ML14115A066
| ML14115A066 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | North Anna  |
| Issue date: | 04/21/2014 |
| From: | Mark D. Sartain Virginia Electric & Power Co (VEPCO) |
| To: | Document Control Desk, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| 14-050 | |
| Download: ML14115A066 (88) | |
Text
10 CFR 50.55a VIRGINIA ELECTRIC AND POWER COMPANY RICHMOND, VIRGINIA 23261 April 21, 2014 United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission Serial No.14-050 Attention: Document Control Desk NAPS/JHL RO Washington, D.C. 20555 Docket No.
50-339 License No.
NPF-7 VIRGINIA ELECTRIC AND POWER COMPANY (DOMINION)
NORTH ANNA POWER STATION UNIT 2 ASME SECTION XI INSERVICE INSPECTION PROGRAM RELIEF REQUEST N2-14-LMT-002 - FOURTH INTERVAL PERIOD I LIMITED EXAMINATIONS-Pursuant to 10 CFR 50.55a(g)(5)(iii), Virginia Electric and Power Company (Dominion) requests relief for limited examination coverage (i.e., less than 90% weld coverage achieved, due to physical interferences that prohibited attaining full weld coverage) obtained during the inservice inspection (ISI) examinations at North Anna Power Station Unit 2 during the first period of the fourth ten-year ISI interval. These examinations were performed to meet the requirements of the 2004 Edition of ASME Section XI with No Addenda and the Risk-Informed/Safety-Based Inservice Inspection (RIS B) Program Plan based on Code Case N-716.
Relief Request N2-14-LMT-002 is included in the attachment to this letter, and provides the basis for this request.
The Facility Safety Review Committee has reviewed and approved the relief request.
If you have any questions or require additional information regarding the information provided in the attachment, please contact Mr. Thomas Shaub at (804) 273-2763.
Very truly yours, M. D. Sartain Vice President - Nuclear Engineering
Attachment:
ASME Section XI Inspection Program Relief Request N2-14-LMT-002 Fourth Interval Period Limited Examinations Commitments made in this letter:
None
%fri Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-338 Fourth Interval Period 1 ISI Limited Exam Relief Request Page 2 of 2 cc:
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Region II Marquis One Tower 245 Peachtree Center Ave, NE Suite 1200 Atlanta, Georgia 30303 Mr. J. E. Reasor, Jr.
Old Dominion Electric Cooperative Innsbrook Corporate Center 4201 Dominion Blvd.
Suite 300 Glen Allen, Virginia 23060 NRC Senior Resident Inspector North Anna Power Station Ms. M. C. Barillas NRC Project Manager U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission One White Flint North Mail Stop 0-8 G9A 11555 Rockville Pike Rockville, Maryland 20852 Dr. V. Sreenivas NRC Project Manager U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission One White Flint North Mail Stop 0-8 G9A 11555 Rockville Pike Rockville, Maryland 20852
wI ATTACHMENT N2-14-LMT-002 UNIT 2 FOURTH INTERVAL PERIOD 1 LIMITED EXAMS VIRGINIA ELECTRIC AND POWER COMPANY (DOMINION)
NORTH ANNA POWER STATION UNIT 2
I Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4 th Interval 1st Period Limited Exams
[THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK]
-A Serial No.14-050.
Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4t Interval 1 st Period Limited Exams Page 3 of 86 N2-14-LMT-002 UNIT 2 FOURTH INTERVAL PERIOD 1 LIMITED EXAMS CONTENTS 1.0 ASME CODE COMPONENT(S) AFFECTED...............................................................
5 2.0 APPLICABLE CODE EDITION AND ADDENDA..........................................................
5 3.0 APPLICABLE CODE REQUIREMENT........................................................................
5 Al Pressurizer Nozzle-To-Vessel W elds.........................................................................
7 4.A1 IMPRACTICALITY OF COMPLIANCE 5.Al BURDEN CAUSED BY COMPLIANCE 6.A1 PROPOSED ALTERNATIVE AND BASIS FOR USE B 1 Head C ircum ferential W elds......................................................................................
27 4.B1 IMPRACTICALITY OF COMPLIANCE 5.B1 BURDEN CAUSED BY COMPLIANCE 6.B1 PROPOSED ALTERNATIVE AND BASIS FOR USE B2 N ozzle-to-S hell W elds......................................................................................
39 4.B2 IMPRACTICALITY OF COMPLIANCE 5.B2 BURDEN CAUSED BY COMPLIANCE 6.B2 PROPOSED ALTERNATIVE AND BASIS FOR USE R1 Elem ents Subject To Therm al Fatigue......................................................................
47 4.R1 IMPRACTICALITY OF COMPLIANCE 5.R1 BURDEN CAUSED BY COMPLIANCE 6.R1 PROPOSED ALTERNATIVE AND BASIS FOR USE R2 Elements Not Subject To A Degradation Mechanism...............................................
61 4.R2 IMPRACTICALITY OF COMPLIANCE 5.R2 BURDEN CAUSED BY COMPLIANCE 6.R2 PROPOSED ALTERNATIVE AND BASIS FOR USE 7.0 DURATION OF PROPOSED ALTERNATIVE..............................................................
86 8.0 P R E C E D E N T S.................................................................................................................
8 6
9.0 REFERENCES
86 ENCLOSURES Enclosure Al-1, 12050-WMKS-RC-E-2 /10 Data Report...........................................
9 Enclosure Al-2, 12050-WMKS-RC-E-2 /14 Data Report...........................................
17 Enclosure B1-1, 12050-WMKS-SI-TK-2 / 2-SI-TK-2 / 1 Data Report........................... 28 Enclosure B2-1, 12050-WMKS-SI-TK-2 / 2-SI-TK-2 / 3 Data Report...........................
41 Enclosure R1-1, 12050-WMKS-0103BN / 6-RC-420 / 2B Data Report........................ 50 Enclosure RI-2, 12050-WMKS-0103CB / 3-RC-615 / 7 Data Report.......................... 55
Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 40h Interval 1is Period Limited Exams Page 4 of 86 Enclosure R2-1, 12050-WMKS-0101A-4 / 32-SHP-459 / SW-5 (BPL 343) Data Report.. 64 Enclosure R2-2, 12050-WMKS-0103AG I 6-RC-416 / 4 Data Report..........................
74 Enclosure R2-3, 12050-WMKS-01 11W / 3-CH-814 / 6A Data Report..........................
80 TABLES Table 1, Repetitive/Duplicative Requests Requested in Accordance with 10 CFR 50.55a(g)(5)(iii), Inservice Inspection Impracticality..........................
6
Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4th Interval 1 st Period Limited Exams Page 5 of 86 N2-14-LMT-002 UNIT 2 FOURTH INTERVAL PERIOD 1 LIMITED EXAMS Relief Request in Accordance with 10 CFR 50. 55a(g)(5)(iii)
-- Inservice Inspection Impracticality--
1.0 ASME CODE COMPONENT(S) AFFECTED Refer to Table 1, Columns 1 and 2.
2.0 APPLICABLE CODE EDITION AND ADDENDA North Anna Power Station Unit 2 (NAPS 2) applicable Code for the fourth 10-year inservice inspection (ISI) interval and the ISI program is the 2004 Edition of Section XI with no Addenda (Reference 1). NAPS 2 fourth interval started December 14, 2010 and ends December 13, 2020.
3.0 APPLICABLE CODE REQUIREMENT Refer to Table 1, Column 3.
Components identified in this request require examination of essentially 100 percent of the weld length. "Essentially 100 percent" as clarified by ASME Code Case N-460, Alternative Examination Coverage for Class 1 and Class 2 Welds, is greater than 90 percent coverage of the examination volume, or surface area, as applicable.
The risk-informed welds described in this request are governed by the Risk-Informed I Safety-Based Inservice Inspection (RI-ISI) Program Plan that was approved by the NRC for North Anna Power Station Unit 2 in a letter dated January 21, 2011. The welds are assigned category R-A, Item R1.1 1 or R1.20, and require ultrasonic examination. The North Anna Unit 2 RI-ISI Program, in accordance with Request For Alternative N2-14-RI-001, applies the requirements of ASME Code Case N-716, "Alternative Piping Classification and Examination Requirements."...
The Item R1.11 elements are considered subject to Thermal Fatigue as the most likely degradation mechanism. The Item R1.20 elements are considered not subject to a degradation mechanism. Limited examinations in this request are in accordance with section 3.3.2 of approved request N2-14 RI-001, approved by NRC letter dated January 21, 2011 (TAC No.
ME3450).
-r REQUEST
- 1. ASME CODE
- 2. COMPONENT ID NO.
- 3. APPLICABLE
- 4. IMPRACTICALITY
- 5. BURDEN
- 6. PROPOSED
- 7. DURATION OF NUMBER COMPONENT CODE OF COMPLIANCE CAUSED BY ALTERNATIVE PROPOSED REQUIREMENT COMPLIANCE AND BASIS FOR ALTERNATIVE Al Pressurizer Nozzle-To-Exam Category B-D See Paragraph 4AI See Paragraph 5At See Paragraph 6.A1 See Paragraph ?
Vessel Welds them No. 83.110 12050-WMKS-RC-E-2 / 10 56.6% Volumetric Cover-aoe 12 50-WMKS-RC-E-2 14 56.7% Voklmelric Coverage B1 Head Circumlrerutnil Exam Category C-A See Paragraph 4.31 See Paragraph 5.81 See Paragraph 6.B1 See Paragraph 7 Welds Item No. C1.20 t2050-WMKS-St-TK-2 / 2-SI-TK-2/ 10f7.%
Volume Coverao.
B2 Nozzle-to-Shell Weld Exam Category C-B See Paragraph 4.82 See Paragraph 5.82 See Paragraph 6.82 See Paragraph 7 Item No. C2.2i h4 B
-12050-WMKS-SI-K-2 /2-t-TK-2 /3 C21 27.4% Volume Coverage R1 Elements Subject lo Exam Category R-A See Paragraph 4.R1 See Paragraph 5.81 See Paragraph 6.R1 See Paragraph 7 Thermal Fatigue Item No. R1.11 12050-WMKS-0 1 03BN / 6-RG-420/ 2B 75% Volume Coverage 12050-WMKS-0103C0 I 3-R0-615 / 7 50% Volume Coverage R2 Elements NMt Subject to a Exam Category R-A See Paragraph 4.112 See Paragraph 5.R2 See Paragraph 6.R2 See Pafagraph 7 Degradation Mechanism Item No-R1.20 12050-WMKS-0101A-4132-SHP-459 / SW-5 (BPL 343) 75% Volume Coverfge 12050-WMKS-0103AG I 6-RC-416/4 75% Volume Coverage IL L 12050-WMKS-O 11W /13-CH-814/ 6A 42.3% Volume Coverage X
!0 0
U)
.-I.
0) n
-I (D
0L 0~o Z
Ci)
(D 0)
(L0 o
0 (D
Z-Z re 0.0 0
- 0) Min0 '-
0 X?
a)
- w. 01
- 0) (n (0 0
Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4th Interval 1st Period Limited Exams Page 7 of 86 Al.
Pressurizer Nozzle-To-Vessel Welds 4.AI IMPRACTICALITY OF COMPLIANCE In accordance with 10CFR50.55a(g)(5)(iii), relief is requested from the "essentially 100 percent" volumetric examination coverage requirement for the identified Pressurizer Nozzle-To-Vessel Welds, ASME Section XI Category B-D, Item No. B3.110. This requirement is considered impractical due to the pressurizer to nozzle weld configuration.
Ultrasonic examination of the following pressurizer nozzle-to-vessel welds are limited in coverage due to the pressurizer to nozzle weld configuration as shown in the attached enclosures. Examination was performed to the extent possible using qualified equipment, and no further coverage is possible with existing technology.
Mark/Weld #
Line #
Scan Coverage %
Enclosure 10 2-RC-E-2 56.6%
Al-1 14 2-RC-E-2 56.7%
A1-2 Weld 10, a safety valve nozzle, is limited to 56.6% due to nozzle geometry and because the cladding prevents extended V-path. Refer to Enclosure Al-1 for coverage details of the limitations experienced. Third interval relief for weld 10 was granted per Request N2-13-PRT-002-A5 at 56.6% coverage. Second interval relief for weld 10 exam limitations was granted in Request NDE-19 at 72% coverage (different NDE guidelines for coverage calculations).
Weld 14, the spray nozzle, is limited to 56.7% due to the weld location in relation to the nozzle. Refer to Enclosure A1-2 for coverage details of the limitations experienced.
Third interval relief for weld 14 was granted per Request N2-13-PRT-002-A5 at 56.7%
coverage. Second interval relief for weld 14 exam limitations was granted in Request NDE-20 at 56.6% coverage.
The subject pressurizer nozzle-to-vessel welds are constructed of SA-508 Class 2, a P-Number 3, Group Number 3 carbon steel material, with austenitic stainless steel inside diameter cladding and stainless steel inserts. The welds extend the full thickness of the pressurizer vessel.
Pressurizer upper and lower heads are fabricated from SA-533 Grade A, Class 2 carbon steel. The existing nozzle to pressurizer upper and lower heads are welded with low alloy steel filler, essentially the same as the nozzle material.
The subject pressurizer nozzles have a minimum thickness of 2.5 inches with 0.19 inch cladding. These nozzles are of the "set-in" design which essentially makes the welds concentric rings aligned parallel with the nozzle axes in the through-wall direction of the pressurizer vessel. This design geometry limits ASME Code-required UT angle beam examinations to be performed primarily from the vessel side of the welds.
Although UT scans were primarily limited to the vessel side only, studies have found that inspections conducted through carbon steel are equally effective whether the ultrasonic waves have only to propagate through the base metal, or have to also propagate through the carbon steel weldment. Therefore, due to the fine-grained carbon steel microstructures, it is expected that the UT techniques employed would have detected structurally significant flaws that may have occurred on either side of the subject welds.
Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 - 4th Interval 1st Period Limited Exams Page 8 of 86 Although Dominion considers it is impractical to meet the ASME Code-required 100%
volumetric examination coverage for the subject pressurizer nozzle-to-vessel welds due to nozzle configuration, it is believed that the coverage obtained would have identified significant service-induced degradation. The examinations performed also provide a reasonable assurance of structural integrity of the subject welds.
5.A1 BURDEN CAUSED BY COMPLIANCE The ASME Code requires that the volumetric examination be conducted from both sides of these pressure retaining welds, however, the design configurations limit access for UT scanning primarily to the vessel side of the welds. In order to effectively increase the examination coverage, the nozzle-to-vessel welds would require design modifications or replacement. This is considered a burden making the ASME Code volumetric examination requirements impractical, which is contrary to the intent of the Code.
6.A1 PROPOSED ALTERNATIVE AND BASIS It is proposed that the examinations already completed at the reduced coverage be accepted as meeting the Code requirements. Alternative components could not be substituted for examination due to the mandatory selection requirements of the Code. The limited volumetric examination performed should detect any general patterns of degradation that may occur in the areas covered, therefore providing reasonable assurance of the continued structural integrity of the subject weld.
UT examinations were conducted using ASME Code,Section V, Article 4, techniques and included 0-degree longitudinal, and 45-and 60- degree shear waves from the vessel side.
The examination volumes included the weld and base materials near the inside surface of the weld joint, which are typically the highest regions of stress, and where the expected degradation sources to be manifested should they occur. Manual scanning was performed for these examinations. The configuration of the nozzle to shell weld limits the effective examination of the required examination volume. The nozzle's close proximity to the weld limits scanning due to the nozzle bend radius causing lift-off of the search unit during scanning. No recordable indications were identified during these examinations. The physical configuration of each nozzle limits the effectiveness of alternative or advanced technologies from increasing the examination coverage for this configuration.
Enclosures Al-1 and A1-2 include the complete Ultrasonic Examination Data Records for each Category B-D, Item B3.110, examination included in this request. Each report includes details of the UT scanning parameters, including transducer size, frequency and angle. Also included are coverage plots for each of the examinations showing the nozzle configuration and percent coverage for each individual scan.
The Al Enclosures include search unit details, wave modality, and insonification angles used for all examinations, including the results of each scan. The examinations were performed with 45 degree shear wave, 60 degree shear wave, and 0 degree longitudinal wave search units (as identified in the reports).
UT Calibration/Examination Daminion' Site/Unit:
Summary No.:
Workscope:
NAPS 1
2 N2.B3.110.001 Procedure:
Procedure Rev.:
Work Order No.,
ER-AA-NDE-UT-702 4
59102532605/NDER1 3-079 Outage No.:
N2R22 Report No.:
UT-13-009 Page: I of 3
IS1 Code:
2004 Edition Cat./item:
B-DIB3.110 Location:
PZR 291 Drawing No.:
12050-WMKS-RC-E-2
==
Description:==
Nozzle to Vessel weld System ID:
RC Component ID: 12050-WMKS-RC-E-212-RC-E-24 10 Size/Lcngth:
2.0" 145.0" ThIckness/Diameter:
3.29" 18.0" LimItations:
Limited due to nozzle configuration.
Start Time; 0755 Finish Time:
0810 Instrument Settings Search Unit Cal.
Time Date Axial Orientated Search Unit Serial No.:
091639803 Serial No.:
M18206SP Checks Calibration Signal weep S
Inta Calib0a27on 13/2013Sw ee Sound Path Manufacturer Panametrics Manufacturer:
KBA Initial Cal.
0827 441312013 Refleclor Amplitude %
Division Model:
EPOCH 4 Linearity; L-13-006 Size:
0.75" Model:
Gamma Inter. Cal, 0755 411312013 1114T 80 1.8
.912" Delay; 1.412 us Range:
5.0" Freq.:
2.25 MHZ Center Freq.:
NIA Inter NIA 1/21T 80 3.9 1.421" MWt CalVel:
.2333 inius Pulser:.
Square Exam Angle:
0 Squint Angle:
N/A IneCl,)1 4
314 T 55 5.8 2.914_
Damping; 400 Ohms Reject 0%
Measured Angle:
NIA Mode:
Long.
Final Cal.*
1041 411312013 B/W 10
+
8.5 4.264" Rep. Rate:
Auto Freq.:
2.0 MHz Couplant NIA Exit Point NIA
- of Elements:
I Filter:
.8 -3.0 Mode; Fullwave Cal. Batch:
07220 Circumferential Orientated Search Unit Voltage:
Medium Other:
N/A Contig.:
Single Focus:
NIA Ty e
_Cai rton Sg a Swee p_
_____________Type:
Sou ndSafe Calibration Signal Sweep SudPt Shape:
Round Contour.
N/A Mfg.:
SONOTECH Reflector Amplitude %
Division Wedge Style:
N/A N/A Ax. Gain (dB):
1.0 Circ. Gain (0B):
N/A Exam Batch:
07220 I
Search Unit Cable Type.._Soundafe 10 Screen Div.
5.0 in. of Sound Path Type:
SONOTE Type:
RG 174 Length: 12' No. Conn.- 0 T'a on~f Calibration Block Scan Coverage Mfg.:
SONOTECH Cal. Block No.
VGB-21 Upsiream
- Downstream 0 Seen dB: 1g.0 Reference Block Reference/Simulator Block Thcnss 40 Ca:
oGain S
IgSnal I S'weepl Sound Path Thickness 4.0" DCa.:
0 cW CCWRJ ScandB:"19.0 Serial No.:
05.6998 di Refleclo ude % Division Cal. Elk. Temp.
73 Temp. Tool:
1070BGCY dB Re Rmmpus
% Division
- Exam Surface:
OD Type:
CS Rompus Block 1.0 1FSDH 50
- 1.
.719" Comp. Temp.
71 Temp. Tool:
1070BGCY Surface Condition:
Ground Smooth NIA Racordabla Indication(s):
Yes f]
No [
(If Yes, Ret. Attached Ultrasonic Indication Report.)
Results:
NRI
[]
RI F]
Geom E.
Comments: Refer to previous data report 41077 dated 5/9104 for coverage calculations.
Percent Of Coverage Obtained > 90%:
No Reviewed Previous Date:
Yes Examiner Level II SlgnDtue Date Reviewer Signfu/
Date Vanruler, Chris e
L* "
L 4/13/2013 04.L.
./.
Is-..-. /'s Examiner Level IlL Signature Date Sit Review gnlure Dale Hacker. Jonathon
ýý 4/13/2013 bt4V N Vies
ý1/61/3' Other Level MIA Signature Date ANII Review Signature/
Date NIA banja*
U'I" Call bration/Examinalion M
I-0 CA C
(I)
C:
(D
=. 0 0o w
~(a)
__Z (0 CDo0 CD a (0 M (P -~
- 0) (n (0 0
UT Calibration/Examination aid" ominion SiteaUnit:
Summary No.:
Workscope:
NAPS 1
2 N2.83.110.001 Proredure:
Procedure Rev.:
Work Order No.:
ER-AA-NDE.UT-702 4
59102532605INDER1 3-079 Outage No.:
N2R22 Report No.:
UT-1 3-009 Page:
2 of 3
ISI Code:
2004 Edition Cato/liem:
B-D1B3.110 Location:
PZR 291 Drawing No.:
12050-WMKS-RC-E-2
==
Description:==
Nozzle to Vessel weld System ID:
RC Component ID: 12050-WMKS-RC-E-212-RC-E-2/
10 Size/Length:
2.0" 145.0"'
Thickness/Diameter:
3.29" 1 8.0" Limitations:
Limited due to nozzle configuration.
Start Time:
0B12 Finish Time:
0832 Instrument Settings Search Unit Cal.
Time Date Axial Orientated Search Unit Serial No.:
091639803 Serial No.:
00Y5K7 Checks I
Calbraio Sn Swoop Sound Path Manufacturer:
Panamnetrics Manufacturer KBA Initial Cal._036_4_112013 Reflector Amplitude %
Division IntilCa.066443203 Caiibralion Signal Swe on at Model:
EPOCH 4 Llnearity.
L-13-006 Size;
.5' X 1.0" Model; Comp.G Inter. Cal.
0812 411312013 1/4 T 80 1,9 I
1.398" Delay:
11.94 us Range:
7.4" Freq.:
2.25MHZ Center Frmq.:
NIA I11er. Cal, N/A 112 T 50 3.8 2.795" M'tl Cal/Vel:
.1268 inius Pulser Square Exam Angle:
45 Squint Angle:
NIA Ier. Cal.
0832 4)13t2013 314T 35 5.7 4.215" Final Cal.I 1042 413132013 ID Notch 15 8.7 6.422" Damping:
400 Ohms Reject-0%
Moasured Angle:
45 Mode:
Shear F
-Couplant 514 T 1
20 1
9.5 7.020" Rep. Rate:
Auto Freq.:
2.0 MHz Exit Point
.6" 4 of Elements:
1 Cal.
20 9.5 C
f02d c
Filter:
.8 -3.0.
Mode:
Fullwave ConflC.:
Single Focus:
N/A Cal. Betch:
07220 Cirumferential Orientated Search Ue i Type:
SoundSafe Calibration Signal SwAmp Voltage:
Medium Other NWA Shape:
Rectangular Contour:
NIA Mrg.:
SONOTECH Reflector Amplitude %
Division Path Wedge S1yle" 8WS NIA
_____I Ax. Gain (dB):
24.0 Circ. Gain (dB):
NIA Se Unit Cable Exam Batch:
07220 10 Screen Div, =
7.4 in. of Sound Path Type:
RG 174 Length: 12' No. Conn.: 0 Type:
SoundSafe Mfg.:
SONOTECH Calibration Block Scan Coverage Cal. Block No.
VGB-21 Upstream R1 Downstrmamr
- Scan dB: 30.0 Refernce Block ReferencelSimulator Block Thickness 4.0" Die.:
0 CW
~
CCWI[J Scan dB: 38.0 Serial No.:
05-998 dBi Seiec gnamlt SwDipiSio un dPt Gain Signol JSweep ISound Palth Thicness 4.0 Dia:
0CW[
F/IISadS 80Sdl~.
569 dB IReflector Amplitude % Diviunvi Cal. 1Bk.
Temp.
73 Temp. Tool:
1070BGCY Exam Soce:
0 Type:
CS Rompus Block 24.0 FS.H 40 1.5 1.085" Camp. Temp.
71 Temp. Tool:
t070BGCY Surface Condilion:
Ground Smooth N/A Recordable Indication(s):
Yes No a%
(If Yes, Ret. Altached Ultrasonic Indication Report.)
Results:
NRI R]
RI Geom El Comments: None Percent Of Coverage Obtained > 90%:
No Reviewed Previous Data:
Yes Examiner Loevl Signatue Dale Reviewer Sign',
o Dale Vanruler. Chris r
'-/i U132013 "UL1, l',-
Examiner Level IlL Signature Date Site Review Sig lure ale Hacker, Jonathon 4113)203 5
Other Level N/A V
Signature Date ANII Review 0-Signs re Dale W/A M
0I-0 C
ni CD
_U
-. 0 0_
D C
Z Z 0
.0
.30 C..
M m
- 0) ><
0-f UIT Calibration[Examination
harnoinianý Site/Unit:
Summery No.:
Workscope:
NAPS I
2 UT CalibrationlExamination Procedure:
Procedure Rev.:
Work Order No.:
591 N2.B3.110,001 ER-AA-NDE-UT-702 4
102532605/N DERi 3-079 Outage No.:
N2R22 Report No.:
UT-13-009 Page:
3 of 3
ISI Code:
2004 Edition CatJItem:
B-DIB3.110 Location:
PZR 291 Drawing No.:
12050-WMKS-RC-E-2
==
Description:==
Nozdle to Vessel weld System ID:
RC Component ID:
12050-WMKS-RC-E-2 / 2-RC-E-2 110 Size/Length:
2.0" 145.0" Thlckness/Diameter:
3.29" 16.0" Limitations:
Limited due to nozzle configuration.
Start Time:
0834 Finish Time:
0850 Instrument Settings Search Unit Cal.
Time Dale Axial Orientated Search Unit S e ria l N o.:
0 9 1 6 3 9 8 0 3 S e ria l N o.:
0 0 Y 5 K 6 C h e c k s C
r S ig n al S e p o u d P t Calibration Signal Sweep Sound Patth Manufacturer:
Panametrics Manufacturer:
KBA Initial Cal.
0640 411312013 Reflector Amplitude %
Division Model:
EPOCH 4 Linearity:
L-13-006 Size:
.5" X 1.0" Model:
Cornp-G Inter. Cal.
0834 411312013 1/4 T 80 1.9 1.934" Delay:
15.12 us Range:
10.1" Freq.:
2.25 MHZ Center Freq.:
N/A Inter. Cal.
NIA 112 T 40 3.9 3.979" M'i1 CalNel:
.1268 infus Pulser:
Square Exam Angle:
60 Squint Angle:
NIA Inter. Cal.
0o850 4113/2013 3/4 T.
30 5.9 5.940" Final Cal.
10431 4113f2013 ID Notch 13 8.7 8.746" Damping:
400 Ohms Reject:
0%
Measured Angle; 60 Mode:
Shear opat5/4 T
10 9.8 987 R e p. R a t e :
A u t o F r e q.:
2.0 M H z E x i t P o i n t
.7 "
- o f E l e m e n t s :
I C apl B a t c h :
0 7_2 D C i c m f r n t a 9i t8 77h n
Filter;
.3-3.0 Made:
Fullwave Config.:
SingleCal, Bch:
07220 Circumferential Orentated Search Unit Voitage; Medium Other:
NA SType:
SoundSafe Calibration Signal Sweep Sound Path Sha:
Retangulr Contur:
NANOTECH Reflector Amplitude %
Division Wedge Style:
30.0 Circ. Gain (dB):
N/A Search Unit Cable Exam Batch; 07220 10 Screen Div. =
10.1 in. of Sound Path Type:
RG 174 Length: 12' No. Conn.:
0 Type:
SoundSafa S
Mfg.:
SONOTECH Calibration Block Scan Coverage Cal. Block No.
VGB-21 Upstream F/
Downstream Scan dB: 44.0 Reference Block Reference/Simulator Block Thickness 4.0" Dia.:
0 CW jv CCW *]i Scan dB: 48.0 Serial No.:
05-6998 Gain Situde %
Cal. Blk. Temp.
