ML20128E960

Discusses 930113 Meeting W/Util Re Commercial Grade Dedication Issues

ML20128E960
Person / Time
Site:	San Onofre
Issue date:	02/01/1993
From:	Roe J Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
To:	Guiles E, Ray H SAN DIEGO GAS & ELECTRIC CO., SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON CO.
References
GL-89-02, GL-89-2, GL-91-05, GL-91-5, NUDOCS 9302110180
Download: ML20128E960 (3)

Text

,.

~

[:

l T

9 pn 8toog.

-A'

< fo,j J'

' ~

, UNITED STATES n

3

-1 NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSIONS 1

WASHINGTON, D.C.' 20666 -

[

V

-Q f

'I DocIdfilos.

50-361 FEB 0 F *" 3 and 50-362 tir. Harold B. Ray Mr.-Edwin A..Cuiles-3 Senior Vice President Vice President; y

Southern California Edison Company Engineering and:0perations-Irvine Operations Center San Diego Gas & Electric-Co.

23 Parker Street

.101 Ash Street-r Irvine, California 92718 San Diego, California 92112;

SUBJECT:

MEETING WITH SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY-.(SCE) 0N COMMERCIAL' GRADE DEDICATION ISSVES As you are aware', we are currently reviewing our positions =on _ commercial grade item (CGI) _ dedication as a result of industry comments followi_ng our _'recent'

!i pilot inspections in this area. A major component of our'rev_iew i_s meeting:

with several licensees to identify and gain insights into specific = areasiof-3 differing interpretations of stated positions and to>identifyf areas where.

additional clarification or relaxations of NRC position's_ may.be appr'opriate..

Our meeting with you and your staff on January -13 provided very useful-

~ >

information to aid in our ongoing review.-

J SCE's warehousing and1 We appreciate having had the opportunity to tour.We found your materiali j

material testing facilities before the meeting.

testing and verification laboratory impressive with4 respect tof the": state of i

the art equipment and the quality of staffing.: 'Once fully onerational, these1 facilities should provide excellent material testing and verification capability to support your overall dedication program.-

Based on our discussion of specific' dedication-; issues-,1and the__ review of-

- sample CGI dedication packages, we concluded that your currentLCGILprocurementl t

and-dedication program is -in substantial agreement-with the;guidanceicontained a

in NRC Generic Letters,89-02 and 91-05:and thatino:significantDdifferences t

exist between SCE and NRC interpretation of this guidanceLasia means ofi

~

c compliance with the requirements;of.10 CFR 50, Appendix lBL Also, based on.

your summary,of SCE-actions in response'to-item specific-dedication 3oncerns; identified in'NRC Inspection Report 91e201, it. appears'that>these: issues have been satisfactorily resolved. We also acknowledge tha_t even atitheetim~e ofL our December 1991 inspection you-h'ad.made significantiprogress towards:

implementing a programLaddressing the guidarce in)theJNRC' generic lettersj I

We'areevaluatingthe-' specific 3cmmentson'dedicationlissues;thatKyouLprovidedl L

during our January-13 meeting; including the need for~ additional _ clarification'--

R for material 1 sampling,- traceability, and like-for-lik'e replacement.

In?thei near future, we will be issuing-for public comment.- NRC1 inspection.g'uidance!.and-n holding a _publicJ. workshop on_ CGI dedication activities. - We willEconsider4your' i

comments in'this guidan.ce.

9302110180 930201 P

' ADOCK-05000361a PDR g

PDR

~

h

=aA

>> + = - -

e vgg.g@gJ f

n m

• ~

?%

-y h :

L Messrs. Ray andLGuiles- --

lf,you ~should have any questions or ' additional comments concerning these -

issues, please_ contact C. E.-Rossi. Director. Division of Reactor Inspect. ion-and Licensee-Performance, sincerel,

1 l

s' Jack W.

oe, Director -

Division of Reactor Projects lIll/ly/V; Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation:

DISTRIBTUION:

Docket Files / Central Files / RIDS IE:09 GGrant, OED0 PDR AGibson, Ril LDR EMerschoff, Rll-VIB R/F FJape, Ril s

DRIL R/F HMiller,_RIII-RMcIntyre EGreenman, Ril RPettis LCallan, RIV LCampb91)

SCollins, RIV GCwalina KPerkins, RV-CHehl,'RI DKirsch,.RV~

t WHodges, RI TQuay MVirgilio

• SEE PREVIOUS CONCURRENCE =

OFFICE VIB/DRIL VIB/DRil kil/NRR

[

DRIL/NRR ADT/NRR i:

NAME UPOTAPOVS

-LNORRHOLM RZIkERM[~

CEROSSI WRUSSELL-

~DATE 1/27/93*

1/27/93*

1/ /9 1/25/93* "

l/29/93*-

Y-YES XX-YES XX_

LYES:

XX1 XXX NO:

OFFICE

'PD5/NRR PD5//NRR-ADR/ - D/DRPW :

~NAME MFIELDS-T0VAY MVIRGil10' JI0Ek T/ /93-l DATE 1/28/93*

-1/28/93* --

1/28/93*

-Y[

-- N0 ?

.YES :

.NO I

COPY YES xx YES xx YES-xx 00C0 10FFICIAL RECORD COPY-DOCUMENT-NAME: A: SONGS.2 n

4 b

l:

~

t p

c.

Messrs. Ray and Guiles

$an Onofro Nuclear Generating LSouthern California Edison' Company Station, Unit Nos.;2 and_'3-

$kesA.Booletto,Esq.

Mr. Richard J.'Kosiba, Project Manager-Southern California Edison company Bechtel Power Corporation-J Irvine Operations Center 12440 E. l Imperial Highway-l 23 Parker Street Norwalk, California = 90650 Irvine, California 92718 Mr. Robert G. Lacy-Chairman, Board of Supervisors Manager,_ Nuclear Department County _of San Diego San Diego Gas & Electric Company 4

1600 Pacific Highway, Room 335 P._0. Box 1831 San Diego, California 92101 San Diego, California-- 92112 Alan R. Watts, Esq.

Mr. Hank Kocol Rourke & Woodruff Radiologic Health' Branch 701 S. Parker St. No. 7000 State Department of Health Services Orange, California 92668-4702 Post Office Box 942732 a

Sacremento, California 94234-Mr. Sherwin Harris Resource Project Manager Public Utilities Department

- City of Riverside Resident Inspector / San Onofre NPS-3900 Main Street c/o U.S. Nuclear Regulatory _ Commission Riverside, California-92522 Post Office Box 4329.

San Clemente, California 92674:

?

Mr. Charles B. Brinkman, Manager Washington Nuclear Operations ABB Combustion Engineering _ Nuclear Power Mayor 12300 Twinbrook Parkway, Suite 330 City of San Clemente Rockville, Maryland 20852 100 Avenida Presidio San' Clemente, California 92672 Mr. Howard J..Wong Regional Administrator, Region.V U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Region _V 1450 Maria Lane,LSuite-210 1450 Maria Lane, Suite 210 Walnut Creek, California' 94596l Walnut Creek, California 94596 2

Mr. Don J. Womeldorf.

Chief, Environmental Management Branch 3'

~ California Department of Health Services 714-P-Street, Room 616 Sacramento, California 95814 a

%.