solutions different from those set out In the guides will be acceptable If
5. Materials and Plant Protection
10. General they provide a basis for the findings requisite to the issuance or continu ance of a permit or license by the Commission.
Copies of issued guides may be purchased from the Government Printing This guide was issued after consideration of comments received from Office at the current GPO price. Information on current GPO prices may the public. Comrments and suggestions for improvements in these be obtained by contacting the Superintendent of Documents, U.S.
guides are encouraged at all times, and guides will be revised, as ap- Government Printing Office, Post Office Box 37082, Washington, DC
propriate, to accommodate comments and to reflect new information or
20013-7082. telephone (202)275-2060 or (202)275-2171.
experience.
Written comments may be submitted to the Regulatory Publications Issued guides may also be purchased from the National Technical Infor Branch, DFIPS, ADM, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Washing- mation Service on a standing order basis. Details on this service may be ton. DC 20555.
obtained by writing NTIS, 5285 Port Royal Road, Springfield, VA 22161.
licensee's operations. Problems might include un scheduled facility shutdowns, high radiation levels that impede operations important to safety. Accord ingly, a special set of limitations and reporting and recordkeeping requirements apply if licensees decide to use PSEs. Approval of a PSE for an adult worker must be in writing before the exposure occurs and, once it occurs, the exposure cannot be treated as a routine occupational exposure. Furthermore, minors are not allowed to participate in PSEs.
In planning for a PSE, the licensee is permitted to assign a portion of the dose to routine exposure and the rest to the PSE. However, when the post exposure evaluation is made, the dose amount planned to be assigned to PSE must be recorded as PSE. If the total dose received is less than the planned PSE, the actual dose received must be re corded as PSE dose. If the total dose received is more than the planned PSE, but not an overexposure, the extra portion may be recorded as PSE or routine dose. In other words, the planned PSE dose cannot be reassigned, postexposure, to routine exposure if it is later determined that a PSE was not needed. The intent of the PSE was that it would be used infre quently. Once a licensee decides to conduct a PSE,
all the unique limitations and reporting and record keeping requirements are to apply, even if the doses actually received fall within the dose limits for routine operations. For example, if a job planned with a PSE
of 5 rems and a routine dose of 2 reins to an individ ual actually results in a dose of 4 reins, the entire
4-rem dose must be recorded as PSE dose.
In determining the amount to assign to the PSE
in advance of the exposures, licensees should be aware of the individual's current year exposure and lifetime PSE bank to avoid unnecessarily impacting a worker's employability.
C. REGULATORY POSITION
1. USE OF PLANNED SPECIAL EXPOSURES
PSEs are only to be used under exceptional cir cumstances, not as a routine method of increasing dose limits applicable to routine exposures. However, licensees may consider the use of PSEs to permit workers who have critical skills and who are necessary for a particular job to receive an exposure in addition to the routine occupational exposure limit.
The rule does not require that participation in PSEs be voluntary on the part of the individual work ers. However, licensees may establish a program of voluntary PSEs. In any case, consideration should be given to the potential benefits of involving the worker in the planning and preparation for the PSE. The NRC believes that the risk of suffering health effects from these limited exposures is small and that the use of PSEs may be necessary for licensees to accomplish important tasks vital to continued safe operations.
The issue of a worker accepting the risks associated with an assigned task is discussed in Regulatory Guide
8.29, "Instruction Concerning Risks from Occupa tional Radiation Exposure."
Exposures in excess of the routine occupational dose limits received during accident or emergency situations that require immediate action to save hu man lives or to prevent the failure of equipment im portant to safety are not PSEs. However, if conditions associated with an accident or emergency permit complying with the conditions specified in 10 CFR
20.1206(a) through (e), a PSE can be used. How ever, all exposures in excess of the routine occupa tional dose limits received during accident and emer gency situations must be determined and subtracted from the annual 5-remn PSE limit and the 25 reins allowed for lifetime PSEs (see 10 CFR 20.1206(e)).
2.