73 Tamp. Tool:
107OBGCY Exan Surface:
OD Type:
CS Rompus Block 30.0 FSDH 40p 1.5 Comp. Temp.
71 Temp. Toot:
107OBGCY Surface Condition:
Ground Smooth N/A Recordable Indication(s):
Yes E No W (if Yes, Ref. Attached Ultrasonic Indication Report.)
Results:
NRI L./
RI -
Geom n Comments: None Percent Of Coverage Obtained > 90%:
No Reviewed Previous Data:
Yes Examiner Level II Signater1 Date Reviewer Signalur.
Date Vanruler, Chris 4113/2013,,L I r 3 Examiner Level iL gnature Date Site Review ignature Date Hacker, Jonathon 4113/2013 6
. S i-r Other Level NIA (I
Signature Date ANtRvlew
-Signature a
N/A A~ Z 0I-0CO)
C X
Cf)
C:
(D 3-a CL U,6 0.0 c 0)En(DC LIT Call bratlon/Examlnation
Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4th Interval 1 st Period Limited Exams Page 12 of 86 ENCLOSURE A1-1
/ In
]terval: 3 Dominion Ultrasonic Examination Data Record 1077 NAPS 1 2 12050-WVMK-RC-E-2 2-RC-E-2 03-201 uplant CalCheck! CalChe.k2 CalCheck3 WO I DCP Procedure Rev 01o22 NDB-UT-703 3
Lhermometer SerNo: 1PT-12 Exam Data UT.NO RECTAGI marklweld Sea d
. Exam Area Surtace Condition ITemp Partia1 Single Side Resuts 1077 5953 14 ATrAcH.7 GROUND 3 1Ye
'No NRw 10J77 5949 10 ATaACK 7 GROUND 73 1Y.s No MUI Comments:
SCANNIG SENSITIVITY FOR THE 0 DEG EXAM WAS 4.5 dB FOR THE BASE METAL EXAM AND 6.0 dB FOR TBE WEL METAL EXAM. SCANNING SENSITIVITY FOR TEE 45 DEG AND 60 DEG EXAMS WAS REFERENCE +14dB.
UT1Signature ILe'velMethodl Date Activity
- 1077 Exje;
-R 11 UT 05/09/2W04 11/1012004
- eviewed By:
Level:,,-:-r Date: S-1/7-0V/ ý ANil,
Date Initial 0 Final HSB-CT
Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4t" Interval 1 St Period Limited Exams Page 13 of 86 ENCLOSURE A1-1 VIRGjWA4 POWE PERCENT VOLUME BY SCAN DIRECTION A WING
-,WLD ANGLE SCAN AREA DIRECTION SCAN %
6-- -.
Z'
..l z,,....
11 1 1L
_____Ti z
4-A/2__
¢.s÷,*..
ig,,,.. A,~,,VL,,.#
~~ Kg
~51/2% e' Virginib fpKvar NDE Levi-III Date ANII ______
Date Initial -03 Final 0 HS1-CT
Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4th Interval 1st Period Limited Exams Page 14 of 86 ENCLOSURE A1-1 Dominion UT Partial Record UTRNOIRECTA Drawing Line Mark/weld Procedure Rev I D77 15949 12050-WMKS-RC-B-2 2-RC-E-7 10 NDE-UT-703 3
CaIN.
Weld Width IExamn Angle STJ Length.
SU Width SU Nose percent 549 2.5 0
N/A NA/A 57%%
Area Not Examined SEE SXT BELOWFOR VOLUME NOT EXAMINED.
Reason LIMThED EXAM DUE TO NO2Z BLEND RADIUS.
Comments 56.6% OF'THE TOTAL CODE REQULMED VOLUME COVED. SEE COVERAGE WORISHEET FOR SPECIC SCAN PERCENTAGES.
Cress Section Sketch la.-w,,
Oc/oo-
-,rc-e I
I i
.I Evaluation The weld volume and adjacent base metal was examined from the Pressurizer side only. Geometry precludes examination from the nozzle side. The weld was examined to the maximum extent possible. See the attached Percent Volume by Scan Direction" sheet for the covered by each scan.
Signature Level DATE K.
11I 5/9/04 Reviewed By:
Level:<
Date-3 ~/o C-,
AN,,.
Date, //
ItiaFal 3 F
"Inef HSB-CT
Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4th Interval 1st Period Limited Exams Page 15 of 86 ENCLOSURE Al-I Reviewed By:
'"'u De~~fate, v
ANIILŽ4A Date 6
Initial 3 Final1 HSB-CT
Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4th Interval 1st Period Limited Exams Page 16 of 86 ENCLOSURE A1-1 Dominion UT Partial Record U1RORECTAG Drawing Line Mark/weld Procedure Rev 1077 1 5949 12050-WMN-RC-E-2 2-RC-E-2 10 NDE.-
3 CaN Weld Width Exam Angl SU Length SU Width SUJ Nose Percent i63 2.5 60 5
.. t.55)
I'
.0.3.7 Area Not Examined SEME TCi BELOW FOR VOLTZM NOT EXAM1NED.
Reason LDMIED EXAM DU. TO NOZZLE BLEND RADiUs Comments 56.6% OFTHE TOTAL CODE REQL.UID VOLUME COVED. SE-COVE.RAE WORKSHET FOR SPCIFIC SCAN PERCTAGES.
Crass Section Sketch
-Lor~t' P=*,* :.*Z6.de'-,*'..**"
er-I.
1 EIao Evlato re weld volume and adjacent base metal was examined from the Pressurzer side only. Geometry precludes examination 6o the nozzle side. The weld was examined to the maximum extent possible. See the attached Percent Volume by Scan Direction" sheet for the covered by each scan.
Signature Level DATE SReviewed By:
Le762y5-Date:
J.",
ANIl
- Date Z-4 InitilI 0 Final T '
HSB-CT
UT Calibration/Examination so Dominion-Site/Unit:
Summary No.:
Workscope:
NAPS 2
N2.83.110.005 Procedure:
Procedure Rev.:
Work Order No.:
ER-AA-NDE-UT-702 4
59102532605/NDER13-079 Outage No.:
N2R22 Report No.:
UT-13-003 Page:
1 of 3
ISI Code:
2004 Edition CatJitem:
B-D/B3.110 Location:
PZR 291 Drawing No.:
12050.WMKS-RC-E-2
==
Description:==
Nozzle to Vessel Weld System ID:
RC Component ID: 12050-WMKS.RC-E-21 2-RC-E-2 114 Size/Length:
2.0" 145.0" ThicknessiDiemeler:
3.29" I B.0" Limitations:
Limited due to nozzle configuration.
Start Time:
085B Finish Time:
0904 Instrument Settings Search Unit Cal.
Time Data Axial Orientated Search Unit Serial No.:
091 639803 Serial No.:
M I820gSP Checks IC b
ogSo d
_______________________________________________-.Calibration Signal Sweep Sound Path Manufacturer.
Panametrics Manufacturer:
KBA Initial Cal.
0627 411312013 Reflector Amplitude %
Division Model:
EPOCH 4 Linearity; L-13-006 Size:
0.75' Model:
Gamma Inter. Cal.
0856 4
.13/2013 114T 80 1.8
.912" Delay:
1.412 us Range:
5.0" Freq.:
2.25 MHz Center Freq.:
N/A Inter. Cal.
MIA 1/2 T g0 3.9 1.921-Mtl CafNal:
.2333 in/us Pulser:
Square Exam Angle:
0 Squint Angle:
N/A Inter. Cal.
0904 4/1312013 3/4T 65 5.8 2.914" Damping:
400 Ohms Reject:
0%
Measured Angle:
NIA Mode:
Long.
Final Cal.
1041 4113/2013 100+
8.5 4264" Rep. Rale:
Auto Freq.:
2.0 MHz Couplant N/A Exit Point N/A
- of Elements:
1Copat__________
Filter:
.8-3.0 Mode:
Fullwave Cal. Batch:
07220 Circumferential Orientated Search Unit Contig.:
N/A Focus:
N/A Voltage:
Medium Other:
NIA Type:
SoundSafe Calibration Signal Sweep Shape:
Round Contour:
N/A Mfg.:
SONOTECH RAflector Amplitude %
Division Sound Path Wedge Style:
NIA N/A EaBt:
72I Ax. Gain (dB):
1,0 Circ. Gain (dSB):
N/A Exam Batch:
07220 Search Unit Cable_____
10 Screen Div. m 5.0 in. of Sound Path Type:
SoundSafe Type:
RO 174 Length: 12-- No. Conn.:
0Tye Sonaf Mfg.:
SONOTECH Calibration Block Scan Coverage Cal. Block No.
VGB-21 Upstream D. Downstream Scan dB: 19.0 Reference Block ReferencetSImulator Block Thickness 4.0" Dla.,
0 CW C~
cnd: 90Sra o:
0-98 Gain Signal SepSudPt Gai Swnal Sweep Sound Path Th0CWW Scan dB:"
Seal No.:
05-998 dB Reflector Amplitude %
Division Cal. Bmk. Temp.
73 Temp. Tool:
1070BGCY Type:
CS Rompus Block 1.0 FSDH 50 1.5
.719" Camp. Temp.
71 Temu. Tool; 1070BGCY Surface Condition:
Ground Smooth N/A Recordable Indication(s):
Yes r]
No L (If Yes. Ref. Attached Ultrasonic Indication Report)
Results:
NRI RI []
Geom [-
Comments:
Refer to previous data report#41077 dated 5/9/04 for coverage calculations.
Percent Of Coverage Obtained > 90%:
No Reviewed Previous Data:
Yes nj naminer Level If Si nature Date Reviewer Signature Date Examiner Level ILL Signature Date
- SPleview, Date 4a/3er, Jonathon 4/112013 e/ý-
c1t I*S U lra LevelASignature Date ANII Review,5,
,Date UIT CalibrationtlExaminalion 5/4111 0
00)
C;a C,)
=!.0 0
0 (0,-
-0 0.
co 3 Lo E
- 0) (n (0 0
UT Calibration/Examination
$"01Dominion Sile"Unit:
Summary No.:
Workscope:
NAPS 1
2
'SI Procedure:
Procedure Rev.:
Work Order No.:
ER-AA-NDE-UT-702 4
59102532605/NDER13.079 Outage No.:
N2R22 Report No.:
UT-13-003 Page; 2
cl 3
Code:
2004 Edition CatJltem:
B-DIB3.110 Location:
PZR 291 Drawing No.:
12050-WMKS-RC-E-2
==
Description:==
Nozzle to Vessel Weld System ID:
RC Component ID: 12050-WMKS.RC-E-2 / 2-RC-E-2 /14 Size/Length:
2.0" 145.0" ThlcknessfItameter:
3.29" 18.0" Umitations:
Limited due to nozzle configuration.
Start TIme:
0906 Finish Time:
0924 Instrument Settings Search Unit Cal.
Time Date.
Axial Orientated Search Unit Serial No.:
091639803 Serial No.:
00Y5K7 Checks Calibration Signal Sweep Sound Path Manufacturer:
Panametrics Manufacturer KBA Initial Cal.
0636 411312013 Reflector Amplitude %
Division Model:
EPOCH 4 Uneardty:.
L-13-006 Size;
.51" X 1.0" Model:
Comp.G Inter. Cal.
0906 411312013 1l4 T 80 1.9 1.398" Delay:
11.94 us Range:
7.4" Freq.:
2.25 MHz Center Freq.:
N/A Inter. Cal.
N/A 112 T 50 3.8 2.795" M'd CalNel:
.1288 in/us Pulser:
Square Exam Angle:
45 Squint Angle:
N/A Inter. Cal.
- 0924, 4/1312013 3/4 T 35 5.7 4.215" Final Cal. 1t0421 41t3/20 13 INth 15"
.7
.42 Damping:
400 Ohms Reject:
0%
Measured Angle:
45 Mode:
Shear ID Notch 15
!.7
(.422" Rep. Rate:
Auto Freq.:
2.0 Ml-z Exit Point
.6"
- of Elements:
I Couplant 5/4 T 20 9.5
._"__.020" Filter
.83.M-Cal. Batch:
07220 Circumferential Orientated Search Unit Filter:.
.8 - 3.0 Mode:
FulI~wave Config.:
Single Focus:
N/A_____
Type:
SoundSafe Calibration Signal Sweep Voltage:
Medium Other NIA Shapo:
Rectangular Contour:
N/A Mfg.:
SONOTECH Reflector Amplitude %
Division Sound Path Wedge Style:
SWS N/A Ax. Gain (dB):
24.0 CIro. Gain (dB):
N/A Search Unit Cable.
Exam Batch; 07220 10 Screen Div. -
7.4 in. of Sound Path Type:
RG 174 Length: 12' No. Conn.: 0 Type:
SoundSafe Mfg.:
SONOTECH Calibration Block Scan Coverage Cal. Block No.
VGB-21 Upstream w DownstreamJ] Scan dB: 38.0 Reference Block Reference/Simulator Block Thickness 4.0" Die.:
0 Scan dB: 38.0 Serial No.:
05,,998 Gain Signal ye Sound Path W 0 COW Scan d______
dB Reflector Amplitude % Division Cal. BIk. Temp.
73 Temp. Tool:
1070BGCY Exam Surface:
OD Type:
CS Rompus Block 24.0 FSDH 40 1.5 1.085" Comp, Temp.
71 Temp. Tool:
107OBGCY Surface Condition:
Ground Smooth N/A Recordable Indication(s):
Yes i
No W (If Yes, Ret. Attached Ultrasonic Indication Report.)
Results:
NRI LJ RI Geom [7 Comments: None Percent Of Coverage Obtained t 90%;
No Reviewed Previous Data:
Yes Examiner Level 11 S
ignatIae Dale Reviewer Signature Date Vanruler, Chris 4/13/2013 Examiner Level IlL ISlnature Date eview ED)
D Hacker, Jonathon J
j 4f/1312013 1lP t'-e v
Other Level N/A
/
j Signature Data ANII Review SintA l
Date NIA M
0 (n)
C X
Nf)
CD (D
- 0. 0 OCD Z-Z 00 0Z
-CL. 0 OD M a.
- 0) (/l (00 UT Calibration/Examinalion
UT Calibration/Examination
!2vaminian Site/Unit:
Summary No.:
Workscope:
/
2 Procedure:
ER-AA-NDE-UT-702 N2.B3.1 10.005 Procedure Rev.:
4 Work Order No.:
59102532605/NDER13-079 Outage No.:
N2R22 Report No.:
UT-13-003 Page:
3 of 3
ISI Code:
2004 Edition Cal,/Item:
B-01B3.110 Location:
PZR 291 Drawing No.:
12050-WMKS-RC-E-2
==
Description:==
Nozzle to Vessel Weld System ID:
RC Component ID: 12050-WMKS-RC-E-212-RC-E-2/ 14 Size/Length:
2.0" 145.0" Thlckness/Dlamefer:
3.29" I8.0.
Umitations:
Limited due to nozzle configuration.
Start Time:
0925 Finish TIme:
0947 Instrument Settings Search Unit Cal.
Time Date Axial Orientated Search Unit Serial No.:
091639803 Serial No.:
0OYSK6 Checks Calibration Signal sweep Sound Path Manufacturer!
Panametrics Manufacturer:
KBA Initial Cal.
0640 411312013 Reflector Amp!ltude %
Division Model:
EPOCH 4 Linearity:
L-13-006 Size:
.5" X 1.0" Model:
Comp-G Inter. Cal.
0925 4113(2103 1/4 T 00 1.9 1.934" Delay:
15.12 us Range:
10.1" Freq.:
2.25 MHz Center Freq.:
N/A Inter. Cal.
N/A 112 T 40 3.9 3.979" NII CtNeh
.1268 in/us Pulsar:
Square Exam Anlgle; 60 Squint Angie:
N/A inter. Cal.
0947 4/1312013 314 T 30 5.9 5.940" Final Cal.I 1043 4/1312013 ID Notch 13 8.7 8.746" Damping:
400 Ohms Reject:
0%
Measured Angle:
60 Mode:
Shear Couplant 5t4 T 10 1
9.8 9.817" Rep. Rate:
Auto Freq.:
2.0 MHz Eit Point
.7"
- of Elements:
C Filer:
3.0 Mode; Fullwave g
SCal.
Batch:
07220 Circumferential Orientated Search Unit Volage:
Medium Other:
N/A Cocus WA Type:
SoundSafe Calibration Signal Sweep Sound Path Shape:
Rectangular ContourMfg SONOTECH Reflector Ampitude Divi Sound Path Wedge Style:
SWB N/A Ax. Gain (dB):
30.0 Circ. Gain (dB):
N/A Sy lit Cable Exam Batch:
07220 10 Screen Div.=
10.1 in. of Sound Path Type:
RG 174 Length: T2' No. Conn.: 0 Type:
SoundSafe Mfg.:
SONOTECH Calibration Block Scan Coverage Cal. Block No.
VGB-21 Upstream J Downsream
- Scan dB: 44.0 Reference Block Reference/Simulator Block Thickness 4.0-Die.:
0 CW n---' CCW Scan dB: 48.0 Serial No.:
05-6998 Gain Signal Sweep Sound Patt Cal. Blk. Temp.
T3 Temp. Tool:
1070BGCY Exam Surface:
OD Type:
CS Rompus Block
- 0.
FDH 40 1.5 1.479" Comp. Temp.
71 Temp. Tool:
t070BGCY Surface Condition:
Ground Smooth N/A Recordable Indication(s):
Yes F, No Sa.
(If Yes, Ref. Attached Ultrasonic Indication Report.)
Results:
NRI R, RI Geom f-1 Comments: None Percent Of Coverage Obtained > 90%:
No Reviewed Previous Data:
Yea Examiner Level II Signature Date Reviewer Signature Dale Vanruler, Chris a13/2 01 0.-1-".t 413203 Examiner Level IlL S
i.._ re Date Site Review Sigrturp.
,t Hacker, Jonathon t-413/20113 6/1 Other Level N/A
(
Agnature Date ANII Review Signet Dt N/A
,4,4 mZ 0r-0 (1)
C X
z 507 0 C 0.0 (0k
-"a) 3 w(7
)in(D3 01 UT Calibration/Examinalion
Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4 th Interval 1st Period Limited Exams Page 20 of 86 ENCLOSURE A1-2 Interval: 3 Dominion Ultrasonic Examination Data Record
=1077 NAPS 2
12050-WMKS-RC-E-2 2-RC-E-2 03-201
~uplant CaiCheckl CalCheck2 CalCheck31 WO I DCP Procedure R1ev 01220 NDE-UT-703 3
Thermmneter SerNo: I-1 mark/eld Ican ~
Exam Data CndtnSngeid eut UTRNoIRECTAGt mark/wold F
m Area Surface CondtonI.TempPartialilSid.
Resul 1077NO R 595A3 14 A TITAC H{
7 GROUND 73 Yes.
No
?JIm
[1077 5949 10 ATFACR 7 GROUND 73 Y-s NO MR Comments:
SCANNING SENSITiVITY FOR THE 0 DEG EXAM WAS 4.5 dB FOR THE BASE METAL EXAM AND 6.0 dB FOR THE WELD M1ETAL EXAM. SCANNING SENSITIVIT FOR. THE 45 DEG AND 60 DEG EXAMS WAS REEECE +14dB.
,Signature Lew I
Method IDate I A t
1077 11 UT 0509/M2004 11/10=2004
- cviewed. By:
Level:,7.g-Date: 5-/7 L, I ANtI Date Initial 03 Finali
.HSB-CT
Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4th Interval 1st Period Limited Exams Page 21 of 86 ENCLOSURE AI-2 WRGfiVIA POWER PERCENT VOLUME BY.SCAN DIRECTION DRAMWNG
/25
~f-
~ZWELD #
4 ANGLE SCAN AREA DIRECTION SCA4N %
£*-
~
ASe 4'
~
2 X0,__
Jr dA~
VqiW&in9a0P we,- 9DE LeV'W /1i Date Initial M Final HSB-CT
Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4th Interval 1st Period Limited Exams Page 22 of 86 ENCLOSURE Al -2 Dominion UT Partial Record 0TRNO CTAO Drawing Line Mark/weld Procedure Rev 15077 5953 1 12050-W-MS-RC-E-2 2-RC-E-2 14 NDE-IJT-701 3
ald_ Weld Width Exam Angle SU Length SU Width SU Nose Percent 345/
L-"
o r' /A
{
NIA N/A.
7%
Area Not Examined SEE SKETCH BELOW FOR VOLUME NOT EX4MIED.
Reason M
EXAM DUE TO THE NOZZLE BLEND RADIUS Comments ODE RHQURZED VOLUME COVERAGE CALCULAMONS TAKENFROM PREVIOUS DATA (99-16-93 NNDER
- 93-299)
'1 Cross Section Sketch I
Evaluation ve weld volume and adjacent base metal was examined from the Pressurizer side only. Geometr7 precludes examination from the nozzle side. The weld was examined to the maximum extent possible. See the attached Percent Volume by Scan Direction" sheet for the covered by each scan e i BLevely DATE D
Reiwe.y:-Lee--ae C7/
v ANII AA*
Date 7/OY Initial 0 Final HSB-CT
Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4th Interval 1st Period Limited Exams Page 23 of 86 ENCLOSURE A11-2 Dominion UT Partial Record UUTRNO RECTAA Drawing I
Line Mark/weld Procedure Rev l 1 077 l 5953 l 12 05o-W M KS-Rc --2 2-Rc --2 14 ND -IJ - 0 CaJIN Weld Width Exam Aiige SU Lengthi U Width SU Nose Percent
-104 1.5" 45 1.4 1.6
.75 Area Not Examined SEE S-TCH BELOW IV VOLU.W NOT EXAMIMED.
Reason LIIE EXAM DUE TO NOZZLE BLED RADIUS Comments CODE REQUaRED VOLUME COVERtAGE CALCuLATIONS TA*CN FROM PREVIOUS DATA (9-16-93 /NDER 093-299)
Cross Section Sketch I
£
-1 :"sL/
E Evaluation
]7he weld volume and adjacent base metal was examined from the Pressurizer side on~ly. Geometry precludes examination from the nozzle side. The weld was examined to the maximum extent possible. See the attached Percent Volume by Scan Direction" sheet for the covered by each scan.
Signature Level DATE Reviewed By.
Leve!-'
Date:
r I
ANII
-Date Initial 13 Fin8Il HSB-CT
Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4th Interval 1 st Period Limited Exams Page 24 of 86 ENCLOSURE A1-2 Dominion UT Partial Record IUTRNO ICIAO Drawing I
Line Mark/weld Procedure Rey
)
a77 5953 12050-WMKS-RC4ý-2 2,RC*H-2 14 ND
-703 3
S!A Weld Width IExam Angle SU Length SU Widt SU Nose
-Percent 103
.5" 60 1.5 1.55
.65 57%
Area Not Examined SEE SKETCH BELOW FOR VOLUMEf, NOT EXAMINED.
Reason LnMITED EXAM DUE TO NOZZE BLEND RADIUS Comments CODE REQUERED VOLUME COVERAGE CALCULATIONS TAKEN FROM PREVIOUS DATA (9-16-93 INDER #93-M99)
Cross Section Sketch PX LL~
Evaluation The weld volume and adjacent base metal was examined from the Pressurizer side only. Geometry precludes examination frino the nozzle side. The weld was examined 1o the maximum extent possible. See the attached Percent Volume by Scan Direction" sheet for the covered by each scan.
Signature Level DATE; H
519/04 Reviewed By:
4Level:.s-5 Date:
C,/
ANII _'__
Date Initial 13 Final HSB-CT
@ Interval: 3 Dominion Power Ultrasonic vfibration Data Record is UTRNO Station IUnit Procedure Rey Siting Procedure IRey I Couplant Call lock CBLKTE2S CBl KTemp 1077 NAPS 2
NDE-UT-703 3
1 NDEUT-N/A 01220 VRA-27 2.479TXI10.057'LXO0 75 CLbType jCLbLngth #Counectl Simulator AmpSwp CalDate ICaLn JCaL~ut I CatBlock2 CBLKTKS2 CBL Temp2 RG-59 12' 1
0 05/09t2004 19:45 116:32 1
Thermometer.SerNo PT-12 Instrument Settings UTRNO MemLoc CalNo CAL BLK REJECT dO jREFdB RANGE VELOCITI ZERO DELAY FMEQ FILTER ENERGY I DMPING 1077 VRA2760 103 VRA-27 0%
1 I27,2
+0 1I
.623 0.1259 116.58 N/A 2.27
.8-3.0 MAX 400 1077 VRA2745 104 VRA-27 0%
1 0.1264
'10.86 N/A 2.27
.8-3.0 MAX 400 1077 VRA27o 549 VRA-27 0%
10.0
-.0dB 0I 0,2339 Wns 1 0.491 us N/A 2.27
.8-3.0 MEDIUM 1
400 Xducer Data UTRNO CalNo SertalNo Manuf Model She Frequency Angle Wedge Type WedgeLength WedgeWidth W AgeNosae 1077 103 337349 PANAMETRICS CONTACT
.5"X 1.0 2.25 MHIZ 60 SWS
].5 h.55
.65 1077 104 337350 PANAMETRICS CONTACT
.5" X 1.0" 2.25 MHZ 45 SWS 1.4 1.6
.75 1077 549_
M182075P KB-AEROTHCH GAMMA
.75" 2.25M-Z 0
N/A N/A N/A N/A Vertical Beam Spread UTRNO CalNof 1/4Depth [ 1/2Depih 3/4Depth I14SPF 1/4SPM IJ4SP.
1/2SPF 1/2SPM 112SPB 3148PF 3/4SPM 3/4SPB Beam Spresd Wil.
1077 103 0.62 1.24 1.87 0.85 1.1 1.35 1.87 2.3 2,83 2.84 3.46 4.17 37,35095963384 61.61 444233522 1077 104 0.62 1.24 1.87 0.55 0.69 0.82 1.12 I 134 1.5 1.64 1.9 2.19 18,98655223019 45.455924961672 Instrument Calibration Data I
UTRNO SRAC Inst. Serial lnst. Model Inst. Manuf CaINo U"RNO CalNo Direction CaLType Point Reflector Position Amplitude
§wep 1077 153 040182503 EOCH 4 RED.TECH INST.
549 1077 103 2,5,7,8 DET I
1/4TSDH 1.15';
80%
2,0 1077 153 040182503 EPOCH4 R.D.T0.CHINST.
103 1077 103 2.5,7,8 D"ET 2
1/2TSDH 2.25" 50%
. 4.0 1077 153 040182503 EPOCH 4 R.D.TECH INST.
104 1077 103 2,5,7,8 DEl' 3
3/4TSDH 3.35" 38%
6.0 1077 103 2,5,7,8 DET 4
ID NOTCH 4.15" 18%
7.9 1077 103 2,5,7,8 DET 5
5/4TSDH NIA 19%
10.0 1077 104 2.5,7,8 DEl
- 1 1/4TSDH 0.70" 80%
2.0 1077 104 2,5,7,8 DET 2
I/2TSDH 1.35" 61%
4.0 1077 104 2,5,7,8 DET 3
3/4TSDH 1.90" 48%
6.0 1077 104 2,5,7,8 DET 4
ID NOTCH 2.40" 20%
8.1 1077 104 2,5,7,8 DiT 5
5/4TSDH N/A 24%
10.0 1077 549 N/A DET 1
1/4TSDH N/A 78%
2.0 1077 549 N/A DfT 2
12TrSDH
"'N/A 85%
4.0 UTRNO Signature Level Method Date Ac ivlty mz 0
r-0CA)
C Nf)
X1 z
C (Z
0 )o (D
-U CD%
z 0
0 0 CL-
- 0) (n (0 0 1077 Calibrated By DAVID TUCKER I
UT 05/09/2004 11/*0 ANII :&&
I Initial 0HSB t/2004 CT Le0v-l E
DatictS f"
I O
Interval: 3 I Dominion Power Ultrasonic alibration Data Record I 6I w.
I1077 54
)NA 1 3 1314TSDII I N/A I75%
6.0J 1077
)4
/A D
4 BW
_IN/A
>1OO9&
&IL M
r-0 m
Wl z
Cf (D
a 0 C 0 0 N1)a
- 0) F co 3 w 6~
- 0) Wn (00C UTRNO Signature Level Method Date Actii4ty 1077 Calibrated By A/*
Q DAVID TUCKER 11 UT 05/09/2004 1
HAY AN11 1-&4LDa ft" 13
/2004 j; 4 41 -/
Reviewed y:.
Leveft Date.
Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4th Interval 1s' Period Limited Exams Page 27 of 86 B1.
Head Circumferential Welds 4.B1 IMPRACTICALITY OF COMPLIANCE In accordance with 10CFR50.55a(g)(5)(iii), relief is requested from the "essentially 100 percent" volumetric examination coverage requirement for the identified vessel to head circumferential weld. This requirement is considered impractical due to weld configuration, including supports, thermocouples, and weld profile.
Ultrasonic examination of the full 165 inches of weld length of the lower head circumferential weld on the boron injection tank is limited to 87.6 percent due to four supports obstructing eight inches of weld length each, two installed thermocouples obstructing 1.8 inches each, and 0.9 inches obstructed by the weld profile. Refer to Enclosure B1-1 for coverage details for the vessel to head circumferential weld (weld #
1). Examination was performed to the extent possible.
5.B1 BURDEN CAUSED BY COMPLIANCE Destruction of the component, including removal of welded supports and thermocouples, would be necessary to perform 100% of the Code required examination as written in the 2004 ASME Section Xl Code with No Addenda and is contrary to the intent of the Code.
6.B1 PROPOSED ALTERNATIVE AND BASIS It is proposed that the examinations already completed in the fourth interval at reduced coverage be accepted as meeting the Code requirements. The limited volumetric examination performed should detect any general patterns of degradation that may occur in the areas covered, therefore providing reasonable assurance of the continued structural integrity of the subject weld.
One other component in category C-A, Item No. C1.20, on the boron injection tank, is scheduled for examination during the current interval.
The examinations were performed using standard ASME Section V, Article 4 UT techniques. Manual scanning was performed for these examinations.
Enclosure B1-1 includes the complete Ultrasonic Examination Data Record for the Category C-A, Item C1.20, examination included in this request. The report includes details of the UT scanning apparatus, including transducer size, frequency and angle.
Also included are scan plots for the examination showing limitation locations. The wave modality and insonification angles are also included. No recordable indications were identified during the examination.
The Boron Injection Tank head is ASTM A-516 Grade 70 carbon steel with 0.125" weld deposit clad ASTM A-240 Type 304L. Tank head design thickness is a minimum of 2.00".
UT Calibration/Examination 21D0min.i -n Shle/Unit:
Summary No.:
WorkAscope:
NAPS 1
2 N2.C1.20.010 Procedure; Procedure Rev.:
Work Order No.:
ER-AA-NDE-UT-702 4
59102532605/NDER13-079 Outage No.:
N2R22 Report No.-
UT-13-010 Page:
1 of 10 ISl Code:
2004 Edition Cat.litem:
C-AIC1.20 Location:
AUX 244 Drawing No.:
12050-WMKS-S1-TK-2 Description; Head to Shell Weld System ID:
Si Component ID: 12050-WMKS-.SI-TK-2 1 2-SI-TK-2 I1 Size, Length:
2.3 1 165" ThlcknessJDlameler; 2.6" 1 52.75" Limitations:
See Attached Start Time:
13:00 Finish Time:
13:26 Instrument Settings Search Unit Cal.
Time Date Axial Orientated Search Unit Serial No.:
040186603 Serial No.:
Mi8207SP Checks Iaibrn Sep od" Manufacturer.
Panametrics Manufacturer.
KBA Initial Cal.
0840 4/1122013E Relector IgAmplitude Division Model:
EPOCH 4 Linearity:.
L-13011 SIze:
0.75" Model:
Gamma Inter. Cal.
1300 411212013 1/4T 70 1.8
.556" Delay; 1.377 Range:
3.0" Freq.:
Z.25 MHz Center Freq.:
N/A Inter. Cal.
N/AV1/2 T
80 4.0 1.180" M'tl Cal/Vel:
.2329 Pulser.
Square Exam Angle:
a Squint Angle:
NIA inter Cal.
1320 4112/2013 3A1 T 70 5.0 1.805" Damping:
400 ReJect:
0%
Measured Angle; NIA Mode:
Long.
Final Cal.
1650 BW 100+
8.2 2.480 Re.
ae; AtoFrq:
MzCouplant Rep. Rate:
Auto Freq.:
2.0 MHz Exit Point NIA
- of Elements:
1 p
Filter:
A8 -3.0 Mode:
Fullwave Cal. Belch:
07220 Circumferential Orientated Search Unit Voltage:
Low Other NIA Config.:
Single Focus:
NIA Type:
SoundSaf Calibration Signal Sweep' Shape:
Round Contour NIA Mfg.:
SONOTECH Reflector Amplitude %
Division Sound Pa Wedge Style:
N/A N/A Ax. Gain (d8):
5.8 Circ. Gain (d]):
NIA Exam Batch; 07220 Search Unit Cable 10 Screen Dlv. =
3.0 in. of Sound Path Tye 10Type.
SoundSafe SType:.
RG 174 Length: 12..' No. Copnn.: 0Tye Sonaf Mfg.:
SONOTECH Calibration Block Scan Coverage Cal. Block No.
VRA-27 ReRferenae/Slmulator Block Upstream [f, Downstream *] Scan dB: 11.8 Referegncewep Blockat Thickness 2.47" Dia.:
a CW [l CCW[] ScandB:: N/A Serial No.:
05-6998 dB Relector Amplitude % D Sound Path Cal.
dk.
Temp.
R.9 Temp. Tool:
Di7vBBCY Exam Surface:
OD Type:
CS Rompus Block 5.8
.5" SDH 52 2.4
.723" Comp. Temp.
85 Temp. Tool; 1079BGCY NIA Surface Condition:
Contour GroundNA Recordable Indication{s):
Yes [E No W (if Yes, Ref. Attached Ultrasonic Indication Report.)
Results:
NRI RI [J Geomr 1 Comments: None Percent Of Coverage Obtained > 90%'
No Reviewed Previous Data:
Yes Examiner Level it-Signature Date Reviewer Signatu.
Date Currao, Jeffrey T 4/1212013 L:"j, XA.-
Examiner Level Signature Date R
iteevir N/A q
Other Level NIA Signature Date ANIi RevtewftaleDe N/A M
z 0r-0 CO)
C X
z 0)
(D K
.CL00 0
co W c0 0)1, (0
0 UT CallbrationfExamination
UT Calibration/Examination WaaDminiame Site/Unit:
Summary No.:
Workscope:
/
2 N2.C1.20.010
. 181 Procedure:
ER-AA-NDE-UT-702 Procedure Rev.:
4 Work Order No.:
59102532605/NDER1 3-079 Outage No.:
N2R22 Report No.:
UT-13-010 Page:
2 of 10 Code:
2004 Edition Cat./item:
C-A/C1.20 Location:
AUX 244 Drawing No.:
12060-WMKS-SI-TK-2
==
Description:==
Head to Shall Weld System ID:
SI Component ID:
12050-WMKS-SI-TK-2 t 2-Si-TK-2 1t Size/Length:
2.3" 1565" Thickness/Diameter:
2.6" 52.75" Limitations:
See Attached Start Time:
13:27 Finish Time:
14:27 Instrument Settings Search Unit Cal.
Time Date Axial Orientated Search Unit Serial No.:
040186603 Serial No.:
00YSK" Checks Calibration Signal Sweep Sound Path Manufacturer; Panametrics Manufacturer:
KBA Initial Cal.! 0841 411212013 Reflector Amplitude %
Division Model:
EPOCH 4 Linearity:
L-13-011 Size:
.6" X 1.0" Modei:
Comp-G Inter. Cal.
1327 4/12/2013 11/4 T s0 2.0
.859"'
Delay:
12.25 Range:
4.371" Freq.:
2.25 MHz Center Freq.:
NIA Inter. Cal.
NIA 112 T 70 4.0 1745" M'ti CaliVel:
.1277 Pulser:
Square Exam Angle:
45 Squint Angle:
N/A Inter. Cal.
1427 411212013 3/4 T 50 6.0 2.617" IFinal Cat. I1651 4!1212013 ID Notch 40 8.0 3.488" Damping; 400 Reject:
0%
Measured Angle:
47 Mode:
Shear F
a 6
21o) 3 Couplant 514 T 35 10.0 NIA Rep. Rate:
Auto Freq.:
2.0 MHz Exit Point
.7"
- of Elements:
1 1
F :
.8-3.0 Mode:
Fulwave
-N Cal, Batch:
07220 Circumferential Orientated Search Unit Fitter:
- 3.
oe lae Contig.:
Single Focus:
N/A_____
Voltage:
Max Other.
NIA Type:
SoundSafe Calibration Signal Sweep th VoN Shape: Rectangular Contour.
NIA Mfg.:
SONOTECH Reflector Amplitude %
Division Wedge Style:
SWS N/A Ax. Gain (dB):
23.5 Circ. Gain (dB):
NIA Search Unit Cable Exam Batch:
07220 10 Screen Div. = 4.371 in. of Sound Path Type:
RG 174 Length: 12' No. Conn.: 0 Type:
SoundTafe Mfg.;
SONOTECHJ_____
Calibration Block Scan Coverage Cal. Block No.
VRA-27 Upstream L Downstream S6 Scan dB: 37.5 Reference Block Reference/Simulator Block Thickness 2.478" Dia.:
- Scan dB:
37.5 Serial No.:
05-8998 dB I
ReletornAmplitudel%
Division Sound Path Cal. Bk, Temp.
89 Temp. Tool:
1079BGCY Exam Surface:
Od Type:
CS Rompus Block 23.5
.75" SDHI 52 2.8 1.136" Comp. Temp.
85 Temp Tool:
1079BGCY Surface Condition:
Contour Ground N/A Recordable Indication(s):
Yes El No W]
(If Yes. Ref. Attached Ultrasonic Indication Report.)
Results:
NRI Er RI E Geom El Comments: None Percent Of Coverage Obtained > 90%:
No Reviewed Previous Data:
Yes Examiner Level Il-PDt Signature Date Reviewer.
Signature Dale Currao, Jeffrey T 4112/2013 Examiner Level NIA Signature Date Site Ravi' ign Date N/A
.UJtTJ IC10-AIAO A
i4{
Other Level N/A Signature Date ANI. Review Snature.
Date N/A I-"
0 C
- U I'l w
Z
-D a')
0.0 0
X 1P 0Y) (A (D C0 UT Calibration/Examination
UT Caflibrati on/Exam irati on 1111IM&
n~t SiteJUnit:
NAPS 1
2 Summary No.;
Workscope:
N2.Cl.20.010
'SI Procedure:
ER-AA-NDE-UT-702 Procedure Rev.:
4 Work Order No.:
591025326051NDER13-079 Outage No.:
N2R22 Report No.:
UT-13-010 Page:
3 ol 10 Code:
2004 Edition Cat.lltem:
C-.AIC1.20 Location:
AUX 244 Drawing No.:
12050-WMKS-SI-TK-2 Descriplion: Head to Shell Weld System ID:
SI Component ID: 12050-WMKS-Sl-TK-2 1 2-SI-TK-21 I Size/Length:
Z3" 1165" ThicdnessIDiameter.
2.8" 5 62.75" Limilations:
Sea Attached Start Time:
14:28 Finish Time; 15:36 I.nstrumCnt Settings Search Unit al.
Time Date Axial Orientated Search Unit Serial No.:
040186603 Serial No.:
00YSK6 Checks Calibration Signal Sweep Manufacturer; Panametrlcs Manufacturer KBA Initial Cal.
0842 411212013 Reflector Amplitude %
Division Model:
EPOCH 4 LInearity:
L-13-011 Size:
.5" X 1.01" Model:
Comp-G Inter. Cal.
14,28 4t1212013 114T 80 2.0 1.152" Delay:
15.55 Range:
5.948" Freq.:
2.25 MHz Center Freq.:
N/A inter. C N
112T 45 4.0 2.360" Inter. Cal.'
1538 411212013 12T44.
I236]
Mtl Cal/Vel:
.1275 Pulser:
Square Exam Angle:
60 Squint Angle:
NIA ina a
153i5 41212013 14T T 27 8.0 354,5" Damping:
400 Reject 0%
Measured Angle:
60 Mode:
Shear Rep, Rate:
Auto Freq.:
2.0 MHz Exil Point
.55"
- of Elements:
Couplant 5'4 T 15 10.0 A
N(A Filler:
.8 - 3.0 Moade:
Fullwave Config.;
Single Focus:
NIA Cal. Batch:
07220 Circumferential Orientated Search Unit Type:
SoundSafe Calibralion Signal Swee p Voltage:
Max Other:
NIA Shape:
Retangular Contour:
N/A fg.:
SONOTECH Reflector Amplitude %
Division d Path Wedge Style:
SWS NExam Batch 07220 NIA Ax. Gain (dB):
27.2 Ciro. Gain (dBl:
N/A Search Unit Cable Ex_
___atch___722_
10 Screen Div. = 5.948 In. of Sound Path Type:
RG 174 Length: 12" No. Conn.: 0 Type:
SoundOafe Mfg.:
SONOTECI-Calibration Block Scan Coverage Cal. Block No.
VRA-27 Upstream 2 Downstream[&/
Scan dB: 41.2 Reference Block ReferencelSimulator Block Thickness 2.478" Dia.:
0 Sne N5-6998 Gain Signal SSweep Sound Pa*h WSn 4
e N
dB Reflector Amplitude%
Division.
Cal. Bk. Temp.
89 Temp. Tool:
i079BGCY Exam Surface:
OD Type:
CS Rompus Block 27.2
.75" SDH 37 2.5 1.483" Camp. Temp.
85 Temp. Tool:
1079BOCY Surface Condition:
Contour Ground NIA Recordable Indication(s):
Yes F]
No [,/
(If Yes. Ref. Attached Ultrasonic Indication Report.)
Results:
NRI [
RI F]
Geom El Comments: None Percent Of Coverage Obtained > 90%:
No Reviewed Previous Data:
Yes Examiner Level 1 1 ignalure Date Reviewer Signature Date Currao, Jeffrey T J1' 4112'2013
, L J
-w "
'-na q &113 Examiner Level NI'K S-Signature.
- Date, Site Revle
.ner r
Dale NIA Squ o
0,
/
Other Level fl/A Signature Date ANII Review
~/
gnature Date NIA
~/Z--
f M
r-0 C
-U 0)
C M. )
0
(
3CD Z~ Z 0
P i
- 0) 2) c~o (n UT ColibratlonlExam[nation
UT Calibration/Examination d0h WDeminion Site/UnIL Summary No.:
Workscope:
/
2 Procedure:
ER-AA-ND5-UT-702 N2.C1.20.010 Procedure Rev.:
Work Order No.:
4 59102532605fN0ER1 3-079 Outage No.:
N2R22 Report No.:
UT-13-010 Page:
4 of 10 ISI Code:
2004 Edition Cat./kjrm:
C-A/C1.20 Location:
AUX 244 Drawing No.:
12050-WMKS-SI-TK-2
==
Description:==
Head to Shell Weld System 10:
SI Component ID; 12050-WMKS-SI-TK-21 2.SI-TrK-2 1 Size/Length:
2.3" 1165" Thickness/Diameter 2.6" I 52.75" Limitations:
See Attached Start Time'
.08:50 Finish Time:
09:30 Instrument Settings Search Unit
- Cal, Time Date Axial Orientated Search Unit Serial No.:
040186603 Serial No.:
G06268 Checks Calibration Signal
.weep Sound Path Manufacturer:
Panamstrics Manufacturer.
KBA Initial Cal.
0610 4/1512013 Reflector Amplitude %
Division Model:
EPOCH 4 Linearily:
L-13-0tt Size:
0.375" Model:
Gamma Inter. Cal.
0850 4/15/2013
'/, T an t.9
.58 Inter. Cal I_________N__A____,_____T__40 1.9
.t5" Delay:
1,27 Range:
3.0 Freq.: 725 MHZ Canter Freq.:
N/A inter. Cal. -
rr-N
'/a r 40 3.9 1.
Inter. Cat.
0930 411512013 M'11 CalVel:
.2329 Pulser:
Squar.
Exam Angle:
0 Squint Angle; N/A
'_1
% T 21 6.1) 11.81 F inal Cal.
1210 4/115/2013 BW60 8.2 i2.48 Damping:
400 Reject:
0%
Measured Angle:
N/A Mode:
Long Rep. Rate:
Auto Freq.:
2.0 Exit Point N/A
- of Elements:
1Couplant I
I Filter:
.8-3.0 Mode:
Fuwav SinCal.
Batch:
07220 Circumferential Orientated Search Unit Rle:...
oe ulaa Config.:
Single Focus:
N/A.____
Type:
SoundSafe Calibration Signal Sweep o
ad Voltage:
High Other:
N/A Shape:
Round Contour.
N/A
~tfg.:
SONOTECH Reflector Amplitude %
Division Wedge Stl~e:
N/A W/A Ax. Gain (dB):
11 Circ. Gain (dB)-.
N/A Search Unit Cable Exam Batch:
07220 10 Screen Dlv. -
3.0 in. of Sound Path Type:
RG-174 Length:
6* No. Conn.: 0 Type:
SoundSafe Mfg.:
SONOTECH Calibration Block Scan Coverage Cal, Block No.
VRA-27 Upstream D Downstream[] Scan dB:
17 Reference Block Reference/Simulator Block Tar0Galn I
Signal I Sweep S
Thickness 2.47_"
Die.:
a CW j CCWL.
Scan dB: N/A Serial No.:
05-5560 dB Reflector Amplitude %
Division Cal. Blk. Temp.
74 Tamp. Tool:
1O74BGCY Exam Surface:
0O Type:
CS RompusBlock Bl c.
s1t. I 5e 2.4
.72 Camp. Temp.
81 Temp. Tool:
1074BGCY Surface Condition:
Contour Ground N/A Recordable IndicatIon(s):
Yes []
No
]
(If Yes, Ref. Attached Ultrasonic Indication Report.)
Results:
NRI ka RI E Geom n Comments: Used to maximize coverage.
Percent Of Coverage Obtained > 90%:
No Reviewed Previous Data:
Yes Examiner Level II.PDI Signature Date Reviewer Date Currao, Jeffrey T "415/120(
/1/213 JA**(f.1
}1.3J" Examlner Level NIA Signature Date Site RavIin,.na Date NIA f~V K-'T "Qr
"_P S1..1 Other Level N/A Signature Datle ANti Review.
Sign>*lu Date NIA UIT Calibratlon/Examination M
1-1 0
'Io C
M.
C:
(D 0:3-7 0
(
0 0
. (0 C/)
Doominion, Site/'Unit:
Summary No.:
Workscope:
/
2 UT Calibration/Examination Procedure:
Procedure Rev.:
Work Order No.:
69' N2.CI.2D.Q10 ER-AA-NDE.UIT-702 4
I 02532605INDER'13-079 Outage No.:
N2R22 Report No.:
UT-13-010 Page:
5 of 10
'Si Code:
2004 Edition Cat.tltem:
C-A/C1.20 Location:
AUX 244 Drawing No.:
12050-WMKS-Si-TK-2
==
Description:==
Head to Shelf Weld System ID:
SI Component ID: 12050-WMKS-SI-TK-21 2-S1-TK-21 I SizeiLenglh:
2.3" I 165" Thickness/Diaineter.
2.6" 1 52.75" Limitations:
See Attached Start Time:
09:31 Finish Time!
10:28 Instrument Settings Search Unit Cal.
Time Date Axial Orientated Search Unit Serial No.;
040186603 Serial No.:
00H45N C
ks Calibration Signal Sweep Sound Path Manufacturer:
Panametncs Manufacturer.
KBA Initiai Cal.
0611 411512013 Reflector Amplitude %
Division Model:
EPOCH 4 Linearity:
L-13-011 Size:
0.50=
Model; Comp-G Inter. Cal.
0931 4/1512013
%., T 80 2.0
.819 Delay:
6.420 Range:
4.133 Freq.:
2.25 MHZ Center Freq.:
NfA Inter. Cal.
NLA
%/_
T 60 4.0 1.688 M't CalIVel:
.1280 Pulser:
Square Exam Angle:
45 SquintAngle:
NIA Inler. Cal.
1028 4/1512013
%D T
40 6.0 2.497 Damping:
400.
Reject:
0%
Measured Angle:
45 Mude:
Shear Cal 1211 ID Notch 30 B.4 3.464 Couplant 514 T 20
'10.)0 NiA Rep, Rate:
Auto Freq.:
2.0 Exdt Point
.35
- of Elements: Single Culn Bt4 T720 10.t niA Md:fuiaeCal.
Batch:
07220 Circumferential Orientated Search Unit Filter:
.0-3.0 Mode;
- Fullwav, Config.:
Single Focus:
NIA Tuelro iSe Voltage:
High Other:
NIA Shape:
Round Contour:
NIA Type:
SoSndaeC CalrtoioniSound Path Mfg.:
SONOTECH Reflector Amplitude %
Division Ax an(B:
I ic an(B:
NA Wedge Style:
MSWQC EaBtc:
020N/A Ax. GaIn (dlE:
15 Ciro. Gain (dE):
N/A Search Unit Cable Type:
SoundSafe 10 Screen Div.
4.133 in. of Sound Path Type:
RG 174 Length:
6' No. Conn.: 0 Mfg.:
SONOTECH Calibration Block Scan Coverage Cal. Block No.
VRA-27 Upstream.
Downstreampi Scan dB:
29 Reference Block Reference/Simulator Block
-Gin I
I Signal Sweep I Path Thickness 2.78 O.a" CW L CCW2 Seriao.:
05-52 dB Reflector Amplitude%
Division Cal. BIk. Temp.
14 Temp. Tool:
1074BGCY Exam Surface:
OD Type:
CS Rompus Block 15
.7 SHD 64 I
2.5 J
1.03 Comp, Temp.
11 Temp. Tool:
1074BGCY Surface Condition:
Contour Ground N/A Recordable Indication(s):
Yes No (i
{t Yes, Ref. Attached Ultrasonic Indication Report.)
Results:
NRI L RI 7 Geom F-Comments: Used to maximize coverage.
Percent Of Coverage Obtained > 90%:
No Reviewed Previous Data:
Yes Examiner Level It-1PD,.-
Signature Date Reviewer S9 nE re.
Date Currao, Jeffrey T Uj 4
Q 41512013 gJAVIjL:
q.-
A Examiner Level N'/'"
Signature Date Site RevAs ilne Date NIA (nExpnao NthA Level N/A Signature Date ANtII Rview Z
aSmaur Date UT Calibretion/Examination M
I-0ca C
Cn C
-Pk ID M.
rZ Z
0,. 0 Mm Cni-0 X ?)0 M
=
CS i
- 0) Cn CO 0)
UT' Calibration/Exam ination
- 'Ocerinion Site/Unit:
NAPS I
2 Procedure:
ER-AA-NJDE.UT-702 Summary No.:
Workscope:
N2.C1.20.010 Procedure Rev.:
4 Work Order No.:
59102532605/NDERi 3-079 Outage No.:
N2R22 Report No.:
UT-13-010 Page; 6
of 10 ISI Code:
2004 Edition CalJItem:
C-A/C1.20 Location:
AUX 244 Drawing No.:
12050-WMKS-SI-TK-2
==
Description:==
Head to Shell Weld System ID:
SI Component ID: 12050-WMKS-SI-TK-2 / 2-SI-TK.2 I 1 SizefLength:
2.3 I 155" Thickness,1lameter 2.6" f 52.75" Umitatlons:
Yes StartTime:
10:29 Finish Time:
11:09 Instrument Settings Search Unit Cal.
Time Date Axial Orientated Search Unit Serial No.:
040186603 Serial No.:
00FIDL Checks Ia tSwo t
Maufctre:
anmeris a...t..rKB Calibration Signai Sweep Sound Path Manufacturer:
Panametris Manufacturer.
KBA Initial Cal.
0612 411512013 Reflector Amplitude %
Division Model; EPOCH 4 Linearlty:
L-13-011 Size:
0.50" Modei:
Comp-G Inter. Cal.
1029 4115/2013
'A T 80 2.0 1.175 Delay:
8.199 Range:
5.81 Freq_:
2.25 MHZ Center Freq.:
NIA Inter. Cal.
NIA 1/2 T 40 4.0 2.343 Inter. Cal.
1109 411512013
- 14 T 22_5.0__.49 Mu 'OCalIVel;
.1273 Pulser:
Square Exam Angle:
60 Squint Angle:
N/A Ie l_0_13_
2..
Damping:
400 Reject:
0%
Measured Angle:
50 Mode:
Shear Final Cai.
12:12 -41512013 ID Notch 13 8.3 4.781 Rep. Rate:
Auto Freq.:
2.0 Exit Point
.35"
- of Elements: Single Couplant 514 T 1_11 10.0
_NIA Mode:
Fuitwave Cal. Batch:
07220 Circumferential Orientated Search Unit Voltager:
.Hh MOte:,
N/A Type:
SoundSafe Calibration Signal Sweep
--e H Shape:
Round Contour WA Mfg.:
SONOTECH Reflector Amplitude %
Division Sound Path Wedge Style:
MSWOC N/A Ax. Gain (dB):
21.5 Circ. Gain (dB):.
N/A Se:
U SilC Exam Batch:
07220 Ax. Gain (dB):
21.5
~~Search Unit Cable_________________
10 Screen Div. =
5.01 in. of Sound Path Type:
RG 174 Length:
6' No. Conn.: 0 Type:
SoundSafe Mvfg.:
SONOTECH Calibration Block Scan Coverage Cal. Block No.
VRA-27 Upstream 9] Downstream W/ Scan dB: 35.5 Reference Block Reference/Simulator Block Thickness 2.478" ia.:
0 c:560 Gain Signal Sweep Sound Path Th
______.4 Die.:
0CW F/W ad:5._aN:
-5 diB Reflector Amplitude % Division Cal. BIk. Temp.
74 Temp. Tool:
10748GCY Exam Surface:
Type:
CS Rompus Block 21.5
.7 SDB 31 2.4 1.42 Comp. Temp.
81 Temp. Tooi:
1074B0CY Surface Condition:
Contour Ground NIA Recordable Indication(s):
Yes []
No [
(If Yes, Ref. Attached Ultrasonic Indication Report.)
Results:
NRI RI LI Geom Comments: Used to maximize coverage Percent O Coverage Obtained > 90%:
No Reviewed Previous Data:
Yes Examiner Level jj.l pj Signature Date Reviewer SI npt Date Currao, Jeffrey T 5
X~/
4115/2013 IjLJ-0iq/AiZ.*;*j-'--.
Examiner Levelled'/'
Signature Date Site Review gnat bate MIA I
af1nar on0 Other Level NIA Signature Date ANII Review Si5 eture Date UT Callibration/E xaminallon M
r-0(A C:
X C/)
C:
(D 0)
C L D 0 (D (D (Do 0 0.~
0 ><
- 0) wn (00C
Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4 th Interval 1st Period Limited Exams Page 34 of 86 ENCLOSURE BI-1 Supplemental Report Summary No.: N2.CI.20.010 Examiner, Currao, Jeffrey T ).d Level: 1I-PDI Examiner. NIA Level:
N/A Other:
N/A Level:
NIA Report No.:
UT-1 3-010 Page:
7 of 10 Reviewer:
"i'
"*S Date:.yz, Zq4,,"
Site Review.- 4" Date:
". p tt ANII Revlem Date: 3 Comments:
LIMITATION 360" DUE TO WELD PROFILE 0.9" WIDTH Tho,,d CwpIe. ILS~b-M 1
WSELD,1.
/
Vd Sketch or Photo:
(4 Spp 8
o.L t mch 8 SQ. IN. X 165" TOTAL WELD LENGTH = 1.320 CUBIC IN.
TOTAL REQUIRED EXAMINAION VOLUME = 1,320 CUBIC INCHES 0' IS LIMITED FOR 1.6 SO. IN, X 165" LENGTH1 = 191.4 CUBIC IN. DUEETO CONFIGURATION.