CONDITIONS FOR USE OF PSEs There are seven conditions listed in 10 CFR
20.1206 that must be satisfied if a licensee authorizes an adult worker to receive a PSE. These conditions are presented in Figure 1 and are discussed below.
FIGURE 1 Conditions for Planned Special Exposures Exceptional Situation Prior Written Authority Individual Informed and Instructed Doses from Previous PSEs and Doses in Excess of Annual Dose Limits Determined PSEs Plus All Occupational Exposures Over Annual Limits Must Be:
<Dose Limits for 1 Year and
<5 x Annual Dose Limits for a Lifetime Records Maintained of Conduct of PSE, Written Report of PSE to NRC
PSE Dose Recorded and Individual Informed of Dose Within 30 Days
8.35-2
6'
1-.
t
!.'
2.1 Exceptional Situations Authorization for PSEs should only be given for exceptional situations. The use of PSEs must be justi fied and well documented (see 10 CFR 20.2105).
PSEs should not be used as a routine method of in creasing a worker's routine exposure limits. The justi fication for the PSE will be reviewed by the NRC staff when the licensee's records of the PSE are examined.
If a licensee would like an NRC review prior to initiat ing a PSE, the licensee may contact the appropriate regional office directly.
The following are examples of exceptional situ ations in which a PSE might be justified:
The work is to be performed by one individual rather than several. A source becomes disconnected during radiography. It may not be practical or feasible for the source to be recovered in two or three steps by different persons. Authorization for one person to re ceive up to 5 rems total effective dose equivalent, in addition to his or her routine occupational exposure, may be reasonable for the recovery.
The licensee is permitted to use previously ap proved procedures in carrying out work under a PSE.
For example, the licensee could have an approved generic procedure for source retrieval that, among other things, addresses all the administrative and rec ordkeeping requirements of 10 CFR 20.1206. Pro vided the situation is exceptional and alternatives that might avoid higher exposures are unavailable or are impractical, an individual's exposure received during such a source retrieval may be considered as a PSE.
All the conditions of 10 CFR 20.1206 must be met and documented prior to each exposure.
Use of dose-averting methods are not possible.
Work must be performed on instrumentation in a high-radiation area where space is very limited and shielding or other dose-averting methods are not pos sible. It may be necessary to authorize a PSE to make the necessary repairs to the instrumentation.
Collective dose to personnel may be reduced.
It may be more dose effective to keep certain skilled workers on a particular job because they will be able to perform the job rapidly and reduce the overall dose to personnel. For example, if two persons can weld in a high-radiation area and collectively receive
12 reins (6 reins per person, 2 reins under a PSE and
4 reins routine) while four less skilled workers would receive 16 reins (4 reins per person routine expo sure), the collective dose would be reduced from 16 to 12 reins by using the two skilled workers. PSEs are not intended to be used only as a routine collective dose reduction technique. However, reducing collec tive dose could contribute to the justification of the need for a PSE.
2.2 Prior Written Authority The licensee (and employer if the employer is not the licensee) must specifically authorize the PSE in writing before the exposure occurs. A contractor em ployer may authorize the use of PSEs by a licensee in advance to accommodate any urgent circumstances that may arise.
If, prior to initiating a PSE, it is found that a PSE
is not needed, the resulting exposure can be recorded as routine if the PSE is canceled.
The procedures for the radiation protection pro gram should specify the management level that may authorize a PSE. The responsible person'should be at a sufficiently senior level to ensure worker protection and to judge the appropriateness of the PSE for the exceptional circumstances. This person would nor mally be the RSO/radiation protection manager or someone in the organization with equivalent qualifica tions.
2.3 Individual Informed and Instructed Before a planned special exposure, the licensee must ensure that the individuals involved are (1) in formed of the purpose of the planned operation, (2)
informed of the expected radiation levels, estimated doses, and associated risks or other conditions that may be involved in performing the task, and (3) in structed in measures to be taken to keep the dose ALARA (as low as reasonably achievable) while con sidering other risks that may be present.