TOTAL UMITATION FOR 0"= 191.4 CUBIC IN. / 1,320 = 0.145 X 100 = 14S%. EXAMINED 95.5%.
CIRCSCAN EXAMINATION OF WELD METAL = 100%
4.24.50. IN. REQUIRED FOR BASE METAL CIRC SCAN EXAMINATION X 165" LENGTH =699.6 CUBIC IN.
TOTAL REQUIRED CIRC EXAM BASE METAL = 699.6 CUBIC IN.
NO EXAM FOR 32" DUE TO SUPPORTS X 1.16 SQ. IN = 37.1 CUBIC IN.
37,1 / Gg9.6 =.0S3 X 100 = 5.3%. TOTAL CIRC SCAN BASE METAL EXAMINED -94.7%
4.24 SQ. IN. REQUIRED FOR BASE METAL AX SCAN EXAMINATION X 165" LENGTH - 699.6 CUBIC IN.
NO EXAM BASE M E-TAL AX DIRECTION 011 SQ-IN. X 129.4" LENGTH DUE TO CONFIGURATION = 14.23.CUBIC IN.
NO EXAM BASE METAL AX DIR. 0.32 SE. IN. X 35.6" LENGTH DUE TO SUPPORTS AND THERMAL COUPLES= 114 CUBIC IN.
14.23 + 31.4 = 25.63 / 699.6 = 0.037 X 100 = 3.2%. TOTAL EXAMINED BASE ME-ALAX SCAN -9.31%
TOTAL REQUIRED WELD METAL = 3.76 SO. IN X 165 LENGTH = 620.4 CUBIC IN.
Additional - Supplemental Data
Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4th Interval 1st Period Limited Exams Page 35 of 86 ENCLOSURE B1-1 Supplemental Report 51Damnihion; Report No.:
UT-13-010 Page:
8 of 10 Examiner Currao.JeffreyT Level' 11-PDI Reviewer:
.- L.-
Date:
Examiner. N/A Level:
NIA Site Review:Y6q-M rp(.D*WIC4*
l X Date:
- '-2.'I*
Other: NIA Level:
NWA ANII Review:
/
r Date:
Comments:
Sketch or Photo:
TOTAL REQUIRED EXAMINATION VOLUME FOR 45/60 DEG WELD METAL SHELL SIDE = 620.4 CUBIC IN.
EXAMINED 2.34 SQ. IN. X 129.4" LENGTH= 302.8 CUBIC IN. DUE TO CONFIGURATION EXAMINED 1.43 SQ. IN X 35.6" LENGTH = 50.9 CUBIC IN. DUF TO SIUPPORTS AND THERMAL COUPLES TOAL AREA EXAMINED= 3S3.7? 620.4 = 0.57 X 100 = 57% SHELLSIDE 45".
EXAMINED 2.74 SO., IN. X 129-4 LENGTH ý 354.6 CUBIC IN. DUE TO CONFIGt]IRATION FXAM IN ED.89 SQ. IN. X 35.6' LENGTH " 31-7 CUBIC IN. DUE TO SUPPORTS AND THERMAL COUPLES TOTAL AREA EXAMINED = 386.3 / 6204 = 0622 X 100 = 62.2% SHELL SIDE 60".
EXAMINED 3.6 SO.IN. X 165" LENGTH -594 CUBIC IN. DUE TO CDNFIGURLATION.
TOTAL AREA ELXAMINED
= 594 / 620.4 = 0.957 X GO = 95.7% HEAD SIDE 45".
EXAMINED 3.64 SO. IN. X 165" LENGTth = 600.6 CUBIC IlN. DUE CONFIGURATION.
TOTAL AREA EXAMINED = 600._620.4 = 0.968 I 100= 96.8% HEAD SIDE
/0".
Additional - Supplemental Data
Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4th Interval 1 st Period Limited Exams Page 36 of 86 ENCLOSURE B1-1 iWDominiaw Summary No.: N2.CI.20.010 Examiner-. Currao, JeffreyT 'Mir.
Supplemental Report Report No.;
UT-13-010 Page:
9 of 10 Level: II-PDI Reviewer jjq
'.q..
Date:
Level:
NIA Site Review.
Date:
Z, I~
- zol, Level:
N/A ANII Review.
Date: _
Examiner: N/A Other: NJA Comments:
L2 2
Sketch or Photo:
FLOW CL SHi EL..
H EAD SH EJ CL HEAD 45 0EG6 LIUITATIPN
-q F.L.
CL ag in
-0 DE I?6, HEADl Adclitonal - Supp~lemental Data
Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4th Interval 1st Period Limited Exams Page 37 of 86 ENCLOSURE B1-1 limabL 5xpDominiow Report No: UT-13-010 Summary # N2.CI.20.010 Pg.
10 of 10 Prepared by: W. Thomas Date: 4/29/2013 Weld Number Thickness 1A 2.6" -.175" CLAD Weld Width Weld Length 2.3 "
165" COVERAGE TABLE ANGLE SCAN AREA DIRECTION
% COVERAGE 0
BASE AND WELDMETAL HEAD/SHELL 85.5 45,60 BASE METAL CW/CCW 94.7 45,60 BASE METAL HEAD/SHELL 96.3 45 WELD METAL HEAD 95.7 45 WELD METAL SHELL 57 45 WELD METAL CW/CCW 100 60 WELD METAL HEAD 96.8 60 WELD METAL SHELL 62.2 60 WELD METAL CW/CCW 100 TOTAL 788.2 / 9 = 87.6%
ANI/AN Me
$ Gsy Reviewed 7
Examination Volume Dimensions -
Height Z425" Length 165" Width 3.3" Coverage Summary Required Scans (each has a weighing factor of 100 for complete coverage)
ANGLE UpSt-Ax UpSt-Circ DnSt-Ax DnSt-Circ SEE TABLE Code Coverage Total 87.6%
Best Effort Coverage (Max 25%) Total N/A Q W kl) 0'p Notes:
11 Code Coverage refers to the maximum percentage of the required examination volume that Is effectively examined with the qualified examination procedure.
- 2) Best Effort Coverage refers to the required examination volume past the weld centerline that Is examined in the axial beam direction with an Appendix VIII 1;0 demonstrated procedure for single sided coverage.
Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4t" Interval 1 st Period Limited Exams Page 38 of 86 THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4u' Interval 1st Period Limited Exams Page 39 of 86 B2. Nozzle-to-Shell Welds 4.B2 IMPRACTICALITY OF COMPLIANCE In accordance with 10CFR50.55a(g)(5)(iii), relief is requested from the "essentially 100 percent" volumetric examination coverage requirement for the identified Nozzle-to-Vessel welds. This requirement is considered impractical due to single-sided access.
Ultrasonic examination of the identified nozzle-to-vessel weld on the boron injection tank is limited to 27.4% volume coverage because of single-sided access due to nozzle to shell weld configuration. It was not possible to scan over the weld with any angle.
Refer to Enclosure B2-1 for coverage details for weld # 3. Examination was performed to the extent possible.
5.B2 BURDEN CAUSED BY COMPLIANCE Destruction of the component, requiring a completely different design, would be necessary to perform 100% of the Code required examination as written in the 2004 ASME Section XI Code with No Addenda and is contrary to the intent of the Code.
6.B2 PROPOSED ALTERNATIVE AND BASIS It is proposed that the examinations already completed at the reduced coverage be accepted as meeting the Code requirements. The limited volumetric examination performed should detect any general patterns of degradation that may occur in the areas covered, therefore providing reasonable assurance of the continued structural integrity of the subject weld. 100 percent magnetic particle examination coverage was obtained with no reported recordable indications.
Two other components are scheduled to be examined in Category C-B, Item No. C2.21, in the fourth ISI inspection interval on similar nozzle welds. Previous examinations at these locations obtained full coverage. Third interval relief for the examination of weld #3 was granted in request N2-13-PRT-002, Section B1, for essentially the same examination coverage of 30.5%.
The examinations were performed using standard ASME Section V, Article 4 UT techniques. Manual scanning was performed for these examinations. The configuration of the nozzle to shell weld limits the effective examination of the required examination volume. The nozzle's close proximity to the weld limits scanning due to the nozzle blend radius causing lift-off of the search unit during scanning. The physical limitation of each nozzle limits the effectiveness of alternative or advanced technologies from increasing the examination coverage for this configuration.
Enclosure B2-1 includes the complete Ultrasonic Examination Data Record for the Category C-B, Item C2.21, examination included in this request. The report includes details of the UT scanning apparatus, including transducer size, frequency and angle.
Also included are scan plots for the examination showing the nozzle configuration and percent coverage for each individual scan. The wave modality and insonification angles are also included. No recordable indications were identified during the examination.
. Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4th Interval 1 st Period Limited Exams Page 40 of 86 Magnetic Particle Examination (MT) was performed for the subject weld included in this request, and the exam was a full ASME Code examination (>90% coverage). There were no recordable indications detected. The complete MT Examination report is included in Enclosure B2-1.
The Boron Injection Tank head is ASTM A-516 Grade 70 carbon steel with 0.125" weld deposit clad ASTM A-240 Type 304L. Tank head design thickness is a minimum of 2.00". The nozzles are ASTM A-508 Class 1, and are just over 5" thick. The nozzles are also clad with ASTM A-240 Type 304L.
UT Calibration/Examination Dom1inion Site/Unit Summary No.:
Workscope:
NAPS 1
2 N2.C2,21.007 Procedure:
Procedure Rev.:
Work Order No.:
ER-AA-NDE-UT-702 4
591 02532605/NDER13-O?9 Oulage No.:
N2R22 Report No.:
UT-13-011 Page:
1 of 5
181 Code:
2004 Edition CatJItem:
C-BIC2.21 Location:
AUX 244 Drawing No.:
12050-WMKS-SI-TK-2
==
Description:==
Nozzle to Vessel Syalern ID:
SI Component ID:
12050-WMKS-SI-TK-2 I 2-SI-TK-213 SIze!Length:
1.25" 133" Thickness/Dlameter:
2.13"I 10" Limitations:
Limited Due to Configuration Start Time:
10:25 FlnIsh Time:
10:39 Instrument Settings Search Unit Cal.
Time Date Axial Orientated Search Unit S e r ia l N o.;
0 4 0 1 8 6 6 0 3 S e ria l N o.:
M 1 8 2 0 7 S P C h e c k s C
r S i g n al Su Calibration Signal Sweep Isoun*d Path Manufacturer:
Panamatrics Manufacturer.
KBA Initial Cal. 08:40 4/12/2013 Reflector Amplitude %
Division Model:
EPOCH 4 Linearity:
L-13-011 Size:
0.75" Model:
Gamma Inter, Cal.
10:25 411212013 114T 70 1.86
.556" Delay:.
1.377 Range:
3.0" Freq.:
Z.25 MHz-Center Freq..
NIA Inter. Cal.
NI__A 112 T 80 4.0 1.180" M'tl CaUVeI:
.2329 Pulser:
Square Exam Angle:
0" SquiintAngle:
NIA Inter Cal., 10:39 4/1212013 3/4 T Damping:
4000 Reject:
0%
Me40asured Angle:
NBA Mode:
Long.
iW 100-6.3 2.493'"
Rep. Rate:
Auto Freq.:
2.0 MHz Exit Point N/A
- of Elements.
t Couplant
- Filler,
.8-3.0 Mode:
Fullwave Col, Batch:
07220 Circumferentlel Orientated Search Unit Voltage:
Low Dlher:
N/A ConTig.:
Single Focus:
NIA ype:
SoundSafe Calibration SignalI Sweep Shape:
Round Contour.
N/A Mfg.:
SONOTECH Reflector Amplitude %
Division Sound P'th Wedge Style:
N/A N/A Ax. Gain (dB):
5.8 Circ. Gain (dB):
N/A Search Unit Cable Exam Batch:
07220 10 Screen Div. =
3.0 IT. of Sound Path Sype:
SoundUafe 1
Type:
RG 174 Length: 12' No. Conn.: 0 Mfg.:
SONOTECd f
Calibration Block Scan Coverage Cal. Block No.
VRA-27 Upstream [] Downstream-] Scan dB: 11.8 Reference Block Reference/Simulator Block Thickness 2.478" Die,:
0 CW CCW:
SrandB: NIA Serial No.:Gain Signal Sweep Sound Path Cal. Blk. Temp.
89 Temp. Tooi:
1073BGCY d
elco mltdDvso Comp. Temp.
94 Temp. Tool:
1073BGCY Exam Surface:
00 Type:
CS Rompus Block
- 5.
.75" SDH 52 2.4
.723" Surface Condition:
As Welded NIA Recordable Indication(s):
Yes []
No 7 (If Yes, Ref. Attached Ultrasonic Indication Report.)
Comments:
None Results:
NRI Sa RI [-
Genre -]
Percent Of Coverage Obtained 5 90%:
No Reviewed Previous Data:
Yes Examiner Level I1I1 Signature Datel Reviewer Signalure Date Currao, JeffreyT
-(......
4/1212013 p
-'ZZ,,
I Exariller Level IeA Signature Date Site Review --
Signatur" Date N/A 411720213 JZC(c-n
/
3/13 Other Level N/A Signalure Date ANII Review Snature Date N/A UT Calibration/Examination 0
r-0 C:
- a C
0 (1
w 3 (0 m0 M cn
- 0) (n (00
- D~m~~on ite/'Unil:
Survinary No.:
Workscope:
NAPS 1
2 N2.C2.21.007 1SI UT Calibration/Examination Procedure:
Procedure Rev.:
Work Order No.:
591 ER-AA-NDE-UT-7(12 4
1025:32605/NDERI 3.079 Outage No.:
N2R22 Report No.:
UT-13-011 Page:
2 of 5
Code:
2004 Edition CatJIlem:
C-BIC2.21 Location:
AUX 244 Drawing No.:
12050-WMKS-Si-TK-2
==
Description:==
Nozzle to Vessel System ID
,1 Component ID: 12050-WMKS-SI-TK-212-SI-TK-2 13 Size/Length:
1.25" 133" Thickness/Diameter:
2.13" 1D" Limitations:
Limited Due to Configuration Start Time:
10:40 Finish Time:
10:54 Instrument Settings Search Unit Cal.
Time Date Axial Orientated Search Unit Serial No.:
040186603 Serdal No.:
00Y5K7 Checks Calibration Signal NiluatrcIiilCal.
0-4 C4i/r2tnn2Sgna Sweep Sound Path Mmulaecturer.
Panametrics Manufa@,urer:
KBA Initial 08:41 411212013 Reflector Amplitude %
Division Model:
EPOCH 4 Linearity:
L-13-011 Size:
.5" X 1.0" Modal:
Comp-G Inter. Cal. 10:40 4112/2013 114 T 80 2.0
.859" Delay:
1225 Range:
4.371" Freq,.:
2.25 MHzl Center Freq.:
N/A Inter. Cal.
NIA 1122T 70 4.0 1.745" Inter. Cal. 10-54 411212013 34 M'tl Cal/VeL:
.1277 Pulser.
Square Exam Angle:
450 Squint Angle:
N/A C.1 1_3314 T
50 6.0 2.617" Final Cal.
14:01 4/12/2013 ID Notch 40 8.0 1 3.488" Damping:
4O0Ol RejectL 0%
Measured Angle:
450 Mode:
Shear Couplent 514 T 36 10.0 NINA Rep. Role:
Auto Freq.:
2.0 MHz Exit Point
.7"
- of Elements:
1 Filter:.
8 -3.0 oude:
Fullwave Confg.:
Single Focus:
NIA-Cal. Btcch:
07220 Circu4mferential Orientated Search Unit Othr: /AType:
Sound~sfe Calibration Signal Sweep SudPt Voltage:
Max Other:
N/A Shape:
Rectangular Contour:
NIA Mfq.:
SONOTECH Reflector Amplilude %
Division Sound Path Wedge Style:
SWSNA Ax. Gain (dB):
23.5 Circ. Gain (dB):
NIA Search Unit Cable Exam Batch:
07220 N/A 10 Screen Div. =
4.371 in. of Sound Path Type:
RG 174 Length: 12' No. Conn.: 0 Type:
SoundSafe Mfg.:
SONOTECH Calibration Block Scan Coverage Cal. Block No.
VRA-27 Upslream Z Dowristreamn--] Scan dB: 37.5 Reference Block ReferencelSimulator Block Gain J
Signal J Sweep Soun.
..t Thickness 2.478" Dia.:
0 Cw _j CCWD Scan dB: 37.5 Serial No.:
05-69911 dai Signal eD ound Path Cal. Bik. Temp.
89 Temp. Tool:
1073BGCY Exam Surface:
OD Type:
CS Rompus Block 23.5
.75" SDH 52 2.6 1.058i Comp. Temp.
94 Temp. Tool:
I,73BGCY Surface Condition:
AIWelded NIA Recordable Indication(s):
Yes n-No VJ (If Yes, Ref. Attached Ultrasonic Indicatioii Report.)
Results:
NRI n RI [-
Geom F[
Comments: None Percent Of Coverage Obtained > 90%:
No Reviewed Previous Data:
Yes Examiner Level II-PDI0 Signature Date Reviewer Sign I Date Currao, JeffrayT "De i
ewg urrD411212013
)
A-Examiner Level N/A:"-<
Signature Date Site Review
,no N/A.
411212013 4
.(
c 1 "t
3 Other Level NIA Signature Date ANti Review Snature Date NiA M
Z C)
I-0 U/)
C:
m Cl)
C (D
(D S0 c/)
0 (D X,-
(a Z~ Za at
- 0) (n (00C UT Culibration/Examination
5 1%j Site/Unit:
Summary No.:
Workscopo:
/
2 N2.C2.21.007 IS1 UT Calibration/Examination Procedure:
Procedure Rev.:
Work Order No.:
591 ER-AA-NDE-UT-702 4
0 2532605INDER13-079 Outage No.:
N2R22 Report No.:
UT-13-011 Page:
3 of 5
Code:
2004 Edition Cal,/Item:
C-B/C2.21 Looation:
AUX 244 Drawing No.:
12050-WMKS-SI-TK-2
==
Description:==
Nozzle to Vessel System ID:
St Component ID: 12050-WMKS-SI-TK-21 2-SI-TK-2 13 Size!Length:
1.25"/ 33" ThickneeslDiameter 2.13" 110."
Limitations:
Limited Due to Configuration StartTime:
10:55 Firnsh Time:
11:16 Instrument Settings Search Unit Cal.
Time Date I Axial Orientated Search Unit Serial No.:
040186603 Serial No.:
OOYSK6 Checks I
_Cli
-Initiel Cal. 004 41121 Calibration Signai Sweep Sound path Manufacturer:
Panametrics Manufacturer:
KBA
___ia___
00:42 411212013 Reflector Amplitude %
)Division Model:
EPOCI-4 Linearlty:
L-13-011 Size:
.5" X 1.0" Modei; Comp-G Inter. Cal. 10:55 4/1212013 114 T 80 2.0 1.152" Delay:
15.55 Range:
5.948" Freq.:
2.25 MHz Center Freq.:
NIA Inter. Cal.
NIA 1/2 T 45 4A0 2.360" M't CalVel:
.1275 Pulser:
Square Exam Angle:
601 Squint Angle:
NIA Inter, Cal., 11.6 4112/2013 314 T 27 6.0 3.546" Damping:
4000 Reject:
0%.
Measured Angle:
601 Mode:
Shear Final Cal. 14:,2 4/2 ID Notch 21
&0 4.755' Rep. Rate:
Auto Freq.:
2.0 MHz Exit Point
.65"
- of Elements:
1 Cou 15 10.0 NIA Filler:
.8-3.0 Mode:
Fullwave Config.:
Single Forus:
N'A Cal. Batch:
07220 Circumferential Orientated Search Unit Voltage:
Max Other:
N/A Type:
SoundSafe Calibration Signal Sweep Sound Patt Shape:
Rectangular Contour:
N/A Mtg.:
SONOTECH Reflector Amplitude %
Division Wedge Style:
SWS N/A Ax. Gain (dB):
27.2 Circ. Gain (dB):
N/A Search Unit Cable Exam Patch:
07220 10 Screen Div.= 5.948 in. of Sound Path Type; RG 174 Length: 12' No..Conn.:
0 Type:
SoundSafe Calibration Block Sican Coverage Cal. Block No.
VRA-27 Upstrerm t
Downstream-j Scan dB: 41.2 Reference Block Reference/Simulalor Block Thickness 2.478" Dia.:
0 CV CCW.,--] ScandB: 41.2 Serial No.:
05-6996 Gain Sigrrlud SOiP Sound Path Cal.
,lk. Temp.
89 Temp-Toot:
IO74BGCY Exam Surfece:
OD Type:
CS Rompus Block 27.2
.75" SO, I 37 2.5 1.483" omp. Temp.
94 Temp. Tool:
14BGCY N
oo A
Recordable Indication(s);
Yes "
No [
(If Yes, Ref. Attached Ultrasonic Indication Report.)
Results:
NRI 2 RI F Geom 1_
Comments: None Percent Of Coverage Obtained > 90%:
No Reviewed Previous Data:
Yes Examiner Level 11.I, Signature Dale Heviewer Date Currao, Jeffrey T 4/12/2013a A5 2 /*,
Examiner LeveIl"N/'
Signature Date Site Review Signature Date N/A 4/12/2013 Jk' u
Other Level NIA Signature Date AN II ReviewS lueDt N/A
!L UT CallbratlonJExamination 0
0 0,
C IT!
a,)
C CD 0 0
/
0 0 IT mL" -~
- 0) U) to 01
Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4th Interval 1't Period Limited Exams Page 44 of 86 ENCLOSURE B2-1 Supplemental Report Summary No_ Ml C-3 1 anA7 Examiner: Currao, Jeffrey T Level: Il-PDI Examiner:
NIA Level:
N/A Report No.:
UT-13-011 Page:
4 of 5
Reviewer:
0..1i
¢h' "
Date:
'X.V?
l., I Is Review: -3~ d~~dDate:
t(% 1,3 11I Review:
.~Date:
N/A AN Comments:
Sketc-orP_*to.
2 0
1 2
FLOW NOZ I
CL 45 N-D a2-SO. IN. JS 45A45
/
/
t
/
/
-J
.47
/
EGS%,-ITxh X.5WIDTqH 1 Th.1,Oq IN. TOTAl. CEC,,UIRED VOLUME CW/IVINCD223Sfl,3 IN. *J 0S eDE 45,h,(
.08S31.te = 0L28 X 100 28%J"IMTATIN. S-',41NED 72% US SqD= 45 AX NO?
CL A/
/
.-A 0
THE
-IEADX
<N4kIH,=_D "05% OF THE REOIOQJ'E' V...*'IIME LJE SIDE AXOROI*.CTIH, NOZ CL n L/
f/
- -.--HEAD E*AMINFD 017 SO IN. nODF.
.;71 I.t5 = a it X 1ia = 15%
Additional - Supplemental Data
ENCLOSURE B2-1 WýDominiow Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4th Interval 1 st Period Limited Exams Page 45 of 86 Report No: UT-13-011 Summary # N2.C2.21.007 Pg.
5 of 5
Prepared by: W. Thomas -0 Date: 4/22/2013 Weld Number Thickness 3
2.13" -0.iS" (CLAD)
Weld Width Weld Length 1.25" 33" ANGLE SCAN DIRECTION SCAN %
S0 AXIAL 15 45' AXIAL 72 45' AXIAL 0
45-CIRC 15 45° CIRC 15 60" AXIAL 100 60" AXIAL 0
60° CIRC 15 60' CIRC i5 TOTAL 247 247 / 9=
27.4%
MIANi
ý-
HSB GS Reviewed Examination Volume Dimensions -
Height 0.66" Length 33" Width 1.75" Coverage Summary Required Scans (each has a weighing factor of 100 for complete coverage)
ANGLE UpSt-Ax UpSt-Circ DnSt-Ax DnSt-Circ SEE ABOVE Code Coverage Total 27.4%
Best Effort Coverage (Max 25%) Total N/A Notes:
- 1) Code Coverage refers to the maximum percentage of the required examination volume that is effectively examined with the qualified examination procedure.
- 2) Best Effort Coverage refers to the required examination volume past the weld.
centerline that is examined in the axial beam direction with an Appendix VIII demonstrated procedure for single sided coverage.
Site/Unit:
NAPS 1
2 Summary No.:
N2.C2.21.007 Workscope:
ISI Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4th Interval 1st Period Limited Exams ENCLOSURE B2-1 Page 46 of 86 gnetic Particle Examination Procedure:
ER-AA-NDE-MT-200 Outage No.:
N2R22 Procedure Rev.:
4 Report No.:
MT-13-001 Work Order No.: 591025326051NDER13-079 Page:
1 of 1
Code:
2004-Edition Cat/Item:
C-BIC2.21 Location:
AUX 244 Drawing No.:
12050-WMKS-SI-TK-2
==
Description:==
Nozzle to Vessel System ID; SI Component ID: 12050-WMKS-SI-TK-21 2-SI-TK-2 / 3 MatJThickness:
CS 12.13" Limitations:
None Light Meter Mfg.:
AEMC Instruments Serial No.:
1044HMCY Illumination:
227 fc Temp. Tool Mfg.:
AEMC Instruments Serial No.;
1066BGCY Surface Temp.:
101
'F Resolution:
Not Used Lift Block Serial No.:
MT-34 Surface Condition:
As Welded Lo/Wo Location:
NIA Field Orientation:
Perpendicular & Parallel Magnetic Particle Material Wet Li Brand; MAGNAFLUX Dry }j Mixed:
Yes [E Applied By:
Dusting *]
Type:
BA Red Visible L-No
- Spraying El Batch No..
100044 Fluorescent [E With:
Flooding I-Equipment:
PARKER B31 0 Serial No.:
3228 Head Shot
[F N/A Amperes Fixed Spacing 7-AC b DC LU Adj. Spacing
.v]
4 - 8 inches Encircling Coils
[]
NIA Turns Prods. Spacing 9]
N/A inches Current (machine setting)
W]
N/A Amperes Indication Loc Loc Diameter Length Type Remarks No.
L W
R/L NIA Comments:
None Results:
NRI []
RI [
Eval [.-7 Percent Of Coverage Obtained > 90%:
100%
Reviewed Previous Data:
Yes Exam Time:
1515 Examiner Level il 1
Date Reviewer Signature Date Iwertman, Justin
- ei 411'4
-L.7*. *
- ._Ar Examiner Level L
S)Wnh..'a Date Site Review
,Zignature Date
~Hacker, Jonathon 4C1112013
- t3 9
Other Level N/A f Si*ature Date ANII Review Signature Date MIagnetic Particle Examinaion
Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4th Interval 1st Period Limited Exams Page 47 of 86 R1.
Risk-Informed Piping Welds Subject to Thermal Fatigue 4.R1 IMPRACTICALITY OF COMPLIANCE In accordance with 10CFR50.55a(g)(5)(iii), relief is requested from the "essentially 100 percent" volumetric examination coverage requirement for the identified piping welds.
This requirement is considered impractical primarily due to single-sided access and configuration for these components.
Scan Coverage Weld Line #
Enclosure Exam Note I Exam Date Page Angle Mode Frequency 2B1 6"-R*-420 75%
Ri-i Up/CW/CCW 9/26/2011 50 45' Shear 2.25MHZ
+ 4% BE Up/cw/ccw 51 600 Shear 2.25MHZ Dwn U2 600 Longitudinal 2.0MHZ 7
3"-RC-615 50%
R1-2 Up/CW/CCW 4113/2013 55 450 Shear 5.0MHZ
...........9 B.
............6
......0..............
0....
5..M H Z Up 57 70*
Shear 5.0MHZ Down 58 700 Shear 2.25MHZ N O T E S :
1 Up Axial scan on the upstream side of weld D w n.A.
ial scan on th e do n stre am s de o w eld
.cW Circumferential scan in the clock-wise direction ccw Circumferential scan in the counter clock-wise direction These examinations were performed manually using advanced ASME Section XI, Appendix VIII demonstrated procedures and techniques in accordance with the performance demonstration requirements. Based on access and physical limitations of these welds, alternative or other advanced technologies would not have provided complete coverage of the examination volume at the time of these examinations.
The attached enclosures include the complete Ultrasonic Examination Data Records for each Category R-A, Item R1.11, examination included in this request. Each report includes details of the UT scanning apparatus, including transducer size, frequency, angle, wave modality and insonification angles. Also included are scan plots for each of the examinations showing the piping configuration and percent coverage for each individual scan. No recordable indications were identified for any of these examinations.
Weld 2B (6"-RC-420), Reactor Coolant System Class 1, was a single-sided examination due to the nozzle to pipe configuration, limiting upstream scans. The weld is at the nozzle from Low Head Safety Injection into the Reactor Coolant cold leg (27 1/2"-RC-409).
Additional "Best Effort" (non-Code) scan with a 60 degree Longitudinal search unit obtained additional 4% total coverage of the downstream side of the weld. Additionally, liquid penetrant examination (LP) was performed with no identified indications. Weld 2B in Line# 6"-RC-420, is 1,500 lb., Type 316 seamless stainless steel piping, with welding filler metal SFA 5.4 E316L-16, SFA 5.9 ER316L, and or SFA 5.30 1N316L procured with 8-20 FN delta ferrite and 75ksi minimum tensile strength.
Weld 7 (3"-RC-615), Reactor Coolant System Class 1, was a single-sided examination due to the pipe to valve configuration, limiting upstream scans. The weld is on the Reactor Coolant drain line off the crossover leg at valve 2-RC-HCV-2557A. Additional "Best Effort" (non-Code) scan with a 70 degree shear search unit obtained additional 9%
Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4th interval 1 st Period Limited Exams Page 48 of 86 total coverage of the downstream side of the weld. Weld 7 in Line# 3"-RC-615, is 1,500 lb., Type 316 seamless stainless steel piping, with welding filler metal SFA 5.4 E316L-16, SFA 5.9 ER316L, and or SFA 5.30 1N316L procured with 8-20 FN delta ferrite and 75ksi minimum tensile strength.
The NAPS 2 Risk-Informed ISI Program is based on ASME Code Case N-716 as identified in approved request N2-14-RI-001. These limitations have been evaluated as acceptable, with no impact on risk analysis, and no further actions necessary to provide reasonable assurance of pressure boundary leak tightness. Both of these welds are included in the Class 1 pressure boundary, receiving visual examinations at the beginning of each refueling outage as part of the Boric Acid Corrosion Control Program and VT-2 visual examinations at the end of the refueling outage once operating pressure and temperature is achieved before unit startup.
Both of these weld examinations were single-sided, but additional non-Code coverage was obtained (Best Effort Coverage) on the critical inside surface volume of both the weld and heat-affected area. These are additional measures that provide reasonable assurance that these welds are structurally sound. An effective examination program must include selections from different piping configurations, as well as selections from piping configurations categorized with different degradation mechanisms.
5.R1 BURDEN CAUSED BY COMPLIANCE The physical configuration of these welds, nozzle to pipe and pipe to valve, confines inspection capabilities. Detailed sketches of the limitations and inspection areas achieved have been provided. No further actions can enable better examination coverage without destroying the component.
6.R1 PROPOSED ALTERNATIVE AND BASIS These welds were selected as they are determined High Safety Significant with possible active degradation mechanisms. Selections were made based on plant specific operating experience or history of examination, weld repairs, random selection across different pipe sizes and configurations, and radiation concerns. These welds were selected, in part, because previousSection XI examination history exists. Comparison of examination results over time is critical to detect service induced degradation. Inspection of these particular welds are considered the best choice for meaningful examination results.
It is proposed that the examinations already completed at the reduced coverage be accepted for meeting the Code requirements. 100% of the pipe to valve welds were volumetrically examined from one side. No indications were discovered. The limited volumetric examinations performed should detect any general patterns of degradation that may occur in the areas covered, therefore providing reasonable assurance of the continued structural integrity of the subject weld. In addition, these welds receive a visual examination during the system leakage test. Therefore, any pattern of degradation should be detected by these examinations ensuring reasonable assurance of operational readiness.
The purpose of the inservice inspection (ISI) program is to assure the structural and pressure-retaining integrity of safety-related nuclear power plant components in
Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4th Interval 1st Period Limited Exams Page 49 of 86 accordance with the rules of the ASME Section XI Code and the requirements of 10 CFR 50.55a. Although Dominion could select only weld locations where greater than 90%
examination coverage is possible (when available based on selection criteria), meeting the purpose of the Code requires selecting a mix of not only piping-to-piping welds (where essentially 100% coverage is more likely), but also piping-to-valve welds, piping-to-pump welds, piping-to-vessel welds, socket welds, nozzle-to-pipe welds, etc. The ASME Code allows only 50% Code coverage for single-sided examinations, and in cases other than most piping-to-piping welds, the majority of weld examinations are considered single-sided examinations.
Sfie/Unit:
Summary No.:
Workscope:
UT Calibration/Examination NAPS 1
,-2 N2.RI.11.267
- ~
15..
- Prbqedure:
ER-AA.NDE-UT-802 Procedure Rev.:
Work Order No.:
. 59102346793 Outage No.:
N2R21.
-Report No'.:
UT-I 1-046 Page:.
1
- of 4.
Code:
2004 Edition CaLtItem:
R-AiR1.11 Location:
00oP Drawing No.:
12050-WMKS-0103BN Description; Elbow to Branch Connection..
System ID:
RC Component ID:
12050.WMKS-0103BM I 6-RC-420128 Slze/Length:
1.10' 121.0" Thickless/Diameler:
0.718" I 6.0" Limitations:
Single side exam due to configuration.
Start Time:
1350
- Finish Time:.
1411D Instrument Settings Search Unit Cal.
Time Date Axial Orientated Seaarh Unit Serial No.:
040182503 Serial No.:
00VJBX Checks e
-Manufacturer:
Panametrcs' Manu~facturer:
KBA Initial Cal.
"0710 09'126/2011 Cn Retionecbtor Amplitude~in' DlvslonS~iP SudPt M odel:
EPOCH 4 Linearity:
L-111-0115 Size:
0.375 ".
Model:
Comp-.G.
inter. Cal.
1350 09126024111 1.0" Notch 80%
8.0 1.440" Inter. Cal.
1350 0.9/2801201 I
N____/A___
Delay:
5.605 pg Range:
1.800" Freq.:
2.25 Mr..
Center Freil.:
NA Inter. Cal.
1410
,'2011 NIA M'tIl Cas/el:
0.1234 In/ps Pulser:
Square "Exam Angle:
45o.
Squint Angle:
INA I
NIA M
Anl:
4 qitAge Final Cal.
1550 0162t Damping:
400 Ohms Reject:
0%
Measued Angle:. 4 Mode:
Shear i_
Rep. Rate:
Auto.
Freq.:
2.0 Mhz.
t
_oEemets Couplant Eidi Point:
0.25!'
- of Elementa:
I Filter:
0.8-3.0 Mode:
Futlwave Cal. Badch:
07220 Circumferential Orientated Search Unit Cnfig.:
Single Focus:
NIA Sondf.
Clibratlon gni Sweep Voltage:.
Ma____ther___.'
Shape:
Round
-Contour:
N/A
- e. :
-SON C
Rlecto Amplitudt %
Siviswon Sound Path Ax. Gain (dB):
8.2 Circ. Gain (dB):
NIA Wedge Stle:.
WC Exaer Batch:
07270 u
N/A 10" ScreenDIv.=
1,800 In.of Sound Path R
Lth 6
N 0
Ty~pe:
SoundSafe Type:
17 egh
'No on:0
- " *Calibration Block Mfg.:
- SONOTECH i Scan Coverage Cal. Block No.:
10876.2 Reftnca Block RaeferncetSlmulator Block Thcns: 22" Da-Fa UpstreamR, Downstrdam[] Scan dB: 21.
Reeec lc Thickness,_ 2.25________
Serial No.:
Gain I
Sga Sweep Sound Patlh Thcak.nemp:
Tem.
Tola:
07 CW ]
CCW-] Scan dB: '26.2 Seral No.:
05-8258 dB Reflector Amplitdegl
% Division Calm Bpk. Tamp::
320 Temp. Tool; 07 xam Surface:
O Type:
SS Rompus Block 8.2 FSDI 2
5 1.060" Camp. Temp..,
82* Temp.. Tool:
07 N/A*.
'i Surface Condition:
Contour Ground A
Recordable Indication(n):
Yes []
No FZ (if Yes, Ref. Attached Ultrasonic Indication Report.)
Results:
Accept [R Reject E]
Geom El
" ' Comments:. Circ. scans performed on Upst. and DnsL aides of the
.weld. FOr T & C aee previous dsta report #UT-08-030.
Percent Of Coverage Obtained 9 60%:
No' Reviewed Previous Data:
Yea Examiner Lay 1-1PDI SIgnature Date Reviewer Signal' Date Knott, Brian 09126,.
,12011-*),.O**
o?-,
iagminer Q
0 Signature Data o
Site Review Signature Date Zoilrier. Brian 0 tI.PE14r 09/6/01 i
I Other Level N/A Signature Date ANII RO4Iw Signature Date NIA
/
mz0 I-0Cn C:
X z
4h.)
0
- )--zz D(D 0v 0 o m CY1 -
o M Ln -.
0Y) (Al (D 0 UT Callbration/Examination ii
UT Calibration/Examination 3po-fte SitatUnlt:
Sum mary No.:
Worksoope:
NAPS 1
2 N2.R1.11.267 Procedure:
ER-M-NDE-UT-802 Procedure Rev.:
1 Work Order No.:
59102346793 Outage No..
N2R21
-Report No.:
UT-11-046 Page:'
2 of 4
I'SI Code:
2004 Edition CoL/Item:
R-AIR1.11 Location:
C loop Drawing No.:
12050-WMKS-01030N
==
Description:==
Elbow to Branch Connection System ID:
RC Component ID: 12050-WMKS-0103BNI 6-RC-420 12B Size/Length:
1.10" 121.0"-*
ThicknesslDiameter:
0.718"1 6.0" Limitations:
Single aide exam due to configuration.
Start Time:
1411 FinishTime:
1437 Instrument Settings Search Unit Cal.
Time Date Serial No.:
040182503 Serial No,:
OlCLNO Checks Msnufacturer Penametrices Manufacturer.
KBA Initial Cal.
0725 0912612011 Model:
EPOCH 4 Unearity:
L-11-015 Size:
0.375" Model:
Comp-G Inter. Cal.
1411 0B12612011 Delay:
7.195 gin.
Range:
2.180" Freq.:
2.25 Mhz.
Center Freq.:
NfA Inter. Cal 1437 0912612011 MT Catf.Vel:
0.1265 Inlps Pulser.
Square Exam Angle:
g
= I Inet. Cal.
N/A t
MExaum Angle: -*
Squint Angle,1558 NA9126,20 Damping:
_400 Ohms Reject_
"0%,,Measured Angle:-
59' Mode:
Shear Rep.Rate Auo.
20 Mh. -Couplant Rep. Rate:
Auto.
Freq-2.0 Mhz..
Exit Point:
0.25'
- of Elements:
I t Filter:
0.8-3.0 Mode:
Fuiwave Single-Cal. Batch:
07220 Voltaer:
Max.8
-3.0 Mode Fulw Config.:
.Single Focus:
NIA Type Sound~afe
,Valtage:
Max._
Other NIA Shape:
Round Contour:
NIA TMp.:
SONOTECH WeMd.e Stye:
MSWQC Ax. Gain (d8):
24.0 Cire. Gain (dB):
NIA Eyxam Batch:
07220 Search Unit Cable
- 10. Screen Div.
.2.180 in. of Sound Path Type:: RO 174 Leng: *p No. Conn.:
e0 Tps:
SoundOafe Tp:-
-~
Legh V
N.
onn:
Mfg.:
SONOTIECH Calibration Block Scan Coverage Cal. Block No.:
10876 Upstresm W DoWhsteam(n Scan dB: 36.0 Reference Block Thickness:
2.25" Die.:
Flat CWS6 CCWgJ Scan dB: 42.0 Serial No.'
05-0258 Cat. BIk. Temp.: 71° Temp. Tool:
_07 Exam Surface:
OD Type: " SC Roenpua Stock Comp. Temp.:
82° Temp. Tool:
07 Surface Condition:
Contour Ground Recordable IndIcation(a);
Yes II, No
-(If Yes, Ref. Attached Ultrasonic Indication Report.)
Results:
Accept []
Reject j]
Geotn []
Comments: Elf Percent Of Coverage Obtained > go%:
No Reviewed Previous Data.
Yes "
dui Axial Orientated Search Unit Calibration Sign*l Sweep Sound Path Reflector Amplitude %
Division 1.0" Notch 80%
8.0 1.743" N/A MIA Circumferential Orientated Search Unit Calibration Signal Sweep Sound Pai Reflector AmplItud. %
Division NIA IL NlA ReferencelSlmulator BIock Gain SignaI Sweep Sound Path d1B Reflector Afnpiida%
Division 24.0 FSDH 45%
6.7
.1.458" NIA I-!
0(0 r-Ch CD) 0(D 0CL CD
(*f 0.
M~
m.n -
co 3 w (
- 0) (n CO C) etive coverage using the 60° search unit has been rifled by the presence of theIweld root response ring the required scans. Circ. Scans pertormed Upst.
UT Callbration/Examination
UT Cal ibrationlExamination Site/Unit.
Summery No.:
Workscope:
. 2 Procedure:
ER-A&-NDE-UT-D02 N2.Rl.11.297 Procedure Rev.:
Work Order No.:
1 59102348793 Outage No.:,
.N2R21 Report No.:
.UT11-046 Page:
3 of.
4 ISI Code:
2004 Edition Cat./Item:
R-ANR1.11 Location:
'IC loop Drawing No.:
12050-WMKS-0103BN
==
Description:==
Elbow to Branch Connection System ID:
RC Component ID: 12050-WMKS-0103BN 16-RC-42012B Size/Length:
1,10" 1.21.0" Thickness/Diameter:
0.718" 1 6.0 Limitations:
Single side exam due to configuration.
Start Time:
1439 i
Finish Time:
1444 Instrument Settling Search Unit Cal.
Time.
Dale Axial Orlerntated Search Unit Serial No.:
040182503 Serial No.:
06-101 Checks-Calibration
. inal '
Sweep Sou-Manufacturer:
Panametrics Minunifactur RTD Initaa Cal.
0759 10912I2011 Reflector Ampilitde %
Division Model:
EPOCH 4 Linearity:
L-11-015 Size:
2(SX14)'
Model:
TRL2-AUST inter. Cal.
1438 09/2612011 1.0- Notch 866/6 6.0 1935" Delay:
8.935 pa Range:
2.420" Fre*q.:
2.0
- lhz, Canter Fracl.:
Inter. Cal.
1445 09/26/2011 N/A IInter. Cal.
NIA M'9 CalAtel:
0.2323 1 nlps Pulser:
Square Exam Angle.
80° Squint Angle:
3' ItrC.
A Final Cal.
1J0o 09126/2011 Damping:
400 Ohms ReJect:... 0%
Measured Angle:
59" Mode: Longitudinal Rep. Rate:
Auto.
Freq.:
2.0 Mhz.
Ext Point
- o 2
Couplant Filter.
0.8-3.0 Mhz Mode:
Fulwav0.3 Cal, Batch:
07220 Circumferential Orientated Search Unit F
Config.:
. D-SBS Focus:
F0.0.6" Voltage:
Max.
Other:
Nt r
TAye:
SoundSafe Calibration Signit Sweep Sound Path Shape:
Retangutar.Contour Fiat Mfg.:
SONOTECH Reflector Amplituhi %
Division Wedge Style Integral
'-NIA._,
Ax Gain (dB):
42.3 CIrl. Gain (dB):
NIA Search Unit Cable Exam Batch:
07220 10 ScreenDIv.= 2.420 in. of Sound Path Type:
RG 174 Length:
V' No. Conn.: 0 Type.
Soundeas C
i B
Mfg.:
SONO'TECH Calibration Block Scan Coverage.'
Cal. Block No.:
10876 UpstreamE] E Downstream1, Scan dB: 42.3 Reference Block Refrenoelmulator Block Thickness:
2.25" Die.:
Fiat CW NA Serial No.:
05-8258 Gain Signal Sweep Sound Path TWccw-Scan dB: NA dB Reflector Amplitude % Division Cal. BIk. Temp.: 7V Temp. Tool.
07 Exam Surface:
0OD)
Type:
SS Rompus Block 37.9 FSDH 80e 6.0 1.456" Comp. Temp.:
82" Temp. Tool:
07 Surface Condition:
Contour Ground NIA Recordable Indication(s):
Yes E]
No ]
(if Yes. Ref. Attached Utrasonic Indication Report.)
Results:
Accept W]
Reject J-Geom [
Comments: Utilized for coverage on nozzle side of weld.
Percent Of Coverage Obtained 2--90%:
. No
- Reviewed Previous Data:
Yes Examiner Level H PDI Signature Date Reviewer
.1 Date Knott, Brian D.
/9 2(.iA*-
09/2612011 itL-a.
Examiner
(...4.evO' i-~
Signature Date S ite Review 9i9nature Date Zollner, Brian D 0912e/2011 I* (E-
/
C J
tC.
d"
/,
4 OPý a Qr
.6oOr
.0.
Other Level N/A Signature Date ANII Review
.Signatre Date NIA
.Y M
0 I-0 Cn (D
-3.0 CD R Z Z 0(0
(.1a-..
P M) in'
-~
o 0 4ý
-a0) c c) 3 wc,
- 0)
(#1 (0 C
UT Calibration/Examination
ENCLOSURE R1-1
~Dominiour Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4th Interval 1 st Period Limited Exams Page 53 of 86 Report No: UT-1 1-046 Summary # N2.R1.11.267 Pg.
4 of 4
Prepared By. W.L. Thomas Date:
10112/2011 Weld Number SThickness-.
Weld Length Weld Width 2E 45 EL.
2B
.724" 21" 1.1" FLOW BR 0
1.05" WIDTH X.241" HT =.25 SQ. IN. = REQUIRED VOLUME US SIDE EXAMINED 100% OF THE REQUIRED VOLUME US SIDE.
EXAMINED.04 SQ IN. OF THE REQUIRED.25 SQ. IN. DS SIDE AX DIR BEST EFFORT.
.04 /.25 = 0-16 X 100 16%. BEST EFFORT BRANCH SIDE AX DIRECTION, NO.EXAM.21 SQ IN. OR 84% AX DIRECTION DS SIDE CIRC EXAM DS SIDE WAS NOT LIMITED.
initial 0 Final [9-HSB-CT Examination Volume Dimensions - Height 0.241 Length 21" Width Coverage Summary Required Scans (each has a weighing factor of 100 for complete coverage)
ANGLE UpSt-Ax UpSt-Circ DnSt-Ax DnSt-Circ 45160 100%
100%
100%
60L
- 16%
Code Coverage Total 75%
Best Effort Coverage (Max 25%) Total 4%
Notes:
- 1) Code Coverage refers to the maximum percentage of the required examination volume that is effectively examined with the qualified examination procedure.
- 2) Best Effort Coverage refers to the required examination volume past the weld centerline that is examined in the axial beam direction with an Appendix ViII demonstrated procedure for single sided coverage.
Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4th Interval 1st Period Limited Exams ENCLOSURE R1-1 Page 54 of 86 Liquid Penetrant Examination.
Site/Unit::
NAPS' I
Summary No.:.
N2.R1.1 W~orkscope.
'OW 2
1.267 Procedure: '
ER-AA-NDE-PT-300 Procedure Rev.:
6 Work Order No.:
59102358434 Outage No.:
N2R21 Report No.:
PT-11;029 Page:
1 of N
Code:
2004 Edition, CaUItem:
R-.AR1.11 Location:
C loop Drawing No.;.
...-. 12050-WMKS-0103BN.
Descriptio-: Elbow to Branch Connection System ID:
RC Component ID: 12050-WMKS-0103BN 1 6-RC-420 12 Size/Length:
314" 1 20.8" Limitations:
None Light Meter Mfg.:
AEMC Instruments Serial No:
AEMC-4 Illumination:
144 fc Temp. Tool-Mfg.:
- AEMC Instruments Seial No.
1071BGCY Surface Temp.:
82
'F Comparator Block Temp.:
- Side A....NIA
- F Side B:
- F.
Resolution:
.Not Used LoiWo Location:
N/A Surface Condition:
Contour Ground Cleaner-Penetrant Remover Developer Brand MAGNAFLUX MAGNAFLUX MAGNAFLUX MAGNAFLUX Type SKC-S SKL-SPI SKC-S SKD-S2 Batch No.
09L08K 09J07K 09LOSK 06C05K Time Evap.
3 Minutes Dwell 10 Minutes--
Evap.
0 Minutes Develop 10 Minutes Time Exam Started:
0251 Time Exam Completed:
0333 Indication
, Loc "Loc Diameter Length Type Remarks No..
L W
R/L N/A Comments:
Flashlight used for illumination.
Results:
Accept W1 Reject [
Eval []
NDER 11-170 Percent Of Coverage Obtained > 90%:
Yes Reviewed Previous Data; NIA Examiner Level II inatu Date IRev.ewer Signature Date MIx, Bridget I_
__._9_20/2011/_____
Exmnr LvlDate Site Re SDate Porter 1t, Robert E.
9/20120111 VLS.
I(.L-41JX4?WM Other Level NIA Signature Date IANII Review A
Signature Date UquWd Penetrant Examinatlon
UT Calibration/Examination Site/Unit:
Summary No.:
Workscopo:
NAPS 1
2 N2.R1.11.437 Procedure:
Procedure Rev.:
Work Order No.:.
ER-AA-HOE-UT-802 2
Outage No.:
N2R22 Report No.:
UT-13-018 Page:
1 of 6
iSi Code:
2004 Edition Cat./item:
R-A/R1.11 Location:
A loop Drawing No.:
12050-WMKS-0103CB Desnription: Pipe-to-valve System ID:
RC Component ID:
12050-WMKS-0103CB 13.RC-61517 Size!Length:
0.90" 111.0" Thickness/Dianeter:
0.438" / 3.0" Limitations:
Single sided exam due to downstream valve 2-RC-HCV-2557A.
Start Time:
0132 Finish Time:
0145 Instrument Settings Search Unit
-Cal.
Time Date Axial Orientated Search Unit Serial No.:
01XK03 Serial No.:
01CP6Y Checks I
Calibration Signal Sweep Soind Path Manufacturer:
Krautkremer Manufacturer KBA Initial Cal.
2050 411212013 Reflector Amplitude %
Division Model:
USN 60 SW Linearit y:
L-13-009 SIze:
0.25" Model:
Comp-G Inter. Cal.
0132 4/1312013 0.5" Notch 80%
5.11 0.718" Delay:
3,9644 ps Range:
1.250" Freq.:
5.0 MHZ Center Freq.;
NIA Inter. Cal.
NIA SInter. C.al.
N/A M'tl Cal!Vel:
0.1241 inips Pulser Type:
Square Exam Angle:
45" Squint Angle:
NIA Int-ner al.
W Damping:
600 Ohms Roject:
0%
Measured Angle:
44*
Mode:
Shear F.
0306 4113120131 PRF; Auto High SU Freq.;
5.0 MHZ Exit Point 0.15" 4 ol Elements:
1 Couplant Frequenc,:
5.0 MHz Rectify:
Fullwave Cal. Batch:
07220 Circumferential Orientated Search Unit Votoc:
45 ule idh:~Config.:
Single Focus:
N/A Vollae:
450 Pulse Width:
100 Type:
SoundSafa Calibration Signal Sweep Sound Path Shae:
oun Cntor:
/A Mfg.:
SONOTECH Reflector Amplitude %
Division SudPt wedge Style:
MSWQC N/A Ax. Gain (dB):
18.5 Circ. Gain (dB):
N/A Style:
Unit ableExam Batch:
07220
-Search Unit Cable 10 Screen Div.= 1.250 In. of Sound Path Type:
SoundSate Type:
RG-174 Length: 8.0' No. Conn.: 0 Typeg:
SOundOteC Block-Mfg.:
SIJNOTECH Calibration Block Scan Coverage Cal. Block No.
10873 Upstream Downarm Scan d 36.5 Reference Boc ReferenceSimulator Block c
I wns~renSignal SaSweep Sn Path3 Thickness 2.25" Die.:
0 CW Scan dB:' 36.5 Serial No.:
05-6533 di Rector iAmlitude %
Divisio Sound Cal. Blk. Temp.
7V" Tamp. Tool:
07 O
v S
Rfetr iuoDvso Exam Surface:
OD Type:
SS Rompus Block 18.5 SDH 70%
8.4 1.046" Comp. Temp.
7._ Temp. Too]:
07 Surface Condition:
Ground Recordable Indication(s):
Yes No P (If Yes, Ret. Attached Ultrasonic Indication Report.)
Results:
NRI R RI E]
Geom Li Comments: None Percent Of Coverage Obtained > 90%:
No Reviewed Previous Data:
NIA Examiner Level ip-P,,'
Signature Date Reviewer Sign Dale Zollner, Brian D R
4 20 W.L"UQr-A5 Examiner Level NIA Signature Date Site Review It Dal NIA j C,
/,,
Other Level NIA Signature Date ANII Review
,i nature Date NIAt LIT Celibration/Examinatlnn 0r-0 C,,
CXc m
cn)
C:
- 0)
L Ln M 0 x co B W
UT Calibration/Examination
- nPDominion, Site/Unit:
Summary No.:
Workscope:
NAPS 1
2 Procedure:
ER-AA-NDE-UT-802
. IN2.R1.I1.437 Procedure Rev.:
Work Order No.:
2 Outage No.:
N2R22 Report No.:
UT-t 3-018 Page; 2
of 6
ISI Code:
2004 Edition Cal./ltem:
R-AIR1.11 Location:
A loop Drawing No.:
12050-WMKS-"103CB
==
Description:==
Pipe-to-valve System ID:
RC Component ID: 12050-WMKS-O13CB I 3-RC-61517 Size/Length:
0.90" 111.0" ThickriesalDiametor:
0.438" / 3.0" Limitations:
Single sided exam due to downstream valve 2-RC-HCV-2557A.
Start Time:
0146 Finish Time:
0165 Instrument Settings Search Unit Cal Time Date Axial Orientated Search.Unit Serial No.:
OIXK03 Serial No.:
01CPeX Checks Callbrallon Signal S
ound Path Manufacturer:
Krautkramer Manufacturer KBA Initial Cal.
2112 411212013 Reflector Amplitude %
Division Model; USN 00 SW Unearity:
L-13-009 Size:
0.25" Model:
Comp-G Inter. Cal.
0146 411312013 0.5" Notch 80%
5.4 0.940" Delay:
6.2169 ps Range:
1.750" Freq.:
5.0 MHZ Center Freq.:
NIA Inter. Cal.
N/A Inter. Cai.
N/A M1,I CablVel:
0.1241 inris Pulser Type:
Square Exam Angle:
60' Squint Angle:
N/IA Inter. Cal.
N/07 4I3 3
Damping:
500 Ohms Rejoct:
0%
Measured Angle:
81° Mode:
Shear PRF:
Auto High SU Freq.:
5.0 MHZ Exit Point 0.156
- 9ofaElements:
u Frequency:
5.0 MHz Rectify; Fullwave Focus:
Cal. Batch:
07220 Circumferential Orientated Search Unit Prqeny
________Corrtig.:
Single Nous
/MA Type:
SoundSafe Calibration Soundl Pathp Voltage:
450 Pulse Width:
100 Shape:
Round Contour:
N/A Mfg.:
SONOTECH Reflector implitude DSweseon p
und ath Wedge Style:
MSWQC NIA Ax, Gain (dB):
35.0 Circ. Gain (dB):
N/A Search Unit CableExam Batch:
07220 10 Screen Div.= 1.750 In. of Sound Path Type:
RG-174 Length: 6.0' No. Conn.: 0 Type:
SoundSafe
-Mfg.:
SONOTECH Calibration Block Scan Coverage Cal. Block No.