To ensure that the intent of the plan is carried out, it is important that the workers who are to re ceive a PSE are fully informed and aware of the cir cumstances under which the PSE was authorized.
These workers must understand the importance of keeping their exposure ALARA. They must also un derstand the procedures and controls to be used in the particular PSE in order to keep their exposures ALARA. Licensees have an obligation to inform workers (before they receive a PSE) of the expected radiation levels, estimated doses, associated risks, or other significant conditions that might be involved in performing the task so that the individuals are aware of and understand the health and safety significance of the PSE. This information should also be included on the authorization for the PSE.
2.4 Determine Prior Doses According to
prior to authorizing the PSE, all previous PSEs and all doses in excess of the routine occupational limits in effect at the time of the exposures (10 CFR 20.1201(1)(a)
and the former 10 CFR 20.101) for the individual's lifetime must be determined from records for each individual who will participate in the PSE. Doses received in excess of routine occupational dose limits in effect at the time of the exposures during accidents and emergencies must also be determined and
8.35-3 r
i*.
V.
I.
F
subtracted from the limits for PSEs. (Accident doses are doses resulting from an unexpected event involv ing exposure to radiation or radioactive material.
Emergency doses are doses resulting from any imme diate action taken in response to a situation or occur rence of a serious nature developing suddenly and unexpectedly.)
If complete records (including the provisions of
20.2104(c)) of the worker's current and previously accumulated occupational dose such as a completed NRC Form 4 are not available, it must be assumed that the individual is not eligible for PSEs, i.e., the person cannot be authorized to receive a PSE (see 10
CFR 20.2104(e)(2)). Guidance on records of occu pational exposure is available in Revision 1 to Regula tory Guide 8.7, "Instructions for Recording and Re porting Occupational Radiation Exposure Data."
2.5 PSEs and Exposure Limits Individuals receiving PSEs can receive a maxi mum dose in 1 year of any or all of the following:
1.
10
reins total effective dose equivalent
(5 reins from routine operations and 5 reins from PSEs); or
100 rems to any individual organ or tissue, in cluding any deep-dose equivalent plus the com mitted dose equivalent for the organ or tissue
(50 rems from routine operations and 50 rems from PSEs); and
2.
30 reins dose equivalent to the eye (15 rems from routine operations and 15 rems from PSEs); and
3.
100 rems to the skin or to any extremity (50
reins from routine operations and 50 reins from PSEs).
Individuals can receive a lifetime dose from PSEs of any or all of the following:
1.
25 reins total effective dose equivalent; or
250 rems to any individual organ or tissue;
and
2.
75 reins to the eye; and
3.
250 reins to the skin or to any extremity.
2.6 Records and Written Reports The licensee must maintain records of the con duct of a PSE in accordance with 10 CFR 20.2105 and must submit a written report in accordance with
10 CFR 20.2204. In addition, 10 CFR 20.2106 re quires that the records of doses received during PSEs be maintained for all individuals who participated in a PSE. These records should include all the informa tion listed in 10 CFR 20.210
5. A revised NRC Form
5 has been developed, along with guidance on its use, in Revision 1 to Regulatory Guide 8.7, "Instructions for Recording and Reporting Occupational Radiation Exposure Data."
A written report of the PSE, notifying the Admin istrator of the appropriate NRC Regional Office, is due within 30 days after the PSE has occurred (see
10 CFR 20.2204). The report allows the NRC to as sess the actual frequency of PSEs and determine whether followup inspections may be warranted. The information-in the records listed in 10 CFR 20.2105 must be included in any report filed under 10 CFR
20.2204.
2.7 Recording Worker's PSE Dose and Informing the Worker The licensee must record its best estimate of the dose (dose of record) resulting from the PSE in each affected individual's record and inform the individ ual, in writing, of the dose within 30 days of the PSE
(10 CFR 20.1206(g)). The dose from PSEs is not to be considered in controlling future occupational dose of the individual under 10 CFR 20.1201(a) but is to be included in evaluations required by
10 CFR
20.1206(d) and (e). The dose resulting from a PSE is to be included in the total for all PSEs for the individ ual, and it is to be used in determining the dose bal ance remaining for future PSEs.