10873 Upstream vJ DownstreamL Scan dB: 47.0 Reference Block ReFerencelSimulator Block Gain I ISienai SI we~eP S ound Pathl Thickness 2.25" Die.:
0 CW CCW---] Scan dB: 47.0 Serial No.:
05-6533 ain ReflectorAmpliude S
Division Cal. Blk. Temp. 71* Temp. Tool:
07 Exam Surface:
OD Type:
SS Rompus Biock 35.0 SOH 45%
0.6 1.49" Cump. Temp.
- 67.
Temp. Tool:
07 Surface Condition:
Ground Recordable Indication(s):
Yes E[
No V (if Yes. Ref. Attached Ultrasornic Indication Report.)
Results:
NRI RI Fl Geom F-Comments:
Effecltive coverage using the 60' search unit has been verified by the presence of the weld root response Percent Of Coverage ObtaIned ' 20%;
No Reviewed Previous Data:
NIA during the required scans.
Examiner Level I I 7D Signature Date Reviewer S
Date Zoilner, Brian D 4113)2013 1,1.<40~i~MAS
-. Z 13 Examiner Level N/A Signature Date Site Review Signature Date N/A (I
c..4CL-&LuDt Other Level NIA Signature Date ANII Review 1
Sattinre Date N/A I
m r-0 to C
-o U)
C) 0Q)
(0
- 0) U) CD00 UT Callbration/Exarnination
UT Calibration/Examination Site/Unit:
Summary No.:
Workscope; NAPS 1
2 Procedure:
ER-AA-NDE-UT-802 N2.Ri.11.437 Procedure Rev.:
Work Order No.:
2 Outage No.:
N2R22 Repoit No.:
UT-13-016 Page:
3 of 6
ISI Code:
2004 Edition Cat./iltm:
R-AJRI.11 Location:
A loop Drawing No.:
12050-WMKS-103CB
==
Description:==
Pipe-to-valve System ID:
RC Component ID: 12050-WMKS-O103CB 13-RC-6151 7 SizelLength:
0.90" 111.0" Thickness!Dlameter.
0.438" 13.0" Limitations:
Single sided exam due to downstream valve 2-RC-HCV-2557A.
Start Time:
01156 Finish Time:
0204 Instrument Settings Search Unit Cal.
Time Date Axial Orientated Search Unit Serial No.:
01XK03 Serial No.:
0OFPDJ Checks Calibratinn Signal Sweep ManUfaclurar:
Krautkramer Manufacturer:
KBA Initial Cal.
2126 411212013 Reflector Amplilude %
Division Model:
USN 60 SW Linearily:.
L-13-009 Si1e:
0.25" Model:
Comp-G Inter. Cal.
0t56 411312013 0.5" Notch 80%
5.7 1.445" Delay:
6.4231 ps Range:
2.560" Freq.:
5.0 MHZ Center Freq.:
NA Inter. Cal.
NIA MNI CaltVel:
0.1241 Infps Pulser Type:
Square Exarn Angle:
701 Squint Anglo:
NIA FInter Cal..
03_
_ __1_120_'
Damping:
500 Ohms Rejecl:
0%
Measured Angle:
70' Mode:
Shear PR:
uo ig U re.
Couplant PRF:.
Auto High SU Freq.
5.0 MHZ Exit Point 0.30"
- of Elements:
I Frequnnency:
5.0 MHz
- Rectify, Futlwawe Cal. Batch:
07220 Circumferential Orientated Search Unit Franecy 50 ~z Reliy:Fulwte Conlig.:
Single Focus:
NIA Voltage:
450 PuIse Widtf1:
100 Shape:
Round Contour; NIA TIe:
SoundSafe Calibration Signal Sweep Mfg.:
SONOTECH Relleclor Amplitude %
Division WNedge Style:
MSWOC N/A Ax. Gain (dB):
46.0 Circ. Gain (dB):
NIA Style:Unit ableExam Batch:
07220 Search Unit Cable______
10 Screen Div. = 2.560 in. of Sound Path Type:
RG-174 Length; O.0" No. Conn.:
0 Type:
SoundSafe Mfg.:
SONOTECH Calibration Block Scan Coverage Cal. Block No.
10873 Upstream [] Downsiream.- Scan dB: 46.0 Reference Block Reference/Simulator Block Thickness 2.2" Die.:
0nSerial No.;
056533 Gain Signal Sweep Sound Path Thiknes ____
___i___._______
CW El CCW-Scan dB:
NIA er 5-3 dB Reflector Amplitude % Division Cal. elk. Temp.
71' Temp. Tool:
07 Exam Surface:
OD Type:
SS Rompus Block 46.0 SDH 85%
3,7 0.944" Comp. Temp.
- 67.
Temp. Tool:
07 Surface Condition:
Ground Recordable Indication(s):
Yes F.
No R (if Yes, Ref. Attached Ultrasonic Indication Report-)
Resulls:
NRI RI Geom L:
Comments: None Percent Of Coverage Obtained > 90%:
No Reviewed Previous Data:
N/A Examiner Level ii.P
.r Signature Date Reviewer Sg" Date Zollner, Brian D
- 0.
4JI132013 W.L L"r~'pMAs 5 4Z Examiner Level NIA Signature Date Site Review Zr Signature Date NIA
-_F 3G(~4.
~
c~~
Other Level NIA Signature Date ANIl Review Signatuje Date N/A xa/r-,te UT Catlbration/Exantirineion I-!
0 0,
C X
Cn C:
N)
(D 0
U 3 D D
00 CD D Co 9 (. i
- 0) Cn(D (00
UT Calibration/Examination Slte/Unit:
Summary No.:
Workscope:
NAPS 1
2 N2.RI.11.437 Procedure:
Procedure Rev.:
Work Order No.:
ER-AA-NDE-UT-802 2
Outage No.:
N2R22 Report No.:
UT-13-016 Page:
4 of 6
ISI Code:
2004 Edition CaIJItem:
R-AIRI.11 Location:
A loop Drawing No.:
12050-WMKS-0103CB
==
Description:==
Pipe-to-valve System ID:
RC Component ID: 12050-WMKS-0103CB I 3-RC-615 /7 SizeiLongth:
0.90" I11.0" Thiukiiess/Diameter:
0.438"1 3.0" Umiltalons:
Single aided exam due to downstream valve 2-RC-HCV-2557A.
Start Time:
0205 Finish Time:
0211 Instrument Settings Search Unit Cal.
Time Dale Axial Orientated Search Unit Serial No.:
01XIK03 Serial No.:
01CWK5 Checks Calibration Signal Sweep Sound Path Manufacturer.
Krautkramer Manufaclurer; KBA Initial Cal.
2152 4V1212013 Reflector Amplitude %
Division Model:
USN 60 SW Linearity; L-13-009 Size:
0.25" Model:
Comp-G inter. Cal.
0205 411312013 D.5" Notch 80%
5.3 1.352" Delay:
6.3834 pa Range:
2.560" Freq.:
2.25 MHZ Center Freq.;
NIA Inter. Cal.
I litler. Cal.
____I_
MuII CulNel:
0.1241 In/s Pulser Type:
Square Exam Angle:
70*
Squint Angle:
NIA Final Cal. I0311 4/13/2013 Damping:
500 Ohms Reject:
0%
Measured Angle:
68' Mode:
Shear I Final Cl0314121' PRF:
Auto High SU Freq.:
2.25 MHZ Exit Point 0.20"
- of Elements:
1 Couplant_
Cal. Batch:
07220 Circumferential Orientated Search Unit Frequency:
2.25 MHz Rectify:.
Fuliwave Contig.:
Single Focus:
N/A Voilelae:
450 Puie Width.
220 Shape:
Round Contour:
MIA Type:
SoundSafe Calibration Signal Sweep Sound Patti 1Mfg.:
SONOTECH Reflector Amplitude %
Division Wedge Style:
MSWQC N/A Batch:
0
_IA Ax. Gain (rI):
48.0 Ciro. Gain (de):
N/A Search Unit Cable ETampBe__h:
07__
10 Screen Div. =
2.56 in. of Sound Path Type:
RG-174 Length: 6.0' No. Conn.:
0 Type:
SoundSafe Calibration Block Scan Coverage Cal. Block No.
21588 Upslream [] Donstreamrn & Scan dB: 48.0 Reference Block Reference/Simulator Block 3
Gain II Signal DSw'eepn Sound Path Thickness 3"
Dia.:
0 CW CCW Scan dB: N/A Serial No.:
05-6533 dB I
RSflectoriAmpl Seudep% Son Cal.BiK..Temp.
71" Temp.Tool:
07 Exam Surface:
OD Type:
58 Rompus Block 38.0 SD" 50%
3.2 0.816'.
Comp. Temp.
67" Temp. Tool:
07 Surface Condition:
Ground Recordable Indicatlon(s):
Yes F1 No [
(if Yes, Ref. Attached Ultrasonic. Indication Report.)
Results.
NRI [0(
RI El Geon []
Commentu:
Utilized for best effort coverage on the downstream (valve) aide of the weld.
Percent Of Coverage Obtained > 90%:
No Reviewed Previous Data; N/A Examiner Level ll-PP-*l_ I Signature Date a
Reviewer Sign e
Date Zoilner, Brian D0?W 441312013
'1
.1 Examiner Level NIA Signature Date Site Review Signature Date N/A
.4 Other Level NIA Signature Date ANII Review
-Signpture Date N/A tio_
__i_
UT Callbrallon/Exami,,elion 0
r-0 (1)
C CD 2.
CD M. u03 0 (D D 0
.0 Co CL.
Occ) M(n
ENCLOSURE R1-2 Supplemental ReDc Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4th Interval 1st Period Limited Exams Page 59 of 86 frt Summary No.: N2.R1.11.437 Examiner. Zollner, Brian D Examiner:
NIA Other:
N/A l
l l
Report No.:
UT-13-016 Page:
5 of 6
Level: II-PDI Reviewer:
Date: '.Z..
Level:
NIA Site Review:j Date:
Level:
NIA ANII Review.
Date; Comments: T',- c FL'-.?
Sketch or Photo:
7 jAI~~JE Additional - Supplemental Data
ENCLOSURE R1-2 Dominionw Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4t0 Interval 1 st Period Limited Exams Page 60 of 86 Report No: UT-13-016 Summary # N2.1R1.11.437 Pg.
6 of 6
Prepared by: W. Thomas 0
Date: 4/22/2013 Weld Number Thickness 7
0.448" Weld Width Weld Length 0.90" 11" 2
1 0
1 1
2 I
r-104 FLOW SW-69 7
CL 45 70 PIPE\\.-.-.
""VALVE 0.149' HEIGHTX 0.95" WIDTH 0.14 SQ. IN.
TOTAL REQUIRED VOLUME - 0.14 SQ IN.
-,EXAMINED 100% OF THE REQUIRED VOLUME US SIDE EXAMINED 0.05 SQ IN. BEST EFFORT
.05!.14 - 0.36 X 100 n 36% BEST EFFORT DS SIDE AXDIRECTICtN NO EXAMINATION DS SIDE AX DIRECTION - 64%
Examination Volume Dimensions -
Height 0.149" Length 11" AN) /ANI Ni.l HSB GS, Reviewed,
4&//-"
Width 1.9" Coverage Summary Required Scans (each has a weighing factor of 100 for complete coverage)
ANGLE UpSt-Ax UpSt-Circ DnSt-Ax DnSt-Circ 45/60 100C%/
0%
70 100%
70 2.25 Mhz
- 36%
Code Coverage Total 50%
100+100+0+36=236/4=59
- Best Effort Coverage (Max 25%) Total 9%
Notes:
- 1) Code Coverage refers to the maximum percentage of the required examination volume that is effectively examined with the qualified examination procedure.
- 2) Best Effort Coverage refers to the required examination volume past the weld centerline that is examined in the axial beam direction with an Appendix Vill demonstrated procedure for single sided coverage.
Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4 th Interval 1st Period Limited Exams Page 61 of 86 R2.
Risk-Informed Piping Welds Not Subject To A Degradation Mechanism 4.R2 IMPRACTICALITY OF COMPLIANCE In accordance with 10CFR50.55a(g)(5)(iii), relief is requested from the "essentially 100 percent" volumetric examination coverage requirement for the identified piping welds.
This requirement is considered impractical primarily due to single-sided access for these components.
Scan Coverage Weld Line #
Enclosure Exam Note I Exam Date Page Angle Mode Frequency SW-5 (BPL 343) 32"-SHP-459 75%
R2-1 Up/CW/CCW 9/24/2011 64 450 Shear 2.25MHZ UPfcw/ccW 65 600 Shear 2.25MHZ Up 66 700 Shear 2.25MHZ 4
6"-Rc-416 75%
R2-2 Up/CW/CCW 9/21/2011 74 450 Shear 2.25MHZ
+ %BEUfc/cW7 60 Ser 2.25MHZ Up 76 700 Shear 2.25MHZ Down 77 600 Longitudinal 2.0MHZ 3"-CH-814 42.3%
R2-3 Down.cW/CCW 4/18/2013 80 450 Shear 2.25MHZ
+ 1.5% BE Down/CW/CCW 81 600 Shear 2.25MHZ Down 82 700 Shear 2.25MHZ
_Up 83 600 Longitudinal 2.0MHZ N O T E S :.....
U
{p Axial scan on the upstream side of weld Dwn Axial scan on the downstream side of weld Scircumferential scan in the clock-wise direction c
.ci c m e e t a s.a
.h lc -w s d r t o Lccw circumnferential scan in the counter clock-wise direction These examinations were performed manually using advanced ASME Section XI, Appendix VIII demonstrated procedures and techniques in accordance with the performance demonstration requirements. Based on access and physical limitations of these welds, alternative or other advanced technologies would not have provided complete coverage of the examination volume at the time of these examinations.
The attached enclosures include the complete Ultrasonic Examination Data Records for each Category R-A, Item R1.20, examination included in this request. Each report includes details of the UT scanning apparatus, including transducer size, frequency, angle, wave modality and insonification angles. Also included are scan plots for each of the examinations showing the piping configuration and percent coverage for each individual scan.
Weld SW-5 (32"-SHP-459), Main Steam System Non-Classed, is a Main Steam pipe to header weld. The configuration is a mitered shop weld from 32-inch piping to the horizontal 40-inch Main Steam header. The 32-inch piping is carbon steel, A155EFW, CLI, CMS 75, and the 40-inch header is carbon steel, A155EFW, CLI, KC 70. Full coverage was obtained at the tops and bottoms of the welds, but limitations existed at the sides where the angle between the pipe and the header is at right angles. This weld is a non-class weld included as a high safety significant, break exclusion region, RISB location requiring >90% coverage per request N2-14-RI-001, and as such is included in this request. The UT examination identified two recordable indications: 1) The first indication evaluated as acceptable per ASME Section XI Table IWB-3514-1, and 2) The
Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4t Interval 1st Period Limited Exams Page 62 of 86 second identified as Inner Diameter Geometry. Beam plots, profiles, along with UT signals were used to characterize the geometrical condition of weld SW-5. The indications were evaluated using the Indication Classification guidance of the Appendix VIII qualified procedure utilized for the examination. Augmented magnetic particle examination was also performed at this location with no reportable indications identified.
Weld 4 (6"-RC-416), Reactor Coolant System Class 1,45 degree elbow to branch connection weldolet, is a seamless stainless steel elbow to stainless steel weldolet. This weld is 1,500 lb., A-403-WP316 Schedule 160 seamless stainless steel fitting, with welding filler metal SFA 5.4 E316L-16, SFA 5.9 ER316L, and or SFA 5.30 1N316L procured with 8-20 FN delta ferrite and 75ksi minimum tensile strength, and the weldolet is A-403-WP316 stainless steel. Coverage is limited because of the pipe to weldolet configuration, limiting the examination mostly to the upstream side. The cast nozzle configuration permits a weldolet side circumferential scan. Seventy-five percent Code coverage was obtained. An additional 15 percent Best Effort (non-Code) coverage was obtained with a 60 degree longitudinal search unit from the downstream (valve) side.
Weld 6A (3'-CH-814), Chemical and Volume Control System Class 1, is a 3-inch check valve to elbow weld in the pressurizer auxiliary spray piping. This weld connects A403-WP316 Sch 160 components, with welding filler metal SFA 5.4 E316L-16, SFA 5.9 ER316L, and or SFA 5.30 1N316L procured with 8-20 FN delta ferrite and 75ksi minimum tensile strength. Coverage is limited because of the single-sided weld to a valve and the configuration of the adjacent elbow, permitting only downstream examination. Allowable Code coverage is limited to no more than 50 percent.
The NAPS 2 Risk-Informed ISI Program is based on ASME Code Case N-716 as identified in approved request N2-14-RI-001. These limitations have been evaluated as acceptable, with no impact on risk analysis, and no further actions necessary to provide reasonable assurance of pressure boundary leak tightness. Welds 4 and 6A are included in the Class 1 pressure boundary, receiving visual examinations at the beginning of each refueling outage as part of the Boric Acid Corrosion Control Program and VT-2 visual examinations at the end of the refueling outage once operating pressure and temperature is achieved before unit startup. The Main Steam System weld received complete surface examination (magnetic particle) as it is included in the augmented inspection program for Main Steam System Postulated Break Locations and the associated line is regularly walked down during normal operator rounds.
These weld examinations were limited due to configuration, but additional non-Code coverage was obtained (Best Effort Coverage) on the critical inside surface volume of both the weld and heat-affected area. These additional measures provide reasonable assurance that these welds are structurally sound. An effective examination program must include selections from different piping configurations, as well as selections from piping configurations categorized with different degradation mechanisms.
Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4th Interval 1s Period Limited Exams Page 63 of 86 5.R2 BURDEN CAUSED BY COMPLIANCE The purpose of nondestructive examination (NDE) is to perform inspections without destroying the component. The physical configuration of these welds, pipe to header, elbow to weldolet, and valve to elbow, limits inspection capabilities.
Detailed sketches of the limitations and inspection areas achieved have been provided. No further actions can enable better examination coverage.
6.R2 PROPOSED ALTERNATIVE AND BASIS These welds were selected as part of the High Safety Significant population; however, no active degradation mechanism has been identified for them. Selections were made based on plant specific operating experience or history of examination, weld repairs, random selection across different pipe sizes and configurations, and radiation concerns. Welds were selected, in part, because previousSection XI examination history exists in some cases. Comparison of examination results over time is critical to detect service induced degradation. Inspection of these particular welds are considered the best choices for meaningful examination results.
It is proposed that the examinations already completed at the reduced coverage be accepted for meeting the Code requirements. 100% of the pipe to valve welds were volumetrically examined from one side. Although two recordable indications were identified, no unacceptable indications were discovered. The limited volumetric examinations performed should detect any general patterns of degradation that may occur in the areas covered, therefore providing reasonable assurance of the continued structural integrity of the subject weld. In addition, these welds receive a visual examination during the system leakage test. Therefore, any pattern of degradation should be detected by these examinations ensuring reasonable assurance of operational readiness.
The purpose of the inservice inspection (ISI) program is to assure the structural and pressure-retaining integrity of safety-related nuclear power plant components in accordance with the rules of the ASME Section XI Code and the requirements of 10 CFR 50.55a. Although Dominion could select only weld locations where greater than 90% examination coverage is possible (when available based on selection criteria), meeting the purpose of the Code requires selecting a mix of not only piping-to-piping welds (where essentially 100% coverage is more likely), but also piping-to-valve welds, piping-to-pump welds, piping-to-vessel welds, socket welds, nozzle-to-pipe welds, etc. The ASME Code allows only 50% Code coverage for single-sided examinations, and in cases other than most piping-to-piping welds, the majority of weld examinations are considered single-sided examinations.
UT CalIbration/Examination Site/Unit:
Summary No.:
Workscope:
NAPS I
2 N2.RI.20.0020 1S1 Procedure:
ER-AA-NDE-UT-80.1 Procedure Rev.:
2 Work Order No.:
59102346793 Outage No.:
N2R21 Report No.:
UT-11-034 Page:
I of 7
Code:
ASME 2004 Ed.
Catlliem:'
R-AIRI.20...
Location:.
MER-2 Drawing No.:
12050-WMKS-o1oIA-4
==
Description:==
Pipe to Header System ID:
SHP Component ID: 120Q0-WMKS-0101A-4 32'-SHP-4591 SW-5 (BPL 343)
Size/Length:
1.8" 110 r Thickness/biamete&:
1.195"132" Limitations:
Single aided exam due to Pipe to Header configuration..
StartTime:
.1503 Finish Time;.
1620 Instrument Settings Search Unit Cal.
Time Date Axial Orientated Search.Unit Serial No.:
0816242111 Serial No.:
01CXBJ C'Lecs CCalib~ration
- Signal Sw~eep Sound Path Manufacturer:
Panametrics Manufacturer:.
KBA Initial Cal.
1428 0912412011 Reflector Armplilude %
Division Model:
EPOCH 4
. Linearity:
L-11-014 Size:
- 0.5 Model:
Comp-G Inter. C 1l.
i503 09/24011 1.5" Notch 80%.
6.4 2.129" Delay:
6.165 us Range:
3.366" Freq.:
2.25 Mhz Center Freq.:
NIA Inter. Cat.
N/A NIA M'tJ Ca/Vel:
0.1271 Inlus Pulser:
Square Exam Anglee 4
"Squint Angie:
N/A 'Ine.Cal.
N/A Damping:
400 Ohms Reject 0%4 M
d FinalCal.
1732 09/24/2011
- , u e Measured Angle : 45
- Mode :.
Shear."pl n
Rep. Rate:
Auto Freq.:
2.0 Mhz.
Exit Point:
g
- ode:
Se om xlPit
.s
- ofElements:.
i opat____
Filter.
0.8-3.0-Mode:
Fullwave Cal. Batch:
" 07220 Circunfurenil Orientated Search Unit Voltage:
Max Other NIA
/
Typ6:
SoundSafe
.Calibra00n gl Sweep Pa Shape:
Rud Contour~
NIACaiatn gl Swe SodP'h N
Mfg.:
,SONOTECH Reflector Amplltude %
Division
%Wedge Stye:
MSWQC.
N)A Ax_ Gain (d0):
2.3 Circ, Gain (dB):.
2.3
-Exam Baedh:
SeW22t.
N-n.Of____________Tye:
Search Unit Cable am Bac
_*72 10 Screen Div.
3.368 In. of Sound Path Type:.
SoundSafe Type:
RG 174 Length:.
V' No. Conn.:.10 Mg.:
" SOoTECH L
Calibration Block "nMfg.:
S CONOTEC
-Scan Coverage Pa). Block No.:
10874 Upstream [
Doinstream iJE Scan dB: 20.3-Reference Block Reference/Simulator'Block Thickness:
2.2*
Die.;
0 Serial No.:
05,699 Gain
- Signal Sweep Sound Path CWR
- CCWW Scan dB: 20.3 Seril No:
05_99 dB Reflector Amplitude % Division Cal. B6k. Temp.: 72.
Temp. Tool:.
1066BGCY E0m Surface:
D
/7 Type:
cSRompusBlock 2.3 SDII 20%
3.2 1.073" Comp. Temp.:
75T Temp. Tool:
1066BGCY
/sSurface Condition:
Contour Ground Recordable Indication(s):
Yes No (if Yes, Ref. Attached Ultrasonic Indication Report.)
Results:
Accept j']
Reject. []
Geom
- l.
. Comnnhents; None Percent Of Coverage Obtained > 90%:
No Reviewed Previous Data:.
Yes -
'l
.Examlner Level I-pDI Date Reviewer S.."'-
Date Kilpale, Jamie 024211-W4L-.
4 q
Examiner Level IlL Si. nature, Date Site Review-.
Sgnal.e Date Fopane, Leonel
.09/24/2011 AA.0
/
Other Level NIA Sibnature Date ANII Review ignature I4,..
Date NIA._____
MZ 0r-0 (I,C X
z t
Cn (D
(D M0 0 C')
co 3'W(
- 0) ( 0.
0 UT Cellbmalon/Examlnetion Ih
UT.Calibration/Examination Zp_ " ow' Site/Unit:
NAPS Summary No.:
Workscope:
2 N2.RI.20.0020 isi Procedure:
ER-AA-NDE-UT-801 Procedure Rev.:
2 Work Order No.:
59102346793
- Outage No.:
N2R21
-'Report No.:
UT.11-034 i;
Page:
2 of 7.
Coda:
ASME 2004 Ed.
Cat/item:
R-A/RI.2'0 Location:
MER-2 Drawing No.:
12050.WMKS-0101A-4
==
Description:==
Pipe to Header
- System ID:
SHP.
Component ID: 12050-WMKS-0101A-4132"-SHP-459 I SW-5 (BPL 343)
Size/Length:
1.8" c ThicknesslDiameter:
1.195"32-Limitations:
5Ingle aided exam due to Pipe io Header configuration.
'Start time:
0839 Finish Time:.
1008' Instrument Settings Search Unit Col.
Time Date-
. Axial Orientated Search Unit-Serial No.:
081624211I Serial No.:
0ICXBN Checks I.
Cirao i'
Sweep Sn.
.Calibrationt pi'gnal wep Sound Path Manufacturer:
Panametrics Manufacturer:
KBA initial Cal.
0700 09/2512011 Repector Amplitude %
Division Model:
EPOCH 4 Linearity:
L-11-014 Size:
o03" Model:
ComPig inlter. Cal.
0839 09125W2011 2.703" Delay:
8.378 us Range:
4.76" Freq.:
2.25 Mhz Center Fraq.:
NIA Inter: CAal.
'_N-A_
MU CaltVel:
0.1276 Inlus Pulser Squaot Exam Angle:
600 Squint Angie NIA interCal.
N211 1
Da pig: 40 Oms Reec:
Finaý.
1211 0/521 Damping:
400 Ohms,
Reject:
0%
Measured Angle:
.60".
Mode:
. Shear.
I. -
Couplant Rep. Rate:
Auto Freq.:
2.00 Mhz.
Exit Point:
0.5" i of Elements:
'I C_
Filter:.
0.8-3.0 Mode:
Fullwave Cal. Batch:
07220 Circumferenilal Orientated Search Unit
- Flte:.
,8-,0Mod:
Fllwve Config.:.
Single Focus:
.--NIA Votage:
a Type:-
oundSafe Calibration Signal Sweep Max Other":
NA Shape:
Round Contour:
N..
Mg:
SONOTECH Reflector Am l~itude %
Division.
Sound Path Wedge Style:
MSWQC N/A Ax. Gain (dB):
21.0 Circ. Gain (dB):
21.0 Search.ni Cable
".ype:
SoundSafe 10 ScreenDiv.=
4.76 In of Sou nd Path Type:. RG174 Length 6
No. Conn.:
Mfg.:
SONOTECH I.
Calibration Block*
Scian Coverage Cal. Block No.:
10874 Upttwam [
Downstram (]
Scan dO: 33.0 Reference Block Signal Sweep Thc ne s
- 2. 5 "l.
Gain
] in"l Sweep S u d P t Thickess:
2.25" Dia.:
-] Scan dB; 33.0 SerialNo.:
0"0a8 id Reflector Situd % Division und Path Cal. BIk. Temp.: 72" Temp. Tool:.
1066BGCY Exam Surface:-
- Type, CS Ro-pit, Block.
.D 3,2 1:491-.
Comp. Temp.:
75" Temp. Tool:
l6OeBGCY Surface Condition.
Contour Ground "NA Recordable indication(s):
Yes R]
No
. (if Yes, Ref. Attached Ulb'asohic IndI66fton Report),
Results:
Accept [
Reject E Geom n Comments: Effective coverage usingitli. 60V search unit has been verilled-by the presence of the weld root response Percent Of Coverage Obtained > 90%:
No Reviewed Previous Data:
Yeas during the required scans.
Examiner Level IIl'PDl Sl l~ure, 7 2 Date1 Reviewer Date Kilpela, Jamie j
09/2512011 q,"p.,t Examiner Level IlL-U~nature 1"_-ý Date jSite Review
/
gnalure Date Epana.Leonr 0912512011, RA r
7-oo-1A6 Other Level NA Signature Date AN Review Signature Date UT Calibrallon/Examination Mz0) r-0(A C
X M2 X.
z C
M..