The 30-day time period for notifying the worker of the dose received is to allow sufficient time for the licensee to make its best estimate of internal and ex ternal exposures received as part of the PSE. The best estimate is understood to mean the dose of re cord as determined by accredited dosimetry, bioas say, air sampling, or other analyses such as time and motion studies. If the intake of Class Y material (i.e.,
materials that remain in the body for time periods on the order of years) is being assessed, the licensee may delay the recording and reporting of the results of its assessments for periods up to 7 months to allow for additional measurements necessary for the assess ments (10 CFR 20.1204(d)). The internal dose re ported within the 30 days may be identified as an in itial best estimate pending completion of a final as sessment after which the actual dose assigned should be recorded and reported.
The dose from a PSE must be tracked separately from the routine occupational dose for the individual.
Thus, a person may have an accumulated routine oc cupational dose of 3 rems total effective dose equiva lent for the year, receive a dose of 4 reins total effec tive dose equivalent from a PSE, and still be able to receive up to 2 more reins of routine occupational exposure for the year, even though the person has had a total dose of 7 rems for the year.
3.
INTERNAL AND EXTERNAL EXPOSURE
CONSIDERATIONS
For PSEs, as well as for routine exposures, both internal and external doses are to be summed in
8.35-4
/
calculating the total effective dose equivalent. This re quires controlling the total effective dose equivalent but permits tradeoffs between internal and external exposures to be made to achieve ALARA doses. The sum of external and internal doses during the PSE
should be maintained ALARA. The conditions speci fied in 10 CFR 20.1502 should be used in making the determination of when monitoring is required.
4. EXPOSURES OF MINORS AND DECLARED
PREGNANT WOMEN
The PSE provisions of 10 CFR 20.1206 do not apply to minors (10 CFR 20.1207) or to the embryo/
fetus (10 CFR 20.1208). The rule permits a licensee to authorize only an adult worker to receive PSEs. In addition, the dose limits in 10 CFR 20.1208 would normally preclude a declared pregnant woman from receiving a PSE since the 10 CFR 20.1208 limits are more restrictive than the annual dose limits in 10
CFR 20.1201. In general, declared pregnant women should not be considered candidates for PSEs. How- ever, the provisions of 10 CFR 20.1206 also apply to the dose limits for the lens of the eye, skin, and ex tremities. Therefore, in some situations it may be pos sible for a declared pregnant woman to receive a PSE
to her extremities (or skin or eyes) that would not exceed the dose limits to the embryo/fetus.
D. IMPLEMENTATION
The purpose of this section is to provide informa tion to applicants and licensees regarding the NRC
staff's plans for using this regulatory guide.
Except in those cases in which an applicant proposes an acceptable alternative method for com plying with specified portions of the Commission's regulations, the methods described in this guide will be used in the evaluation of applications for new licenses, license renewals, and license amendments and for evaluating compliance with
10
CFR
20.1001-20.2401.
8.35-5
REGULATORY ANALYSIS
A separate regulatory analysis was not prepared for this regulatory guide. The regulatory analysis pre pared for 10 CFR Part 20, "Standards for Protection Against Radiation" (56 FR 23360), provides the regu latory basis for this guide and examines the costs and benefits of the rule as implemented by the guide. A
copy of the "Regulatory Analysis for the Revision of
10 CFR Part 20" (PNL-6712, November 1988) is available for inspection and copying for a fee at the NRC Public Document Room, 2120 L Street NW,
Washington, DC, as an enclosure to Part 20.
/
8.35-6
-.-.
o J
UNITED STATES
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
WASHINGTON, D.C. 20555-0001 FIRST CLASS MAIL
POSTAGE AND FEES PAID
PERMIT NO. G-67 OFFICIAL BUSINESS
PENALTY FOR PRIVATE USE, $300