=3 0
(
00.0 CLm0 -
- 0) Cfl (D C
Site/Unit:
Summary No.:
Workscope:
UT Calibration/ExaminatiOn NAPS I
2 Procedure:
ER-AA-NDE-UT,8O I N2.Ri.20.0020 Procedure Re'v.:
2 ISI Work Order No.:
59102340793 Outage No.:
NiR21' Repofl No.:
UT-11-034 Page:'
3 of 7
Code:
ASME 2004 Ed.
Cat/Illem:
R-A.RIt.20 Location:
MER-2 Drawing No.:
12050-WMKS-O101A-4
==
Description:==
Pipe to Header System ID:
SHP Component ID:,12050-WMKS.0101A-4 I 32'SHP-459 1 SW-5 (BPL 343)
Stze/Length:
1.8'1 ar'"
Thickness/Diameter:
1,195'Y32" Limitations:
Single aided exam due~to Pipe to Header configuration.
- StartTime:.
1010 Finish Time:
1119
'Inatrument Settings Search Unit Cal.
Time Date Axial Orientated Search Unit Serial No.:
.0816242111 Serial No.:'
0OFtDF Checks Caibration Signa Sweep Soud Path Manufacturer:
Panametrias Manufacturer:
KBA Initial Cal.
07"02 0912512011 Rellectolr Ai'p itude %
'Division Model:
EPOCH 4 Linearity:
L-11.014 Size:
0.50" Model:
Comp-G Ilnter. Cal.
1010. 0912512011 1.5" Notch
- S0%
7.0 4.967 Delay:
9.573 us Range:
6.959" Freq.:
2.28 Mhz -
Center Freq.
N n
/A
- i.
Cal..
NIA NIA.
Inter. Cal.
N/A T
M'S Cal/Vel:
0.1272 In/us Pulsar:.
Square Exam Angle:
70*
Squint Angle:
N/A 020 Damping:
400 Ohms Reject:
0%
Measured Arngle:
71° Mode:
-hear
/
Rep. Rate:
Auto Freq.:
2.00 Mhz Exit Point 0.53"-
- of Elements:
1 Couplant i
Filter,..
0.8-3.0 Mode:
.Fullwave f
F N
Cal. Batch:
07220 Circumferentlal Orientated Search Unit
__________Canfig.:
Single Focus:
N/A_____Type; SoundSafe Calibration Signal Sweep Sound Path Voltage:
Max Other NIA Shape:
- Round Contour N/A Mfg.:
SONOTECH Reflector Amplitude %
Division Wedge Style:
MSWQC NIA Ax. Gain (dB):
32.0 Circ. Gain*(dB):
N/A Search Unit Cable
- Exam Batch:.
07220 110. Screen Div. =
i.95g in. of Sound Path.
Type:
RG 174 Length:
6' No. Cohn.: 0 Type:
SoundSafe L.
Mfg.:
SONOTECH Calibration Block
.Scan Coverage Cal. Block No.:
10874 Upstream W D'wnstream-] ScandB: 38.0 Reference Block afercefSlmulator Black Thickness:
2.25" Did.:
0
'ASerial No.:
0"998 Gain Signal Sweep Sound Pat CW E CCWE-Scan d N:
d3No.:
05-998 dB Reflector A6nr litude % Division Cal. 81k. Temp.: 72" Temp. Tool:
l066BGCY Exam Surface:
DO Type:
CS Rompus Block 26 NSDH 40%
15 1013" CEma.
Temp.:e 7-Temp Tool
.SD IO;BC 1.011.3".N Comp. Temp.:
75.__1_=
Temp. Tool:
1I066BGCY Surface Condition:
Contour Ground Recordable Indication(s):
Yes No Q (if Yes, Ref..Attached Ultrasonic Indication Report.)
Results:
Accept R]
Reject El Geom -
Comments: 70" search unit utilized for best effort interrogation of far side of weld.
Percent Of Coverage Obtained > 90%,.
No Reviewed Previous Data:
Yes Examiner Level II-PDI S
tfe
/,
Date Reviewer Signature Date Kllpela, Jamie 09125/2011 J.).L. -40oM AS Examiner Leve lL Date Site Review Date:
Espana, Leonet
/$U 09/2512011AA-Other Level NIA Signature
' Date AN Review vote N/A UT Calibratlon/Examlnation I
I-0(A, C
X C
M (D) a Z ZD 0 0 t) CL -
0 )<
- 0) (n (D00
Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4th Interval 1't Period Limited Exams Page 67 of 86 ENCLOSURE R2-1 ft bw Supplemental. Report Report No.:
UT-1 1-034 Page:
4 of 7
Summary No.: N2.R1.20.0020.
Examiner Kilpela, Jamle el: 1I-PDI Reviewer..
L" Nom,5-Date: o0.-3Dd Examiner Espana, Leon Level:
IlL Site Review:
- ,,Z-/.
Date:'/Oy*/
Other:
NIA.
Level:.
NIA..ANIl Review.
Date: lzl
,,x Comments:
"Sketch or Photo:
FLOW IND 1 60'.-
CL IND I 70 HEADER
/,
7 ddlitonal - Supplemental Data
Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4" Interval 1 st Period Limited Exams Page 68 of 86 ENCLOSURE R2-1
.Supplemental Report Report No.:
Page:
Summary No.: N2.RI.20.0020 Examiner: Kilpela, Ja*[e
~
eve: IH-P.D Examiner: Espana, Leq, Level:
I-L Other N/A.
Level:
N/A Comment.s:.=
o c:,
-:5 60 Reviewer-o, J,-7Ttk, p.S Site Review: AA~gb&
-ANII Review:.
UrT-11-034 S
'of 7
Date: D r'.30, I
Date:
Dlate:
Sketch or Photo:
FLOW IND 2 IND 2 70 60 CL.
HEADER-
,'./
Additional - Su~pplemental Data
ENCLOSURE R2-1
~Dominhon-Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4th Interval 1 st Period Limited Exams Page 69 of 86 Report.No: UT-11-034 Summary # N2.R1.20 0020 Pg. 6 of 7,
Prepared By:. WI. Thomas Date:
9/3012011 Weld Number Thickness
-- Weld=Length....
Weld Width SW-5 1.09"
~1-8"~
2.50 in
. I
-7.
I.
TYPICAL CONTOUR @.90 DEG. AND 270 DEG-AMI DU
,L&
Inft C3 Flnal_
Examination Volume Dimensions - Heiqht
.365" Lenoth 108" Width 2.8" Coverane Summary Required Scans (each has a weighing factor of 100 for complete coverage)
ANGLE UpSt-Ax UpSt-Circ DnSt-Ax DnSt-Circ 45160 100%
0%
45/60/70 100%
100%
Code Coverage.Total 5
Best Effort Coverage (Ma~x 25%),.Total NIA Notes:
- 1) Code Coverage refers to the maximum percentage of the required examination volume that is effectively examined with the qUalrhed examination procedure.
- 2) Best Effort Coverage refers to the required examination volume past the weld centerline that is examined in the axial beam irection with an Appendix VIII demonstrated procedure for single sided coverage.
Site/Unit:
NAPS I
Summary No.:
N2.RI.
Workscope:
I Ultrasonic Indication Report
.2 20.0020 SI Prbcedure:
ER-AA-NDE-UT-801 Procedure Rev.:
2' Work Order No.:
59102346703 Outage No:"
N2R21.,
Report No.'
UT-11.034 S Page" 7 of.
7:
we I~A Search Unit Angle:
60/70 0
Wo Location:
Weld CenterlIne Lon Loction:
Tbt:
PIplng Welds FerdticVessels >2hT (7) Other.
MP Metal Path Wmax Distance From Wo To S.U. At Maximum Response RBR Remaining Back Reflection W1 Distance From Wo At Of Max (ForWard)
L Distance From Datum W2 Distance From Wo At Of Max (Backward) m z
0r-0(n C
-m Indlcaton No.
Of DAC w
MP 80%FSH 1.77' 1.63" 80%FSH 1.45" 2.117" 100%FSH 2.8" 2.47"
-I-I-REF 4.57" AREF 2.2" 4.57" z
C' CD 0 n CD C
-4 Q_
C:) MC (0 X 9 0 X) 0..
cc) 3 w~ (1
- 0) (nl (0 0
UT CalibrationiExamina Site/UniLt NAPS Summary No.:
Workscope:
.1
- .2 N2.RI.20.0020 isi (Iq6).
Procedure:
SProcedure Rev.:
Work Order No.:
ition ER-AA-NDE-UT-1103 Outage No.:
N2'R21
- 1.
Report No.:
UT-1I1O5 59102346793 Page:
1 of
.2 Code:
ASME 2004 Ed.
CatJItem:
R-ANRI.20 Location:
MER-2 Drawing No.:
12050-WMKS-CIIA-4 Descrptoni Pipe to Header System ID:
SHP
- Component ID: 12050.WMKS.O011A-41 32"-SHP-4591 SW-5 (BPL 343)
SizelLdngth:
1.8' 108.0" Thicknese/Dlameter 1.0.95 132.0" Limitations:
None Start Time:
1200.
Finish Timo:
1210 Instrument Settings Search Unit Cal.
Time Date Axial Orientated Search Unit Serial No.:
040186603 Serial No.:
001 304 Checks C
D...
S""
Calibhlion
[ Signal Sweep Depth Manufacturer:
Panametrica Manufacturer:
KBA Initiai Cal.
0950 0912712011 Reflector Amplitude %
Division Model:
EPOCH 4 Linearty:
L-11-018 Size:
0.375' Model:
comp-d Inter. Cal, 1200 09/2712011 0.75" Hole
-80%
3.7 0.75" Delay:
6.347 us Range:
4.000" Freq.:
5.0 Mhz.
Center Freq.:
NIA Inter. Cal.
1210 0912712011
.. 1.0" Hole 50%
s 5.0 1.0'.
M'U Ca/Veh:
0.1265 Inlus Puiser:
Square IeExam Angie:
Squin Ainr.
Cal.
0/A l_______
NA Damping:
400 Ohms Reject:
- 0%
Measured Ange:
0 Mode:
ear Final Cal. 123009272011 MesrdAge 0.3
- ofdeens iopt Rep; Rate:
Auto.
Freq.:
5.0 Mhz.
E~it Point s
Couplant Filter:
3.0-6.0 Mode:
Fullwave Cat. Batch:
07220 Circumferential Orientated Search Unit Config.:
Single Focus:
NIA Voltage:
Max.
Other:
NIA Type:
SobndSafe Calibration, Signal Sweep Shape:
Round.
Contour:
N/A
" Mfg.:
SONOTECH Reflector Amplitude %
Division Depth Wedlge-Style; MSWQC N/A I
Ax. Gain (dB):
2.0 Crc. GainSeah Unit Cable Exan Batch:
07220 N
10 Screen Div. =
2.0 In. of Depth Type S
RG 174 Length* Ca ble Type:
SoundSaeo Tye
____4 0egh Calibration Block Mfg.:
SONOTECH Scan Coverage i_
Cal. Block NO.: ______
21________________Upstream J] DownstijeamE-Scan dB: 28.0 Reference Block ReerecelSlmulator Blockn" Thickness:
3-D*a.:
0 Gain Signal Sweep Depth TCal.knTemp.:
T iemp.Toot: 10 Y
CW [)
W Scan dB: NA Seal NO,:
5,-860 dB Reflector Amplitude % Division Cal. Bilk. Temp.: T5' Temp. Tool:
10O6BlGCY Y' e CS
-~nu lc Exam Surface:
00 rype:
CS Rompua Block N/A Comp. Temp.:
751 Temp. Tool:
10665GCY S
GonSoth Surface Condition:
-Ground Smooth
,'i Recordable IndicatIon(s):
Yes 2 No nI (if Yes, Ref. Attached Ultrasonic Indication Report)
I Comments: Proce'dure ER-AA-NDE-803 sizing techniques were used Rt as a guide to obtain a thru wal dimension of the Percent Of Coverage Obtained s.90%:
NIA Reviewed Previous Data:
Yes Indication to enable IWB13500 evaluation.
Thomas, Wayne L.
09/27/2011 MA Examiner Level N/A Signature Date Site Review S
Other Level NIA Signature Date R.g I nature Date NiA UIT Calibration/Examination mz0 I-0Co m
z C>
C:
t'J
- )
(D M. 0 0
0 W
oi) 3 w.. 01
- 0) Wn (0 0
Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4th Interval 1 st Period Limited Exams Page 72 of 86 ENCLOSURE R2-1 Supplemental Report Report No.:
UT-i 1-055 Page:
2 of 2
Summary No.: N2.R1.20.0020
- Ex~aminer Thomas, WaieL~Level:
lll-PDI Reviewer:
A/4 Date: _____
Examiner.- NIA Level:
NIA Site Review.
,,/,J.,J
- 4. 2 /_Date Other. NIA Level:.
NIA ANII Review.
/e.
Date:
Comments: Flaw evaluation of indication# I from 'UT" report # UT.11-034.
FLAW EVALUATION INDICATION #1 FROM UT REPORT # UT-11-034 Sketch or Photo:
INDICATION # 1 LMAX =50",. S
-MEASURED T = 1.15" MEASURED ANGLE: 60° LENGTH:
1.125" 2a: 0.07 IND IS SUBSURFACE-a : 0.035 / 1.125 =.03 = a/I S =1.15 -. 83 =0.32
.03 - aspect ratio WEEP = 4 DIV. REMAINING UGAMENT DOES NOT APPLY:
MINIMUM MAXIMUM TOTAL DEPTH 0.83" 0.070" _
a t
.035 / 1.15 =..030 x 100 = 3% actual th.ru wall ACTUAL = 3%
ALLOW=
10.8%
INDICATION # 1 IS ACCEPTABLE PER ASME SECTION XI TABLE IWB-3514-1.
NOTE: TH E MOST CONSERVATIVE % WAS USED. NO' UNEAR INTERPOLATION WAS REQUIRED. NO'SIGNIFICANT CHANGE NOTED IN LENGTH OR AMPLITUDE SINCE THE PREVIOUS TWO EXAMS IN n989 OR 2002.
INDICATION PRESENCE WAS VERIFIED WITH 0 DEGREE PROBE.
Additional - Supplemental Data
ENCL RAn n~
SitelUnit:
/
2 Summary No.;
N2.R1.20.0020, Workscope:
AUG V
Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4th Interval 1st Period Limited Exams OSURE R2-1 Page 73 of 86 etic Particle Examination Procedure:
ER-AA-NDE-MT-200 Outage No.:
N2R21 Procedure Rev.: -
- 4.
Report-No.:
MT-1 1-003 Work OrderNo.:
59102346T93 Page:
1 of I
Code:
ASME-2004 Ed.
Cat.item:
RA/1R1.20 Location:
MER-2 Drawing No.:
12050-WMKS-01OIA-4
==
Description:==
Pipe to Header System ID:..
.SHP=...
ComponentiD:. 12050-WMKS-0101A-4 I32"-SHP-459 ISW-5 (BPL 343)
MatiThickness:
C/S 11.25" Limitations:
None Light Meter Mfg.:
NIA Serial Temp. Tool Mfg.:.
NA
-M Serial Resolution:.
0.044" Character Card Lift Block Serial No.:
MT-34 Lo/Wo Location:
NIA Magnetic Particle Material Brarrd:
MAGNAFLUX Wet []
Type:
BA Red Dry [
Batch No.:
09F056 Fluorescent E
- Equipment:
PARKER Head Shot N/A Amperes Adj. Spacing W
- 3.0-8.0 Inches Prods. Spacing MI
- N/A inches.
No.:
NIA I No.:
NIA Illumination:
NIA Surface Temp.:
,N/A F
Ground Smooth Surface Condition:
Field Orientation:
0/90' Field Orientation
)
Mixed:..
Yes E]
Applied By:
Dusting [
No W Spraying D With:
N/A.
Flooding El Serial No.:'
17868 Fixed Spacing Dl AC DCD-Encircling Coils E
, NIA Turns Current (machine setfing)
.-l NIA Amperes Indication Loc Loc Diameter Length Type Remarks No.
L W
R/L NIA Comments:
Character Card# DOM-2009-0300.
Results:
Accept R Reject []
Eval Ml Percent-Of Coverage Obtained > 90%:
Yes Reviewed.Previous Data:
N/A Exam Time:
1300-1328 Examiner Level II Signature Date Reviewer-I Date Espana, Leonel 09/2412011 Examiner Level N/A.
ignature Date >4e Review Date Other Level 'NIA Signature CIate ANIl:Review Signature Date I MIAg nAtAcPartcleSxgmiatio Magnetic Particle Exmination
UT Cal ibratlon/txaminhttion
- Site/Unit Summary No.:
Workscope:
NAPS "./
2 N2.111.20.0039 Is[
Procedtre:
ER-AANDE-UT-802 Procedure Rev.:
I Work Order No.:
59102346793 Outage No.:
N2R21 Report No.:
UT-11.028 Page:
1 of-6.
Code:
ASME 2004 Ed.
Cat./item:
R-AIR1.20 Location:
A Loop Drawing No.:
.12050-WMKS-0103AG
==
Description:==
45 degree elbow to branch iornection System ID:
RC Component ID: 12050-WMKS-0103AGI6-RC-416/4 Size/Length:
1.30" 120.8" Tilcknrrss/Dlamete.
0.710'16.0" Limitations:
Single side exam due.to configuration.
Start Time:
157 T Finish Time:
1525 Instrument Settinge Search Unit Cal.
Time Date Axial Odrletated Search Unit Serial No.:
040182503 Serial No.:
D.OVJBX*
Checks Calibration Signal Sweep Sound'Path Manufacturer:
Panametrics Manufacturer:
KBA
- iUal Cel..0935 0/2112011 Reflector Amplitude %
Division Model:
EPOCH 4 Linearity:
L-08-006 Size:
0.37.*"
Model:
Coimp-a Inter. Cal.
1453 09/21/20tl 1.0' Notch
.180%
.7.0 1.423 D elay:
5.605 iJ%
R ange:
2.040" Fre e.: 2.25 M hz.
C enter NI._Ine A_. AN IA
- Inter.
- Cal, N/A M' Cal/el:
0.1234 inips Pulser:
Square Exam Angle; 45s Squint Angle:
N/A I
Ca,.,
Dam ping:
400 Ohm s Reject:
0%
F alC l.
172 9 2 / 0 1*
Dampig:
40 Ohms Rejec:
0/.
Measured Angle:. 45' Mode:
Shear172____
Rep. Rate:
Auto.
Freq.:
2.0 Mhz..
Exit Point:
0.30"
- of Elements:
.'Couplant Filter:
0.8 -3.0 Mhz Mode:
Fullwave Cal. Batch:
07220 Circumferential Orientated Search Unit Voltge:
Max Oter:
NIA Config.:
Single Focus:
NIA Routaen:
Ma.ocush NIA Ty.-pe SoundSafe lCalibration:
Signal Sweep Shap6e:
Round Contour Mg.:
/ONOTECH Reflector Amplitude %
Division Sound Path WedgeStyle:
.. MSWQC Ax. Gain (dB):
0.2 Circ. Gain (dB):
- i.
S c
iaExam Batch:
07220.NA.
- . Search Unit Cable 10 Screen v
2.040 In. of Sound Path Type:
SoundSefe a
Type' RG 174 Length:
G' No. Conn.: 0 Mfg.:
SONOTECH Calibration BlockScanCerg-.
"'.i Scan Coverage:
Cal. Block No.:
10876 Refereri'celSlmulator 6lock CTh.iBlckness: N 25' M.
F t Upstream W Downstream El Scan dB: 26.2 Reference Block Gefern MeSImulat or So u P
Thckes: 2.5" De.
Fa 2.2.Gain tSignal Sweep SudPt TCal.knTemp.:
TO2" T em.Tool:CWR CCW(')
Scan dB:'20.2 Senial.No.:
05-.535 dC Reflector Amplitude %
Div slon Cal. Blk. Temp.: TO" Temp. Tool:
07...i Exam Surface:
OD1 Type:
SS Rompus Block 8.2 FSDH 20%
5.1 1.035" Comp. Temp.;
78" Temp. Tool; 07 5.L Surface Condition:
Contour Ground NIA Recordable Indication(s):
Yes []
No (]
(If Yes, Ref. Attached Ultrasonic Indication Report.)
Results:
Accept ]
Reject []
Goom-Comments: No Axialexams were performed on the Downstream side of thle weld.
Percent Of Coverage Obtained > 90%:
No Revlewed Previous Data:
yeo Examiner Le
.PDI Signature Date Reviewer "u
Date Knott, Briane 09121121 JJ.L
- 'Z, Examiner i
Signature Date Site Review Signa ture
,9 Date Zinr rn D...
.0912112011 Other Level NIA U
Signature Date ANI' Review -Sl*gnature Date NIA UT Calibratfon/Examination M
z 0
I-0Cn C
C/)
C:
- 2 C11
_U 0
(
4 CI 1 ow 0c)3 w c 0)(n 0
UT Calibration/Examination
-14 Site/Unit:
Summary No.:
Workscope:
/
.2.
Procedure:
ER-AA-NDE-UT-802 N2.RI.20.0039 Procedure Rev.:
Work Order No.:
1 59102346793 Outage No.:
.N2R21 Report No.:
UT-i 1-028 Page:
2 of 8
ISI..
Code:
ASME 2004 Ed.
Cat./Item:
R-AIRi.20 Location:
A Loop Drawing NO.:
12050-WMKS-0103AO
==
Description:==
45 degree elbow to branch connection System ID:
RC CorhponentID:.12050.WMKS-0103AG.16-RC-41614 "Size/Length:
1.30" 120.8".
Tlickness/Diameter:
0.718" 16.0" Limitations:
Single side exam due to confliguration.
Start Time:
1549..
Finish Time:
1556.
Instrument Settings Search Unit Cal.
Time Date Axial Orientated Search Unit Sertal No.:
040182503 Sedal No.:
01CLN0 Checks
-Calibration SIgnal Sweep Sound Path Manufacturer.
Panametrics Manufacturer:
KBA Initial Cal.
0946 0912112011 Reliector Ampglitude %
Division Model:
EPOCH 4 Linearity:
Size:
0.375" Model:
Cm-G inter. Cal.
1526 0912112011 10" Notch 80%
7.0 1.505" Inter. Cal.
N/A Delay:
7.195 pa Range:-
2.500" Freq.:. 2.25 Mhz.
Center Freq.:
N/A n
. NIA M'tt CalNel:
0.1265 InMps Pulser:
Square Exam.Angle:
60" Squint Angle:
NIA inter. Cal.
N/A Damping:
400 Ohms Reject; 0%
Measuredl Angle:
W0° Mode; Final Cal.
.1723 09121/2011*
Rep. Rate:
Auto.
F req;:
2.0 Mhz.
Exit PolnL 0.25"
- of Elements:
1 Couplant filter:
0.8-3.0 Mhz Mode:
Fullwave Cal. Batch:
07220 Circumferential Orientated Search Unit liier
________Config.:
.Singlie
. Focus:
NIA., Tyo on~f aIraon Snl Swe Sud Voltage:
MaxType:
SoundSae Calibraonr Sgna sweep Shape:
Round Contour:
NIA Mfg.:
SONOrECH Reflector Amplitude %
Division Wedge Style:
MSWQC '
NIA Ax. Gain (dB):
24.8 Circ. Gain (dB):
N/A Search Unit Cable EWlam Batch:
07220 10 Screen Div. =
2.580 In. of Sound Path Type:
RG 174 Length:
6' No. Conn.: 0 Type:
SoundSafe Mfg..
SONOT ECH Calibration Block Scan Coverage Cal. Block No.:
10876 Upstream [] Downstream [] Scan dB: 30.8 Reference Block ReferenveiSimutator Block Gain 1:Signal Sweep Sound Path Thickness:
2.25" DIe.:
Fiat*
cw* ~
- .CCW[Z Scan dO: 30.8 Sedal No.:
05-635 dB Reflector An~plltude % 'Divialon Cal. 81k. Temp.: T70 Temp. Tool:
- 07 Exam Surface:
00 Type:
OS Rompus Biock 24.8 FSDH
( 54%
5.6 1.450" Camp. Temp.:
76" Temp. Tool:
07 Surface Condition:
Contour Ground N/A Recordable Indlcation(s):
Yes 0 No 2 (if Yes, Ref. Attached Ultrasonic Indication Report.,
Results:
Accept [
Reject El Geom []
- Comments: Effective coverage using the 60* serach unit has been verified by the presence of the weld rodt response Percent Of Coverage Obtained > 90%:
No Reviewed Previous Data:
Yes during the required scans! No Ax. Scans on the DNST Examiner Le Signature Date Reviewer S
Dale Knott, Brian D.
00/21(2011 iALL.
Examiner L--.l-eel Signature Date Site Review
- 8.
ature D~ite Zoliner. Brian D092101
ýl i
Other Level Ni A on Signature Date ANII Review Signature Dat LIT Calibration[Examrniatlon m
Z 0
r-0 C/
0-M n 0) 3u
- 0) U) 0 C-
UT Calibration/Examination Xooww S1te/Unli:
Summery No.:
Workscope:
NAPS I
Procedure:
ER-AA-NDE-UT402
- N2.R1.20.0039
'SI.
Procedure Rev.;
Work Order No.:
1 59102346793 Outage No.:
N2R21 Report No.:-
UT-11-028 Page:
3.
of.
6 Code:
ASME 2004 Ed:
atJIltern:
R-A/R1,20
. Location:
L A Loop Drawing NO.:
I2050-WMK-0103AG
==
Description:==
. 45 degree elbow to branch connection System ID:
RC Component ID: 12050-WMKS-O103AG 16-RC-41614 Size/Length:
1.30" 1 208" Thickness/blameter 0.718" 16.0" Limitations:
Single side exam due to configuration.
Start Time:
155I Finish Time:
1604 Instrument SettCngs Search Unit' Col.
Time Date Axial Orientated Search Unit Serial No.:
040182503 Serial No.:.
OOVBBK
. Checks Calibration Signal Sweep Sound Path Manufacturer.
Panametrics Manufacturer:
KBA Initial Cal.R 1002 0e121/201 Rflector Ampiitude %
Division.
Model:
EPOCH 4 Linearity:
L-11-015 Size:
' 0.375".
Model:
. Comp-G Inter. Cal.
1557 09/2112011 1.0; Notch 7.0 1080" Delary:
8.495 i's Range:
4A00" Freq.,
2.25 Mh.Cne.rFO:
NA Inter. Cal.
N/A N/A Inter. CalM N.A 7.A t
MWU CalNe:
0.1290 Inips Pulser:
Square Exam Angle:.
7&" Squint Angle:
N/A Final cal.
1728 09A2112011
.Damping:
400Ohms Reject 0%
Measured Angle:.
71, Mode:
Shear Rep. Rate:
Auto.
Freq.:.
2.0 Mhx.
Exit Point 0.35"
- of Elements:
Couplant I_
Filler:
0.9 - 3.0 Mhz Mode:
Futiwave Confg.:
CaL Batch:
220 ircumfrentI Orientated Search Unit Voltage:
Max.
Other:
N/A Round NA Tlp:
SoundSafe Calibration Signal Sweep Votg:Ohe: NA Shape:
RonM Contour:
fg.:
SONOTECH Reflector AmplItude %
Division Sound Path Wedge Style:.
MSWQC NIA Ax. Gain (dB):
30.4 Circ. Gain (dB):
NIA ExaUm Batch:
07220 Search Unit Cable 10 Screen Div.
4400 in. of Sound Path.
Type: - RG 174-Length:
6' No. Conn.: 0 Type:
S4undSsfe Mfg.:
.SONOTECH Calibration Block Scan Coverage '
M Cal. Block No.:
1087i Upstreem.W] DownstNiatET Scan d8: 36.4 Reference Block Reference/SImulator Block Thickness:
2.25a Die.:
Flat Gain ISIgnal Sweep Sounr-Palh Thinss
_________Flat CW EJ CCWr Scan dB:
N/A Serial No.:
05-6835 dB Reflector Aný litude % Division Cal. BIk. Temp.: 70.
Temp. Toot:
07 Exam Surface:
OD Type:
35 Rompue Block 25.9 NSDH 80%
2.2 0.980" Comp. Temp.:
- 78.
Temp. Tool:
07 Surface Condition:
Contour Ground NIA Recordable Indication(s):
Yes a]
No g (If Yes, Ref. Attached Ultrasonic Indication Reporti) *-
Results:
Accept R)
Reject Q Geom []
E..
Commenti:
None Percent Of Coverage Obtained > 90%:
No Rleviwed i1revious Date:
Yes.
Examiner La4 I-PDI Signature Date Reviewer Si~gn Date Knott, Brian D.
iA6~.
9)1/211i~l t4L.
qzq.* r Examiner
'.-.Ie l
Signature Date Site Review
,Signature Oate Zollneir, Brian D 09121/2011D I eI
-(C-*
/..
Other Level NIA Signature Date ANII Review Signaturet Date UT Calibration/Examination I-0U')
C:
X Ci)
- 3 (D
03 0 U) 0 (D
1J-D 03 Z3 Z
-3 0.
- 0) Mn~-
00 aD ) W.1b
- 0) (n (00C
Site/Unit Summary No.:
Workscope:
UT Calibration/Examination NAPS 2.
N2.R1.20.0039 Procedure:
ER-AA-NDE-UT-802 Procedure Rev.:
I Work Order No.:
59102346793 Outage No.:
N2R21 Report No.:
UT.11.028 Page:
4 of 6
I18 Code::
ASME 2004 Ed.
Cat./item:
R-A/R1.20 Location:
A Loop Drawing No.:
12050-WMK941193AG
==
Description:==
45 degree elbow to branch connection System 10:
RC I
Component ID; 12050-WMKS-0103AG I B-RC-41614
$IzeiLength:
1.30".1 20.X" Thicknessi.Dlameter.
0.718" 16.0" Limitations:
Single side exam due to configuration-Start Time:
1608.
Finish Time' 1612
.nstrument Settings Search Unit Cal.
Time Date Axial Orientated Search Unit Sertal No.:
040182503" Serial-No.:
06-108 Checks*
Calibration Srgnal Sw.ep' Sourd Path Manufacturer:
PanametrIcs Manufacturer:,
RTD Initial Cal.
1041 0912112011 Reflector Amplitude %
Division Model:
EPOCH 4 Linearity:,.
L-11-015 Size:
2(BX14)
Model:
TRL2-AUST Inter. Cal.
1605 09/21/2011 1.0" SDH 8 '0%
7.0 1.981" Delay:
9.085 pS Range:
2.8307 Freq.:
2.0 Mhz.
Center Freq.:
. NIA Mar. Cal.
1 NIA N/A Inter. Cal. -
NIA M'II Ca~eh:
0.2331 Inlps Pulsar:
Square Exam Angle:
e0° Squint Angle:
3" F
Cai.
1730
-9__1/__11__
Dampng: 400 hms Rejet:
I-I Final Cal.
17IT30 D9l211120711 Damping:
400 Ohms Reject:
,0%.
Measured Angle:
61" Mode:. Longitudinal
" Coupant i
Rep. Rate:
Auto.
Freq.:
2.0 Mhz.
Exit Point:*
0.3"
- of Elements 2
Colant Filter:
0.8 -3.0 Mhz Mode:
Fullwave
. D-SBS Cal. Batch:
07220 Circumferential Orientated Search Unit Voltage:
Max.
OtherType:
SoundSafe Calibraon Signal Sweep' S'"
Shape!
Retangulhr Contour:
FLAT Reflector oundPath Mfg.:
SONOTIECH Ampiitude %
Division Wedge Style:
Integiral NIA Ax, Gain (dB):
38.3 CIrc. Gain (dB):
N/A Search Unit Cable Exam. Batch:
07220
.Type:
SoundSafe 10 Screen Div,=
2.830 In. of Sound Path Type:
RG 174 Length:
6' No. Conn.:.O T*.i SOundaeH Calibration Block Scan Coverage Cal. Block No.:
21588 Upstream E] DoWnstream
-6. Scan dB: 38.3 Reference Block
, ReferencelSImuiator Block Gain Signal Swe oudPt Thickness:
3" Dia.:
Flat CW E]
CCWF] ScandB:
NIA Sefial No.:
05.6535 dB Reflector Amplitude%
Dvison Cal. Blk. Temp.: 700 Temp. Tool:
07 Exam Surfece
'OD Type:
$8 Rompus Block 32.7 FSDH 1 80%
5.4 1.523" Comp. Temp.:
78" Temp. Tool:
07 r
Sdrfece' Condition:
Contour Glrdt.u nd ENIA Recordable Indication(s):
Yes E]
. No 2]
(If Yes, Ref. Attached Ultrasonic Indication Report.)
Results:
Accept R)
Reject E]
Geom ] E Comments: Utilized for cbverage on nozzle aide of weld.
Percent Of Coverage Obtained 9
80%:
No Reviewed Previous Data:
Yes Examiner LevV i-I-PDI Signature Date Reviewer Signa turg Date Knott. Brian D.
.09121/2011 J
o
.7..
Examiner Signature Date Site Review Signature,..
Date Zailner. Brian D "0912112011 Olher Level N/A Signature Date. ANiReview,.
Signature a
UIAra tio*
ixamina:on...7 m
0 0
C:
X CD CD 0
0 0 k CO)
(DI
- 0) (n (D00 V
UT Callbraf/on/Examlnatbon
MIML 3FAU"hýr ENCLOSURE R2-2 Supplemental Rep Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4 th Interval 1 st Period Limited Exams Page 78 of 86 ortt Report No.:
UT-i 1-028 Page:
5 "of 6
Summary No.: N2.R1.20.0039' Examiner Knot, BrlanD.
Examiner: Zollner, BrIan D Olber N* A Level: lI-PD!
Revievr j-,L D
A Date: !2.2q I I Level. I11-P01 :Shte Rview J
Date':it/
Level:
N/A :ANII Review.
Date:
Comments:
Sketch or Photo:
ý7LBC0VI.
SVL, W.
rqoA 5.
'-4..
Norz.LE.
~,,
r7.:
- /
~-
I. O.¶3~
Wc~W: 1.318
~.
~j375b
- 3. b.UO" 84
- ~*
~5Ii
~.
~.
'1.~.'t86 Additional - Supplemeontal Data
ENCLOSURE R2-2 S9D46minion-Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4th Interval 1st Period Limited Exams Page 79 of 86 Report No: UT-1 1-028 Summary # N2.R1.20.0039 Pg. 6 of 6
Prepared By: W.L. Thomas Date:
9/24/2011.
Weld Number Thickness.
-8~.32!.*-~
20.8" FLOW 45 70 60L
/
EL,
'EXAMINED. 100% REQUIRED VOLUME US SIDE EXAMINED.06 SQ. 1N..OF THE REQUIRED.32 SQ IN. VOLUME
.06'/.32 =.187 X 1o0
= 1.9% BEST EFFORT DS.SIDE NO EXAM.26 SQ IN. DS SIDE AXIAL DIRECTION.26 /1.32 = 81% NO EXAM ANII _j&Z Date4$
WInftaJ Fine) 2-I-18-CT Examination Volume Dimensions - Height e.277"
.Length 20.8" Width 2.3" Coverage Summary Required Scans (each has a weighing factor of 100 for complete coverage)
ANGLE UpSt-Ax UpSt-Circ
.DnSt-Ax.
DnSt-Circ 46/60/70 100%
100%
-100%
60L
- 19%
Code Coverage Total
[
75%
- Best Effort Coverage (Max 25%) Total 5%
Notes:
- 1) Code Coverage refers to the maximum percentage of the required examination volume that is effectively examined with the qualified examination procedure.
- 2) Best Effort Coverage refers to the required examination volume past the weld centedine that is examined in the axial beam direction with an Appendix VIIl demonstrated procedure for single sided coverage.
UT Calibration/Examination
ýXftominio.
Site/Unit:
Summary No.:
Workscope:
NAPS 1
2 N2.RI.20.0811B
'SI Procedure:
Procedure Rev.:
Work Order No.:
ER-AA-NDE-UT-802 2
59102532605/NDER13-079 Outage No.:
N2R22 Report No.:
UT-13-025 Page:
1 of 8
Code:
2004 Edition CatJltem.
R-A/R1.20 Location:
PZR 262 Drawing No.:
12050-WMKS-OIIIW
==
Description:==
Valve to Elbow System ID:
CH Component ID: 12050-WMKS-0111W I 3-CH-814 16A SizelLength:
1.2" 1 13" Thlckness/Diameter:
.620" 13" Limitations:
Limitations due to conflg.
Start Time:
10:25 Finish Time:
10:33 Instrument Settings Search Unit Cal.
Time Date Axial Orientated Search Unit Serial No.:
0401086103 Serial No.:
01CWK4 Checks Manufacturer:
PanametrIcs Manufacturer:
KBA Initial Cal.
07:00 411812013 Reflector Amplitude %
Division Model:
EPOCH 4 Linearity:
L-13-011 Size:
0.25" Model:
Comp-G Inter. Cal. 10:25 4/1812013 Notch so__._1.39
______1.0" Nth 80 8.0 1.399 Delay:
4.483 Range:
1.75" Freq.:
2.25 MHZ Center Freq.:
N/A Inter. Cal.
10:33 4/1812013 NIA MWi CaJVel:
.1232 Pulser:
Square Exam Ange:
4 Squinl Angl:
NA Iner. Cal.
NIA Ea AFinieCal.
4512:01 4A18/2013 Damping:
40)DO Reject:
0%
Measured Angle:
451 Mode:
Shear Final Cl12 141B Rep. Rate:
Auto Freq.:
2.0 Mhz i
Couplant Exit Point
.175.
- of Elements:
I Filter:
.8-3.0 Mode:
fullwave Cal. Batch:
07220 Circumferential Orientated Search Unit Voltage:
Max Other:
NIA Config.:
Single Focus:
NIA Type:
SOOUndSaf Calibration Signal Sws p o
Shape:
Round Contour:
N/A Tye onDf airto inl Siwelpn Sound Path, Shpe oud Cotur NA Mfg.:
SONOTECH Reflector Amplitude %
Division SudPt Ax. Gain (dB):
13.8 Circ. Gain (dB):
N/A Wedge Style:
MSWQC N/A Batch:
_7_20NIA 10 Screen Dlv.
1.t,75 In. of Sound Path Search Unit Cable Exeim Batch:
07220 Type; RG-174 Length:
6' No. Conn.:
0 Type:.
SoundSafe Calibration Block San Mfg.:
SONOTECH Cal. Block No.
10873 Upstream.E] Downslrear6 Scan dBi 25.8 Reference/Simulator Block Thickness 2.25" Dia.:
0 Gain Signal Sweep Sound Path CW ]
CCW*J Scan dB: 25.0 Serial No.:
05-6535 dB I Reflector Amplitude %
Division Cal. Bok. Temp. 74.
Temp. Tool:
1076BGCY Cutmp. Temp.
79" Temp. Tool:
tD768GCY Exam Surface:
COD Type:
88 Roropus Block 25.81.7 SDH' 75 6.0 1.045 Surface Condition:
Contour Ground N/A Recordable Indication(s):
Yes -
No [
(If Yes, Ref. Attached Ultrasonic Indication Report.
Results:
NRI L_
RI E-Geom n
Comments: Limited Scan 2"In the introdose of elbow Ax and Cir.acans Percent Of Coverage Obtained > 90%:
No Reviewed Previous Data:
NIA Examiner Levely 11 PD Signature Date Reviewer Date Currao, Jeffrey T 411812013 WJL--IQ1j q.Z11 3 Examiner Lev6l.
Signature Date Site Review 1
Sinatur Dale Other Level NIA Signature Date
'ANIIA eVieW.
i1ptur Date N/A I
M z0I-0Cn C:
z C,,
CD n
-0 (D
0 CD UDW 0
CD M n -~
0 X
- 0) (n (D00 UI L, llraaon:xamlnallon
- Dominion Site/Unit:
Summary No,:
Workscope:
/
2 N2.R1.20.011 B 1SI UT Calibration/Examination Procedure:
Procedure Rev.:
Work Order No.:
591 ER-AA-NDE-UT-802 2
102532605/NDER13-079 Outage No.:
N2R22 Report No.:
UT-13-025 Page:
2 of 6
Code:
2004 Edition CatJItem:
R-AlR1.20 Location:
PZR 262 Drawing No.:
12050-WMK8-0111W
==
Description:==
Valve to Elbow System ID:
CH Component ID: 12050-WMKS-01 11W I 3-CH-8141 6A Size/Length:
1.2" / 13" Thickness/Dlameter:
.620" 1 3 Limitations:
Limitations due to config.
Start Time; 10:34 Finish Time:
10:40 Instrurnent Settings Search Unit Cal.
Time Date Axial Orientated Search Unit Serial No.:
040186603 Serial No.:
01CWK3 Checks Calibration Signaa sweep Sound Path Manufacturer:
Panametrics Manufacturer:
KBA Initial Cal. 07:01 4118/2013 Reflector Amplitude %
Division Model:
EPOCH 4 Linearity; L-13-011 Size:
0.25" Model:
Comp-G Inter. Cal.
10:34 411012013 1.0" notch 60 6.8 1.706" Delay-5,455 Range:
2.5" Freq.:
2.25 MHZ Center Freq.:
NIA Inter. Cal, 10:40 411812013 N/A IInter. Cat. INIA I____
M't CallVal:
.1232 Pulser:
Square Exam Angle:
s0o Squint Angle:
N/A Inter, Cal. 1 0
1 Final Cal. 12:02 4/t812013 Damping:
40017 Reject:
0%
Measured Angle:
fl0l Mode:
Shear Rep. Rate:
Auto Freq.:
2.0 Mhz Exit Point
.2"
- of Elements:
I Couplant Filter:
.3.0 Mode:
Shear sA Cal. Batch:
07220 Circumferential Orientated Search Unit Voltage:
Max Other MIAR ContIou N/A Type:
SoundSafe Calibrailon Signal Sweep Sound Path Shape:
Round Contour NIA Mfg.:
SONOTECH Reflector Amplitude %
Division Wedge Style:
MSWQC NA Ax. Gain (dB):
30.3 Circ, Gain (dB);
NIA Se; UnitC Exam Batch:
07220 Search Unit Cable 10 Screen Div. =
2.5 in. of Sound Path Type:
RG-174 Length:
6' No. Conn.: 0 Type:
SoundSafe Calibration Block Scan Coverageg:
SONOTECH Cal. Block No.
10873 Upstreamrn Downstreamr-ScandB: 36.3 Raference Block Reference/Sinmulator Block Thickness 2.25" Die.:
0 CW SScandB:
36.3 Serial No.:
056535 Gain Signal Swe9 p Sound Path C:CW
____-___53____
dB Reflector Amplitude % Division Cal. B1k. Temp.
740 Temp. Tool:
1076BGCY Exam Surface; OD Type:
SS Rompus Block 30.3
.7 SDH 45 6.0 1.484" Camp; Temp.
79' Temp. Tool; 1076BGCY Surface Condition:
Contour Ground NIA Recordable Indication(s):
Yes []
No (JIf Yes. Ref. Attached Ultrasonic Indication Report.)
Results:
NRI []
RI E Geom []
Comments:
Limited scan in intradose 2' both Ax and Cir Scan.
Effective coverage using the 600 search unit has been Percent Of Coverage Obtained > 90%:
No Reviewed Previous Data:
NIA verified by the presence of the weld root response Examiner Level
-D
)SIgnatura.
Date Reviewer SignlI~,
Date Currao, Jeffrey,T 4118/2013 GA.Lj17jnZ-if.Y 2
Examiner Level N/A Signature Date Site Review Si atu ate NIA 4111112013 g
ý/ 3 Other Level N/A Signature Date ANI eviewignaluJn Date UT Callbratlon/Examlnation M
0r-0 Cl, C
C/)
0)
C)D (0
0 Uz 0)(D CD 0
UT Calibration/Examination Doninton Site/Unit:
Summary No.:
Workacope; NAPS 1
2 N2.RI.20. 0818 ISI Procedure:
Procedure Rev.:
ER.AA-NDE-UT-802 2
Outage No.:
N2R22 Report No.:
UT-43-025 Page:
3 of 6
Work Order No.:
59102532605INDER13-079 Code:
2004 Edition Cat./Item:
R-A/R1.20
==
Description:==
Valve to Elbow Location:
PZR 262 Drawing No.:
System ID:
CH 12050-WMKS-0111W 2004 Edition Component ID; 12050-WMKS-D1IIW I 3-CH-8141 6A Limitations:
Limited Due to Conflig.
SizeiLength:
1.2" 113" Thickness/Diameter:
.620" 13" Start Time:
10:41 Finish Time:
10:47 Instrument Settings Search Unit Cal.
Time Date Serial No.:
040186603 Serial No.:
01CWK2 Checks Manufacturer:
Panametrics Manufacturer:
KBA Initial Cal. 07:03 4/1/2013 Model:
EPOCH 4 Linearity.
L-13-011 Size:
0.25" Model:
Comp-G intar. Cal.
10:41 411812013 Delay:
7.008 Range:
3.1" Freq.:
2.25 MIZ Center Freq.:
N/A Inter. Cal.
10:47 411812013 Fre.:2.5 HZ Cete Feq:
IA Inter. Cal.,
NIA._____
M'tl CalNel:
.1232 Pulser:
Square Exam Angle:
70' Squint Angle:
NIA a
2 1
Damping:
40011 Reject:
0%
Measured Anglo:
67' Mode:
Shear 4
Rep. Rate:
Aulo Freq.:
2.0 Exit Point
.4"
- of Elements: Single Couplant Filter:
.8-3.0 Mode:
Fullwave Conflg.!
Single Focus:
N-A Cal. Batch:
07220 Voltage:
Max Other:
NIA Shape:
Round Contour:
NIA Type:
SoundSafe Mfg.:
SONOTECH Wedge Style:
MSWOC Ax. Gain (dB):
39.4 Circ. Gain (dB):
NIA Exam Batch:
07220 Search Unit Cable 10 Screen Div. =
3.1 In. of Sound Path Type:
RG-174 Length:
8' No. Conn.:
- 0.
Type:
SoundSafe Mfg-:
SONOTECH Calibration Block Scan Coverage Cal. Block No.
'10873 Upstream E] Downstreamov Scan dB: 39.4 Reference Block Thickness 2.25" Die.;
0 CW F]
CCW[] Scan dB:
N/A Serial No.:
05-6535 Cal. 131k. Temp.
74 Temp. Tool:
176BGY-Exam Surface:
OD Type:
88 Rompus Block Camp. Temp.
79' Temp. Tool:
1076BGCY Surface Condition:
Contour Ground Recordabla Indication(a):.
Yes [
No D (If Yes, Ref; Attached Ultrasonic Indication Report.)
Results:
NRI U RI Geom M*
("nrlnrnnf, H-.
Axial Orientated Search Unit Calibration Signal Sweep Sound Path Reflector Amplitude %
Division 1.0" Notch 80 8.3 2.569" N/A Circumferential Orientated Search Unit Calibration Signal Sweep Reflector Amplitude %
Division Sound Pati NIA Refere ncelSimulator Block Gain I Signal I SweepS dB Reflector Amplitude % Division Sound Path 27.4 I.3"SDH 40 I
2.8
.859" NIA m
0 CA a
z (n
K)
CD Z/
0)U 0)
L--
No Reviewed Previous Dlats:
- 1 lllll*llL*l IIII]1ited for 2" In the Intradose for the Ax Scan.
Percent Of Coverage Obtained > 90%;
NIA Examiner Leve._[- Di Signature Date Reviewer t
Date Currao, Jeffrey T
/
41181013 Examiner LAWl -N*A Signature Date Site Review 9,4'3SI*,*r Is/t NIA 4118,2013
ý1J Other Level NIA Signature Date ANY Review "Si6 Af~nure Data NIA r__
UT Callbratlon/Examinaelon
UT CalibrationlExamination 20Dvarin ia" SlitaUnit:
Summary No.:
Workscope:
/
2 N2.R1.20.08118 is]
Procedure; Procedure RAy.:
Work Order No,:
ER-AA-NDE-UT-802 2
591025326051NDERI 3-079 Outage No.:
N2R22 Report No.:
UT-I3-025 Page; 4
of 6
Code:
2004 Edition Cat/Ilem:
R-AIR1.20 Location:
PZR 262 Drawing No.:
12050-WMKS-0111W
==
Description:==
Valve to Elbow System ID:
CH Component ID: 12050-WMKS-0111W I 3-CH-814B 6A Size/Length:
1.2" 113" Thickneas/Dlameter:
.620" 13" Limitations:
Limited due to Config.
Start Time:
10:48 Finish Time:
10:53 lnstrurrent.Settings Search Unit'
.Cal. Time Date Axial Orientated Search Unit Serial No.:
040186603 Serial No.:
22K0-10001 Checks,i ogWS d
Manufacturer:
Psnametrics Manufacturer:
Sigma initial cal.
-704 41132013 Calibration Signal %
Sweep Sound Path 4/182013 Reflector Amplitude Division Model:
EPOCH 4 Linearity:
L-13-011 Size; 2(14x8)
Model:
SDA2 Inter. al, 10:48 41=013
.75" DH
.0 1.496 Delay:
5.855 Range; 2.5" Freq.:
2.0 MHZ Center Freq.:
1.990 I nter. Cal. 10:53 4/1812013 N/A Si nter.,Cal.
N/A_____
M'il Celee:
.2488 Pulser.
Square Exam Angle:
60° Squint Angle:
NIA Ine._a._I Final Cal. 12:04 4/1812013 Damping:
4000 Reject 0%
Measured Angle:
- 60.
Mode; Longitudinal""'
Rep. Rate:
Auto Preq.:
2.0 Exit Point 0.375
- of Elements:
2 Couplant I
i Exit Point-3 Mode:
Fullwave nts:
Cal. Batch:
07220 Circumferential Orientated Search Unit Filter:
.8-3-0 Mode; Fullwav Config.
O.5-BS Focus:
FD.54' VIType:
Soundae Calbration Signal Sweep Ath Votg:
M.
te:
NA Shape:
Rectangular Contour:
-RA2.0" lvf.
OOEHReflector Amplitude %
Divsion Ac. Gain (dB):
37.3 Circ. Gain (dB):
N/A Se:
Integal Exam Batch:
07220 10 Screen Div. -
2.5 in, of Sound Path Type:
RG-174 Length:
6' No. Conn.: 0 Type:
SoundSafe
- ----Mfg.:
SONOTECH Calibration Block Scan Coverage Cal, Block No.
26446 Upstream D
Downstream E Scan dB: 37.3 Reference Block Reference/Simulator Block Thickness 3.0905" Dia.:
4.5 CW CCW--J Scan dB: N/A Serial No.:
26446 Gain Signal Sweep Sound Path Li dO Reflector Amplitude % Division Cal. Bik. Temp.
- 72.
Temp. Toot:
1076BGCY Exam Surface:
OD Type: )!a Radius Cat*,k (1,W:'
3
.75"SDH 80 6.0 1.496"'
C_.7Surface Condin:
Contour Ground N'A Recordable Indication(s):
Yes El No L (If Yes, Ref. Attached Ultrasonic Indication Report.)
Results:
NRI..O RI F1 Geom 1 Comments:
Limited 4" in Intradose of Elbow.
Percent Of Coverage Obtained > 90%:
No Reviewed Previous Data:
N/A Examiner Leve Signature Date Reviewer Signature Da Curtac, Jeffrey TI18213Wt-Examiner 6veI N/A Signature Date Site ReviewNgA Other Level NIA Signature Dae ANII eviaw Dae
- UIA, UT OalibrationltExamfnaffoon m
0 0
Cl C:
(D 0-1 (0
- 0.
(D2 0D Cl 0
X 0 a) (1) 01
- 0) CA (00n
Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4h Interval 1 st Period Limited Exams Page 84 of 86 ENCLOSURE R2-3 Supplemental Report
-, Damgime,,
Report No.:
UT-I 3-025 Page:
5 of 6
Summary No.: N2.RI.20.U818 Examiner. Currao, Jeffrey T Level: II-PDI Reviewer: Oj.L.-Va-'
Date: o0q-2-7. /_7 Examidner.
N/A Level:
N/A Site Review: )&
dz.
Date:
Other N/A Level:
NIA ANII Review:
Date..--_____
Comments:
Sketch or Photo:
_.,PLOI "4 10Z Alditional - Supplemental Data
A, ENCLOSURE R2-3 Dominioit Serial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4th Interval 1st Period Limited Exams Page 85 of 86 Report No: UT-13-025 Summary # N2.R1.20,0818 Pg.
6 of
.6 Prepared by: W. Thomas Date: 4/27/2013 0
Weld Number Thickness 0.6201, Weld Width Weld Length 1.24 2
1 0
1 2
FLOW C L 6A 60L VALVE EL
.207" HT X 1.1" WIDTH = 0.228 SQ. IN. X 13" LENGTH = 2-96 CU. IN, 2.96 CU. IN. REQUIRED VOLUME US AND DS SIDES EXAMINED 0.02 SQ. IN. US SIDE AX DIRECTION FOR 9" 0.02 X 9"LENGTH = 0.18 CUBIC IN BEST EFFORT US SIDE
.181 96 0.06 100= 6%
X*
NO EXAM 94% US SIDE AX DIRECTION EXAMINED 11 " DS SIDE AX AND CIRC DIRECTION 11 113 = 0.846 X 100 84.6%
Examination Volume Dimensions -
Height 0.207" Length 13" Wi ANI /ANII HSB GS Revlqmed______
dth 2.2" Coverage Summary
-l Required Scans (each has a weighing factor of 100 for complete coverage)
ANGLE UpSt-Ax UpSt-Circ DnSt-Ax DnSt-Circ 45/60 0%,
84.6%
70 0%
84.6%
60L
- 6%
Code Coverage Total 42-3%
84.6+84.6+0+6=175.2/4=43.8
- Best Effort Coverage (Max 25%) Total 1.5%
Notes:
- 1) Code Coverage refers to the maximum percentage of the required examination volume that is effectively examined with the qualified examination procedure.
- 2) Best Effort Caverage refers to the required examination volume past the weld centerline that is examined in the axial beam direction with an Appendix VIII demonstrated procedure for single sided coverage.
OSerial No.14-050 Docket No. 50-339 NAPS Unit 2 4th Interval 1St Period Limited Exams Page 86 of 86
.7.0 DURATION OF PROPOSED ALTERNATIVE The proposed alternatives in this request if approved will be applicable for the fourth 10 year ISI interval for NAPS 2 which ends December 13, 2020.
8.0 PRECEDENTS Similar relief was granted in the Third Inservice Inspection (ISI) Interval, as follows:
- 1. Request N2-13-PRT-002-A5 granted for limited coverage for ASME Section XI Exam category B-D, Item No. B3.110 items.
- 2. Request N2-13-PRT-002-B1 granted for limited coverage for ASME Section X1 Exam category C-B, Item No. C2.21 items.
- 3. Request N2-13-PRT-002-R1 granted for limited coverage for Risk-Informed examinations on weld 2B (6"-RC-420).
Although Fourth Interval Risk-Informed selections are different from those for the Third Interval, alternative requests were granted for examinations in similar locations with the same service conditions as identified in requests NI-13-PRT-004-R1 and N2-13-PRT-002-R1.
North Anna Power Station Unit 1 was granted similar alternative requests for Fourth Interval First Period Limitations in request N1-14-LMT-001.
9.0 REFERENCES
- 1. ASME Code Section Xl, 2004 Edition with No Addenda.
- 2. Request NI-13-PRT-004, NRC Letter dated 1/7/2011 (TAC Nos. ME3333, ME5136, ME5137, ME5138, ME5139, ME5140, and ME5141)
- 3. Request N2-13-PRT-002, NRC Letter dated 8/17/2012 (TAC No. ME7180)
- 4. Request NI-14-LMT-001, NRC Letter dated 8/13/2013 (TAC No. ME9913)
- 5. ASME Code Case N-460, "Alternative Examination Coverage for Class I and Class 2 Welds"